Central Administrative Tribunal - Ahmedabad
Kuldeep Alabhai Gadhvi vs Department Of Telecommunication on 4 July, 2025
:: 1 :: O.A.No.276/2025
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BENCH
O.A. No.276/2025
Dated this the 04th day of July, 2025
CORAM:
Hon'ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon'ble, Dr. Hukum Singh Meena, Member (A)
1. KULDEEP ALABHAI GADHAVI
31- Geet Gunjan Residency, Vimal Nagar Main Road,
Rajkot 360 005
2. AJITSINH KARASANJI CHUDASAMA
32 Marutinagar, Meghpar Road, Anjar,
Kachchh 370 110
3. ALPABEN HIMANSHUBHAI RANA
2, Shashwat Bunglows, Nr. Suncity Sector-7,
South Bopal, Ahmedabad 380 058
4. ALPESH MANJIBHAI BHALANI
203 - Sanskar Apartment, Nobel Estate - B,
Near Vaibhav Laxmi Temple,
Zanzarda Road, Junagadh 362 001
5. ALPESHKUMAR JAYANTILAL PATEL
47/2, Harekrishnanagar Society,
80 Feet Road, Surendranagar 363 002
6. ALPESHKUMAR VITTHALDAS UPADHYAY
Palanpur
7. AMISHA VIRENDRA PATEL
At & Post: Atgam, Joting Talav,
Taluka & Dist: Valsad.
8. AMIT VINODBHAI PARMAR
C-504 Kalash Square, Opp. Green Aura,
Near Dev Paradise, Satyamev Tragad Road,
Chandkheda, Ahmedabad 382 424
9. AMIT MERUBHAI BHUTIA
B 46, Radhakrishnan Society, Behind Raijibag,
Motibag, Junagadh 362 001
10. AMITKUMAR SURESHCHANDRA SHUKLA
B-8, Ameen Park, 150 Feet Ring Road,
2025.07.14
PRATIK VYAS
11:01:07+05'30'
:: 2 :: O.A.No.276/2025
Nr. Modi School, Rajkot 360 007
11. ANKESH SHASHIKANT SHAH
"Nityanand", Anand Nagar,
Yogeshwar Society Road, Godhra
12. ANUP GANPATSINH THAKOR
C-202, Abhilasha Appt, Halar Road,
Near Doctor House, Valsad 396 001
13. ARIF ALARAKHA SIDDIQUI
Besides Ratanbai Girls School,
Near Khoja Gate, Jamnagar 361 001
14. ARUNKUMAR JETHABHAI PRAJAPATI
9-13, Prajapati Vas, Ugamani Sheri,
At & Po- Jagana, Ta-Palanpur, Banaskantha 385 001
15. ARVIND AMARSHIBHAI CHOTALIYA
Block No. 84, Sahkar Society,
St. No 01, Opp Hasanwadi, Rajkot 360 001
16. ASHISH SHANKARLAL KALANI
B-503, Nirmal Signature, Nr. Aditya Greens,
New C.G. Road, Chandkheda, Ahmedabad 382 424
17. ASHISHKUMAR RAVINDRABHAI PATEL
A-45, Pooja Raw House, I-Road,
Palihill-3, Tithal Road, Valsad-396001
18. ASHVINKUMAR RAJABHAI MAKADIA
Radhasoami, Shraddha Society,
Airport Road, Keshod 362 220
19. ASHVINKUMAR BABULAL RANA
A37, Vrundavan Society,
Rajpur Road, Balasinor 388 255
20. ASIFIQBAL AHMED PATEL
B-6, Amanpark, Near Bypass Chokdi,
Bharuch 392 001
21. ASIM PYARALI PANJVANI
303, Silver Plaza Apartment,
Nr. Shak Market, 80 Feet Road, Surendranagar
