Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Venkateshappa vs Govindamma on 29 May, 2012

Author: Ram Mohan Reddy

Bench: Ram Mohan Reddy

3%' ':32 3&5: Qmgm' QE' fiTA§% £3' §§§€§;%§,»s§§E §g'rE§ @3513 'rag gm: 3;? Q?' Esiéifi'. 2@:2 *.

EEFQRE EEE H0N'gLE §siR,5'£§S'£'ICE R&%'I :i{e;I%:A§'~-..§REff};i3:§fj&f" J' REGIELAR $339253 AP?E&: §€é.':;1:3>é;*?*¥ %:;:§ '2£3:il§F' BETWEEKE 2; View§<p;:';£.35:Ai>:3sL S59 azi:§N:'3\a?;mA:>r>;x.;__ E:{}Ef§ AS9231' $5 Y§:'A;%§S;._

2. :y:a;?=§:§::aP9;x§ '- _ .

BEZCEEASEJD BY§*§E$ :,;?s';' -- "

1%? ML%Ni¥FE§?§§$'E5§{§§Rfikéfif' _ 1 ;%si}f€§} V' 'E518i.£§;'§'Ei¥**?f§,?'?§§?;€'f%.E'§'.§;;' _ '-- ~ 23% gage ;:.:3.<3%§§ 3: '*::'*'::.;z;§w:.:$'.,J'J*--- ' 519%} 1532:. A, EEN£'*2'zl§i'§§};y. ' AL; A;..%§'%f:~&t. :§;%&:3§-::::r~:Cg 25:' :--ia.;j§m:§:_L;<:0j:'§: %v::;i,;;-égizgi.
' " @332;
' :'+§gi;:;,sj22.,i:::'z:;':;:§§9----.
A L' 1- gaa-:g::<:-V53': ~ ;%;§:: 2 :;<1 M. ;:?:3E;;L;::-§?$ $3':-$7..$3.:'§;:;,:ig;--:'::z:g; ;*:E--E?ar'§§i§}, .;a:'::é:2;%%~';x;:s1:13gs§:%¢::wg:.
V. ;%fC':i§§} AE3€:3U'? 55 ':'Eiz%f§?;S, __§f:»';{::: ifiJ§'§%: §::*1:;§<s;;*'%2<:p;raza§ Q, R§iS§§}§N{} 3"¥i" EHM §:3;"*1{: ELV'E§%i'v'1iz%VT'§,5i§ £21333 '\fii,LE%.{}§3, %iGi&§¥€ Effigiifiii §'§@§,,£%§€ i}§S'§'§€EC"§' ~» f§{i=3 E GE. §iE§$?Qi**§§'§§N5f", {EEY 3E5 S=®E\éI§'1SV§['i§iV§€:lE3i E<:g%.SE--TiE}aE;§'§"}E, .!'--'«i}'i"'g {E I V ':':--::s REA :3 3:11:32; UN;:}:a:R s:;C'§:<::x?_,'_:'@§':§r? 4<;ii>"C*;,.. £:Gg%E§\47S? ?§-as JUE}GE\:'iE£?€'§' ;a:x;':3_' i::E:c::E?;» ":::;:i:*£::} E'F.1i.2§®'§% EEASSEEED EN EEA. G2/22305 ;03a:«.,'3;*:e:E:F;::,£:.;:*>:~*'*:j:e:§5:
PR§<2$§§h'\3G oF¥§€;s:R, ¥'F€~E, ;<::;§:£;,.;I12J,A~ '3:s3M§:3f$§§«:J:::"--~i§':::E: ;r:??;«:;g; €T:GNE'§REiflE"£G *rH&:;. Ju:>'@M§:3s'§ @432" aE€:R£::§:' :>;;:':+::> 533 :2,2a<34 :>;;ss£;:3'::'\%--~.§,;S, 12;-:m9§s;._ O§\;:'*§?§.E"E':LE;V GE' ma: ;§;>:>:b c:'x;§L JEEEGEZ, "gs:-s;%,.;i>:\3§3$ 'FEES I/§§E3§}E;:2'i1.£¢ <jj<:s;§:ix3§*gEQ};'<:'}§§E2:Am§:s;é:@x 'm:s mgy, Tag <:@Ta;§2*:' 1::E:;:*:?§:;2:§:;:§Aj?"m2:;j% §;;;;:,Qaaz':N{;: "

