Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Delhi District Court

Land Acq. Act/9203/2012 on 20 June, 2008

1 ! "$#% & # ' () * + , % -.( / -





        0214365)7$8:9<;=9?>A@ B

        CD>FE          GIH J KML:NOE?P&Q LSR
    T          RVU:RVPXW EYW-N[Z \^]MU

        _ 8 T      8`W N aMP b W-Nc\:U d



e 
 (gf        h i jkj                            	+lm on  p	



         UkqrRs\:P"EtP duNvU wyx<z={ |:P d 7M}<Rs\:P                               €           B&/@ B

                   LyU~E?P                                                 

         |:qrRs\:P‚ZkU:RVP 7:} Rƒ\MP
Ly7 { {„NOEyEyN[7 x                           9k9 8†@k;$8†@ B

                   7:}kRs\:P…7M}4}VP x:LyP                                 


         Lyq‡Rs\:P                  x:U${'P             7:}       Rs\:P                Š       7 x‹EŒRVU |<w[P.'PŽ`U.3gU {

                   Ly7 { ˆ<wvU Ncx:U x^R/‰ƒN } U x^]Mq                     

         ZkqrRs\:P           x:U {&P7:}‘Rƒ\MPUkLyL:z<EtPkZ                       W-N[Z \^]MUrš

