Karnataka High Court
The Commr Of Customs Hqrs Office vs Sri T V Mohammed S/O Mohammed Unni on 29 September, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
ZN 'i'E--{E1 E"EE{f§E'£ €CvE;§§{"'E' (3%? §{z':E€E\éEa'§';?'§z§;"ix XE.' 'E,§faN'{}AiAZ}§3{E*Z E.}A'§§l§f} 'FE"§§f,3 "TE-{E3 293" EDAY {E}? SE §'§'E§';fx/E §3E§'§% iZ{}§ E §3"REZS§3§.\§'§ "S-»§:: %»i<}m;s':,.§:: '£vEE{...;?U'§'§'E{EEé§ N E<i§'E'v'§AEg»:...._ ' I "
AN 1:} /;*:«§Ei PEONEELE MR.JUS"E"§C§£ 1§€A'§':E I\;:g;;g[,§f';!:;:,;$:":e:_ 'V J CSTA Na$f3*3{2fifi'§'§ "
Be%.wee:1: 'V V V '"fhe:;% C:3m::1is$i<3:;'1€§* 0i'€:igs-;:,<3:--fi":5:«:, . V" "
E-EQRS Q§"f§«::€ _ » C R. B'ufi&§::g>;;9:5 Q:.2_:;*:z:*::fz;.'*:2-3:...,'§?,1?.:{>;;:ai§ "
B2:zzga§€3re:wE36Q.Q{>vE_ 'A " _ Efiijx :Sr£. {T 3, SE*:2i1:<§%f::.j?as;2?{;;":i,E';',_A{,£'w{t;.;i:e} And:
2. 3:}: "'33/' §§zE{>§";21.;%:§m:=<:§ S {(3 ;§s.«',fE<:E1z1:z_1::1eé:§--$33hi , ' V.f§.'};:§:%T:3': :3j€é9z.fi§.21§3§E §_£<:;2: S8 _ " 1.95:3-sf:'%?Z<i;zj§::p21_§.
_ "f*;E;:3.§:1:§§é"a.::f.;>*::'§'2"§)}§5§é:?§<':€:
' Kéarafiigi iL"§z'§f1;€?>» S2-iméézf I ;' <7; 3% . E?.A%3<3{>?>2a<:kc2 :' x _ §%f1{.2::zip2;%..r2:::a'%3i§ §€<;2:.:;$::?r £%§'2':.'Ez.ék2:mgbaiii ?<§:'i«;é;,:E{:%E;§;<i§ 3%-'Z:?:_};§2i's.§3:2:'2;:§':": Ejf§§:§é..::'%::§:
§<::i*::"2:sE;;i =ff§§'I§§i§'%'?.
( ( G §E€?'i'::3§}€"§f§"§§f§i."f'§E§féé {E392}; E%%a§:%i.;»:fg;'§';2.z¢ j%<.*§m;.}<::t:':§".at% §%.>§' RE. ;:':.2.:<;'§ R2} , , . ..5%§}§'§€:H.EiEET, ,,,, '.,--I 22:2"; E"h;r2'r h.<1ni'.::%§ pz*e§:1i3e-S. Thazé h{3i:s:rE 2:.;.;iT.E2{>§°i'€.:%es5 W'€"?1"€ 2»a3.§<::%£§ ;;.:E}o:.1'é 311:? {>22-*1'2<2;_'$§2§';3 <2? éhy: sgazécé 1;:;;éi'1:£<fE£: vs-*%.':_i<:§'2 §'ev€:a§e:{'E ::%";.;:§': Ei§'§f.-?f aziay E3¢.*k>:'1§_._§éé{§ {<3 iriw {7::'t<:azp2«:--::i::,=3 Ra<>m No} ':3. r§'§":{"'§ _r<-::<;:~{}:"{£s aufzziizzibiazt at ---.:1,:E":e -fEf;'{}~'i:{'?.§ §n::ii<:;1*:,€e:§ $12131: cme. Shy: S21::2«L*:'e:~'*:.z'"----. 'M; P'.,_,. E?'2;:gE.hir:--3ié.2; E3ha>*zm, Edapah i§\z'{2?:_1Eapur2:m h.2;2;{:E <:E:.::e'}}<:;£><<E"§.mt.o. T%{<}':3__:é*:.. "' I\Er::, E. 3.3 «:3? "she: 5-seaid heitei 23%.