3' hi§..;i's 1"§;3£E';§.E:;.?3f$5';-:':§§.{ff}§E{§; agjggagez/3} Caliing' E12 €§i€S"'f§G§}. f:h::+i »§L1v'i3é§§"€?f:"é€:}E1 "at¥§2{:_rs€"{3f7»--é,'§1e {?%U;ET,S beigw §}Ei§'§§}' {§€{%§§:é'§.;':g fiiifi _ ' 4;'2.}..§a;::§3€%'T§§::}§:%;'s i:§.::§'€i"5:§1;s:3<;': §\§<>x--'i9g'8E%% §£'i€'ff€:%'§"é': Ehii' i'i2:§{%§ii:%';3A;z§.ifiyii Eazégs {SE1 33:25} 3': Eigiaz far {3} 'E0 <§€{:Ea:*:i % %:"éf?.§* a :3? 553$? §>:*::§{%:§*é:§::-':$; {Q E3255: %;'::::-3 E"{Ef.;.>;§i4js§€;?E'§?E{§ SA/'§§ {§iZ%€E:?C§ 'i:%%¢i:%i§, E " {:%:::;%<j§:§és%éiE; ?bj»;' Eéyiihzzrzimzz 31:: §av::}:.::* ééés {§€§§%§§€§é%?i§, £3 :fe:}§£:i <Z7{}§E{?:i:'é{,'ET{if€§ zfisaé 229$: §"}§£'§{;§§§E§ 3:: 'iiéaé ;§f:§a%f{é;§f'§é;:

«gm W. xx {C} €_§%Z;?{1'i§;'«;%§'é? §§":éi> ::>§'{;§<>:/*5; §::;;;z5;é+;:%z::1 E2}; '«i1'i:<i:% §si7f'§i)E,E¥:l}7 iatahaiigizzz in <ff€i,SE% §*~é@.RR'§ §}§.<:e; 2fE§5»E3?' ai.sm:%a:i E8.§,%3E%7 V é>§{E€:%:* éisgsiiééé €fr2;02.§§3'§}§j% sf %:E:<% f'as;8§8?:;2::1*i {Z_a;§1%:'ré§_8§i_:;:}L:é':'M_ iz': RA. E\EG.22Gf €361}? :23 126;: bigggiingg §§Eé:§::::§§é:"~ zmé id} {Gr pe:*man€r:ii §I1'}fi,§.{;Z€Ci){::'§{}17i."V :'€:=:_sE;;'2i:'Vi:r:'i"fi;§i;;i__' éiefééfidzzné, {mm §::é;:€::'§%_?:*§::.gésxfiih 33%airzéiffsv.i§gc».:"sVss%sSi{}::. ' {sf fizs 331%? ${3h€fiL§€'t g3:"G§::_é§:j:,;:'~._bs§::§«£3} Eand I'1"}.€8$L§§i§E§.§ Z a~:::"c-fig :Z":¥ §;§'L'§*3"E7§;3;VS: §§;Li $§i*NG.E4f2: {b} £33? Eand; §2€as:::i:;'gs;,_;% a:::9éS'§'§~E- §j::"Sy.N$,§28f2; {CE 3%/"€35, Eané 3.-3r':':€'fé;;<§:jA:~-:7 --v..:3.t3s'--«§,:: ,f},z£\E0§ 388; and id} Wei Eand .§:";V::ta%€g{1':f§:r1g§§*iI::3.~'?} ';j;fi:':.":i228'vf§}?.E\§9.M§ fé Siiiuatieé 31', §§i1'§2:i:€» 3ji7€}§!§,€' habéié, Eviahzr Eaiiséi, §€E3§3£i>fi{§€}~"3.fiZ %%{;:§*:::iré~.Vaa>'é:%}:3 a:':fa§g§:s::<§ as zésférséiafié, zm t::<f;é,{::°e:%:;§'€;::g:}€:gr2::':€€s zzati E"{?Si§f5i€?§1 ihi? 312%: $3}; 3%/.22'§e::r:s<:::€', Era?/<%::" EEELEE éanjgingg é/ha 21'A§}_<%;§;:V§:§.<}§:é--_. 3:5/1%: g:a§m§§;éiV§:2g;:j iZ%":€: :"%:%E35:i::}z23%:i§; '§<%§av€%<':é:: me §32§E?;§é:%.f-§__f3~ fi§'飧f{, ééze ;}§.8;§n%;if§3' izihfii" Z€E8§}f1€ " '?:§,:/Lgégiswvek/ma;§3f;2:?z z:i§':s:E Vf':::%;h%3:"
___$§§§j+::5:§;:§;:: axraériét '§3:"<;'§;§:a%:*:;5 wiaéké iiiéfiifiit'/'E':,»:'§;€i?{§_ Efigiiiéizamzéégfl, 225 ;' 333;' §§<;;i;§%1<?::' of é'/he €§;€?f€?'i{E{§EE£1"i§, ;'%<t{:0:*&}i:3g is 'aha ::i<%§<%::&2:::%f:¢ €336: S§§.,Ii'§ ss:it%as:s:§2.:Ei%~ pra*§<é:rEé::%s';* bséészgg ;2v;i€c_;é7s:§ra§ a>v€§*e: §{>i:§é: iémiiy §,}§'{E§)€'éE"{é€E%; §ar*{E%i§{:::€+s:§ _ E§f1e§;imé% sf G§rij;a;3;>a am} M;:::§sV33?a:¥2a;.§}a;' ::3Li:e"