>A7› z=bSP~E\œ3/>A7› 8ž5)7$8 ˆ:P d’Et7 x=“ U x:Z!\<N”E•ˆ:U d–P$x^R–U=—kP  9 € >ŸH^9~ ~“ ¡DU~E¢Rƒz=dƒ|MU 5)Uk—kU ds“ U x:Z˜d–P~E™N[ZkP x:LyP T \:U \:ZkU dVU$“<£)P wc\<N†8 PkqrRs\:P 7y}¤}VP x:LyP L^7${ ˆ<wvU Ncx:PkZ 7:} C/>¥E`GIH J KML:NOE?P&Q L¦R 7 d/ˆkd–7:aMPkZ  }Vq Rs\:P˜ˆ<w[PkU 7:}<Rs\:P UkLyL:z<EtPkZ Q LyL:z<EtPkZ Z NvZ˜x:7:RDˆ<w[PkUkZ — zkN§w R¤]~8 U x:Z˜\<NOE+P:KMU {„Ncx:U:RƒN[7 x„N } U xy]  —kq }ƒN§xMU w¦7 d–Z=P d Q Ly© zkN R¤RVPkZ 0 Ncx:U w¦U dV— z={&P x^RuE¨\:P=U d–Z 7 x  \:q @$ªk8†@kG$8†@ € N[q ZkU:RVP 7:}2EyzMLM\&7 d–Z=P d H^9?>A@kGt>A@ €  «.¬ lm­¯®<°%±M² « ²ƒ®$³"®$´~²/µ2°D²m¶~®·lA® « ±Mµ ´$±&°sµ lI²m¶~®¹¸2®kº ­4±=­¯µ ´   @IH:8 Q ˆ:7 wON[LyP…d–P ˆ:7$d4R¨Ž+U~EYˆ<zyR"z=ˆ‡Uk—=U N§x‹EŒR'Rs\:P»UkLyL:z<EtPkZ…|^]YRs\:P T RVU:RVP¼Rƒ\=d–7 zM— \ T RVU:RƒN[7 xr)7 z<EtP6½¾}¤}ƒN[L^P$d 7:}*_ T W-N aMP b.W-Nc\:U d 7 x‡H^9 8†@IH:8†@:¿ U w§w[Pk— N§xM—.Rs\:U:RI7 x˜9k9 8†@k;$8†@ B·U:R%U |:7 zyR € ª@ U:RgÀr|<w[7kLMb™“=W N aMP bžW N§\MU ds“/£)P w§\<N  2 ÁkÂyÂ:Ã<ÄtÅkÆ Ç+Á~ĐÈVÉ Ã=Ê:Æ ÇžË ÌsÍ É Ê:Å Ç'Í<Ë ÌVÅ Î<ÏvÁ~Č̃Ë[ ÂyÁ Ê:Å~Ä É:ÈÑÐtÒ Ï§Ë ÌVÅ Ó’Ä ÂyÉ Ê^ÌVÁ ËcÊ<˧ÊMÔ ËOϧϧË[ÂË ÌÕϧË[Ö ÃMÉ Ó.Ç¨Ë ÌƒÍ:É ÃyÌ×Á Ê^Ø Ï§ËvÂyÅ Ê:ÂyÅ É ÓÙÎ:Å ÓƒÚ„Ë Ì×Á Ê:ÆÛÌsÍ:ŠӖŠÜ^Ø ÂyÉ Ú Ú„Ë Ì4ÌVÅkÆ Á ÊÝÉ:ȤÈVÅ Ê:ÂyÅ Î<Ã=Ê<ËOďÍ:Á Ü<ÏvÅ ÃSÞ¥ÄàßIÐ á âMÂ:˔ÄtÅäã ¦ÌAå Í:Å Ê:ÂyŠďÍ:ŠďÍ:É ÃkÏ[ƘÜ:ŘÎ<Ã=Ê<ËOęÍMÅkÆ Á~ĨÎ:Å Ó2Ï[ÁÇ&æ Ò=ç æ ã ȤÌVŠӷȃ˧ϧ˧Ê:Ô É:È ÌsÍ:Å Î:É ÏOË[ÂyŠӖŠÎ:É Ó4ÌAå.