22. AXAYKUMAR NAGINLAL DOSHI
C/56, Ganesh township Co Op Housing Society,
Nr Shravan Chokdi, Link Road Bharuch 392 001
23. BAKULCHANDRA GUMANBHAI CHAUDHARI
2025.07.14
PRATIK VYAS
11:01:07+05'30'
:: 3 :: O.A.No.276/2025
35, Divyanagar Society, Kaps Road,
Vyara, Dist - Tapi 394 650
24. BALKRUSHNABHAI BHAGVANBHAI TANDEL
A/16, Satnam Raw House, Satnam Co. Op. Ho. Society,
Opp Raval Nagar, Bilimora,
Tal.- Gandevi District - Navsari 396 321
25. BHARATKUMAR KARSANBHAI PATEL
C/4 Mayurvilla Residency, Berna Road,
Opp- Viratnagar, Mahavirnagar, Himatnagar 383 001
26. BHARATKUMAR NAGINDAS TANDEL
At & Post - Umarsadi, Machhiwad, Mandir
Street, Ta: Pardi, Dist: Valsad 396 125
27. BHAVIN JAYSUKHLAL CHUDASAMA
90, Kamlapark Society, Ghodasar,
Ahmedabad 380 050
28. BHUSHAN HARISHCHANDRA DHANESHA
323, 2nd Floor Oscar City Tower-3,
Sadhu Vasvani Road, Off. University Road,
Rajkot 360 005
29. ΒΙΡΙΝBHAI KHATRABHAI PARGI
721, Ambika Nagar Society, Godi Road,
Dahod 389 151
30. CHANDUBHAI PANCHANBHAI TANK
25-Man Row House, Anandnagar Street-5,
Chakkargadh Road, Amreli
31. CHETAN KALYANJIBHAI MISTRY
H3/104, Shivshakti Township, Udwada - Bagwada Road,
Saran, Udwada 396 185.
32. CHITRANGKUMAR BHIKHUBHAI TANDEL
D-403, Neelkanth Valley Society, Tithal Road, Valsad 396 001
33. DAXESHKUMAR SURESHBHAI PATEL
19, Ishwarkrupa Society, Aslali, Ahmedabad 382 427
34. DEVINKUMAR BABUBHAI BAROT
22, Shital Tenaments, Near Hinglaj Society, Mehsana 384 002
35. DHARMENDRA GHANSHYAMBHAI DALAL
Shreeji Krupa, 61, Harikrishna Society,
Near Ankleshwar Mahadev, Godhra
36. DHARMENDRAKUMAR VERMA
6, Yash Tenaments, Joisar Estate, Street No 2,
2025.07.14
PRATIK VYAS
11:01:07+05'30'
:: 4 :: O.A.No.276/2025
Digjam Circle Jamnagar 361 006
37. DHARMESHKUMAR ISHVARLAL CHAUHAN
A-303, Pious Parisar, Chandkheda, Ahmedabad 382 424
38. DHARMISTHA SHETALBHAI PATEL
108-Ramnagar, Ankleshwar
39. DHIMANT CHANDULAL LIMBASIA
"Chandrajyot", 279, KP Shah Wadi,
Rameshwarnagar Society, Jamnagar 361 008
40. DHIRAJ MOTILAL PANCHAL
46, City Sangath Residency, Kala Hanuman Road,
Ahmedabad Highway, Palanpur
41. DILEEPKUMAR GORAKHPRASAD PANDEY
A504, Sahajanand Elegance, Opposite J V Patel ITI,
Karamsad, Anand 388 325
42. DINESH KHODABHAI ZARMARIYA
98/3, Swami Narayan Nagar, Behind Halar House, Jamnagar
43. DIPAK ARVINDBHAI TRIVEDI
A-14 Laxmi Residency, Near Oscar Residency,
Raiya Road, Rajkot 360 007
44. DIPAKKUMAR PRATAPSINH CHHANTBAR
D-68 Ganesh Township, Link Road Bharuch 392 001
45. DIPAKKUMAR PARMAR
D-103, Swati Residency-3, IOC Road,