rzsrthizrn hzzfi' p<}:'§§<:=z1 {Q}? £10 €h<?:'~_Shf3.'i"$':VOf'»§}§?§%§?£i§§§VEi..'€ii£.i{i {ha SGE3*{h€;f';fE half is} ?»€:1r:%si€s:2a:;1ap§§'3. aacé é§fe:€sé:3.<:Ve-~1haVv§;. ' 33861": Er: pééasisfui pe__ss€:ssis__:: a::'é,_v €:1§e}f::';$::3'f7 of iheér 1"€Spf3iZE§i'v'€ paréiszsg ef'*:h<: g':e_:*<is;-;,b%V5r'é'§;*;:% ..'§}e§e::a'a:3{*s father bi? game Giféffaég a:'i§'V'siéi.:§'"§ :>--_hairs. '53ie@§ Vx7h€'§'€3.fiZ€§ By€%:amm-ag 2§j%Ci@:é;.___V::«:';:1::in{:ed':0 b6 :1": §©SS€SSi3§':

anfi €.3<':g§€:e§?::{é,'s:§1*:2:~1i§r:::%.:mr%i%:'€:vr1:v":ha§f gsriéezz Cs? éihs Sufi pr0p€§€§e'i5' a1:{iV&'§,n:;afi§T;§;'Vi:.§:é* }i'§€:§:';:2€ execaéeé 3 :5;-ii d3:€@1 $8.3, E§9§"~§:5e{§:§a;3.€E:é_f:§.--"éhét narihern 73:31:? poréien Q? {:16 §2;§?:"~s:;Ei:€<§._a:E€ gags-$2"t§es in {gm-'{2:::* 0? figs Cieileneiiaréé, pa . ~ A .j. Ez: 11333:: ':*€::":§§€ e::2f §€:adi%:€%'$ 95 V aréifia 3&6 iiégi atszégzii E-?%:i:;::*:'gé<i egg §}7"§af§}7 2:5; 9 $331233 :»%£":€§€afi€§£:saf§%§ ihfi W " if géginfiiff aaagieg €:§§::::":3in€::i 22$ P'\?%?j§ 323$ aneéhsr 'vg":;'s::€/£23 §V~§.2 ragéisié mgaréiad EZ};s5.?,§ E0 azssii {'f§E7?§%?E"§{§2%fEE§, wzzsg §'.X2*iEE}§§'%€7f{'§ 22,53 §}§f\fZE :>t:§§{% fiszzrr {;:E%:»2*:r w%§;n::%<s§8e%$ sag if}Ws.:"/E ii; ::E%E{§ §1':a:'%:€:d. :<>E}5E%;3;._V 4, "§"%:s zirizizé q:::;>m*t havinggj §a%§3;:*<i is é%3&%«.;}:'é€ég::§iV§:g§r:5 .< j{ "
'f,h§*f ;3a*z1'*ties§ ':',':1{~: ;r::2:i::€:*§aE an :tl<%:{€ai>:*:i« gag-xi .;§E1Vé <:::i'xi£i:}C;?: bath era} azzii {§£}{Z{lT§1€I1*§3i'j;' an;9;w:%f{é{§ §SSL.i:;f_lfS §'=§G,2*:{};='5§;-.. 7 am} 8 in thfs ::€:gaViAia%5"'~ugéféiéls iS3:_:§:T ;'§@'§vif§ in iihe ,.s.
