Karnataka High Court
Judicial Layout Residents And Site ... vs Bangalore Development Authority on 15 July, 2011
Author: Ram Mohan Reddy
Bench: Ram Mohan Reddy
{N THE Ewififii COL? R?' Q?' E{A¥i¥:=%'E'A.EiA XE" E3;5';F\§{}.?a§T,{}RE';
E}A"§'Ei) THEE TEEE Zi.§'-3"" E}??? Q?' J UB1" 26}. E
PRESENT
':*:+§: H®N'£~3LE MR.JUS'"§'E€E: §?;Ai'«i MOHg%.N_.E§Ej'§f§V§}E9__f. _
AM I)
THE HGE_\§"B§__,E IVER. &US'I'§!:§E i%I:;:;,A?§A
M:$c.W'.N0. 56'30..;§1=.* 2¥:3v1 1 :3:
Wm? PETITIQN N0. a1o9?953;;a»BéA%V2c§G°2 ix-1L}?
BE§'E'-Ev'EZENf
JEEDECEAL Lz~'x'r'{3U'§' RT:25;1:}z«:1§:{:"'5s-M33} " . .V
SETE; HoL;:=3f::_zz..<3s ASEKJCEAT-MN :§a%:é3:3.,.;
€3.K.VKK.POS'§Z _ _ ,
B!aNGAI,QRE W5-55:: «efxaév; «
REPRESEN'E'E;jE3 L3'>'.9A:*:4:L'*;::vV . .
Eisozamis OF £::r":*»:§:<:':'<>:5«aVs<_s <:~cm:ss:§;f__§";;':x.:§::; 5?)?
E% g
2:: a
'V " .3 zz:::<:1.;?gL_nA ,A'i{'€3U§i
8.*;.I.BYRA §:z::zj::ia'&.', . V'
PE€ESU}£§?€"i'. "
.I'€{},,E_;i'3£'3,'2;'~.EH {:§<{}s:~:=:;7
V E:;z?34,E°i{S:".i£§1§.L{;L}'E";i_§::' 4:
"Y. ,»?a{§;-%§§i%§,§§E--§.,;' - V .
'J3CE?'4E3E%£:5"{*E:éj§*Z37'€'§1
?€'i3;C:;_5§8g _ $13: ..'E'vEzfaEN §%{f}AE)._
g (,3z5z>§c§;a:,.;;:r'<>:3'E'§
».;:13;a:i'=».%€.;;s;§.,{;%:«::3 $5;
" ~ . "fax; C§-§1«§€E{;%,LEN{};'§E;f&E.§é
::%:.?:'<:<,:§1i£a:'§';?:§'{%; Ni}. :5? 8w
:,:a;;€::>.:€:;é;%2:, :gx::*<:2:;':',
= -~E3--3%?~E{}:":L{}E§E§ €325;
gfii
mm¢uvm.m.mnm"%.....m... ..
<3 '
§L
Tm)
.
{T-E. K. ?€A{};7§§?;z%;§f&e TE€£*Z.5'iE§E}§%E§R* Ni)" E "330, 6"'? :"\:'£;'3§lE'*z§* 533"" {fE¥1€}E*3ES., J U DE€Ti1.1%_L LAY€}§§'§'_ §3.A.?\E{}AE.{')RE§ 435$.
53. D ' V §§1'€ EiA'.1}X.§{f%.§VZfi;E'€AEPifii ; E'OI.§NDE§R PRE§S¥I}EZN'I' {KNEE E'}§REC3'i'{}R';. NE}. 18933; é?§M"?'i i'e'?;X1N ROA{L'a J U DICIAL LAYG UT, EfiAN(}A§,(}§?iE ----
M.SE--EVA ?s.x§:;R";':~4£Y. F<>RM:«:R v:<:;3-9:%:§;$::}:§N*:i;a§.I:3 ::,x§'_*;'-?§«f:i<':*:<':;"<",>:az_v . . ?~§{}.E€~3{}§ 155"' CE%{)$f§, ' __ JUDE{3E,5K§., LA'{€3'{3'1'.
E%A?x?(}E§L{}f{.E§ ~« €35, [3.N.KA{}WAD, §')IR}E3C'E"OE{, _T ' » N0. 2 E86, 19%-!-V C§€GSE§,_ ' Ji:§)1<::ATL i.;a'_{€;EI.j'§', " ' ' E§AN<;A:,<>I£iEi«'*'j:5%, EEIWE E2':;:>,§":::§M;%aaL, " --.
