Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner vs The State Of Karnataka on 12 April, 2010
Bench: Manjula Chellur, Mohan Shantanagoudar
EN TH:«: ma;-i Cf-€}UE'7€"E" <2? E-{AE1ENA'i'z%}{A, 8A:xz{:;;u,<:>§e:f:f: §_
m*r2;<:::: W23 '?E%Ei 1235 {BAY {)9 39323;, ;z:3.:'§§- VA '
?RESENT .w _ "W
ma 1-~I{}1'é*E?:§.»E MRS. J€.}S*'i'itC.fE; P«§;5;"?§JI;'?'_Lz%.:€:&I4~§;'$f§;L;{}'I%:.VV '
mi> ._ :. " V" '
?fiEHfififimfiMfiwmgfifiaMQ$§NS§mfi§fi§%fii%R
'WfiTAH%fiLNG&¢&S$3§?2$E§@%RE§
BEfE"ié§:'E2ET'€
1.'E"h.€ {:€3}.}:'§3:;{i,4';SAS's:.}:%f}1T1€3;"::El: > --. Karzzajlgaka §_wE{5'::.s;i:j:gg§"E3<)g2:i*§'«.__ _ ' Cauverj; Féhassazi' " M K, G; Ri:'s::§:3 ' M ' §i%a,z'3.g£¢:§.{:s:'€:--"_.-7?_¢ M '"§"§1s:.' .3-§:é1.if$'.f §fZ;1.1gé;:r3I:r;-e31j_¥\!§z*:351'§3€:"
= §{a5r:1at:iE«:a'§%.Qusing 80991111 » €:&»?;V€37fg"B§'§%"*§'Z%:} "_g,G;§agr';
.3? 'E'E1:;€".%C:;%Vg:2:s.%::$ 3¥.E§3€E"§1'i'E€i}{§€{i'§I Eéamafafiia H=Z}E_iSiI1g §$a1'€E {T-;;;::<J€rj§?' Eéhavan V' Eégaci ' .iB§a*:7.s'gai{:rew§ fiPPE;L"§£§§*+f§'§ '§EL%;,= S2"i. Qagigavéné E3. 2%.. Eiuiisiamiuls Sidvsxtats} §£ND E; 'The State ssf Kfilifiéifaiiéi E33: its S${"?i'?3'§ic1£jJ ti;
§)r3:}:::«1z*t«1::1c::1I cf Laimzzr M; S. I*3ui1t"3;i:1g Ba:x1g21}o1*€:- 1.
EVE/*:;. Nagazjuzza C--O1}S§1'¥.E~:T'fi{3I1S Ci<>mpan§; Lii;'{1,itt":f(i §~£<3:3{}3€, Batavifga {lhambers F~§<:;,8<._ ' _ Kumax' Krupa Road -
Kama: Far}: East §3a11g3}ore--{}5 Represented by its Eiozzipaixjf ;§EfCr€i-31:27' a3'.1::?" ' V Vice Presifient;"{L€=g{ij.) ' _ Sri. M. V; S'_3"i3'3§?§:i§a4§§:Z"Z:fl_?;1I"?;h")F'__' .',".VV RESP{3?§§.){~§?~%*"§'S {By 83%.. Ba V§er&;:;fja;>V«:.5'§_€?gAb£5;r*::}?€}} M, \3}"'e.7€€is2t€,'.}fia1a, ,1:*?'::V.1£fi"\'.'-(7')tZ')i=&'g§'€f for R2} Tiléi-§?2£3' '*<§3fi§. A;§';_--"2sé;3.§ .LV"f§§:%{2 :1; S 5; of §'I?.2.«:: §{arI:.a$a§{a Hig_§724 C;<::'s.::"';%* fia{.' "{"l'~ §:>r¢=:j,~%i11g to: $55232' aaitiie fim ozfiei.' gassed. in the 'E53. E', Na}. ;' 2{}{}'E' '$3253 2: W556'? ,1 2§}§*§' €§§§'i'Z€f§. {E33, '?:{}¥'2{}E}¥:}a {Z'Gf£§§I1g cm €01" ?1"&§im§11a:°§f §~§€a:{éi:g this (E§;_§;g_ '?x%§3§.~%Z§1*§E;LLUE€ J: deiivemci the fc)}i0z%2.§11g:
Jiifififiififi'?
3 " }r§;::&re§." the £631-iméi éfgzzzzssi far EEK: a%p§3e§ia:;:"?g M; £30 .'f.1§:;.a --{§G:%éz":;:.:::6§'3.:' z§a.{§V€}{.'8;§f!' ami 11%}: Essie 'if, Vesiachala.