afiirmaiixni ané §sg:1<:S"§>§@, E', a_:m.;3 .9 §€f €333} Gfdéf.
5. The tgfiai <:<3§;:é€E"2:§; Qb$€§%?€{i that 'ihs ;;3Ea§§3§:§;fié"'«._fé:3%E*:--;=:§* "E":f5I:"--i.'€"«'§§'§1:¥1iSWB;¥¥}8;:§§3a ané $238 §e§€=én:3;;::1€.'i:'g";.faféifizr r:3i':<:€;--v":Giré.}i*ap§a avers biofié b:*at§:$:s"?3»:*é::_§;§'~é£;:;S_§§ é::j1§ §§€:::r§1§aa Whfis 8};i:ham:::":a. Wag 1,éf"§i§;m*2s{{}§".'_ E3~fsé'<3:4:§r§§;a'pg};: Ea Wiéam '(E16 d€f'€nda;ai xa?;;ii§' ;_--.§;%(;%3T§ ;§'§v§%:: ii": marriage is 022% _ §'?§fi'§€§§;<?;if;E§E:.§.f§f?i§}§.32}. £5 E}imbaQ%::5:_manah21§?.§. 'fiheugh €323 §;;\A§:«:.1ff§:,:iivf1f%~§ :--*;.;;2{ii:f"@:'ih 22 gfiééa %_ih,:«35?{, 833$? S{'EE€{§}El§€ §}§G§;*sé:f§%é=>:$ :¥§%:*<% {E63 $6? a::':§;:fi;:"§:s:§ §2§{}}3€3§7'{E€S 9? ihsiy " E35:L§EE§8?§.?E3,ffEE2Ea}§}E§, gmié iéézzzi; SE16 §3:*r:';p£2é:**%:§g--7a$ vazazfe ._ .3?é1$3'éA;g'g:;{;j<3é €23 {';%§:ss'7§:§E:'§,:;?£:§; E;%2i:::§»<: 2:3:5'E'€E«;g%.E §i:s;:* 3; §s:>:.>:;;@ 9? {a ?§§%i:}§€:>,:"'~ {'.R';A:;;3<%::%é5 E';Z§'1ii:J 'E"%:s;:aV:§21:":<V£ {B3155} w?:i<:h W225 :20? :%§$<:%13:V:*g<%::E a::: f: 3,32%? {izaifi 0? {:2}? :~;;:.:ié:, §"i€3ir'{%fi)E:€?i£?S8V ji:'§:.s:{"E"_:°i3,E Cgzzéi @bé--;;a=::'x?<%:i than': E3. E9? E :2: itmgsa 8/:><;ami:;.:%%i§{3§_'§":;:%.is'§%e/2%?A _. __ _ ,2? , €1,€§1'}'i§§§L€3£§ 'éfizif §:"1éf'i"€ "=3%'€}:'€ H0 <i:>{::;;f:i€:::%:As_*r@=:i§'"::7:%;E;§s'E: 51:16 * g3L:1"e:f:%1as=€: sf féifi %mm0xfab},<:>: §)':j(;p§3:-::**:,.€-Es f_?€:={:é' S:{i?%:;{:§.§_a SE:2:$é:/ri azzzi 833% E\EaV:*a1§;2::3.::Tg_>;;:';;, v;3§é;::;, sf 'é3f:Ev«-§:§va§::ii§§s..L' that {E6 suii Scézéésigie g<é.