Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
N R Rathod vs M/O Railways on 22 July, 2020
Avd ; a & ced ns J vt es > % ti o a 2 td if} os oe wn "4 Woe sd Co fe ow ee, he * ee, che a a a" 2 vel A wd a8 Go. be te da oe Hoe es ot née TE Ba © oA Sak oe o iy th mE a bed 4 Moet WR ey Pe AE BLS fen ms © iv Ss Sy a Sol eG ey % oS a, ot ma Gs Be Moe-rd oe ey ged ER io ' ~~ a 4 = Os we we 2 ey i rege a Q a oS yy sed we is ; . a OE fe wm a 4 my my oe mt ose t~ eit hoet £2 00 i GB oo mI 8 3 reba Hai & * cy von PD ha a a 8 on es spe EE ed 03 het Oo : me ae be "ee te ; * pk OF 6 4 om it om BiB Sy Ow a wD UO ae "bd moO me esl . 3 eS mt Se we fry 52 a nw EO Og fa rg ft a : oo. © wee Sod a ee red bd Of eed oy ed ts 9 " s o i a e WO Ge COO Bm 6 oe iG we "era aa 3 songs % ao es rE AY LNG 4 $f x alii El © Bt wn LS SF ey et CB SY Oe th tz an i a ak @) $4 Woe aa rad Kee rt xe 3 & rl fa (3 Ry re ord a4 Qo 4 & mimi tho os td a owe ae Lo iq iS wy) oS ay ad oc! oe a eo, : 'Sy feed by hl 3 ey me s om a oy . i) goed ee Or% * oy etl a BS ty ™ i ON erd co ta AS le wo» rai og} ® et Ow Ros eo BS oe oO OD OM So Bra ecg Ce Bot Ag agial Oo Be Sea OP to a fe. Oe ms el a tl Go ther fs Co BG we x fe] 3 ot ce be " oo OG BU i gw v 6 . fy kt Ee £4 Be, bed md wore OP RS bos to "S$. OG ay ip ia bef Q ral mF ea a . % © % Se t ' ay md f "i Ly £3. C3 4 be 5 wad oS aa A hha Co 6G e 4 Eh eek ft io tp O i By Et . wh i <Q { Smo. go os wef ifs mo me © pe De G . , i "4 6 + ha ay eas MoUs mS & "<i Ud Ly ne tt Wy O th ea okt aS 0 DS ed od red OF wy od sy i me mm £5 Th aed «S fois seh ow we TH Es id £3 * 3S ce fe eo ed TS oA 6 fed Or * hy bey wh in m0 8 eth vet eet » oe nok es s mM » 2 Oo aa He Qe Oy ap iG ht bb ord oH eS Gord aed oo oe +O & ON ed <F Bey eT we mm i at :
is ie Sp ed we be 6 on Bow Op B * wo he toy cat mn © fa 3 GQ $4 2 bo SS rae i wed 6B QO. ky hy fw oR TS eee oend ne bs 48 oe Go fs rl ee <4 mo a « Gyo erd ey EY ra be og ee tye OT a a ay th 4 es » <P od ONY Bd iD a cs ened oe ES 4 fe OM Ey ERE ed toe Eg ES a . moog As % 08 G6 uy TCE ed 3 3) PLE oy mere ay 4 oo".
