Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

C K Laxminarayana Hegde Since Dead By Lrs vs The State Of Karnataka By Its Secretary on 16 June, 2010

Bench: Manjula Chellur, B.S.Patil

 I: 11 1;     % 1 N 1 H   

1N Tilli 111G11 C()UR'i" 011-' KARE\IA'i'AKA. 113ANGA11C;-RE:
1:)A'1.'1:+:1") T1 -113 '11-} 1a 161"" DAY OF J UNIS.  ~30'    - ..

PREZSEINT

'I'HE HON'B1.E MRS. .1Us'1'1CE"'M.;a;N,J1111.11 1'C 11'1;rs1.V,UR 

AND 

T1 112 1 IONBLES 1\/1.1~:;1.,:g1"L.1%>S'£'I('i1%:1__13;s, :I>A'1'*--11§'  

w..A. No.32sf21oo3 --
BETWEEN:» ' ' . '

C. K. 1,_ei1><M1NAf1éAY1-QNA' ;=-.'E:';_"»--,..(V_:1i:1'-1'«:;,' 
s1NC1;"Ii)1_e;A-1') 1331111-as'; *   

1.  0,1... s11:1::1'111A1aw11 .-- J
"*5/O_ l;A'.I'I£'«C3 K,.{;fiJ3§}\;IINARAYAAI---i113GI.)E.
1V1'!_\=JOR.   _  1
R/ G ,131_<3},1 ,1-'~.__1\IE\I.I§ 'V. 11,11/XG 15..
 ~ SAGAR i1'A1;L11<.'
' I S1'H_MOG21\«I.i).1_S7E"R1C'1T - 577401 .

. ~11;.«., V1i<::_1.\1 KA"mG1_R_1 .
' ».S*«,.'.§') !;2~'£1TI4£ C. K. LAXMINARAYANA I--{$361311}.
MA;;--c>}:>2.
_ W .()i'.=J OG ROAD.
.. SAGAR -- 577401
,s'1~11M0c;A Ij)IS'i'RIC'I'.

. . .Ai?PEI,I.ANTS

 (133: : SR1 R c.c)1>A1.. 1\ifJ\»".}

AN 1)



1. 'I'}"iI.*Z ST/\"I'I*I OF KA.R.NATAIr{A.
BY ITS SECI-{E'CTAI'{Y.
REVEN U E I1) I23 PARTM EN
M S BUILDING.
BANGALORE 1.

:2. '1fI----iii. LAND TRIBUNAL. 
SAGAR, J' va»
REPRE3E3I'3N'I'I<3D BY ITS CHAIRMAN 
1r>:N+577401.  

3. GOVINDA {')I.*3VADIGA ' '
SINC E INEAI") BY LRS.

3.[21). 1-mam l)P3V;if)'}«GA--'_VAS DEVADIGA
MAJOR R/O '"_{'AL.:\czv1Jȣ3APA '1LL=1o.BL!,
SHIMOGA - 5i7_'72VQ1 __  * "  ., 

1. 3.'[E5)'.'As.1\E;fr vE:N12<'A§./;Iv1A, 
 __ .w/Q1:,A";iE:'GQu1rsDA DEVADIGA,
_/-xc131.1)«Jx£3Ou'I'<.73_.Y1:ARs.
 L W 0 VVI'gf§'E~{IgIf\N'E¥'E__£fl' \/'I'I..LAG 1-3.
"SAGAR3'V"
SI-HMOVGA  5771401

... RESPOND ENTS

 'V w-mi} 1..-L.;~;1;> 1.5/8 4 ()F"1'}-{E3 K,»'\R§\'=A'I"'A§<A HIGH C()UR'['
'..<-xcfi' PRx'X'.K§NAE;§ TO SET AS105 ORE)I:ER PASSESED IN THE. WRIT

P£33TI"I'IV_OT;"*€_.I~VE\? "1"1»-H5. WRIT PEiTITI(f)N NO. 29€}6()/'$995 DATED
m/1 112695.