'E'§1£z*::'i3af't:€r Q16: Q;;?"§'i£::--':§f:%;,pz'{:»{:a%'étii§fi' --.E}€.0{3::r': Vf;'~§(3;:"}V; 153 Eff me amid 'h:)i;€:§ where ffv;'<é ;;:c;§*:é'§0E_f:.S"*i.%£E5:;':}'__ ir:§'.1*<}du<:<-zd E1}: ayzzsa-E.E2=-*€:$ ';'?§e.'if:;"§;g«i'"i(;: ¥f;:r.:.§E; ..§3«321;";<1é%'{%:'j"«W@1ff~é pi"f3iS€3.":T{, Sim. Efihaféig~'é:€§1s;:'.:§:§i¥E€éiggiidifiai: §:?":_€%"'"%2?z:* §3e§;:)nge<i :19 him zmd §'§i':+:,*é; "E426; %§:';::"§'.§:":;%3', "§':j€§§:'; Edzmzai in 1§'i'z1§'§;1;>a1.:"22:7:f:.§ Eierzflgz zziéézéggf wi":§'2'"8mj§"'Sa§tr::3<:;' {>31 C¥§,{E5.2€}83 21:26; :"fir2i<:Ef:é;:*{%_§i§;;%L:é;é§a§€>§':% £19? E'.E':€% if'f&§'§§J .h<';a;,2:*s:; <35 ET§a€38.,2{}G;'3 "--23,E1{§~..{{f§5§,%iE{"f§£€;3.{§ Emiéfi "" 'fitzéé hm;:I=.E' G1: :;%:fs£;:1§'§'j.;i, Ehssgr §z:f7{ie.:**::<;.{§:z;§E}? :f§'::e§; %";2ias;' {'?E£§"§'"§{;',{§ {',i>}EE§}LE§'.£f?E" §}2u*i%:::; $3: $353 &%:2:§{§'*~%:::::*' EZ{§z3.p:':E E3": E%'Ez:E_Ea.g;;:;::*a:21 :3: §'§€3";1§&i iii') E%22:1:;;:::Z:,;V§"€'§E%:" §:e2,%.E:":* 3:': §§é?§§T§§§;fE:§§:I§§"€? am 'aha: §é:°s;%e:t?.:iéf;;"::%.% £2? :2 E§~,2%:2é- E3'§z;§':;¢:::'z:"z:<:{E <2? §':€:§22§'}2;'%§¢ }%:=t:*2::a__§a:z. .E*Z:x:.a:.:32.§m.=:§iotsg 1,,.a_i:E7._j£,§'é.::fi E1-1Ei:i€,se:"sL.z'§.3:::e;:§':§ §.;:mz:?2=7:;' ma" wags; <_:r2;2§':'%€:{ii <::2_:'§".. ' {"2-sz'%..<.:§:.';,§§ <3';§.:§_.;»-:_E.::'*;..i.":':g SEES? 2:13;?' j§.:.2'%;a?:§ $2?" ézT.::';z gs;
2'
-.,:
'E'h<%:'::%f<>rax ha': ss1,z?:3;mt;<.-is 3139:: %?E'1€% £273} p¥.,1§f§'}€3{§ o:'£ier ;;}2:s£a:=;-iaegéii E3}; ihss 'E"'z:'E3:.::'1a1§ 2"<:%::§z,1';rs>ss 9;} E38 s~;;€~.%;. asiciesxg "$1 Per' <:<:mE'.1"a.7 %:.}'1€: §€%z;2*m;?c§ C<3u§":*:e;eE fa: 7. §é':§% re:e;'p{}:":€i§%nE.$ s~:.up§><>r§:&:d the ii"IE};}i§§};i"E€:Z'i <>r<£e%:*,__;'""' T?§?3: $:.:$3s--s€e1z'1i'.i21E qua-::3i:.i<:»n g:>;fE.:s¢nv f;;E1'3;E.'-- 2i_;s*.