C wat B
a) at t Th R a v o 5 » 3 fas va (So Bs Oy ee my "es Th ed 2S Cy ES 60 AP 3 Oyo Rg oo eS 3 on At ~ @ PQ Oh oe Gm LA fa} Moa ay & RRs 2) a a Ba feb seed thw am 43 Che H aeoog a et co mh rot $4 RI Oy ey Mh os OF OMS Used re @ 2. edd. DALY "eo ac gt LS eed CAE ee AG 03 ms eA LY Ma CR Feo asy, "AG Oy Ley ong ip 394g ch Be ed ved sy apd Ly od WOR oy ep me ged eed QD-t2 wy Sa IR Oy MG Tw AS oa, a ka By AO mn ae RY td sede ae ow Qed ed ed io ee Wh bbs ve fr ed oe i hoary fh, i Os eee eed LL eed fa Lad C oka a8 fhe 4s Hh O° 0% "cy (a8 M433 SRP A ke WD es) SS Oy he bdogt Ka Sa FR EO Che 6 « Oo OO Ree me OE a ees ad iss 3 fee Se 6 LF BOS B42 in ith ef a ™ Ch Te Oo @& GE nm md ae Cop bon RG geet on i PO ms Ht) et Bow «iS Oyo O. op as m Ot 6 boos Wh ES eS a rosa ag rm A Ch eed BG ty A apd hy ot By teh LEO OES é BA be fig Rp oO Da ge ba as i moe Oy ba poh EE wed : by "fs goon $4 TF Sp by ie , cf Bo POL ow. en OO + ot as 15 235° @ Doe Boos 34 £ & vel i tid oY PoE Us Ce Gs @ 4 0 fs, es) 3 Doma ay ag tho Tip ws eg ie ret OY 44 ® 6 Op 44 te 10 4 x ee§ 3 od sd DB ep toy EY tt ce at i op £5. as i kot in fee Ay vf Pe "ot Ad yy dee be : CES Os Q Ob C2 vend &é to 203 wy, i te ad ed M4 oh wEY Ba if Q " ay Cys yg me rr fees &5 rod EY rd » QE «4 T+ ier roe BES a Woo + Ey in ao pF ay Cope ag ' De Gao mn me BEE Bl 2 be BOE OES O oe ws eS) a ay se Bord Bo ms od Sa Oe 08 eA ee ie = ved ore TV fy io AS red ey ie 2h Oy a Doin Bek if ed rm Syed eo Sp sed 4 vO RP EE + et a PR ge ped "a RD HP cd :
he gbo ag ig rel OD ES Ba Oy FG ORE mae Se iy 06 et oho CIO ct fo O TD os mf rd OG mm ee ee, wt Pu et TS Pa Bor He 19 wd " yt owes bs & ms i J a6 ~ m wt o ord Bd 8 C3 ay Ere ww on nt ig we 1 B om 4 to bs ' A 2 is hg t (boss $4 Ess ce 5 wy 3 i ss ot oO mM -« ' Or wn 4 Sa @ n R CS re a ow re sp hornet 0 ~ ey 44 ry aed C ~ @% i kp Dy bey sot Th cs mw ed wy % tr res) UW MG he» a oh . « eee f Uy AG sed ert x oo hg m4 @ ie 4 ot OS Bey OF bp Pe rd <P
- ced Py Gs pete 4d Sa UP 49 Ooh ae od Ag Go a rd 20 Bod ES Ne yO ow Y a: beh BO hd ot Co TG net Gy 0% fo novemaS| vn 8 red on z ord ry fe oM Oy = Oo ® ES ES eh, "65 peed Oo ~ iD ep) ea gh. cf ms ng OG mepow a4 $b on, ory ed * ot ay i ah om ef ae we RA es ~ £2 0 Qe Sx cca) sip kh RG Moot ag Bo iy Mos H ot SG eed sed 44 TE QB Gm. O oy EMO MB PO ig tort Se a mh Ho ets 6 a sy eo " 3 bap et Eo wm 3p eG £3 iw Per oR oh a os Pts wa hg MT) oS See ed A ef wef bE ow i 40 ee co a eee G G3 we ot OG wae RB sed a cy wo gs te 8 13 BS aS Qo my ot PE ad a rd wy 02 MG aes Det Qo a ES es} "s bhp ae i tye os ry Mort Ba eS Cd Wes Cy mo U4 hao $44 ng ica 3 he geeesaunes, peg ot oO md pS bp hy EE Met tg das Pe Sah OY ed ped ord CE vet Ty td 0 ho Us ite Hh iy <4 BY 3 vet QS OS a6 ES ROE w BD y in Gore ip a mt 06 Come a beg ES tet af Og oy ew ci) kgs So) 2a $8 we