The State Of Karnataka vs Syed Jilani on 29 March, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 2]

Karnataka High Court

The State Of Karnataka vs Syed Jilani on 29 March, 2011

Bench: Mohan Shantanagoudar

' IN THE H1634 CQURY 0? i(ARNA"§"AKﬁs CIRCUIT BENCH 32"? GULBARGA DATED THIS THE 29"'? my 0'? MARCH V;2§i'3€."'~~'.' . PRESENT :

me :~mN'31.E Mrmusrzcs rvsozagn SH4;i\§3'f§;!§341§G€it5l3§{R:AVV T I W53; _ THE :~:em'3:..E r»':R.Jus"rivs::}:"%;x;z.a.LI"' s§m,$;m;:§ CRIMINAL_3E\,;5ZPEA'£"N'oT§f;._§:_§_g(V ggof Bggwgere: V A The State af ﬂy Hummabag?-~§3a:ﬁ§V§cA:%,§§t:aé:é.§,:7," H Aggeéiant { Ey S:*'§VVVE3€.i\.§V§bVE"V1"a.§"'a p;;:c,:V;§§§.@@;V_ Ariﬁ ;

1, Syeé 3§L%'2:s.Vn§V; V ._ , 32:; §:.::§:us'é:b Syaébiéaég ._"§"3;g3d§'a¥§Q:;: ;§'6§--.e".e;a':'s, , '£R;4f3""%~f%z%E_§'i%<§f:e§a {3} ' . §<*§§}%'?}V¥§a§E§:§ »'§f}3§E£§(.

2* ':§ye§ .§'s'-°é%:'j3;f:'*:§ab;

'§'§_x'% Quﬁusgh, £§.;aﬁ?=,a§e:si 53 yearsg _ TRg'§%~§'a§§E§<?§€§a (Bf;

V V %~--§..:,zmna§a§ "E"a£:.:;§<' Syéé }3§"::';s*a;

Efg Syasi iﬁgmasgaia '.223 ?'..lv Ageé abmét 33 years;

We E~éa%Eil<i'":@da {B} kiumnabad Tafuk, 4» Eyed jawed, Sm Syed Osmangw, Aged about 34 years, Rm Haiiékheda {B} Hasmnabad Taiuk.

S. Syed Hannumiya, Sm Syed Gafarsab, Ageé aéaut S8 3/@353, Ric) Haliikheéa {g} Humrzabad Taiukd .. ':»'"€.«s3$§@nd;§ents Q' 33; Sr; ﬁnéﬁkzgmar ¥\Javad«.gV§; ;Aci§:.5_f{>r'~-§;§.,"E7;3 ta: R5} "§"§7v§'si"{i.~;s§}:f::na§ :E§\§3né*a.EV"'§s :"§'Eé':j"':,E::":ée2' Sectésn 3'?8(:) and {3} @f CE.,P.€Z; far the gtate graying tﬁgtg ihég %"~£@r°§'bE@ Cqzugrt may""%§e,.}}.§,é4aiSe§ '£9 grant ieave 55$ fiie an ap§8a§.a§aE:§§S"%_ ._i§1e.§ud g?3é'ént éaieék 11'/283,295? gagged by _"*.E:{f:e anT§T':;T;-E-;-;§§a'a§, in SC. Neg 31,391? -~ Aaquitting V':_:§'*:$":?r3:s;3:§r2«:iz4::§E§,f_accLssed fer the sffenceg P/Ufﬁs. 34?; M&

32.é%';-['.i.'j:;§3§2«,<i¥5~::;'}<; Sea, 24% 9% Em and 3%.;

"??si g,V {;":;§z2":§naE Aweas gaming an hearéﬁg ihég day, V§%éaH;%%z §';e:',ér»;T;:§*aé;1$§*:;§;m;_§ 3., d@E%2;e§"ed Em fczéiwgiszg : ,ZQD§MENT' The State has ﬂied thég appea Q?L.E8SE§$Jt5"§"§V§€§§:"V..'?:§;%:*§§ jmgment am Qrder Q? acquéttaé péasseﬁ b;:z, ;At :%=":;e;7$3é§'si<%n':., Cam in S,C,E'e1Gi3}';/E???' Th€I _reﬁéﬁ;.§éie3{§§:_:;'----:x?gr'::%';*§ éVé:£f#§§: accmed befsre Em SasgéonseiCQur':.'¥.v_"§"hey w'é;';e__vt_;r§e_}j %';r;::*i *. the asffences purzéshabﬁe unée} 'v§"§§ec:§0n's:":;<3{?, :48? 324, 302, 594 rjw. Ser:tEQr':V§«--4::<j'§ ;o{;:r:.§:V%" "

