Central Administrative Tribunal - Patna
Surya Kant vs Railway on 2 February, 2021
1
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
PATNA BENCH, PATNA
OA No050/00068
68/2021
Date of order 02.02.2021
.2021
CORAM
HON'BLE SHRI M.C. VERMA,
RMA, MEMBER [ J ]
HON'BLE SHRI SUNIL KUMAR
KUMAR SINHA, MEMBER [ A ]
1. SURYA KANT SON OF SRI
SRI RAMYATAN PRASAD, JJUNIOR
UNIOR ENGINEER
(MECHANICAL).
2. L.P. CHOURASIYA SON OF RAM NARAYAN , SEN
SENIOR
IOR SECTION
ENGINEER (ELECTRICAL)
(ELECTRICAL
3. ARBIND KUMAR SON OF LALAN PRASAD, SENIOR SECTION
ENGINEER (MECH)
4. SHASHI BHUSHAN KUMAR SON OF MATHURA PRASA
PRASAD, ACCOUNTS
OUNTS
ASSISTANT
5. SANTOSH KUMAR SON OF SRI RAM NARESH SINGH
SINGH,, ACCOUNTS
ASSISTANT
6. RAVINDRA KUMAR SON OF OF SRI RAM SWARUP MAH
MAHTO,
TO, SENIOR
SECTION ENGINEER (ELECTRICAL)
(EL
7. SANJEET KUMAR BHARTI SON OF SADAN RAUT, O
OFFICE
FFICE
SUPERINTENDANT (ELECTRICAL)
(ELEC
8. PRADEEP KUMAR SETH SONS OF LATE GOKUL SETH, OFFICE
SUPERINTENDANT (PERSONNEL)
(PERS
9. NIRAJ KUMAR SON OF MADHESHWAR
MADHESHWAR PRASAD, TE
TECHNICIAN-1
10. RAJESH ROSHAN SON OF DEVENDRA RAJAK, TECH
TECHNICIAN-1
11. ARVIND KUMAR SON OF DASHMI RAM, SENIOR S
SECTION
ECTION ENGINEER
(MELT)
12. ARCHANA BHARTI DAUGHTER OF UMESH PRASAD, TECHNICIAN-III
13. PRABHASH KUMAR SAROJ SON OF SHIV CHANDRA MAHTO,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
14. LAV KUSH KUMAR SON OF
OF PRAMOD KUMAR, JUNI
JUNIOR
OR ENGINEER
(MECHANICAL)
15. SANTOSH KUMAR SON OF LATE BHOLA PRASAD, S
SENIOR
ENIOR SECTION
ENGINEER (MECH)
16. RINKI KUMARI D/O SATISH
SATISH PRASAD, HEL
HELPER (MECHANICAL)
17. PAPPU KUMAR SON OF PRABHU
PRABHU SINGH, HELPER (MECHANICAL)
2
18. BRAJESH KUMAR SON OF ANIL PRASAD MAHTO, T
TECHNICIAN-III
III
(MECHANICAL)
19. RAJESH KUMAR SON OF VISHWANATH PRASAD, S
SENIOR CLERK
20. LAKSHMAN KUMAR SON OF
OF KAPILDEO PRASAD, T
TECHNICIAN-II
II
(MECHANICAL)
21. RANJEET KUMAR SON OF BIRBAL BHAGAT, TECHN
TECHNICIAN-II
II
(MECHANICAL)
22. CHANDAN KUMAR SON OF SARWAN MISTRY, TECHN
TECHNICIAN-II
II
(MECHANICAL)
23. DILDAR HASSAN ANSARI SON OF ABDUL HASSAN ANSARI,
TECHNICIAN (MECHANICAL)
TECHNICIAN-I
24. BHARTENDU KUMAR SINHASINHA SON OF BISHESHWAR SINHA,
TECHNICI
TECHNICIAN-II (MECHANICAL)
25. DILIP KUMAR SON OF CHHITTAN
CHHITTAN DAS, TECHNIC
TECHNICIAN-I (SMS)
26. MANOJ KUMAR SON OFNARESH
OFNARESH PASWAN, TECHNIC
TECHNICIAN-I (SMS)
27. AMIT KUMAR SON OF RAMAKANT
RAMAKANT KUMAR, SENIOR SECTION
ENGINEER (ADMN)
28. ARVIND KUMAR SON OF KAMESHWAR YADAV, JUN
JUNIOR
IOR ENGINEER
(ELECTRICAL)
29. SANJEEV
NJEEV KUMAR SON OF KAUSHALENDRA
KAUSHALENDRA PRASAD, TECHNICIAN-1