%s7€s; ':%1:>:* mar <:e>:'1s-;i{ie:"22'E.£(3r1 13:': fgfhxiseg appziai "W'h<:3:n the {é<}nf§s<:21'i.f3_é_i'*~...g<}{>€i§::~V (Es: T';:{>t;«._ '§'zr-111% uilraier SE::<:§',§{m 1.23 :}f *:L:'hs:.?§ _A,;:€; *;=;:'3;"§.2§i*£ ;Z.;*~f; fiihé 'm.:r{ier: of ;:s':5_:>5Gf %:%zE1_§_:§}:«,_ §§§:=:<:::;. wiiith the D6: a:"§.m.e:z:: ix) I'§;¥.">,.«-96', 1:§'£:?ss%;i E:h?6~ . ;~_4s;s3§:»:;I3d if{>(§d:€; V V _ z . _ _. {'13 7:?-}.1r°:'*:__ g;<:_é3:3;_s; afiad whezi €f2X£i(fi'.§}f ihcz ssafgi "?:2u_:'ci.;{f':i°":-.;3:::::: 'iiézr hazfxzié b§?§;":'IE s:h;i§ta.::%d {Ii} _ _%:.Ef;é:: §;"<3:'s~§:).21_'§?:*{>§'t_1 ?;s;x'h<3s:§€ 'p<35s;e$:'~i;§:}:1 €319 grrméis f:-aft: --f§§é?§;#f€?:%;i§(i\'«.,. _____ })fi?'.fE'?:i_v§$1ESS§L{}i"£1E% E':{:€;, Eiééfii is; 21 {?<}:1s§{3Ei.{i;::i.§:1§§ .:%:=::€:.,V E'::€3_€I'§§ i{§.1"i' $3 %;.fE2€:: {%ei':%:"1.i§,§{:si': {:'§&"i§iiE%{"ix ~.%,%<:s':~: i/?:{2§f: <;§z3:§E:':es; :=g%;;3*£: "'§§32g3<§:°E:s~?{.% §:§:}<f:§.§:'~s5" :2':{<:2%:;2§«; :.:m§€:"':
"§z'§':_§}<::*§':a-%<% g§;{::<_*:::§§;§"' :§.:{::--é;:'::e% az':§; ;g;:;::i;=.::§:«:»; §;::2"§::,.2_g;{§:'§' .§§.'s'§.?§.<..} §_m:§§_2;*: :§*::':::s_": 2: §3§:,.::_':a?. s:}:..zés~;i{§{:=. §z:{§'£.;":. §:3':.:§: W,,...W \ 9 éiaez'-.'~s moi'; §}'}(T§"Li(§{iE g;0<>ciés w'E3£<?h §'::a.xr@ "E3e::e.n {%E2?:;'%.::*é;>{§ €01" E1<}:":':<3 <*;<}:'é:s;m2§pt'i{H'L 5§€{,'f§1§{f3I'"i iiiéiiééi c%e§iz":t*,:e:. "5;z"z::L,z5§a§£.§1;-;°"' '1m<i:'>:': "3m1.:gg§in§__-§" in 'ri%i21i;i@:: 711:3 any 3 xnearis émy act: €33: cuznéssism arvE:i{?:§§"~..j.xr'§E§E'V. L. r€:::'1{i<;é§ :'~?su<:§: g§<><3cE$ E§éTi$i31*:f'"M'€:{)"if{}f}if§.E3§iféTfi','%C}gE"iV zmder :e*-;:e*,<:\:;§<7,s:'1; 'M E. 0}.' s;;e<:i;§r,i::. 1:3 $€t:";'i',i{}§jE 3 E3 {i=--"i,€:h; {?{}I;'§'§':i§%:if_fTE1I fi{}fiW sf §m§r<3'p<:~r}y i:*r1p0;"z?:@{i, §ig{?iV;()C1i%':."[§;:' i:.