Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Gopal Mishra And Others W Rly vs M/O Railways on 6 March, 2019
i OA No f632079 CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBAL ORIGINAL APPLICATION No, 163/2019 Date of Decision: 06.03.2019, CORAM: DR. BHAGWAN SAHAI MEMBER (A) wa F * RN. SINGH, MEMBER (2) Gopal Mishra Male 37 years, ee ugegape Clerk-~ Mumbai Central, 33/15 Western Railw ay Colony Dahisar (BE), Mumbai 400 068. Suhas R Naringrekar Male ~ 37 years, Chief Luggage Clerk - Mumbai Central, Flat No.302, H-10, Rustomjee Evershine Global Ci ty, Narang) bypass Road, Virar-West, Maharashtr a 4G} 303. Brijesh Dubey, Male -- 33 years, Chief Luggage Clerk Address ~ 304 Pooja tower CHS, Dewan Enclave Rvershine, Vasai (£)-- 401 208. Sanjay Kumar Sharma Male 32 years, Dy, Station Superintendent- Cormmercial Mumbai Central. Room 38) THE, Western Rly. Colony, Dadar near Shankar M andir, Mumbai 400 O28, Hemjeet Kumar Verma, Male.32 years, Chief Booking Clerk ~ - Mumbai Central (Commercial) DRM Office, A-12 Lourds'B Co- "Op Housing Society, Amol Nagar, Naigaen E ~ 401 208. Manoykinnar Yaday Male 38 years, Chief Lugeage Clerk- Mumbai Central Address M 20, 604, Rustomjee Evershine Joint V enture, Global City, Virar (W)-- 401 303. Yadnyada Pramod Joshi Male -- 38 years, Chief Booking Clerk -- Mumbai Central (Commercial) DRM Office, A/102, Gulmohar Complex Phase III, Near Divekar Hospital, MLB. Estate, Virar (W) -- 401 303, a a renee:
CS
2 (4 No P6307 G Shashikant R Patil Male 35 years, Chief Goods Clerk ~ Amalner Rathway Qtr. No.STB, Railway Colony Amalner 425 40] Hemraj Saini Male 37 years, Dy Station Superintendent ~ Commercial ~ Dadar, C 004 Navshakti Apartment CHSL, Chandansar Near Bhalchandra Nagar, Virar (E) -- 401 303, . Harendra Kumar Male 46 years, Chief Booking Clerk -- Nallasopara Address ~ D/202, Kritkya Paradise CHS, Opp. 3 Road, Soprastha Complex, Nallasopra CW) - 401 203, . Naween Kumar Nirala Male ~ 28 years, Chief Booking Clerk -- Bandra 40U/C Ajanta Apt. Mittal Enclave Pereira Nagar, Naigaon (E)-- 401 208. . Sudhanshu Kumar, Male 37 years, Chief Booking Clerk (Commercial) Mumbai Central, L 605 Reliable Garden, Naigaon (E} ~ 401 208. . Mahendra D Sharma Male 37 years, Chief Booking Clerk ~ Borivli S4/8, Railway Colony, Kasturba Road, Kandivii (W), Mumbai 400 067, . Karson Ghawari Rajak Male 38 years, Chief Goods Clerk -- Valsad Qtr. No. - 265/A, West Yard Rly. Conony, Valsad 396 001.
Saurabh Dalpat Masekar Mails 32 years, Chief Luggage Clerk ~ Mumbai Central (Commercial) DRM Office, Address ~ B-501, Astoria, Deshmukh Residency, Ashok Van, Borivali (E), Mumbai 400 066. » Applicants (Advocate Shri AV. Chatuphate ) fa VERSUS Divisional Railway Manager (Establishment) Having its office at Mumbai Central, Western Railway, Mumbai ~ 8, Assistant Personnel Officer (Traffic), Ue Wh on 1 +
10. 3 Od No L63/HYE Having its office at Mumbai Central, Western Railway, Mumbai ~ &. Assistant Personnel Officer (Electrical) Having its office at Mumbai Central, Western Railway, Mumbai -- 8. Anwar Hussain N. Head Luggage Clerk, Bandra Terminus, Western Railway, Bandra Terminus, Railway Station, Mumbai 51. Ravindra §, Gaurav Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Railway Station, Dahisar, Mumbai ~ 68, Raginiben 8. Desai Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Surat, Guiarat 395 003. Manishs S$. Gavit Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Nandurkar ~ 425 412.