30. PRASHANT KUMAR SON OF
OF RAM VILASH SINGH, TECHNICIAN-1
31. ABHIK PANDEY SON OF ASHOK KUMAR PANDEY, SENIOR SECTION
ENGINEER (ELECTRICAL)
(ELECTRICAL
32. UDAY KUMAR SON OF YOGENDRA
YOGENDRA PRASAD YADAV, TECHNICIAN-II
33. SANJEEV RANJAN KUMAR
KUMAR SON OF KAPILDEO S
SINGH, TECHNICIAN-I
34. SHATRUDHAN KUMAR SON OF DASHRATH PANDIT, TECHNICIAN-I
35. RAMDEO KUMAR SON OF DUKHI JAMADAR, TECHN
TECHNICIAN-I
36. RANJIT KUMAR SON OF SHANKAR MAHTO, TECHN
TECHNICIAN-III
37. RANJIT PRASAD SON OF PARMESHWAR PRASAD, T
TECHNICIAN-III
38. MANOJ KUMAR SINGH SON OF NAGENDRA
NAGENDRA PRASAD SINGH
SINGH,, SENIOR
SECTION ENGINEER (MECHANICAL)
(ME
39. PINTU KUMAR RAJAK SON
SON OF YUGESHWAR RAJAK
RAJAK, TECHNICIAN-I
40. RANJEET KUMAR SON OF RAMSHISH YADAV, TECH
TECHNICIAN-I
3
41. BIKRAM KUMAR SINGH SON
SON OF AJAY KUMAR SIN
SINGH, TECHNICIAN--
III
42. SANJEET KUMAR SON OF SRI SUNAYAN P
PRASAD, TECHNICIAN-I
43. NITISH KUMAR SON OF KARMENDRA PRASAD, TE
TECHNICIAN-I
44. GAJENDRA KUMAR NIRAJ SON OF SRI D.RAY, TE
TECHNICIAN-III
45. ANAND MURTI SON OF SRI
SRI VIJAY PRASAD, TEC
TECHNICIAN-I
46. BIRBAL MEENA SON OF BHAG CHAND MEENA, TE
TECHNICIAN-II
47. YOGENDRA KUMAR SON OF SRI D.PANDIT,
ANDIT, TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
48. PRIYA RANJAN KUMAR SON
SON OF MAHESH SINGH, TECHNICIAN-I
49. SATISH KUMAR PATEL SON
SON OF LATE K. MAHTO, TECHNICIAN-I
50. VIKASH KUMAR SON OF RAMESHWAR SAH, TECHN
TECHNICIAN-I
51. AJEET KUMAR SON OF VIJAY
VIJAY SAH, TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
52. ABHISHEK KUMAR SON
SON OF AWDHESH KUMAR,S
KUMAR,SENIOR
ENIOR SECTION
ENGINEER (ELECTRICAL)
(ELECTRICAL
53. SANJAY KUMAR DAS SON OF MOHAN DAS, TECHNI
TECHNICIAN-I
54. NAGENDRA KUMAR RAJ SON
SON OF LATE RAMA KANT
RAJ,TECHNICIAN
RAJ,TECHNICIAN-I
55. RAKESH RAUSHAN SON OF
OF LATE SUDAMA RAM, T
TECHNICIAN-I
56. SUJEET KUMAR SON OF SHYAM NANDAN PRASAD, HELPER (ELECT)
57. VIKASH KUMAR SON OF AJAY KUMAR SINGH, TE
TECHNICIAN--
I(ETECT)
58. RAJESH KUMAR SON OF PRAMANAND PRASAD,TEC
PRASAD,TECHNICIAN-II
(MECH)
59. JITENDRA KUMAR SON OF
OF RAM KUMAR SINGH, T
TECHNICIAN--
II(ELECT)
60. ANUJ KUMAR SON OF KISHORI
KISHORI DAS, TECHNICIA
TECHNICIAN-I (ELECT)
61. BANDHU KUMAR SON
SON OF UMA SHANKAR DAS
DAS, TECHNICIAN-II
(MECH)
62. MOTI LAL KUMAR SON OF
OF RAJ BALLABH PRASAD
PRASAD, TECHNICIAN--
III(MECH)
63. DHANAJAY KUMAR SON OF OF LATE DEVENDRA PRAS
PRASAD
AD
CHOUDHARY, TECHNICIAN-I
TECHNICIA (MECH)
64. SANTOSH KUMAR SON OF ANUP LAL SHARMA, OFF
OFFICE
ICE
SUPERINTENDANT
4
65. RAHUL RAJ SON OF SRI DEV BALI PRASAD, MELT SHOP
66. KUNDAN KUMAR SON OF SRI MOHAN SAW (ADMN)
