Central Administrative Tribunal - Cuttack
Raghunath Parida vs M/O Railways on 19 October, 2023
ty Na OLA. DAO GS 20} 5 Coram: Hon bleMrodavyesh V. Bhairavia, Judicial! Member Han'ble Mr. Ramesh Singh Thakur, Judicisl Member Hon'ble Mer. Pramod Kamar Das, Administrative Member Ragncoat Paris, SS Coast 1 Railw VY, Ce. BR. Sadan, C "han asekharpur, Rhubuncawar, Residing af (juarter No. Dk PPG, Rail Vihar, haat Coast Railway Chandrasekhar Bhubaneswar --~ 74 | Apmioant t, Union of india, 3 fed through the General Manager, nd Sore oes wr he, Re od owes. fr, ae ry whol fu pa " oS a te) " Sees, ae o oP, re ft, Ricod i aes po eo oe ees 'ese " 2, oe, 2 a R Vi K ne a a "
+ rt <3 Pea oe a, : ae ore Dene, (pate ea Exes yas "eS nt ; 7 Rat bead aeree nn toneny % pes ree we
2 "a Aon nee, dior Finance (CUA), niravia..
Cd et £3 oe woe ear Es co zt Ks ae aA pet Nene Ae ey * ys a, "yp s shee Pes 2 pes as ite Ca 4 ne po boikes es % yore beasts 'aa sine eee bebe Way 4 4, Se reed, on, "at ia Pec ES 'ee ou es LY oS eos Pea vee dw 2 ce HOVE ae SS 43 ob i, Fs heer' ce oe, ioe Bes eww a ook aos a, e ree oon tn, a mS ade order dd Meneh af thi at Romar a feed oe a i pet . waned, : B red "EE y A a eed ae ¥Y ane aoe * we to wn ae; tex vo . ces moe ~~ os we tie. "He ey ae af *3 rs, cond "Goa wna hos te a eg ne 2 at #3 3 « i ; fod 'oma, Ty owe oe ig pam BS px ap hoo, oes! Co tine. MS ee oe Be pon ge anaes See ES, Eommers Kage Bes, ey we wt ws Hs ates, coos 7 ry. Yi Oe | ae Peto ie Teds 3 be Ses To me ke ~ Be de, x "Sy, es te BO ee ie eS ee nee oy Eas ae bs ee 4. ed psc Be aE a4 oF seen we ws . Se he, ay "et tPF:
~ se m : fo 'of 3 ae eae See ik & os ° cette Pet : iit, ie ee £5 ¥ we "yi he r, five * pe ; a Soe WE a wes oe ee Be 0% oe w% es eae be Bid ite ae, ar ee, we Ree Oe ot oe t we ae ee birvot fo, ty ms hy poe oft pee ped ae "ewe oe aes. 3 ee eg xo Bg, pred oe : me § . Ero fe ug HE ones Capa a eas $0, gee war! 2 oe rr, £m Mey z is Dan a pete ane go eas oe ER be arn, a ee oe So yee ee eas won * Ont ie ae as 4A "nee #3 Seal aocad Bae CN ih 4 ava aa om op 7 nene ' ee. a a Ss sod: ea ae epee, As ech ' oe Kebag ns ae Feo pen ret seeks ay ward " hcg RM oe ts Qs Pees ee bs oe Y EA wo Be ge x baad wee ee ee y he a j tne Sen at ied incoad fe i : vas Ss ee a he te ae ot oy. , peers Boe Seay ne .. 40, oe 4 ee. ped. Be % Ca Aa: Eso ~ es w. Be aa rey ; iy _ an a ae a oS Woes casa gh Lr he Rah og Se ey nap pd rs ant ca , 3 i SR: ee tee "ad od a pm eee bead fe ay ses x: Re Sat aye po @ wy 7 a me a G : 7 7 a fis By wf 2 4 cha Mek nee feet os ne 2 ae BG on we we "3 pee ie SS Se me ae wid ray ° mes oe gene, . Se, 'ss tale ee Sky a "eee ind Meg & te, ' bod ag. cod ke, 2 Stas rey Poin' tees ed Ka ened g cae Fenix oe wy wat , ea ae | i ee " . lac ic os a a a 25 Ee 2 fi a es fe se eB Z Nee ee hon be fe os "eg a5 od ue : 'eth a Rw weet 3 fa fae) Eg pan . vee . esd bog oo ane bee sa 'ot site , he. % ' an ; lone nah nd, wy a whee. "6 a fone Sy, TP Se rs aes on fen , oe we ee ed a ae ag Ge eg E ee to ba C5 oe ££ od pans tae Saree co Om! Q me ae Be Bs om. U ra ; os j Se vey aE EE AE ; ; "ie "te aed pea fad we te ; fed "Sei baa A ised Bases ote, ae ' wR oe bee Fase ne Bes 6 kee = e as = S Boe SB a ne $34 cs a : od 3 nae «tee ay ve ed a _ g oe hte: és Fa my rook Te a ie oe oes fe ty "Ratt pe ee tosh poet 4 oy aa por cs or tL rn od en. * ot races GB ae ' aA % a WEE ay SB By, oe ; 3S oe gen Lined Foal . a a Mc es a teen, toe sees a a ek = rere 83 aS is Fi ay par face peo ee =, Bin, To Fg mm Ft eee, % a po as eros. pad Som, cr ae gan ny pi ope, +0 coop ede ne ery, tee pees Gis Foe rem: he nl a pera er woth ", ss - ge ro % al Gt Deed oer wy Wi, Pee ig oe Hee F ft yet es pee % eng TR as "at bh . Boa 'ft i ; , ' a) OS pg ame oe loon ws oo acd ot ie ane sees meee Sn a ace na os, Pade Foerd, Sow tS » wer Oy ee Le ' whos ad fee we rece Ber Yam Bee ye Be "ae oh ed a ag haces _f wt aa Pied ite ne ae ring See ee wore Spee 'wine?