Andkumar J. Pandey Western Railway, Goregaon, Mumbai 63. Edward M. Parmar, Western Railway, Kandivali, Mumbai 400 101. Shabir Ahmed N. Sk.
Western Raihvay, Lower Parel, Mumbai -- 13, Krishnakumar Tulsiram, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bandra Terminus, Railway Station, Mumbai -- 531. Bhikaji Sawant, -
Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai ~ 8. Dattaram V. Nate Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai -- §. Rajendra Y, Dandekar, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bhayander, Mumbai 401 101, not ay e
16. V7, be » br tS 26, ey G4 No fose20ly Parag Suryakant Wadekar, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Malad, Mumbai -- 64.
Arun D. Sarfare, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Santacruz, Mumbai -- 54.
Swati Wadekar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andheri,
- Mumbai ~-- 58.
Ashwinkumar N. Sharma, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai -- 08. Santosh R. Bendre, © Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Virar, Paighar 401 303.
Rishikesh Tiwari, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Randivali, Mumbai 101, Deepak S. Ralushte Head Booking Clerk, C/o Station Manager, Western Railway, Lower Parel, Mumbai -- 13. Ganesh D. Patd, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar, Mumbai -- 14. : ae © Rajendra K. Thakur:
Chief Booking Clerk, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Nandurbar, Nandurbar 425 412. Shrinivas R. Navk Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Charni Road, Mumbai -- 4.
Alka Harishchandra Awasthi Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borivlt, Munihai -- 91.
Rajendra Kumar R. Verma Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai - 08.
"Land hy
36. uw od oss O4 No. f63/2079 Yogita 8. Vartak, Head Booking Clerk, W eater Rail ay, Bandra Terminus, Mumbai ~ Varsha V, Patil, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Palghar, Palghar 401 404.
Chandrakant M. Kolte, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railwar ay, Churchgate, Mumbai -- 20.
Darpana M. Mastakar, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Marine Lines, Mumbai 20.
Vaishali Vilas Savekar, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Matunga Road, Mumbai -- 19, Prakashkumar Nair, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Churchgate, Mumbai 20, Jurunal Shaikh Head Luggage Clerk, a estern Railway, Bandra 'Terminus, Mumbai -- Suresh C. Patel Chief Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Navsari, Crajarat 396 445, Rajaram B. Bhor Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar, . Mumbai ~ 14, Rajnath Ramlochan Rai, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mahim, Mumbai 50. Hiralal M. Yadav, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mahalaxmi, . Mumbai~ 11 Shrinarayan C, Pandey, Head Booking Clerk, W ester Railw ay, Bandra, Mumbai - 50.
Sanjay M, Ttal
40. AS, . oO Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andheri, Mumbai 38.
Simran M, Hiranandani, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mambai -- Damodar Pd. Meena Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Goregaon, Mumbai ~ ~ 63, Shagun D. Choukekar Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Bandra 'Terminus, Mumbai -- $1. Kavita A. Shinde Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Jogeshwari, Mumbai 102, Chetna T. Prajapati Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Bandra Terminus, Mumba: 41. Motilal Meena, Head Goods Cle rk, Western Rallway, Bardoli, CGiyjarat ~ 394 355. Paresh Upadhyay Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Goregaon, Mumba! Fatteshging Ravtale Head Goods Clerk, Western Railway, Songadh, Gujarat 394.670.
Samir B. Pariera Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bandra Terminus, Mumbar 51. Amitkumar Shrivastay, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai 08. Priva J. Nair Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mira Road, Mumbai 401 107, Preeti Mehul Desai, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Valsad, OA No. 1623/2019 rt ha Ln aa Cay
60. Oy bs a tad ~~ 7 Od No 18362019 Gigarat 396 001. -
Priya Rajesh lyer . Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Matunga Road, Mumbai 19, .
Harisingh Meena Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Surat, Gujarat 395 603, Omkarnath Chauhan Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borivli, Mumbai 91.