€f'.e 3?'fE§€'§"{;%EiS Sé;%:::i:'::»:": M3 éeais; wig": €:c3'§";E'is;<t2:%:i<m:~ ';<?s_'§,§.:t1*_1;3p'é;s:r{i {Q bi? iI:3p:*<}§§{%%E§;.§€:;p{3§'%:zE€i;"*3{{L §=%<L:"é*,.i{>1': E22 {:32} {§é3:aE$ w.13f;:E§ %:h.:L% §3'»'E':{FC¥;'i'.€_i1;iV§'{Tt é;'2::§:*'~.;£.{§_§i:i:3;i'{;;2i.§<}§': sf {.'.{}E1§§SCE1ii{}I"iEr3 2;-'s3'1{i §}e:2e;1_i:§€::<.=s. = V' 8%;%{Ei'§{§§:«_ E2.Z§[2:a§ {§&'tEf:E$ w§i:.Z%'; 'm.::':"§<:z: ca? ;2:f::s<>£" in g:?.<%%%j'f;.:3;§.zi E°€2}i{§§'-5 Z3,§'E{§sEE':
{2:}'""--€:1 2: ~E;§:¥;'E"§.\§«:f§¢€¢:,? $z,1::;:E': iéiéiiiif frzzrag "%:£":{:~ ;:sé:as3§s'%%s3&§§<,m sf §,1§'§;}7 p€:':°§{:%:2§ --
aim §;%3e §}:;2rs5s{}:'";_ §'mm %.:s..:-"'§"2{.";§g§;: ;:sai}sz:::sé::s:;as.;i{,>:': 'figs: ;;;::><_§{:§&+; -5*'-?s%i?*§i-¢i§?'.{§;
if 2;::':.§; §}€3.IE;"~E:'%{}3E§ {'}§.l§".§.%iif.:" %}.E2az;'1. 'E:'.E":::=: §.',}€;%E"i'=:-ESE': §':i'{s:":: Wu.
'wwn-fl' 2a%'%'2a:'::'~;:;:% §§<:5e::;a%:e:s;'§{}a": %3_':':£: §2§§}(3{'i§%§ *:2;€::°ai= :<;a:s2?:;:::;;r::'i.§ §:::<:i. is; z.::;3<>:'2 him. "_E'h§:~i-3 p':<*:w§si<::§'3 is-; ix": é:':*1<-% m::?tz.1r:=: 9%' an a::§:;::i:%§}$:é:§m 33:} $€{'f§'.'i{)§ES EGE zmsi 192, $<:é:':i',§.=:3:': E633 is; mat. mE,€3:'1§:e,{i :':'{::: :'"€'%§i€"¥i% 2121:; ;§¢::<§€3¥:3 sf {he-1:: {£111}? or bz1:t'ii:%:':. it thaé, wh:r.~.=é:'1 221__E§l;€é:%"'{ ~§: {:% §E"§E'J€{i {whfifgmzr ;1§f§:rz:121E,i*«€ er §};§;§§_§Ei':.i'€a'{i:3' = _~'§"('3:{'.~€.§"l;§;'E.§uf~3Ej,*."'A3i§' " wfihiza 'éhc::': }_<;1":<:s*.sg,-*1:-;*T{§L;_'§£*: of a pg1r"€.jq§-,i€. :T"._.'s_és%fe':5:"' mm fr) '§:;sff'§&§.,r":'=::i;' ii. it £3-.mb<}«:§i<é;<5 21 :"1.1§.€ iE":2::."§, 'Ax-%%:'-:::;'e: %'§:a: sszggiaj &"5?Z:37Z;i£§'iéi.1.;.f'E}§??T; sf 'i.§":<3 21E}.<;%§;,f2':€:i{::r: E63 pesgtuii21ri3;f___1i%'i%hi5:g izhé ':<:.::ve:'y2..>:2§§§é(¥;g§e {:25 9:16: at" f{.h<'3 §}2£'§"{i£*S§ fné' g>g::*§.j2:j r%;::.;$i1."-;§:'§}4¢<:3%,, "%;a:%1e%;.h.