State Of Karnataka vs Sangappa on 17 February, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

State Of Karnataka vs Sangappa on 17 February, 2011

Bench: K.Bhakthavatsala

IN THE HIGH CGURT OF KARNATAI{A
CIRCUIT BEEICH AT GIELBARGA

E'3A'§'E'.;E} 'm:s1«: "ma ':?'%"%L-E {gm 3:? FE-:,E:2:é&:3;a::2&%::'  

PRESENT

THE HQNBLE 912., JIISTICE K;=.A1BHAi§Tii;ii?A}r€;:§IQ;,A 

g:x:-:»'£3».___%
THE x-Ienmm MR. JUSTQE: 
CRIMINAL A1§P3§;AL"--Nc§4; ?~3%;=:{G§* 29:)?

BETWEEN:

Stataz sf '      
Thmugh ?:1'1C_P<§__E§g:jé:= C'E1§'£j:tg:>j;:1'p:7§.'aV;

 --------   ':;. ,  ' . ' '   A§;>p€;*.E1ar3%.
ggy smga Aguxiaﬁhia» 'ggaén 3,93,}

A1\§§:

 =  _ E.  S Ts'; 7%.£_'_"_i__i_f§.:,zpp:'a;
'  "x;"§:1f;;r§_.' §:5%;_.f:1<>g ﬁirgifasg

V  ;%g;'§§3<;§.V: ':3»5$'v§',.-'é+2?a_:'§s,

._  :3' '§{€:.§2:§?:§:'é3é izﬁiagaé,
A ?'::E::k21 ",E§u§"::::e1%3;:d.

' '  2. §~§.22.=;::z1"€'.5~;T;*:. S / 5:2» 'Kfi_tt.a. §1'r'§}é:§;

* ; Viiihaé Raax G-i.:i;§;ir€:§_

V' V. _ Agﬁed 28 :;€:a:"::'~a.

R253 Vilézigge: %€<}€_i2m1§;~::EK

  'E<:€:$E":;3;;§;}a as '%fi:§;.g:_;>§};:_

 """" 



 Vithal Razz). Girgirﬁ,
Agxzéﬁit 45 :g€:2:.:'*ss;§ Rig v.i1Eag,§&
Kacizgambai.

5;. Shi\é'E}.§pE'1 Sig} Vitt'.a.p'p21
 Vithai Ram, Girgirtx
Aged: 38 ys::23z.r$§   _
R/<3 'fiilage §{{}(§&1I'I1bZi1. "

55 ?'v'Ia1Eappa Sim P:;:ncia;3pa 
Aged: 35 yearss, Ric) w11121g§:: ~. _
Kadambaﬁ, V. A

6. Ran1shef,iy S/0 Hu$%:_ii';1_pp§§    :«
Chintaki! aged: 50 yi:'a1';$; ' 
R/62} Viliage Ka:3da.mba§E...» _  '

7. Vitt_a?F%a        x 

8 ,/'0 Nar:éa§_3j;3*:a.;"a.g;;§:di"-$5 '3:g_a:j§§';,_:  '

R/0 Viiiagge; 'E{é}a;§ia1'r:haE,"~.' ..  ';

Tq. §~§urim.;2;:Ei}ad§:fi'2>iSt;:,E:ida%;"'W "

 .§~?;<:spe:}r:de3:3ts

{By Sri Bab{:VR§aaV1¥f£aziga::é, Aévacate}

 . . . . .  

--. V'    "if§':*é§f1Ej.§r§.21£ A§Jps5a."£_ is ﬂied E.E§";{i{"::f' Se<:'£i{>:1 3?8 {E}
 E3} Cr';§??:LiTi.'T:?3§,-* éihi-3 S%:a.'£€3: 9.? far ma: S'z::a:':,:'3 p1;'€:ij€i{1§.§ gm:

i;h_':$'  AC<>m:*€ meg: be giéiaigeai 321:} gfkiélf. §€':'2':1.¥-"£3 is £336
an sapgééai ag21.2'.:'3s'i' ﬁx: jkiﬁgﬁéfiili, :2;-:.*£::::€i ?;8.S'?'2{i§'? in

