Toyota Kirloskar Auto Parts Pvt Ltd vs The Commissioner Of Central Excise on 13 October, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

Toyota Kirloskar Auto Parts Pvt Ltd vs The Commissioner Of Central Excise on 13 October, 2011

Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath

ﬁé?HE%ﬁ$%§C3§§?{E7KAR%§?ﬁK&;?8&NGé:G§E

$§§"?E@ wig ma :3?" 3%? G?" <t;ai:":'®8§Ri 20:1 

?R§SEN?

mg E~é§E\§'§E_.E MRJUSTECE §§.K{,§%'§AE?-- =- 

§N§

mg %%C3§\E'§LE §'v'i?.,§i.JSTEC€ :'E?am'.fii' {§é1;aL:i%4&/3%; %   * '&

§EM:€x1@3§>E* 20:25' A
agrwemg  A' '

*r$x=<3m §<::R:_@gé<AR AL§*rLQ_'E2;=:§<?.$ pjmf' :3 
pm"?  :a:@.2:; Siam; :;'a:9%k;?&;*:"f:"2gA:.;..;£"1:':r%.::~.2,a   
RA§'»€AE'4%§§\Rﬁsf~€ TﬁLL§E< ' V  '

B,m~é@aL,@~:;§ .-;- E3*§2 

P<AR?~é;33:AK,5x   H    _ -

{REPRE$~jENTEfi_'} av:%§g,;<..,{;';:ss%§§:~«:;»a:x: §{U?v@i.ﬁ,?;,

x;:.:H0:WE~T:«rv2 E=mR'§.::':":§faj;  "  ,',»'%?@ELL!'«:f\§"§"

{av 39.: ;<g§,:<:,ss~a...r'§; i§§f?}%?€?<Z§%'¥{;"';'%S'JC3{";ﬁaTE}
§=N3§_§ V  ~

._ °':*s-sé':::s:::rv%§:§$A:§r2sER 95-" CEFéTR;EL EXCEE
 L7{%j;' 5% ._T:"7}if:i.E F<:~:_,_,
-:::§:m" ,:«::;s;;@ .':<<:m¥r;a;

EsE§é;3a--%7%'§~§;':,E*ié§{fsi.R§:=:-éﬁ §"§2:i2§a
?}!(:l§%"d§'<T%§£i\§¢{::».'§,§:":(~§.'%..~"f-Llgggg 538%. ,x;?g§§?§;\»:aEi::.%*;°

7,g:.§:;-'=5 3&3 :,':;»:;*s;«s'»:'$;=~§"::»<,m~Ta:"':",é/--«:g, ,az:s::@cmE}

xsxxzx g ,,,, 



$2"

"§"§'s'§s Ciﬁé fgieé emﬂes' ﬁagtéan 35$ 0;? ﬁeniraﬁ Exaése
As: Eﬁﬁé arégérzg 02:: 9% aréer éateﬁ 3§'S3.281§ gagged an
Ema: Srﬁer f\éﬁw$§j_j{28l€}i waging ﬁzz} ?{}§":'%"EE.£§§§@ me
3zs§$§a:':':ia% Q%._E§S§E€}%'? éf iavs giaieé §§"':€E"'8%E"e, quagh {ﬁe
émgugmeﬁ awe? in Fina: Gram E'\§@,59:,f'2§3;Q séaieé
3§.§3,2am gagseé in aggeaé g;§:@;203% by heidE€'3§._iE%;at
the éemars sf értterest unﬁer mée ?{4j: ef the Ce:3§r;3_§"Ex3;c%TsL£%4

Ragéeg, 2&2 came? be made in %s@§atéQ;:~g~~..,;;g;~:§j§g;';;_g 
csagééarészg me exaegs §a3;me:':': G? ﬁuty gﬁaﬂ-:">;_ 'gp§e.a;f§s-E5e':.s'_'T 
arsﬁ eniétiameraz is §?:i€§'€$§ under mie '?{.§v}--»,.Q;':f.VVi§EiP, 533:?  '

R:,;Ee$:

