Karnataka High Court
B Raghavendra Hegde vs Manorma J Shanbhogue on 6 September, 2011
Author: L.Narayana Swamy
Bench: Lnarkyana Swamy
4
6•
Decree of Appellate Court
ICR I A. 35 CPC) HR No. 32A
IN TI.; E H1GB COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
BEFORE
THE HON BLE MR. JUSTICE LNARkYANA SWAMY
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO 1241 OF 2003
APPELLANTS
B ARC I iAVENDRA H LODE, 66 YEARS
S/0 LATE PADMANAf3HA HEODE
R/OSV1ISSION SCHOOL LANE
KARKAL TOWN AND POST UDUFI DISTRICT.
SINCE DECEASED, REP BY HIS L:RS1,
I (A S IT, WOLF.ITHA H HEODE,
FL: C LATE L. RD04 1. 1 Vt" BE
3A,uijnI1'S;\F,zA,;L:JrTh.
LATE B RACLiAVEI EDRA fIlL'
o) fOOT. B. SAHITIJA H HEODE,
AOfI 1) YEARS,
B/C. LATE H. HAOf1AVENDRA HEOLAE.
dl EDT S SUJ3YA C EiEODE
At ) VEAPct
I. ama P. IJACA I cm O.tAp A
H
c'ra I
ci .c -.
EL CfID AS Pif.•ft COIL ET OHITIIIE DATED: SQ S ;
IA 'CA
t41i2zQQ
RESPONDENTS
'AJflRilMA 1 HA P[]514flfl1 P
fl, \N
Wi C). LYTE J\C3\33'5' SF! SNBOGLE
4, ' R 13 uM UR GE
KUNDAPUR TOWN, RUNDAPUR, UIAUPI DISTRICT.
SINCE RF.:SPONDENT NO.1 IS DlED
PEP. BY HEH LRS,,
M15F)E AS PER COURT ORDER DATED: 5220 I 01.
I. (a) SRI. S ATHISH SHAN'BOGILE
AGED 34 YEARS.
S/0. JAGANATH SHANBOGUE
R/ 0. NIl AR HONUMAN GARAGE,
RUNDAPUR,
UDUPI DISTRICT.
1(5) B. PRARASH SHANBOGUE
AGED ABOUT 37 YEJRS,
S/O. JAGANATH SHANBOGUE
RIO. uEAR HANUMAN GARAGE.
2 T137 U
R. [3(21301 DISTRiCT.
t
RUNIDAPL
2. ANANDI NARAYANI HAl
Age: 84 YEAR 5,
W/O. LATE PADMANAPHA HEGDE
,_ ( ,
KARPi\3A TOWI% ANL) 0(25'!'
LIDLJT'I DI5TR[C:T
3. DR. B RAMALARSHA HEGDE
Age: 62 YEARS
/ 01 LATE PADIvLLNABHA R.EGDE
- U
-
)2IANCAL.ORJS TO. IDE. SINCE RESPONDENT NG,3 IS: DIED. REP. BY HIS LEG.
(AMENDED AS PER COURT ORDER FATED: 52:ID0i0) 3(a) SMT. B. MEENAKSHI STRODE, W/ 0. LATE KAMALAKSHA H EOD S. ROSA) 60 YEARS, ANUORAIIA MARUTHI NAOAR. NH. 17, BHATKAL.
3DJ SF 'IT GAYAT'HRl PRABHU W/O. DR. GANESH PRABHU, AGED 33 YEARS, ANLORAHA MARUTHI NAGAR. NH. 17, Bi-LYTEAL 4, B ANNAPPA HEODE, 35. YEARS S /0 LATE PADMANAB F-IA HEODE R/OMISSiON SCHOOL LANE, KARKAL TOWN AND POST UDLIPI DISTRICT
5. DR. UI/HA D KAM;ATH, 63 YEARS W/OLDAMODHAR KAMATFI MAJOR, USHA CLINIC R/OSIDHARTHA NAGAR MYSORE.
6. SUJvIATHI KAMATH, 55 W/ 0. SRIVARAYA KAMATH A 4 R 3' 77 J 1 z\ t BAiNJ1.WAL. DIG
7. SLTBHADA 17 SIERRA. 54 YEARS SHAN EAR SHANBHOGUE W/OSHANKAR SHANBHOGUE MITHAGHAR ROAD, ;:VIHt-L. B (.5). BOY/BAY 8, NI DEVAI3AS PHAT. 55 YEARS r. IG L A APPELLANT. K S AT. HA 5115 1JCHANO ER MARG, UDFJPI TOWN'' AND POST 9 .JAAI\EH5155 FEAT D/OM.DEVADAS BRAT RFA NOfl.24j2OO3 MAJOR BY AGE R/ABHA.RISHCHANDRA MARO UDUPI TOWN AND POST
10. JAIFJSHAN BRAT MAJOR BY AOE S/OJvLDEVADAS HEiST LHARISHCHANDRA MARO t R/A UDUFI TOWN AND POST Ii. OEETHA HEODE, 55 YEARS W/0J3 RAOHAVENDRA HEODE P/OMISSION SCHOOL LANE, KARKALA TOWN AND PCST KARKALA.
12. SUDHIR HE ODE, 22 YEARS S/ORRAOHAVENDRA HEODE MISSION SCHOOL LANE KARKALA (R 11 AND 12 ARE DELETED AS PER COURT: ORDER LATED: 19,10,2010).
