Karnataka High Court
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd., vs D. Hajarabi W/O Late Mehaboob Basha, on 18 April, 2012
Author: Subhash B.Adi
Bench: Subhash B.Adi
ms mg SESH £fi§JRT §F :--<A§3@;€A:<§ CERCQE? E§E{2§C§'~i A? gwsawga gmga 'WIS "ms :8?" my 8? Asggg 23:2,~~ j"-«.. *-- ggmag >V % THE §~iG§\§'BLE §v?R.}US?ECE sf;L;%5;5:;a§s;5:%'5;=$;::;A3 « M.?.AgNag2G93G '2é':=;: ;'§*'E:i:' ' A %V M M.F§A.CRGB,8'1§!2G:v.iV .
:v:.Em:e.2a93a 23:: W) 8E'%'WEE?§ SHRIRAM GEN, ENS. ;€i'_§.L'§'§,..--!--. _ ' E=»8,, Ema REECG; SE"%"§?»%._,ER; I garpzspw RA3A$m=s»3@i2»§:2., REPRESE§\§"E"ED €83!" ':frs'~--.::,-:si§"H@;§.:_ZE§ §§é?ii;1,?fiR¥', V J 4 V' ' Z ,g,A??ELiAi\§T ($2! gag ; :*:§;§g;s:.a:x: V ;t ..;:;:»§; ,5 §x?'~§§ ;, @;;§%:?&.3g:§?<&g§:";:2?§Gi;' aAé'§,:'«§EaA§Qag gégagg M ~ 2;: §;"E;5;,R§'g fig'-53;' %AR%¥I§<.fiig ' T§Q:§<'iiiTA.?£}L;5.L_§1; 333?: EELLAEK
--. -§v2.%§xg§.£;*.§.§A :§3;§~;§;:~%:v;:§;«*A ?»%A'§'%§E%i§§i:ERiE; * ,&;:3'E: :25 .'%5a;&R$,. 9$£:@RE:zEa. :::,g%@. :<.:§:Aj%gé§A§<§P@A viaggggg ma a'g§x;A@a;f QE$'§": H;&fi:'ERE§ " *Eré_ZS§'§?§R§3 $532 C§*='i:§§'a§§'~éA§A§A??A E~'§i§iéS.§§,;
- _ x ESE: VSAQGR; §CC:B§§§§'*§ES$; §l;fG« §~%Gi3SE §\§&3S8, §{s3.§A§<Q%.; EFELLQEQE, ?Q:Sé:'¢'§§'%%§®R; EiST:%"§A's:"ER§, ' RE$§G?€§E?f5§ 3?; :%v%;a§:a;§a;§a§;a,?:«§ Ea ?;%?1:§fia.SKfz gag E: & Rfis; SR1 :Sa%3,§<§§£@;§:%<;&3'"?E,, QSEEIZ ?§;§; R3} EN.) MFA F§LE§ {:55 133(1) 3? W AC2: gasgxxgxss'? mg 3L§§f3%»'§E?«§"§ A533 é:ar'%.%;fiR3 Q'?.22,i'$9,!2G§§ @5353 :52: §vL\£sC;F'%$',88?f23§§ mg?