Dnyanesh M. Lad Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai 08. Firoz Sayed Head Goods Clerk, C/o. Divisional Railway Manager Office, Senior Division, Railway Manager, Mumbai Central, Mumbai 08. Swati Manish Rathad Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mira Road, Mumbai 401 107, Madhuri Y, Parab Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andheri Mumbai ~ $8.
Kiran R. Satam Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Jogeshwari, Mumbai ~ 102.
Mandar Shetye Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Bandra Terminus, Mumbai 5]. Ramesh Dutta Mishra, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andheri, Mumbai 58.
Mohd. Asiam Farooqui Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai 08. Husenbhai U. Belim mm Od No. 162/20/9 Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Vapi, Gujarat ~ 396 191,
64. Sindhy Devadas Nair Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai 08. 65, Rajashree S. Kulkarni Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andheri, Mumbai 38.
66, Tapeshwar Karmoa 8. Head Booking Clerk, Western Ratlway, Santacruz, Mumbai 54, 67, CH. Srimivas Rao, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, © Kandivii, Mumbai 11.
68. Rarmjag Vind, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mira Road, Mumbai 401 107,
69. Chitra Sanjay Bhujbal, Head Booking Clerk, W estern Railway, Dadar, Mumbai 14.
70. Balay K. Iyer, Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Bandra Terminus, Mumbai 51. vad bene Vinayak U. Kahsnis Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Churchgate, Mumbai 20. cond NS Dharamra} Meena Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Khar Road, Mumbai 32. nd Sad Vinayak S. Arwart, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bandra Terminus, Mumbai - $1.
74. P. Alexader Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Kandivii, Mumbai [G1.
78. Avinash Shirke,
70.
80. a4, CH th
86. 4 Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Churehgpate, Mumbai -- 20. Pravin B. Jadhav Commercial Controller, Senior Divisional Railway Manager, Mumbai Central, Mumbai -- 08, Vaishali Sanjay Govad Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Malad, Mumbai ~ 64. Hemangi Deepak Dalvi, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dahisar, Mumbai -- 68, Sanjay Kale, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borival, Mumbai -- 91, Jatin R. Patil, Head Luggage Clerk, Wester Rathy ay, Bandra Terminus, Mumbai ~ 31, Manojkumar Pande Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borivall, Mumbai -- 91, Supriya 8. Salkar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Jogeshwari, Mumbai. 102.
D'Souza Arthur Lawrence Head Booking C "lerk, Western Railw way, Lower Parel, Mumbai. 13.
Mano} Ramprasad Verma Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar, Mumbai. 14 Shankar D. Baulekar Head Booking Clerk, Western Rallway, Jogzeshwari, Mumbai. 102.
Prashant K. Joshi Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borivali, Mumbai --
Sujata Prafulla Patil Od No. 1632019
88. 89,
90. 96,
98. 1Q OA Na 1623/2099 Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Marine Lines, Mumba} --
Sanjay Kumar Nemace Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Prabhadevi, Mumbai ~ 25.
Pratibha R, Darekar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Virar, Mumbat. 401 303.
Pankajkumar Gupta Head Booking Clerk, Western Railwa ay, Kandivall, Mumbai. 101.
Sadhana BD. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Umbargaon, Cujarat-396 165, Rinaben Desai Head Booking Clerk, Western Ratlway, Santacruz, Mumbai -- 34, Karuna Joseph Chirayath Chief Luggage Clerk, Divisional Railway Manager, Mumbai Central, Mumbai ~ Zakir Hussain Mohd, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar, Mumbai ~ 14.
Akhil Usman Shaikh A. Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bandra Terminus, Mumbai~ 51. Sandeep T. Rao Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Vile Parle, Mumbai ~ $7.
Dharmendra Singh Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Vile Parle, Mumbai --- 47.
Mahesh Kumar P. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bhilad, Gu arat - 396 105.
Mahavir $8. Rajput © 7 107, 100, LOT.
LQ2.
106.
108.
109. tid.
Li O4 No fas oi 8 Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andheri, Mumbai -- 38.
Hemehandra N. Apandkar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Virar, Mumbai - 401 303.
Shailendra M. Patade Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dahisar, Mumbai. 68, Lakhidranath Sandi Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andheri, Mumbai - 58.