13. RANEACHANDRA HEODE, 24 YEARS S/O. D.. R. KAMAUAKSHA HEOLE PANAMBOOR OP MANOALORE TQ PANAMBOOR POST, D,K.
14. DAMODHAR HEODE, 14 YEARS S/O. HANTAPPA HEODE MISSION SCHOOL UANE KARKAUA, KR.
ML OR BY OUARDIAN ADLITRM PATHER H ANNAPPA HEODE This Regular Pirst Appeal preferred against the Judgment and Decree of the of the PRINCIPAL CIY1L JUDGE (SRDN), CJM, UDUPI in OS No. 215 of 19S9 o.n its file dat.ed the 30 TB DAY OP AUGUST, 2003 coming on for hearing on the. 06 TB DAY OP RFANO. 1241L2003 S.E.PTEMBER, 2011 i.n the presence of Sri, N RAVINDRANATH KARL.TH, Ade ocate fbr .r nooei..iaca: 1. (a.-di. Sri. Plharnnri.hor, Adrocate- tar R•-2. 5 & 6. Smt. SHEFS'Ah, for K,M,NATARAJ, .Advocate hr R4, R7 to 10 & 13...
2 ads 3-2 taR sep. by R-4.
An.d..for the reasons stated in the Judgment, it is ordered and decreed that, this Reaular First Aooeal. be H the same is hereby dismissed, by afiirrning the jndgment and decree passed by the trirl UU L. Arid it is canner oniered cain decreed that. there shalt be on amer as to costs in this Apeai.
Giren under my hand arid the seal of this Court, this the 06 Th OF ShPrhN:BhR, 2011.
V ASSISTANTL,R,E.QJSPRAR ,t itt& 5 Its,a p*siaar 1 HIS "n" at U -- estm SCHEDULE IN OS NO. 21Sf 1989 n 'k_ SCHEDULE "A":
a --,
Cu L1 ul
"hi ia "a" c ud on 'n rat
1'
-6-
RYANO. 124112003 Non-residential premises with upstairs bearing Door No.152 (Old.No.7 1) situated in ward no.2, Karkala Town Municipality in S.No. 133/3. The tenancy right over the premises is valued approximately at Rs.60,000/- (Rupees sixty thousand only).
2. The following immovable properties situated in Karkala Kasba village of Karkala Taluk, held on Mull right.
S.No. 136/50-Garden-O.26
-with tiled residential buildings with upstairs etc., (Door No.1 14/IV)-valued at Rs.50,000-00- 18 Coconut trees, 3 mango trees etc.,
3. The following properties situated in Karkala Kasba village of Karkala Taluk, held on muli right.
• S.No. 136/35-Garden -0.03 0-31.
S.No.136/34-Garden -0.02 0-35.
- with non-residential buildings consisting of 7 shops occupied by building tenants on an aggregate monthly rental of Rs. 1,500-00 (Rupees one thousand and five hundred only). They can be valued at Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand only);
4. The following propcrtics situated in Bola Village of Karkala Taluk.
6 7RPA NO 124 1L2003 GiNo tWo &SDNo Kissam Pxtet As ssmeat 19 Ua 0 ri 'tt Ac 4 1 .1 .1 V N EoO1fl?T ONVRJ With 2 tiled 05114011175 (lnOiSIOitiZ IDairiodara Rice frees 0uiithas hatti kottige of a total value of Rs.80,000t 0, 200 coconut trees, fO 5t'jfl11t and other trees.
"B" SCHEDULE
a) Movables situated in the Plaint house in item No. 2 of the plaint 'A' Schedule.
Si, No, Particulars Valued at
1. .
Entering Hall
1 36" x 32" Wooden stand 4 rack 1 100.00
2 20" a IS" Wooden Chairs 3 22.5.00
or, Sr fr07f
4 60 xDM Ron sofa um bed 52020
6" size children cycle 3 wheel 1 400.00
7 42 car 'tr fpr 1
5 77" 20" iVhrror of I1
V'ooeleri irame I 200.00
9 iS" a 12." Mirror of Wooden fume 1 75.00
Wail ri'r.a 130.1)0
11 15" x 15" wooden framed father 100.00
ohotm I
Photol
'l
-10-
RFA NO.124112003 13 24" x 12" Lord ganapathy Photo 1 i 100.00 :
14 24" x 12" Lord Sathyanarayana 100.00 Photo 1 15 6" x 4" Lord Ganapathy photo 1 50.00 16 Hard soil elephant face 2 30.00 17 Hard soil flower rester 2 30.00 18 Plastic Flower 2 20.00 19 15 amp. Copper point plug sockets 30.00 . 2 20 I 15 amps. Copper point switch 5 15.00 I Bulb Holders - Brass 2 -- 10.b0 --
n--"ii&;inH 23 l5WattsColourbulbs4 1 20.00 ---
24 24" x 18" cotton window screen 2 30.00 --
;
Total 1 4,395.00
2. , Middle Room:
25 40" x 30" Wooden show cause @ 400.00
Glass frame
26 r.d.2... above
300.00
27 70" x 36" x 35" total dosed wooden 1500.00
boxi
---".-...-.--..-
--
28 65" x 75" wooden cot 1 1000.00 t S -11- Rfl NO. 124112003
29) Iron garden chair (wire) 2 -- 150.00 30 72" x 48" x 12" Wooden cupboard of 1500.00 4 racks with glass and wooden frame 1 31 42" GEC Ceiling fan with regulator 500.00 I No.1 rr i [ 33 34 [ Mastic BulbHolders3 8" x 6" sunmica/switch board 1 15.00 15.00 15 amps. Copper point plug socket -- 30.00 I 2 36 : 15 amps. Copper point switch 3 40.OOj [ 37 18" Dynarablack and white TV 1 3500.00 --j i 38 voier [59 5tt TV Booster 1 ã&oöâ --
----
40 . Hard soil flower rester 20.00 41 Hardsoilplasticflower2 20.00 42 j : 30' x 18" Devi mariamrna photo 1 100.00 o" x 6" photo of all children of B. ' I Padmanabha Hegde 8 120.00 44 36" x 24" wooden framed photo of 150.00 Sri. Gururaghavendra swamy 1 rr: iÔiia&iira;closer 500.00 10,785.00 N -12- RYANO. 124112003 3 God's Room 46 48" x 36" 3 Rack cup board with I 500.00 1
--
' doorl
ThT 6-1/2' Godrej Almera with locker 1 3000.00
48 20" height 8" diameter copper 500.00
vessell
49 18" diameter plastic bucket with lid 100.00
-
50 30" x 12" x 6" wooden bench 1 1
-
50.00
51 24" z 15" show case with 3 side 300.00
glassi
52.20"x14" show case with single sidej 150.00
glas
53 24" x 18" wooden cup board 1 100.00
4 feet length bajaj tube light set 1 - 125.00
55 15 amps copper point plug socket 2
-
3oMa
56 15 amps copper point switch 3 45.00
57 30" x 24" photo wooden framed of - 150.00
Lord Venkataramana 1 24" x 18" wooden framed sharada 100.00 30" x 24" sharada devi photo 1 150.00 20 Laxrnideviwoodenframed t ioO.00 photo 1 RFA1LQJ4iJ2QQ di 18" a 10" Sri saibaba roto wnouen 75200 framedl 62 12" a 10" Lord Dasharatbara 50CC) wooden framed photo 1 65 12" a 8 Sri, Guru wooden droned 5000 photol
-- ---.--- ------
10" a 5 otner Photos of woooen .