"§"%-EE ms 3% T§~%E Cm: iggggggaagaag am ?vEE§v§BE§,; :I::§~s:;2c"§; KUQLESI; éWéR§§NG THE CQ§¥§PE§'€$,§§"EG?% Q? R§a§;885§§i:§,fjf"1*'§!I':?§"§ EEéTEREET AT 'EHE RATE G? 8% 93, mam 'mg QKEE z3¥~j§>§:'::*:«Q;x; °§'E§_L 953953;: T' 5 » e'V'LF&A.CRCB'8§.6'2@11 BETWEEN
i).§~§A3ARABI w;Q,;_ATE MAHASQOB BASHA;
AGE: 24 YEARS, Qc:c:HQuSE wxm * R/Q. $AN;3Cv'1§<AL 'KEELLAGEE :<z,E3:.:s:"'€Q*~. §EL§_.AR":" ms:
* j CR8E§S§ElEC'E"Q§% {BY SR::MA§é}:§Es§AT%é fig, §;af:';;_'A5=s,5fi";:"
Ezgffi :2 §AsA:;AE:A:"'C.\. %:.:.:;A:sA_Ri' Sm cHAmNg;E.;xsAr>;>A '_ * MA.:;:R.,§w.;x:ER~:§;;E_ "ME ' LQRRY BEARENG ;¥":~'gEG.;B'.'?s5Cx _ KA~2.?,/A-<;Q??;.""-..A' ' -
RIG. %:%QijSE risgiggjssg' ';<gJ';@§~--.-:3: viamigg, $§3£A§\§i§R mg §=:ms':§§<: 33% g 23312" Ev§§,E*\§33§€3EEi%.,; " "
._:§i;§e:Esg:*s; gEs駧;;a;..::.§;«5::§;A?~scE §@.;:§§;§, 3%: {TS §%_&;f:;$ fimagf 5-sf REECG §§'駣jS§"R§§,:
' . ;;:9.\§s:>.., ;5:fm_§'L%;R§, 3§E?£§R; V 33 '-.::%aj:§%:%t;1';?;'Lj?:£E{§g%;:%«% xs:s;@§:m"§§»s::@:< e%%§Hé§%%:'*°fiE§ ;%f$§:_.§?_"€fEAR§5 asa. E.£§¥?§*~«ié!? Qsfififig ; EESEQE ?7%QL§;*E.?i§ 3-éES%§ gggsaaa, §E§.§:..g§;¥:Y Ram? %§@S?E"%: §§LLAR?2 " RE§?Q2'1§§§?%§E"S .'1{§%"Vé59;§;"':maaafiag ,§.%<§;:.a';:s%,L $232: FQR gag; §'~'E§finCR{3§ ES FILES i§§'2§§ER $R§§§_ £1 RSLE 22 Q? C235; i§§$; FELEQ fixgfiiikffi"? '%"E~%E ;§U§§§'*€E§'%§T §32§'>é§ §§CREE §§%TE§:22§§§j2§E§ §§§$SE§ 3% §?E'\;5§,?€S«8S?f2G$§ G3: "E"??? ELE GE? TEE CEEFEL EEJDQE {SR,S§'€.:; CU:'¥'E ¥'*v*'EE§\"§EER; §\i%C"§".f*~3§I'=,i§,§<L}§§i£GL %3£E,Ti.'¥' fi'%i.i.QWEf\E§ THE CLQEFVE ?ETI"}"EQ§'~»i §Q?< f§$§¥'§?§¥'~§S;%T§§?xé gfiéifi SEE§--<Ef\§§ ENHQFQCEEQENT SF CQ?'~='??E%"~éS.fix"%"ESi"\§5 T%§ES ?V3F!% fisfixifi §'~'iFé;€RQ$ §Q§V§I%'€§ SEE FGR i"'§E;§$R§f'%é,j{G:'»~;€T§£€é_V\E.«§a,, "PRES §§£'f,, THE CGEERT §Ei_lVEREE THE [email protected]§WE%'~éG: ' ' 3 L5 B G M E 32% 'T There is a éeiay sf 3.'? days :§n?"'f'E*E--%.r'2g 5:3 V sbjegfisns are fiéed. Cause shsséfgg aci:e?;_:¥ie:dv3 «. "
candaned, 2g épgeaf ig by thVe'; _._i§*s;:;--%%e¥r "$v§abi%§€:y ag weié as quantum af_ judgment am award gm Man<;;:§e;s;A;'~sé?,'2E:«0f3il:i§:§g;i%%:¥:k;§«;é§1e $5': the fife sf M.A;C;?5 fiigeéking enhancement cf cemp€fis::%t%G;L_