67. SANTOSH KUMAR SINGH SON OF PARMESHWAR PR
PRASAD
ASAD SINGH,
HEALTH ATTENDANT
68. RAJEEV KUMAR SON OF SRI GOPAL PRASAD KES
KESHRI,HELPER
69. SUNIL KUMAR SON OF SRI
SRI BAIJ NATH SINGH, HELPER
70. MD ALAM ANSARI SON
SON OF MD NESRUL HAQUE ANSARI, HELPER
71. CHANDRA PRAKASH KUMAR
KUMAR SON OF OM PRAKASH MEHTA,
HELPER
72. UMESH KUMAR SON OF GANESH
GANESH PRASAD(MR)
73. GAURAV KUMAR SON OF BINAY KUMAR JHA,, SE
SENIOR
NIOR SECTION
ENGINEER (ELECTRICAL)
(ELECTRICAL
74. VISHAL KUMAR SON OF SHIV KUMAR PRASAD, T
TECHNICIAN-II
(ELECTRICAL)
LECTRICAL)
75. PRAVIN KUMAR SON OF SHIV SHANKAR MAHTO, TECHNICIAN-III
III
(ELECTRICAL)
76. RITESH KUMAR SON OF SRI RAMDEO CHOUDHARY
CHOUDHARY, TECHNICIAN-I
77. ASHWANI KUMAR SON OF SARVAN PRASAD, ACCOU
ACCOUNTS ASSISTANT
78. SUDAMDEO RAY SON OF SRI DURGA ROY, MR
79. BARUN KUMAR SON OF LATE
LATE SURES
SURESH PRASAD, TECHNICIAN-III
III
(ELECTRICAL)
80. RITESH KUMAR PRAJAPATI
PRAJAPATI SON OF SUDARSHAN PRASAD,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-III (ELECTRICAL)
81. AJAY KUMAR SON OF JAY
JAY KISHOR PRASAD SING
SINGH, TECHNICIAN-III
III
(ELECTRICAL)
82. PANKAJ KUMAR BIDHARTHI
BIDHARTHI SON OF JAY PRAKAS
PRAKASH
H YADAV, SENIOR
SECTION ENGINEER
ENGINEE (SMS)
83. YOGENDRA PASWAN SON OF INDRADEO MANJHI, HEALTH
ATTENDANT
84. VIJAY KUMAR RAY SON OF LATE RAJ KISHOR S
SINGH, PERSONNEL
85. MUKESH KUMAR RAJAK SON
SON OF SRI SADIN RAJA
RAJAK, TECHNICIAN-II
(MECHANICAL)
86. RAJEEV KUMAR RANJAN SON OF SRI SURESH PR
PRASAD
ASAD SINGH,
HELPER (MECHANICAL)
(MECHAN
5
87. DHARMENDRA KUMAR SON OF ASHOK KUMAR SINGH
SINGH,,
(MECHANICAL)
88. RAJEEV KUMAR SON OF MAHESH KUMAR, TECHNI
TECHNICIAN-II
(MECHANICAL)
89. MANI KUMAR SON OF SRI
SRI MUNNI LAL RAM, PER
PERSONNEL
90. RAVINDRA KUMAR SON OF
OF SRI RAMANAND SINGH
SINGH,, M.R
(ELECTRICAL)
91. ABHISHEK KUMAR SON OF
O ANANT SAH, MR (ELECTRICAL)
92. MADHU RANJAN KUMAR SON
SON OF SRI BANARSI SI
SINGH,
NGH, MR
(ELECTRICAL)
93. SHIV SHANKAR KUMAR SON
SON OF SRI NARAYAN SA
SAW, TECHNICIAN-III
III
(MECHANICAL)
94. MUKESH KUMAR SON OF RAM CHANDRA RAY, (TE
(TECHNICIAN-I)
95. SANTOSH KUMAR SON OF RAJDEV SINGH, (TECHN
(TECHNICIAN-III)
96. SANTOSH KUMAR SON OF RAM JEE SAH, HELPER
97. AKHILESH KUMAR SON OF
OF NARESH YADAV, HELP
HELPER
ER
(MECHANICAL)
98. AMIT KUMAR SON OF RAM
RAM DEO SAH, TECHNICIA
TECHNICIAN-I
99. SANJAY KUMAR SON OF BIRENDRA PRASAD GUPT
GUPTA, TECHNICIAN-II
(ENGINEERING)
100. KAMLESHWAR KUMAR SON OF SHIO GOVIND RAM, OFFICE
FICE
SUPERINTENDANT (ENGINEERING)
(ENGI
101. RATAN LAL PRASAD SON OF RAM BILASH PRASAD
PRASAD, TECHNICIAN--
III
102. DINESH KUMAR YADAV SON