Chandkheda, Ahmedabad 382 424
46. GITABEN UPENDRAKUMAR SHRIVASTAV
A1-1002, Nandanvan - 2,
VIP Road, Vesu, Surat
47. HARSHADBHAI GUNVANTBHAI PATEL
5, Parth-II Bungalows, Karamsad Road, Vallabh Vidhyanagar, Anand
48. HEMANTKUMAR BABUBHAI HEBATPURIA
169 - Plot Area, Opp Kalyan Bank,
East Kalol, Dist - Gandhinagar 382 721
49. HIMANSHU JAGADISH CHANDRA VYAS
F 402 Khodiyar Upvan,
Near Paras Bungalow, Bopal, Ahmedabad 380 058
50. HIMATLAL GOVINDBHAI DHEDHI
B-2676, Kaliyabid, Bhavnagar 364 001
2025.07.14
PRATIK VYAS
11:01:07+05'30'
:: 5 :: O.A.No.276/2025
51. HIRALBEN PRADEEPKUMAR NAYAK
38, Niharika Bunglows, Nr. Azad Soceity,
Himmatlal Park, Ahmedabad 380 015
52. JASWANTKUMAR PARMAR
Satkar Society, Behind Maruti Ice Factory,
Ganeshpura Road, Palanpur 385 001
53. JAYANTKUMAR NAVNITLAL JAYSWAL
C/102, Aaron Elegance, New C. G. Road, Chandkheda,
Ahmedabad382481
54. JAYESHBHAI VANAMALIBHAI PATEL
B-102 Shubh Residency, Near Mangalam Nirvana,
Science City Road, Sola, Ahmedabad 380 060
55. JAYESHKUMAR JAYENDRAKUMAR PUROHIT
Plot No. 41-A, Doctor Society, Pareshnagar, Porbandar
56. JAYPRAKASH VALLABΗΒΗΑΙ CHHATRALA
102, Prizam Appt., Noble Estate -B, Street No. 18,
Zanzarda Road, At Junagadh 362 001
57. JIGNESH KANJIBHAI DODIA
Plot No.-14, Navjivan Society,
Devbaugh, Bhavnagar
58. JIGNESH GOPALDAS RAJPARA
"Aashray", 3 Narayan Nagar, Dhebar Road South,
Rajkot 360 002
59. JITENDRAKUMAR PARAGBHAI PARMAR
3 Maa Gayatrinagar - 2, Behind Setu Health Club,
Bamroli Road, Godhra 389 001
60. KAJAL VIRAL JOSHI
301, Shree Mangalya Appartment, Rudra Tower Lane, Opp.
Chhadawad Police Chowkey,
Ambawadi, Ahmedabad 380 006
61. KAJAL ANKUR SHAH
24, Malbar Hill, behind Blue Berry Hotel, College Road, Nadiad
62. KALIDAS AKHMABHAI BARJOD
Satyam Society, Bamroli Road, Vavdi Buzarg, Godhra 389 001.
63. KALPESHKUMAR KANTILAL PATEL
A-301, Sukun Residency, nr. Sona Cross Road, New C G Road,
Chandkheda, Ahmedabad 383 824
64. KALPESHKUMAR NANJIBHAI JAMBUCHA
2025.07.14
PRATIK VYAS
11:01:07+05'30'
:: 6 :: O.A.No.276/2025
31, Street No-02, Shastrinagar, Bhavnagar 364 003
65. KAMLESH DINKARRAI JOSHI
D-201, Shantiniketan Solitaire, Beside Nikol Police Station,
Nr. Gangotri Circle, Nikol, Ahmedabad 382 350
66. KASAM AYUB SUBHANIYA
Nr. Old Fish Market, Sikka, Dist Jamnagar
67. KAUSHAL DEVANGBHAI SHUKLA
2- Shivam SBI Society, Opp. Convent School,
College Road, Bilimora 396 321
68. KAUSHIKKUMAR DAYARAMBHAI TANDEL
8 Vrundavan Society, Abrama, Dharampur Road, Valsad 396 002