 T:3,€.N<'.:.»..f{i2Qf2,(}£}5 am the £116: Q§ ihe Pi}, F'§'C~§E. 35%;. Biéaéf

 5 :%;a:t;q2.§§i.'£,i.§3g§ the 's.'§3s§_><3';':€§::>.:'r{. €i{t(':i1S€'?{§ §'aEz>:"~3,E ii) 7? far {ha

. '~;:§f§7er:':<t:z5 ?;'ELT_g'$. 3:235 34?, "M18, .':§+'iL  E38'? zzmji 534%
'  R/3%? 4;'-'-';;={':=,<?:b 35% 8? E539.

5:-\'L'-~e"""'<..,,..(,,»-"""'
"""""'1"



J

"Phi:-s apps-:21} <':<}miz1.g; <3': fez" §i':'m_1 i2e,z1.:*ir1g.;' :".1r"1.:ss day,
Araii Nagaraj, J, deE:3;vc%r€d t,E".::i f<§1§m::i1'1g;:

JUDGMENT'

"ﬁat-.= (:<}:1'3.p121iz":2H'1t: - S'i',ai'€i in E':3,,C.N<.:a .12€}g'

ihfi' fiie 0f P':'e3:si<iing3; Offi<:»3:: §?'21;s::%: 'E'rz>::tk Cm.1_.:_fi}----§I.  ~

{E:€:re§;naf*:,e:r 1i.'€;?rf{f§'§."€€i ta 21$ 'Trial -Cﬁurtf 501*  4s--3sh-.%13~2"1;.V)"  V

    

»\

ekaetiistiggeci in ihig appeal {ha £e%gg211:;s§,y1:i:ri£i {:%{.>':';§€::~:%i::1§3s:L_L:'
'(he §L2d§__§m€m, and <:»:"d€:':* af ;;;<:%4§1§;:f.»'i.i.e2§v. <12:-1t'€~£§ ;2%3%?
gasgesci in the saziid 0,2155%~.;§w<::;11Ai%i53.§::g§;' :iiﬁ<._%".1*1:;*: 3f%3sg3<}':':4de';2t.s; -

e1::tc;t1:x$§3é 0? the <;ff§:r:ce$ §:.:*%,{§s£§7;S?§€:<:_§§{i§':i_s%;.K438 34?, 

114% 3214, 3(}?*'::'::§{."5Q%:_ 'E'f;§EE;'f:{§':'%E§'§;?A§;£ 5':fk§€iV(f%§'i{;=E1: 14% «:1? {PG

2,7>Si;.at.e:~d-- in':i:»ri<:*{ i~;h%:.. ease 9f the pmsemztien 21$

asiiegﬁﬁi m'%* aim_x;:;;3~:~:a;5§;~;::z~;:. Exma ifmed by pwzg

 ":%;:31*:1p§z3;--§;':'§2:iA1fg. $E":_2::9:*:é§;?;ﬁ>;}za; 'Si-'h{"§ is 21130 iixjureé ;i;<~;; ms m":{ier:

  2 4vé§'V%;>;::i:§~:s«:3§1 ef p:f<:<iri.c::3s; é£'i~wi':i %3a:t.x-%;1?»%m'1 the
'M  <:<§5%ﬁ3j§§£::i:1ei:1i: an 3316 {BEE szidé-3: 22mg}. 22%} ihfff
A;§<t:*é'::::3€:<.'§ an ilhif <3t%:€fa*., €§:'.'i EL'§'{§2.?2;%{}4'1 at
::':b6::':". EL-'%§,€}G A??? aii '£:§1<-3 ;::<i:<:u::;é:?:<:§ ?~E€:2:ei;.'§ E5} '?
§<>':"m§é£.% '€'§E€?E"§§$€§'E?{'EE:E Emit'; ;f;::": :3 ;:§;1;.w§'u.':

