Karnataka High Court
Commissioner Of Central Excise And ... vs M/S Adecco Flexione Workforce on 8 September, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
¢ §"'§'2~'a:":;w.4_-f_E:2'2i?g{%::§."%:'_-*;..;~ fifié} 983%.
:3? fmg EEEGE-3 $91231' fiffi' =:::
mgrsfi '1'I+IiE$ THE am 32;? QF SE?TEMBERg:2@.} 1 PREZSENT $32 :mz~:*mE may ,5i3§s;%r:€E :;;§:z::i§;;§I§ _ " 'V AN'::» a i{'§£E §iQN'BLE ;s;1R,;§%:%;s:3f,z:cE ::"e2§;;?1% gezggjggiamég % €E£;.NG. :;0:i%'%5,3F.;2a%~ A CEA,V1s:i0,.1:T::)2iaxztéaag 1§wafin$V.V:j' _ ' Q <>:§1:::2T &:s5i{>t:i1é:'. ii' §3':':%j1€:;--E. Efijsic ami S§e:rz-*%:3s=::T{;;${; "
Large 'E":1:::;pa:§,I:::%f ijwzaiz', _ «,fS§§ fE"'<:w<.%§".:fa, i®.@fi:. 'R§:r': Rfifiéifi, B.2?:§};22,SAE:;'::':ka:*'i-- « V3.13 _ zigta , z':'§~§}§}{i1§£iE"§§;', §{i<:s:12m<_:§':_ in ?>€.:ti%"§ fiéé? 21§3§3é:*22:.§$} ~§§j; E=T3é°L J<%€::2'2%:': J 3j'=E'<%a:s"z1E;:'§;; ,:'3,<:'§a?.} V' ,E%§ ;%::§€::<*:j2 §?k::;§:i3:{ie:é '%f*»-r'<}:°E§_f%;}:*{:£:=. . §:"§{>'§%:,;: :. %1<>:':s>; EA ii. _.
waaa2>«-"W \ KN} _Regem Scéurii, E 5; E1 E<"E{><;:*, P122: 1'\§{>.1'?., S' Bed 8% E1, Reads K{>re1ma.:1a.gaEa¥. , Baz1g§a.l<>z'<i M 569 S34.
_, E¥2é§i-§p'.{}*§t:.{i¥;:--:§'é; .> iifi<;mm{:xn in 1{3j{:§->§.§".i~~f§L}§f3 %Z§}3'éf%a§'§} {By 833:; ?atimi:r:§ SE1?1C§&1I{§.ifBg ;;5s;i?¢'ii;'L':E7r '7 '§"h<~:s<i~ C3533 are fgliegfz Uj'S;3-59 {>13 i:i%i€-3;' C's:%f1"ii;°'2§E EX{1iE-Ki Ae:tt:, 3944 arising <)L:._'§¥:>§f° {}rd€=;r__ daj;.<:-£1; pa$s€é in Fina} Grdei" N0,' §'?2;' praying thaii ibis I-E<;sr:'"?0i<-3 {Z<)uz'i. m.;3.y 'z3«é:"':g;>':£%:_a;;%éI'a:§:_ ii): E§}'T~:>-'{ie-{tide ma-3 8ubSi:antiaE questianfiff" _§2=:;%._v s;~§i:~11:':!:.;:i' ..fi:;~s=~r{«:in§ {ii} Set. aaidfi Ehe CESTEXEI South Z{):1£:'-vB§3I1{'th';-- "8;i;§g;?aI0re in Finai Qrder N0,€§52& §'72,f€.-35%::dats2d_8'€)}{Q5,€2G08 in tha QEEGS of juagiiice $151333. s:'q':2:'i;y..' . ' .
am for E"§€3E1§'§E}g, 'éhils; fizzy?