-- ;§§3'g§€I a:"é3';:g 53: {£25 giriéiaie 1, 31% <~.0m2er2;€:§ :§:::p.a:"E:::1e:1i' ':0 §'%ezsrd as ;::3.é:1':£:%.{>:1e:;§ 3 upm. "
4. E31 £4333 §')f'E3E3£'I:E ('E3365 {£26 C{}"§'}'{I'éi(?'i' €1<::{>':,1I'e_'i§z'2§fixizfiérgiti £111.10 bafixvséitzz {he yarfies at fi1i;:3€>=:'i'::*::*f€Z' §sp€C'ia1Ef;f'£Z_§§i';.:::-g _ A' ffiffiffi "Eu sfzvtirai d{;<2a:m&*:1i.$ arizi , cs_*srz'e$130i':-::i:a':1<>€g.".;I%'1Aa1i {@313}? mm i:xistf::.":s::a:: §3$?".Vs?'€fi3E} {ha ' £.";':.fg'V{,;§.E1{'§ rc§;p«:;:&{i€§2§; V V ' :33. Thf: Esrarnsd §'a_::¢flé;:?:i_'.:%.'.;EV."'.bz'{':_v__presgsni: C5135} is <t<331:re:::°i:1t":€i <}ggii1:§§ '-as ifrmifii' was mucéz priar '£341 _Efi%i'iCQ}.1{§. E'fiS:I3QI1{i€;'11Ef wrii }'}€'ii:'E:v{€)E1€3"i'¥1i§"?$ .ne:;f§ §3}:«.2t,%}E§-:~_ is p-33* '£16 C633 at 1%} which :«:?'aS a};i'&a{§.'§,.5 -.:::3i§éC:€:s:£§'%§'§? Viigri: é';:§5fi31.:t. fish }E:~;}s;>:ji§i:1g§§;'i_ "%;Ai:*-_§::" _p€ti1::io3': fzieci 33}; flit: S€{7£}i;:{% _. V:'t:s;}<;1,:V{?:'e12iL'2z?§2s ;aii':;~3>;:=f éd fifzfiatiizgg {E16 agspaiiagzt 'ac: mf:,Lr:1£§ {ha ?.s3_ié .a_13";.:mi:':f£' §,G ?.§}.i3t geirazici I"fiSp<<:}E}{§€I}'L. 'E"h§ preaani agjpfiai '{":13s3.ls:_'§ .§3fe;3:::;f§"€§ Cflilffifiéiflgf by Eifiaiiizig {E16 'g}:'0v2ZS:i{:n 2-2?2:6:'€:'*-tha Vf€C'"§lfv5*§'f; {ism {Kati éfy' 332:: {§0%ge§:;;m$:2t it wqmézi 6:3}; K *~_._%i::§éca'z€ .%;_§};_;%: €316: <:o::§ra:?E {§'i'£g§§§ :5; Ex: fmaiigérai agzii %§':€::
' :%%e:%_z'E:_§;é:;gE1€ $2; hzgvit %}<=:€:1 €;i'€'}'fiim;ifI'iC{i{§ grméaz' fie) EYE };.:Z€}i3é $0 233 is get €ht:=t E){:3'}€fi':. bf; ms S:-:c::m& 3"€S'§}0T£'1{'i€'.i}'fI, i'.t7I},{i_(",§'§I'-."§C>3'f-.' vi':OZiiI'€i{.'fOi'. "'I'h€jis' {+1130 3:633' 12339:': 'iiéfi d@:;?31si::§:1a staiszfi _ 1;: '2f{}G8{1} AER Eiar. Hi": z's:p::a'rts 2:3 §;éf§;,"':--§:g:i%:;g_'_:g;
Cempzfmjg vs. Natiunai Eiigizwagz bf i::;€ii'2.z_ & :7
3):;
Ltd, VS: ?I"1f: Assistam Q:33ié<3?,0::f__'_L{VTlVf:;;$_§t<;a:;}ss; 3} ELK EFJQ6 Kai: 2§'E'8 §ff:S;j§iE1§3;'}}.:T;£§"*'§:5§'f;:»:?I"&fiGI}. {sf Endia V3. 51.33% Gazxgmihar S}1an%:-Efiégg "
4} ER 2069 3' §":*<:V/.£31*..1:L'?:V'i,§;¥V}.v'8:.fL"§V}V£:5i'"5}:3V€;'£'S€aS {§rra.::i'i:::
Limfisai VS' :};;:;§;§:a~e{i; .3136 fi11I€pO1'ff;':§"i :i;;:?§s§§§#.1';':2.'{}i)9 Ciaiéci E1. _"§..2{} 10. Si} far 33 ELF? i;Zi§%}§3 ~§{a:*:r§:ié:?;é::a.; giiziigemeixi. sf ifiévisiczqz B<:n.2:?h aim am>t§1€:j §§§5.:ési<3:: Efiafiévb jzéigemani. iéatfici E. L 326* 19 fzazsés art V" 1_ éiiifgisiji r§3?f§{%:¥:_.:1'E?