SON OF UMA SHANKAR YA
YADAV,
DAV,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-III
103. DHARMENDRA RAM SON OF
OF ARJUN RAM, HELPER
104. ABHAY KUMAR SON OF SUBHASH
SUBHASH PRASAD, TECHN
TECHNICIAN-I
105. ASHISH
ISH KUMAR JAISWAL SON
SON OF AMBIKA PRASAD JJAISWAL,
AISWAL,
JUNIOR ENGINEER
106. KAPIL KUMAR SON OF JAGDISH
JAGDISH PRASAD, TECHN
TECHNICIAN-I
107. B. RUPESH SON OF B. BABLOO, TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-III
108. RAJESH KUMAR SON OF BALMIKI YADAV, HELPE
HELPER
109. AMIT KUMAR ROBIN SON OF MAHESH KUMAR
MANDAL,TECHNICIAN
MANDAL,TECHNICIAN-III
6
110. SONU VISHWAKARMA SON OF VIDHYANAND VISHWA
VISHWAKARMA,
KARMA,
JUNIOR CLERK
111. NITISH KUMR SON OF MANOJ
MANOJ PRASAD, TECHNIC
TECHNICIAN-III
112. VICKY KUMAR SINHA SON
SON OF SRI SURESH KUMA
KUMAR
R SINHA, JUNIOR
CLERK
113. UJJAWAL KUMAR SON OF SRI RAVINDRA PANDEY, PEON
114. SUSHIL KUMAR SON OF SRI RAM PRAVESH PD. SINGH, DEPO
MATERAIL SUPERINTENDANT
SUPERINTEND
115. LAL BABU SINGH SON OF
OF SHAMBHU NATH SINGH
SINGH, TECHNICIAN-II
(MECHANICAL)
116. HARIBANSH RAY SON OF LATE DHANPAT RAY, HE
HELPER
117. AMIT KUMAR SON OF JAGDISH
JAGDISH PASWAN, TECHNI
TECHNICIAN-I,
I,
(MECHNICAL)
118. BIPUL KUMAR TIWARI SON
SON OF DILIP TIWARI, TECHNICIAN-III
119. VIKAS KUMAR SON OF MANINDRA
MANINDRA LAL DAS, JUN
JUNIOR
IOR ENGINEER
(MECHANICAL)
120. SUBHASH KUMAR MISHRA SON OF AMAR NATH MIS
MISHRA,
HRA, JUNIOR
ENGINEER
121. RAKESH KUMAR MEENA SON SON OF PYARE LAL MEEN
MEENA,
A,
TECHNICIAN ,(MECHANICAL)
TECHNICIAN-I
122. DHARMENDRA KUMAR SON OF KAILASH SINGH, SE
SENIOR SECTION
ENGINEER
123. SUMAN CHANDRA BOSE SON
SON OF SUBHASH CHANDR
CHANDRA
A BOSE,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
124. NEERAJ KUMAR SON OF RAMESHWAR PRASAD VER
VERMA,
MA,
TECHNICIAN (MECHANICAL)
TECHNICIAN-I
125. ARVIND KUMAR SON OF FUDAN PANDIT, HELPER
126. RAVINDRA RAJAK SON OF
OF SURESH RAJAK, TECH
TECHNICIAN-I
127. MUMTAJ ANSARI SON OF KAMRUDDIN ANSARI, SE
SENIOR
NIOR SECTION
ENGINEER, TECHNICIAN-I
TECHNICIAN
128. NITISH SAURABH SON NIRMAL
NIRMAL KUMAR SINHA, JJUNIOR ENGINEER
129. VIBHAW KUMAR SON OF HARENDRA TIWARI, TEC
TECHNICIAN-I
130. VIKRAM SINGH MEENA SON
SON OF S. R. MEENA, T
TECHNICIAN-II
131. BIRENDRA KR. PODDAR
PODDAR SON OF TRIVENI PRA
PRASAD
SAD PODDAR,
JUNIOR ENGINEER
7
132. SHRAWAN KUMAR YADAV SON OF BAIJ NATH YAD
YADAV,
AV,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
133. MUKESH KUMAR SON OF ARJUN RAM, TECHNICIA
TECHNICIAN-I
134. RAMKESH MEENA SON OF SURAJ MAL MEENA, PA, SENIOR
SECTION ENGINEER (MECHANICAL)
(ME
135. RAKESH KUMAR SON OF YOGENDRA PRASAD, TECHNICIAN-III