This CEEE mméng an €92" f§"s:_a§::._'§ééar§é*:*§, ihizé 

iééﬁvééﬁ .1, é€§§'%.s-'8'E"€C§ {ha fQE§@:¢:;n§:-
 _
The as$e$2ee  't'§*°>:V§_s:.v,: a«;3§eaE ;fA:§"':V%§E&ngi§':g
we Qfdéé' passeﬁbgr   {he éevy ef

§F?i€§"%S§ 'V§':{:%m%~'f3$$é:é;$2sé;' ~ . 
2%  "5-he 5;3§é{'§Z§$3'$_ée--~._$':"z'.%s .:.:%§€ manufaztturars sf ;§a:r'%:§ sf

mgmrj.~«geE":é<:Eé:;V_ f::;:;:s:§f: alga ?':;@:'%%: ﬁgxzief Raaﬁ ﬂa:<§€; ?m§eE§@:"

' V' "§ha?§--;§':'§zA§-ﬁfeﬁgr §§£'.'"""'§"§3e§§ gmﬁg gag séaamé :33": gaymeat

kfsf"'sg$§s*<:5:§;i§_a':é«.::é;":2::'aE €X£%SE alsiées. T??? 53353;}: §i§'§,fE§" af

?_:%2e$$ §aa::»;g§§ ':'%'§,f§."?"$;r<3'§3 %<§;*§@$§<a;' i'vE$§§r§ 9r:s"2:at& Léméieéf

["'~-<4.__"Bés:§a§§_,_"§§%1:':§a§:2rek ?%:& aggeggse am $28 §;:::;?;?'C§"2§;%e§' are

'  "§':'§':;%§;§.;3:*:ect€ﬁ EJﬂ§5€E""C&§<§E'E§$ s:2:*;sj maze bugémgg §E"&§§E"'%Si$



W 3 W.
wé%E': ma aﬂstééa? En the éﬁﬁiﬁxt Q? Seiiim é{3;}{§:s} 3? %::ha

Cerzirﬁé Exaége égi, 19%, "$236 asssessee 2*equestagé..__§%7&

$33E§iaz";%:;'§e;;:)::*;3,z Cemmigaéaner {:5 C&né,::'aE E><c§$s":V,."'~i_h_}:';~s'tfyg":;<:-u

Taxgagzerg iirzétg Bangaism far a3Se5$:*2'°:es':2".--_ 76? §:§{;:ié"'--TA'

manufacmred and séaareé Sy ih€E'§E..§§ »;¥%§j§,"?f§y§:a.-'I,2»:%%§';3é%a§-, V'

%'vEQ%:e:*§ Ffivata Léméiﬁéy Biﬁéﬁé, aa%%ga:2%_;}:*e ;;:?:;2;1§'s2.§s}s;g§:»g}{'--~§§%*--j.

the §:§¥"§§§":£§&§ 3/gar 2§Q';?~Q8,  ,'~1{.f§€;<:_r§:;é§E:i_; %:§;V}g»..V;g:€§;é's'E'~:§§teé
24.Qﬁ.ZGGZ? game {G be, '$33336---£:é"Lv--te':;::s  ::;:f the
ﬁentraé Excise Riﬂes;   axecutéan af
'mad 3?' Rgﬁﬁ E:a4§;?§3__§:%;é%:€:2'"éar'.:§%§  Eakhsﬁ
Eaads we:'§:-' §"%:*:>{V&';'%.ib§:.._.z.f;§é   guaraﬁiee wag

fggméghégd, _  - 2§:Q9,;2@G8é, the awgessee

§"@q:..£e5:eri::?u $3123' 'f§v:é?;;~.iV§2%%£'£}__§:%"'«'E2? tﬁe Subjﬁiﬁj gmazigésnai

a§s@§s_m&r':'{;'~. ,5;§':§s" .£€§i*;$E'e:§'é:"§:*':g {he $E'E§.'.,§E'E mamréai maﬁa

--_ava§§;'23-?§Ee;A'%t?;e §a2$£e.$S%_:;~;§ ﬁuiheréty paggeé iézs fiaaé ayéag

' :%:h.%A:_';?':   i,%§"§ﬁ€F": --

_     f§"f?e aggeggmeaé 5;'; r@:~;;;3§§:" :3? 5%
" . .  §P;:%§z:f§ 53 §?{-l'*§"§§}--" arsfereﬁ fa ﬁe sif;"§§§i2@§
?'a;v*« ;f§:i5"'Vf,2§:§r ,§:§£%?'~{'?8; §§'{};f}§§?'§§ 55% §$§€§;<.,-;3§f§