. Pradeep Waghmare Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar Mumibal ~ 14.
. Babulal A. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bilimora, Guiarat- 396 321,
5. Ani Kumar R. Shukla Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dahisar, Mumbai ~ 68.
Shivprasad Girdhari Verma Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bandra, Mumbai ~ 51.
Ramnath N. Bhor Head Bookie Clerk, Western Railway, Mira Road Mumbai ~ 401 107.
Manish D. Bhavsar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Amalner, Maharashtra- 425 401, Yogendra Kumar Gautam Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Santacruz, Mumbai ~ 54.
. Abdul Rab Head Booking Clerk, Borivali, Western Railway, Bandra Terminus, Mumbai-9]. Sandeep Desai
113.
114. Uy, Lis.
12 OA No f63/2019 Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Churchgate, Mumbai ~ 20.
2. Sk. Gahb Kemruddin Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar Mumbai - 14.
Pradeepkumar R. Menon Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Malad, Mumbai - 64, Roshani J. Kantharia Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dahisar, Mumbai - 68.
5. Baby §. Paul Chief Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Udvada, Gujarat- 396 18S.
. Mohanbhai Rudrabhai Gamit Head Booking Clerk, Western Raibway, Navapur Maharashtra- 425 418, Shirish 8S. Chavan Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar, Mumbai -- [4. , Ashok A. Shinde Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Surat, Gujarat- 395 003.
. Anthony J. Dias Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar, Mumbai -- 14.
20. Balaram 8. Bhoir 12h, 122 Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andheri, Maunmbai~ 38, Motilal Maurya Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Kandivall Mumbai -- 101, Mohd. Hakim Mohd. . Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar, Mumbai -- 14.
33. Rakesh Kumar L. Dhabi a aw ®
124. 130,
131. 135, id O4 No P832089 Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Umbargaon, Maharashtra ~ 396 165. Laxmikant N. Shirali Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai ~ 08, . Vinod Chitowan, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Vile Parle, Mumbai -~ 37 ». Maruti T. Pawar, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Nallasopara, Miunbai 401 209, . Ashok Laxman Shinde, Head Booking Clerk, Ww estern Railway, | Andheri, Mumbai $8. . Sadashiv C. Tiwari, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Churchgate, Mumbai -- 20. . Sitaram R. Rane, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Vile Parle, Mumbai -- 57.
Abdul Rafiq A. Rahim Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Valsad Gujarat-396 O01, G. Algaswarnt Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Jogeshwari, Mumbai ~ 102, . Jayashree $. Subramaniam Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai -- 08. . Bhaskar H. Potinde Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Khar Road, Mumbai --- 32.
4. Arvind J. Jagale Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Goregaon, Mumbai - 63, Sybila R. Gonsalves id, Ot No 23/2819 Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bhayander, Mumbai- 401 101.
136. Kuwarsingh Vasu Vasave Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Surat, Cruarat- 395 063.
137. Mahesh V. Surti Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Khar Road, Mumbai-- 52.
138. Chhaya V. Dipnaik Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Santacruz, Mumbai- 54
139. Shobha Nair V. Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Virar, . Palghar-401 303. \
140. Momin Farook A. Hamja Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andhen, Mumbai -- $8.
141. Sujata KR. G. Nair Head Luggage Clerk, C/o. Divisional Railway Manager Office, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Minmbai-- 08.
142. Alka Hitesh Gandhi Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Goregaon Mumbai ~ 63. .
143, Amit Kumar S. Verma Head Booking Clerk C/o. Divisional Railway Manager Office, Western Railway, Mumbai Central ~ 08. 144, Prashant D. Jangam Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai -- 08.
145. Mangesh V. Mane Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Charni Road, Mumbai ~ 04.
146, Pramodkumar N. Parab Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mira Road, Mumbai - 401 107. , 749, on OA Na. 62/2019 ?. Chandraprakash J. Mishra' Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borivali Mumbai -- 91, . Bhushan P. Sawant Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai -- 08. Rajendra R. Dusane Head Booking Clerk, Western Railw ay, Surat, Gujarat-395 003, SG, Vinod R. Hambire
158. Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai --08. .
1, Karit B. Rathod Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Surat,
-- Guarat- 395 003. . Dilip C. Deodhar Head Booking Clerk, W estern Railway, Virar, Mumbai. 401 303.