20000 frame 8 7 n iS- c 66 Erass hanging deepam 1 100.00 67 Brass dee pain keeping in door 1 2.500 68 Wooden stand tcd1. ean.e 1 25.00
69. trticir eontaining in cup board 25 200.00 Total .
. 6,240.00 4 hiningHali -
a b sunrnic a elinais table 1000.00 1 Sunmiea wooden chairs 6 600.00 2 <7 "
45" steel touring table I .300.00 73 2 burner stainless .steel gas overt 1 1200.00 L-7 :.
7 .. napr 75 18" a 15" a 15" wooden brat with lid 200.00 76• 4 feet tube light set Phdhps 1 1115.00 78 15 sinus 3 pin eonper socket 2 30.00 -14- RYA NO. 124112003 79 15 amps 3 pin copper switch 4 60.00 80 81 1 Bulbholder2 Stainless steel ring 5 1 10.00 40.00 J 83 82 Ohee and pickles bottles 4 Glass sho jug 1 F 1 15.00 100.00 r-------------- 86 Tooth paste 1 15.00 L-!*J..__L_.e...._J 88 Steel Vessel Holder 1 20.00 L...i_t.irc f•• --.
90 Plastic wash basin with Novel --. 300.00
Total 4670.00
II
91 ,
flbnRoom
Two Burner steel gas oven 1
-
1200.00
-- -J
92 16.5 kg gas Cylinder 1 500.00
93 2 plate 3 KW Johnson hot plate 1 -- 750.Ô0 -
-- .... ----. --... .--.--...._.--.-- .. -- --
94 Smgle plate 1 KW Sony Hot plate 1 400.00
- .._
.
racksi
V '----1
Wooden CuPboard --
Sracksl
97 . Field Star electric wet grinder 1 . 1500.00
98 il2rbumnheter 30' height water 600.00
: Vessel I
100 Stainless steel meals plates 10 300.00
'1
4,
-15-
RPA NO. 124112003 j 101 Stainless steel curry plates 15 375.00 102 : Glass plates of Curry 15 150.00 :
103 Stainless steel 12" Diameter plates 180.00 12 104 -do- -do-B" -do- 6 60.00 105 -do- -do- 6" diameter Mandi 6 60.00 106 Stainless steel 14" it 8" Rice plates 2 300.00 107 Stainless steel 10" x 6" Vessel 1 -- 50.00 108 Stainless steel 10" it 8" vessei 3 150.00 1109 Stainlesssteelthambige3 tow "! 110 Prestige cooker set 2 800.00 1 112
-. Sumitrnirgl Mixy stand 1 J 1200.00 50.00 113 Cudgels2 i00S)0 114 Coconut cutting articles 2 I 100.00 115 - Ironcudgels3 - 45.00 116 Plastic Containers 18 90.00 117 Iron dosa kavali 2 50.00 k---
118 Stecl souts 2 30.00
TfflThd"ãC
Total - 10645.00
120 Steel souts 6 100.00
[ lwrmaiaarJ&awro
V
.16-
RPA NO. 124112003 123 Steel spoons big 6 30.00 124 Steel thopu 10 300.00 fli3W Wooden cupboard 30" x 24" 2 - 100.00 r iiijitj&kai fio:oo 127 -do- Switchers 4 60.00 128 ; ] 5 amps. Copper point switch 5 25.00 E &iunmica board 2 1 F 30.00 ' 130 Brass box with lid6 150.00 ThbEi [ isifieter &ã tJwfI i&iöb 132 • 10" diameter bowl 1 50.00 133 Stecl bowl basin 12" x 6" 3 100.00 134 -do-8"x5"3 50.00 135 Transparent plastic container big 5 50.00 136 -- -do- - sniall6 50.00 137 Bournvita empty bottles 8 25.ób 138 Horlicks empty bottles 24 25.00 139 Wooden spoon rester 2 50.00 140 Gas lighter electronic 1 40.00 141 Stainlees steel knife big & mnl1 6 60.00 142 Iron knife big & small 3 20.00 143 Stainless steel Scissors big & 50.00 small 5 '.4 Slay-
RYANO. 124112003 I 144 Stainless steel water tap 1 30.00 L 146 145 Iron kavali of Appa 2 Alluminium padvane 1 50.00 50.00 :
147 Water storing big steel thopu 3 225.00 • Total 12705.00 6 UpstaIrs Room I part:
148 18" diameter 8" height copper vessel 500.00 1 149 15" diameter 12" height copper 800.00 • katara2 150 14" diameter 10" height katara 2 700.00 151 12" diameter 10" height katara 3 900.00 r ro bamtaram &ioo --
[riM 153 8" diameter 9" height copper katra 2 TWdiameter 8" height copper katra 2 400.00 300.00 r" ma il"heightkapana2 I 3do.bo 1 157 1 16" height kodapanal 12" height 6" diameter vessel il r 250.00 150.00 I--.--. ---- -- --.