2. we C§3$§'K'3:~ :{.Ei;'_E¢ EM §.?:r'gé;~§e'€a;§ft?'i'{§§*;..'é_.rf%5«brief is 5:575? : the wmpéainané._V}Zs.:f_§*:';3'§'iv.$éi;: ::§'§i'.'j,?%%:E3§e §%~:;t%:er {sf the decegsad, aCCE§$8ﬁ1_ N§§A.xi . §ﬂ§fV€2 es3m§'Vv__as3r:i§$'er "Zn; Qsmangab (mi 3%? :39 fé:i_ is+§aE'}'.-_'A';:i{;:§_§e.§"§§1es,3 and ﬁr are the song 9? QSE'E'°§aE§S&i§3-, 2*-"f2»:§:;é5s5::%d §'x§G'§ is gr: agsasigie if aiher V'I.Va:é<:a;s3§L:e;%,""' : 'f'"?}f€§TT{8 were ﬁifferertaas beiweers Ehe bmihers §:9§':.';=:;;* ;§_:.:'3"§:s:§_§2.§:,;~§é" 9% iha éiggsgte ﬁeéatérzg is a§§'Em%t:;ra§ V --§aa§S .§'" z"§"§"}£e"§éi%2er :3»? we déaeaseé 3:23 gagzsgeé Neal 5§:i*zd '2;~._ 3:"§§ 'me €IC3i?'§"'§§§§§ﬁ§§'§§ had Mi behind 12 aamg Q? ___'* §§a:€':§ gi {ﬁe iéfﬁﬁ $25 $33 ﬁﬁﬁih. :f,fs:*f:a§§'2 Q? 3% Eanég %'i$?'§%C§"§ .23% were Standing in the name ef the father ef {ﬁe cem;::>§e'%ear%t game ﬁe be mutated in theW_:*:e'§'eeVe..V'ef Qemaesab. The ::eme%e§ee:'1%: arse the eec'eeg$eje.:VVE§eé:§.}}_;'V {he bf'O?i?'I€§"S ef Gsmarsseb, e$e<i;§ %'e1"'eeE<eSer%§"e§yeVe'§§' te« divide the ereeerty and :0 give tf§e..i;? 'e%1ere.;,.".eA.Q'e;"rzeEj3e'aEf§"g refused the seié request, éeéeiijéce', i:F:eV.r}§j.Vese'§éVﬂte be freaeerst qeerreie betvéeen $31 even regisfteree e caeeega%eeVf;V_§'§eVe§§__VVefe E::'m;§'.i'4,'£gEee{ed Eaeg and wee? Q£'ebEes'¥'_é x;;E:'§Ea§f,3_§.; _E?§'Z*;e:'V.*?"efe'§':'e§Eder hae éseeed neiice te ééeetiee :8? of CRRCE ie ehese efder eheeée me: be eessee ageing: Eééerﬁé and trerrqeéiéty in we _feé§Eege.._i ®e.2?'i'2A,V..?;:§9§:ei ebeet 33% em. whee beih ;'ee;;'t€Vee.*e'e'm_e eeé ef the office ef Ehe Teiuke V Exee:;é'i§--eevV.VEeeéggéeiifvfeie after etéeeeieg the matter; egeér:

'me zeeeieeeiierizee, eceeeee §'ée.3~3aE':ee{ seeieee tee v4A_:eL_rr{eVEe"§*;2e::i, eeceeeee eee eifzere ef ifseér greuie it': fiﬁihy V"~'e.._§e?r:§eege eee iieeeteeee teem zeiﬁz eéee eeeeeeeeeeeee 3' 5 sgé Accused ?xJe.§;.}ee5ené teak eei: e epeee Fmm PW.a~__Qee:;i eefeaeétee the deceaeee ejeeg with speee an hés*'ji':eV§§eé'e<e 0? the heae eed eeuseﬁ eéeeeéeg mjuriee' ,ec;.%f:{;$e.5;{ Imamseb eee eceeeed ?~éo.4~}eved""eEse A_e"eee::e_E:;te<§ erértiie beck ef the deceased w§{h_eton:ee:'*e_}1d eVe*v_;;e:ee'~ gains Gemaneeh {mt sent the eempieéeeeé with etéeégzgee caused ﬂeeeéng §n}7:.ir%ee '{o - iwfermueab eseeeited wrist ef the cempieéeeeii suetemeé severe §r2§er%es,ﬂ__:e." Hemeeeeé Hespéiei eé %w§:.:reeebe:dK:eeef' eeseétei ei Geibeege. __L§£t§rea_§;e'V5y; i?seV"e*-e§::eese:§ suecemhee te {he ée3?eeée.§ on 'V_28§g§§'2,_:i3,§:§ eee day eféfey tee ieeéderzt ée eueeicéee, efierh %*e'ves;i;%'V;g--e§§=ee; eeééee Eeée ehe eherge eézeetﬁ .. z 'E.-'ieeréeg the merge ef irieéf ihe geeeeeeetiee ée ee 4'_'_e5xe_%e*§;*:'ee 2% eséieeeeee eee gee merkee 3% eeeeeg eee T -«.4§""5"ee€e§%e§ eegieeeeg {Be beeeéf ef See £fE§§\.§§"3€:§<.3; égege is dacasments were go: marked The triaf Cm;;'t_..___aft:e:' hearing; aéquitted aii the accugm.