This»; appeal  <1:(:>1I1ingj, on for p1't?Ein'1in;=.1t'y hearing this

" V{i'a-rg.»'i' MANJULA CHELLUR. J ., defiixfereci the E.'(.)IIowir1g:



'"».§"'~

.~u

JUDGMENT

E--1c:*a1'd the i€z11'1'1€;'.d ('()Lt11SC3E_Jfi3I'.__fi'.Y1C_'é1}.)f§€3§T§..€1}71't ."TI'1is= i$u 'the Sc-3('.011d 1'(.)u1"1C1 liE'.igat.io11 at E.i'1€;".i.1'1S.'_['.;EiI"1!(3€T C1' the". pétif--io§if::F- owner. Ac'.c:01'cii1'1g to me? p¢'f'i1...i0rac319'~i1":spité..()E*{ti1s'."order of remand by {his (_\L)1,11"'£. 501': €211":i_CT.1;V:§5f?§f£i§i()11..i'I'I.'W.f';7_Vfi§?().3244/8E dated 17.9.1984 a.1'1dv 2153 many as 38 d0cu1"nem..<a z111_d-- did not cor1sid.er which was sim.il.ar to orxe :v1.:Q ' E;_)_c'aV "the earlier mund oi' Eitiig.'i:1;__i01j 0 ,/8-1 (:()1.1nsei for the appellant.

1.1113'"E€;11'1'1eci".,Si1igi€' Jxldgc Coulcfi }12'.wc (i'ons;id€r(?d the A '.c§dL.t111'i1C;'1_tzltfy and orai ctviclence br01.1g11':' on record by the 'a1"y'§)eiiv2:ii*1,lx ir{riv!.--i'1t)1.1l 1'ema1'1di1'1g back the 1'na.E,1,€1' to the 'E"'1<i.l)Lu_'1'2'i1~, all the 111a1eriai 1'equired to cronsiciex' the C()I1E€'f1£iOI]S of both the pa1'ties was very 11'1uch available on ' r--:=,C0rd.

3. The v<;*z"y ;g1'it:v21n('e of the 13eti1i.()1{1e1* bezforc: the Eea-u'n(?d Single .,}x.1cigc: to 1.11:: effect Ihzau inspite of :'€:1I'a2111cii1'1g E110 ma1t1.<.=1' to give an €)})1)OI'ELl§'§.i{},-' 10 both ;)z».1r1.ies amd 1'0 ('011si(1('1' a1dd1"I'i011;1! ("\"iCiGI"l(".C 1-hm wcmld be pI_'<.)_Ci1.1(red by the 1:)2.1.1'1.i<'*s. I'.}'1c 'i'1"ib1411'1ai did not ihc C1('}iffUi'I1:'fi?-IV1a1".&'g'1'v\' and oral (tv1'c1@11c0. Based on this submission afid ()1j of the orclers of the 'I'1'ib11na1, t.}'1E',.:1'€'."&}}'.I"](;'.d I Si11gi';>4:,J ;.1V(1g_C \vas jL1stii'ie~.d in <.'0nCfu.diI1g 1I*1z1t."1«&i11E;.%_;')Ti'1'i-:1 0i'" ..V'U1L1fTfi1'i'I.1f3'i1S d0cun1c11t'a1*_\/ z'.m(i oral C?\-'1'dV(:J.1_('5'Ct., t.hc*""E':V*im.1_naV1 ("x.i:Ci"'~;'1.f;L: every' reiktl' 110 those d0(*:.:1ncr__11s in de.1.21_i'1x:--_11"1*d did 110-It,;'11)Vpi*'eLria1.e the C"-T\riC1€E1'1('?€ cm re<:c..>:'d. --Whai a'{3;)'c.H£1;'1! seeks from this ('.01lI'1 11()E'i1i11;._'g- bul jr_tq'fj[i1'e.ffi;'1tfiQf1._of "i.}1é'1m21t4e1'ia1 on record as "bg: :f'o:"c fife? 'f'1'i§5'1.11'121i way oi';-1ddi1.i()11e.ti e\.-yidence. As t'.hi":i»' C01111 C'<.;.r:1"1:?14(;A)1=. VZ£"2','V(")"--.._ifi.'.}"'{(_) the fzlcjttu 21! si1.L.1atic)n we>. are of the 0;.)i1'1i"01_'1."€' §'}€T \).I'(Vf(.'l' "<)E: @=i1<«% 1e;11*11(*c1 Si1'1§.§1c Judge jL1sI'if'icc1 in I :f1'E" 1';-1('1.5 a'1»1(,1 {.?iV1'<..'111'f.1ss1211'1{..'t's oi' the.' ('.£15~'s€'.. /.'§<"-f'QI'f1iI1g'Iy,.._:t'_l1<,* £1ppE:'2'11 dismisscrd. 3&1' * EUEGE S&/w REESE