158 10" heightS" diameter vessels 2 200.00
159 8" height 5" diameter vessels 6 600.00
160 16" height 8" diameter vessel 1 500.00
161 Copper padavane of [dli big 1 500.00
.-- --
16• -do--do-srnall2 -- "ioOEoö 1
163 6" height 8" diameter vessels 2 200.00
t
I8
Rif&rfQt4 U2PQil zf julu 165 Bronze santa 3 i5000 ifb Seats bronze S 20000 c 2 SubO 168 Brdss errri 4 rsse s 2 1 20000 t i 170 hans i Iron O\c i 50000 17 1 1 St ft height 6" length wooden 7a, ,00 172 Keroser' stoe2 10000 17:3 Brass roake Stove: 2 30:QQO 17 Bras) mane aiding stow 1 15000 175 28" x 17" x 10" Iron bun with lid 1 15000 Total 9875M0
------
-
.177 . 173 kg Emergence a.s burrer .1 5000 178 18" diameter 8" height Iron kavali I 150730 1- 170 diameter 0" hei ht non kavali 2 20000 180 (tEd 3 heuse rii.uuL'i starter I 50000 181 0 & T 3 phase motor starter 1 07300 183 6" height 1" diameter brass 100730 t,bo.rrrbize 2 U -
156 Seats like article crass I 5000 187 Milk vessel 1 15000 188 18" height deepa 2 2O000 189 12" height deepa 1 100M0 190 10" diameter 1" w5dth brass thatta 100M0 2 191 8" riieaeeter width do 3 15000 192 - Nan savige maker 2 15000 193 Wooden --do- big I lOOMO 194 Wooden --do- small I 5000 . -
195 7" height 4" diameter brass 7ik00 thambige 3 cia :5 Eleeg 3 dbanaeter bass :
1 oa Rrrz,cc roa5 21cr ni srnil it __5 --
____ __ :_:
.
or'
1 198 Electric articles 25 20OOO
PART II:
199 46" x 24" snnmiea table 1 500 JiO
5 18" c.kc
a
m :rcFfl table I 30000
k*arrf:a eaa.ir rroa t -20- RFA NO. 124112003 204 60" x 30" x 7" book self wooden 1 150.00 205 Wooden stand 1 25.00 206 36" OEC fan with regulator 1 J 500.00
---- .- --- ..-.-.-'"---.. ...-. --.4 ' 207 4 feet tube set 1 125.00 208 Tennis bat 3 75.00 [j 209 I Tennis net plastic 1 25.00 210 Book and other stationery items 200.00 jyy: - E1 I..--
Total 16,225.00
7 B.R.H. Room
L I
36" x 18t steel table with drawer 1
-.- ..-.-212
....-.-.
I 600.00
- --... -".--- .--- ...---. ----... ---...--- --- .--- ---
I 213 24" x12"waterfilterwithtwo 500.00
L.._!
214
_._e±
56" 4 blade khaitan fan with 650.00
' regulator 1
215 4 feet tube light set 1 125.00
216 40 Watt bulbs 2 10.00 --
217 15"xiO"mirror2 1Oo.00 -
218 Ponds powder 1 hair oil 1 other 150.00
articles6
:
219 30" x 26" wooden stand 4 rack 1 . 100.00
rflo.6o"x30"woodencotl - 0:00
L
(7:.
I
-21-
RFA NO. 124112002 L 221 12" x 12" wooden stool 1 100.00 L ' ?L 223 f1 2 Emergency light 1 2 cell Eveready torchlight 1 15000 50.00 224 - Electrical iron box 1 ---
225 National Panasonic two in one 1 2700.00
-.- -----.--.-. .-------- . ----
227 Wall clock automatic 1 150.00 228 I Alaram clock with wooden box 1 100.00 Cane make basket 2 75.00 229 Li ' 230 15 amps. Copper point 3 pin socket 30.00 2 231 ! 15 amps. Copper point switches 2 30.00 L 2 32 5amps.Copper point switches 2 T&öfl 233 1 5 amps. Copper point holder 3 15.00 234 ! Wooden Geethopadesham 1 50.00 --
235 Wooden Sriram Jairam 1 25.00
236 : Plastic drum 18" x 36" with lid 1 150.00
rf 237
238
f Children book carrying bag 3
UmbrellaS + 3 folding 8 100.00
475.Ô0 FTh39 --- Wrist watches 5 1000.001 i____ [ wow 1 241 1" 100.00 Th5ri;h;r;rr rr Cotton piilows6 J .. --..
.. 10000 s&ir"
244 Flask 1 bowls and other in drawer 200.00 Total 9670.00 1 22 8 B,A.H. Room:
2 5 40dr25 wooentat ewitr2 iEm000 drawer 1 246 20 2 1 t woodc:ti chiur I 75.00 247 Table lamp 1 4000 248 6 22 feet dram steel Almariah wi.th 1560.00 mirror 1 240 E 70" 10' woooen mccc 1 100.00 250 70 x 50" mooriec cot I .