136. PREM PRAKASH KUMAR SON
SON OF SIDHESHWAR SIN
SINGH,
GH,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
137. RAVI KUMAR SON OF SHRI
SHRI RADHA KANT THAKUR
THAKUR, TECHNICIAN--
III
138. HARI OM GIRI SON OF AWADHESH KUMAR GIRI, JUNIOR
ENGINEER (MECHANICAL)
(MECHANICAL
139. MUKESH KUMAR JAISWAL SON OF RAJ KISHOR JA
JAISWAL, JUNIOR
CLERK
140. CHANDAN KUMAR SON OF DEVENDRA CHOUDHARY, OFFICE
SUPERINTENDANT
141. JITENDRA KUMAR SON OF
OF RAMKRIT SINGH, HEL
HELPER
142. MAJOJ KUMAR SON OF JAGDEO
JAGDEO RAY, TECHNICIA
TECHNICIAN-III
143. AVINASH KUMAR SON OF LATE SHAMBHU SAH, TE
TECHNICIAN-I
144. DHARMENDRA KUMAR SON AMARNATH ROY, TEC
TECHNICIAN-I
145. RAHUL CHOUDHARY SON OF BHIKHARI LAL CHOU
CHOUDHARY,
DHARY,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-III
146. LAKSHMAN KUMAR SINGH SON OF RAM BACHAN SI
SINGH,
NGH,
TECHINCIAN
TECHINCIAN-III
147. NIRAJ KUMAR SON OF SUBHASH
SUBHASH PRASAD GUPTA, TECHINICAN-I
148. PRABHASH CHANDRA SON OF YOGENDRA PRASAD M
MAHTO,
AHTO,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
149. PRAVEEN KUMAR
K SON OF AJAY SHARMA,
RMA, TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-III
150. SHARVAN KUMAR SON OF JAGDEESH PRASAD, TEC
TECHNICIAN-I
151. PAWAN KUMAR TIWARI SON
SON OF CHANDRA BHUSHA
BHUSHAN
N TIWARI,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
152. MANOJ KUMAR DIWAKAR SON OF LATE OM PRAKA
PRAKASH,
SH,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
153. NITISH KUMAR SON OF JANARDAN PRASAD, MET LAB/CMS
8
154. SATYENDRA KUMAR SON OF LATE RAM PRATAP P
PANDIT,
ANDIT, MET
LAB/CMS
155. LALIT NARAYAN DAS SON
SON OF JAY PAL DAS, TE
TECHNICIAN-I
156. RAJESH KUMAR SON OF PRAYAG PRASAD, TECHN
TECHNICIAN-I
157. LALCHAND KUMAR YADAV SON OF JAGLAL YADAV, TECHNICIAN--
I
158. SANJAY KUMAR CHOUDHARY
CHOUDHARY SON OF AMRIT CHO
CHOUDHARY,
UDHARY,
OFFICE SUPERINTENDANT
SUPERINTENDAN
159. VIKASH KUMAR SON OF AMAR NATH GUPTA, MET
MET.LAB/CMS
160. ASHOK KUMAR SON OF KAMAL
KAMAL RAM, TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
161. MD. SOHAEL ANWAR SON OF MD. ABDUL QUADIR, TECHNICIAN-I
162. PRAMOD KUMAR SON OF LATE GOPAL SINGH, TE
TECHNICIAN-I
163. SANTOSH KUMAR SON OF PRAHLAD
D PRASAD, HELPER/ELE
HELPER/ELECTRIC
164. NIRAJ KUMAR JHA SON OF BALA NATH JHA, TE
TECHNICIAN-III
165. JITENDRA KUMAR JOSI SON OF RAMASHANKAR S
SINGH,
INGH,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-III
166. PRAKASH KUMAR SON OF CHHATHU SAH, TECHNIC
TECHNICIAN-I
167. MANOJ KUMAR SON OF MOTI
MOTI RAM, MMR
168. RAJEEV KUMAR SON OF RAM KRISHNA AZAD, WFPS
169. MANISH KUMAR SON OF ANIRUDDH SINGH, SENI