of foe ey ce ie, % es Rr ape i, i, ten oe so A ae oS * roy a feet a "a nie ¢ ce Gee ' "pel Smal 4 peat Ly yy a3 5 is F , oo ° , pad Eee _ Ps ' a Sn op g es : oly so oe ge bee an og ely het ow, 'oot 1 é ~ oe = z ee -- ke ye 43 "a Ket: By cA ope ges a ee Pepe yee ah "Sater: porns ad oor pte oft 2 oe on o Bb a ee "sere aA a is ns ee ol a e & a BG: 25 2g if nae coed en Feet race we Bx ae wh ay wa, 4 nee Got iets, ae Re : Gy oft: Pa 2 wort ee , Eee a a cee we, at we poo EG whe a sen oe "ey ior ote eg nee sees tasen ae. pe Eats Bock ae poe ceed "iy « ae os , pes. . rae' "nd! ace work a wank oafine net eee. o Rs aoe pant Z BB > a 2 go ~ i " ¢ ae ee Sees * soe heaced wes ~ aa ree, pee. wet e we, Ba od alow. pans "he, a3 af 4 pos 4 os; a .
Ce e 25 red a4 "
mis ea e e. Stat bees » ay he chert . fentios :
: poke tg eee cad v4 ry re ay 'od pe Wer per) area xe cae anne Zs en ae ate See mbar MACY benelit in the Grade Pay (herele s ox MEQ Lgawks omshy cage ate heiee ab PSP WA other similar Wee, Hamiedy Spare V. Venkataranian, who was eranted borneiit af 3"
; : & Hight of directions issued by Madras Bench of this Tribunal neny dated 26.48.2008 fs vide ords ws Venkatararmanan v. Union af india dors.) (Annexure AS).
ped Sot x pod 4 argh 4 ne ete cae LE gig & sy es £% ea x.
Fane ee perc a fag % a we ree fa oh os ey treba we ee ee tS ns ae i':
ups aft Woeee yew £4 oF baac ont eet i.
pe oes bene CS ~~
-
inet es a La wee % a a oS £5 3 i, Being aggrieved with the sad order dated 7.2014, the anplicant "fa Joe quash the order af rejection dated 23.2014 under Aswexure AL, ant fh) dad te direct the respundents io grant 3° Financial Uperadation under the MACP Scheme wef LO 208 in PR-3 with GP of Rs, S400 and pay te differential arrear salary with 22% interest for the delayed period of payment by extending henefit of arder passed in QA, Na. 235/200 *.
And pass any other order as Hus Han' ble Tribunal dees fi and proper in the interest af justice"
aft ar Cuttack Seyee tive Phe ary fred ba mention tit the Dy Re Ad th SCM NE Bench af this Tribunal in its order dated [2.7.201)9 had considered the Islowing submission of the applicant that IS ese ope 'et hee cores 2 St Cy ise) z 5 Ss By a5 Z :
\ 2 spelt yon va B & Saoal wee 3 BS oe pen ie : : a a See, aes epg: ytd es * s wo at 'cmd en if ra Ye "iy 3 meen ts ve i Ly be
-- Fock ot. ag Pr, 23 aad "83 , s eters om f cae' bord ° 'a 'Sak he : 7 ve ea £o, ; 3 : ped oped te oe om Py ' rs i 'aees oa tem. a, few ay on Fae os vee ra ws i ay aw? ve een, B% Ye es ee e ms Sakae Ake nei tops gon fe , : "
es ' fina ro hee pa es ES on i, ta a : y, oe, oe me 2 ea a ra on a ~ ees teva: a a a re am - Fo : Le CaP pecs hy eee * Ss: ee 'a oa earl od a es os pa et: oe hey a fy ws Le ws ws a soe oh, ta 4g : re os eh JB ;
" ee f : ma is a ee a s "
-- mee % edad on epee, "hee oes, toe Ee pany eh ey os ce acroei ae " me es Sine os babies -- ie man 4 _ "eek ts sane whek oon ceca og a } aS co Bod we ye fee 7 Se pore foee oF: + nek won py arene boas) wa me cs pa ve, a e ~ é camel oonet, bot F baled es - e a "F Be fos x 2S pao # ieee ti is re Ge F tis pat ; a ees 2. " oi fe ed ee mds ry a % 5 ie ae 'nani yes od ea = we oe eee eee. te we 2 pe 2 on Fy ae a ee On iad ' ae wee om ra setee: py hey s 2 oO Bead "eons tt fey tes. eS . ee fe, , 4 Saab ges ae a a om, pe ae Pass ccna BA: hd an x a Sox tp Sree "St int " s a ty eee et pares ot See tree Be) cs eG La is a Ay is = oe weed oe Book sm of Paes r : "J Z ee me 4 a te stone a] . E ad a A ee gee o cers were te * , Kas Fs hed: a3 ps 'ad tee, mo % oS "f devs te 7 ey : om cea ws tf ones her - ¢ tf fen aS oa & . S pe a Dees me teed end z pees 5 ober : i 5 ex ae xe , a 3 ise ed ee 43 i & ' Z oe feny Pal ethinn ' . pov' a re 3 ony a my , a, m bord woe a of ' % pee Facet Jd a ; : ~ ae ; a ; ua ra a wes 2 ee See ee a4 oe = . « pot ote ae Sot : 5 Co Coens ped Bm) <A oe ie £ = we wat hues, ee os oats a 5 Z : é oS 4 ee i Ay aes 'int oo te, ie acs Me ot eh es nition, Sens <n HEE: hese , Se i a shee care et eer ene eae ene ¢ ee ee SAE re stead we "ES "te e "ied 'eagl see os ae pe anny hee: red: en, wo. : deer ot rots Peeve a anne Panne "eth 5 : "neg on won vee Bae fe od as we ch ea "af " beg Ly os om, "ch ood , ft a % Pes Bod Ke "mer mead oe we; cos ne vee, be, Bae os be nad Bee uM x roves ene to oe ont as . ce a eo} ay ton on ice re Bsa Hs . penne Foe' ee ae sre anege ent al * - boa aes 2 rat, "a pars weed rage yee. wet, a LE . jou oe ieee gem * ' Sa robe, ¥o tom. oe rag i teed ye pea ad we ed cae Gos: tee :
fon, = A : £ Be Ions ' a nee von : Bo ge at we : as ee 2 A Napa Ree ie 5 Me on pees "ha Be : bow Tad ywaeed a ae .