1600.010
18 \ 1
0 "surm'eanapoy2 70000
I -
2a2 Srmgar seeing machine i 100000
253 56" khatian flci \\:Sh recuJator 1 550.00
70* Oaf x 24" 4 racks iroc rack 1 250.00
255 48" x 24" 3 rack iron rack 1 150.00
r
--
a a ••
a co rrire aaii a
13" a. 13" a 8" woocieri stool I. 5000
N
45 0 Safari I Aristocrat suit cast 2 000 .00
0 t t seth iJo
1.) JiLt I .
I 5.00
70 mm cc a i i Do
1 2"x9 litii Saharawe with *51 3010,00
-23
265 stmnlem steel box 10 400 00
2bb Stainless eel titlin COit1effT
267 Stow less steer 10" a 8" katara 1 1 o0O0
268 12 iO"bi ozebowitni'o 1 15000
269 15 ps. Ceper point 3 pffi socket 3000
7
270 15 amos. Conner noah switches 2 30110
271 5 amps eoppnr point stGtehe.s 8 2G00
272 5 amps copper point holders 4 2500
Total 9665OO
273 Snnmieah swneti hoard 1 niastie 3 2500
274 Ijka time pic.ne I 6000
275 Wooden stand 2 5000
276 God ohoto 8 25000
277 Gorehes (3 cells 2 eelisi 2 1 OOeOO
278 Tool box With tools 2 000O
--,
278 Philimi two in onml
ioa t otto) i
tee )r)x whet 112 1 S -
L - . ..
2.83 100 gms ponds powder I 3000
284 AIl.ntnin.dtns rodes 4 .l200
2a7 llalur o ten in eon er stood I
0000
24
288 Plastic hoe Re mu
7 lid I tooe 2 7500
rIO Omore.aa 1 6000
290 Bharadwa diction arv 1 40 00
291 Beds cotton 4 7001)0
292 Pillows 8 2001)0
293 Bed sheets 10 2001)0
2.94 Brass make god statutes 8 15009
Total 14,260M0
9 Bath Room:
295 10" dlaneter 24" height copper 15001)0
vessel 2
296 12" diameter 12" height copper hot 3001)0
water he ater 1,
297 .
Op. rnniailr heat regoiator 1 .1. 5000 298 Loner vessel or wotenae 2 725000 PlastIc 1 p ,yc 20000
-
Th
--
•7:
301 12" copper vessel with lid 3 3001)0 092 2 hid Water toring dcc ant 1 130 C 0 O1P C .•%• A. $ cAl ,l$S. c.$. P.t° $l$lc ..!..
----- ' ' a I P 5 ] 5 --ia:;00 ;--igj Z5516:o 306 5 amps. Copper pohot holder 4 101)7' 25 RFANO r i C 308 Brass water tap 2 10000 309 Soap aird tooth brush rester 1 1000 310 Plastie soap bus with. soan 5 3500 311 Tooth naste I i500 312 Tbotb brush 6 1500 313 Plastic pipe 6 feet length 3 50M0 314 Wooden stand I 25.00 Total 3M45OO 1O Out House: 315 Kinetic tuna MEG 9465 (1) 3000J30 316 22" Ralleigh cycle 1 50000 317 Electrical items 25 20000 318 36" x 8" wooden sofa I 15000 310 36" x 30' woecen cloth stand 1 5000 320 ibid wooden ortlcnleg uosta.ir 25000 Total 4,15th00 Ii Out •side 32 1 21 feet plashe tnj.e. 4 graund 6 30000 324 Pia c pipe P oatr'np i0000 325 200 litre water storage drum 1 lsooo 26 326 314" Iron i7e 21' for TV 1 200 MO 327 1-1 /2 [nor pipe 21 tar TV I 25000 fl Antenn 4 40000 329 TV Booster for antenna 1 15000 TV Antena wire. 1 15000 Total i,890M0 331 940 foRM. Seo.ien pumpset I 2000,00 332 3 abase electric main switch 1 250.00 333 3 uuase electric starter 1 150.00 334 15 amps. Cut out 3 45.00 1.35 15 an.ps. S50tches 3 45.00 336 15 ps. Holders 5 2000 337 Wooden board 1 504110 335 320 wire 50 meters 1 00 3°0 - -. Iran pek axe 2 10Cr ii;' Iron 1p1krasJn pian axe a tO Out) Th_-PTh gaao 04 2. Old wooden windows 4 400.00 Cii tlrir..rrtn drier REt I 50000 aria 007fl to it) P1)!) (4)) 00' 'in or ooiox irs o.nos., roars 1000 OLu..,) Total 5335.0O 27 fNQ..J241L2PQ 13 Steel Articles in show case at LR: F Stel xx xxx od big 3 50 Oo 345 S ci ao r m 5 3 2 110 00 349 Steel Big ;ar with lid 1 7500 159 51551 Bia aawl ith lid 3 sooo 351 S1.,eei ?vledium bowl 3 10000 352 Ste ci Sm all bowl 6 1 2000 3a3 Steel Big) thambige 2 7000 33 te- (0 355 Steed Plate 10 dQQ0 356 Steel Meals plate 6 1 5000 --- --- -- . Fsf sail 100 00
terse!: Glass big 10 361 heel Round box 10 l.5000 362 Steel Big thopu 3 l5000 363 SIteel Med.ium thopu 6 l.0000 366 Steel Deepa small 4 SOGO 367 Steel Harivana big 3 15000 28 Th6ä St'el email 4 (medium) T 200 00 Steel Bowl big 10 1501)0 ..-----aOli.