2-§§--:se2:j::":':E::;E:,:'.f .;;::°:"n:.§%<§ :v.§.i:}: €,§{::;i1{:§E.j§: g:+«£.}':2:;; :i§§<;€'E'i





ail-K6? katéii e::<:::, .:aab:.;s.~;e{§ ﬁlﬁ? {"f€')E1"1p1é'1ii'1€1E1E. zzzmii
hm E§{'}§': PR7»? 1.5} Shivz1.k.1.:m2H' eimd 222$s;zm§.t;e:<£

E',§Ti€3f£E§. 23151 i;}1§;%r€:b3; at.i;.:;%§:2pi:s:<i {.0 <::<_§:11§:1'§t:;"'--.

rm1:*::§.{~t:* GE beiia ﬁlm: c<i;:":1§3§2;1i;:':2;m: ramgi 1'--:_ié;--w__"'--«. 

SGE1.

{b} A} Sa::.;g;app21 a:::$.2mé'{.e%::% x§.r'iif?:"*3iaE.ff1§' _.§$;:§1~a_;;§3 V '

edgeé wacapozij <21"; Riff. p;é%'i:i:3§:_A_AT;»"%;2 §§{2£n:€:sf:a

aSS2mEi'.<;=;d wﬁzh {.336 e;;3::":1--:j§§iz1"{.i._{§I" x$;6:a§>'{3.7;:?:v.§}':1 
'i:h<:: right f{}:"€:~*:_rm, A3 V%E{:§$§121pp§'23-.§LS$'éi::;i";,§3&
with the same§%€<3;1p:}i:'"'%§é1%§f\:;!ji*'igE2€ kiiéc: "ém"§
Aﬁ M3112-'ippzé. 21.sé§2i.1;.'E'i::;:'ai..§«;.::§:'éE1_::3:f:§:gin ieféz kﬁiiﬁ
of the ;':g';}:§:piai:':'é%f:t.' :§§h:;i;<i2f§n:a§;§;>a:§15'§K?33} and

iher§>.E;:.;  T.s;€2:'i_<4:=V1;~€~:v " §é1;§'z;"rie§; an big

 per§§€§'§'; V (3 .  V Q§E1..Ea:;1ppa1. a$s:mEi.<3d
 *E?K?€E  :'%}§;i*y;§iE;{:vn:§?é:;r.:'<f»n {he .ieft hamgi f<}§<--.*,am:

_ rgégiékh =2=:::*§a'"E_ §f:.jﬁ§£:{'~.~£ési an his pe:*${>n b§e:3::1i;.":g.g;
 ix§"EjE1§'"§?:"-..%f;f:£f'i§:F§fi':€§ N§3:~_1s.€> zmgi '? ':":2m:1s%1;.r
'§§§§x:%i:s§i§:{%.}? and '€it.':'.ap§3a--: i.:'::=;ei§ga€,ed iiéze
 v..v:V5<;v«3:1.§::V%%:"::f"[~. }a{:{:as%€d in E1S$2iLiE'§'. %><>t,1': éihe

g:g§f:éjg,*Eéi:§:1.a:2.E, azzd his ﬁﬁfi S%:ii:s*za_§s:a.::?:22u1

' 4_ 25811 ithszr Esasisa {Ff €;E3.é3 Said {".?iT:fE'Eg§§E,§iI}¥Lg 3; f_','§'fi.'£'Y§€ W215?

z*$;:g§iS?;.:;%':"e::% 22;§;a.i§§:'+;i?: 2:2: meg: ;--"£s;.%::::.:§;e:%{7E_  ii} ? '59:' :-QB é:':':s*:



5-said :>§§e:::C<::s Eiﬁid f',}.'1{'3':§ came E0 E/32% Eiaéiiéci in tihe: s--:;a.i::i

§?>t?;SSif_)i"lS £33189.

 Gr: a;'}pr€£ti21i,i<}n Of akifai ;?::1":d €i<}<%t.z;f;:'@:i'E:;é{1%3,€'~.,
<:vi{i<:=~ne::r3: piaqted 0:1 :'eC<:nrd by ihe §3msse{:ut,ie:1iT:";.__i.h¢;f~Ti'f§é:E=  Q
C{>m:"t§ by its §I:3pugg;z1ec§ :.T'L1§d§_:§.f111€3I1{:.'§E-3.I"1:#';i'C§7£f'i§€I"?,' a}:?c;:2it'jt.é{i 

211} the Said 21a:':<:§:15~;e-d; of ail the _-Said '<:s§f€:11<:€;:S}, _:'}§{=::1c:e  '

p.'f€S€I1.i', appeai $3: ihe cGmp1ai§i'a2.'§é*i: -- 8i'..é{'é;<:~%_."'AT 

....

