Karnataka High Court
Sri C Govindaraj vs Smt Padmini on 20 July, 2011
Bench: Mohan Shantanagoudar, K.Govindarajulu
ii £52; 'E'L§E€;': {Tf£E$€E «:11? me:*:'m:.2fl {:m.:s'->§'é:§a 53:"; E'§";.z.%$<: g,;?r<>L::'3{§é:é, i:%":€ E1z§$E}az'":{E has pz"'2;:3?'e::i fez' d§s:»;§;<>Eué:§c>z': {:5 nzar:"i2:.g;§;=2;:
3. E333' {E€}I1{.'I'£1, thif' wife: E22155»; :fi_"E:ed p:3:'£::Ei?;Vi;:3r€*._f'<').'gf :°es;t,ii'.§,§.t.i{}n sf §:0::;*uga§ rightss, JX{:<:o';'fii;:g§--'..':4{> V' }1:,1:s'b2md hass i:fi.€::t,i0na1§§y* :r<3F::.:s1ééi"t.<>éégzikg. ;h'e::é::_ '§,{:»--.7éah<':-
mattrémailizii h{}m:3; Shéf is; rezaxiy émif."xgviéiiiggfiai -ii'veV ~W_i-3.19:'. ha" Emsbamei fer ever as a ci::'t,'ii'f{i'*§.v¢ii"e. .
Efimh éthfi m:aati:e:'%:,:..V_w€r:é"'ih£:2%;§T<§\"§.sjg£:%the:"' E§€é€a':'é: %:h<3 'E'm?&1 Cozzrt. i)u1°i:1g {he 3;-?QL::f':';é7<)f_.~§;f'i;é.f§', three w£i'.1:e5sses w<»:r:=: 5;'éxai?if:iA:3.Vé3d I;%«dj;;'aif Q'f""i:h€ va2'if€.§ whereas two wii".m<.-:*:3s€:a3 '&-"J"€;"i:f"f;i' {:"f><?©§}:*::i'2':£:::?»»{)z': behzfif «:3? '(E353 has-zfoand, The {£(}€:%.£:V3:E/§,{;,1"i':'.EE.}':;BFV_€%V§EE{:§i€:;E]<Ef3 ES 3&0 p:'z}:.it2<f:€d by the paréiiess. "'Af§'.?é:>':'§_§xsE>ari':2.g,? <é<;:fif§:ji€::1 ercier wa$ pzzsésfici rejaézrting $1316: A§::»&t.;é%;:i€>;?.1 i§E.§éé{§fb};i~~i;h:: h1.:s:;b2m<§: far d§&:$(:sEm;.:i@:1 of :'§:e:3"1"i21g;g;§€:. 21.11:}...<:<>;*§$:;:;:§::s5:*1E,Ej§; §,§'§."8;;E1§1i.E"§§._§ €219 §}§2E§§§";'§" cf "Eliza": w:i'€ f{3»'§"
."E"§f§§?:§§;L§*Ll§'{§§E 1:3? zignfiigzzi. rights, @Zl€§S?;§Gi'§§§1§§ €;E'1ra: game firm} EEEEEEQEEEES §i;'€f;': filéséi by ism» Z%1u:~;;§i";22;§2{E, 2 ml h2::'21$§s::1<:=;n.§: maf:,':;2>::2 {he wife: ::21'::::'~;€n:§ memai {i"£'¥.3€L'fi'.:f by net: pr9;}az'§.§a.g Ehz-3 §:3%.31(E-. and d§.'§':3:{é{in;1_§ {ha h::$b.21;:}€£ :10 $'$:.;i:;f ;f::1gi 2." "
$i€~<3§3 31:: side. the h€>u;<3€:.g' * '7'. The {§§V"€)i"C€'3' §3e11ii:f'<§:f:._§.-S §};§;3_<>ss2d ':":*e;"'€:.f:&;e:4_m>'iif"§:. VA 8' E3: is I18 [email protected]:E::e;§ 'f§;.§(TfI{'faj'fL;H§'i,"E'%;L'V3v: pzisaed in fzgvous' of husband faf' rights in HEVEP Na:3?/:,emj%-;3»,«¥A.%€:a»§;g=%, Maharashtra State an §3;;fi§_'1'{ an exparie befozre '%;5§i%€qL:entEy the exparte .§ué5§m€%Ifi._%%"e1S t'f%1<:: wife in EXP5. Since the :.m= dig? 'z1._@9Ej' §£i"1(§"sA7 about. ihé d€C?{'€€3:, t.'i'1e're £3 ma :;3cQ;§si<§£:;A§}3§"Efgéfr Ea} <::<>mp'§:: xvii}: the judgmeni: reiaténg ix} "'1'.