SENIOR
OR SECTION
ENGINEER
170. ADESHKAR KUMAR SHARMA
SHARMA SON OF MAHAVIR PRA
PRASAD
SAD SHARMA,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
171. PARMESHWAR KUMAR SON OF KAILASH NATH YADA
YADAV,
V, JUNIOR
ENGINEER/ELECTRIC
172. PREM SUNDER SON OF LATE
LATE LAL BABU PASWAN, TECHNICIAN-I
173. KUNDAN KUMAR SON OF RAM ISHWAR SINGH, TE
TECHNICIAN-III
174. SANJEET KUMAR SHARMA SON OF PREM CHANDRA SHARMA,
HELPER (MECHANICAL)
175. ISLAMUDDIN SON OF LATE
LATE MD. IBRAHIM, TECH
TECHNICIAN-III
176. SHAILENDRA KUMAR SON OF DINANATH PRASAD, PERSONNEL
177. BHUVNESHWAR SINGH SON
SON OF LATE RAMDULAR SINGH, SENIOR
OR
SECTION ENGINEER
9
178. SIMA KUMARI DAUGHTER OF RAJO PASWAN, TECH
TECHNICIAN-I
179. NIRAJ KUMAR SON OF TRIYUGU
TRIYUGU PRASAD, MELT STORE
180. RAJIV KUMAR PANDIT SON
SON OF SHYAM SUNDAR P
PANDIT,
ANDIT, MOULD
ROOM
181. VINAY KUMAR PRASAD SON
SON OF GANESH PRASAD, TECHNICIAN-I
182. DHARMENDRA
DHARMENDRA KUMAR PASWAN SON OF RAM NANDAN PASWAN,,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-III
183. RAMAYAN SINGH SON OF HARE RAM SINGH, TECH
TECHNICIAN-I
184. ROHIT RANJAN SON OF MOHAN THAKUR, TECHNI
TECHNICIAN-III
185. SANJEEJ KUMAR SON OF RAKESH PRASAD, HELPE
HELPER/ELECTRIC
186. ASHOK KUMAR SON OF SRI
SRI MUNESHWAR SINGH, TECHNICIAN-III
187. AKASH GAURAV SON OF SATYENDRA KUMAR PAND
PANDAY,
AY, JUNIOR
ENGINEER
188. RITESH KUMAR SON OF AJAY KR VERMA, SENIO
SENIORR SECTION
ENGINEER
189. MUKESH PASWAN SON OF LATE R.K. PASWAN, SE
SENIOR
NIOR SECTION
ENGINEER
190. SANJEEV KUMAR SON RAM
RAM CHANDRA PRASAD SIN
SINGH,
GH,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
191. VIJAY KUMAR SON OF VISHVANATH
ATH PRASAD, JUNIOR E
ENGINEER
192. M.K. MEENA SON OF LATE
LATE MADAN LAL MEENA, SENIOR SECTION
ENGINEER (MECHNICAL)
193. CHANDRA SHEKHAR TAMSOY
TAMSOY SON OF CHANDRA BH
BHUSHAN
USHAN
TAMSOY, META LAB/CMS
194. GIRIJESH JHA SON OF SRI SATYANARAYN JHA, TECHNICIAN-III
195. RAHUL KUMAR
KUMAR GUPTA SON OF AKHI
AKHILESH
LESH KUMAR GUPTA,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
196. MINTU KUMAR SINGH SON
SON OF AMRESH NARAYAN SINGH,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-III
197. JACOB SOREN SON OF ANTHONY
ANTHONY SOREN, TECHNI
TECHNICIAN-I
198. MADHU SUDAN KUMAR SON
SON OF ARUN KUMAR MALL
MALL,,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
199. SHAMBHU KUMAR SON OF SRI RAM BRIKSH YADAV
YADAV,, JUNIOR
ENGINEER
10
200. SITARAM PANDIT SON OF
OF NUNESHWAR PANDIT, SENIOR SECTION
ENGINEER
201. KAMAL DEV PANDIT SON OF MUKH LAL PANDIT, TECHNICIAN-I
202. HARE KISHUN CHOUDHARY
CHOUDHARY SON OF RAMJEE CHOW