ÂyÉkÔ Ê<ËvèyÁ Ê:ÂyÅ É:ÈéÉ:ȤÈVÅ Ê:ÂyÅ Ã=Ê:ÆkÅ ÓêÄtÅk¦̃Ë[É ÊÙßIÐhá â:Â:ËOÄtÅéã Â¦Ì Ç`Á~ķ̖Á$ëSÅ ÊrÜ^ØrÚ*ؕÏvÅkÁ ÓsÊ:ÅkÆìÎkӖÅkÆkÅkÂyÅ~ÄyÄtÉ Ó ÂyÉ Ã=Ó4Ì%Á Ê:Æ ÌsÍ:Å ÁkÂyÂ:Ã<ÄtÅkƘÇ`Á~Ä Â^Á ϧÏ[ÅkÆéÃ=Î:É Ê ÌVɘȖÁ=Â^Å·ÌsÓuË[Á ÏMÁ:ȤÌVÅ ÓrÂyÉ Ú Î<Ï Ø<ËcÊ:Ô Ç¨Ë ÌsÍ*ÌsÍ:ŘӖÅkÖ ÃkËcӖŠÚ&Å Ê^Ì É:È2ÄtÅk¦̃ËvÉ$Ê&çkÒ íXÉ:È$îêÓsï%î¾æ Ò ð=æ ñXÊ Òkß2æcÒIÐMæcÒ$ò×Í:ÁMó<ËcÊ:Ô¼Í:ÅkÁ ӖƑÌsÍ:őãêï ïÙÈVÉ Ó%ÌsÍ:Å ôI̖Á:ÌVÅéÁ Ê:Ƒ̃ÍMÅ ÁkÂyÂ:Ã<ÄtÅkƜÁõÈVÉ ÓƒÚ&Á ÏgÂMÍ:Á ӖÔ=ÅìÇ`Á~ÄÙÈsӖÁ$Ú'Å=ƜÁkÔ=Á ˧ʋČÌ+ÌsÍ:ÅöÁkÂyÂ:Ã<ÄtÅkÆYÈVÉ Ó Í:Å$Ó Í:Á:ókËcÊ:ԂÂyÉ Ú Ú„Ë Ì¤ÌVÅkÆ.Á ʹÉ:ȤÈVÅ Ê:ÂyÅ Î<Ã=Ê<ËOęÍ:Á ÜkÏvÅéÃ=Ê:ÆkÅ Ó÷Ä?Åk¦̃Ë[É Ê ßIÐ á âMÂ:ËOÄ?Źã Â¦Ì ÌVÉÕǨÍ<Ë[ÂMÍ×ÌsÍ:ÅhÁkÂyÂ:Ã<ÄtÅkÆrÎ<Ï[ÅkÁkÆkÅkÆ,Ê:É:Ì Ô ÃkË§Ï Ì¤Ø¼Á Ê:ÆøÄ™Ã=܋ÄtÅkÖ ÃMÅ Ê^ÌƒÏ ØrďÍ:Å Ç`Á~Ä Î<ÃyÌ˜É Ê*ÌsÓuË[Á Ïcæ Ò:ùIæ úpÊ·ÄyÃ=Î=Î:É Ó4ÌõÉ:È)Ë Ì’Ä ÂyÁ~Ätŷ̃ÍMżÎkӖÉ~ÄtÅkÂ:ÃyÌuË[É Ê·Å:âMÁ ڄ˧Ê:Å=Æ Á~ĂÚ&Á Ê^Ø Á~Ä,Ä™Ë âœÇžË ÌsÊ:Å~ÄyÄtÅ~Ä:æ ï$û МËOÄ»Í:ÅkÁkÆàÂ^É Ê<Ä¢ÌVÁ Ü<Ï[ÅÝü'É Í:Æ$æ¹úpÓ4ÈVÁ Ê=å ï$û çýË”Ä ÂyÉ Ê‹ÄŒÌVÁ Ü<ÏvÅÙü'ŏÇ`ÁÕþgÁ Ú¹å$ï2û ð·ËOÄ ÂyÉ Ê‹ÄŒÌVÁ Ü<Ï[Å ÿ ÉkÔkÅ Ê:ÆkÅ ÓAå/ï$û ù ËOĞÇ`É Ú&Å Ê ÂyÉ Ê‹ÄŒÌVÁ Ü<ÏvÅ×ã Ê<Ë ÌVÁ·ÿ ÁkÆkÁ:ó~å ï$û ò Ë”Ä î IÁ Ï ÷ËOďÍ:Á Ê=å ï$û ßÙËOÄ î ï ӖÁM̖Á Î ô ËcÊ:Ô Í=æ Ã=ÓuËcÊ:Ô¹ÌsÍ:Å ÎkӖÉ~ÄtÅkÂ:ÃyÌuË[É Ê¹Å:ókË[ÆkÅ Ê:ÂyÅ ÆkÉkÂ:Ã=Ú&Å Ê^ÌuÄ á â~æ$ï$û Пޒã å/á â~æ ï$û ç?ޒã å÷á â~æ/ï$û ç?Þ å÷á â~æ/ï$û ç?Þ¥î¾å2á â~æIï2û ç?Þ åIá â~æ/ï2û ò¢Þ’ãêåIá â~æ$ï$û ò¢Þ å á â=æ)ï2û ßtޒã å á â~æ)ï$û ßtÞ å á â~æ ï2û ßtÞ¥î»Ç`ŠӖÅhÅ:âMÁ ڄËcÊ:ÅkƼÁ ÊMÆÙ̃ÍMÅ ÂyÁ~ÄtÅìÎkÓ–É Î:Å Ó4̤Ø6á â~æ ï Ð.Ç+Á~Ä Á ÏOÄtÉÙÌVÅ Ê:ÆkŠӖÅ=ƕÁ Ê:Æ6ęÃ=܋ÄtÅkÖ ÃMÅ Ê^ÌƒÏ Ø6ï)á6Ç`Á~Ä 3 "! #"$ ! %'&( ) * +,