§ai:*€& p§*@p&:r%:ies GE" '7{h{%?E§:" -zxsézgj Tia iiriai CGUFE Ci€{':h§?}€d '(G the RR exiracfg Qf éhe Swwziiféi' '§'§*Vi:'?'€:V¥VEV"Cii'f"i{£;},f the name Czf £5328 the <}v.m€r as 3339 e1£:q::éVvé;§_§i§:'_a v_2'_':': $§:,E"§0. E53»/2 $32 'J%'3§Z sf sgie: p::rc§3.21s€:%"--«.V{>i§v §f;:i§:?, $=;?§1€{§z:§=:é V :'\%C:,3 £925: 539 E{a:;§§a§§3aaE;E<:M_i §5::*}é§é"§1E*'§§~§}'§EE"{EhaSé3 «:2? $213? gaéizedzzie E:/em §%E<3s~'§ _ §':*:éf:2_i%;§%§%iZ§Vi§_§:'§%;§a§s: am}; §3u:'::*é3as<~: {:5 Sziiéi 8C§}€£§'{;§§€ éiem §r{*u:'n; éj_;:§€%: §'€:5:§ay§:%::3§3g33,, 33?: iihéf 2:E;2§e§3::{t§é 23? me 32:33 {E2::§':s:;§;<§_ V*éa.?'§";é%:*<:2¢:§:{%%z* ':§V%:{~: p§:;=§:3<%fi:%s%5:; '*f=I§§°§E'i ggiié is $363 2;E_§;_<i§%;§:afi}; :":£i2:'::fe}?{~%<{éi Egg; Eh:-E ¥'z:%T~/:<:{§s:§:";~:~; in §i':VQ€i§' 3? -3?/h<>;r {>5 V_é;§:::i% §3i;1%:%:%;;§ff§, 2:: §:':2zV§/{tar 53%' §aé:§:V $326 %i,E"i£§ éiéiifi E 3 NJ €}3QE§€fE"V€id éihazéi ii); €X.§ii § :'"§§'? v'<7::'*:<E<:«:" 2:3? §§if:??E1 ?§£>.3 :3? {$26 gsiaéiié S{?:?':§7i{§§,'I1€:'7 §31'€,:=§§{%§"§;'.}7 {3;:':?S£?E'ib€:%{§ 2&3 GEES Eiagiéiggf/hi SE121sé:*§ :>2IE1<--%:'e%2:$ §3'%%R.1 in she €?'V§{§€?Y}{,',{% '::as_§'_é"{?5s::$_%a:':__ _ ihs V€::§éc::i" aims (EEK? Sriégganizz Shggséri aziéé.' =a %:;vr;";E1€:-'§9_:E§" = i\E:1:'ay21::ag3;:s2§' in that, viaxaz 0? tE*':.,§: 1:':'aiE§€'f;».:h€"§3"§:;§'*€§§V:*£ deciineii to 3.CC{E§Zi§ as <:z'€e;£:Z':é_§€--~géviiiiémsé ih$'V_€3::§,:?%:%sV 52::
REC §>ahaz:i€a<:~; airy};    :I#i%._ §"§"%1e trial
scam': §ur%:h€r  W636: {he RTC
ghafiéés in :f§:4€:§€.§:§   EXSE38 and
P9 1:116   {ha piaénfiffg
 9? Suit item Maggi
and  cam": ebsfirimég rscardeé

