Karnataka High Court
State Of Karnataka vs Dillu @ Jillu @ Aseef Beig on 6 September, 2011
Author: N.Ananda
Bench: N.Ananda
3&0 §_.;§2ia:':i. Eé3a2_%:a::i:.':3..V§?§.E.e an agspeafi a§_§21i.:1ssi. {E16 j1,1:"}ggzm3~I);.€. {§2?a%';'.€:=:§ _ f=E%}2'*:1?~§;'3§E's§Ei}£%¢ {L ziaiézrezrszéai :l?x;*. iii'-§{T%'?s,'iET1j:§;f EN '.E'§"fi%Z §"T§§{}E"'§ {f{}'7L.§E{'§' {E}? }§AE€§\Jz"§'E_'AE§§a EYE' .E%é§N€.}z"§'%;{}§€§§ ;3;m:;_:> '.E'§~iEE3 *3;---:;«: <::::5="N _my 9}' -SEr':',P'E'. £.';'1.1EBE?E{ 29 3V ;i>;'é§::s:::;'\;*$ ' '_E'§~§€; giomzgigza; M§mUS';':<:z3 Na;a.NAN':>:«:g_:'* V ANE} V. TV . V V V "m§=:, E»-~:<)m3L££: M§mUs*:f§C:: Vf,'s:,:§§:V';:._§>'::%A'¢ '§}{';*4:)' 'V , V 1:' CR£Ii«'EIN.r'kL A_2'-wzzxg §"~;T:;%. :53::%;r.é2;€,s@5 V . f 4' E3§§'EW§§ ':N:
332119 :::«f §{22:*z:3;'{ak2; , . , . V ~ ~ By E-3é:*€§":21E1'123.r1§V,:e":3.2}. E?><:»§éc::=. ';:':1_*j;éi'£--'£{'m-'_ . " :~'x§;;)€sEE2¢;11i {By Sr:,N'S,S2:mpa::;;;'i:':tm':ai$3:;'EECVQEF} AND: V. ; _ , ._ .
2' zimm @gmg "
A866? Beig, ;'_§g""r;_ E-$3.2 322$: V" ' 32 Ygsars, £'?;_,!' 0;V;f3E?:1:1§;.a§;:"p<:fi"Z132:mi»:-g *
2. Nagaztaj V V_ SEO §\£ z_1.:1ijy"ap;3é§;V 3%-5' Y'€:j£1%":~:aV R] 0 E3e.i'z2.mhai§*§ V'x5=";§'E;§jj:»,s".{<g<:' ' -~ " « .
§3;1.::garpe"£HfEE:Eu§§V§' V . ' E"{€ss;30z1<i§%§3§.s§ {By Sr£.C_;P'21§:2i. ",t5{€T'V€Zd~V°j.r.',..:'?';CE%§T()€ffé,E,f;3 far R2 ans} {{2} V' .2k=§V 5f§'%§%:';'% :_.;mie§° ;L'§e<:§.i{}:": E"';f?'E:%§'2} 5: :3} $1196. ;i?;?';V,:2Z'f}%3:'fx__; ":::s :i3§£?€§ by E§'}€' §':'esi{ii1":g-V_§ Qi'§§c5:*, §*-"f'i';'--E§§ Eiayigzr in S.,"€I2_F*$-%}«Z;i£1E%'}-7,? :?§.*5_}{%'3V;'"é1a:?:z;§::'£€.€ii::g; *j:'m :;*{:%s;§3<;:§.:"E€::{.53/'21{t<"::z$a:%::§ €232"
{}§°f€":EE'="§fi7§§ p:.;:é:{:;}%';:a§'%3§:% LH'i€3§{:Ti2" S3é3iff2§{3E1;':§ 38'? amid 382 EE3'*C :"jv;' _s;<é:é%:i0:i----
_'E'§3§55§'"'22:gj};::€3aE e::<3:3':£n§,V:f 3:": E'é:;:" iénai §'1.s:*z;:..z"§.:":§;j E:%;:'.e':; ciayg :5; -.