-.) / 0()213 4 +54 2 6 7 2498 : ;=<> @?A<B)24 ) C D 7&( E 4 ( F 13 C4 ) 7 4 GB H, 24 * I-. 2 J +(G2&K L M& 2 /4 7 K "!ONO * +, 05P * & 2 4 4 * 24 K +5 F 4 G & 2 0()213 4 ) 7 24 )24( QF+ R @& 2 S+5 13 T 9 @& ) U S& V 3 4 4 * 24K A)24 W & W& ) = 243Q ) X Y Z[ 1 P, C K) 4 @& P 24K 2 *) "! %'&( ) * +, 4 ( \ 0 P5 * Y & 2 \ S C ) H 24 * ] C4 Q 24 * "! ^ & ) H( ) X G H( 24 1_Z @& +(G2&K TQ7+ * 24` S 2 ) 7 24 24a @& P +* 7 24b H, 24 * c-c&, & )2 ) d+54 2 fe ?hg ;= V i& ) W * 24` j )2 , lkc 2& h! ^ TQ )24 -c& m 2P i @& ) A 24 8 82! # n ! #2o & c-.) JP j

p) k qO<rks)24( 3 24c @& ) 2 ) Z=qO<B?U ) )2P/t' 4 G2& 2P S [)[ Y )2 u 0( X Y WP,+ )24 )i)24 WP, u) j 7 *)249) u 24(G3-v 7& 0( X Q 2 71 ) l-v 7&l @& I ) Q_?wt 4 @& x1 ) y*& )24 )I)24 x& z1 ) { @& 24K @ RZ 4[ G V j 2 '4 "!A; n ) | 2 F ) 4 "! 8 }|; om~ 0 !?hg ;€‚N>!?"g ;vQ7+5 R @& 2 2P @& ) ƒ 24l;j}D! ; # ! #2o & l& )24 „ H( 2 A @& „ Y )2 u „ 0( X Y „ )21 P, )24 z 0( V …Q 2 71 @& +(G2&… * 24` j )2 , u …†O G 24( 2 ‡ ~ 0 X ‰ˆ )" 2 ) 2 RZ Š ^ %A‹ )24 W 24Œ; n ! ;K82! #2o qO<‰ ) G2P ) 2P S Ž @&  *+ U Q @& „ )21 „ 4 @& 1 ) yK&()24 )"! ?hg 8 X K 24,  )2 , kc -L) ‘6)21 -c& 2P @& ) l 24 8 82! # n ! #2o & =-.) P j