AG Mo bese Uy sed et ty bd ed Ta CER ed co we TS Che AD hy Od Ae oe fy Dag eth Goo. Feo wef nad 3 Ci eed "A. eo oS At eS i oO & as * Uw GG Cl Re + Gp oer ot OC ae Oe ft fA g 1 eed bE OG ret Uy wt ka 13 6G iG ze ed 3 2 Cad anes Ad. gt ita a cre AE "et ott . GG sef UL BE OT a 1 Gow CF Boe 2 ts 4) 9 iD af rt 6g $3 3 CA os OG mt wd we "eS op om th go © (DOG - PR 2 EE * > tp os ip a c ' orf O Me Hed Bf hp C3 +4 De bE td ce fe bd i eet Py it Ch a 2 tt By ced fhe at are ae SO i "
veg Ds ww Oe 8 Go oO 3 Mee be By et tord 3 / ho ' Gc oe BO ok OD ay ' @ on f4 mM OL OX ep $4 3B wr GQ ge ae 6 mG ef ©) ft Ose Co oa$ tty OE 8G mM SE og bo NM Fond my, on f of ne ee) Jaws ing as xX z "yr 3 8 wo AS ¥ ne 9 LMG £3 Ee if fe % ae I $4 = ef Me Lows rk sid a 43 Do ey w a wy Al «3 5 wm 2s Gg Ce iy a 4 * wy tee ix, 3 * itr gd Ue Ley ee Cr ore "
cw ms Q oA me Ca Eo id apd ced seh bd at <ed ered oP AB 7m we A TS eh MBE BH TES Ob fee) ord 4 vet oat eed aa Uy os on a Cp oA sw Gt © Sy Sood ee 3 Bo fe k eo db rt ed x (G3 ted nee mg a1 ry mot Oe CO x « is ne ig 42 UP ved 0$ Uy im AS ened xn rok by ty Bel BS bab ye} pot {4 Pe GS ted GD Wh Pt iG ry Th. 4 3 m OG wo eae cond cede TS i. ER Sao a 4 Oe 8 Ie AD ag ia z - ie a K Oe he SM a need wy CTF CTH sed eae 4 6 8 ah Dar S 5 MESS goon S » coy ~ £83 Me zs AG 5 req > a WG re 43085 ved 3 * Eh oe bed Sey ty eed a4 Ge Bao pe elo ES i} Ovum Cho GItG iB 2
- ° mg os £5 4G cond ees rd oR ~ pad ese ae aed bas Bes wo $I ES eb) Meo Up ne ka oh 6S oH a kaya a booed Ee 1h et £3 ~ <G Lh Go 8 % eB 6 OP ey . 1 ee @ a WMO fe od ME TG rd oy eats) 6S "er ta 8 2) £3 & Ne ard ho i wa ved Oo Gov id EF ot m3 wy pe SE oe t on i me Ep th os as ~ Boe mod AB ri ori oN €osrbord a Pog OS wets yo Wg ra " BWoed + My OG} XD wed Gb ved A te od 3 ey Spo ay. ag ON ag Ua a ot fre OL SO C4 fy UE PE Lhe ey CO SE AG ey hE po op ngs a Fy oy a3 : +s wm ita fu ri Bb m 42 . fn iS ir +6 Me it on cre ity ced 4 Ae Ly as) " Ad ts Oe goo rl 84 bd ee s wt . 13 « sd obs Eg orf 4.3 oR OS sf oc . on 3 rd OY Moth Cz Bos som ae om XG Ot 7D wef ood "A oD bf Pact ae Eb ocd OO 24 got be ed M4 nN GB it ok be 8 we 6 TS Of fa bord OD rh SG ved a Mom Ae ES Oo i pO mE Ef sof ed Se td Ota c a} As vetoed Qe ae GMS Es Set: wet ee fo Dh
3) Ov oom ord ig wf ow bt OB oe OD ow , OC oe af pa Ue o& PE xed eed od uy Ss Ww ow 7 Ooovrt 6 ry aD Py TS og Bot CS we og
3. tt me Oo » ft OG, SO oe COR GQ eo 3 G) -rd rey oO Ai O a ard ME Gh 0 GS mom oO yo uy 2 POE ~ OG Mao se pod (4 wm fe 43 3. a5 ha ng iy ch w EG i ei aS mw Ly KOON th) or fs Sa moos Q} if oon ee . L "ed a % Fee rd oS Do owe ge By oo fe pry om 1S Gy rl ert ef OG hy a red EP ome oop ke G8 Pee Sots i Qo 4 et 5S Pat WO om Ae OG Gord + el eae tr dG ort ko » me worD & Ar on Wb. 8 tS yes a Gm Ee 1S bg my SD ri TA ped tS o Sy Os sy} p> wy. mon Oo a Ht . & oD od oe cy og weed rm th kb rd Mos at Oi fh et Go Hm kbd wed we ab £3 te $f vend SG ey oy OF DM a oo a ey wo ao ete TS oh TH ad eS CON wy Ue aya so 5 Me moet & hw MW Apo eh Fr tap ad ed nh BG "OG Sort eee hd 43 oe OG SS Wie mM £2 0 i MG E+ fo 42 HS it mY . +4 mo ® eG £3 Ds a a EP Phe. « oA meee mG G % wes ue 9 bey as ma Word ms a SG ret el 43 " = SoG he ee ts wn " Sod 1 O MG £6 © #3 " ow ba 3 we a aig ae ee TL eopa Oo ft mM med « SE 0g ha wd wir} ret haf &4 ad CoE Ga aed fp seg Be We Ds Be GE fs wet ry EAD TH Led Os ted AE RR ~ i web oe AE Ea 44 f>3 mt EO OE Cpr oe ee rod my SO w MH 4d 24 KS abs Ot So BB es Ob at Te $3 es Mm ved AS BBO Me Fg ts ved CD Gy CB owed eed fe ge ea a A TE oh Go 6 4 OG BA red Ey ce hy Indoceb eID Kose a bd dk GEE G3 rS to as sof peek UY} fir ow mt oe Gort Aor he Ob. TAs Eat rd SEY a Ty cet 73 rt > a) ™ fait oa m « 4 ee 0 i ef 5 6B ow ww types gS LE RO SE od ned hod Ho Keg ee & (Go @ ot 4A bf sed TE (By TE et % ~ 4 ra) Wy iG 0 "et OE tD ee m5 . ha Sore aed So as FEC} ae 43 fo 43 Mp +s Paired ha oe} 6 0 wed no a A an roel fey 1X wD wed rod wpe iy os a $e £3 mH. ay 3 om eo C3 bp Rat » 43 Th. oS mm Ro sa fir EM red 6S r18) q4 Th he Et ote a 5 oo oo Shs BG a 6 a $e 4S 1 ty Be ORY So 4G EL Aes ry CS EE kw wy ES so. eG Ad cod OES ry at ~ GH rR wh 03 A is a ESA iy * GH OB Doe af CG foe & ih ret S tag ag 45 gh rf ist Ag Be * O Get cf mi) ne od GE ED bos mo a ht ER 6h es oA) Ee mo EOS EE A tet et Ott Ww oO "A Uy Tz G TS hy Bie |. wd Ttd tea & t3 i Os £2 sd Pan a ON ses} tm #3 pe 8 OS eae oN ES a ee) MT Oe 3 re) eG AD im MM cAl Ow a me be Ee PG iG toe mE bo ved GB nm he cs ebb Heed "ty os © 03 OH cA °T> O os «OP Beet eh et > bs Ww) oo < "io £ +e TS «ha ay CO oy m O ato gh a caf Ba et fo Gb Ot EY G) 00 Oy Cy a 6S "-P iy PY | fo Cy mM 4 ey Ue Le, my 0 Ub tp ap £y Pe << CI A wy ep Bt ny ae SRG I sp <r LO WG sp 2 > ep Se as pean) = acnan 2x4 * BVA AY % léhea, 7 MY ES wt e one £;
af 48 ae rf «ef % oy red is bt Ad oh s, ~ bed a a
8) oA G toy fre me.
St oO sod 33 sed '4 oS i cS ao int Sy wee:
ars 2 sae Ps .
te, wt ON ae;
oe) bos, ho} ed iis Bs Ok ret SEEN EY PROT y re per 2 ak 3 YK ies ¥ .s as SEC, Satyam 1g as Faye tf PO RUC EY 'A XY a LE Os bt rf poe ad G iss "
Ee Clove CR ee ve o3 fy uh wi oped G vs my Chowk on us ost rs Move + owe ed oA ( co in 6 ay PSG %S ns *~ x . 44 fis) $a. 3 fe IG s med. tg Gas G3 as seo besthes Mme sed ry 23 Mm Li Lb & hy iss Ad weed Wor is ih ir) £3 OS ORS psd Wal Cy md "gr ond Se Pp O. ti is UTR tia a3 hy 4 % 45 % "set chy hep pb ar} ort C3 cG 6S BeOS seh 6G Oy a pes mo Om co. Fh ted GG Aa tpg oO 6 a. wR "4 aM Se eS tel es i. rr ae a) bs fh ue a eS By o ER H&S at ON sy ee fe Op-ed mos OY eet 4 Gort Dy Og wohl Ho vad * Of ES eS a ford 2. $4 OD ned D wom ose 2B sat a Bene 1B wed oe Ud wh SE Mh Ob ke y eb