Se Smt, Am11*a<:ih1a' M "§Z}{%*3i;:i,"é.§32"s$':1e::i Add'it.i«:ma1 Stats: Pubﬁic P_r<:é§é:a?:ui;::;_% s;i::"€in§;i§?. t:g>z1ﬁsiixviig {ha}. *':,h<>ugh PWSL ii':-wéirvié'; {E25':%'§}*é:x3é;?§¥:1':eés"é§::1:~:" $19 the i:':<tide:1'L, haw:

furzzgd §*:0sE.iié% {<3'ééfiat p!:_{§;é.{§§'.ut.i<3:';, P"'\}u's;£3 and E4, wha are £'§*".--'§"£€ <:='?{':irj';<:; ' €h.;ir:"vi:hé?':"i:1j::;:"@d <:<:}mpEai;';a,n%. 2111:} his ":i3':_§::':--'eé gérsiifz Shi%fé1k::m21.§x hz1W: fully $upp<:>rt.ed }j1*V;"z1}_:?'§iE{'iZ3;.'Te;Z'§{)§7'}. V(3*&;+é_l:::: am: thiéir <~:vide:':{?€: 'E,G€.a§§"§; {E{}§.},E§;'E%"§i£ii'i'i wit§*:__i;.h§-:':' %;E'§.{'§?:'E":fEii'f§}'§'.=5?s in °£.h{:=. e;:<}:::g3i;}im1 mid %',§.1£;é:i*€:f<:s~:"{:: E339 . v.""ETriTaE {3::>:£:'€; wazéa E1533? j"€,1S§flif§ffC§ in 2z<t{§:.:§€;*é:§."a1;_§ §;.h{"f' &{?{f'€.7£S{'f{§§ a::_§ :1.-'mi: ssaié {Bi-:§'€:h-E-éiljg-:i$R «"'"--~,.»v~».«_Ma-«W.»-*' fwwﬂ actts {If iézaiifh of aitmzssai E\E<3::-3.} :0 5 (>11 b«:}'£.h this ssaizti iiljuféifi are :?::):":<;:e:t:':2ec§. Eﬁessiciszsé iihis, {ha §.'{§C:i{i~:':nt 'wok placé-;= at ab<mi'. 90$ AM sm .1.5éﬁ2,,2QQ4 a.:c1_r::'r~ C€)ETI:1p1E£i.:"1§ {".i3H"1{'.' E0 bﬁf' lscigge wiE;h<>z.1t. any €if3t§Ei}f":73§§f' 9,45 Ah-'E an ihe game Ciay. 'i'hé3ra%fi3i*éz..t.he::§é§ i;s":€j;; é§{t:j'p;€- to held that the said C{§I11§1&1iI1'£::':"§x?:;§:?;_:E§A' againsst. a£:,«::'uSs3,d 1\}'c:~;~3.E ta "ins clinciiixzg earide:'1¢e plarizleg 'g::<>s~:;*:cut.i0n '£3 "prays {ha <':E'§a:'ge.s; L§;:;1§d:31' $£'{':f,iO1'1S 343$ 14?, Ev-$8,; S<:*e:~i.i::n 'L49 Sf IP85" """ "x*§2*§c'::':7'¥;,1f§€'iV.jv €:£:rt,'ifi{:2;1t.€ <3? PW13 ca§11p}a:§:.9g1:r1i {he €:vi<£€r':";r:;€* sf PW12: {he 2':/iedi§?e1E Gfficgir W.£1{§A"v_%:"§:ai§1ine<i ?"€~.7':_3 gegnd E-$s;u€:'E the '"3-';aiéi'~1>é?§--§:aAr:€*:..;:€:°'§f§fi{i2:€€: esﬁxabiisheg éfimi. {ha Semi mjufesd.