N, KUEAEE .:fi{-zlivs-fi:"?s3::3 'the' f{)EE<:)wmg:-- E "§§§§ME§? ----
~ ""31?-%%;'_%.E_:'~%;§:'i:§§<3 a§3pe2;:Es are pr@EE=::°:*2§d by 3.5%: as3:»$%":s:$@€ cE§';1§k=':if1g'i';'§.;;f téza sarziez' pazggezgé E33; §.%"1€ '".E':"i_':3:1:':a.§ 21$ zazézéé as " A' ':.%;zj;ja~ !'§;§p€:EE:/1€:§;% {f<};'r;§:z§$§§::§':e§ %}J§'}{} §:a_%:s;": fiiééiéii fiiazzi fiéss is; :'1=:3E. §i.a%>E:'-: zizra gag: amjz §_}<3§'12?zEE".:§,z' zzzaiiaz Sazéat, 2 é =';y~.
gr/.2 mséw 3 is? {heat Fizzzzzscfté ACE; E§}'§}4.~ 2iE'1iT§ £f.§*s::ér:%§<;1z@; mi: EEES zyrzier pzisseszi by iiizz-5': E{}'W:3I" 25:1,:§.§1{>~r£:.§es §mpas:§i:'g~;§¢;:;,::Eé;5;'; _ 2, §~'a{:{s Eiféf ms! in d§s:;;>:.§'*:c:.;....71f'he:~ ;3;$§S§é':5s::€;<: 312:3. p~:--;..ifl'V hath Ithése ss:=:z'x:*é.{:§% 'iiax am} i§:é:e:"ésf. 'de1i£_2§;:*e;§E' };}é:»f§f;§:§%1;*:tS ':::»s:'§'{;:*<:: :i.s;sf:::% 9? Shaw czmé-sfziv "I:":.i}'¥;'.sZ:i:<:"";_m:§€*1"' *§.§1i::i.._ $xe:t.€:. Su.E::i=~ V Segzifi} sf Sec. "?3 z:)f.::§1€% §?3fr_<1i23,£f§;'?<;3r.;*:';¥*=:1{A:'i:§ § § 9@,.{i&1%,&§§{}§'§C&fl§y Statea, 2:f'§«$:' ilhff p2"zyi:i€;:'":i';"«?.%§i*:':§a:%Wié€.f::L"<»; gmé ::m.a;~e~.;«;: iség made ané _%:.'::§é_sa.i{fi iriigr-r::::1~i:L2';:r: ':';<1::« figrgaisheei ta €136 21:,1i1':'é:§:*i'%T.§£:-31s--;.- 5.{i":é§i%: E'E9;<:3._ au.':ih_{:%i€iie3:~; ésiaaié 310?"; s5£::'v£: any z2:>§;iC%:':_ :::1d?<ezf :2£,1AEf}¥£'«sb:;.§§'}fin F€',Sp€3{f'£. sf E126: ::1::1{}'v.:"a;'i, 39 paid, T'is1§3ra<:=§"{3??::*, égui;-}:<§;:§%:§es §1av<~: no :1L:'{.h{;r§%.y ':10 énitizxiez prz§;e1,:€:i:d:::g:s'-.fa?'Eiéciiveiry 0? penaE'£.j_J E23166}? Sec. '?'8 0f ¥;'E'1&: ax ' ' .
.5 x.,.V«.f E§:2:3E?)19*i-',§,:zzai.€E}f H28 ;3_$S€%$$§::g§ 2w;:h@§*§§:j; 23$ E-'--£'€fi 3:5 . %§:,'§'"':_é;* g:'j;'i§$E£;:§%i,'é:~"'2::,2§:h@::"'£.i.y' -E:"%§3ff.fE'§.. E10 E1h_§§}§§, if 232:; 23.:-§&:<i~s;$€:-3 %'§»{}{fS 31%' j,;;'%a:=.__;' %;;h:i~ €22}: z¥§E',E:.i:3 3316: 5;-;'£',%;:::z2_Ea§.{::a:§; time mad rséga;.§2:2?:§§ 'a422::='~: gfifié' %.§'m% e.:iz;{;': iT§E-'E§,{:'. wii.E": §:1%;.<::"'€s=:si;; ii, §:~;§ 2 §__/ 6 ;§a1%:.§'1e:::"i'z:§:%$, :1.e:9i: ':10 ::a:;:':ir;:'<:€':";a:c Sub-§€i%C.[3} Bf ;'E§<:{:,?'f_% sf iihe f%€','{.. E:§':i5~§ §}ii"{}'J§SE{}'§"'i, .:i:2.:zm€ EV