. Vikas V. Patil Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar, Mumbai -- 14.
4. Kajol M. Mackwan Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Matunga Road, Mumbai -- 19. . Neelesh A Raut Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Najgaon, Muumbai- 401 208.
* Hanumant S Chavan Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Malad, Mumbai 400 064, . Mohd, Uityas Khan Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai -- 08, Natwarlal D. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Valsad, Gujarat -~ 396 001,
160. lel.
162.
164. 165,
156. 167,
168.
169. V0.
OA Na db3/2019 fet ay . Ashok Kumbhar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai -- 08, Sunil V. Sawant Head Booking Clerk, Western Raibway, Goregaon, -- Mumbai ~ 63. .
Hansa R. Mackwana Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Khar Road, Mumbai -- 32.
Dilipkumar M. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bhilad, Gujarat-396 105, _
3. Khewar Azam Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andheri, Mumbai -- 38.
Manjulata V. Kothari Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Malad, Mumbai. 64. .
Ashraf Ali Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bandra, Mumbai -- 31.
Arvind Kr, Singh Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Kandrvall, Mumbai -- 101, Ramchandra Bhogle Head Booking Clerk, Western Rallway, Bandra, Mumbai - $1.
Yogita Patil Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Vasai Road, Mumbai- 40] 202, Kunal N. Bisra Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Divisional Railway Manager, Mumbai Central ~ 08. Teetendrakumar K. Verma Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andheri, Mumbai ~ 458, a ivan 176, Lv.
178.
179. H if Od No. 163! 2D78 Rakesh Kumar Triven} Pd. Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railw ay, Bandra Terminus, Mumbai ~ $1, 2, Mahendra G. Kuba! Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai -- 08.
3. Mukesh Kumar Shaw Head Goods Clerk, Western Railway, Chalth than, Gujarat-394 305, 4, Seema P, Sharma Head Booking Clerk, We estern Railway, Goregaon, Mumbai 63, . Rajesh Dhope Head Booking Clerk, Western Rail iway, Marine line Mumbai ~ 20, Vv inay Madhukar Kadu Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andheri, Mumbai $8.
Kripa 8. Purandare Head Booking Clerk, Western Rail way » Goregaon, Mumbai 63, Kailash S. Naik Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Lower Parel, Mumbai ~ 13 Harshada A. Adaw Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Grant Road, Mumbai . Britmohan R. Sharma Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bhayander, Mumbai- 4017 101, , Srikant D Sawant Head Booking Clerk, Western Railw ay, Malad Mumbai ~ 64,
2. aieh san N, Patel Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railw 'ay, Surat, Gujarat- 395 003,
184.
186. 190, 19].
194, OA No L632 019 pat oD 3, Maheshbhai L. Patel Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Bilimora, Gujarat 396 321, Tarunkumar Parmar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Surat Gujarat - 398 003,
5. Ashimkumar M. Roy Head Booking Clerk, Westem Railway, Naigaon Mumbai- 401 208.
Tejal D, Parmar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Churchgate Mumbai ~ 20, . Raju Barma Nowa! Chief Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Churchgate, Mumbai ~ 20.
. ELD Victor Chief Goods Clerk, Western Railway, Surat, Cruarat - 395 003,
2. Ajay Kumar Pandey Chief Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borivali, Mumbai - 91.
Amuitkeumar Amratlal Patel Cheif Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Vapi, Gujarat- 396 191.
Narendra Dhodia Cheif Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Surat, Gujarat- 395 003.
2. Mayadevi R. Thomar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Malad, Mumbai- 64, . Pravinbhar V. Rathod Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bandra Terminus, Mumbai- 57, Hemantkumar C. Mahamuni Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Charni Road, Mumbar ~ (4.
© SO Sty
196.
198. 199, i = = 2Qt.
13 OA No 83/2018 . Natwarlal M. Surti Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Nandurbar ~ 425 412, Rajpal Singh Baghel Cheif Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Nhandvara, Maharashtra- 425 416. , Jagdish N. Singh Cheif Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Sanjan, Guiarat-421 303.
Dilip Gorakh Kunwar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Udhana, Gujarat-394 210.