{E13 r:a:::r:€3S«..e§'%:h€._'§'a£%:€§' 0f {Eris §}'§ain§2;fié afifi E336 m<:>th€:° A of-'gi'%2~€;_i§.§tf€~:m§a::§' 3;~3~:}i:v§:e:*s if: §§:GS~S€SS§{}£§ 31/mi €f':j{}j,:'f:("1,€?§3'¥i 7@§T_5éi:1i%:"'%.§é;§é' zmé Er: éhzzi: véevg sf ihe mgiier, She ééigi «:<;::?;L'-_i;'5b$€:"*:?{i:£i iifrzgéfi, ihéé pkg 95 gel? 5;C{§1§§$iE§OEE by $2.6 §§z%:§_'€€:§ 3? giaéygiziff 8? 8331?: §E{':':§'EE a:":{% 3 gisséi " %§E:S?i5§"{}"»f{"T{'3a §§€?§'§f§E{§;%§E§l §;"§:?:¥'§1"E§E §;'sas:é€:r:% R'§'%Cj gééagzzées 1; is Efiiiié :1}? aézéziirsh E32 3% §}€:€; :"é:E3§,6é:E ti: éésérgz $53.3 6:? ?;;}:<": giaiizé; ;%s<i*h%::%{:§:V:E€% §}E'i{}§}€:?E"{i3:{??S whiésé E}? E0 2332 if: §'€Tf13;~ig}€€?i', 9:? §::<i%m 3359.1 ezzzcji 33:27? is E £6 22324:? E} 35% ii"; éejsggiécé; {>f§*i1{,>/3?} ?'~E<:}t4 vfiziisi Eixfli'? ané {BEE} '\f:f€§'E: _ item N®g2§ ihe iirizzi ::::3:::*§ n<;='i:<i:~e::§M§E:a: EE:%"s22fi_:éi::E§e§uE€"' grogeréifis £?=,f€]f'€ rai%:<f:@rd€ad as '2:r:C1€%s1";*aé'».p:°:§;:€%*:?i€:31%??? ?v':{§fEiE's's7»'3f§§E1§}}}E1§ i'/he f§zit§é;<5:';._ {>5 ;j:§§aé':5g$::v§'{;"~3 a;:r1€§=C Cr§f§}i'8;}}:L}Zi% b§séjf';€:' (€::r;_£§.fl'*:§,{::?Q;"s§:::§./:23':,._:*$:;fi§:*d€c': a fizxdizzgf Sig: Mz1,EisW8;é2{g.§1§af $5 the géiaintiffs haaj 320?; ;}ur§E}§§sé:§i 'éihejgg big S63?
a<:C;uis§{i<)1§; gfiéfiériiés cf {E26 gigém faffifi}f..4{}§ I3;§i:'£V§V3%%/am;ap§>aV isgséhars As r€gar*§":§ 53:6 ' E996 ggrgpsuadsd Egy {ha E562"; €;»:€<:::f€fi by her mgihe?
j§;..§_§:a,%f::::;2: V-¢§3é:*:;:a:::":%i:'i€::"' Shae aéééiéiééagi W38 $325 kggjaéies _ 9""?:§"§$.§§"§§:7§if;§§' {}f '$25: 8:311. Eécééedizée g3m§:u:%:"*iEé€/s the '£133 €Q%;§"'§ zégfcééfiaéfi 23:5: evéfie/§:{%€i {>5 §}W5»3 5:3 5 Whe WEYS {ha Siézibé _3}:3;{i éwa <::h%3:* 22%/§:{%£.~;€:§§:g§i :a?i§§:%:§§€§ §"€Sp€£Z':§§'*%"€§}? " ;a:f§3_€:A.A.--':s§}<:§éé;£? :5; i'f§::%': z?:»:€:s:::7{£{3:2 ca? E3/:{>: WEE 29:; 316% s:i$::%€as::%d ._E§jg€2":21,Lm:33.aV fie E1,§ES§'§«f'f:?E* §,E§SLE€? hekfimg éhat B§?€i,{['Lh€i,§E3f2E£E <%xé#:<éz¢:i<%<% :i:§%2{';% wéii E::<?t<';::<%ai:Vf%¢1§:'1§5 'iihsé }{}2:}§'{'§}€%E"{E Ezaié p<>:*%;%a:a:: {>3 3329 saw: s+;<i:§:<é{§z:k% ;>:*<:a§£%:"§is%s in j{g:.%5e_3:;.;j 5? i:h€ {:i€%f€*:z:a:%;2i:':i., LRe§§::r<i biéizégg hm} £10 E:1r':{:% 2::_ PE&i1 in ::7::*<>s:~; £%:::a:::::321i;i<}n *:1h;::*_:§::1"é:1;;"?;;.E':;--é::'VEif€:§:i:::;a>: 3:3?"