ES ee AN bb 18 ¢ ~ 00 oT OS ~ om oe net RG ed ZS cm od weored om wo Gy Goark 5 @- ai Sey nw wD bs ~ peo th 3 Gy AD he 1G 140 eG me by La 8 Gove c bho DG 6G me m4 oe a) " OA 6h ey 0G Seth Soo MM mor os OS 4 Geet fo A yo - MOO @ ty Oo @ o g Ur Dod G3 & raped gQ Lord mk Py ow Oe cosas mea Gyn tye + Mord Pw Al ay » ios 0) Rr (honed iy ca cd moa 1 TB cy WY eee fos LO Re fe Chote wp Oy GQ et erd C Qe 4) Cy wb hy wot or wat ved ch og ms mw a Crom. 4g ha a 18 Wo Dy 2 AD wooy Wy 6S th SS in ay bys 3 EP ey SY TS cid mn go usw % wh Wor ot oi fe me KS iors Ch pores mf ie Ooo fo « roy a Poy ne Ge wy fh Cy ah ba eh Og ot wd OD ef (2 -e Th Peas og eg Rg +4 AE G nl EG moa gy bay bt 4 fg % bt i? erg Gh GH ow he 2g fo we xe ne ch SS ea GS) & we oom BM oy & eo Y nm hed * mM on bd Mee oe Ae ES C52 oe Bo pass ot UY oh i ey 1 EB rd OE OD we ee hd eho bd ba Dy SS Wh Rhee 2h IM OD ede BG Cyd et fg Os Eh eed oS eee ha A ho ag CoG Kt Cy 1h et me Seog mo hae aS ka TE att re td WB Bord wha OG Gy Ro Qo SEP iG. fe Oe EG Or OG 0 5 OG) vt 2 165 OF PG Be geod EG OL 4a fe ef ME CS sre OF vd Cho -et os ag Boe ned a Ghote ie Rao wad Rye ved 1G ba we a et Os ed Eye G CP eae + bb AP Dow we EO i Wo Th ha a Of &4 eB og 423 «Does eh OF at % 6S ried Do a Cy PQ Re fu Oo. i th od > 5) Go on cy £8 wo bd v FS = RY BQ TR oe sae TS reek £4 se an Ly eho CY 2S bE sed red Ty Cig EP ow ved redo Coe o nef Co tp oO wd ped ES cot Es Mo Dy CAD mt Weed AE dow Me mH od ed Mh Z. tea hs gh Oy. tp ed REG Gh Gy et ES 4a Ty te Wow bo eH Gm 4b G8 AR (GAS ES m © boos (hope ad moe * co 42 %S + fi ed vef 33, Tio {3 Oh ed WM th ot oo + wy GO 4-8 Sayed ee 2 # ed mock» (xs w oof 'het hood * OG w SE a co get Moos iy ee Am ON Oy a a eo ed ) bE Py mt Ae MO 42 ty =R mts @ & web EF Gs my Le. & TAD OE » mG % fet Dy hs nm Be i) Bo ty <4 mM My Mw gs fo ie U3 x C3 bt Ey By mo bt Beh ED ~ 3th bs ha Bos fed tt « 4 C3 ad £4 wb ba * 2 Ho vow Sed 1 Sy » moo ty es * oO 2 r EY OG - & £3 TE O66 3G Ghd ort 46 co £5 3 oy iy 2 a Oe re Ye at io ed 6 LG ot Uy bt wy eA hs ny EY foe wee 2 XL Fat ed LE OB Rte Wo oy fy 88 Wy bE OER SMa f A f \ be Ye S tA xT aN GS % aS WS a. RS ary f oe aot tae yt ye f Aa a ras) + Ad a3 ¢ x 3 y OOEk ? At ¥ wy a, rd ee i ord Ct weed Awa EUS ue, ieee ws oe 44 oo Oo bd Qa pheb thao RS CBC, = + o EE * ef fe ye '.2 3
wh zt we a ¥8 x ye Let NG cD cA co my yt bf "es wh © Pook:
"4 « AS 43 ip & ne C3 wD ' b> ms oh we % ad 3 6 ™ {3 we {3 © EY & me G & ~ <i "4 Phy vet wy yn mp 9 Ly th 3 ys hg {2 or G & Ry tp. th M4 3 Sow em db rs S ord ot mo 6 A a seh id ay" gy "4 C a6 we 4 verde sew Ge & ek. 13 tT ~ * As us ha o4 ved née TR ed eo oy LG Myofes 63s ne at bog e Che a ME sed ed mae pte Om 43 na be SR TS ved Chom od ames ry Ob Uk ord 4d 09 ch om SS Bo ia Pe 43 cd HO ws eo Tey CF a le tp se OY ym oS es 4 "a Bort ig Gtr % se ened " ty ey, Boos oO Oo wm A 2 mk ip wm OY % ~ rf in Of We 0h me tr + oc fred oad bd i ee Sh Uy wae co Ms te Pe ks s4 * e Ad cs eee 8 " ki ood AB ns 3. 