4, Pwsal, 4 and S are {ha §r"s;?urea_--~&~*g~éf:aa.§§'i;~§5§§«sVsaé*"V» §'W~i £3 the bmther 3? {ha decea:§'ed::-35:3 :::z§:::'_+3':fEe"§§;f§3!'<;'.ae€ ég the 39:": Q? the de:::ease§.* EE;s§$,P§;Ev8' anéfP5'»Aw2_?--V..;a'ra:é injary certéﬁcates reéatgijg ts:_t4E;ié~:§g;:;*};:>§é§r"::a:§:_: Ha, %'*:é P'«fxz'«4 reagectixfeiy. PWVS ah§@*%ﬁ:?if~3.r'A'--g_3€'%§:i~ is aiso the ms":

sf the deceaseéig    far scene of
afferzce the witness fog'
remvery """  " ""'§""§'*:é} scene 9? offense

§a:z::?§an:§5:.zf_n§:%. E><:,P~«4 ané recsvery pa:':§%:a_r3va:':":a}"3 ;35A:'@_:*f:*1a5':'*_E<éi:§§LV at §><s,P»S_, ?' am Q, Daring .f '%;*E'2_e :i»:.';§§.,:rs:;-3 <3? reCé':?'é='%g;, ffigﬁgi W spade was rezcavered f**rs:">%?.fs'_T.'Vaa:zj:é;:--§é¢%'V"T-%5~§_é;§,1, ?«/%,(Q.;§ knife was resmseraé frsm ' aaszgs-ed A§%§<'j>.2 W $:E$§< wa§ rémzrared {mm aacasgeé ..'§3$'J~3 ég Eha iaquégi gansha? Tm énquégi ;f235n:§"':a"n§r:2a £3 3: gxﬁiig 5% E3 aéga gangﬁa fag" i:"m::

--«. §;';'5:'2§%§az:a;':'2@ 2:}? 9S8§2L§§"§ 3% €§§'§"§'§€S 9?' im $££%gS€§!+ w§':%{::§*2 i§}<,.

ES marked at E><..?m13. Pwaéf E' am 8 whﬁwere €X§8C€€ﬁ E0 demge 33 eye witnesses, ha:;6;«j"¢:"::_3--rV%§--e'd §"'iOSi¥§&, P'v'°v'~§ is aim are eye véétﬁﬁggf ﬁG§iT§§% in part. ﬁwgi :0, 11,; V' witnesses, Whﬁ have turned i"*:«::>stEf%::=.V. {fie who has cmaucted the past e.xanﬁEj'z§af'té:§'ré"; E"he mgt marten': examine-égégn ::e§s_:2:;%§t %§"§'1f:ar?{é'd"a£:"VE><.P--24* ¥3'\Az'~:§ is {he Head ;C <;.;éVsfa§§é _..g};{§E--:}:.:§1~. __:%'?3gE$te:~ed the gamgéaéﬁt Eodg§eﬁ«..J:§V3r P\}'?_vf~:%,,.:'..'TE*:é '{ﬁi§;:5"???.§:ETaint is markad at Ex?-1. afticies ta Forensh:

§4absrat(;§r'g,_' aa%}?:é.§ieg*g_ié«,, «»-j the Carzstabie carréaé the ma as wegigmm§ms;&;%%¢%¢grz. mrsz--:9 gg me Agséstaﬁt __Sub-£,r3€fjs $e«€:"{Qr ~-.::%:;€?@§:ce whe Candugieé we Enqxuegts sgeaks abaut {Em mmiéve asgeci Q? the m:a'E:§::i.' vv%%§¥é"."}:§i':ai§V'v$§arE<e:"s tézat zmre uséd {Q be frequeni ' ':':gz,éa:":*é§s3. regaré Ea Shaférzg 9%" agréségitwaé iargdgx ;'9?'{'i:£?§V25L}?k«--..A&§ Ehe ?S§ Wm regégtered Em aemgéaéni am *-..__"'?'ie§sé§,:*reé the m§':§&:* Ea "§"aé:,;§<a §X§£E_§€%1;'€ Eviagégigrgésg, 59? initéatiség action under Sectéan :0? cf Cr1?.C. PW_.»_~__22 E5 the Taiuka Executive Magistrate Wm was ::Q¥1dz;~':'%;%«~%;:§'§;;=;_:t%'}e matter betweer: the gartéaa arisérig under §E:.if;ii:iQréVV:3;:§i':"§*?:'$5 Cr.?.€. WV-23 is the B3z,SF~""'vz;§':0A'".4¢cs§§';§;{ﬁ;§§::%_;§sé{ﬁWtfée Enasestégatien am Eaéd the <;harge: 's;%ir:%;$tt investigating Qffécer Wm m'r':vL::':.£EL:§:"te<:f. n*:;:3;ja">Tr9.'.=pAQév:j€ ViQf tE"2e investigatiea, He reC:§v~e;re;§' €§:'}e~-i.:f_r2Véie2.réaE olbjéctg fmim the afaremeatéaned acc;;_s e cj, 1 5, it §.f;"':°:7+::,§é§;V§3:é---':;%£é§3:;.£;é~.f€§§E5s_:':«€f:E":e_ 'd@ai:?z in gasastéen is a hamicévziai._é'€é§ﬁ';§:,=.E'v'é:*':'<§%jh'er--%%se, the Q93: méwtem remrt E$<,P?--24', cééi;3.i:e§_ a;«:é:§'§;. the evidarége 3?' %:he éactar ?".§1!'*15_§"':"'§3§L4'<.é':_'5~3 §§ C'E.€é'?fsVilﬁuéi the éeafth Es %':@m§c%daE 5:2; "?¥f7;?:E&~~.<j;0cE§:*"E":'&§isi Qpined that the caagge 3? death $3 '£:;<e'_Tité--§::$i:'§V$é§:m $G§T%§E'€§SE€%FE a§ 5 resmt af heaﬁ " ?rQm we afaremenééaneﬁ £'§3E"f'E§t§QE'E Q? Ehe facts "'~-..__'a5s'*::.:?: 'i§"E€ 2f%§§fE"'é€$S€S gt§i§';r;r:&s*::§ aefsre Em Sea??? éé ég <2 Sear that the eviéerzce of ?Ws.:, 4, 3 am 9 are reigvant for the mrgese cf decidmg the questém as t€:--*ji;*e::?§:_"t;~3§.f§*;..gr the accuseﬁwregpondents herein were énstiignz-IaVV§%'E§.=3'E m causing the éeath :3? the §eceaseg:i"ér'*rz.r3;t§. ] ?. Pwwi has :iepc::sVé5d«...__thaVé'-..§9{imse¥§;l.jg:ﬁa.§ea;iSéﬁ,. ' Qgmarégabf and accusgé a.%é'*:ii§iQt§ﬁ7er$ infer Se, Accusm NfC¥S.3 arz;d"'e% are':«L§§f{g;Hs'é5z9i§ '§E..Qsmansab. Gm 2Z?,:2,199é :?:¢4_<\'::<'3.:j:"*epiej'3E":*:5l$ri; %.::::; their graug, as weft agf E0 the efﬁce 0?

$29 ?ai;5vE'<;a- :0 attens 'Em matter arégéng ::::"§*t%§ie2.':" .C:',.P.C. $3": that day; tha maﬁa? was ;é'::{%;éur§"é.ed';v. *§*§*éey same mi fmn": the Qfﬁm af ,f ':'§":.e &'v;':£:$€u€Vé%.?é""€¥'§5Qégirate at 33$ glkrng After they 'éa~'é:§§*':.s:.:». gffécaf gcmgeé $39.4 W Saygé Eavad i§3§"ea<~i:;es":§«;§' - §'%ir::,;zjdE:"s with ﬁéra saageguenceg,