E)'I1?;EC'1'(_)R; " _ F*£{};",E,26, 2 Ear Iii;-:..;s"~,:2N§ _ J:3:>:<:;Ai:,mrf:;I::fE",'« "
E-3}':§*€{}zEi,.§}I {}Z M :35, "
':6; {.1 S31;_§;_}A}3E§A§.;:5;fAE£ ~3z;>:rx3':.' §E'g£TE%§i'£';iiE§?;_§f£1NE,'3 I)ERE£{T"E."{}§€; A V"'N{}.E7§%Z*{},"'1.%'1'%i <:§:»:<>$s' V = .. L_;:::>:<:.:m, :;_:a$:'<}iJ'::
" V _ §::';~¢r~;z'{2;?~g;»;'§;?.:_€:'5; $5.
--A ;f'%~,L.r'%}{§;:i§§§.E'§13$: Eizkiié. .__§3§.§%£«:<:*:'£'}j'R; N{}.§22§ 5a§::v§«:z~a: §a::.{;:,s:;§ 2:;m:.s1--:::§:<>5$. lam M51133. :EU'§f:§E€ZE§3§., :.m:-'<}z.:'_:'k n ; .E31%N{'j}x%EJ{I}EF%.E§ ----
x __ §.;;,::;. E%:"::.3?§: %4{l,.%,(:4-3:
§}E§-'~'{§"§{fi'§"{}§2.
«R f 'f'e:mw.$5ewv"
wsm: ......w..m.m........ .. ..
_ :3- 4* mra. §<;;a§2:;N';x':*A:{.ra :1-¥;:;:s;':":; J:;:.":i<::.;a:, E3E3FAR'.£TMEE;'=Z"~é'.i' §3m>L<>YME:§~;':' 2--iéf}§,EE§§i\§{7§ 8LEEi,§')'§N€,': Cé}-{3§3E§RA'§"§'€%Z E:§»{}{?EEi'§"§", §~%:§*,'E?n £3'; ITS SE:CREi'i'A§{':'. :»::=:;:~:: {3{f}'L§R'E'E13¥;.EEL[}{N{}E93, E%A.N€}AE,{3RE§ »- 565: {:26} .2. _. V _ "
{?.{}1'*~:3'M'(§N {EV SR1. K. KRIS}-{N;'L AIDV. FGR R} SR1, JAC};'3°:E3ISI*'§ EVIIJNEEAFEGI. {}.!-'L §"<}§?; R2 SR}, K. V. 3'§A§{ASII*¢1}'§z*&N. §J."J'v'. Pi??? f%3'"
MKS' M' S}*fIVA§}E'A é§.SE?{F$,. ASK--'E5. FEDR :{'_§"-I'VE; SR3 M' SAITE-"R:£XE{2'XS§'§ RE3{}D'{. ;'-'sI)\7. E3'€T}I4?.7E_'{;%"73 . . ' §2n_r.::;17:5:}>'<3:s2_*T;j:-:;£:_,':~x:'f::vf'~:_;;3;' ' _ ':'§»§':3 '£'vEIEE5*C1V~,«" a.;>1>:_,§<:A'2"§{;g'$.55 :r:r.:;:::} @;:é;2f;7:';=~..é<f;w::"::ézeA A" ' DEEl':§:iC:'£'E£"}E'\£ 'E*€} ':'r-:5: 5m RE:3;><>s~sz;E«:%~s'?:% m H;a_:?~.z:D..{3_\,}-':«:§% V:2:--1vsICm., P*C'}SS§€;SE§§ON (>2? 'IE.'HEEZ ssc.:»i£;.z§2:;I.,:::V s:*:'1;s fii;:y 'mp: §¥E'm"§:3NE:Rs:
1-'§.NDE'}{'C. 4' ' ' V "
THIS M1;<-3<:._W--_i ;xE?;>:,I-:§iA*1f:{§§:: §.:3;"{,*;'::::.:y:1*;»?'{;« €31'? FOR F'UR"i'E£ER HEARING mg;¢..§§_»xf\g;j1g4a2»1fM¢3A1\:__..12;::bn%£*;""J, E}E2I,§VERED 'FE-IE2 §r<3LL<>wI,t%I<;:" j; _ . _ 1%:
'E"fh§&; ;§i';*:;)i§'i<:2£§";i£;ié'v_ *é;{rVZm§r1 §"1é3a:*ci 0:': 24/§/2&1}; 'fe;:sE?;<>w2? 1% g i,{':;'%f'd¥£*§§' 'N215? Sséid: _ " Papé Refidgg, Egamefi éfowzsei far ihe szzfijzrziis Ehai Zf:ej?o:;:'2§;£a::iQzi: £5165? was Eaéd fbf "'é2';"é::€s'{:2§ a £:'é2:'2'z§Ee 53;; E,?2,.<3 app§é<:az:f:s wseuid be AA ,_;*"°:-3;'2**a':':':}e<,-55% czzzzicti. 5316' pr@;3€?E'§; :"es;i"§r§£§ :19 55$ gfigimzi " -. .§a:%s§EI€@:a gi" grémizéai {z'.z?:e:
Eréi 32-53:. 52:: Efagé 325.-€?3«:E'i' éaze? z:3f?z£::r:':'25j§ 3:} reparé an $3 ?'Z/ .202 EX'
2. 'E"':;}a:Eay, Sria '3'21";3§z"€~:€_t§<i§;, E€:a:':?.<-rtci {1<:<:,z.:f:é;e::E féfiajfthé appEi::a::L 5-mbmfits that: Em: 0}"€§€3fi" cit. 241j8f}:'f;_::i1;§' <":<.:m;3§ied with, Sr}; %{.V.Naras§i1":2harL I23ez.rr:;:§_c§"C{)':::':Sé:§ f<>r_ 9 {he BBMP, s;:.1E:sm§i',$ Ehai: hs E3213 §§}Sf,£'§3€f'{i{)§1S':f£Z'§v._f3:éL3;"§{§ §f}:}§2'£f .. V?