3 bt ot GS ard ced et % GB oats ae net tie oy La a «ge ip Boo 3 ome Tm we oT ow SS {6 OO ors TA eat 8 gy De wd a Py be ced Wo Pas vert A 3 ra 4 By wm £3 1 OE reg. 2B £4 ret oe oO pec os et wy 6 ( @ B oy 6, Be E+ Pe my SPCR a wy ' sa Ah et OF oY pened et " "ge by wrt 23 KE af Cl eM OG i ka ord C5 $4 wooed ord 18 3 bes 3 ye OG i RM ih oO ve BG it on AB Ror OO iy GQ 4p in SO wm ay G3 6. ered ES so th £85 ceed Send wp ey oes Cr OS i PE ne Ae, Coon a on oh 1 C4 La mH aD is a et Teg ored woe Aehiet QoS Sok 08 ' aa mw = FS Mg moo. & Cf Mg a BY Gs. GG FY v4 cas a Rhode £8 oh BSE ID ta By Saks FEU ES Py S My as Cooke 43 4 he EE ag rh "OE ES Wy bee ee) Bo ee i a Qa oe « ye A ee ad CRs AG he kD Cet et te defo Le ah ss Bh rb peed vg Bok ab hoses ea Gy Bs ao 6h GES x Fe OT ro ma iG + ef UD Gs an 3 Boop bos th nt oD Sw & oct BS ard in bed we qa 8s foo ws it Go Gheerd oO fey ms. * et ELS ra bed iy ord Opa Gwe ED o a 48 TS Gy Se eee " aS s aL it 2 wo wt C3 O ts Ot er td eed TF fy Mey Os Be wh Pipe 0h Bee Po 8 fed. ys os mG 8) Ch, ed 44) UF red me AD we sed m 13 re ' a) 45 3 mS Ch. c3 fe (2 rd ved ord ko 4c a $4 $3 4 get Uy Ton Ab iy et O64 th AS he UW ho mt. et TS UP Berd Ci & rf a wm. 3 BS te AS fi 1 oS 42 » tAtG Gry mt a dh fe ow 3 i Ly GaN a oe, 2 cS up & mo IN Sy Es a cys bey Se Q) teed wo 2 ro) oO fh ow. Ct cod "Ch EY ED wd OB Ge Ged ae dn Ct ER at ea ty fp 7 EX Tee mw wed EG eed OE Gy Sh ord oo O eed $l awd ow * vec mo it bb LD Oh, % 6 Sy Gor
4 @ CO. rd ES Ips , bE Fy ery TS hy re be ep a oat ex fi rd a fo TE me ad md oe ord AD ig ach set ch GO. w > fet word oe tS OM + kt i ost 2 oon © UM + be 1 eH ' pod ng . «~ ta os > fh he «i? 4 qe > O&O a o> mp ~ @ om Cy OY @ 3 wy Oe SE EG 'DO rey oad to th. ag eg Se De Bh wag > Oo mo he Bo oO 03 04 (G RE ny CO Be gg 2 oo ED oy 3 co 5 ve 14 CO RO 2 wt. ma ry Rvs ~ Oe oy ogc SG ts o> é * KS et veh OD i need Ps, Co. Ot CO sob es ita) "ad Th ag Boe me rh eh (2-0 Gag 3 ny fhe Dy in word 'tH a aoa cod os a vs i t BS Ub el CP 43 0G (yee OF ee EROS "
ya ted za $$ By 18 Gm Go res a a BES et "th cm i 8 eh orm Fp i" ican ra) ere O sat me 8 a wc "yd poe ow a So UR wees CROP red Be ES GO ord a th Oo ne) Se he oe bE SS 1% te Ho Ss ad ss ane Ce BAG COTS (ee HOT ep Mm OCD Sa a Ch vet mo CS 96th oth mo IG Dos M393 o sped os we ES * an eo) ed YD ova be goog TA , s "GAS "rd ee G ne Apes on G i ~ O seh at we SS fea A eed 3. eg . Oko os Oo fe ey me wow (wp seer es La oG AT tae 8 sit 0 a s4ofG ams ct fist mo teh ha mts % eyed bp bo hoon (how te feb Wat O iv oom uw hy ray ent & td fol ay OD Evted red a ae Pet OY Grow & a Ors Ae 2nd Op TE fey no canes: a i OD ex ard eg ote Cena os vay mx Go