ot tg "eh pes ane fs ' eet wane a3 eo, ee ra ps i gee es if tee Le ww, x apie 63 ; a '3 tft wn fi ie vee ig ees hee wm, rn pee cee "rey oe era den ea ie ae tote oon #3 cons wed, we ef me wrerk, res, ae c 3 sae f . eee, Set [7 pene, went: cn OS Fs bes bach ye eee of 4 an ' 'nat eo ware cceeed dl we 'nae ye . wie ab $ ft bs ng Pi ee MS z, ode Sov ccaa ag Seana wie By i tor. cad ben Es ay Pct ° "5 '! a ies abies "need ee fey me 5, oe ol My, wy wn yp ., sas ce ia ee: oS cater fae are ; Soe were sent, % $e vanes! "sf bes a é Sa e ees "te he, of oa D z, wf ee) es ad mts 2g e Qe 2B 4 ar, 4 Poaad a ° "towel 'pes a Ss % week Soe aed ~ wees:
a a A a taf "a8 " "eget poten ener ont, 4, "iat 'tah 'nat: we es ae pon er ome, we bg pees Been ites artete Fag mth . Sami Foam " nee, Sade re ay 5 5 ard sent ae aA ot ant, Lot a £ ' ra gee whens ene, fk a eteteety Faced, gob Aa at 3 ss Vail Nemsiait" tent Atty, eer ntee tee, fo went a peed were eae "anes aad oes fi 3 Ay 5 e bad ae ae ae; Le as 3 esd wit "hed? xy pe eo tn foe "ry one ee eob "good wes ren von, res 2p, oS nce?! es Sane ae te rn. *, weer o age: eZ ay an { Fae wet eens rah ; , a as sng tha ae :
' & " "os eB nents, a Lo a5 :
= z 3 ey eet ° Pex al res ony es wee pom seed "Cs vn os sere reed rl se Seed z ¢ oe eer ae " ie aca! a ey, Wen. : ra on, Laps 'ee, Soe tert p04 4 yee poon ae oe poe Bae DK doped noes. ty ee a5 oA gt : 5 baesd Soe wn an pee ae pa ' ee 5. geri coe ie es, oo ee oe be oe a Log poet rs, mm a ene at feed aS £ ete, on we fe es xy i whine wo ie hes A Ya a _* red te te ad tea "
os wt aed bees 8 S. tek tak os on Ease feed nek pees) rons a at ans ra: ar, ron pond oni itt, pe od anaes soe. Pad pret pened, moo ed wees, See ay we ots ? ae , 43 be * Pers OF ics pars at none een : SS oon nnn G B stood .
on wa oa <& eee ta how who4 oe ry ee Hen pot LE oat qua + ee + ee ed oy ' nt oe " a Leen wo ahaa, $3 , fas a ye oe oe bots sd we re' po} be fetes Le pan 124 £ "seh vee Saeed we ern nee Bow Some? 'eet eed aaa eS baat bates, "hie 2 Seage Hg Ge oe ie ;
ee ns, 'tre. ". we * 'gee se aS oe es "a .
rm fey tok ae Boe. Bane: £ 2 oat > a * fon, fon * oF Le 'work. ca) x s a fe Phe ed 4 1% we a a : or 4 Ee ' test rie, £f;, nee 4 HE, oe, a} eet va ae; Sa site"
ke oe < : we ee : Nag i $ "a, Oe "ante nS a, oe GM, Bedy:
Reeccs cass % = ae it4 wee OAL Ne 38 appl s 8 Anone?
Arey th x ir S oP RAE He e oe = a, is te = = bf 3 od Esa oe ae:
ite, BEES * w Ss PAIR & © os f 7 bee a:
ao i SOG > ah ike is Oe?
S808} ea & fh Te fa ;
"> x in gh wer dated? 28.
Fac sae ae Pe Sb OF f sprarerd ge g£ ue RE RS % "A fei int f as € a Ber a Se ° * '.
Pe er fe Sard for the ref ce ESS PH ft Afarra faw wi BE goed SEES POPE y the 3d ed a = g az Jeon Hy and by re} a RS SF eo be ig Lo, g rae thuns! dat b for a pre:
Sane nen, fae os, Daa fo fans, abmis s ned oF < ta ne, rat ine Aas ae oo as ie Seen, a is 'net eee beac es z a * AS TH He aw <¥ Sed S vein a ver, .
eH Su mhadign fo ihe pas ied pre Agoounis Assists Wand nol app! ye.
ge.
