Central Information Commission
Jaipal Singh vs Northern Railway on 3 June, 2020
Author: Neeraj Kumar Gupta
Bench: Neeraj Kumar Gupta
a sa pecee, The CBIO, M/o Railways, _ wears? 'Respondent Sr, DIYM, Northern Railway State Entry Read, New £ delhi, AGO VaNE GALES OMmerging fram the appeal RYE PZ US.2018 PA 13.06.2018 SA 20.07 2018 CPIO : 24.05.2018 FAO G6. 2018 Hearing : 19.05.2026 ORDER
i. The appellant filed an application under the Right to Information Act, 2005 (REL Act) before the Central Public Information Officer (CPIO), M/o. Railway St. DDM Office, Delhi Biv ISIOH, state Entry Road, New Delhi seeking action taken on his application regarding the handicap certificate of his Son, » Me. - Praveen fumar, including, ivter-
aa The CPIO responded on 24.0 13.06.2018 which was disposed of by the first appellate authority on 27.66.20] aoe cm. we thereafter, he fled a second appeal u/Sec alia, purchas se details of toilet ¢ OS.2018. The appellant 4 1 193 Ny L 23 O% fied the fi Commission requesting to take appropriate legal action against the CPIO u/Se 20 of the PAtOOTOOPPEELD.
RTT Act and also to direc ee e t him to provide the so ught for information.
.
Page g the RTT Act before the rst appeal on et OF, 3 LQre we . bey shy me x Fh. at z= ~ ony int oS ; on as ewe a es . he a) me oS raene " Sas 91 Q oS rat oo, om ted 'vat wg ; ee a5 on ay tors om ken pone tay" ~ x ee f i panel wy a Z SS os me a Sens * Cy eS a a Ot Vv. o sama a one ped mS whore 9 mm Ps, te a ony No rhe ; oe we oe go EE an Dyes te 4 , 4 : " Fon % a ree a eo sheet hers Fs aes n wl ™ sS ad = Foe oS 2 os en, oe Pea beret e. «eR aon ees ened, rn ee ry, on Taek "wat cn ws we ioe a ie an yea ap - nowt 3 te Seo wm bra oN Fed : beh ue feed wo fan] eal - 2 Ne ™, CX "rad fer cat cyt ve) as tad ne hei ee She See oN oy nS Medd Cony " oped te Nena? oa] aS ee tha oy Sound Pet food fred hy an & "hemes on ea a5 =e thee tenon M4 banking ¢ Na an Fie ag renee iatnne " $n xb one e. apes! oe a "toe, ' i % ab ong it ee ts, pe ty ah st a3 a ' ae) gS ey ~ they ga won, ot DB ne oy fy, tt = oat ong ie a5 ee ry we oe oe ie: , ry, ft we on ts a Np fe we Shes a MES . 3 mest on 83 adh ned tm oe, ries = peed er a5 oS o * x nase! Cary, as BS aos * ny a a. So fp bet Se Oo m : Y FS Sb ae tee ws en 6 reas sto we . ch Fro pebad Put Me ink, re Panes . ores oe nfs we des a3 3 og ah 'pons * ee Hens ory en "A a oe > a5 43 ~ oS - read os a i] ma mS he seed pe kaa rah The New pene pr fot raped « "ret oe ag wee teh speoei pee - ed ~~ ae OS "he! ~ ¢ w Ra = ' A om oe CE OS aS oe TT tng BS = " = * "Sh S : ad Sere eet Cre mS oo z teed oS tt aon SS ae Fetal a "3 os og oa omy oo "a ad SG ca omen rg "oe "ee seg os we r. =, " am ¢ pees % } oe. yy ;
G "ge fe O mm JF oy Mend = ¢ S f "= net Pn i BR eG Ss 8S ey Som gy 8 we we "ee na ot ; tad ny Es os Bowne vend oy a "