cf oo rz OF do rh oo = of "Be red ya gos ths te EO Ly EN cared geod "ft ga 2 IS f. > 3 w ord a RPS ii} ay eS at eam fon £3 UF ees os Go ba a aos Ta Bag G me a it D4 hy eo sag ey es #6 at « iB BOTS seh BD "ot ak mS * ed mk a ~~ e Wo 7G ee Oy owe 3 SAE ae Tey IG CO oo pod Bh od ex Wot % a aa rE dA Gee Cee Bed oe ed a "4 Boe oo 8 bd GOB > Uy OF ME bag Econ he vot Ba cet G ED m4 MS BG ey C3 © «eed ein as eh 8 % g j 9 ir os oe ¢ rd Oy Ooo rs % 4G ormen Bt ml By Goa £3 as - uy os of GS a o> at ; Wy uy ees it. seed sed fig id Sa BD ox Chet om ard op * tH -O wa CO fos EQ ed CP eh bt io) PEP LD he (Perr £3 be oR (h- % Ro boy ma it Th) oe ons 4 "Th eh ad fed Eas ad Fe Aa 3 Che eed bet! bt mh fa be Go En * i m m oO fos 4 TE, CO 6G 7 .. 6 et Ls on > wm red IDs ee ef ON Ma 4g red ae 5 GG Dy IPM FS Ee Os er Cy de B eC WG OA Gk Wy By ba ay 3 £43 G ey O02 2 tag ¥ x oad ik vot of mE gz
53) a pa cet . wet % Cy Dha 03 Bir Ed ot 3 eho eh Ba OO a we OS mh % eed a fh & too bag 4h Ae nde Oat, 6 Oe C0 £3 03 Sf OF StS Be ' in Ce os sO ES UES oS eed OE te fet os 8 Ch 24 OF OF dose SPE Ga a We tH T4 SR Qs 3 Ea BE EE Ms EEG) ody Ca Rete?
tp = mr O35 CN SE ee nm ty U2 OV aE Or Gy by oy ON GRO DT OO EE Od te OS eo GO.
4. PI ww > 4 w ' Q ss oa x o west vod ord _% .. Applicants e Ne $ entral Bhawan, & a t L .. Respondents & ke wh * se ES " c Ao ba EN ad oo t (3 ord O in Oo gc wo by ed th PP orf a es PE ork ord TT ard wy oad wa iy fo G "3 £3 AF A a rect £3 ved tee mond a 6G z a om re --
mi & oy eed RE vet G red G be Doe 3 "rf £5 4 2 "el oy "et fg 6 Mw bd iis) i 9 {3 k i a x 1 MG ay uy ced ef eed -ef a hey om, (8 O Lem f+ Ss % 3 D> a ed @ 2 reed yt ss ord ON "se4 , aa) Oy 13. 23 J i £4 on cy LP} i ras «ff $3 By 4 wy - a "4 ~ ™ iy oh no em a Pa God bed se oS a ok CER bs i rd ip tg me m) Mos {f3 oe Yk bd £30 rt t2 t & CS ed 4 sed ' Ds 2 o¢ Zw © Brt Mg BO we aed i kG $4 a a & oe on 4 Be OR koe ed KG os ay 5 by 1G wx Od 1h iy ty toy Be, Feed. 485 mm Gm 5G a ney wm cn aw Da 6 2g 5 > 0 ea tS a Tho - ho feat rae] eed SS (<5 ce x 2 hi ce Shri gh 6 3 a xed a nd (By Advocate Shri Vicky Nagrani) L L the 7 ES ned OU xD XG nt ha Tos bed 18 GS fe ty hy 88 hod 5 u a 6S s goo ee bet Sd i rood ke oy oe hy 48 @ . ted gee on wot yd re Ot ee eg to, Boos Ut ter a ae Zor 4 Mod dS 14 a be 003 Qo: ft Oe @ i 3. aS wy xd Odd oH LS "sed "a ah oe 7 Ch LG ay Og TS fh oe. et i We 4 14 a mS . Pog wh @ ch ot Oh et vied wel Bh Dei ot ae, Da 4s ears > (3 ES "ref LY Bh "4 > es C8 Ce oe 6 re it ct op ey wa "4 1 wy ods mo & id a8 i oo & RE OIK TD ced fd 3 rh 4S Py nd LG 1 a eed Dy et Gord C1 & & oS 3 "ed a +4 my CD fhe ra og set ae » 5G > « a + ont fy 8h et CD Oh ot es Cd Be oF =p U3 Lo BG Oo £3 i 2% weet os fed a i iG ed hes et , i Ch ry ue t, 'oe " at ' es ha 3 'tet x o " ra , ' ba i ah <s 43 ws Fat Le wa me a .