CHOWDHARY,
DHARY,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
203. BOBY T J SON OF JOY T M, CNS. POLICLINIC
204. GAURAV KUMAR SON OF SHAILENDRA PRASAD, T
TECHNICIAN-I
205. RAJESH KR. KASHYAP SON
SON OF BHAGWAT PRASAD
PRASAD, CMA/MET.LAB
206. MD. SHAUQUAT SHEKH SON
SON OF MD. KUDDUSH SH
SHEKH,
EKH,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-III
207. MAHESH KUMAR MAHATO SON OF LATE RAMPUKAR MAHATO,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-III
208. DHIRENDRA KUMAR SON OF LAL MOHAN YADAV, HELPER
209. SHASHI KUMAR SON OF KAMLESHWARI PRASAD, HELPER
210. SANDEEP KUMAR SRIVASTWA
SRIVASTWA SON OF BIPIN BIH
BIHARI
ARI VERMA,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
211. RAKESH KUMAR VERMA SON
SON OF RAM SEWAK, SEN
SENIOR
IOR SECTION
ENGINEER (MECHANICAL)
(MECHANICAL
212. MD. SAQUIB NAJMI SON OF GULAM MAKHBUL AYU
AYUBI,
BI, JUNIOR
ENGINEER
213. SUSHIL KR. YADAV SON OF AKH
AKHILESHWAR PRASAD YADAV,
V,
SENIOR CLECRK
214. MUNNA KUMAR SON OF INDRAJEET
INDRAJEET RAM, TECHNI
TECHNICIAN-I
215. SUSANTA KUMAR SAHOO SON OF BHARATA CHARA
CHARANA
NA SAHOO,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
216. NAVIN KUMAR JAYASWAL SON OF RAM PUKAR CHA
CHAUDHARI,
UDHARI,
HELPER
217. KUMAR RAJNITI SINHA SON OF BRAHMD
BRAHMDEV PRASAD, HELPER
218. PANKAJ KUMAR SON OF YOGENDRA MAHTO, SENI
SENIOR
OR SECTION
ENGINEER/ELECTRICAL
219. SUMAN KANT SUDHANSHU SON OF UMESH PRASAD SUMAN, CNS/
MEDICAL
220. ANWARUL HAQUE ANSARI SON OF MD. ABDUL RAU
RAUF
F ANSARI,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-III
221. AJIT KUMAR SON OF SUDAMA
SUDAMA PRASAD, HELPER
11
222. RAJU KUMAR MISHRA SON
SON OF AMAR NATH MISHR
MISHRA,
A,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-III
223. SATYENDRA KUMAR YADAV
YADAV SON OF RAJENDRA PR
PRASAD
ASAD YADAV,
JUNIOR ENGINEER
224. NITU KUMARI DAUGHTER OF LATE R.B. PASWAN, SNS/MEDICAL
225. MUKESH KUMAR SON OF RAJKUMAR YADAV, TECH
TECHNICIAN-III
226. RANJEET KUMAR SON OF VINOD
D KUMAR, TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I
227. AMARESH KUMAR SON OF SURESH SINGH, TECHNI
TECHNICIAN-I
228. PRIYA RANJAN KUMAR SON
SON OF NARENDRA TIWAR
TIWARI,
I, JUNIOR
CLERK
229. DEVESH CHANDRA PRASAD
PRASAD SON OF SRI RAM CHA
CHANDRA
NDRA PRASAD,
SENIOR CLERK
230. BHOLA SAHANI SON OF SRI JAWAHAR SAHANI , TECHNICIAN-III
231. RAJESH KUMAR
K SON OF LATE R.K.. YADAV, CHIEF PHARM
PHARMASIST/
ASIST/
MEDICAL
232. SANJAY KUMAR MEHTA SON
SON OF LATE JAI LAL P
PRASAD
RASAD MEHTA,
TECHNICIAN
TECHNICIAN-I,
ALL ARE POSTED AT RAILRAIL WHEEL PLANT BELA, DISTRICT - SARAN,
PIN CODE - 841221 (BIHAR).