""3 ." "--.?%%?J:~%_c§::3«%§'er:§eé accusaé N054! E1759 désmrzce between :?:€%_V'§;a»a:s;§ gfﬁiiﬁﬁ wag ﬁééiéi 13% fig ,%t 8235: gain: Q?' time; T -- .4:%>*%é:'¥% ?E""§@§%*:.§ 25:33 :s§@:";%<§mg by iéze gizfe Q? ifze éiégﬁway, H} ﬁe was hoidirzg wade En his hand. Accagged §\i@,1___2:eG%< Gut spaée from PWHQ am came :0 the spat, G*'§'}*%'*::}§-i%L:':*:j:§a;»*:Z%3 amii ascuged Neﬁ were havéiwg gtickga asgauéted an the heaé Q?" the:"dAféé:€atséAc% §péﬁ:e"n .Ace:u§eé N02 -- Syed Ima§ﬁsabA14'Vafn:§_A.acc.§;.'£§'cf jawed asgauiteci the deCease7dvL«L.j§9*é»th $t:i»:'f:;e7's;-9;-}ri"'§j2és back. Anethar bmther ﬁsmvaf;~5;§ab;"ééé§§§§s._§_iiéL::§--_:he'vV$a?s;%2§Eair:ant with sticks: ﬂaccggsed --'?~é:%§éE%j;;;:§*r2§ya asgauitgﬁ the §a:'r'r;3Eain'ia2_:i;§t"':,e~;:§'a5_ $t§<:E<. At that paint a? ':he rescue 9?' the co§3*:§Eaiﬁ§Qa:3__$;:;_AAA ':§%E:§..__%%Vé$':v.,§i-ébbad my aCcL,:S§d NQa3~Ss;ed Zahir witﬁ "e?1€e~ N95 agsauiteé P\fsi--&» with ___sigma,i 33?:ereafie:§:v§:heA§:* am away fmm the same, After A"~_i;%2AejV'«:.r§Vcé:§»§%:§;. §?f2§ desaasaé wag séwéfteﬁ te Ezaspitaﬁ by ?'§ii-}%'é'*~.%4~ Tése c§m§§aé:"2ar: i game éa gaiéte C,__'3Eaté§%% ..s7':*2:§ 4'E@dge@ the semgéainiz ?;%:er@afier;, the {i :>E*§jg:i§a_§§:: wag brezgghi: ag SE?' Exﬁéﬁ Subgeguarsiéyf iha V'-..._ é;%é<:E::;§'*r2 wag giiifieﬁ is €:§§.3Eb§§'§& Emsgéraé, 5%: 5&3: éiginili $10.2 against Campiainarzt ans the Same hag 8????-€55 in asqméttai by 3,M5F.C. Chart, iéumnabaﬁ' §. "gm names of 9W3: arz dWV«5g a:é"f§:;z}_¥?ﬁ'w»:éﬁ'_tE*:.é c®nr':§!aEr':t. Thar mmpfaint ES Eoﬁg&e§_"é..%§*:;%:»éﬁé%¥;ei§§: " :,%§f"%r;::.:% Ehe incident» The éncéﬁent 'f%_;§;::... QcC:;m':e£§ '3.3G~ gym is 4.03 gm" whereas;3Vt.§;i%.;¥'v}'vr;s':<1*j:_pEé'Er%'i;~-%.$ Qéged at 43% gm. %.e., maiden? in quegtiang factsrsg Not ﬁnk; it ::{"-fwe' wéiﬁe§se§ E0 the énCé@§nE, *'$3'{;{:~ g§%é' ::E%§é%"é'¥'§5.:"V?3%«§?éé §mar:n@r in which the Enciéeni Ee'.:'s@fE< gjiajcﬂei;'j_LjV:?§'!%' '§§:'~~%*'sﬁlaénamt hag stataé En {ﬁe mmpéaént abJ§é':;§ %1:%1;é'~ §'E"A's.i.f::iV§A'{é'.;8 aspeaiz. £3 afarementéanéé, I-' iji2@A ré§%"%2w;*;: 'Sf W€V$7';"i arm é» dlﬁ férgd giaw in Em §:G--§ﬁ'Q_§-§§§<;t. &§";éS;.é.1~~w§%neSseS. Each 3&6 evgry deiaéés sf the §:é'cj§ev;j*§%: Egan bmugiaé: ea: in ihe mmpéaémt, Tihe _.::,",""g'§§;€§i'.:§§.;3V,§f§{:e. ﬁwai am 4 fuéﬁy £@z"§"'$%§§'§i&§ we gage sf _%.T%'f:§F"._§"r:.;*§le£:,,z§§:z:": 53 faasnﬁ Er: me Qazrrméaéréz in as far" ag i:

T --4'.;s§§§ia':a§ ta; 'ﬁg aggazséé: gr: {he éiaceagasj by sﬁﬁﬁéjﬁﬁd Eaéaj;