-:2?;a.;5s f£"{}L% :1w:_i "::i,;:'sé: ;-.-;i.:'s.€s:i §'%."2:<:t,:sr@ Sf hi:-1; méa':a:7~arpai hang iizf hi-s"~«.__rig§1'£;.* §'3fa.m§ zivhiaéh £5; E: ;5;;ri§3v<:s:.:ses §:'§3j?.£'§'}-3 buéq. {hit t7- "{:h;2:rg6".§E"amz:d 2":g_§a1i§1:;§ a€';{'i"{ESi;"d 311:3 '? is; far the 'z7;f"§2::::::.é3 Eiilfﬁifvf $€3{TfE,§€}}"} 32% résagi W:i:;E"; E§<:s::%'.%;{:::: 3.5% 23? EPC.

" ""»%§.§3{I£§ 15:.E"::=3: e;t%:;:::';;:é3 'wast-2 §.'§{}'§. §:"2?::":':s;=:<:% fax" ﬁfass i}'§§%SfE':{?ﬁ 2221533; /"ﬂ"'«.,/""~v-~s M .<.__.m»A,Q'Aa «_v»-M $€:.::i;'.i{>r: 326 at}? EPC; this: ziatiizzsesed <é22u'1m'}i' be {?()E'}"v'i{Z"{€€§ far the Said 0ffe::<':§:: H{>w£:év@z; I/zen-'ir?i.§_; bfiéﬁfn f€:1:nziVVi;hé::. éi{'I€?L'é.iS€?{1 N031 {at} 5 are: g12i§3:.§; {if '€'.h€3: :3f§é3:':§7§""2:§.;:§§::¥;__42 Seciian 324 3»? WC §'<>:s' hzixsing ir1§1i.::§<;éCi EI%i¥_°£'§.§_>§.F;.'::'§i}}'€..iYi.€E5 "

on {.h€: persan (Ff PWSEE anﬁ E4, .' ccmvicted for 32.6 affesnce L;:id.§:é*=._Se*<:tZi<>:1 32%: 1'$2::i_ v.:i.;t.hM Sézctien £359 35 EPC and Jnat fO1ji..:F£:€f'v{:}f§*S§Fi€T¢3.'§§i§'"1%:i'E'fT'Vv§§€{§'§.f:{}E."l 326 mad with Sé3<::1':i{::z1 }