370 Steel ndi g
Total 2,61000
14 Steel Articles in Wooden box:
371 H K Pai ol.ates 3 1001)0
3i2 Shivana.nda plates 3 10000
373 B. K. Hegde harivana 1 1001)0
374 Dr. Kallva dabbi 1 501)0
375 Dr. ELM. Thai dabba 1 401)0
376 Iviadhava Bhat dabba 1 4O.oo
Javalaxmi harlvaaa 1 50;00
¶1
-
5 DO
3713 . . CMKath 1 4000
.50 B H H S S Hi. S S .KarueHi tbaau 5 . 20000
1. B K Km iat..la and K V S.heno thopu 1201)0
2 A a'h Tb
dabtiMCK&NSH6 CO
-
2001)0
- --
I 71 K. I Hi I \24l4 I I
29
RPANO 1241J2003
Ix )
t I
36 Sb U) Ais ik ni OOO
dih)
Total 1,850.00
Total of item Nos 1 to 14 Item Na Pa Nos I 439300 2 1 8,00 240 0 6 0 0( 0 2( 0 T 10 30 RPANO. 1241)2003 I cottoN 9 e ae sA lcd d t a arka ad nesee a inn Nc e,den a hois a ited t en No 2o the airt 4 , heduic o ('oldA Nd cHic f 'nt yofM a 1 eB I I idrn r ih Dcci Me N t I BM ,lool' no N I DR lcd P F akras ra 1 (2) ye a r gus ,400 00 2 Mohar mat 1 3 so crc (600 00 Iddige ) t it cc r,0 00 o e c n B 2c1 3 00( I iip 00 0 I (I ) (0 C 31 RFANO._1241J2003 12 0 Oc sr' rrelcs Th00 50 Baianisara I -- sovereigns 0600.00
14. thatch saranaiies 2 -- 7 sovereigns 5400C0 15 . Deesaries 34 sovereigns 16 eous 1D-4soverejgns 8SOooo 17 Shirt Buttons 4 1/2 soverei.gns 3300M0 18 Godi.sara 2 7 sovereigns 1540000 19 Vyajaganthi male 1 5 sovereigns I I000MO 20 Child's garam patte 1 - 6 sovereign.s I 320000 (iii If. 9 .) .1 lflO in ''ilILLAUIiC ±iIlvcuctSc'Jct I 22 Beridoin :1 --2 sovereans .
23 (1 's hair star 1./duds 3 /2 3300.00
sovereigns
Total 2,38,8OOOO
I -
iii. U ri. sit. a •ovooisi nine .e.a.ruoaa a is
32
RFANO. 1241/2003
Re. P.
1 Arat.hi Harivana 20001)0
3 Akshatha thatte 1 50000
4
. Gandada thatte I .
40070
S Passer Dani I 500330
6 Milk 1 water plate 1 4003)0
7 Silver Glasses IS 9000...00
3 e
40 dprpc 707 013
9 Silver thamhige 1 200000
10 Theerthada thatte verb 300000
harivana2
11 Deeps showing in the 7501)0
o.iarriae,e I
-- 3 P
13 Spoons 6 6001)0
14 Boxes with designs 2 15003)0
15 Ruro knm bax 1 10(500
o . a aria ens castes
Total of Golden Artieles 2..353)0G00
Grand Total 2,67,40(500
C
It;
BYANQ_123 1/2903 SCHEDULE 'B' iL The blowing easn aniounts kept by defendmst. iso. 2. in t..ht. name of himse f, h.is wife and eh1dren in the vanons banks..
Bank Karkala in the name of B. neeiha He ode 2 RD LAD 17/87 -do- .
'IA. H , Cu.. h.arkai in lacy nameot 1 Savitba dtr'. I fLASH Sniana (No. 61 /88 and Sudhir (No. 159/88) no u60$udu Unit rust of. lanai in UUuU.Uu the name of B. Geetha Hegde No. 70011920 -- Unit Trust of India 680000 in the name of 2m1 defendant 6 Amo.unt lent to: Sri, K A Arabbi by 50O000 Cheque dated: 18,4.1985 of Vaya Bank, Uduph ::: the aJb&.ob Total. 54,6S0O0 34 RFANO. 1241J2003 SCHELULE W(di N5() C in trade of M/s. B. Padnsanabha S. Herneartct Sons.
ivieJtafl 000 anirnIssion Ait(tnL Msiiis Road. wa0000t siro areS ;n Door
51) 132/Ward 2.
;-
- -_- r
''
0
:"s en near sdeo coonter 1. 750.00 4 _e 4 10 kg c.apac.itr beam 5ca I 40000 5 51)" a 6" sunmica cash counter 1 15001)1) 6 60" a 30" wooden c uphoard with glass 1 1. 000.00 7 '0 a tin a 36" wooden counter stana 1 800.00 8 60" a 30" a 12" woode a cupboard with glass 750r00 9 60" a 12" a 2:" wooden self with reapcr 3 4501)0 10 30" a 24" a 8" wooden cupboard 3 300110
-Ti 4h"a3 : TTLT TEi se o 4 12 Measuhng htres set I 10 to 20 un, 6 1501)0 13 Weagiung stones 5 kg to 50 gms 8 nrifl .LJJ;.J "n 14 600 42" a 10" woode.n cupboard I 5001)0 15 Brent C tin, for keening food grain 20 1001)0 iei 1 "np o "'tb brass tape ad 3 toUr) 17 Parrer fi•nglish and kannada 20 13/ R4NO124iJ2OO3 38 kum 1mm 1 Oars 20 kg bag I
2. g Lob a.xia Ha:d 40 R.g bag: 2 480 00 40 Shard. eleing powder 2 1/2 kg•• 20 30rd00 L Hngru mud with oil I 0 kg tin 1 .
i 50000
--2 r
1 Cu
- -- ----.. -- --
---. ---
-t
Haid mngu gms oaex 0 laO 00
...