Pravind Mahida Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Navsari, Gujarat ~ 396 445, }, Atmaram P. Dauskar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Virar, Palehar -~ 401 303. Shirish Ghag .
Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Amalsad, Cruarat- 396 445,
202. Vijay S. Nair 202
203. 204, ho o os t3 SS OOK Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Santacruz Mumbai ~ 54.
S$. H. Laxman Perumal Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Nallasopara, Mumbai ~ 401 ~ 209.
Naresh D. Surti Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai ~ 0&8, », Dipika Sawant Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Vasai Road- 401 202. . Shailesh Kumar Sood Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar 209, 218, fe > Q Od Na. f62 2019 Mumbai ~ 14,
207) Arpana M. Nandiwadekar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Santacruz, Mumbai ~ 34.
S. Pramodkumar G. Panda Head Booking Clerk, Western Raibvay, Borivall, Mumbai - 91, Rakesh D. Mhatre Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai -- 08. . Subhash P. Patil Head Booking Clerk, Westem Railway, Bhayander, Mumbai- 407 107, . Firdas Sabavala Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Churchgate Mumbai ~ 20.
2. Varsha Vinod Pagdhare Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Goregaon, Mumbai - 63, . Pratibha B. Alva Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dahisar, Mumbai - 68, . ¥Yatin Hemant Vaity Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Matunga Road, Mumbai- 19.
_ Mohd. Ayub Pate! Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai -- 08. Bhushan Padwal
-Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Churchgate, Mumbai ~ 20, . Satish V. Sonar Chief Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Udhana, Gujarat - 394 210.
. Kirti Nitin Pal Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bhayander "
WY 6 bo en "i> 226
228.
72) O4 No. f63204 Mumbai- 401 161, . Satish S. Bhusnale Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bhavander Mumbai- 401 101, . Rashmi Ramchandra Nair -
Head Booking Clerk, C/o, Divisional Rail way Manager Office, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai ~ 08, , Manasi Ashish Kadam Chief Booking Clerk, Western Railw ay, Bhayander, Mumbal- 401 101, . Bhakti Santosh Waran Head Booking Clerk, Ww estern Railway, Vasai _ Read, Mumbai 401 202. . Anil Bhatarm Head Booking Cierk, Western Railyw vay, Pr abhadevi, Mumbai --
. Rambabu Gurjar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Umbargaon, Maharashtra- 396 165, . Usha R. Prabhakaran Head Booking Clerk, Western Raih way, Dahisar, Mumbai -- 68.
226. Chetan D. Modi Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Vile Parle, Mumbai --
7. Sonali Yatin Dhabale Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borivali, Mumbai ~@1.
Milind Chandrakant Gurav Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Churcheat Mumbai --
. Arti Narendre Chauhan Head Boking Clerk, Ww 'eastern Railway, Andheri, Mambai -- 58.
. Dinesh M. Sawant Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borivali, y Ko Cbd bad ~~ bh ie 240, 241, , Dalsingher Rajput Yadav
5. Santashkumar S, Pal oe C44 No. IG RENTS Mumbai - 91.
Head Booking Clerk, Western Railw: ay, Borrvall, Mumbai 91, Jyoti Prakash Mistry Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Matunga Road, Mranbai -- 19, . Pramod Kumar Sharma Head Booking Clerk, Wester Rail Iway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai ~ 08, . Baviben R, Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Navsari, Crujarat-396 445, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railw ay, Santacriu Murmnbai ~ $4, . Sarvesh Kumar Soni Head Booking Clerk, Western Raiby ay, Jogeshwar, Muribai ~ 102, . Deepa Girish Kurup Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar, Mumbai ~ | Ganeshan Mudaliar Head Booking Clerk, | _ @ C/o, Divisional Railway Manager Office, Western Railway, Mumbai Central ~-- 68. Jayash S. Kapoor Head Booking Clerk, Western Rall iway, Bandra, Mumbai ~ $1.
Prema Paul Head Booking Clerk, Westem Railway, Khar Road, Mumbai ~ 32.
Pramodkumar M. Raj Head Lugpage Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Centr aul, Mumbai --- 08.
. Mohd. Iqbal Jamilkhan KA af had 244, 246,
249. a nl en OA Nal 1652 GY os a oa Head Booking Clerk, Wester. Railway, Vasai Road, Mumbai - 401 202.