£:;';';:;§5::§".¥,fi,v§L';:§'§V§§:.,_ §;§*"§é::::juga3 2"i§;§h_'€ss' "hi: '%:zz:~'~:$:3a'z":{i kept. E";imL's;€§§7----V$iE1<:iét. '%;<..'ri?:.§_:@:2?; §-';x€<:ui:é:z§§ this: Said d€:C:§"='3:{if. Rafi hfi " Vééisszéa sX€¥:7ut'..:i{}:1 grni-3:',§i:,§{}n far s3:>«:<;%<:w?::§:1g_§ €316 Sfiifi iifiifféiéfiig SE36-r a;«;{§f£::H 'i}«J"i3&};§€§i 'E}z:wé;é km'>w:": €:E:.a§i sg3.<3%'§ 2: s'ia>,<::*<:€ is '§}3SS€{'§ "um". ' 2?:§_§g1§.:§:§:: E':.:::~:*. E2': '£E':§§%; vizztw {sf '::E:€: I?.3£§§§.,{;'f§', ii';-2:? "§':°iaE {T;<:;'2.:§*€:
is; jus=.=;E1::f§€:& in {Z"{:'I§ii{;'.§"V.§I'E<<§ :.E";.29ui, Efitz :: {§€{,'fZ°€:€i <:i>E';»i:2-£iz':{;'::.E %}§*'..{.E1€E h2,,:sb.;md9 {ha}? iim} m.:g;2?s:"'{.s:% {w§1§<t'§f: r{;é:::3.';.a;§_:':<:<i 2.:rzgiéifiityisfiifsisdé-. Was; 9'§?£21:i.;n_{:d <>z'3E},~* Ebr 'iihfi §}L3Z'p€3$€: 0:? k<:%3.p§::g izéjée. $:a i{§.-- {f€E'.t1":§"€:t;% fer dig--"<>e:°<>:e far r<§<:0:'€£ §>'1.::";_;¥:)'s::~:s§*«. a~:m£§. f-"§}E'7_ "'{'.§;§€ purpmses sf g€3!;.'i'i:2g ihe >{§€_3{f{'i'3€3"~-- £753}? disS{::§i.:'§,E':}§1'1--'E}? ma1:*1"ia§§c and R0: fazf a;I1y €}{:,'§"§<:r pui";}<§§*;<:--§-I 'EE:;e Said :'eas0m;Z:1g' giggigrzed .'TrijaE" --€j<2{i:f:: 21pp€21§'s3 in be jzrgt, and §rep::=::r, H Q, Q§:£_ '{:séTI.f2V%;:r 3';.:%r:é_"{h€' €~s"g:--i§'m.i$s§0n is made an 136%-;13f._ :>f '%.{E.';<2a._ E1L1'sbé::s_§i-- fizat the husbzmd oraiiy iniizzazated E1:isVVW§'f?€: .2€§E:=:j1,::.§3L;1é;s:§2'1_§;,§ 0:? Sizcéiz 2: dacrgie. Such a &§u3:%.mi$si{2n i$J21.:f~;«§11a:§e before 'aha "f'r§21': Cami: Eii-SQ' Tha §s2i:::s:§ '=»%:a>3.%;fi7§;§.'ifl;}y disbeiieved, We E;'i.§S{} éo 219%; find ::'ii'l},f 3*:35€£'§%;{é21i.1's::.%1~..'{.:}::Véséieéepé; ':he azzéé s«z..:E)::1is§s;i{33": :'na{§£3 'fig 'Lbs: j E'1u&;'b:a:j1{i, 6/ 16}, ii: mm'. in €§.i3§::::i.a% 'é%3a:. éhe assifsgé hag §e:_:a;.gr,§g&{§; itfiée aéixmpiainii ;:.§§c::giz1g {Eaw1"§; E1z1m$:asme:fi' --gE§§,;*__"'~«ig.}'::€ E"m§3Cba.'::::i and E1§$ 1"z--:};H§v:3.<»:' ?'v'§{fE"€3§:y' b'«3{7é}.L.§.';':;%:é£' V&1§1LV:::3E§:'M "
<:{>mpErc1im: is E<>e:iged§ 31:: €3&i§};I1{)'§:§'3'~f§V';§4§'T€S'LEH1€'(,}§'*'§}§'?E§.?LI-- iE{Eé"-- ssame is; faés-3:': azmji the Samé: :f§}.:s:_{§"--gm§y ft;-:7' £§a2f::'{és:~§i::*:g§". E3716 husbanii r:':é5:1§'aE_1§,-2 ;)u§::%:§:§':::a:: éaaid mefiiefzg" re§a.t.§ng in €.§.{%E":{ii:y* }LfiC;:'¢:"iv£"§"i€:C% Juége asked; the hu:~3'aa,:nd to ta 'E?v'2§rdh&.