.. ~ €;.'::2ejg%' irwre aaraziéiégzg 2:53:32' E-'<::E,E:..a:"23;_§2:.;';;5:iéaiéé §zmE«-:; E.,'.§€:.,S:(:.§g 2i.{:<j.:,:.Sté<§. ?é§<>,f2 sufiiie H13; :*:%:2:<:w':%{;§ 2-: E:>:.:3E;'_%3 :»m<.:i s:;€'£:'§}E3e»:§ $313,? .i2,~§ii22z_'£:%u_'f::.:'i.§£ 4uu'...,.,.v.waw %mmgm m%§§' _ \z he: iéii {££)wz':' E3€:§'<}3°aé he couizi 22;}? E'E{T.'{f'£.EE%§{:',{i i'iL§'f.";:'ti'".§' ;_;;';7 zéhaaseci Gm:1%_n{iaraj1,: etazaii $i'..z"sfz3b€{§ m__1'1:..;a%:i{,h _~é.§":.'%:§'''$2é:;":s5§'E<;:£':i§E;%=-V '' arid zrauzsefigi hiss deetssih, 2'-'x{:a::.3i:;€,<:i; 3T'€<).:'E' Z%Efi{i 2 :9:»:.:1"2é_*q%s21:;* .:§":*:1;fi":1.T_' i.%:a';. g_>i:a<:g>.. 'E'h&1'ee1§%.e'rQ P'W,2 S<;jfis_';%:7§r}{;w $2512-'a:*:a:g{:ac£"Vf£::§=.rc:;g,{";Ej: iéie h $12863' 05 E3E?'\?Z "E 6~Ven.kai.€$_%1a;3pa: fad .é£ra--*;E':§§fi' i<3vvvET3E£?2. §}u.:°;ing_§ ;1=1e::»m:Tng 915' "E waés ahmad and a=2_dmi§i£€:d §i<}i:a.:". 33133.5- \.;m1k&'£a1rz:n:gi:§,'"{¥;:§-N:%:i¢j:':{:.:1§ {H1 ksaming abmgi; fine E;1{:id€:.}§ ézrilci :é%,'*':é'§;,'::E"'E:}fV{3{i§4,-' 2>fG<>vir1{Earr.«:g§u. field met. PW!f2;_&ifi :_R§§., at Koiar and i€f«,"z3"'1'.fl'j £ib€)'L3.E ihe .i.:1.§:§d€:3.:§:émd ink) maiicm. by .}.<3€%g§,i:'1g; {ha fir€:=:5:': _w'ii..§' "E3§%:§§:m'1e1:";gaEa PS. The itixifisiiggziizigg V'V'..A{?1:.£F,§;5§*.iVC'i€:E7,'fivféviéiéfrj*%,%§.'£fi §}§21{?fi 0? §;1«:%§€§::%1'u:. A£"%..e:::r' $.13:-,* m§;_':1:€§3é? siirstzufi '?:'}.{>";":§;?""'M«:}% '*~:':«*;'«;§,§; §:;::':;§§&;:<:i.€{§ ii'? g1;<:::~3;fz.:':T1.:}2"':,@m ' V @::<;e2::?:i.z.';§:§, §.€;:':Q ?>'Ei;',.2§{}~§}§n§z§'.1-KBEez:"aye:.1'12z$:s&:a:E;.}* $93351: <;?§3::a:§:;<i=é"€{§ mg: W-g3<};§;i:2':<>:"i.€;>:":'; <~.%f»::c:§1":§:':2:'Li{;:': §'€;%.g.2':";-{E §.§}&'é. Ehfj'. a:§.€;%;::%;%22;<;:€:E éizaaii ' K"?
