Karnataka High Court
Venkataramana Reddy vs Elanchezhian on 17 August, 2011
Bench: K.L.Manjunath, H.S.Kempanna
E"f°€ TZ"iE€ §H{.§ H C{}U§~2T OF E€;?x§€f'€E&"E'2'aI<L5§ ;"'{."§"' I;:3Al'\§ €}.51'%§,€)E'{E§ 1:};-"%.'?E}I-I} "EH18 'F'E""£§:3 E?"'§"§ E};-Y2" GE' AEEGU 25$}. E E-3'RI7'ZS If:ET'\é"§' 'E'E--iii .E"i{)N'§3L.§7I; 'gvrk, Ji§'S'f§'iCE:T K.L.:wzAzxaJ'a;:~g;:;*1:2~:.' ... j ;_. A' {ENE} "9;-1 :4: }~i{)N'§?3LE§ M",{3;.JLES'§'E{f;E"} if.S,§<i§3E§?£.P;i:I§§'1T%£Q3;' 'V , [ :' §v1.F,;?:.:*e<}y_:5::~:8;3/2:j::>:*;*":':?a;z'%x) "
BE"iV"v*EE3N ' 2 :. 'WEN E{A'E'ARAE\/is7%_Z\?si ':a:«::;:3:::":%'" = Q S,/O, 'MUi'€ERE~3[)£}¥".~ _ --
;:xG§:§3 55 yiaaizg T :3.) $321' ' m,41:::§;x:;::%:»qL&§ v;;0;' ER} f»;f':a:I-:_E§;§s;'1*;x£4<;:gv:A'Nza 'M21313? A:A:;-§;;:j>--a,2;'gagrgxtzss " ._ - -
Ezaarr»-~§._A§2;_}; R.-,s'c:a "m":'*1_f§;:t«: vgx:2:;>ALL:=2:
H:A:2ri:,s3:T OFGEENGE'~;':fx§{if>*A,I;Ei,.§%:
V§LLA{:.E§,"$G£1}AM M~AN§}AL ; <5: §f2f:.".:'c><;-:42; V_:}'§:£~*;:.';2;:c'z' 5%." :2 z*1E¥'?§%ZE,§,:%T'€"§'S ., €g%j'%'":°%Ri*."'£{:s :9':-::<a;:§.r:{>i:§ ~wzx,z;;x-a;
2 §:._:;-$5:*:.%.v>z':a:z§--swxs :-3/Q, '2?E§E%:E%1§E¥;i§{}§."§£§'v'§:?*~§ §v§.z*1J{}E"~<E 2%; A.{}§:i " ' gags; :;>:«;:v: §~::<};:£;: m:£4:$ 259, E.€E'§{2'3:.?*£ <:<:}z2:::->:','§_:::>a:
ECEEEESS {it§~»:;a;v:gx_R;a;;;>§e:*r :T3;€2§a§{;;%.§....{>;2§e: A :3%:;<§<:§ .2 i'f§?§'¥§§_%E{}?€5%E', §'ir'EZ£'af'€3%€If;§£?E3"<i §.E§T1E§"E"T?;E"f} §§"éf§I}Eg'~'§ §E'éE§§,§'§{fa§*'£{ZZE£ 3%,'? §.f'§'%§.f} iii 5 E." ?%€.%;'°E"§f:§E{,"}?'é E1€{};:-Eé} {E '§'%:E;§.'§""§.}'7% 'E'{iT}'ifif'E**L E'?€-33 §§.51?£§f}5E§,€f}E1i.§3:L -M 2"" :§{fEEi}fZZ7L 3523555';E?{}§'=sEZ§"§*§;§?'T'a§'§"f%?> "Z3 {BY SR£,57%,, M E%ZN§{_;'7'{§'£%:SE-'1 W ;'%,i:}V. FOR R2», ?*»;IO'§'EC£%Z "H3 R-- Z '§'.)ES§3'E?INS§%ZEf} W§5E'E'E \x"',fQ E};-'¥f'.§;*:I[}: §3.%§§i§.U9E 'FE--{ES rvézzrxa ES :«='§_1;.za';1::> UXS 17:31} SF Evfif ACT A<::.;fx_1:«4s"r "mg: J'UE}GE'viI§§N'§' AME} f--*~.W,:%.RE} I}A'§'EiE}: i.Q.6.2§O"E" .§¥'z?;_SS§EE} EN E&:£'v"'C NO. 68'?6f2€305 01% 'PHE%§'- mg: 01? "m::;*, Kw'???-:fV'._.(;:):i.§F§I::}-Efiv Jfj{;)£§EZ, C{}L1RT <3? $§'V{§,&'L,$i§.!E,.r C£'§USE%ZS, ME::~x1:ia§e;:f2;,". .i'*¢ifi{§Li'ff?f3, M1E:'1'RGE3'{}L§'1'EAN AEEISEX, ::3;xm<;zx:J<>;<2£«:, _£:;fi4C'C«E:5§;i-3\EQ;.3_}';« _ PAR'§'I,Y AI,I,O\?V§E\§G "i_'E~{I%IZ CLAIM _p§::*;'*:j:':Q3s, " mg: ' COMP§§I\ESA'£"1QN ANEB s2«::«:;x:1L\:C, bE§NE**I.;*&i£¥z'Cf-E3321"£§1'*~&?'