69. KAUSHIKKUMAR KANTILAL TANDEL
1740 Yogeshwar Co.Op.Hsg Society,
Eru Char Ratsan, Navsari 396 450
70. KETANKUMAR CHUNILAL JAMBUDIYA
"Kailash", Ambika Nagar-1, nr. Saibaba Society,
near Bus Station, Junagadh 362 001
71. KIRANKUMAR MAKHJIBHAI BARJOD
6, Chamunda Park, near Deshalbhagat Vav Pase,
Surendranagar Station Road, Surendranagar 363 002
72. KIRITKUMAR KHODABHAI SONARA
B-22, Asmaakm Phase-01, near Torrent Power Sub Station,
near Samang Row Houses, Vejalpur, Ahmedabad 380 051
73. KISHOR MANILAL CHHABHAIYA
Plot No 55, Ghanshyam Nagar, Antarjal, Adipur Kutch 370 205
74. KISHORKUMAR DAULATRAI PATEL
19, Sahkar Society, Gandevi Road, Jamalpore, Navsari 396 445
75. KUNAL ROHITKUMAR SHETH
82/A, Navjivan Society, Station Road,
Mahemdabad 387 130 (KHEDA)
76. M. SHAHAM JAMAL MALLICK
A/502, Sai Golden Residency, near Kotak Mahindra Bank,
Station Road, Ankleshwar
77. MADAN MOHAN SWARNKAR
BSNL Chittorgarh (Rajasthan)
78. MAHENDRAKUMAR MAGANLAL PATEL
At & Po: Palgabhan, Ta: Vansda,
2025.07.14
PRATIK VYAS
11:01:07+05'30'
:: 7 :: O.A.No.276/2025
Dist: Navsari 396 590
79. MAHENDRAKUMAR MANSUKHBHAI JASANI
110, Madhav Avenue,
Jamjodhpur
80. MAHESHKUMAR JASHVANTLAL SONI
Palanpur
81. MAHESHKUMAR CHUNABHAI DABHI
Brahmanvas, Danta, Tal-Danta,
Dist- Banaskantha
82. MAHESHKUMAR BALDEVBHAI BAROT
B-1, Akshatam-1, Akesan Road, Palanpur 385 001
83. MANHAR DHARAMSING VASAVA
Panchayat, Near Sagbara, Bharuch
84. MANISH DAYARAM SOLANKI
Opposite, C. P. Shas Petrol Pump,
Main Road, Nani Daman 369 210
85. MANISHKUMAR MOHANLAL PATEL
14-147/D, Maheshwarkripa, Saikripa Society-4,
Air-Port Road, Nr Mashal Chowk, Nani Daman 396 001
86 MANJUR GOHIL
O/o PGMTD Karelibaug Vadodara
87. MANMOHAN SIKARWAR
C 204 Ambe Green City, Valia Road,
Ankleshwar, Distt Bharuch 392001
88. MANOJKUMAR NAGJIBHAI DESAI
8 Greencity, Patan Highway, Deesa
Banaskantha 385 535
89. MAYUR MANHARLAL RAMJI
Plot 9, Street No 2, Dharmanagar Society, Bholav, Bharuch.
90. MOGHJIBHAI JALAMBHAI CHAUDHARI
Palanpur
91. MOHAMADRAHIM AMINSAB FARUKI
C-202, Luxuria-1 Apartment, behind Imad,
TP-85, opposite Amber Tower, Sarkhej, Ahmedabad, 380 055
92. MOHAMMADALI MOOSAJI QUADRI
Mota Ghanchiwada, Near Fatema Masjid, Dahod 389 151
2025.07.14
PRATIK VYAS
11:01:07+05'30'
:: 8 :: O.A.No.276/2025
93. MUKESH SHIVPRASAD CHORASIA
B-7/9, Swagat Residency, near Motera Gam,
Motera-Koteshwar Road, Ahmedabad
94. MURLIMANOHAR MOHANLAL MUNDRA
182/3 Tirupati Park-2, Dhichada,
Jamnagar 361006
95. NALINKUMAR KANTILAL NAYAK