-':

is CC%f"§C€F'$'E€C§. Tféﬁ evidence 9? thesé {W3 eye wétnegseg E3 Cansistent, cagem: and r"e§§abfe :9 the §ffé'::: j'*i:%1at accagsed Mai mcyk gut ggaﬁe fmm the Prabhu (QWQ) arid agsaufteé "5é*%"'t¥3a.éa_ deceageﬁn 3.9g 9W~5 ég anaiffer e'gVé.L:§}§s'v§:E".sée.s;;s EVjrr:Ec:éde:"zt Er':

Questéaa. He is the "b:;':§tAh'e}.rvElf He has aise depoged ab9L;.:..f§§*§.,e He fuééy car:*0%Qrates; and 4, Nsthing is eﬁicéteé ﬁn? as $9 dgbeiéeve his ev§des'°sce V;'.V"i=§Qiz*;§~:aV§§%%jLE~._S§.§_:A:";i%§§..§-E 'Kama? Navadagi, Eeamed aaunsgﬁ _ap§é?ar§}":g..{;nA'E:é?ifa§f Q?' 31% res;p@r:<:§$n§s-accu$€d I-'f s?é':~;r°a;:"1?¥:3.§J'§; :,_:;A:3:'iig;§de§'"'ii§§at me name :2? Pwmﬁ deeg mt é;:%§§:a:9'égi"«.:V?:éV".T-mmpéaént and Eharefareg hég versian 5:3 :.:»§'2§:;>e§";~ava;__:"3E::;,i%.g«:"" The cempéamt new mt CQ?"%E&§%'°E exgery ktiéiaéé, as. §f®§'€F"f%€E'%§;§QF'%€{§, the eamgiaéraé:

_'_§.i~':__G'§"':.ié'§§"éiS1 {$33 rggmeg <3}? ms eye wéirzgsggeg amt}? %: §§eaE<g v 3§5'i@ me r':':§§'2:*:e:'* ﬁg": i--*'%i?%§C?': ::%:§ éngéégni Ema §€C§$§'E""§ék E3? §S rm daubt true that the mama Q? PWME dczes r::::::_ fmﬁ ﬁace in the »:amp§aénL That daes mat mean mi the eye witness to the §E"1C§<i§EEE'}{. His §?"€EZ«'%:."-'¥.j";"§""£(T,:€éVV,}(f,V5V&?%?§§'E '.;E:§'Y: b€ ﬁésputed on the 3:305, éyéagmgzﬁi it is; fi:§'z;;'£=:1:i:a--*:':;::ia'§ far ﬁim to accompany ?W«: s§nceV'%*2_é"és a5s:::> §v_:":At'er5e3sVt;s'2§,§h=..L faméiy digputes. 83 that 35 a\?eré"'ew*§chV§ej;§?§Vfég the V evidenae cf PW6, t%:'fe*~~..A_acc'L£s;e7V:i'«- ;:,v§f'rs.s1.ct gé?t 0ver the vergran at' ﬁkﬁésgl am .«ic:2;f9":€:s:*:grf_§z'--er2§i0s":eé, the evééence sf' ?;Er'J$::,i-" anti ééiﬁég""c.é:%-'S'é$féfst, mgent and reiiabie, :':"=§0i:j_:fﬁ;:_':§ 5S. ~'§5'fLé'§"€"¢_:'3V5L':'g:;:5§'1§ g 5:3: in the .:r0$$~ 8}<aE"%"3§f"'E&E §__G%"§._G? §§';éQ'$§4"E"y%§€'E'ilé:'E'S&S 3% as is éégbeiieve ihaér avidenwg F::"r;§:"§*s_i?%'ie_ sf @'v'v'3.1 am 4, ii: ég Qiear ﬁéiat a:§§§;s?eﬁ fxigafm.__§_g:;au!teé the ﬁewaseé wééh the 7$.gj;;a:;;je.; .VV;%é:_::a§§g:%ﬁ"v€'x§@.§» Eﬂﬁéi ihe same fram a wsrker wha was"\z§G':%"%<%%2Q -%3§eE~:'§"V{ﬁg $§€}§E; 'me Sad W®E'E<€§" 'A2,, Prabhu *~..___%$§:>«:am§:f2é:é;_ as ?%§\£~»§' Thaagéé ?'y"2i»~9§ ééé mi ainaags m ﬁamge ahségé:

"%:}§%é"f:2£%{§an: in Qéééiiiéiéﬁ, ha mg §L%Q§3§$"%"€ﬁ €325 {fﬁﬁé Q5 the ggrgsemtian by demgéng that whéée Em wag ééggiﬁgg the earth with the hem Q? the 33.36% at abaut 4.£';£}*'-- .;::--«..};9*:?'*:.y5, a garmn gnatched we sgaée fmm his ?'2a€":d*; "

abmxe it is cigar that ?W~§ aé:"ar'2&;?;:5s""t:"na.tA_31$ '.fg§?§f$§.v§nxg« §n the nearhy spat with the heis Qa§".$§a_§e aVé*:v;:f§ fs0:':':é$t:e~§i s,'1~.u snatched the spade and we:€t:VV'Iaszgay. *._E%'eT:'wé'$;'v'£%éateé V' hestééet as he §éd n<3}}:'~~..A;spe§r'ia '§{V_'jé'£f;§::§§:':._:he "subsequer:t imgéﬁenik