<3r it be 9? am. :1;§"§'i1'n';;:i;.iéJe {.?;:9é:' ;1V$g§;é:€;§§:§é s::§.?:2é.;:§;*é;::W:'.:>3", ::m_:"i m»-1:21;. é:h<m§;§h E',§.:€'ré[ '§3::%~._2'i';;:i"£:«§:;€}.m;3t§.i:wn af §:.;1w in hisa fazrisytzz V22: §}{--§'3£i:V*:5;§3?g:%i%h_$'::i:;§§g§.<3{§ g;§os><:Ess§ i:}3::: ;§xE:}f'_7X €<:»m'%: I*::4:.e::§' 2:13;'? <,";a:7§:as~si:}§:""é,'<§'V{:m;'::§;§{§e:* Ehia pri"ra<t§;3E_é;*: in s:§<«":§:aii " "Es"; '§;'§'1_§;%'--.A_&%::;;3:%>ss;2_ j::}§' figiieezmés ai" Slifiifiiflfig §z§a&r§.$ 332$ $:,§ffze3°$~ éfigéfiixaarmuifi :*<>§§{>:f%:€:::i Ea 3§§3{§3§ Efiqi'. nifiéfi w§"2§»::E";. 2?;:"'<}§;»;=:% ':.:§"s::E§?*€ $316 $92: §::§,4§§%§;.{}E1'.'§&T~§ A:;t:':; mm 2:; $225: <':<";':m;3§<:"é: sf," {'E:;::2:s1%%: éj§.'§§ aiz' $§':{Ti'5['.§€fi%§'E 13%'? in 9
---aa?é'*;§zé§': 3%:-%<?€.§<,}§'1 E? {i<:':.»é::'>~; 33:3': 22;}§}E.§.-"I. '§'E:€;> $'E.§§}§."§:'§"£"§€? éifs:s2;_.:%.;*f:: 'E;z§::§ §'i{::a.a:§": ':'.'§":.€i*. §'>§;E<;}2»r§:'2§4§ §}3"§3'§{"7§§-}3%"'?;%» §%1:»§i<>wi.:":§,;,>§ gm. isms, 'i"§3:%y hzasze iaiici {:§<'3W.z"; 'i:E'§é:~ iaawsz in :h::? ;}r<}<;%:?:<a-:'::s, We. aim? 1.s_na§}E.€: $.53 :1};-xiii: 92:3' w§'22.:z€: i.,':'3€ ism' *9.-*E'3%z:h is; {"'.§f;'.'.':;:1.E'§}' isaéd {E<::w§'2, E3? zgizfémazzazaiiazf"i.?:£s.: ": 2': '§":'EE";»1.::'_;2.z_§ wE':§s:?.%2 ss3_pa::%=:_':.'gz?:§§:+;e:%s:§ ':§=<;:2jy', ;¥..:~*:;'::i7-:;iT:<-35;':§.;{;E' "L-:5? . zszppiyiragg Eh; {Hind iii; the f';a:<:ts {;;f"' £:§*é_':£§:-; -%;.r;'2;:<3<j»2,'AT'€;¥»;: €:h_é;':; s3f£,2m.zi.ory §}r<)vi:-.;i<m§; zzznd é'.i":<e: p.r%':j:<:§--;}i§ée:: :2:/@>§\;%'eci;. t';§f'~.. " E"E1{}Z"€ ?.'.l121:1 E7<>u:" {$6 :a::'§;<:s§ 2-1;{';r:§ ""V§§fs3<:i{§ar::w.. Etélfiie ":;::a.é.::: '"E*%.21.§; If€¥§.}{}X&'ii§{i j:_.:dg:::e'§1t: W%1§.::E"§ <:.:1'3';'2:";::«f*§,' a2;3g>:"{§'e'::*:<i zmii :*:am':e::>t. be i;::'e23_§',e:§ 2155 .23; _§.';L:c§§g:aée::V1i,__.