Ae & Rang ge BOT Re x te allowing the O.8 sordenis chat the applicant therein is not entided "PB is teams of Para i apmicant was promoted ta the post af Accounis Assistant and the same ea ¥ ron af the reapondent Bench of this Feibunal i OLA.
(iv) Further, while re CLA. 24 "8 Since the respondents were not satigfied with the order of CAN, Afvdras Sench as welf fo way challenged Sefere the flan "Ale Hint Court af dudicature for Tan! Nadu at Madras in ieea Poritian Na. 2272 ef 2008 (Aanex AYT) and thelr Lordsiins vive order dated (922010, nor anty have disaissed the H'rir Petiign Out aise cbserved Stat they do aut find aay season te ad ay ire Yribunad the Hoa 'bie intwrfere adil: Gre order pass Hied Coart fed aar ealy dismissed the Pri Petition aut alse yeh £22 <p tee observed Mat they de nat find any reason tu interfere with dhe arder pussed by ily Tribunal Noweeer, for better waderstaniding of the dispute, the relevant observation of their Lordship are extracted éelaw:
"S. dn the Hele af the submision nade, ie point of cansideration thar arises is whether te resiractarine of poss die amount fe promotion if nat applicant is entitled for the benefit of ACP Scheme? What orders.
a. df is well settled principle that dere and agen Ge Hon life dpex Count Aas held Neat if any reiructuriag of posix fakes place Ho dees Hert amanni to proportion. Pherefare, he comentian of fhe fel Counsel for fre respondents dhay restpuctiing of post amounts fo promiation is witirel GY FELT, fi soar fhis makes clear that due to restructuring of past, fhe pay scaly of Rs, 2200 DINE wae revived fo Rs PLO, Pherefored' is clear tha' there wax ae promotion and H iy only revision of pay on arco af resinncturiag oF pasts ° x is} Lal, Counsel f » or the apmlics in order dates? 287 2018 had alsp observed as under:
"8, da aafe of seel authoritative proseuncement of te Lnan'ble Hiek Court af Madras, the department ald not saderstamd treir mistake and still burdened tte exchequer by fling a Special Leave Petition te appeal befars the Hon 'hile Apex Court in SLP (CC) New 8925 af 20701, Their Lerdship's of the Hor ble Apex Courteide order dated 40,2012, dismissed the SLP givieg a categorizal observation. They fave considered the pleadings and the material place an record and fhe sabenissinn ef La Counsel and jiey did nat And aay aieri ie ire SEP and, accordingly disnusse a mutter day beer set af rest by Nee Har af eanfenfiogs gesue, 8 aire ih PC ay: nd SAS oF culee witht ni 4. 1987. : cannot the} freate i ae 1 BromeHost "aid CaN one de treated as revision of pay on accannl of resteuc fering af Pasty é Legh 208 : merging tele L600. 2600. Sine & tie wa igned onder fits jadicial 4 pronounce emenk the SANE APE "fable 10 he quashed: iy 'the interest of justice and equity. Nevce, ardered."
1 Fhe OLA. i allawea and Ate speadine arders dated (33.2014 fanaexure AT Shad dee clanifeatary letter dated 292.2014 (Annexure AE?) Bowed by He Railway Board are quasted. The resents are directed to cansider the case of the applicant fer the 3° Financial Upgradation wader MACDP Scheme treating the restructuring of pay scale ap Rs. PIOU ME sived fo Rs. P9GU-Sh0U ay revision af pay due ie resirecturing and not fantmmoaniine fo promotion and te oh *e effect to the applicand in the dele of jasoment of CAT. Madras Boneh, as es been upheld te the Neale Apex Court, referred adeve. Compliance be made preferably within a period af three meaunties.
femphuans sepptied) ma Ld, Counsel for ihe aprlicant Groaught fo the knowviedge af this Trebanal, ihr the beme agenieved wath the iudarnent dated 23.4. 2018 passed by the Hon'ble High Court at Oniesa i WP OC) BSQ8 af 2007, the Rahway authorities ic. respondent is the Q.A. had Ales SH Siilnder of feadia vo Parmeswar Biswal) witch was dismissed by the "
Hon ile Apex Count along with other identical SLLP os} vide common aricr dated JO 3 20082 Therclars, & fas Been shinndted that the jicement gassed by the PSOE) upholding the order igyegxgsd soho UE Sas eee d a ee AES to seavoret Sleaalises aned maser by this Tribunal in OLA. No. S87 of 2014 attained Hoality and same is squarely goplicable to the facis and circurmatances of the present '* re pots £3 aA, Bred.
Peel one a thew:
eed rs :
ey "S Seana we 4 'eel en cae : ee we "i pee toy E : :
2 ~ ee eae oe & : :
oe " a ae < a 5 a 3 i z ary AES: tee. "a 7 ;
3 as a S : :
: ; : Sasa a ott : < os SS : : 2 : #. ths Pane Meg ; : : 3 : : on : ron a ees pear , me 2 2 oe Be y z .
on pee z z 3 i ; z A ts Ve eeaed %.