8.. Sr: _i§,§1§3 §'L i§f:~§'§f7i':7?'§1€1_Qt'§.~ S€§§1ié3'£E€7i€K..v:§.€E1f"E1§E';d cam}:-3&3 for *:he r§_$p<3.1;a{i<:§%;§s; - a{:€:=éé.s.e'd'Sz,i"%;>1*r:i's.s3 ijhat i:h€-. {2ff<":n(t€ Llﬁéﬁf $€€:%i.€3¥E'i.,~~._3§2:1LW._ £3-ii EEC Essa» 'pL:msha't>it3 wiih §mp'ris@'nr::{:r.:f.V{::é*'*u?iith fing and them/'fe:}r€§ €:nds:% of ju&3't:i<:%3 wawgj bk': rm>:'3£'.' 's§}';E':&3 accusgeii 21%? .s;=:::":§s::":£:e€§ {:3 pay ﬁne %<?::ﬁ::s1. ' *§5:4:5;::": 27.315: <é$§_d€:':1<:<: :3? §?'W's~aa!%3 "c'1§1(§ E4; E3.§'K§ 'six? Irix-%€:*'z':1I<;*.:;§.%:,s,z in %:'§:a-3 {:<:m§Ea.:§:€:: EZxK?25§ xxx: f§w:i ﬂzazﬁ. éhers _§S"s::--2%;a€ 2:§;:;1ir:s;;?;;. ;':a:{:'%.:§a:;é{§; E'*E<>s:=;..E ':1; 5 §1:>:° 1;:%:::é <>'§."§E::ia:::{-3 u:f;{§£3'i"' "'$€3{E§.3E{}E1 32% §"€?£i{§ v£i%:.':': -Ss;>.<3*:'.§:r:§':. 2%} £24? EEK'; _§{_tsr E:.a.:«-*§.§:;.§ g'f"""'~€)gMA ,4 ,..a, ymmmk x.vw"' =<ri 9 Cé1E.1S€;'3£§ injuriatiése in FWMS and E4 E33; Ei$S£1LiEi.iE"1g; than with "vA?'t37.:1peZ")?1$ like E«:;z1'?i}1§ e:i:<:. '1'E1r3:r<:":§':):*sEx WE'. 2:m;":_ i:;.{ the carasidered <};}§';3i<>:3 that. a:::<;:u:sse{.': Nezxa.E,-i;z:§'€; fa_:f(:r.-_'_ Eiablést {.0 be €T:{}11'¢"§§{'iE.€fC§ far :h.€: <)ffe'::1";_<_':.:;<2.. 1;;r1de--r"ES£:'<:{ﬁ<}i:V.324 read wi"t:h. S<~:c'?t,i<::1 131$ sf WC for §"}f;?§%7Ti:} 3€§§§'~§Tf£?i{1S5s{3f{§._'§:1jV{i;;§'i.€3§3.'_A an the perscsn of PWSEB 21ndV»1..§;'V_ 1.0., 'Far the reas<t;::1:'§s:- appeal if the c€2mpiai:'121.:1t' - is j_§,§.1rt.. A<:::":uSe:{i i\§<)s.} is :"e:~3pe(:t§*~seEy R€sp0ﬁ d;_€_nv§ 21:}? ixétreby Ciﬁllifiiitéd for the e:}f§:,fg1a:é3':Q:AV;9§§;:3é:;. sf EPC. £01" hazring Cazised i1"1j'LE'E"E€S ﬁi:::<__' namesiy, 'me {:::>rnpEainar:"£' ';~:;:?£*€;'~ pay" a fine 9%' %'»'§-,{}C%@ sash Eb: having ir;3Z:.::f§z:S €19 Pwiiég ?2,%}®{"I> Eiélﬁih far E':21*§2€.1';;§V"'%::¢a;§.,i%é3{§ i.2:1jur;%t3s--; '{1} ?'JV' ":4. S}'E§."'§'§1§i§,EIﬁ'£:£', E1': zisfzmk. :(AAjsf:"'§3'i*';';i'j»}z"%':1ii'f£'§"'Z Q? the Saieii a:m<";'un%. <7}? fizjzeg ihey ghaii :,m.::§@rg{> é5i§:§'g:x'§<% %§'E"§"§}¥i$€}§';:"§E{':EE§l $2332." 21 p::>:':*%<?:{.§ 9'? avg} V" ""wv-H-M. ,-a <"'"""*=~3~ '"""

5 U n1£}t:1t:.E1&ea {>11 €::1a::E:. {.".'{}1}.§'"§I.g E¥§i;,€::" 'iiissr s;«s2:1i{.i :g1m<:§:2.n_*';', {if fine is gjaid GI' 1°::-:::£::v€:£*<:{i;. 2?; 312:1: of §'2.®,{}{){} satzali E345? ggzzici '€53 FR?' 1.3 ::::3'mpEa§::;mi: Sifzarmapa azxrgi 23 5mm {:5 ?§G.{§€3€;"}_i:.z:":s_ his SGT: §'1££I'ﬁ€1}-' PW14 Shiis'ak'un1ar:. "1'.%f2r{:e, ':::§<3_:--':::".E":$"

is g_>;;"e11:1t;:-zci Ea d<;=:p0s_§i':. Eihe ssaigi _€32:t1€:_ air:-:éi£i{H':%.5$.. impugnézd jiidgiiiﬁiif. and arcissr Of 2i€:<;i§_ﬁ.'t.é:§ in §§;{>_ i1;aru a~é§s~--:.'ié¥1.[_' 'r@E2:t.£::~3 to a<:q'ui5:.f;ai of z1<:<:u--;<«;_é«:3V_ E'*~Ei:3s§;§b* w:~m'::i§ EE-Eff. u':1d§:«:turb€d_.

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court