m) K 24,  )2 , m) |?wt ’“ H "yd’“ & )2 D)24 W& =-.) 4 ”2•3–@— ˜W™ š –@› ” œCœC • ž Ÿ S–R¡ š2•(Ÿ[š –Aš2¢ ” *–D£"¤R¥ ¦ ™ §©¨c— ˜2• — ˜„› ˜ š ª(— ˜ Ÿm •3«@› ”2•K– ” «Ž§ š C•¬ž š – ˜©” «Ž­ ¢,œ ” ª(®S¯r°± ²(˜2®³°“ — š2›@¯/´|— š µ ˜·¶T¶c— ˜¸µ š ¨ ”2• ˜¹œ š Ÿ ¡ ª*”2§3 • ž³«@› ”2§ –@— ˜Eµ* Ÿ ˜B” «/› š Cœ ¨Lš ¡zœC • ˜¬®*— š –T– 𬗠š(², • ž\º ¦¬œC – ˜2›‚µ³™,œ 𠵐–7 ª ª*š2• ˜ C• — ˜"› — š2• Ÿ µ » ¼ •/µS ,µ ™, ª u”"•/š2• Ÿi”2•/ª(— š µSC•(žŽ— ˜2› ™,œ š µj–7 ªdªKš2•(˜3¨.š µ « ” 5• ŸW— š ² C•(ž[CœCœCuª  – œC ½ (”2›@»m´"¾ ¿ «7 5›R–@— ˜2›hŸ ˜2™ ” µ ˜ Ÿ9–7—(š –A •À–@— ˜W§ ˜ š2•K–7 § ˜ Áà´U› š – š2™ ăC• ž2—3š œXµY”]ª*š2§ ˜=š – –@— ˜ µ ™ ” –š2• ŸŽ— ˜Ž™ › ” Ÿ (ª*˜ Ÿ/–@— ˜=š ª*ª ,µ ˜ Ÿ š œ ”2• ž=¨v –@—]™,œ 𠵐–7 ª/ª*š2• ˜ – ”W—, §9»9Å'— ˜2› ˜ š «T– ˜2›U¶ ¼©š µS® ˜ Ÿ9« ” 5›2«7 ² ˜W™ ˜"›‚µY”"•`µ – ”‡Æ@”  •À–@— ˜W™ › ” ª*˜ ˜ Ÿ  • ž µ3¢, *–lš œXœ,› ˜ «7 ,µ ˜ Ÿ=š2•(Ÿm¶ ¼¬– ” ”2®d”2•(˜ ½ (š2›T– ˜2›w¢ ”(–R–7œ ˜ œC ½ (”2›‡«@› ”2§ –@— ˜‰µ š  ŸM™,œuš µj–7 ªÇª*š2• ˜zš µ{µ š2§ ™,œu˜zš2•(ŸB™,œ š µj–7 ªÇª*š2• ˜Ç¨L˜2› ˜ µ ˜ š œ ˜ ŸÇ¨d –@—ȵY˜ š2œ|” «À´wÄ6»r¶ ¼ «7CœCœu˜ Ÿ³˜ É(ª XµY˜È« ”2›@§ š2• ŸM™ › ˜2™ š2› ˜ Ÿ‰µ ˜ uÊ 5› ˜ § ˜2§ ”WË2É »´"¾ ¿ŶÍzš2• Ÿ —,Xµ/µj– š(– ˜"§c˜"•K–'Ë2É »2´h¾ ¿YÌ ­W¨.š µ3› ˜ ªK”2› Ÿ ˜ Ÿ"»„´"¾ «7 5›R–@— ˜2›ÎŸ ˜2™ ” µ ˜ Ÿ]–@— š – –7—(˜2› ˜ š «T– ˜2›ƒ¶ ¼p™ › ˜2™ š2› ˜ Ÿ9– ˜2— ›F ›Îš2• Ÿ[š2• ŸW— ˜ ¨L˜2•K–Ζ ” ´AÄÏ« ”2›6› ˜ ž Xµj–@› š –7u”2•Ž” «D–@— ˜Wª*š µ ˜mš2• Ÿ— ˜l› ˜ –7 5›7• ˜ Ÿl¢ š ª(®/š œ ”2• ž ¨v –@—iª*”2™K¡ ” « Ðh¶RÑÒ¯ – ˜"— ›F ›iš2• Ÿaœuš Ÿ ¡¸ªK”2•,µ– š2¢,œ ˜©Í‡•, – š"»vÅ'— ˜2› ˜ š «T– ˜2› µS – ˜ ™,œ š2•E¨.š µ ™ › ˜2™ š2› ˜ ŸŒ¢K¡i–@— ˜Ï¶ ¼pš2• Ÿmš ª*ª µY˜ Ÿ[¨.š µ]š2›7› ˜ µj– ˜ Ÿi²  Ÿ ˜„š2›7› ˜ µj–O§ ˜2§ ”ÇË É » ´"¾ ¿YÌ Â »6´"¾ «F ›R–@— ˜2›ÒŸ ˜2™ ” µ ˜ Ÿ–@— š –6–7—(˜2› ˜ š «T– ˜2›L™ ˜2›‚µ ”2• š œ µ ˜ š2› ª(—„” «6–@— ˜ š ª*ª ,µ ˜ Ÿ…¨.š µ ª*”2• Ÿ (ª – ˜ Ÿ¬¢K¡³œ š Ÿ ¡Èª*”2•`µj– š2¢,œ ˜ÈÍҕ, – š{¨v—, ª(—ȝXµ³Ë É »>´h¾ ¿YÌ ÓÒ¯_ª*š µ ˜·™ › ”2™ ˜2›R–T¡JŸ ˜2™ ” µS – ˜ Ÿ¹ •‰–7—(˜·§ š œC®*— š2• š·¢K¡B–7—(˜a¶C¼ š2• Ÿ·—,Xµ µS 5™ ™,œ ˜2§ ˜2•K– š2›R¡3µ– š – ˜2§ ˜2•K–,¨.š µc› ˜ ª*”2› Ÿ ˜ Ÿ ¢K¡d–@— ˜Ž¶C¼/» ´h¾ Ô Xµ ª*”2•`µj– š2¢,œ ˜ ÕO” ž ˜2• Ÿ ˜2›Ö¨v— ” Ÿ ˜2™ ” µ ˜ Ÿ –7—(š –¬”2• ºj× » º ¦"»Ø¦2Ôٗ ˜¸¨Lš µJ™ ” µj– ˜ Ÿ š – ´wÄ °“ ² ˜"®‰°±C— š2› š2•(Ÿ·”2•J–7—(š – Ÿ š(¡¹— ˜ 5 Ú*Û ÜCÜuÝ Ú Þ Ý ßiàYá2â ã,Ü Ý àdß ä5Ü å9à Ý á Ü Ý ß=ævç Þ7èdÞ7è(Ý à Ý á ÜKÛ éAêwëé@ì Û2â¹â á ÜCí*è á2î á]á2î ß ß Ý2ã Û àSç Þ Ý ß]çCî_Þ@è Ý[ï2ð Ú çXà Ýiñ á2ò_ó çuß ÝiôÃõzö6Û"÷ ø,ù2újûføÎü ÷ êhý þ„çXà¸æLÛ2â Ý2î9Ú*Û2î`àjÞ á2ò,Ü Ý]ÿÒî,ç Þ á Ãá ß á ó3ævè Ûiß Ý2ã Û à Ý ß]Þ@è á Þ Û2î ø ø2÷Ø ù "÷Øù2úià è Ý=æ.á à=ã Û àjÞ Ý ß ç î êA ë “ç ó(Ý2 í “ç è á2ìDá2î(ß[Û2î·Þ7è(á ÞAß á åŽà è Ý ì Ý á Ú(è Ý ß¸á Þ Þ@è Ýsà ã Û Þ á Ü Û2 î Mævç Þ@èbÚ*Û2î`àjÞ á2ò Üu Ý cÝ æ.