) ' , # te ay rr "eer 2 :
Se 'arin 3 eet . te : 3 : ears a Bid . oe : ; | | yee: poet Sof a Leg ' : : E & fe 5 : we 3 | EE B wt cored ifs yee ips > Sows betes Soot oat ay oe 2 : B Pa aan oe, * : : : . pot tote, at eet! : S | ; 5 B ns at wre, ke Bons or : pineal : eed a Roe pe bao Z ; s ~ - Ee Ee Ee 2 eh pa vA Fae "ne ea % : Z
3. ee Fas beer "ast 2 % :
hcg i, 'mae oe 48. ie ea a io Cay von Bas pase 3 oe) AG 23 ee x a rt ce :
. es = Bs rent a pia aataigt ro nd pai a | " : oo wa « & EF * a : oe ae we £5 tes 6 : a ee oe ae: : g is 'nae ° ". : on Ds es i oe £5 es a ae oe g "Fe nd & jose aA : : LEA. Peed Lk lentes vat SA : el ms nope < : ' ZB "Ro zi cS , : es, we Sat. a oe x Ned eae : z es 4 vas ie rae $e fe a pee oo ob : taf * 2 ce 3 e oe ne : Son, sa ooh, 'ad 43 ; 2 4 as A te, ee me ' ee od :
y eo 2 :
e tow Rcd : we Cent : i 2 ~ pase ad vr oe g 3 EB ors :
A tg '& E y Bs A 2 pees oS ae e oe weeee we fri zg ; ; 2 é,, tee a é : :
peg Sas aed ' = Ly po oe oe Soe PLOOe, =. ee a of ee fe , a a at ra g Paes wot ee os e . oS i oe ; oe nll > Se, panes ; . ; ge oe fe. Ee, - oe B3 ~_ A oe ;
us top ae a #2 & a ie ene, Ae. oe z : "pee Pe om : tot al ' ; yn Wy Coed a a at cen on, 4 ore Se on 7 oot oe he, wen < ; ay yes ¥ i we Pd oe. es ae oS : ae Pohl $04 a : : tot ie | wets. ' ies foe [08s : es a cc oe Af. ee poe ton , ra "eal Be ® be aaa ae ° ens : ; ° _ & ee fe RS Cope "S ek 599 a wen, rs 2 of a8 % iy trbation bars om, pa snes ate 24 kena a iS 4th the sas ce Es roy? io the perudal vet ra:
omotion hae ta x pr iy % as) AR th ioe Iw oe, iat ae Seen a, oot pes fe pn be x, Pom eee % eae, wv the purty Z BOHYRS ES HHCY oP ACS & % Hao eo PRUTPA :4
ot c see pa pea aed ze ras whe S "2.
aintment frarn Js < y
7. .
x fant is DrOMGHc "es, 4 "
Baa bese? ap oy "
; Toad 2 pa at a saret ny an, ord whee baal ay oe om od et new Spe ; cal : a ia os yee seh ond pens Se ied wee ed on oe y A ve ee oe saan Seat ; "a nook were ee, ee aac oo S05 4% secon eg ae ye a ee od oo me Le Gee ae eat pee a pe 2 ost ee, Poa! a oe os we oe:
wer bon Rod won: ig nat £ Poa hod 7 pose m5 ws as aA ood ae ad. 4 he bee ooh vere en a2 oa oS poe as A os ry oe, oe hoot onere a ae a a hook Passe Ly ween B04
a) ; paees ay a yn wert we get oh & we tag 'ceed Ey ae Se es atord bee a = wet is Fie a on a " ree ee veges, © ag Peds fed 3 OS es , Read va Ba4 7) bana 4 . &, » sien t a open, acd a poole 7 ae Le vaew TS ee and oo 5 pi, 'ne i 4 ab. ceed gan *3 wg, roo ead hao x cee eos ee eee. oi ~ Laer apes fey peas ' ant key en oa be Peden x3 Sines 4 x i" ms god re "3 oe ps wn, a n> a 2 2 @ © a ' Pee " .
; 80% Bes f vat wos -- . ee oO be BS oe " ty ery ze + pee 'pl Pa s eS Pee oe es and "ee ve ny beat aS iron Eee a) vad my yre seat Rood * ee Ps peed Ded oa ie a As . a ae ee bates thos LA bod ae £ iz ee che es ' * fet Te. wn ron ans Ps :
2 ay ee bees oe oy " Petes, 2 'ig args , Lp peng oe, oe : ee ba pth 4 oa Si Ss ns ae wt "tha as ; E48 wy 4 Thaw aeons wey pn * ne ae 3 ts at. Were ge, ~ nae ed * 'Sa t atts Bs kee te oe oy iad psoq a tere a recess ern "ees y Celine etl, Wy 43 as tom Bones ; ead a : fee wv - ban z 43 3 ay wes, * vy a fae asd ene be Ps we on, font geek cae owe aff ee mst -- "eee come" Hoty Pa Pag hee or tS hen £3 " we. ait Reed Fons ~ eee "eg Ee we Sat om 7 ny all ater pare ex on bad Ahh 4 ; aon, , ay a oS me ta ot vey on o>, oot, af ws ae, fs Le, fy SH a Gow aes ra oe "nf? oe) Serta, se fom 2 'hava Meee 3 pa ee ad pd mm Bee ; iced #3 ns -, ' & om pee ink , ae? fa ae * pea ae BD aoe atenr. mo Sows, ty A, pon Sed yess eed eat yee are tne yon 's Be see, bec peoes. 4g bs kona a ok oe 4k oft oe a wen pest ef 3 x ao Se pa mn Be LB sees a rs oe A * & " es ee oy oa oe * bapond a wrote oe ae bo fey ' wane . ee oe oy a SS as os te - tag ns 404 Hes eet, oes paies Rica TA oy we ce ae ay ES pace poets oa SS aes a a cas ae 7 ' 4 a2 :
Sno nee, Me Sana Ecos op %. & att:
ain, ea %, ot ping & te ores pee a sin * " " es ae ye x EG es bod sh cae' B4 ie ay roy be mpet poe poe, cand OR were bas Oa ine % me "nee ay ey %e