. Irfan Gulam Vashi Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Va api, Gujarat - 396 191.
Ajit Kasam Sk.
Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borivali, Mumbai --¢ 5, Krishna ap. Goyekar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railw: ay, Vi le Parle, Mumbai - $7, Ramktmar N. Yadav Head Booking Clerk, W ester Railway, Virar, Palghar - $01 303.
. Navinchandra N. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway Dahanu Road - 401 602, . Ramakant B. Sonar Head Goods Clerk, Western Railway, Songadh, Gujarat - 394 670.
Rajdeasingh R Head Bookin ng Clerk, Western Railway, Virar, Mumbai ~ 40 300, 3, Satishkumar C. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Udhana, Gujarat - 394 210.
|. Vijaykumar R. Yadav Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Surat, Gujarat - 395 003.
Mahendra K. Kale Head nn Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar, Mumbai --
. Badri Pd. Ayodhya Pd. Shukla Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Centra! Mumbai -- 08.
4. Ravindranath S. Raul 24 O4 No. 16302079 Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Goregaon, Mumbai ~ 63.
INO
55. Rarnesh B. Yadav Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bhayander Mumbai- 401 101.
». Gulabbhai B. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Naigaon, Mumbai- 401 208.
hes AY On bn Lay wad . Manjulata Haribabu Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dahisar,
- Mumbai -- 68.
258. Kirankumar D. Patel -- Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bhayander Mumbal-401 101,
259. Dhrubhai Dhodia Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Sanjan Gujarat - 427 303, 260, Suresh Gulabbhai Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Vapi, Guyarat- 396 191,
261. Dhirubhai M, Patel Chief Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Surat, Gujarat - 395 003.
262. Ramakant S. Bhawar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borivali, Mumbai~ 91.
263. Nareshbhar Ishwarlal Leuva Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bhayander, Mumbai ~ 400101, 264, Rajbahadur Singh Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bandra Terminus, Mumbai -- 31.
a
265. Rohitash Harijan Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borivall, Mumbai -- 91.
266. Harimohan Verma "
x
268. Oa No. 16% 2019 ts tR Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andheri, Mumbai -- 38.
7. Kundan A. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railw ay, Navsari, Gujarat - 396 445, Maya P. Khare Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mahim, Mumbai -- 50, Styaram R. Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Navsari, Crujarat - 396 445. O. Rameshbhai B. Rathod Head Luggage Clerk, Western Raihw ay, Navsari, Gujarat - 396 445, |. Baban S. Baile Head Booking Clerk, Western Rallw ray, Dadar, Mumbai ~ 14.
. Balasubramaniam V. 'Chief Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Virar, Palghar ~ 401 303. . Mahesh B. Mackwana Head Luggage Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai ~ 08.
4+. Kalpana 8. Kotkar Head Booking Clerk, Western . Railway, Virar, Palghar- 401 303, . Surdl Damse Chief Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Mumbai Central, Mumbai -- 08.
5. Sushilkumar Sinolia Head Booking Clerk, Western Raihw ay, Dahisar, Mumbai -- 68, 277, Shirish Waghmare 278, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Nalasopara, Mumbai -- 401 209. Amarkumar M, Barot ho tnd ND 280, 282 bo oO Sab 284,
286. 290, Head Booking Clerk, Crujarat ~ 395 003. Head Booking Clerk, Gujarat - 396 445, 26 O4 No. 16302 GI9 Western Railway, Sur at, . Dbirubhai Naranbhai Patel Western Railway, Navsari, Indravardhan D. Rathod Head Booking Clerk, Crujarat - 395 003. _iaypratapram Biparam Head Booking Clerk, Mumbai ~ 38.
Head Booking Clerk, Gujarat- 394 210, . Gurupratap Singh Western Railway, Surat, Western Railway, Andheri,
2. Nareshbhai Ranubhai Solanki. © Western Railway, Songadh, Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Navsari, Cujarat- 396 445, Kishor Sudam Salunkhe Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Ram Mandir, Mumbai -- 104.