ápô6á2â á2î ß©á Þ Þ7è(Ý ç î`àjÞ@ìFä(Ú ÞFç Û2î`àŒÛ é>Þ@è Ý Ãõ ê|ì á(Þ á2ãxë'ç î 2èzè ݉Ú*Û2î ß ä(Ú Þ Ý ßÈÞ@è ݬã Ý2ì‚à Û2î á Ü à Ý á2ì Ú(è Û é2á Ú*Ú ä,à Ý ß ó ç ß Ý â Ý2â Û[ï ð ÷ ê"ý øY û Ò÷ êhý ]çX à O õ á Ü DçXàSè(á2îcæcè Û[ß Ý2ã Û à Ý ß9Þ@è á Þ Û2îWüjþD÷ ü ùh÷ ù2úiè Ý æ.á àIã Û àjÞ Ý ß‰á àÈß ä*ÞTåxÛ éTé7çuÚ*Ý2ì á Þ êA ë ±ç ó(Ý2 í “ç è á2ìdá2î(ßMÛ2îÇÞ7è(á Þ ß á(åBè Ý ì Ý Ú*Ý ç ó(Ý ßŽìFä5í*í á/é@ì Û2â¬Ú*Û2î`àjÞ á2ò,Üu Ý cÝ Ý æLáiô6á2â¸à Ý2îKÞAòK å OõBêUì á Þ á2ã/ë'ç î 2è á2î ߄Û2î=Þ7è(ݏò á àSçXà/Û éÎæcè,ç Ú(èWè ÝÏì Ý Ú*Û2ì ß Ý5 ß Rô‰Û éDÞ@è,çXà Ú*á à Ý ï2ð ÷ êhý û‚ÿ á2î ß Ý2î ß Û2ì‚à â Ý2îKÞ2Û2î ìFä5í*í á]çXàÀï2ð5÷ êhý  û U÷ êhý çVà Oõ\ê|ì á Þ á2ã ë'ç î 2è/æcè ÛWá ÜXà Ûmß Ý2ã Û à Ý ßWÛ2î3Þ@è ݄à á2â Ý ÜCç î Ý=Û éé á Ú ÞFà á àÀàjÞ á Þ Ý ßWòKåŽêhý ø3ævè,ç Ú(è9á2ì ÝWî Û Þ|ì Ý2ã ì Û ß ä(Ú*Ý ßWè Ý2ì Ý]é Û2ì2Þ@è Ý à á2í Ý Û éò5ì Ý ó ç ÞTå ÷ "ù ! ÷ “è á ó(ÝMè Ý á2ì ßEñ ß"÷6ÿ>êUê¬é Û"ì‡Þ@è ݉ëÎÞ á Þ ÝBá2î ßzÚKÛ ä î`àYÝ ÜDé Û2ì‡Þ@è Ý á Ú*Ú ä,à Ý ß á2î #ß Û2î Ý Þ@è ì Û $ä 2è_Þ@è Ý â á Þ Ý2ìFç á ÜYÛ2î ì Ý Ú*Û2ì ß"÷ &ù %2÷ ÞwçXà àSä5ò â3ç ÞTÞ Ý ß Û2î ò Ý2è á Ü éAÛ éÞ@è Ý[á Ú*Ú ä,à Ý ß]Þ7è(á ÞAá Ú*Ú ä àYÝ ß è á à ò Ý Ý2î=é á2ÜVà Ý Ü å[ç â ã,ÜCçuÚ*á Þ Ý ßç î9Þ@è,çXà Ú*á à Ýmá2î ßiÞ@è ݄ëÎÞ á Þ Ýlè á à é á çCÜ Ý ßiÞ Ûlã ì Û ó(Ý ç ÞFàLÚ*á à Ý"÷ ù "÷ During the course of arguments counsel for accused 6 submits that prosecution has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. Counsel for accused has drawn my attention on the statement of PW 2 who is the recovery witness and he stated that he identified to the accused Anita whereas accused's name is Vidhya. Further more PW 2 further stated that the case property was recovered from the possession of the accused lady Anita. The aforesaid deposition of PW 2 shows that PW 2 could not identify the accused as accused's name is Vidya but he again and again repeated the name of accused Anita. Counsel for accused further submits that empty case property was produced before PW 6, IO of the case which also shows that case property was tampered, hence tampered case property cannot be relied upon. Counsel for accused further submits that IO stated that accused was arrested at 10:30 pm whereas as per arrest memo of the accused shows that accused was arrested at 10:10 pm. Counsel for accused further submits that prosecution witnesses admitted that alleged spot is a public place but no public witness was made as a witness for the recovery of alleged liquor. Simply prosecution witnesses stated that public witness refused to join the proceedings. Counsel for accused further submits that no notice was served to the public persons who refused to join 7 the proceedings which shows that accused has been falsely implicated in the present case as nothing was recovered from the alleged spot. Counsel for accused further submits that keeping in view the aforesaid facts, accused be acquitted.