eae Le us at : 2 4 ant ows y te, a SS "ey w sped in es fee gy peg Es ye ty wee x ce s a rec 4 we ie so os on ws ene es ied om ond a os " cot se & oh t3 od & fea 5 os 'ie oon ie a td 2 eel a ea a 5 ' on ie Re TS ry pt % 4 > 4S OS a8 S83 ad % oo bent oe Det a3 oS fy po ws > aD ae a ° oD Be i ys wn vied et 3 oa "mg ste 7 x3 e See eee yoerd he wr tom "es ect ny oe 7. Ne Pen, ae tea ot, ie gt a a & a BOS oa &, ee seltiecnsenveee ory won ed me bres ao ry wy i on a = i Qa at vette Anat on ke we weed Pa So fee 2m eek feat No vy a ne ro, 2 got wee 3 es % " . * an 9 rs cee Sn = & = FM ee A 6s a" SoS " S 4 3 a ne wet . tA cael 4 . we re ~ e pte "t ¢ ne tree Bom TE es = » 2 & RS a os s ' poe e Ione : toler : ° ren Fon] . s en Soe 3 wet mt : En ~ Leh on, :
it moo a os Bos bb =~ s 2 2 a. am ss we thd Feat Not 7 5 ~ a eae a 8 ae $. ae +m 4 fy 7 mm oD "S F3 mies ms Pe ae act me foot gs Sees Ay "C3 weed wane . eet " pee ne me i Town * fe = e Ory we Be ts 8B RR Sad et . ayaa , Get nat ne, mm a gee a ee . f iS nn fees a et at o> ' See pa ae re et he ty we on "f os tk nes SG gy ee SES & ee om ose SUS Cy Sr es ss Sia! iad OS we x . SB we OD oe 'ee RT "~ fe Mm OS C82 ee cog mo Ey weet et os os oo wid m Bo os ; x se he 3 <t co oe vn aA ee S = Oa ma GS SS ge. # ee oe . oe & ~ oe OS SPM
4 net * i ery a Kasei Pn "2 * evan tng Sits cE tent , eon hy % one shaw os ad a be ah Bs " Q voy ae et tp ween, feed z ed oc 78 ee 4 a a ies Be: Y ae Nd ae oy a Named ret wey ms 4 i ~ eo pe eed mw want ike Fone ert beet got Bao 7 ores : 7 on a ered ere ss rate a, Sea rena . wos ee ac ony ze x » be oe Be tet tal ae wd oe So Aa we : s a "sr. ay e z r om ok, ry al ted DB ay wa ¢ os oy 4 Rr a ma OE . ales oe 4 NBG ce OR C3 "3 Be ben ee fh. es ne i oe, a pened et a be, . ay at a Fy * pew ay vet 4 Ss "ons > col ch dy os, :
i nt Set ' as J ' ee toy, me et. Na t ey Co F om os gS S 8 SC gg i oh a By le 4 3 tee : wae, rr ayer aaa! eee tet fen, see, "lenpatlt me, ¢ ° fe < eess rye way Coa! ebed: ~ gid oe. Brey hey a men, Foe hd res x em v7 cp A oe oa wy ay Ru det aw ne ey teh fa the 3 os 8 om a = ae a3 SS a = em a a ° 8 2 e & 2 2 ¢ = & &§ Z eo S g£ me ay oom oe neve, cA hes mood "SS D ae) ry x, Ce 2 = Be ee we % oo me dnt + ews hed Po at jeanne a henge : hs, "3 ke oe OE 'eon Shs SO ee ei ' on So a $ we taee . % * vee nh tha - i au " Ed x
5 aA " rs. 5 * " * ' we et ory oe Be & 2 Oo &e ¢ 9 < = =s 3s £ £& § & oat ws oy omy eee wept ee a ea) ht . ne * reese me S an > ned i noe oh mt a ct a G23 rm = aod Toe mem ue fy oy SS oa s 4 he a ie os, oo of ae Nel % oon xs pom $ . > zest ' a . aes cw tay t $8 5» & 4. € Sg "= 2S . fe 'S 8 Ss