};%s--}i%g§<.:§é' :'é3:.:2<§€:r<:*.-zi after r€:§e'zf:*i§1§j *1::Q"_'-- iih:.i}S€*,. §...:i2c%g_;i_r*1%:é:';4f{'.;§; :f'é:0 2-xzhiérh 211 :"e§"€:r:?:'Lsfi:€ is-3' ':12fa::_§§&. 'E"h;é'u{ig:z.§eni. in f§?'%:weefi. /§?:.;':'2ed K§"?;{Z£"L_ 'épégggéié V{i<§*2.§;'fé --4.:'t:.e:2V'E:e%%,f§%;?',« K <>:'2§y E1216 'f:*§.'m.:_:":a§ $12155 'Ea<f§§_i2§e:z:*s:§; -v:?:'.':é'i'<_: ;¥2,:s:i:§m::m cf Q22 ,;%§:es_*,. .3<';:.,:§*%;'. "='§.,;} '%§£h:i{.':'._"§~, wz:%A. %f:z';a:.:*:=%"':i"2'éI:.<§5: 21 r@§i:;*>a:°<::*.:"g:;:t;-=2 in <§@::a1§§, 3%: ii'%'¥;'}§.3§§§ §:;::»*3 ':;§':é"<,§2v:; iE.§g§.Z§:. ré;?g;fz1:"{i§:';§_{ %1s_;:.>»: §f§"§%ff§§:§«€2? :z:;::%".i.§:ys £23' béi' iiségéiit v,:§1::}'": E33; €:<}'§.1§"§',E~.":; in 11.2%:-2:', {tsm':$;<?=.>;§:
-- S€:<::*;:.§{f»:'": "~-- E{§'€§ 35$ ;:;j>§}§i<:z:b§ee £2': :;i;.Ih:':§ a:<>'::"i;$>s:*:: S€:<i€:i<§:2 i?;3 'Eta: ?E:;¢:-i=. asz2s:i:;7::"::;€,{:s::a{'i £~f:.E."E{'§ ;7a':}<'::-»'::: 22$, '§':<.>w _ ;.m{'§ 5e;;':'mg§,;:Ee3.{§ fiiéiflfifé §'":2-233:? is be: {__é<:3_:':i%;é{§s%;*s:.%<i " = €f':::'>:..§§":i's%;. '§'E:':2_;f;: {'i§*£€;i'%'i_E.'§.;:"~:if E1': 225:2: '::sa%:s::3 {'§{.§§'E,€,Z in *§E:":;:::__§", "«2'a:*>$»'v 5 am 7*:
hzwéss §;"3{)SS€':'£~§E'5€fE "£1229 :fi:.><'%un':ez'1*:.s $i'1z'>w§:':g ifiiée :9 £13.19 :5aa:1?<:E p:'<3;'3<:t=:_*'é_j5;. if her §'12::.sas ;'}14::*':.ri':21.se;e{?£ it §":"<:;m 2:. dea;Ee3?.:}"-02*' 2:2. 'a:JE":<:sE€r:--€;;2:§E€=,z: ?;'§3<;%m $E:_{:;:.:;§<.§ héér S{}§"£'.'£%;? €§§:<i:.:.§:":éé=:~::?§}?:§ m*§a:%:;%:1<:§2'1;_{ §S'£.E("'h p':2;r<':§':3,:-3:3, E? gmt. _':2éé*E'j§:*a}{;»r:éE':1;;§; '"E":1«:'~_**_:*s;*%E"::>re..§ 31¢}: iznézial §3:'%3§<3::,:z:€'if3%?i}.Ez};*'3 T 9:)? 1'~§_:'i':'?..<$L:§%fl§?é:. {?3;I':I1{)€L bi: i';*.Xiir'3§"i{§€fd to {E36 §'£:_:§';:eg3z':c£cm:s.V §_§<><:}&5:; Me: ail §;£r<;2'i1:g §'0_§'e:%1?gn m;2:r.k§I1§§;»as, in iizgégzitéssyiaff:
$3? any 1'}'if¢1t.€:§"ia.§ '(.0 s_E2o"§;*% €;§1z1"é.}._§}';'» ';§::Ti::*.{;%%*::}:::%;€3{§ {mm 23; :"c=:gg;ist:e§f€d deaief £i§3.e1ii:_1'g a£%I'i:}Ei: .tET:¢§:a::;% g;c}'::s«;§s zzzmi in {he Eigfifi sf \'».-*s:hz>i*:. :;Efié:j§_g ".h:%;*..-*:§'é»:.{:},:i?:€é£§in tzbé §;'£::«;it::=:m€:m; ands.-=.r Sé3<i:{'é{§n £08;.j5§3u:"Ei{>:;':_ k:::f ;:r:':rsv;Zng £:§1a"§. i:E1ey were ;2u':q'::i3:°é2d = igm-¥§'z3_i§.}( "s;:§';v§§i:.é;..'__€§g': in if :'<:sp<}.r:cii-zmtsh "_§'%1{;sy .ha'<;-*9 r::.§s€:';:%i%E3; §"22i2v:r<i E-'::s $2.2E:$i:a_:2.€'§.21'€:r;% €.hs::>i':° 'E§'§1;7--: ':"'<;és:;§§5;}*i1<:i;i:;-%:'1éséé'.:;'§'£.%§m" $E'E£}LiE€.i §".i23§J'{% §}§'{}d'E,%.{'.3é3£§: d<'>Cz.§;ne;z§.£:s-3 As;=;.--£":a:;s*;a;=§«.:-*:i:é§:.Vv'"i:Ef1'::.?'.VA'j~.f§.?%1<;§s€: g<:;<>{§s-s VJ{?§"é;'f Em-'rgmfi. Eb}? §1:;m»:: {::m";s;,::f::p§é{§:: . :35': ;3z=:j.s::2e':";t: éiteé' $225.52, $<}:.2g,'§;Ez%;;. :0 Egg? .r_:'::;-1<§@ €}?,'§§,'I ;_'5E"i '::E':<-éir s_;§£1.§:§>.m:m':%.$ £3?' '§.:h§3y E"§£'§'§r'€;'? ;mr<:h;»1s5{?:{E "E? .§%;'23_%£f:%*:_. {E33 {}§}é',,E2 §:r2a2:§«:<%%. ':v§'_1:a.>..:'e<.;'-;-: ii; is; 22.:r'a,i§a%.3Ea:% E23. §3_§.<%§3é:§; .., §'r<§:;%2:3. £52.: §'§1'"§2fi §"§§fi}i§Eéi.E"., €IIE'::3:':.s"§2é:.sL '§'7%:§;:}--" §":;;':_*s:i:: §Ei:i§=::é<§ Ea; : §}§"€f}§7{,.' '§;s;3t::§: iiiézsi '=J=;::"s;§:3:'2:~:: §§§i~'§?:'3_ $33; 'E"EEE€f?§'L '§"§j:_:%,;€s;7:§'<:}§':::, Eh e:}:::':§.§}-" §:':'a%?s;é:4;é.i.%.:s§{'3 {"7€i§I'EiT§€.E§§§i.}§.§ %j.E':2.1§ <*a:'é:.,r§{.E. Eféé? i"':?2;Ei,i'§!'i€:if€ii_ is; a.§'?,f A Ex) JV)";
'E'h:? <}:*<iie3.rs%; §}8.S:'sS€?€f3 by EEEE: :3r§gi):":2;.§_ ::n:§.%':<>2'ii?y wail 2315:: £:i§'}'§}i'.?§§éiE€;* 2:1,2.%i.E*:§?s:f:§_E':§2 2:.a:*::~. §"'i'3S'§'{}§°€.'{.§.. V Pa:*i'.ié5:e; £3 bear" §;h:::i;' {mix} £?{§S~}i;S*$. m x<'»%\%%? >> , '3fi~.W'c.'.-xg