*fgE";€:§r fzxéher anci ':1IfiChi': C:i1'§-§;aV§;g';»~aT' §':§:'?}i,){E";%,€'§I' E/?:;€:

{§€f€?f:da,H§E éhééfg w€::'*€ 1iVi't1_g"---.V:(>ge%§:€r .386; §3::*€?;§1e:'LV.L' admisgisz: 'iihaé; 'i"§"§€,':_ Sui?/3_..g€f3":.€??{§%§:€ i3.»'€§'€ zinceséreii (?{}1§§3.€{§ €?'i/'"i§£§i€IEC€ as WEE} as ihst sj::€_:§:iaé§ §:1::"§iV§3§£ discigsing ilrzai Byathamm}-ag' Igfsrggern 3:35 gzeriien Ce?
wag fizz PGSSSSSEGEE {>55 heié iihas': 'SE6 3593:}?
E' :"<-*5:s::e3:'<§1€ci Siéifififi :1": £29 rsvsrsus K eezmi §;é":'é%%'n:y3:':3é.:21V:1?; i;i£;mm%S8i@n€:' {:38 was f':}{fi_'§?
V' 322;? ag}p€::5:E éiied by "$25: §iai§=z'£iff:§u 2% :'%g§a§a:§§. %$s*§..;é% :::"§:;z§ :::z£>u§'§: '/363$ éihafig: %;'§";5 §Ea%::f:'£,if§'s ':?:j:éé: §}{}SE§E:"tSf§:¥§8§E €22? 33:5': ésguiéf; §{:ir*:€€§%.:E€ §:2r€::§::>z'{1?s3$ " ;z:f:_<;§.--'§sj§é%{é§:i>a{% €:%a€: '§Z?:§€?t€3 53$ §::a,é:*iEi::i:é::E§:§;: E:§§{:§*§° "£1333 {ism}? ébe;-'r . _.;<§2:§<'i §:%:"€,>f;}%2?'§"E1§§ff§e 3}}; *w;:}; 52%» zaa%i2ré.>:x*$€r ;}{;2§e3%:~:ss;i<2r:« C€)E.E§"{. %3;<%§::E %.:Li"::ssJ;' i:%:{%% §:£e:i::§;:?fi3:--g ws%zv::% <%::'i:i*:2e<E {,9 ihif bfiffiéfiif. :35 {§;€%<é§:;1:"aE1i{>:3 {éf {;a:>é;*z'1s;%r$%::%;> <33»??? ,<e{3::i'i':&%:"r: ha}? §.}{}§§'_;j%€;3f; :3? $16 saw: EETEEQECEE/Q5? p1*o;§£:ri;i€::s.~; zarzd aé::c€;§"<§€§%é a:;%»%%% _ iieciéeééfi fhfi 312:? whiks mggaatigg Q3163: §'€t§.:E§f"'¢§3§:§}1f3'"§'1i1fEiS:Z(Ef.i§ffi""
§::§:2n<%i/$03: 'éyji/§C§§».§I}'§€%i"E'§T anzi (;'£c::':<:::je<~f: (5. Thai gudgmeni, *;17E5':,s%§_': RA, §\Ee::=.§;'2GQ§ thét '_'Erafi§§ §:' 'éigiég? Eiaaréfig :'8;21§1>§F€€:i3t€:d {he 132$ svidencs bath Cara} :§:}:§:; wit}? 'ihfi findings ef {he EEESVEV. <:i;§:;:~: $3/2iJ'ig';:*§7f:é:";£ arid éecyae dated E ?. E E; 3&8? "<i:.:g:;;is:3€§_i§Efs;€ :~':p_'§:2e3§,
7. §'y€¥E:§"§1€{i'__C;i;§,§:f:§';.'i1€V/E 'Ear 'éhfi :€i§}§)€f§3,§¥[, §:;<:<:€§%: fez' étiaaéfi<:-€:~§;:r221"?%§::S E§E«'f:', ézétgaiiaéégg 3 »3€%:€1€::1€:;§ T.%;§*g:i:':i.é§:%fés:%;€::1:, is; azzagbéezé 2:5; éiaiaége figs': findizzgg 9? f:~3;::fE Mr<:é§f:_:7a5:*3::§§:f(§V '€316 {iamis §€§Gi£? basgééfii GEE adméggéerés 9%" §3':?'«;?,E 3ér*: {:rei}§$~§:é;&:é":%:":a1:2le;:;1 <::::::2pEs%C§ 233%}: Ehés: fizgmias :*<:%v:3:1:.:e:% :'§3€€;2*{é§' if: 2315: z:é:'s:,2:.:::§§2m§:€% :29 5 :
cfi SLib8E2'§§f{,i2iE aiyaw/s::i<3:: £3? Eaw arises fT<:::a €i€?C§S§{3§1 mzzkkégfi The appeaé E%.{?£?€}§'{§§fi§.§§}' £fiS§I3§E%$€?€L YKL