-, 2 ead we ¥oR " paren wey sei be a eat Esc BY Fate ae ee Naat & £3 ceeet os np sete ee 'eased Seat pea ok tod "ss kas ye oe Pores fees fa 3 ie ay & Fe Se 3 of an fe 'ite SS ae os Ke S54 = a8 het 4 2 we x oe Pes eel a Pe tg a4 ae Pre. oe a ad LES bra corr Sone. were et, ' ten, Witag net ee ahead teh ag" Pe 'ee wy ° pete! cad 2 ° i ge sae ne oe a z bite fh ee ocd . rw] ape ha yen, 7 spk a8 he ee Ges eri ies bot rey Enh, pecei Kcaed "reat pes ak hop ee a e ap cA te a ise te ges cc oo Ce seed Peng age, . te £p vat peed Boe a. ae oars ot Boe aes wot Pais A wi _ ca Lites, A; oe oe nd "gee z : poe ares, 2 a, : ne Pa wn ee os Ee tae ee ee oe oy po gee! i a ees cd sr, Ces 4 ood a3 we or, 'awed ees oe en Ca 63 * ww Seat ae Bs "eet ier: x ae m4 ee; a) ay es; be . EE " ote ke a * wiki CZ as % won oe oe co a Peed : Pome es Ses pre ae ies pa oe Hak, 'a yes ees aes ween, aw, we ot "yf L. eee 508 bod Raced Ft. A pee re a meena aia A Bost bed oh Loe on _ we a? ~ uf Sat -_ oe oa ie a a4 segttees col beceed eves + rah ez Bas 25 a BA ia beac] 'age peste hee Boy ' Ay eae cael on 4 ~ Pie es S pea . pee pont "wot ie A wom, vet oe ra cos ai Sa ee) pee we ee ta an < "rt = os we oe pe %, " oe oe $ port ed wet emet ae ee Fan 'nines pager! 34 Kos oe . ee fre oe e _, iG :
ete os, By 508 2 wes. baat Paes . ot eewis,, potkas a ' oe neo oS. a5 23 peed ot 4 Eeacecl 'peers : ° Le Saag o noes ran tet £ ae Ess aS PF ot be a oe oe oe Set a a S Se 2g « " * ex 'rept + ; ea oe sb LE Pa of eg oo, oe 2 :
yen & oi ott 4 @ oo a 2 on, , me wee Sen Lae oe, : tH ag Aaa S Piece ft ue, oe Pa A ates tot 2: oes 2 Bee vas td EE wed peneng peta wet £e%, St rae "set hey, ", ' ry bond ' "gs ". Camel Gates, fits aoe, . Ss 540 a wa & site ea vo y ie es "sat oo ee x od tetas, we ~ a pe " fad Bd bos ag sob oy ty ond , yoo. yee 3 weet sae xo hawt "eat P wy nee . Sit sere re 4 * os " tn chews me aa 4 Eee nent ee Ie ee i) hes «3 vem ye "ae "ft we 73 'pg on ae rage "ad rd hove ane Lae att BE Ean ' on , elt fated aed pao Pe Lael al ones rie oS a wees Ser Bs ap ie Ay me when "ae Sone eet j ety Pee, Lied es eet aes a ' yn beng ae! aed pass ee ec : aces " ay eee ie @" Bisset wage vine, Bat faved %e, poe , mee a ¢ : PA Peete oh Meeeey <7 j Se. passe ad 3 oo at x en ve? pe om co oo 3 ae oo fos a ° aos. Pars aes mee Bas fact ei i pot coset wie We a oi te : oe ft po * " An. aes, : eee Sct peers ane Dn Set on r etter Ee ped ye eee £ fe ae ° Pes LER Loe te, od wee, poe ied fon. wry spony 3 ea. on ey, pees Figed 0 ee.
Fon sis Re . pos wee Fos) npn is aes toe pe ope fs x . A oe so eed iat re pou oe raat Bots Sade pears lees "nat oe ay ae peels w ° Bare Ears en: as Koel tbe pi Roa ors lors pees 'aoe roan, ae Smee "Soi? &S wa aot RS "Cage "net we. rae ty pi hoe a ° geet cae 'ot Sed pecan ses Pe; Es oe :
om base bac FA # z A
"8 rien ps a "4 a ty oe wg Sow hy Fexal ised if ee wo eo ac be Sere enee side ah Seed perk seen. ane. 'pane ain' ar = a ? Seaee' rae pte, ce) ne $ Aeeh ent oF tnt per we, re er Ly LE pee teste ne week et ae 'snd! ' ce Bees Pao, eee Saeed 'aah ¥ ine pecs : . "ft on ret - pe cae ne ny fox od pa . a ee we = Riad rane sane a, seat. spat ond Bow . a oar oy cna A eat % i 3 Pal er red Ses paeee ng Fond oh ny Be bo) ome & a & eA ogee ane eth, wt be proors 3 ta "inh aes % oo ieee Fe G . ' "3 a £3 - & Pe, . mes ri a3 xs, e - mane bat 2 ' a d pots ws nee Ze Spee, A iacae "