M. g W
:x§;':z@ €§E?fE§":"F?§.?"E§§ ;s;"§a'§;' 5:523 2:335" C§§"?$§"f'§;1€:§L"§a'3§?

meifwd éggeﬁ 9;: C,A.§~4 g:,;:'a'§f;';?es am' 552$

wag" ceriéﬂzraéa Egﬁzjeﬁ by 52:8 C355: ,»§£;°»f§§..e':"3§"§£'?§.
2. E5? fesgaat §f ceréass? zéems, 525:9

grmxigfargai vafaze adagfeci by me asgagsee 

53%' ifmn we {$533! E.-'*§!'g,:§ arrived Sages? 

Cos"? Ascsaniané cerféfﬁcate zmécf? f?a§ re§;};:f§§§' ' 

in mar: gaymgnz 9:' éufy $55§s.1Q;5;§';«§Ev.?Tf9~A~. 

éﬁafudiség 5c%:1:::'f$§§an Cass ;§:'za"_ASejjs:é:;:Q" a;;;<_"8;<<._ 

Hzgiéer Egiycaéian C555 5?::V:ﬁ__1:';'3é 5§.{_:§¢¢>. gs V

éemgnﬁﬁd 5:3 farms $f»-Q1555 _? Q:¥'[__é:'sgu 
Exafse Ru:'§s,2ﬂ§;i  _  .'  vi
3. 1% V '_;é§';*::s;;:'_*A:§  fe~;i Rf's--..j@,63,£E 2;-

fffﬁféiﬁfﬂg Ea'L;:'3€s;:>r2  :7a:<s_g:i;_LT"~»'«*}i?3:<";;'¥f%T'3a'§r;,»' 8:

f~j'§§?f%l'e;<.:f;i;3':z§.;§;/§o;§'--.g:e§$  by 5% 3§§€$§€§
:«'}';:j'e'-- 4'   dated 2519,58 gs
a§§:'::'a $;~"§3j£€}'§%'.  .   

  'E ﬁiémééés' gaymmé :3?' inisregi"

51.:$"§:%;fs§:;;';§;*5;';g §§*§i';;;:;34,53a%r'w {£33395 $86 Egkié

' ~  z%;;,5rz:;xV4;§:#*;;§<z+2;s=:;s*§::a arm' 3;}: ﬁamﬁreﬂ am éfsﬁzfy

 iermg :3? $:';g§~«r:;§s {cg} 3? 35% I? 9:'

A  i"f°2;:s *Cé}=';§,-"£5 EJ>€i'f§§§ Qsjigs, 2§{I2?.

§, 5:: 5539953 Q?" :.'§s"§§§;'§ §E"€f?'?.$} 552%

A ' "«.,";*;%rmz;E::'§::':§§ vaézza géagéeéﬁ ééy :f"f?§ é*.§§§$SE8 is

'  s'??Qf§ ::§:§;': 3% 55%; 1:35:25 §%'§"§%;'s§{§ 33%;? $5': 5%
 .....

.,_,. 5 M Cagé éaraeaafasf ceriiﬁimfe whésf: hag regagiéeﬁ is': exaagg ﬁgymené G?' Q?:.::":.r sf §§,2',??,2€:;§5?';'»~ izsafzjﬁirtsg féféiéﬁffﬁﬁ C333 gm? Saamafarjg & éfégﬁér §§:;2€3z?£e;': {L'&§$ $33' 523$ gama is <::$r:;"E,rme§, éfwsezrer, ma §$S€$S€€ in his iéfésgt a'a§§§ 2:'i2§,§8 ﬁgs aﬁdgriakam mi" 53 ~:*;'a;€z*2;'.fV~'~;;:".r,r§_;gj.'__'__:' refamd gf ﬁiiifv' 355$' which 5'3 refurzzfabfa €.5:je éegarémeryf far tag f;":3a:':c:'_;:;+i~~ .§ze§r.' é§'§'?}:'3é"