._
41 Hard hingr ms pack 144 30 000
Tecoa} cleaning soindon 700 ml. 210 33000
-- Mmc ma IOu gs OJ ir 24 3300'
-------- ----.
---
-- -------
:
47 Orange jam 400 gm.s bottle 20 300M0
48 Mixed fruit lam 12 1 9200
49 Mao sca souash lie. 700 ml botdes 12 2 1030
:._•
Orftd wjfta kg ftc m I 101 10 do
51 Orbpes squash 14 700 ml, bottle 10 18500
a --
x --
1'
Total 3191100
3rrc (cx cx20kg ;1 1
30
51; Sanibar uowdcc 100 gras x -- pack 5000
56 Jeera powder 100 gras. x 6 00
fjo,
I
Z
-
51 Uhdbes pond r 100 gms x 20C 8000
F 6 1 Bar 1
cm a3c rhar 300
37
RFANai24jjOO3
61 B riley loose Tin 200 gm.s 20 I0000
62 Barley loose Tin 100 gms x 10 8000
63 Barley loose Tin 50 gms x 20 I0000
64 Lavnnga 2. kg tin 200 4000O
65* HaVe 1 kg tin I 15000
66 Cadamem plain withont blne 1 30O0O
67 Cadamem Bleeched 2 kg 2 350M0
68 Cadamem Seeds 2 kg 2 36000
69 Jaijai 1000 tin each 75 1 750M0
70 Match hox bnndle 2 24 000
71 Candle pack hg size 6 12000
72 Candle pack Medinm 4 40 16000
73 Candle pack Small 60 15000
74 1 Gnm botde 100 gms 6 10800
75 Gnm bottle 50 gms 4 10000
76 Godr€ Hair dye big 36 36000
77 Codrej Hair dye Medinm 20
.. Vt
78 I Codrej Hair dye Small 18 22500
79 VI:n cleaning powder 25 kg 6 15020
3724200
80 100 watt bjj hnlb 100 62200
L ..
81 60 Watt bEjaj bnlb 10 44020
82 40 watt b1.jj bnib 100 50020
38
RFANO._1244j2003 83 25wattbkyjbulb8o 360M0 84 15. watt dec.orated colour 50 2750O 85 60 watt milky bulb 30 18O00 ; 86 40 w.tt milky bulb 40 240M0 87 Safoia refind oil 10 kg 350M0 88 X.ey washiu.g powder 10 kg i.. 0000 89 Key washing powder 500 gws 20 2200O 90 Wash deaning powder 15 kg 9000 91 Wash cleaning powder a, kg pack 25 IOOMO 92 Nirma washing powder 50 kg 45000 93 OK washing powder 28 kg 252 MO 1 94 Chavi washing ½ bar soap 30 1200O 95 501 washing 1/1 bar soap 60 240M0 96 OK washing cake 24 7&00 97 Det as shi.ng powder 200 gms 16 8000 98 Det washing c.ake 100 grns 30 9000 99 Trillo detergent cEke 100 grim 40 12000 100 Double detergent cake 100 gnrs 20 61:700 101 Kir... detergunt cake 100 gms 30 9700 102 K,asturi wasLing bar soap 100 30000 103 707 washing bar soap 80 24000 1 04 OhriM wa aTJo.:g po a acr 1.5 [ f 105 Wheel wash.ing cake 30 9000 3g .RF* NO• Ia4.kL2QO 106 Sik pmvo a 200 s 20 1 20LO S mu --
CC
Total 432395O
Hkopy th 0
109 Hamam bath soap 100 475M0
12 - Hteoouy9O 36000
-
111 Rexona Bath scao 30 15000
112 Lux toilet soap 50 23T50
13 fl2 d d
2 u vu to a )Q i
114 Chandrika Medium soap 60 270M0
_, -
.
115 Santoor toilet soap 30
C--
15000
116 Wipro shikakai 20 1 l000
__••••••_
_
--
66
118 Pears 20 200CC)
.1 12 Hamam sample ma 3 1 4L0C
cmn 50 225 00
.••
r fli12.2 Mknthei5kg
kg. o
15000
L23 Jeera 5 kg t
t3i...c1
I 25 -ara dIaL kg ]SCLOO
--- . .
. I
di .i. i._
127 Tam dC-al 15 kg 151C-00
I.
-40-
fl4NO. l24lI2OQ
128 Sabakki 10 kg 80.00
129 Bengal gram dhal 10 kg 90.00
131 Sojipacketlclass2o 70.00
[132 Soji packet IT class 20 65.00
133
j Wheat flour pack 20 40.00
134 salt peiaTi4o äöbo
tz
Total 47367.50
-
'r -.
136 Chillies Madras quality 10kg 200.00
137 Beaten rice 20 kg 120.00
138
139 F Sugar 40 kg
Raw rice best quality 20kg 320.00 120.00 ãifó1C 141
--
--
Rawricelllquality25kg Corriendar 20 kg
- [ 112.50 300:00
--. --.
mia 144 Horsegram 50 kg____ Ragi6Okg ]ThEbr 1 120.00 1 145 Coconut oil case 90.00 146 Groundnut oil case 40 100.00 147 Gingilly oil cake handmade 30 90.00 fl18 -.
1nr 149 Cotton seed expellnr30 75.00 4o:oo 'F C 41- RFA NO. 124112003 Jaggery II quality 20 kg 100.00 pw mwwcawaoir 1120.001 153 Cattle feed cake 20 kg 60.00 vy-i--- - - -
" Powctiriö ij
-
155 -t Gram floor best quality 10 kg 100.00
E -r Thi&& Ii qüiiiflWi
157
--
._.
Badesoppu 10 kg
--
....
I '°°°ZJ
159 Thathayi 5 kg 60.00
160 Grapes dry4kg 160.00
ifflb 70.0O
Total 50905.00
iir r-- tiöij jZi(i& 1
E oEr.