...............Applicantss
By Advocate : Shri M.P. Dixit
Versus
1. THE UNION OF INDIA THROUGH
THROUGH THE SECRETARY
SECRETARY, RAILWAY BOARD, MINISTRY OF
RAILWAY, RAIL BHAWAN,
BHAWAN NEW-DELHI-110001.
110001.
2. THE CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE
ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER, RAIL W WHEEL PLANT, MINISTRY OF RAILWAY,
BELA, DISTRICT - SARAN, PIN CODE - 841221 (BIHAR).
............Respondents
By Advocate: Shri B.K. Choudhary with Shri D.K. Verma.
O R D E R (ORAL)
M.C. Verma,, M [ J ]
1. Two hundred thirty two applicants ha have filed instant O.A, alongwith M.A. 67/2021, for joining together in one O.A. The grievances of the th applicants is that they through Railway Recruitment Board/Railway Recruitment Cell have been recruited and appointed to 12 various posts, posts before year 2016 at Rail Wheel Plant, Bela but are not given three advance increment as has been given to other employ employee ee posted at RWP, Bela.
Bela
2. It has been pleaded that vide Memorandum No. E(NG)II/2007/PO/Genl./19 dated 27.04.2007 27.04.2007, Ministry of Railways gave incentive by granting three advance increment to Railway Staff to be posted at Workshop Project Organisation under CAO (Workshop Project) Project)..
Said incentive was to attract serving Railway Personnel to join Worksh Workshop p Project. That benefit of this this memorandum la later on was extended to the RPF staff posted at Bela vide letter dated 18.04.2018 (Annexure A/5) and also to one employee of accounts branch namely Ritu Sahu. That Ritu Sahu was also appointed through direct recruitment and is posted at Rail Wheel Plant, Bela.
Bela. That, several applicants gave representations to Railway Authority to extend the benefit three advance increment to them but vide letter dated 02.06.2020 (copy at Annexure A/1 of the O.A.) their ir claim has been rejected with direction that no Directly Recruited ed employees through RRB/RRC at RWP/Bela would gave application for extending this benefit of three advance increment increment.. That after order dated 02.06.2020 some s applicants, gave representation representation, on 15.06.2020 and 09.07.2020 taking categorical stand that in RWP, Bela, RPF employees 09.07.2020, appointed through RRB are taking benefit of these three advance increment,, one employee of Accounts Department namely Ritu Sahu/Accounts Clerk is also getting the benefit of three advance increment,, therefore there their right of equal pay for similar work is being violated.
3. Heard. Learned counsel for applicant applicants pressed the O.A. He urged that when benefit has been extended to the RPF officials and to one official of accounts, a why it could not be extended to applicants who are on similar footing. He further submitted tha that respondents are acting arbitrarily and the impugned order itself reflects that even right of making representation has been curtailed. He requests to issue notice notice. It is enquired from learned counsel that whether RPF personnel were recruited for the purpose of posting a Bela project only and whether this aspect has 13 been clarified in advertisement given for selection and he fairly submitted that he has no details. He requests that some of the applicants has given representation on 15.06.2020 and 09.07.2020 and itt was incumbent upon the respondents to pass appropriate order thereon but no order has been passed.
4. The learned counsel for respondents Shri B.K. Choudhary vehemently hemently opposed the maintainability of the O.A. He also has added to his submission stating that this O.A. may be disposed of with direction to respondents, RWP, Bela to take decision on the representations of the applicants dated 15.06.2020 and 09.07.20 09.07.2020 20 (Annexure A/10 series of O.A.). Learned counsel for respondents at this stage also endorsed that O.A may be disposed of with direction to take decision on the representations.
5. Considered the submissions. Taking note of entirety, we direct the respondents to consider and pass appropriate order on the representation dated 15.06.2020 and 09.07.2020 as early as possible but latest within a period of three months from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
6. O.A stands disposed of accordingly. No order as to costs.
(Sunil Kumar Sinha) M ( A ) (M.C. Verma ) M [ J ] /mks/