' Y ted + a} f uw go ° Be 4 cc rts BL ® me : t oc wh wn , e a 4 = " cs a pee 3 ye c a ge 4 os ty oi eS 3 oe in 43 # a Me Dy y ss . a Sw G6 Do rd ed ag Ss Ho a :
4G Aw S 8 2, 2 a ec 3 & 7 ru az O 'ss ar eA ad 5 oy a & aot a w a '4 % nett he aos mf pas ae e Ee rat Q vod vs in ti ta . ME ¢ ro mt as 6 gO os, A 5 3 : a:
+ a res Oy ts ipa 4 ee fs Fh sf 2; a ewe a wee ook sy pas 3 w GS tae 34 ps r a (it Peet os a © wy me MM ns ¢ fof st a eo be e -- 8 "A Op we 74 LS ves . ars fad hea rr Ho Ba i Me 4 tesy > Mo "4 "4 AS & '8 & : ym Ag ° a 3 ae roa B & Met if on , As e " rd él x ns ts Set thf a3 * SS rf ai ay cj nf A ing Z ' rit a ke to ~ 3 . 4 % a grog ay ry et bs ct a se ty we eo a, ame, Seed Aped ef 4 ae ped we A ey 5 WA wy * ab et PrP ed x Cu "
ae ns fos ye. tub 7% <3 AS C3 oa be ' be "a a " ay t - " ce i we 8 Bj co js i eo Oo 8 a] = m4 my cs 3 3 ca ~ " 34 r , a 4 > 4 -
2) fs @ fs BH te a Boe a e a as . 3 3 vo fed a QO « a 5 "> @ oy Ss tea ae Oi "B Lo wos ty + re o bs 42 o mn 4a Pe 4 det tat fon eo 'be 4 st * ws a a oO a , ay wt iy a oe pet. ma, ee (7 e t ob rot ie 17 4 "f me a La Ct ve oa oh. "et te red ord s 3 m% , 2 it & B ; de uy te G i '4 Ae Av s > oH © a0 me Fm a ae os " ' om : " a te 4 Ch, ar +4 m a bod 2 ce we tH 43 at 4 pie ss. * ue ' f: " :
G * * is by, e a ot 5 : - ee sok ish oe . ae te 6 ay he Cy ws he fy be rd ood he ns i 42 as ' A ae "4 Mee : 3 1 3 y A Be ' @ in poh * "4 % rs we 3 $4 7 uf ea a oy +5 thd 3 be ved ay ro * ed oo ie ° & a 4 ag ff 7 a G 5 oS 8 my g G63 j cece] ' ij ; o hee ° it a ;
4A . 4 a ty hy od © § i we ws By oh Os hoe a ho % Sh > bo 2, td wel 3 fe 3) gi ca) oy fa C $ ed bt "et ay n uh ra] Ch hs FS weed es Ads e o as 2 th gn LP a a Be eB ha ah a Ad ~ os KS ee uM oe w be Sat * zr ' $3 rs oy & : $4 ro i 1 i ra :
33 ct a By a4 2 ce ne ee a ' 4 cot me e ng a3 cs ay rea $4 "es ad : 6 $3 © 'bed oot & oy 4d rr o " '3 * : a | Oo} 43 Q , 6 8 a 9 j a ¥ 'ead! sod a od " Ro es oa es a wd rs Pa hi & ui ' 3 > 6h, x fe 2 Ck % e tig os Fy "
hee ty oS 3 RRR us G hOTh m9 Bed shee ae vd a mG ao be nS wf g wee a as ssed ' LEMS e Pye a
-
Ne $3 ® 3 a Ho } ax as Member oo x ija (R.V (Ravinder Keur) Member (7} a