gézma 551% ggme £233 afrgady §iEE€f§";%&%'S$i';€§ ¢::%?- €é:€f-.___ :"«f,fsffsr;»'9é§ §<:'r!£;5f<ar ﬁfcfsr a;é'e:§_é:%e sgﬁéée. ..ié§.§ 58%'? takes: £23552 §{.%€oz.;z';z2"'»_ ""--% . V 'V ., ' 38 Tim aggeggge c<3s"2tA;e.::1ﬂf::'«':-vfi 'i--E:":_&t if"%;é':e_ igﬁai ﬁat? gaéé §r=:3vé§§@:2_§§23: Es :a§<é§:' iTn.i:i'}_:§:é'fss%45é{,efaiV§:.;»%§; were was :39 Sheri ;Di'=:%§f'rr:e';@i.: %:§'€'f§§§;:i3; '€z§:'a§E:' ﬁr; the corsirary, may had gaié ?:he'é3_>{<:§ge' '§a;t";? 'i§'€ ":%%'éés3 3? R§£_,66;S§,?4€3,f- am iiéerefara, %:'§*'2'a:5_:'<;:::e1.:;t§{;.z"°;"*§§ff" gaxgmenfz: sf mteyesi er; we " V' '=gf;r$z;«:*25 €;}'§$§"'E§§"% §a§;:*%*s'éﬁ': Q? éuigs Er: msgesi sf €§E'§§€§"§ §:§:":*":$ a§s;§:;.é'§-::§. fréaargmsggz mg saié Qﬁﬁieﬁiiﬁéé E52353 {mi é::::'§:£';§--§:i&3§" "'§.g__ '~§,% E§ aims» frame 2% aéjuéécaiéng wéan gﬁggg-=.%.;e:s§__§' i§'%§ 33$ $:"§§:; {ﬁg &'S§€S§ﬁ§ ;a:*e§@:*s*§é $5":

% 'Nut 5 }h9lG agﬁgaé :9 am €:§%"'E"2E"':"£§§§§§z'E8§" 5% zzgmegés wha %£§7_%§"I8§§ we QE"{§§§3 ﬁggféeveé W the gaéé wﬁeig the aasagsaa §£'§?$E'E'€'E$ 3:2 aggeaé is §_T§'§€ Trébursai, 2;:;%":E:.;fh aisa ééamésgeé thé ggma, Therefsre; we asgessee is befme tﬁég cmsri, riég ééaard the §€B§"§3§§ Cmmseia fa' 'aha A ~ :3, "ﬁe ﬁasbsianiéai Qéiégiéﬁif'? éf'-3-3;-V :§;§'*:é;f%: e:%7§$ég--.iE7@% ~ canséaemiiam Er; this aggeai ég whéijhé-:'_ ?:'he '"':'"%ff§.b~s.;:§":a§"

régimt in cwférméng we derr":a:ég;*.._§§~._§::teé?é::.?: L2-:::;d";e:V"V% ;'2§'é'?e*" 33(4) af the Cerstraé Excése Rigées, 38G..2§ -z%s%E%iEf':ea,§f"?%22s--rmvéa§9u§§y reading the gmvéséang §§'fV%;_;2'§:=;'L.?.§%j§:'} $§'fvV:ﬂ*sV%e"" .{jer2t:'a§ Exciga Ra;E&s,, QKQSZ?

5, Ruﬁé'-.? FQBSS 317$ :§;"é §@§':w A 'fﬁfsgie x'?;""'§~*rszz;'3i9i:a? 5sg&=s$m5s25: M {E} ..i:'%;'ﬁz_§;<:*2:';€i?27?<:ﬁ gggessae :13; :,::'s§§f§ Ea ﬁefaarmézgs €529 'égvéfggéfg gacﬁg Gr §§f€:":'"?§,5{"§8 {"539 555$ A '--..__:::" §2'~z;:%§g?j'.3;::§ié:'§bfs ffféfﬁfﬂ, Ex'-3 ::*«:§;r re:;?:.:§§€ éfize ,fa3;?§s'§::§;3€ {fc2s:3s?;s's.st:'§::§: 3?' §:€ff§;"s"§5 §;<s::§s§ as"

x 4$ff%e"z'}8§:;:"3« Qammfagisnar $5' ﬁerzérgf :?'_:,§<€§§€, §$ 'féﬁe €§£§€§ may 5%, 5;; Eﬁ.ff25€§§?§ gsvﬁgzg f"8§.§Q§?§ _f$:

/""

%;/ ;§§§x';'7?€§'E§' as?' afgséy an gﬁmvégsamf éggég mg 351% ,»52§§§§i"§;?E C:;:mmz'$$s'§:§er Q?' C@;:e:;:r§f §.><€§3r§ gr figs ﬁépﬁéy Cammiggémggv :35 Ce;'2§r5§ £~'x'{:is8, 55;:

5.3% £3.35 may be, mg}; agﬁer afiawirzg g3ay,r::§r:Vé _ of éuéy 0:': grmr;'S;'er:§§ msés 55 552:3'; {£336 gush vaiaie as may $9 Sﬁeﬁffiﬁﬁ 33; mm, {2} "$539 £53;/merfsz" sf zfgzéy» 5:3 ;3.;*'fs'v;5E:},~;éé;?

$3355 mg? 5% aim-area', :2' we :§$S€;_§S§.».é':3X%3;;-zfégv, § barzé 5:: me farm grgsgrébésf §::;f.r29:*Sffs";5'§§§:3 V' K by 336 Eoam' wiéuf? gassffé-.,:v?$ax§fe:"y :::_;s;*eg:f§,:1;j{£'§: '§.r:~V~ gzzéﬁ amggsné' as éﬁe ,£%s$£sﬁ;3Ts%,§ £i¢mné';$s£o}?2er %0f Cmzraf E,><:::£se as" §_¢$§.;§g?y :.;;;*;;;{;:;-,<g3;'s5i0:;§e_?2: of £'ez3ir&! Exafgg, gs 'izééi fzjaem ﬁt, biﬁﬁing z'h:: ass€s;§'ééf<5{{ §f3'y§*n;es?V€ §;¥fV"0§§ff€r@;3C§ b;:ééa?%Eé1eTr§ i§i§?e'& :32' $'_;'ﬂ3é':;/33 ma' be ﬁréaiiy aS§a<.;'§m' 3;r:'é§'-~.§f§?e 3:2j:Vl§'=::§?§' sf Qmy gmvésisnaéiy §ss:a§sz3Qi ' _ ' ..

€33" ?;*:é'..V}4:*;,§i%$§"§;?§" femmégsiamgr :3? .«§l:C§er:~fra! §X'§i§$_ as", $3129 Sésgggé;-f {L'@;';";mi;';:§s'::>s':8;° sf s":'é'g€z";2,:%g"«g§x5::$e; 52%' 59% 555% may :59, s%sa!§ gzasg 'f%§;=._§g;.i:§€ ggggsgmmi, £3 saw; gs mg}: $3, '3f§"§;"' f§f§?:~§ i"§§§2/§§'?§' éﬁfarmsééaﬁ, $25: mgy Se rgeggggiféﬁ' fa? f§s3§E§2;';2§ 3539 as$€és§me:'::a: is " A. gaéggffﬁbﬁa, 52:3: M55255 § géréagf 33$: gxggeﬁéﬁg 35;:

2%,,/"

.,,_ 3 ._,,, mméﬁg fmm 51% afaie 9? 52% agmsmzaésgzssa Q?' {"529 gréar §s:.§:,:sa* gsnﬁer 5e.;§~r'a;§e {:2}: gﬁrﬁvgﬁeé mg: 552% ,§@r;'a§ sgecéféézf 5;; £255 s;m§~;ufe may; 3:? gaffigggaé {gags éeérig gfggwn gmaf 5&3 :'e§$0i':$ is ﬁe regeraéd 5:2 wrzéirsg, €Xi'éZ%:"§Q7§§ by we €0mmi§s;éar:er 5:2' {§@;*;~§',:ﬁi:s:A:!».'__'_L"'.j' Excise far a furfﬁer peréosg' 523% e:<€eea*'§;:%;gf' _f??G?:'?ff'?.§ §:"?2:§ §;/ 5533 Chief _£,?;%s::;r:ig.aff$ké'ée%r'.'jv Cenfraf fxaége far S§,1€ffE fa;s"z:%f2$r:_-;,v§%':a%a:{€25'-!'?é f-LL..__ may éeem £5:

(4) The 5s§es§ée--v..%ff;&§! bé §£r3;fbfrE*;: S"?