12. ;«:ga%::;r%g%g;[%ijg~eig;éar::%;T«::;%.%we'€%c::Va~§§:y Q? the gvédensse bs'aug%3t~:§fi"r&§§i;:£ﬁ:'E;gé.géws;i';>=**«§«é:':§ 9, E: car: be cleaﬂy hem %:%*:a *?t;,éc::.c:;:séV§ '$.£§'.viV_ 'T€§::aizited an we heaé of the degeagegj. w'§'t§*3_ ~.$§aA<,;Z_a;,"'"cen$€quer2i E..§Q§{'E which the '{;§ec}e"r&--sé{:_§'~-%_§s.;§~s:&é§"zé§""§évere mguriaa am succumbed ta §L£..«3é%;j%?:VVb§fciaAE§.:"$3e;°T~.;@:.:%7 ihé Enjurégs $u§ta%r2&ﬁ E5: the Enaiéent, ' _%%§hé§"é§§§:§; Eriai ﬂmsrt Ea mt justiﬁeé ii"; aaauétting W H " '--«;:§l£;«:.,*.:,;;;g=ﬁﬁ 'é'*éfa. if remrd a3 ﬁiemseﬁ by PW31, 4 am 5, szigmritécf by tﬁm evidence sf ?W~9,

19. 3:1 Ami: Kumar Navazjagi, iea:"n§é_..%:";§ §i'a;;'i*=é§§§§ {ﬁe amused taking as t§ the e\:_§_{i§::f:_ce _r.:;é"":iE*::1§:-;§':§:;:>r;t;;>;s° E3'W~ 1 S W E": 9 £{} nd uctieé th e $086» Am ;:§_%*'i:é rt? ' ~ .e;'>::.§a ir";"7:iV'r ayguég that MG~: made CQ;é£--§:§i§"v..§§O{A§1~Z*3}s'&'?.VV§§§§§';i_ 'E§'3v£3§ fer'-

the CQ3"R;!TE§SS§Gi"'§ 5?' 3:;'§"}% 0;Affa§';s;é::*e"*»-.§Ence"'"tine: mjurieg Si§Si8§ﬁ€ﬁ by the ﬁec&é$é_&' 63:3.i*n:ot t§§§'§;é "giéth the sﬁade which ﬁg seizacj... « "fj'fr';e sééd€V<§_::ir<:t{§f' L?;_as_'deéeged that E? :h@ wade érg q;,seé?i'§v%:.;--v:f1_j$,;,i3é§«.§§:"_ agsamtg, the extemai injury mea3ur§§2§w..S i%§":c'r:~é5s' 3§ss :_é'i':*:.'i:::"'pf.c:3s5éb%eg On the gaid bagig, _ Sré ;ifg:.;:éE" §;<:,:ma"r..V §'§EévaV§%agé safaméts that %.:§"ze gpaﬁe £5':

AV. Qi;§%;'7S.§§€;€'"§_ 'A£fT'g§€;§§'1Z.VFEQE have been useﬁ, We ﬁe mi Qmgase té~$§V§*Ff%§N:;%_é%_i:--%é"éiée gaié genientian, Vv'E§§r% éziwe Spam is gases.u%a..r" a§§§a,:§t, 323: :99; a': the iﬁaaﬁ Q? {ha mamentg I .:f:f@5b§!Qf«.%-gf {BEE metégaimgsiy abgmwzg 3% 2a which Qariéaéz sf ggaﬁe tmgchaﬁ étééa éwaé. Tim Ezégzﬁ ggrtéarz 3?' ma , j~:§§§§@1 magi §"§5%f& iaugézegj? gr {£19 Ems": §{}§"§'§a'}%"'§ :&;?:é:%2 meeeeree eeeei: 6 Fee 2? inches méght have aiee teuched the heed ef the eeceeseds The extemei %__e}ur;z meeserieg E inehee which 'wee feune by tee ﬁe£:;{e§'f"-é;%i'e,;$ eezered weend em net Ehe actual the weeed-,fs7effe're7de "

the deeeeseé. Mereevea re¥§,;Ii'e'g«--.eer2"_¢ t§§e$e_ ke:em<A eeeecteg the amused caneet take '~ . «. "