2. coon beet | eapeg mm Can oS ' i beet ne = 2 a ne pry a ny Se A oe wo . . , Uh ty a Moma Be a oo xs Seat a a Gi oe oi At 4 re) Sed mnt a a - a bases, pA wien os wre ied oo . ao) pss . = nee fs, - Se oy ry on an " boo TS OG bet g on ra ae ws go tad ony reed Anne eel < tren. / Ss % Med et a 'aot Coe meet i a ae et "to, wee me, tm = a en 3 Meg " "ee a ; 'at, ea & we we a SNe ay, a pet ws ped, ne wnt pia on rok ed % Ope "eee ' Peed ws ad ot whee? a) ea eed as nae eat wy ur oo Le tant ? nape, ay ded © eet oy + ad te 3 "S a . oy ot oF a on eens om Me +} ry Rp mS phew wy nara a te stent "ne peers Nel? es, "
a hee Cee: weet as as he Aner Apes on ie 4 Se meet ee ee ~ tebed us oo Ne iB pny ~ Gp tm TR we 4 ret «pest ms # pret ee m "newt " ees! @ = G Oo Ss a © i £ & & aad om por ny Sat st x 7 fs Ay aay Sow ae _s ms bean os yor ae give aA sar peed GA . Shae * ry font Peg a4 C3 pee set toy ry oe ns i, Wy By wand fee OE Se oe ae , tee a 'at Be oa wre J at " nn A rang a "3 ep a "A iad aed oe "* mabe tae LOT sper law © pre th io iS 0 Tr Acti + :
£ 'hat the | weed g such lyin:
OF TESS fi rate fora her appropri { a ind that there are S % ARCS © < Ny atters, mt & > ted 24.05. 26018 ad g th a reply d § aithou t ¥ ryes tha ne Conn t r i ny i + ¥ % Hanon OF E infor point no, "3 3 OF as nati OKT hue int ci ide 3 pray ent te id } 4 a b ets t ire a respo G2 iP hind § a ha i Tat infor 4 AES :
he rec t & hat pet GF ae het a or, Fey, WW
8. How £ ett ey GHer, | ~, Danes Sahl & ved. th cel * not to have Claurs on ww 4 shee 1G nae mn di YHHISSIO * x lant.
p to the g Saou:
on ey ecard ee OBA oks & = So serrcesres et gory fg i sie wd c ae mo a Heaps a bet > ~ Q ie YF ae beget ee G ce * int Benes ran oe barn ereed, ae "| gome a ghe ve $ 5 pete PY on cane" fe ths ; a hex brewed <4 a, PF, © oe Lee oS i ore A pewwes ws eee a hy a LT wh _eduearne pre * Rh oe hs Ben 7, 67 Coed cate gees FOR, fee, oS newe here bas cies Son ord boea as oe Senoy «.
wed .
ey aD Le \ of breed, oh ne Th Fatehabad, hri Baru Rarn, airy Roa 0 S Ward No. 20, Opp. Old Tehsil Office, ge OO, he 4 i § Sep Wn ey oy} oe y, DRM's G re r PIO. Mio Railways, O/o Sr. DMM, ohana, UNstrict ~ 8 pete, wD oe . & oa wD "rp: ; 2, SE a ews os a a apne ty pe a . pt a 12 Ih sm fee bag pees ay 5 "prs ot ra ned re us, wt fee re Bt a OR : c ; a Focoor ope a "me vee asd ra oT i co be mae ! od Oo ma BZ oo ~ iit ben PD prren, 43 pals 8 coe . pod el pat ie : oo yon : 5 ' rie Set none FG hog oe me ' eet Seat mepnet, 3 "ewe Sats, ed ; ty on . rot M . 4. RO fond PLD Qe oD a io Se ee ex Ba met pe ve wm tea even nm OF oy oO Oo cn i Fi Re aed ee ont eri BBY ad weieed 7 tb ua hawt bet * a nanny eR a3 fee be OE, nt fo le Se, ae wo Fa Senne of Beh Peed oe . te sped, ro Ty we pene a ae Cas Sec, aS , bo ty Sa wed > ame ~~ Ce pace hab ef tho roy a ; ee Naser, a BR Ex tf Oo ® Z, C2 A OE hen OT " x ony CG a so od « a a cal "eo Tad Te "
= trees n oe Yared 4 A ty © fe oe of : LA fy eo wr «
"4 ape Sa A terest Neygt Tay panes o 3