28, Rajdeep Society, opp: Akshardham Bungalow,
Near Viratnagar, Berna Road, Himatnagar 383 001
96. NARENDRAKUMAR PRABHUDAS PATEL
1-113 Shankar Street, at: Sedla, Taluka: Dasada,
Dist: Surendranagar 382 745
97. NARESHKUMAR GOVINDBHAI BAVISI
Nadiad
98. NAYAN BHUPENDRABHAI TIKARIYA
G-23, 4th Floor, Aakanksha Apartment, Near Sola Bridge,
Ghatlodia, Ahmedabad 380 061
99. NEETESHKUMAR ISHWARBHAI PRAJAPATI
26, Punit Nagar, Near Ramnagar, Ankleshwar
100. NEHA BHAGVATSING PATEL
C-25 Anandvan Society, nr Navyug English Medium School,
New Sama Road, Vadodara 390 024
101. NILESH BABUBHAI KHARCHALIA
Block No. 123, Astha Avenue, Ayodhya Chowk, 150 Ft. Ring Road,
Rajkot 360 006
102. NILESHKUMAR PRAHLADBHAI PRAJAPATI
A-23, Gayatrinagar Society, Mehsana Road, Visnagar 384 315
103. NILESHKUMAR NANDLAL PORIYA
Shivam, Plot No.4/A, Sarkar Society,
Ghogha Road, Bhavnagar 364 001
104. NILESHKUMAR RAMABHAI VASAVA
51, Manas Nagar, B/h. Swaminarayan Temple, Zadeshwar
105. NIMESH PRAVINCHANDRA CHAUHAN
80-Namaldeep, Alxminarayan Society, near P and T Colony,
Surendranagar 363 001
106. NIPUL NALINBHAI KARIYA
Plot No. 35 Mira Park Society,
Near Akhilesh Circle, Bhavnagar
2025.07.14
PRATIK VYAS
11:01:07+05'30'
:: 9 :: O.A.No.276/2025
107. NIRAV HARSHADKUMAR BHATT
16, Shiv Shakti Society, near Aavkar Hall,
Ghodasar, Ahmedabad 380 050
108. PALLAVI CHIRAG KARIA
Jaliyan, SBS Colony,
Veraval (Dist-Gir Somath) 362 265
109. PANKAJ SUBHASHCHANDRA JUNEJA
C2-1102 Godrej Green Glades,
Godrej Garden City, Jagatpur, Ahmedabad
110. PANKAJKUMAR BHOLABHAI PATEL
Vantavas, Vill-Joranang, Ta-Mehsana, Dist-Mehsana
111. PANKAJKUMAR NARANBHAI PRAJAPATI
6-Yogeshwar Society, Part-1,
Behind College, Nagalpur
112. PARESHKUMAR NATVARSINH SANGDOT
490, Dantai Nagar Society, at.po. Kadod, Ta. Bardoli, Dist. Surat,
Gujarat
113. PARSINGBHAI RAYSINGBHAI PARGI
Home No 1. Sampad Raw House near Kirtidham Society,
Vavol, Gandhinagar
114. PRAKASHKUMAR VITTHALBHAI SAVALIA
15, Anand Nagar, nr Khedut Talim Kendra, Chakkargadh Road,
Amreli-365601
115. PRASHANT KUMAR KARDAM
Plot 146, Marwadi Society, Ward 9AG, Bharat Nagar, Po: Gopalpuri
116. PRASHANT RAJNIKANT KHAMBHOJA
D403 Royalhomes, opp. Satyamev Vista, Gota, Ahmedabad 382 481
117. PRASHANTSINH NAVALSINH RATHOD
Plot No 255 Anandji Park1 Fulsar Road, Bhavnagar
118. RAJENDRAKUMAR BHIKHUBHAI DHIMAR
33, Jyotinagar Society, b/h Somnath Temple, Bilimora-396321
119. RAJENDRAKUMAR MOHANLAL HADVANI
B 703, Moti Palace Gold,
Zanzarda Road, Junagadh 362 001
120. RAJESHRI RAJNIKANT RAMANUJ