On the other hand Ld. APP for the State submits that prosecution witnesses have proved its case, hence accused be convicted.

10. After having gone through the submissions of the counsel for the accused as well as submissions of Ld. APP for the State as well as material on record, I am of the considered view that prosecution has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.

Firstly, it is pertinent to mention here that PW 2 Mewa Ram who is the sole eye witness of the alleged recovery of illicit liquor from the possession of the accused. After having gone through the deposition of PW 2 constable Mewa Ram it appears that he could not identify to the accused as he repeated again and again the name of person namely Anita in his deposition whereas name of the accused is Vidya. I am of the considered view that identity of the accused is not correctly proved by the PW 2 who is the sole eye witness of the case.

8

Secondly, case property produced before PW 6, IO of the case was an empty cane whereas prosecution alleged that cane of 10 liters was recovered from the possession of the accused.

Prosecution has not explained why the case property was empty. The aforesaid fact also creates doubt in the mind of the court.

Thirdly, PW 2 and 6 stated that alleged spot is a public place but police has not made any public person as a witness for recovery of alleged case property. Merely stating that public witness refused to join the proceedings is not a sufficient cause for escaping of their liability. Moreover, no notice was given to those persons who refused to join the proceedings. It is settled preposition of law that police should make an attempt to join the public persons for the recovery of any article which is to be suspicious. I am of the considered view that attempt should be reflected on record. At least notice should have been given to those persons who refused to join the proceedings.

11. In view of the above discussion I hold that the accused is not found guilty of the charge framed against her and she is acquitted of the charge under section 61 Excise Act framed against her.

Accused be set at her liberty if she is not required in any other case.

9

After compliance file be sent to record room.

ANNOUNCED IN THE OPEN (R. L.MEENA) COURT ON 12.06.08 METROPOLITAN MAGISTRATE KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI 10 ' (*),+.-0/ 132&1547698 :;4=<?>A@CB"D$E FG<IHKJLENM @O19/P6 >0/P6&Q RTSUH"<5H9VOM=W JXRYR[Z\-9S3M^] H`_;M\a M\H0/ JbEcEed3<IH f#-9V#g a"F hP/ ijFkf&Hmlon <IH9p a9SUa M\Hrqsd$f t9lKH9VOM7uYa EcE d3<IH fvFG<wa Ecx"d F MyM\H f - Z.M^] H E$] a9SUt Hzd&V$f H9S <5H ENM{F|-9Vm>A@}- Z~M{]$H B"D$E FG<5H,JLENM7/JLEcE d3<IH f€g H€<IH Moa MK] H9S h Fg H9S*Myn F Z <e] H‚FG< V -$M[SUH x"d FSUH f‚FVƒa9VOn - M^] H9S Eca <IH0/…„†a"FGh‡g -9V fˆ- Z#M^] H a EcE d3<IH f FG<‰Eca9V EcH"h hkH f0/Š_d&SUH Myn‹f"FG<5E$] a9SUt&H f0/XJYZyM\H9SrEO-9l#p3h F|a9V EcHzZ{F h|H g H <IH9VOM M\-rSUH Ec-9SUfrSU- -9l / Œ )j#ŽŠH H9V a  Ž#Ž~4‘Y“’;4”@O19/P6 >0/P6&Q