::,::§;0:"t5:i 'ave éacéaiazgs gfiariainiiig £9
2 EL}? 1§§6 arse aiéé 0:1 {iiifaxfiizi faités, '§'§f1€ r€§3<:3:"i:=,{§ {i€CTi§§§{}I}. 3?
" Eiaz" re-parts 213 Wa$ Wiih régazfi :0 {E36 {§3.3é€SEi(§§3_ ' i¥;§'%.5e;§_b_§'_§:'€re is {'i§S§)Ei'§€ ixraéiiz ragarci {:3 £225 fag: aaehfiiz E'i":€ §,;9;3_€:%'act was Cazxctiuiifisi, {hm} $316 wrié pzziitimz Cmzézé not {:5 ' A . §é'a':::r:Ea:z1£:i.
me 1995 Ear. 2986 -m M,'s§ E'¥'§§s<::0§:AAgiec':-»_Cii.;:§;fixiC€¢£Sé. {P}
8. T223 Eeaziaaci simgiéé Jtadga ii: the grmesem rafezfizzg $0 §€1}1{3Eh€§' u11~i°e;:§::m""ie<§. ;':.1{ig&z3_':{i;':t. ' ieafiiiiai $;*221g1€ Jmiga in §?€.?,13823f heié ihat £3116 E2(}IifiC;i--1¥'.ii')E'1 aiaicd 18. £3-.2(}<1§'?T if £1065; amt .i--ip§)§}--' 'is'; tbs': 'facts sf §§};i;"'KV'§','é3f;.'.*;"_Vi.S€i'1".iV§"Z'{:'c'3.;€§{;"v as' W-2&3 accaégatfié mud}. pxiaz' is E, 1 :§T'.§j:f;'VC13;"'£'..s.fitfi.:
93 f§cv::(>1"€§:i:1g' "arcs EEK? $316 seconti msgaeznciszm <::>nfra<::_ was §t§1:i¢§:i<§é:§ a Batik GE-grantee cm mg: isttsr daicd 2339,2986 iaziizzxafizig their accep'€a:2<:.:§% éfiiéé ' V .
fix By géagfiizgg wlrm:*€:§;*; C13: off ézm:
:35 :i33.+:.i:lc.::1:§:_{§., §§Efi' '_f§_j;'vS?{v .§;}.§;%i'?.i.é,'&§'1'§;'3.*f'§§';i?£? Sfiflfififiifiii xwguiai {ififuléiaifg Q"§ii£'5¥¢iC8'i§":€}3%§} ;£z?5.$I'€ $§;t'§3:;2;Li'sIVs§011 9%' '£316 Emzdar waa tzzgaetagh ES "'%:a';3§§§E§.4" §h:: highfist ';i,:::i:;ida:: '?h€r&f{.>§*e, in "flag ' W '§fsi'€S:£;§I'i§ "{fe':£Sf+;'f ";¥:j_::'§%'€ 3CC€§}'£3E}{f€f :3? '€€I".{§§.;E§ sf e;:w:;=1:i1"8;<:€ was _a;ag;.p3;::::;ag:. %E;;_ 3:} 29:29:35 am the <::.§:ijgi70r;:1a§ii§;{:f Sigiiing €316 4§;agit'at3nl2%--:}m§' .§Ii{':'i}¥°§}{}¥'é'§§'§j'.§§§ :E:§T£;:3$: {€E'fiiS ami Cezgéifiezizs was Efiéiiiiiilgr E12 2335 ggzeraselfi €?f:1Sf "fiia execufiarz of Bank ":f}:,§ér'a:1§'é3é? is m}§§}.i.z'1g bu?' 'S533 éTi{?{."€§§31TlC€ «:3? 233% e3:§2fE3:E.;:$§m€.s;:% prgposai $611? by fix: e?E€p;~13:imm':z{ '£23 316 bi{1€i€?3."-. is much prim' to 3.132885"
11" T3.1&.1"€tf01'<:, 'ihé: isarnaezi {'(.}1i1'lS€§ f<3rH_:i'iL: s5éf(:~Q1";{i 3 r:?s;pc:2m<ir::1i. §7€{:3,S __§u:§sEifi<:d in Sa}=*i:1g {E22}? 3:} 'i:a:»._as fif{'ii~§u'"c{}?';€§1f:§:§li1 0?' (Z'€SS was 1101' 3 term 2§"h.i€:3'l was ag:"€$<i".';1p011 %;:;'»::¢é3u&>.5 1"=.}€*'r vmczuifi have: §I}C§*L:fi€{§ 'ii:-': am$'u$1§.'».,;;'"'..g:$§S 'ii': amtmfit if it. wag Z}3fifi€d:" tg '§,§1&<*;V£i'i E1; §f§;::3w' z::f the aifsoxss rcua3<;:1':.'u1g, W6 am fig? "E+r::.a1"I1€& Singie Ju{Zg€ V§'EiE§ A§2.:s;iif'i;;€:;§;:i13.. 231121 we find 12$) g1'<:*»u1:{£s §.(:s__.22fi?<:§%J fi::iv;e1*d_ifig1j; :,.'fE.':;: "appg;éE3__ am j i§.iSfl13§,sS.€££. Ci<;:nsa:q::€:nti}; Miscfifif, ;,'$§0§, f5;'zirE;iVE: ce:;11sir:§€ra€§£2n., % % s&/3.
rapsg 3514 magi
--. _' V