3. §'\"iF;5§'C§'a:§V§" _Qfi§Vé£t--%'éfi $3 by me siéimgnt gaekéng '¢3;r:*{:%1aa._§Té:;r:":;?.*;_§:2*:;: $5 £sA%%s§.f;e.§fé§;aEi@fi, I awgrfigfi €%§'?'¥;Q§§"iS§§f§Q§"% 9? Rg,§;88;§§§;'~ :5».s§§%'*: §;i'i:%e:e.ss':';:::7§*$s§:'é§ iésa 1:163:31 sf ?§%.,1S§§§"%§ sf ihg siaimaizté . §5';*~«_.§'a§§ flaw: 3 €%:T£%"Ei€§'§'C§Q%'? is aaigeé $2; as iagagrey §:§"'§§i '-.___%:f:e ééyéver 3% *:he 8%':§%§"Eé§f3§ veééécée étafi rm Eégssgs :8 fisive Wgfagsspari 'if€Ed:;§~:§$!g Em 935$ Q5335 iécawgg E3 firive neg':-::a?:§§$§*i wxégzz"
§:'i;r'£$ see' ee4ex,:e"' she eefeeeeseee ' ' V .. _V . §Teie':e'sé, ee§sieEe, eeweeer; eieéresee sew sebmiss shes see €_Ir§s!er Ease the Eiseeee te erixxe trensees: V%hEflE§§ es seeeg, eeese is es v%e%s':%Ge ef the eereeit eisee Eves eiheneise, if ?:§2e§<e_:'Es7se'§g £3 véefetéee, 2: Es eiweys sees ie tee éeseser te_.-3'{eCe'§%e-r..T eeeseeesetiee frees the ewner, é. Eesefer es eresswebjeeiiee is :eréCernedgiA:?s'ev e:ee'eesee--.. was running e meehenicaé seep e"es;df""i:.he ec<:§;5_ee%:".§s if see year 20%. The eestmertere.§fe~;g_ert_."s%i'e§ss.' %:§*:ee'eeAeesed was 25 years as see time ef aee%d'ee?:;'"ecfvIs'..sEs.§%;:~V'.gfierresperzéfrig ihe age ef the e;Efe~;"es_§:'e zsiesg' es see time sf aecédenia .'fsas":.§eef2e a mistake is seeing 'E4' mu§:f'psi§e:*;'eA Rs5,§G€};'~ eer meets; eieéseeet V V V % ' 'eesézéeej'jj}'e%~..§;ss.Z;,EQ;§QGf~ {Rs.3;333!»><§2s18} ':es:e;res_§ess e'f V_eeee-ee'eeVe%;* e %se§@§§§%f~ sexeeses éess es efieesiseei §ess"e? eeeseseere see feeerei exeeesesg §§?%eVe_ee;'T;;.'e§eEesee: Es eeiéiiiee fee eemeeesesiee e? V §s.?;?'§,eG--§f%'es egeéess §~"isg§§%&.§§S;'=r see Rs.82;§$S;'» ever 5"?
ssseseee es: see Ekieeeei sets 5 5% § W-E %;'§ 's E 9,, x» 8; Fa" m@§§f§€§tE:§r'2 sf téze sfiireciim éssueé by the Tr§§::;::a% 53 regarfi is :he &§§erE%em:e::: sf C$§'fE§§fi$§i§§§§; Eimrty is géxsrz ifi 32% ciaémani :23 mave 3:": a§@%§¢a€§_§2.:"*:_:'-::4é€?§s*€ the Téifiunai Acsordingiyg M5.A§Crgob,Ne5§i'5/23::_ f§§é':!l>4._V§évy":V":i:;ié:
ciaémani: is pariiy aéiaweéi M..FA.NS.Z3913-§;f2§1:_"_~A§S d%::r%i§,§.:§§eVdfi'.'--..L Amauré: $5} degssii as i;"asi§fg:*:"$_§T--t_§ ihé T¥"_'§§§U?'§{;f%§; ETEJE wmmw wk & s a.I'"*3".§ ' ;
"E, A,