Eimre '£3 {:<§mg>Iis.z1ce with :;h;e: GrC§é1'-- :f§;:e. 2;4;i"v*z"V:V>,«*"..2fVG«'1I.'3 . 3,ZQ '. €}€'h€*.i" W{E§"dS, 'éhe fe:.':1i1§§21i'.i<>n émilszés iE:zs:%£E é';:': thkfs Siie in quasmtxm, have SHIEYS b€~i:3'}I";x'e::.1{>V§;"~.cE' 21;1§i""t;%1€- site brazighfg to its angina} c:a:3c£3;t,:{m.
33 .;§:'§; -;T\§é3jm::;§i%:'1"hsaim, {:<:%:;I:":m:':::i.V in his S§,':b}.'1"1iSSi(}i"1 '£:.haE:, in the séghg; sf fileV{>?§$§3'§'v_;;i3i.--§,;>:;.$ Q? the Suprzzrnsi Cmirit {hat public _2mih{5'§¥.t.§'t:s_'Vas'€=_ 19%§€at.z"a1i11€d Eran: ai10é.'t§':2g ptibiiéf 'V;:;m;>:*::""E,i<2*§s~».h::«§§>ng§;::ég""':;éVthem and in ijhfiii" §3<>s$%:$s5:iez1, ii): %€:.§§g2_;;§¢:}t;$ 'p§;::*§§s;:.$5§_. ssuch 35:»; §l§;".I"§}§§§€iS' ::§;'n,z:"{:'§1e:::~;, Efififiqiififi, :;%?;<:,;»*iE1e $~ié':é ;'§.~::T q::é3st;§€>:1 s:;:i."{1€:£~:* reriggéazaesi zirzéé r€§§r:qu_ish%:cfi 'A fem-m.ié"v.§:§ ihs BB?/E? 21$ 2; Civia: f§E1'2€§}if§f Siilfiz, <:a;"::":{;e:;. E26 2%. T$:2b§»@:~.<%_§';¥ Z§EE§,§,§'.i§§ {>5 aE§<§é:::"1é:%:':£: £1133' <E<3:':s2;Efi.m{::':i<m <3? 31 ":.€:':§pEs:. =§4.x%?:2f:§"::§%{§ C{>u:'::~;§:E $:2'%mi%::5~1s E:ha.*€: '£:h€ EBEEF wmzéii {£3 3:. §?% twxxiwlkcfiééxmwmmmmuwmwmwmmwmwmwmmm. .__ . ..
.. MW ' 20 thus? €§§§'€3{?'£.§{3§'EE.~3 is;$u€éd Eggsx "she: ,{3;p{f'X {f»:3§_.::*§;: in .21 Speatéai Lc2ws:= P€:'£'.2'f{:2'<)m eirémpiizrd '»V1§{'.}1 fhfi fiaétig éihzzi; the p4.r<;ps4i*iy is xw% LV§§\§' :'1z:>w pazbiiz: pmpa%:*{.:,,-' 2121:: dezi {K-="{'.";f"' iice €.E'§€: "
§'{f:{}:1"i€§1lI:Sh}7E1(fE1ii e:ie<3<"1 {t>:e<::,:ti5:£i a;:%é"
zrsilabie its z;1{:<:<-zpé. the: :t<3r1E:€:§1ii{}:r1 7-]
6. in "aha-3. FEfSL1E§), rejevéied. ii: is _ne@d_Ees,:=; é{> 3,?'-.§s;i.g _:'t§ié1f €:.i1§:téa'p;3ii':;an*c; may ass{>Cia€.€: itself' wiish [n.e::".*£:er Qf :::omsst.:*°:_:{:i:i0n mi the *Gar:.esha Ede? 211:: 3; SuTE32r:11fz12mya J{}iS§ Si!"
REESE 5 §¥§@§