Gota, Ahmedabad
2025.07.14
PRATIK VYAS
11:01:07+05'30'
:: 10 :: O.A.No.276/2025
121. RAKESH RAMESHBHAI PITHADIYA
A 304, Krantiveer Mangal Pandey Township, near Pushkar Dham,
Vimal Nagar Main Road, Rajkot 360 005
122. RAMESHBHAI SHANKARBHAI PRAJAPATI
J 202 Himalaya Royal Flat, Nagalpur,
opp-Wide Angle Theater, Mehsana 384 002
123. RASMITA KINNAR SHAH
B 304 Shukan Status, nr Vande Mataram Cross Road,
Gota, Ahmedabad 382 481
124. RAVI RANJAN KUMAR SRIVASTVA
Flat No. 502, Freesia Building, Tropical Greens,
Kamli Faliya, Nr Ayyappa Temple, Silvassa,
Dadra and Nagar Haveli 396 230
125. RAVINDRAKUMAR FAKHIRBHAI CHAUDHARI
Madhav Society, Ukai Road, Vankvel, Songadh,
District: Tapi, Pin: 394670
126. RINAROY GULABBHAI PATEL
43-Vivanta Raw House, Chhapara Road, Navsari-396445
127. RITA NITESHKUMAR JADAV
D-301, Satva Appartment, opp. Shantivan Society,
Paldi, Ahmedabad
128. RITESH DEVAYATBHAI AHIR
G-102, Shaligram Flora, nr. Sangini Bunglow,
Thaltej Ahmedabad 380 059
129. RITESH BHARATKUMAR THAKKAR
65 Nandvilla Bunglows, Tulsi Cottage,
Bhavagar
130. RUPALBEN SHAILENDRAKUMAR PRAJAPATI
A-37, Shubhlaxmi Bunglows, nr. Unnati Vidhyalay,
Zadeshwar, Bharuch 392 011
131. SAMIR NATVARLAL PATEL
A-204, Milan Appartment, Ramdevnagar,
Satellite, Ahmedabad 380 015
132. SANJAY RAJNIKANT SHAH
Godhra
133. SANJAY THAKORBHAI PATEL
Navsari
134. SANJAYKUMAR SUMANTRAY CHAUDHARI
2025.07.14
PRATIK VYAS
11:01:07+05'30'
:: 11 :: O.A.No.276/2025
C401 Pramukh Abode, Sargasan, Gandhinagar 382 006
135. SANJAYKUMAR JAIKUMAR JAIN BSNL
Chittorgarh Rajasthan
136. SATISH GOBINDRAM JETHANI
Room No. 210, 2nd Floor, JTO Transmission Room, Lal Tekri
Telephone Exchg. Bldg., Bhuj 370 001
137. SATISHKUMAR SHANKARLAL PATEL
10/Rushikeshnagar Society, TB Road, Near Ruturaj Flat, Mehsana
384 002
138. SHAKIL AHMED ABBASI
54 Shan E Mohammadi Society, Sukhbag Road,
Palanpur 385 001
139. SHIRISHCHANDRA ARVINDLAL RANA
B-61, Alekh Society, nr. Chamunda Mataji Temple,
Zadeshwar, Bharuch 392 011
140. SUDHIR HASMUKHRAY ADESARA
18, Akshar Bunglows, Chakkargadh Road, Kanani Ni Wadi, Amreli
365 601
141. SUNIL CHANDULAL RAITHATHA
A 501 Pooja Avenue Apartment IV, 11/2 Patel Colony,
Jamnagar 361 008
142. SUNITABEN MAHENDRAKUMAR PATEL
Pelad Faliya, Palgabhan, Ta.
Vansda, Dist.Navsari 396 590
143. SURESHKUMAR SOMALAL DARJI
B 77 Shiv Darshan Residency, Kansa N.A at Visnagar, District -
Mehsana
144. TARUN KHUBCHANDBHAI KHANCHANDANI
20-B Shreyash Society West, corner of Street No 7, Main Road, nr.