163 Aralu (pudi) 12 kg 108.00
Agarabathi suganda sringar 60 90.00
165 Agarabathi Three in one 20 80.00
I-- --
166 Agarabathi Vasu roil 30 90.00
167
[ Agarabathi Cheeper quality 100
1w&1hra"o:or-:
169 Karpoora ---- 60.00 --
-
170' Pepperi0kg 30000
171 Black gingili 12kg 60.00
1172 Bengal gram (bigj 10 kg 120.001
73 gram r
iao:oo
7'
42-
RFANO. 1241/2003
174 Peas green 15 Re. 180410
175 Black gram 10 kg 7000
176 Green gram 12. kg S..600
177 Sacred thread bundies 50.00
178 Rev on bite layb) big; size 30 00 00
5-- r 1
S i Sr
180 Playing cards pack 30 2 1000
Total 52,939M0
Articles in Sri, Darnodar Rice mills bailadka anekere, Karkala Town, Ka.rkai Talnk, Din.
55, 940 RPM 20 HP Crrrnnton electric: meter 1e n1 2 3 pHase oil knersioned electric motor starter I 100000 3 Heavy duty copper point main HPtcb. I 80000 4 Voltaee saver cent capacttv 1 50000 jointer I 3" diameter iron pipe 1.0 fe.et 150,00 4 43 8 3" diarnetea pipe bend 3 75Q 0 9 Iron clamps for pipe support 6 I20:00 10 owe 10 feet 1 2000 11 30 amp coppe.r point switch 3 75J3Q 12 30 amp cop.per point holder 4 IOOMO I 0 Vitc nthcatrng meter 1 20000 14 -
Omes Indicating meter 1 1 5000
15 24" x 48" x 2" wooden frame with supporter for 220430
e,Ujr.tctjc I
dianreter 4 track V pui.icv I 250430
17 Railings sea.ts 24" for distance adjusting to the 500430
motor
Total 15130M0
18 4" 1
diam
e ter 30 lengt.h Iron main shaft 1 iootoo
19 24" a 6" a 4" wooden suo9iortcr :!fl( 00
c trOt) 00
21 14" diameter 4 track V Pulley I 500430
V bch 20 fret. leo: ot.h 4 40000
ciiruncrcr flat 50000
24 24" diameter flat pulley 1 áji o•:b•o
25 That belt 35 feet 1crrgth I 399 00
SIn bn:iI:.t I
27 6" diameter flat pulley 1 150430
2.8 748 a 24" iron. sheets frr hrl.,sk carrvin.g ie 300430
4
.44-
Rfl NO. 124112003 29 Husk absorber fan 1 300.00 iWT enclosed iron box 1 31 100'x6'x6"woodenpiflars4 !600.Oo
---r--• 32 -- 30' x 30" wooden frame 1 ..........
100.00 33 Iron rod with 5/8 bolt and nuts for absorbing 200.00 f4 34 Total enclosed wooden box for transporting 300.00 husk 1 35 8" diameter flat pulley 1 175.00 36 6' diameter flat pulley 1 j 150.00 r 37 Flat belt for husk absorber fan 30 1 in length 200.00 38 Flat belt for rejoinder 2 100.00 39 Flat belt paste tin 2 100.00 40 Flatbeltboltandnutsl6 64.00 Total 23719.00 41 28 No. Dasendingator 1 5000.00 42 72" x 6' x 4' wooden supporter with solid nut 300.00 I f and bolt 2 43 f Flat belt 24' for Desendingator 24 18' diameter 1 240.00 F •
--"
*d&&iani&r6iF "jm&or 46 Pipe wrench 18' length 1 100.00 4 No.18 and 16 ring spanner 2 4 .4 .45- RPANO. 124112003 fl4UT 1; E4r jjjEädã I__ 50 ]uerC Ordinary spaner 6 120.00
- 51 Empty bane! 200 its 5 500.00 52 ---- -- Empty Lid 4 Toolskeepingwoodenstand2 1 200.00
-
200.00 54 Paddy carrying cane 4140.00 8 feet wooden paddy spade 4 160.00 56 10 ft., wooden paddy spade with hooks 4 240.00 57 ..----------
48" x 48" x 36" wooden stand 1 .
1 500.00 phase motor 1 59 L & '1' 3 phase starter 1 800.00 60 GEM 3 phase main switch 1 500.00 L ! 61 62 3" diameter 0 N Bend pipe 4 3" diameter pipe cuplings 6 120.00 100.00 f 5 F64 3" x 21 ft., iron pipe 2 itrrJ 325.00
---z---h----"---------r---r-.--"- .. ....
6o 2.5 x 3 pipe reducer 1 3a.00 66 15" gitii'dlü&l 70.00
-
-
--.
r ..
L68 I
Total
Baby palvalizer 1 11 36784.00 Lw t-..-- - .
-.- iitifl&èJiriieir 1 2000.00 ao:oir t 44 -46- RYANO. 124112003
--.
71 I Mash set22,18,24--3 500.00
- + -.
10 ft diameter iron sheet (kavali) -. 3ooo;o
73 Iron husk supporter 2 800.00
.
J
Other articles 20
--.______________________________ _
-' ooo L 44,209.00 Total of Schedule B :-
a Rs. 97,830.00
.
-. i-..
c Rs.54,680.00'
Fe
-.
[orand
Total Rs.6,41458.00 I
C SCHEDULE:
Joint business being carried in item (i) premises of plaint 'A' Schcdule in groceries under the name and style Bola Padmanabha Hegde and Sons, Merchants and Commission Agents, and Hcgde I 4 '9 0 I 1 9 0 S C Jr w 4L i '4