' pa BE Be: oe is op. cage ; aa et 2S we be ener Pe wie " age y ee a boc po oy cae] . ay pee e anaes oy Bscers on ye se. "5 Pe PsA et bye ood z. "ee ae corn Z ee, pene ea arn pad ms ee a ° on oa et oe a sft 4 A a wu ae i 4 ee yan pe, te cd Sonn ae maaan er aeerh pies "et an é a oe a ¢ oe -- ves bong re, ; bet Set baad cas peor ae na hae o woes a fet aoe z . gl : hoee ret on, 2 'at end Kr, ay ane oe Look RS oat: $ vate wie see Log see we pee, RS ae fe = s = ee Ts te any pas bee on yon = ee wong pees roe ares ios ond mm eae ~ mes wet. tee as a S pees ae Po * Ba a ya tad " The €" Central Pay Coannission bud recommended lar tere should be broad parity in tie pay scaly af the staff (dccoxaty Stagp ouvd offer Accaants Greanizatien, No fas further recennnended thai the propased seale of pay of Ra 1400-24600/- and Rs, 2000-3200)- may be treated as functional grade in future and that there will be no selection grade for any af these pasts. Ag regards the number of posts in the higher functional scales, fs the conmmasion led? this mutter for the Government to decide,"
aa ay para 2 af ike aforementioned Circular fois mentioned thar:
at been notified side tis Aitnistre's ferter Ne PC FF soda Schedule! dated 24.9 188bie accordance with the orders therein, cerfain persons foie already been avlowed dhe Aicher Further, ia pare 3 ofthe sand circular, @ has been stated that:
* fhe question regarding prmier of posts ia be placed in the dieher scales af puy bas bees ander Me consideration af tus in Aivher and dower xeafes fa the accounts cadrey stay fe ay fells "Fs Sona: nny Sf a a 4a we, be FS 3 ae re vat + eee fan atte bs " rer goa ., $5, seat + aan : pan eee, Se ' SS yom Boar pine x ry * ae os pe oA os on Bae ae "ad aes gen an £ : eed, Fad "ipsa Ss eae, ft : es ey os
i) ape ae 5 "ae Z Ey we be ae bo es Pe, nae. ors 23 ee. wy aR i ¥ rd ¥ ® ey :
:
t :
t :
:
¢ t :
:
t t i i :
:
:
:
t :
i i i s s i N i N : PROSE or GG aad As.
= ben ae 3 iow ', te, fava Sad iid ge 60 a bined ; = a :
$ ie Ps ": 24 peed i pce ah pa a cA ne bee a ae z= fs ; es i ae "ue om on a me & 'i Baa "Bie ete, ; ft an al fo a ee : . ; tA p ey 2 ane! y et ia ; us z 'se : wnt t a. ty a ? phy, ae t --. and i. 5 x 'nat AY a " : Es Pg Pag, sr, oe nee, in laa i os Sed ng "Sem Z Sent Sune ooh : Fa ee: a 4 . we ae : Mer ae ad 'wt oe Se oy 3 se fen a :
3 ee aS Pad a, 4 wh 4 3 3 coed z "adh tee "a 'at ea 3 2 Ae. %, Yyr¢ a at en ye B potas beg aon too: on : ord Be ip. . : ghee ea re Ody iss on oH ; hs i fe "een ee : oe 3 ee 8 'pi = Set ed 4. ™ =. "ete Sox: es = : Ripa oe me yon, al iy dy rt aoe ff Fodfert © ees % APRON aN z ~ t cae " = s } 'alee po ae be 2 ¢ wrt 18: ey cect . Sead oe, fe me ae ete F ; nh, peed € oe hy: tees, bas ceed sone 4 ¢ 'eet Food ant Hog. . pant BE rcs "
os ¢ by Fae 4 * a ue, wen get: ra io m i Rak ano, toh "ey ie ¢ ome wees io 7 Son pas : ¢ wh es, Perend hes '¢ Sree fine, &. an po KG oe a as a Seon bpd ther Hing we oo " rah, OA oes ped a 4 he wh. &E: Fie vere ° "eee See ' ot Pes na Fi re way Pe at & th see es ot fe : en * ie ps ae fi ca aa cad igi on eae "ot %, Pas = tent oe 28% ae wie OH: iw Bde a ae Peng: Ae id oe. ers aaa wi ae = '3 Pa oa & a 2 Ba ceeceteneaceveveatenent oe, a 4 & oh, ee 24 oo & Be ae ES wee ee % is rr op. Be fe os oe 7 we an eee te gE a ts «e 'ee oy. SAN os (aaa ". a 4 a iy e 'eet "as ae he = Eon a ; x Eo "et we Sab: , = Ge ri ey, 'sage oe. a, 2 he & a Ace Bc oe, tony. pod pea Cee xy op. et tae S Need Ae ig : ae a ' a wy "gy ; wen SE rs Z Ei "Se" oe po "we bes Ca Kos sf a meee fect a oe a "3 xB bee Zs aed we oR we ee iso ah i $ 4 oS Banas Be x ge Be pons baa oe ip, bd Sere ood oe at ered %y Age t- oe ed fea van, caoae , Oe os _ Re Sant " ont 3 wet & oo Bom : ies hs one, a oe es "aes 5 pod nner Pesce as wed "r My sid one pen. Tong 4 ES £8: 'ea : s are . P Fah Nop 3 tit bor aye "opie oars AE " ves. tea ¥ © es a oe, ge re.biy eles en - 'A $3 Pos oe : Coby 7 "ee "
3 prs ta ea Mie = ~ a 23 00- ER.
y Prades & i q oH ad place mooF "eek 3 i STS % ;
Ree?
ie 2 # 2 % PONE & TESTTAN i "these orders take cdenis vide 0) As regards de SUT BeL.
y Tata Pos eee one a "a _ food es eon 4 On " fe > ed ee, eid, mgr baad book Spee ccd roe wl "og Se oe. pee ici oa bed $6 pect sae; ae tb ee cae sot apek « my tig mw. : es , 2» & : ed s ¢ os, wee Caced Z eis bed "eee ne ics Pd es bot on eo i és aa a i bee & eo Se a a po fen. a ow we a Mes es as be Fe Y: ace we; a es ye oon ; me uA a ae ae a: pe we oe oa oe , ayn » oy, "dh ra nets 208 Sn.