The: wife agr£é:§';;jT.f5:>V:" 2: . {3.<T§:r1'se%q11e:3'{Eyg 'both iived at %}"1sif€a.fi;er Ejhey 1:°ei;'=»13'1":'.§§fi"V'vi;;_<A>A" _a%;;fi§§§v2:1" before the czsiminai £52131 2%}; the wife £8 :2 at Wi'Ehmg is
-siay;é;.?'if:§f1 hin':,_S'§'iC vi?r:}:z}(i :1<3'£: ifiavfi §§{}I1{'3 Wm': him and §}3;:E.: {hat baih sf them av€'r€ Eiving '§7{}§?_;<:'i'ffi'1{v§':".Awfféfiif %,%;a:3 Emir :ne::'::_t.'E'§$ §§:::%{>.§f gaefi Eli} $E";m=<5 %';h.23;,'i:" 1;}.f::3%fiw§fé% wézsé i?%?'ifii§1§,§; iez} five wit}: é:E3._€ %1:,:§b2;:1d, ii} 1%" ii: iii; 31:} {%<3::3bE: smza 23 <:<}mpkiin%. is; Eacigtéii "by iihié §'m$;b2;-méi azggaimséi €:.E2€ wife: 211'Eeg_-_:i1/1g tE":a%: téfm '%,»'<s';if€~% 'E2213 a§s5a2m3éf§,e<i him zviih €:'n2:pp:fl8 withizé E11515: ;€_'::--:'.>;L:§"€. Qempeunéi, Bun Stag: said c{>mjpEai:1i is :30? p11'g'f§3'i:§§fi--L§;"&:1'y. 'f1,EE"'1".h€3I'1 '_E"'1r;é::'€f<>1"é2 Hi} =::a3{%3 'c'i§§2E,iE":S§: {ha Wfife {:'a:3. b}§' :=.n*1:)G'c Qiéi by viriimz 05 Such 2-: ("3OI11p3Eii11t1v.%'hi'?Cf§1..iS I1€:i2:--§VLi~}T$1gfiE&k E2. 'E'h01,1gh it £3 2: C2-.§s»;£:__ <31? 'i§é§;"§1L:Sb:cié':g"% :ij:_ha€:T;ii't1.€ Wife treated him badly and mania} Cru€§5ty at. Wardha, {'ifi§;;§V§r';a§.,_§;' the wiiffi waS Ewing with him. far §i'1{3n'EhS, 1'10 <::0mpE3,i11t ~§:4ig.: f"0'f;§L1§é'h §:1ci{i£%n€:_ Even bfifofié _§fn.§.S_'€ir§::19»§.;::ilggéafigf.' ::"i§:'<i' mafia %::y the 2'm:ézfb2a;-;.f:'{§ :31'; the 2"£1at?,€:r. E3. «--.E,%32;rr1€;{§ 7::{':=:;:'::~ss:E 5%}? ilhfi zzpgjfiéiaifi reiiaa u§{;:5§;«:.§".§':§;§ j:_2{§g3;1?:Aé'€::3§:.._{:§ "éihézz Raga:-${.§'2;m Higgh €<2:,:::°E:, &a§§3z.:r W.tE§réi::~e:i§§*:-_§::: "~é§:e. saga of Sm€¢Sar;£a§§z fievi 'V§,§?:°em €?§:g.'::¥:§ §"a>§:s{}:"*i;§:{§ £1": ma gag?' gajaggggaagg .23; E 5".
fig Wf W.» zémzpié §1?w;%<:E far Eksur m@ni:E':.$ 32%. Wagrdha an {hi-3 Suggge-$i;i<>n 9? the Eififfiiiézfi €<:s%;§rE. and bah gtzmze §£1:{.?!'}Z, ti} E3Z»3_1'}§.'§&1§{}§'f;'f Eta 21'§;?i'e1:1§§ ;>m<é£:::{ii::gs b€f€:»'r*§;?: €:h€:~~~-a:'1j"i«::_é§':i:i§ C0113'?
E5. Ex': théz €"fE§,f.~':€ rcpgrted 'E~?;.}0g§r:;sV:E:?'zja:{: :' E69 {ciied $L::§ra} {:1 fafi-S6 {:Q.:':';._p§a§:"2t._wa.&§ aga};zié:é. the hugband under Sectior: Of after' imvegtigzliian was :f9L1V;;§;x.:1f':'~i' a',i:§:§:. 0:i:. haizd thsre is-as 11<>thir1gAe;%1 h2m;<§iv E,{§:. £":0£"I1p}aiYE3i;. af {ha wife 'e,v'.2;s§--.: aéamplaint wa$ iodged €§€§_§§f§y::?}1¥1;rasSmeni:§ it caznmsi bi"? fa faise itompizzinéi 213$ the Sfifiiéf is; Y<::":f:E§%' {he hE,§SbaE'1d.
=~1§§., E3": :}:'€€f»%'..._..€§.5 E336 .2:b<}W; if itiiiar ?é;Ez;:§: frge 1'_':3,:.S%§3a§::§'Er:aS"'iafied ti: §>§*<}'%.:-'£3: 3:31 that E0232" €:f€}IE§,{:':i"fi.§{}:'1S :r2':};Sé:%. if: '§iEE_ff.'::§€§§§.i£}f1 for diss§{3Ez2t§@r1 aéf mar'riag<3< "fhe E'a:§;§§y C7:"3E,i§'§, 2233 ii} €{m::~;i€§e:" 'izhgié r:2;3,?iri:":i:_{;§:§z:.§ §::2§E'.E:€:'§-3 &%% E4?
H£:m:e;: mt: §E"i"{.€;?¥:'§€E°é%§7;€?E;? is iféiifi-'iii i'7::::°. B:>*;:h {Ems appeaES are: zfiisszgaiséseiiri GE "aq.z.J§%i' 5 >3