Mahakaleshwar Temple, Airport Area, Rajkot
145. TARUNKUMAR AMBELAL CHAUDHARI
Jesingpur, Navapada Faliya, Ta. Vyara,
Dist Tapi 394 633
146. TEJAS ARVINDBHAI MARFATIA
32-37/7, Vrundavan Bunglows, Diva Road, Ankleshwar 393 001
147. TUSHAR KANTILAL PARMAR
104-Aastha Homes, 150 Feet Ring Road, Bhavnagar
2025.07.14
PRATIK VYAS
11:01:07+05'30'
:: 12 :: O.A.No.276/2025
148. UMESHKUMAR AMARSHIBHAI PATADIYA
893, Kailash Nagar, b/h S.T. Workshop, Bhuj-Kachchh 370 001
149. UMESHKUMAR BABUBHAI MISTRY
7, Amrapali Society, Link Road, Bharuch
150. VIBHUTI BEN NILESH KUMAR PATEL
A/28A Vatsalya Shubham Park Soc, Chhapra Road, Navsari 396 445
151. VIPUL BHIKHABHAI VADHER
D/103 Harivilla Appartment, opp Kargil Petrol Pump, Sola,
Ahmedabad
152. VIRAL AMRUTLAL BHAVSAR
Plot 8/B "Bhavi" Adarsh Dairy, Jail Road,
Behind Adarsh Complex,
Bhavnagar 364 001
153. VIRAL NARENDRABHAI DOSHI
7-Vaniyawadi, "Arihant", behind Bhakti Nagar Circle,
Rajkot 360 002
154. VIRENDRAKUMAR MAGANLAL PATEL
At & Post: Atgam, Joting Talav, Taluka & Dist: Valsad
155. YAGNESH RAMUBHAI LAD
28, Sumitra Park, near Civil Hospital, Nanakwada, Valsad 396 001
156. YAGNESHKUMAR BABUBHAI MISTRY
44, Nevilpark Society, behind Gayatri Mandir,
Udhna Magdalla Road, Althan, Surat 395 017
157. YAGNESHKUMAR KANUBHAI PATEL
Ahmedabad
158. YOGESH BUHECHA
201, Suparshwanath Apartment, 3, Mombasa Avenue Park,
150' Ring Road, Rajkot 360 005
159. YOGESHCHANDRA PARESHBHAI CHAUDHARI
At & Po- Moritaha, Tal - Mandvi, District - Surat
......................... Applicant.
(By Advocate - Mr. Samrat Upadhyay)
VERSUS
1. Department of Telecommunications,
Government of India
Notice may please be served through
The Chairman DCC & Secretary(T)
Department of Telecommunications
2025.07.14
PRATIK VYAS
11:01:07+05'30'
:: 13 :: O.A.No.276/2025
Ministry of Communications 'Sanchar Bhawan',
20, Ashoka Road, New Delhi 110001
2. Department of Pension and Pensioners' Welfare,
Government of India
Notice may please be served through
The Secretary, Department of Pension & Pensioners' Welfare,
"A" Wing, 3rd Floor, Loknayak Bhawan,
Khan Market, New Delhi - 110001
3. Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited
Notice may please be served through
The Chairman & Managing Director, Bharat Sanchar Bhavan,
Harish Chandra Mathur Lane, Janpath, New Delhi-110 001
4. Gujarat Telecom Circle,
Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited
Notice may please be served through
The Chief General Manager, Telephone Bhavan,
7th Floor, Navrangpura, Ahmedabad - 380 006
....................... Respondents.
O R D E R (ORAL)
Per : Hon'ble Shri Jayesh V. Bhairavia, Member (Judicial)
1. Mr. Samarth Upadhyay, learned counsel for the applicant(s) present in Court room.
2. Considering the facts and grounds as stated in M.A.256/2025 (Joint Application), the same is allowed.
3. It is a grievance of the applicant(s) that they are not granted the benefits under Rule 37A of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 and they are also not extended the benefit of the memorandum dated 03.03.2023 (Annexure A/1) issued by Department of Pension and Pensioners Welfare and in this regard they have submitted their respective representations on 15.07.2024 which are not yet considered/answered by the respondents. Hence, this OA.
4. Learned counsel for the applicant after arguing for some time submitted that the applicant(s) will be satisfied if appropriate direction is issued upon the respondents for consideration of their respective pending representation.
2025.07.14 PRATIK VYAS 11:01:07+05'30' :: 14 :: O.A.No.276/2025
5. Heard learned counsel for the applicant(s) and perused the material available on record.
6. Without going into merit of the claim of the applicant(s) herein, we deem it appropriate to dispose off this OA at admission stage with direction upon the respondents, that the representation of the applicant(s) shall be considered and decided in accordance with the extant rules, policy in vogue and service record of the applicant(s) within 90 days from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this order and any decision thereon be intimated to the applicant(s) through permissible mode. It is made clear that we have not expressed any opinion on the claim of the applicant.
7. In view of the above, the OA stands disposed off at admission stage.
No order as to costs.
(Dr.Hukum Singh Meena) (Jayesh V Bhairavia)
Member (A) Member (J)
/pv/
2025.07.14
PRATIK VYAS
11:01:07+05'30'