. Ajaypal Singh Head Booking Clerk, Gujarat « 21 303 Shailesh §. Gajre Head Booking Clerk, Mumbai - 2 . Keshav Prasadram Shi Head Booking Clerk, Mambai < 52, '
8. Raju S. Sonawane Chief Bookime Clerk, Gujarat - 395 G03, . Nagin D, Patel Head Booking Clerk, Mumbai - 48.
Chandra Subhayya Western Railway, Sanjan, Western Railway, Marine Lines romani Western Railway, Khar Road Western Railway, Surat, Western Railway, Dahisar, 291, 294, 298, bho oo ere 299, 300,
302. 27 Od No. 1863/2019 Head Booking Clerk, C/o. Station Manager Western Railway, V de Parle, Mumbai -- 57, Sanjoo Narayan Head ae Clerk, Western Railway, Borivali, Mumbai --
. Chhagan G. Gavhane Chief Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Surat Gujarat - 395 003,
3. Bhagubhai C. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Westem Railw ay, Udavda, Gujarat -396 188. Manisha Nilesh Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railw ay, Barival, Mumbai ~ 9], . Sachinkumar Tailor Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Valsad Gujarat - 396 001, Dinesh M. Vasava Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Udhana, Gujarat - 394 210. _ Kamlesh A. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway Bhoisar - 401 501, . f. Sat Privadharshini Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bandra, Mumbai-- 431.
Geuri Linus Fanse Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borivali, Mumbai ~ 91.
Kuldeep Rangi Chief Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar, Mumbai ~ 14.
1. Vishnu Gopwa! Chief Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Malad Mumbai ~ 64, Bhavin J. Rathod hed om Spd 304, tad 2 As
306. hand os 4
308. Sad wont Lad Lad of Cet 2s OA No. 1622029 Head Booking Clerk, Wester Railway, Dahanu Road 401 602, . Kalpana Mitesh Mackwana Head Booking Clerk, Western Railw ay, Dahisar, Mumbai -- 68.
Bharati Sury akant Diophode Head Booking Clerk, W. estern Railway, Vasai Road, Mumbai-401 202, . Navinchandra P. Solanki Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Borivali, Mumbai - 91, Shekar Sudam More Head Booking Clerk, Western Railw ay, Mahim, Mumbai -- 80.
7. Ujwala Tishiram Zende Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Prabhadevi, Mumbai ~ 25, Sangita Roy Head Booking S ok Western Railway, Mira Road, Mumbai- 40] . Vikram Siknh Ingle Chief Book! ing Clerk, Western Railway, Dadar, Mumbai ~ 14, . Manesh G, Bhelsekar Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Churchgate, Mumbai ~ 20. :
1. Saraswati P. Veny Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Bhayander Mumbai- 401 101.
. Maheshwar Raj Janga Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Andheri, Mumbai -- SS.
, Ravindra N. Mare Chief Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Dahan Road - 401 602.
, Naresh Karsan Solanki D C4 Na. £63207 9 seh 23 Chief Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Surat Gujarat - 395 003.
315. Kailesh Mohanbhai Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railw ay, Bardoli, Grujarat - 394 355,
316. Trupti N. Naik Head Booking Clerk, Western Railw ay, Navsari, Gujarat-396 445,
317. Mayur D. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Duneri, Gujarat-396 375,
318. Harshad C.Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Pardi, Guiarat - 396 "191,
319. Rohan A. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railws ay, Amalsad, Crufarat-396 445.
320, Hiteshkumar Ranchhodbhai Patel Head Booking Clerk, Westem Railway, Valsad Gularat ~- 396 001,
321. Pritiben P. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway, Valsad, Gujarat ~ 396 001, 322, Ketan M. Patel Head Booking Clerk, Western Railway,' Dahanu Road- 40) 602.
323. Pramod B. Thakur Head Booking Clerk, Western Railw ay, Nandurbar - 425 412, os Respondents ORDER _ (Oral) Per; RN Sin SsHgh, Member if} fy ter ee of $ ete Al ye "AT ty le, 3 4 PErMLSsion to withdraw the OA with iiberty pe eo x er ar o eM ys a - " - an py RS eG Tlie better OA. Permission is granted. (RN. Singh) Member (J} ani, O4 No. £62209 one, PNT aes 3 = OA stands arr .
+ 4 sede liberty in ry Ae AF (Dr. Bhagwan Sahai) Member (A) @