28? Theegh the juegreeé*§tV:VVeF§ the ?:':*.ie'E'-{fVee'%v: §*ee5 ﬁe V' ebeet 32 eages; we f%eé"tbet_"A§'%{eVAéé€§._e% '€,7eert'Eé'eS ;"zerretee tee eeeeeétéee efAV:he wiiggiéeeseézﬁéﬁ 'el3;"..e'g?eeh3. Qrziy ée tee :%eiai'§?1§';' ei:""§aregreeh ?\ie.32, the evédeeeeveés d§§e--e,;V$eVed_'T'e.e't§»..;:--eec§es;éen is arrived at, E2':

Ehet geese; §e:§_ gm.e~eé"v.e?"Ehe iréei Ceeri ﬁe cryptic. The .:§"ée£V {3ee%?%:'e§'1ee eet §?ie%;er% eeme ﬁe eveieete ifée reeﬁer 5%':

ese §.:ae-6 ;;veVéf':::e?ee':e'5§jx?e§ '2:§,__"zeeeiew ef" the eeeee, we eeedeee the: the efétéée Ceeri eeiew En eeeeéiiéeg eéé iee eeceeed ._§e"eee§' ee eeeieéeedi size efeeeeéeeiéeeeeg éee YTW}fR<'sKV9JF3¥s\'!rt\1nvmNMeww.w.w.w.......m,............... . . '$33 to $3- §m$e§cw;:im"2 hag waved its 535% cégmsémtirzgly agaémsi ascugaé Eé{}iIg.§ He ﬂag wmmittaé the mu:*der_.~«:}f-.._i_:%':.:e damaged Ajéej Sash, Therefare, ha is mnviaizeé fefcsr the efférma ;3a.2nE$?waV%;";E'€»--:s§f1ds$r S'é<.*I§:§é%'";.'_'3'§82._V sf EPC. HGW€V€?f the arder V3? aaff'e:';§.»::%'Z§*:§fa'?i ;:>1§a'3.Af$'e5d; Cami beﬁew against sther aCé::{:'5ed §é'«._ﬁ§:.::;:.ﬁj*_a%i'*;i' "$r'éger" umder 31% facts ansii'~~..'cér<:'a;é§44:9:gii;*§:1Vé&.s 3f '?.'h7e gage. A<:tQrd&:*°:§Ey, the fQ§i0w§n §V_VGf_§é":°'VE§

(a) '*§"h57e" _§.;;:é§g':é_fg*1'e§fé_i:...__i'a..:';::§'---"_ £!;fe:ige_r m;0f acqzsittai .... ..g.3af'7ss;;éd¥--:§;g\z_ in 5% far as it reiates amused Nagvi V32.A'T3-.?;{Eﬁ3rEEE&';§j'E~«____ _ --

gm Gudassab syeab::a%;« 33* EEVa§:r.%§V$"'»'§:<x':::"'§§*-.. get agiﬁe and acggéﬁénéiig. ':h;€e _ gtarsés se':_.«-"a§E_Ge,v_f 3<. §§_%{i€E§Sé.Q ~~\..1?%§.Q="iv ig Cmviaisé §7§:" 1'§ff:§~ﬁ;$i"~..gg;mE$ha§§e under Lisecmg' .':§#'ﬁf.2.'A am ﬁg s&s:i:es'":£':2j.@iE" %i::,§ u:":§e':g§ §.§:=':;:3;':f.;--$:":z:f*a;";i:e:'3{: far igivéffeg if:§"§%i.j§-v*€;f'§S,{}®{%,55_":.§S aéss imgsgaa % ~ ~ .. _;_;és': ?wE..:f9:'2V. * F_~J {J1 Accused NG3. shaii gurrenéer' before the Eréaﬁ Court wéthir: we mQnt§'3V =._ ';_ from ieéayﬁ

(b) ﬁts juégment and §r:j_e.;r7_Q>;" af«:"qi:;§§i_'i;s§E"'« "

paﬁm $3: ihe triai CQ a.§?€ gscugeé Nagz', 3; 5%» and §?~.é_$*;'~sr:Q;zf§JV?vs9%s.:.;£r;§."

Tm OQ€F'§ti's.!@ pgrtém ﬁiﬁézirfi sfsaii be cammunéaated is the trééi*C0s.:--r%j:f~§{:r4ﬁ§t:'?;.%ie:..:"_ actien. The ap§§;§§"§':;'%éé§% '§j§_':'Lé: S:':a;:€:éQ"'%:....;§!Iowea' in gar":

acmrdéngiy, 1

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court