§:"3§'€f"€'SE $3'? $3}; __am9u;:§.._.g§ay52'§a!e z{$"'£f$3n;ir3aE $Gv$rnme;3:', §:3f;§é:'i2;;e;?_2§ ;_:"s:;?% "~~r§m"~r_ ﬁgs" firm' a5§€.§sm@:3£' iiﬂdéf Sﬂgﬁwiijféib __éE-he ram 5g??e7:*Ef,é6s:2§1:, 5}}? ~ . e:%f§f{3§" Ga yerﬁmenf 73;:

::0 ffj'2'§:'f 3€£z%rfs"'};=§::;:z%§"T»T._;}:?¢'er Seams': EEAA Gs"

sgcfiasjz ;."£',v2,ﬂ;;::'E $5" {mm 5926 firs: a'a;2 0f ;:'§':::,3_ ;?"2g§:;.iT§: 5s,kz::Cé:*€§ing {ﬁe :*'3'fQf??§? far arvﬁfcf? =£%{'??&:;§%f""§3"vdeiermiﬁgﬁg 55!? 55% d§{'§ :3? " ~ , g;;:<}%;:::e:r%§"§E:@r&§i . §';.";~""§r1x'§:§s:"e E2536 §$$e3§e& .53 eaéiéfeé 53 5 r§.f's:,;z~":{_:if '.»* A gaasagzzeﬂé $3 §§"§&'§' far ﬁrm: §5:::§%:;§:?:m§ ﬁﬂﬁﬂf 5a;&~m::€e {.3}, S:.f§}"€iL'§" in §:;§~ x ._;":;;'e 56), éfzgre ;§f:§§i be ;::§§§' 3:"; :';*:fere§:" $3 gasaf? ";?:%f:;s?§' §§" 5&8 rgée .§ga:'§;*E'§§' 5;; $323 £35353! Mg", §@2zer;";;:r;a§;?€ 3;! mffffgséézsa 533385 anger §@£§_§Qf? 34638 :3? 352$ #25:? fkgm 5&9 zifrgf ﬁg}? $3 32% mgmffs gaggcmcifrzg we marsitfz fa: whsafg Eifﬂ'? refzsné ﬁg ﬁeégrmiaéaif {pi}; 5&9 £556 @f_..__ refasﬁe', {5} Amy gmmgrrf af refana' Q'e§"e:"z;{:f;?s**2?§Qf"~...'._j: a;r:Q'€;" s;;b~n.;;@ {3} srhaii be a:'reQ'£z"eaf__§;3. égégs:- ' %% Fa::?§,* Pm3:§a§eé E2335 $539 &f«r;m:;;':f.::i>.'0f"»;§f:;éz§,"

érxgteaﬁ :3? Eeirzg gredifﬁa'-':0 i°!':éfz';sr2a',a :3 3:6 aggifesanf, ff saw: '(:}*;:*3f§<fs;,;z*:i §3"'g*<?=*.;§Laé'.$;b§e7,§"$VVV {5} 5&5? 62557;»-' a>s<{:;~4f$:f2 _ '$3; {ﬁe m3nuf§c€ure,...§f.;':--e i§§d_néf§a'5se*';:f ax? éhe """ §:2«:f;::3'er§€f'f;:%" §'z'.'VV's::£f?"_"V5i'::éy f§ any éifzer . 'ﬁérgéréﬁ-~.;§r»[. "= ' ' {5} V-,§?":e a"$;;*§"}?"'5:';'..§,3i%:;ii§& berm $32 552% buyer, 5'?' f::%3..,i2f§ie:3""n§§f ﬁéggéﬁ' :35? abs §:3€:§:?;'a??35:@ sf :§;:;§f_: £:;:'3:*'€{2 my gééer pe:"s::;;?, "' 3 .,:}?§§f%..s$a§ $2? frag afamgaid gmaiégigm maxeg ii:

£§§e:,"3_r7é':%°:a%_:_§'i;§%i.§f&;§r$ we .._V.,:sa§::& ::é§'"st::x€;E§abE§ gaﬁég <3? §e%.:§§'m§,:"2€= $338 {$9 5? wty §$§§§S€€ E3 i.§§'"'§a§§€ is ﬁétezmérsé tfzé 3%/' 3§§E§£§§§€ iheretsg he may $'§Q_i.3§S% aha aamseiené §:..z%:%':s3r%:y :33 gwvééed %n 33% gaéﬁ grgvigégrz, {:3 §&r:3j:§::_é*:é.;j'z :9 gay iha ézsixg 5:": §F'§%.z"§$§€}§'E&§ basis at gush sash zzamg ag may ﬁg ggacéféaej by if ?:%':--<:V-

Saiésﬁaéf ﬁg may gasa an eréeg" p%5;rm;é§%:§:é§'3::é:§'*:"---§'a~§,;r;*r::;§;<r::%;.' arsé taking aii necessary g*:eps:'fo_%" ;§a;?:*:;é";:%: @fT.3'%:3{ .;€,_§:@ri'ff§f§§E 9:": {Em gut?' gayabie aé éghe em §§¢a{gs§s$€%éemV§:[_; ""§"%7 e.;==;ar&afEe::

ta {mat as3@§§:";'2,§r:€ Q:*éé--:* .E}:, :€3'._§€§"gf§a5'E"I~§§:"§5§*. if after the fénaé agsegamentg if Si. is; fo},!.:r*:~v."_:'*;%z;=;z;éi V~:§15:éE:r: é';§:l'.'*a§ shat faﬁ én §ﬁ3/'E'E'§€E'§§ Q? ;;:s;° a7§.,%'i"a"e$ far gaymant of §nte:'@3: Qgrjé s':;:wg'!9':. /§ji;§jya?*'§ §a€§§é%ieE§€§:"isf Whereaa Si§b*¥'U§8 {5} grafafédefrsz dams gaié.

°§_§'"§§f€fQ§'T€fV_{ _§i '§-.§§' V<;~~E%as" the? afier 5; ﬁféﬁi aggeggmani "'«...§r§ié._%'~:3.._§a»$$e§; %§~--?:--E*=:§ ézéiy gaaéé 5*: iarmg £3? ggmvéségmaé _§§$ﬁ?$3€%:v§§*:i,4"§::[_VEa:-$3 wan 3&3 ﬂats; §§3;'§§§& aftgs" 32$ fénaé §$§g§sm§;éi~;'i.V_§?:e aigseagee is Eiabée ta ﬁg? Em %:'z§e:e$i er: 'V..:§"2e $h'::§§'%:.%E§E§. is $6 Qféiifé $€ZE"":€§'EE§ Q'? §u§e Z2 %:%':§re ﬁg m "~--";::§;§a;_«:§sa 'Tim: when $5: aweggéa :§ pemreiértasé ta: gag; gut'; ix/"

éa §§§i'§L§§§"'§C§ 9%' & gzmzzésécraaé aageagraeai ardfea, E? E9 Ea ﬁeaimg a;a;§i;%": :*r:§:'§ tfiaa mg g{:3%§E;'§- they have is §5.:%E%$'t:»§f§ gagarateégn, Eager: tfmugh the 53:3; g@a*ya%Ee a:s":§§*.:f 5::'£1é.'_;é*§:-?§%:: _ ta he aaécaﬁateé 2m§e:* each mad Qf e ac§': Ca-5%v~:;.§Eé:§.:f:'éa.§:€§gs §t 'V ES iha iatai duty gayabie Ea? aié g'@>{§.€§S 'i§!.?%'§.§'iV§'% 'a1'?§,.__:E':;~;T_A« gzzbjegt matter 6% {Em g3;'a3:;.i»51;::2;"}aE é::?.§'é§sma5§'é"{A.,;;%;:_Vj6 §§éna?E gﬁeggment whéséz $3 is be Ea_%§:é':;:_é5f2;V§a :fe!:"s.§T§§'é:"aViL:éa:":» If after taking %:":i:3 €ansiﬁ$%E~:'i§§:'é_ %%.ga1,%v .§7::_:f;;jgayﬁbie in ragged: af &§E the gems am :na%am;-aasgkk;n{§g;gg%am G? the fénai §gges$2*:s':en%c {::i.:je::5{ Ef._ séiééé izéage a;§.:;e-§éeVé"':'é mm ézz any éuiga, ihen f§r__:_§_f;e'aEf'é::a':;'%:_:;faE§ ﬁr';-» §{§«-§g:V$E-uE'E'yP the asgeggee is ééabée ;paf;:-