§'* _ ::;~r?"'v CGEK/EPENS.?§.1'§€}?\T. "£H;iS AE"~'PE~?.AL gamma VON F§:;~.'§_2 '§?::_:x:z».._:.J §?»;1:€:;xza:Ntg:.';§'E1:8; EBAY, MANJLTNAET-i" J"; IDEEZLEE-'EL§?.I_f§§f) '1'§:E.,E§ §'$M;Q\s'£f JUDGMEQQVV A '"{"t1s-5 azlaimam/,3;\Ij'4-..:§;hé«?A "..._§S:§ié:'.%;3a.:°m1t$ sf {>:f:r:?:
C§12:k;é9;=:pafii=Rtéezifiijgg '?§7?i§§ céis-':«:i in 2: mad i;raffi{: 2:s::<.:.ici€m'; <><:<:urz*%:A:'§V 13:1' at 233:::z,:i: 2.39 am, new"
{"4 {W3 Baxiaznxunxgéizg R-='h'Ei<: 'éififirgr (Ff {',§";§":."iT:isr {'heI:":I:"ges,iw §*3é;;L%:'3;g2,a§'§7{;-::"°é" :°<>ac:§§ E{'}€Z§§§€i'.€i 3., é?.EEii§"§"£ p:';%'E31t:::<:>z1 ii": MVC V' 68-?§;:é;}Q'::' fig-33.1-"£.%1€ gm? (:2:-' 3131?: is/m<:':: §*"§21:1g2iE<>§'{%. .'§";:é:: '§_"§*§bz:.n21E {?{l§'EES§{E£;?'f'§Z1§§ fizzfi: {§€;',£?€:é§.f€:'=€d wasa 215 §;'§r::§,:"§s ééizé z::r:::§ §:h;>si< Eu: 'aa;2?:;=:~; €;?23;Z'z"§é§"§§;»§ ?5.{}{}{}f-- 33.22}, as "V":F.§E'%.":'§VE;-':€'E::'Edg by' 2::g>§}E}?§.:':g;§ §'E1z3: m:.:E§.é§}E§§~:%r :3? 3% 22:f%.m' §:%s:%{§:.:{:%€',§::.g "'Ef';s{}<?>é5:; ai::=§" 33.53; §§'3<':<>;'*:2<? %;':>:a?;?::*{§;:§ ms; §f}€'I'}"Zfé{',}'§"EEfiE E<'}s;&; £1}? &::3::§:}{;%::.{:§£é§':a:'*.j; %'<fé,,2€IZi€3{}{E§ ~ §z'§"::f§ 2%i¥2E§,§'{'§€f{§ 2%,. .:1;a§;":2 9? ?jf}Ei{E¢éf3€}{fZ:f :":<T§a1::" <..i=.<_i::s*'*;'2=*s-ii:".:.iém"':;«s'§ §r'2za:%;;:.§::§:.»':':._ 4 hs-3&5} in 22 szum 0? §'2€§,{)O€},/-- is; :32": "?£:_f::g=? E{}'i¥€?f 5:-;:T<is:% azéd i;h:ér§:f<m?_. Ehzzfi 2?:pp&?.EE;?:m:s a3"<;'-: &.:1*i.ii.Ea=%<§ far 2: §:,'::'?;.':1<:%=r s3su:*:'; o§'%'E*C?.€3@€1,/-- z,:.I1c:.§e:* the aE3<>ve Saki hcgézxgi.
4. in '$16 §°€?;'$ELi.§.i'. 32.1%": 21pp:'<2z3 zssiiuweai ?:3;i?:'~~«iZ.¥}'«._i..If'i.:. ." '??E'..Eia:i fix z:p§)eiE21z1%.5; sire {%1'1t.if{E€§,5;f"<>r erikiazmeci <jé{;;;1§€:3$:é§i,i<}:/g 3 {;;f_ ' ?'2C%,GGQ/~ 1,a.-iii': mt,€=:ms3t: at 6% £515 3@ti%:ioz1 {iii :*eaIisa'I,'i<:r;;";. :C<}:':s;i{£§%r§':"2 f ?;;h-%:-. Vz"§1g:1"}ifi.£Eai"< ixlzrreasss in the. <:<}'r:1'pé:%r;$ati<::i',u..::sLn:%_direiii '§'1*§.bu.r:21i '£10 :*e=§<3*e1ssa*: 'ithfia {:%:aé:§re:: ;?1;E"E"£'Z}_§'f3"fii t:.;:§ ¥:,§1_.€:L" C:E_E2§§"'£'1'£§'}}*{IS.
rsa