pica 2 eee ond Shy and Ot wy aa S x He 3 Sey af x Tune of ane;
yay eye y 3 oe See roan on
-
OY x Be Saas \ LG gay 3 < ah werkin Rey \ TINE WWGS & p mi ihe respandents werp directe:
x Ny 2&8 WANE To The said quashed © Veonkataranion, # wy "
Xs Apex Cour Ht ny ar 74 va oe chick Were tak <. whi .
feomdd Temean Beas Han appl y thes ¥ x het as oe :
pees 'ees we wee. ce Pky Lies 5 , re wo fnew fen oer load Hite x eas 43 we" oon ladh not oe a pa fe roe os te meee ys "
: ooo ese oo te bare Vm:
ed Bo] Una, os © ey sor En > < 3 x yi af proamcdian to ihe $8 q x aad conten fern, as Pa :
pe * sf 'apna bon ve ee) Lan ed Powe' As 2 = '7 oa ¥ ioides 'meee pees, En ea por ant pa :
$. Sani ee es By pa pe re eee eee me at hod eee tn GS ian' ap fa on os oa ars os os ee ;
& NAL POSpay } Cail "eee "~ td ay th geontasst Pn a oe ge SS yy 'aurt af ©} Sy a Hon his High 4 dnted % x pete, cree oe "i ns ry we ee Ley : be + cone pad ay £05 im fag we £eo OH cardinely o Jer dhitec Courac tees gine A Seas taf SSS S ae bs ave ve one Be Bees:
eg it:
g = Se, % Paid Pe ps x Pat wets 4 cy TBs a ced Ps pert Pro on pes yy. toed ot pas i a Fone' See oe ten, ee Ba SS: nal nad on Aten ee, aed yes ry Xe i aver whic Sp SARS GES i i wh Court on oe ae Ps ered :
wos be Gael os ' FB iy elon, rate Lana vs hen territer pore oe cas me Be Pon a ee pee Fo , . Psa] pes Foca he 2 ao.
'Seen, wn ' anni A a m9 = sna pe bord ' eee Bar. SARA eee. 4 > e esti ~ ae Se oe Bs booed RRRARAAS.
wi heme fo a or ew oy ga : Pot , ata "ee a. pce eh:
pa ag. oo weet, oo Saas sr pa Ps cans a i554 oe eh ge oat pod an fogt: Ess aw deel % pte bd co po point Tribunal, it would be binding:
eatly, we Raid:
R. Scrat wt ee are . y a Ay % a 3B ts se pea7 ps Pa Tmt od Lord paenies) x4 as. joe Cae meta a aa ~~ at Sean, ee So Soe ees i) aed ee nw os es id e " 'met Pos "ae ee ae a we ee, aches ot pa 43 "o Saat e yer, HES actthiod % be ag cn YG am, Food 4 an oe bon g he vee sehen ed Lae ee eo iat sat we yee ge aA bel men ae we a we ae : 33 Poca a wEA bans ae nh iste ee oA eo 4 3 oan, oy Ps : hes "tet ite 4 ns ee go wed % ; 'ot wee ban ee 2 a2 ' pa = oo! of z Peed oe 2% best Sd eed Y ety tans reroll ws aa a2 ~ ;
Te oS e 4 ten a ree, aso tt = Pot re tae PA % Pd 2 £3 noe - & s ae awh pee) cal ;
Ly oor Kass,
a) pea x :
& vats TE ge A nepen "4 0 WAR ireain nee.
pee 2 bean Naat ra Mist gnc Saeee eves ae aa ee y Cour af C he basap at fen fen ass eS 8 ise eh bonne ords & vised to Rs, (400k:
mipupned an pnt of pars os ates, procs) es 0% ise Seas iaaadl oe tis, eA 5 ped, Z ;
ce uy e oe ig eee gry me oe ¢ ey ee, carers. ed eee, an ARE ee iA bee gee of o oe ee ae tg a age a ee SPT ao ari CETTE eee necnane: EEE IIIS i the Kase ad fy Re case af tat ae tact AQ?
xt therein who were emplovees of £ cits granted to their cousterparts in the Northera Reilway in pursuance of the wc ANghabad High Court which has became fing! the Hon hie "vod de feat af command of driicle if and 26 af the Constitutian of fadia, the same treatment is required f be accarded to Are petitioners regardless af the faet that they are xenvag in Eastern Railway andess # is shows iat there is seme diinguiiing feature, fur according a different ireatment. La. Additional Solicitor appearing far the Railway . ; is mat in @ pusifion fo contend thar there is any xuch special distinguished featare fo pasiify denying af uniformin: in treatment. The prayer af the Writ Petition suet accordingly he granted fo the aferesaid extent. ff is therefare directed that petiloner sfeesealel be xecerded We sante ircaimen?t ax tieir coummerparty are being accorded ia the Northern Railway ia revard denting the running allowance granted te ie running staff as part af re pay when they are transferred or promoted fo a stationary past during the period they Radi the officiatian in ihe stalienary past te Me same extent and an Hee sume manier ax enfaped by the dtahabad High Court pursuant te tre aforesaid judgment"
ix.
ese a the present case, as discussed hersinabove, undisnuied!y the similarity placed Agents A deht af the orde wagered Seer 2% BAERS SQL ponte been granted Lo a sinilariy situated employee Le. Mr. P. by He Han"hle Apes Court im the case off $5 hai the arder passed Gy The Divisian Be ped S55 te ny EAL Ne, a ac, ys BS phon OLA.
e applicant f $
3. PHENT Fgh coy yh f20 Lal helt 3} and tp 2 Ses SPARE