5 (:22: «é;E*:*e ' :ir:iL§7€;:"%'::«221.%.<:»m. 7i.}?§§§::n€s%<--::"s:d 'E33; é}{T§'fL1$€é I%3@H?;. Sr: ._gii§;<f%5..::é:€:éé%:5§ gas; pm: E53,??? :9 91.3 agzai }fI.1£-'s,7i.€'§'i§%;} <}E"}};§~3.<:%;'.§; :35 E323? g 33:} E0 "%2;<~t%:"c:a £12.;-s.z"E«::*.<§. "Emit :%{}§1i,:'2'§.{Ti:?<:EI:<>z°'§; ;::<>'1"§:§<m:<s 331:. Ehfii s;é.;§.'§7£?§°€{i fem? ;<:';?;2?:%§ i:'3j:.:i'ie.<;§ {rm E1316 vi§'2':E §:};'»":z*i:.:a«; a::'1<:.§ <':€>2§.E..§':: '?E;?'&}.EE§ grim": is E1.2i€:::'1{}:fE.121g;c? z»;':.1';d air.-:;{:» aim-3 K': §'§§§L§!"§€S§ is i::.%;E.%;%-'§..=.ii'a.% <>r,g-_;*z:z1s; :~mz':'E1 as-; .s;;.i>Ee::%:": zmszi pi-'§I£TE{.'.}.'"€;§€-if-3. In 133%: fémé, §§":S%§i.£?iI"1€,'fi. PERf.2'¥§A.§é:'E)L:. &_v»;--<:5»:$ .; 'i,fff?1'€',{f{i 2;; SNR Eém-:pi'é.z:E an Kaizxr a;t1e:§ Viaéez' "E}<~3: '.&v21s; §;:t<;::1i',€:~a7"i in-~. ' .E€,L.=J;1E21E&;§23. E"'§{}:'é'~E}i'i.z::E at KGEar,F._'"'§??§X..E->.E2*.iS;--.._%i:§'1eV'*Vv'5'L;::{1 £7e3'i.ificai:&. "fhe: cizjciazsz' =2éf};1*:<'§_ hid _%f'z'<3.£.:i'f:<iz'..A §'W.2 v§92>:$ 11:}? €X8;Y"{"§iE"i(i'{§ be€€>:"e {ha £',{>'Ll.f§,. iéfazE:25?«.§:£:v:?"§.§,f'§:€.3Lé€ E}E§;>;.P.12} wozzfid 1'ev'c2:E ':§1a.f:' 'E'"~I2?V;"2 had $;I:§Nf€'f"€{§ 'E§§f¥:£Tib'__§§§§'L1£"f'y gnezxsurirzg E. X 2" 2: E" d5é:3§3_.-4€;*.5éf"::-E28 §'éfEt:Aétbcfgzia-%:r1v'2" 'égmiow U.{E1bifiCLiS anti 0§§1erii.s;:Mifi p:"{)?£:i*'u The i:1\ré;:;ViTigé:€:_i::§;§'amff'i{:_éi'« ":%*:2<:<}rcEe4:E iha s1at,em@:":3;.s of Vy-'i'€1§E6§E~3§'t;';E~., 3.'i"I'{:*.E§E.$.s:§ 3;;-:25 e1C::z2:~five:§ ;5i§"i€§ E"'{'§CG'i='"€1f'€d 251 i':s"a:i.E:<m knife <€%,;.'§:*:f;:a§&%i'.':E:23?~.;;§* %:V;:;é:j:s€:§;%§a%;.§<}:3., a7.E:a.rg<;=. s%1e€:'i': *a:9:>.z$ ss:.:§3mi.E.i.€:<:i 3_g§a§§.1¥:';_'; E13} 8 .3 g::e:;; :§t5:€§.
I §}*:,::'§§:g_;; Higii. E5}i§J'.:::=§ is 21% 2£..»'€§*s3 {:>:am§::::*§"i9 ,/' r 'U: g:'.., 3. .g. 29 5 ».w:.¢.>~,%n , .. .-..~.~.'UAv.i|'fl\\%5'I\0'I)j Wmaww §f:X'P5. E21 é'_.h€f fimi. in£'<32"'2'":'3ai.§m':g ave? fimi that. E'-"=3?-"a§ '§:'f;.e.1s;: :':<::>§. ggrm-;"'::': Eéééir :'1za;1'":"3.é:%s'~; <2? 22:::~:éé;2:EE2'?::r'H59:s. Cm '€E'1€ :3é§*:€:' hzzmi. he __E";23;&i~: séézfaifici '£..ha"£, .2'~xss per 'Q16: i:1§.{>r:§;'12z%fi'i€):"1 giwsitz 'Ea hi:':1 %§}}?.:'§:}%§,%'\.:2K 72 13%' .2 gmd {E16, tE::ee:':€:21ss€:{.§ ézziici E3661': a1's~3s;e213W1,1E'{€3.<:i__A-'ééiéz;'A L§:1};:}«:>'LVm a5s&az1;'.§21;;}.€.;*~;; {,5} mb z11<}£:tt}f MHf:«f_2:':»%:n '.§fi?:5(%"
'§'h<:3m§"<>'re;::. we firtzi éhaé. {he evidczzce :;
'WEEEZZEESS tr: :'.§:€~. §:1:?i<;§.e1:'1?£. 11:5 §'E§'.§§§{}§"3-"V {"Eé..s;;<:1'<ia§3£::':§:, VThT<--%V {7:7::'v:.!§§,::<:'£_.3::>}i' PW,2 35.3 ur1:}21'fz:ra.i, "$1.6 €:*.fc1§'i.17.e5sf. *x;6£".;~:_ic:n;u of §f§s;,§..(i€$z'1E: §.;9;§i\3€'1"1 E)j;' F'W.2 ';2e€cuz'e the j2,11"::5gi:é::4;'ia>:'1.23.§. ..p§>i:i::es; .{>§"E3CE5? " (}i\ 'E-'fez.-'i1'én:r1a.:'1g;ga.Ea 9.8. 31.21:; ijeem a;u;3;:):'&».=:,Ti:_-é§e<E§};T§'§'2<% ii-isi:<%r§r" <3? ir1};Vu1*i«;?=js5- gira-.-='e:': by PW.2 E}e:i1:::'e:
{E16 «:iQct.c;:*>5s. sf :%5NR":':()V$.}'i1:i'€2:»§ :'zi'§:'VE%Ic§§2;-r:,23;i'E?g.Cr{} a.2":2., an 18.817 .2801 givaa £1.iEQ§§é§.E€EE°'- ;1:Lf,£ii{.'£e:.'€%3':'%. '*»-*.r;:*:=;:'on '§5E3':é:?i: .§31¥,2 xr<sa:<3 a..<:=sszmE?;ed by {E02-'i:§(§2: xi-'ViA3;h 'é7__k:1:i'evV2:§"e1E»«:S':;4::'é?§\QC__§:>.::L4 01': 17.€}'}"Ci2.0{} .1. 235%,» {:1 21453:»-<:::§:é;;tc>'s'I1 ;*§}f}0}E.e{§ in EEEEQ 395"? SC EU; {in ifte .és;:£;3e €:;§f° ifiafiiasglu Q. flag State af fizfaéras}, {E25 S:.}:;gV:$:7A<_§:'§3é:; E%.2};S,~.:~ §;eE»:.§:--
'""iE'h:{3:::i}:1%z3;:%.ia::»:1 iéiai 2:3. 51 m:.z:":i<:::* (raise. $1216 {,';a'u ':"t;~.;_ ssh<>1;2E5: éziéaist. zzpém §:':§%..7:::."2-:.E§i.y <3? w§E.;T:€r$&'a€:'$, %§:';ii,t{3?%; i<3:;:x ¥:3:r{};:d.E§; i-;;E:a*£,.z«3€§ '§"E";;i>, Eiédiizzrl VV E;€:g%§§é5§;~:E::2.:"s:: ':":as:-se :':<:='%'. E:E$§Sf.{'€§ gm Eezgringg <§<yé2ar'z2 32:3; swath <--3x§::":p:.:i{3:'25; ?;.{i': %;§'2z:% géé::{é§2:.§ :'z:2.Ee Z'€:{T€§;:1§:E.1iZ€T--{§ 32;: S 2343;. *;a:h§:':E7 33:,-' §22.};:§.ng§ :%::,=w:'1 %.2*2a%: "M3 }{}E?i.§'§i{?'§,.§f§.éCi.§' 1 J}.
gag . -$,,»~--M, 3; «M g5%1§h_ uh . ..ummwax;umu~mwwMMAWw%WA z:{'t{:':.:s:3€:<.§ ?~=E€}.2: Eéiii ':.E1.é;f i.:.'2.af€%5§ig22§%.§'},g_=§ 0§L£°§<;'ea:é:° ;'2":":§'E p;1:'1<%§*1 E-'»--'fi"EEf.".°SS€S 10 E.}€:'éf;'i£"21E"za§§E§ "2'.1:1§<be«:%. azsd §3E«:'.fk€?'{i mg) §Z'~.?::{§T:_é§E'. which xvzxs Eyéngj E'E€.'23;}" gm €Eé3<::'E..:ié(: _§3:;>§:;~*. 2-md %;..E:e_.«s9;_€s._§:':&r.'Viarzig-'. 53:,-{i§;=':£3*{i z.:::dé:%3* n";21E':;::;:{£::° pféi' E%Zx,§3<i§R
22. E-'3"=N,4%~;E%Zam.21Chaziadria R_€;'i{.'§'4,'."§°j:,?{-.." ;»;§.E} wimesss fez" Ii'€E?.{)'«£'€3.'iE'y has; e:i€;:>0§:,?:f'§.:' '*{,h21t: &i{i':f3L25:§fC§ ihs i1:v<3S3;:iga.ii1::.g Défiaiftz' ami P'§?wJ.¥§ &.€3____}fi:is_ 'i:v::}1:1:+;s: 'zfi; _§:}€1»'"&§.:?"a§'E£iH§.
"E"'h<3 gmttzziezed 91:"; §.t::<z*é3{% his 21:1: :'§é_:*A 2;-_n.e:§;_i;:°{§'::::gh§'ifiigéa bE{>c}ds?z.ai:1&d ;<3§m1.:'t'. and i§{}U.S(}}"S.'f:1I1Ci %'h«:j3;-*v»v.%€1"€"~Seiziifl L.§'§.."§CE €if'I' mahz1zar as gs:-:2" Ex.,P3g ;'£"li";€¥§e21"£7E4<3:.; €1<:u2__ £'i;f?§iE§:Séf€i 3.r;'€:i ithfi inve3s'{1?.ga£,i::ag; offictez' £iE7EvC§"'E}'i}'1 3;: Wi:§£?{--?~€%SSé'f:S'~.,1":€f:?if""E3:?§'2i'2'8.iT§.EiHi 'E'a:'r";E:a:bed aria? ':"e:1'2<;ved £1. kéiiiméj'bf§§3%f'21;i%:--.v{I§;§€3_xi§§f£{f'i,E'§{f peie and {he seams: was seized "am daézr" ;3.j:2:§':a;«:t:zr' as; §}€f§€..'"§§X. E-*4» ;_E.{ 1:3. {ha ;2;"'{:s€<?L1E.§{m ?LE2a_§. £,E.:.e i2':<:2'.€Ee:i::IL i,G£>k §:2.};a::=.e "::::n}-._§.?I%3T?}ii8@E, z%<?<*.m:f~;<":d §\;£<>:2 'ai-'EiEf% azrzfiaifid an 2®={;'*?f,."..£§€3i3Ii.» ".5:;1§z2s§€{i E\.%'<}.2 Etzazi .:5:mp§5: times: is; 1"¥3§EE{)"'é.----'f3 '§::_E;{3€2<:§:ea':':z:§:*::%;«;' Efiiiu §'E§f:§ {T:§{§'%i}'};€;'.$. ?:E':={):?€ $33 EYE}:-2 §1":.::::"'§.mi.'namnggj é Es 'E?'5;'%.V{3§;é;'::'§§s..A w'e;?:"€:- z'2<;§'. samzé. €110 §*':}:'fi*::s.~;§<: iSe:::'.a:r2.<':€: §,2:%}<>§2::?'.{}1*§; 1::
V' .__"::<2':"§ff 'rs: i'E1;»:i' é4§::$ Z3§<><><§s;§,ai:";§ss itrazgzzzfi am §'.}1§§ 23;':.§a?Ei:':5 ;»":.:';{€