9 .VE§'§é'€EE7':.fS'E:&;E_'i}.i saga aﬁméiztediy far aeyiain é:&:f:f:;'él_%:§h!'@ £a£§;§5'é$af:_§_:;_§. ﬁazgiézezéiy $333 iéaéﬁ {he gézsri f§§E in *;3:a;§r':":i:e;<%s:'«:;?".._%§va;_:3i aim? ééze fénaé aggégsmeni aréer ag §;:::f:'§};53g€~"?§5?,53f in regpezii 3;? {giiiaer éiema, me agsﬁsee has u§3.a;§§'V.«§§..§?=4'1;??,...3S;EE'?';"»~ in axgggg. Eu: éefzgra émggsésgg V' '..f=.%:é:é:<é>i;g%:; {E38 auéiﬁgrétg ghaasiﬁ Ezazze zieéasﬁted E?2@ 3325?: isié E;

__ :2 w in éiéze &K£€$S gaymmi maﬁa, if ihera is 52% ghari faéé Er:

§3y::*:&:*:t sf éuftyg §ay:":':a:*2*a: 9% érsierast siféég mast mag: '§"'hey have ::'&&%:e& the guts; payabée uféééf Evaga iaiegeriesf Z:

wag §ez.;§":ﬁ ér: regsesi 9? same é§em$ Em daty $aya:%E.é ';%_%ft~§:r ihe firtaé Gram $3 msra ihéﬁ what was §rev§3Ee:*§a% asgessmemi, "wag a§pma;;%i2> Q'? ':E2'é"'a'L:%j§_::;%s'€:ée3_ 3:': ihis reggré $3 errmagug, £.E§"3\;*J3{§"a§'§§7,€§ :ga;T':.,€§ u'::=,s:2g}V§a:9":-é'§?__b'g;T_* any statumry §E"O'%é§SE§f§, E? :rx;?e'~§s;:ee@"Es'?s %1":éVm3*'f§E9:é:=:§"v;::iéV;f';<fé§§é é.£ﬁd€F'E';i§¥"'§§ the Qrevésierfzsg E': %s____<§f:!§: ::x{_§2€r%":%:§e ._§u:v§;r $5 ﬂue arsﬁ 91: gg mat paid aﬁiéihéh"iiiéé.Si;;§§é;j_§a%é'<§. E:§Eﬁf'e@» arzé the éuty £3 gaiﬁ §h&reafier,=--is': 0r;;€§'r»..:}e c;§m;§éé3s«;a7'§'é$'§he rexzenzgeg §nierest_E§__%rr:§:ﬁ;3e::'§_».'.§fv%;_§*§a::.:_ éxsfzg be kept in minﬁg is": the iﬁgiani '<;;?;$:~3,.A ::*¢%i:e?';'2.?jvf:f*2s3.é_ ';§2§;'$a3s@e hag gaié 3 Sum ﬁf R§.§,.£2_§,§é{?<.$®;.!»~V§x=:ﬁe.$$'~~--éu'cy wiwééh ﬁg entétieé m séaim '_ ;'&§a,I §'e~?;§F, §'_? E €a¥'§E"%§i_" &s,e___:;7,:y:e§ asazéééé gagfmeni cs? &X€€S§ Sam: is": :%::~3_ §":%sf%:é_ _§%~._é:'2ie%s':,§ Yéée erﬁzéra aggsreaaéa %§ we .gj§é:,3;"~§é4::;Tj"s:».§f;*:'v§4V§A~T:;éé.:"eas::.*;»§*sa%.:5$§ §%E2;§s'"§:"~g :9 $23 gahgma 9%.' am g §sc2:§§%.§:*:g. "'§"h&2"e§m'e; 3% me auiésgrétéég 'ézféfﬁ in errazjéié ﬁaiiy §§'i§ :§i§a:&?.§§':?€S téw §_3§'§§'§€§fE3§€E a;i§*;§@*:'§:;§;*2§ ihége

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

Toyota Kirloskar Auto Parts Pvt Ltd vs The Commissioner Of Central Excise on 13 October, 2011

Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath