Karnataka High Court
Jabbar Jameel M A, Anr vs The State Of Kar Thr Mahila Ps, Gulbarga, ... on 12 March, 2009
Author: K.Ramanna
Bench: K.Ramanna
EN '§<'E§§i H§{§'%*£ {ESE} E93"? {EF §i:'§E%fE':§f%"f'f§%{;'i §~3{f;%,§E'T Efiffi-?s§{fi§*§ ft'? €§E§L§}§g%§?€3:'% :_>;a.~'§;:%:§T3 "'?:--£§;'i§ '?§:§:: 3:292 my {:2}: :5«¢:A§2<:.§§§ -. EEFGRE A u 2 C ME: m3:xé*:?sL§: zx«:§'~m:A;.:%z*:<:.§': ;e:_"u'_Ee;§§§:§:g.':x::e2% V {,f§2§;.E"?§'€{}.8E">E§«} <;:~é'2' :}i<}§<i;=-- .. "
8 §:T§"%J' FE :
V' " 1- T ($2 :3;%:.':'§':':<.3§~z.:§:Rs;e * . .{'§g: s:~a;':'%;-§;in%:;> Z§%.E~';§§% 3;-§E_E$f§E':£E'é, f?%<§§-VVE H = T"§m<: ;%;§:£;:'§§ GE?' E§z%§%?€A'E'z%§{A, :s£?a.ga§:%£i;1§: L}i5§§G:'%,'i}'§{;EJ; -
5::;g<;: :.,A:>ms; :3A':*:e:.;,,:-- _ : V mg: 38 Yiizkfifi, _ ' .
<:;<:<':.: <:§*=.;::_, %:I\éGié;'*»é'Es:}§:§<i, _ . =. R/'{1} ms;:<:;»:2;, vs;;~:a:j::>N1:3 ';.:>;.»i;sg:%;z4::-.._ ' "
$if)E§;'%i?fi§?sE»£ f ' :93»-as: I*i§:1§f§A['?*4:*§E%§§< , W,' {.13 ":2-:{>';~§':: jimzgié ssmi§<;:H_, ; ' Egiigii; 34-*::i}«':i;raK$, ' <;>§:::;: HQ E{fS£?i---E--§x£;>'LEL}, ;:gz:3 ;<;;;x,.3a c'::;L<;,m:
"§.'§"§EA€{}E§{§E-'E E's"EP;E[§ EEA E30 E.,zi€73€%§ S' E1-"--'sfi'E(}?'<§, {EU L82'-"£E%§'%.{'&.
{ml SE3', §*v'Eé§}*%i%;}E%£%ff:~ Eiéé W} {E §'e§.£'%.,&é3aE%Ej§§'§E33 ;§AE%fii§iE§,,
4. '.9 .~;
Ev.) _§;2:,;<> E-§'.E\§{i},:"§--§{}%/E-f18%, <>§~>¥s. fmv ;>:;~:-mags f:§€EH€}<:,'H;.;
K}-§AJ;% €:<>m:~.:Y, {}ULBPsR€3r.?i. §€}%;S§E3(§E?si.§;%'ii§;;?if"i'E;3 _ {B}; S§iSi.3E§AE5§~i MALL&P3j§%, H%Z':1eGP .?f_}§5€ V' SRE.§§i}I3E*i'iF~iE*1R E{iT§L-E{f%.F€}'\§E, ;'§fT)"sf, >§{';€_b}¥-3 E312} "
"i"h;i$ Cr§.§'fi*{i'{.is:3z1 is ffiazi 3.E3fI};{:§§:3._¥';;7S§:(?£€{31"'i'.'f%g2 333; fhfi advacaie fzitai' {E13 §}€:tit:i<3;1£:r" A§L3}:*z33;§,';1gT $33}; V {EELS §"ié;':"::'Ee Ctsuri: 1313:}; be pieaged 'ii; ._{§'ua3h iimt: 'g1:"(}{:ec=fl._"§rI.g$ "ir1.i'iiab3:'i against, §:2€f;i'ii<m€z* ii: {:.{::'§€3§;L%'dr./2{§{}. 8 E'1«e;§3.;":18}fi'?} zasf Mahiia REE. Gzlibarga. wh.§.(:h__ is._pE1_f::'£:iI2.g "§3vS,:fGrt_7ih& "ii Aiizii, J?sJiF{T: at {}u§.b:%.1"ga.. J A _ A N This Cr.E,?€1:iti<3:.1 <.%-<::23;:%§£1gb <31} _.§§:#§:%:dVz15j,§_Ssiei; this {$133}, iht:
€7:m11*£. Iitiéldé 1.1%: foii:3é:,v'i15;g:;:" " V " 'V ' éZ}'§if§E§R _ E'E';iS is l'£~'5..V'"}'.3€§i;§:.";'.}'..c,9_V}1T,§'.§§§Ed 11:16.83' S£~:{'f§é%i2 <3? {3::P'.{,1 is igjaaskz {flit é;%;:3€,i;::: }'§:7<>C'@é3€i%21gS .i13;i€ia{&tt;§ against 'i}.§.{i §}€i?§1§§.€}}:1§f3' N<}.8.4-"f--£}'8{__§:z;«.C?3'°i;3;z$ §*~$o,.:"iE8/(3? ::=f.' gmgce 323.1191}? is §}z*ai":{§§::':;g (>11 Ehé E336: saif EE fidziig a_.;§I§E"{:, .~ }?§':6: <::a3z*: azf :'::$;::0:1:fi::1':i:-:2 f€?f)£E}p§.€~};%.£1§,iE1§;. £3 iizgisi. .é;"i".%a:: fig §:.Fj:»$'[.§&g.iaE§;-* w:*:<§<%€::% ax-*i§£~: Gf §£3§;'°€i§i€3E1€"{" x::Q.1 aazhe :3 "vs."-'=:2:'}<i:':g V a iiévii £27,'-.i2.giz1&s-rzr ;1E3:;0as:E. "§'E:é: :z121I"riag:: sgzf fiiéf <:°z:::23;:_:;;2i3_%.:';3I1t '::30k gsiacfi a§::s:;L'ri. 8 %3a<;7}<'; ;:::c>::*r;';:fi£2:1g Ea') this {':E,l§~3/i":{)fl:T1S 4,...' 5"
E 6
4. GI: mg: fitilfsr Ifialld, .%€3;ms:éd é1{§1?{3{f€»1'€€3 far 2%} ':'a3$pom,§;c:m§ c:<::rn1piai::1a33t igaibzmitg Efiaat. §)€¥iii(3I1€i' :::=:;.5:~;, E §5%}1{§, I2 aw: §>{3'w€:3"fu§ aztxd izxiiuazxtiaé p<::'$<::15. '{"he:i:*-f§,:af::*;f;'§;$ mmr;i2':g sdrwzcéis 2:1r::ai. for 5:18 aaké: <3§'::10wrjgg __'g3:::*f;3E'§',i aV:1a%i'>:~: -2:3:";i?i; 2 *ss:€:1'& Eizarasaizlg zmii i3}--'ji_>:'£:::5?%i§1g§:':fi':&§§§€:%i.¢'.t§fi4f£'3.f;':~=*;2 'L-V_z.1::::§L §uhs:s:z:;:::{::::}{3.}; p€*£it§z:3:1m' 110,}. 1ifi2i1'1"i{f{i'~§Iié'Z}'}€if "'.,':,"i)11'§,3.V'$:'":";'ii,V:A'{ is ' a.:'g2.zs::§£ ihzeaf; :::§';iir.:i:°a;:3 <}i'p€%f'£{ie;1s:" Iii; :2 ::.:};'E;*. £:,i'us,§ };i::.g,§ ?<:e:'{5 =:;:;:';js:
2-1t. élmibarga but 335: <:*.e;u11{§[ 1:<;;§'.§3:";>c§:_;::v5: i}it:.3f'gs1<:vg:i1§ 1*::e<;r:*§$ ta shszmz that: f:%aiEaz;'ér€:,::1"'--e:;f ;;;e:;.:;.;.j;:~;;:i~=-- siiuiiffibggg in {Ex sa:?§:10e:;2§ ':)£::i":1g.3;':.1;;1. §:;f3r~-%:;fl:"=§2§*;:tm':::¥;.é:» .':+11<3'f.;V:%'." in a §B&T3;"§fi10i1§.3} {raga iiizf E-\:%V1;:?f'%.::"V%l-%'V1'€:" i§}'rV'§:§"?Qf§;?:Il13E1":I'i"§; 5331;}. {£163 ::;me:éit§g zsasisé cm'i ta ;E"£1ai"°i"'§:t:{'§ V'J(}};:}5C*?£1 9:: '§}:1%§".i3i7S:if~}I1{3€Z vi" 'me Em3%3z:~3,1';.:§. 35:; 2V€:§.§ as 218:' i::~§aw:~;."".. '§'%':é:r:afor#E., 5:a'3'e:'€:§y ?;':{:{::.«1ug::= 3"<3$;7{m{Ea§:::z-i2 E5233 _m:2€:
.f:i'h.§::.i?i~§¥{;z??é3<ti §E':£~--..«:.?..5:.":{: am? €3\§€§'i{.S 311:3 ':;"%::% zazaiurvs {sf S.}- _, i.i"€*':~fii}ji{1f§}f§T'-.,§}i€33L§i{§ {mi ':0 Easizr 21:}; §§3.€i ';3£i..i§i€;;1:é1'~;Z Fm 23 11:33: a a.T-g;::'%mi§s:%:V 'Vi;<.>E;is,zV::s:=;§.'i figs :::3"é;%:{:: §:.:::>:::€:€:c{'§::1g§§ in.i£iz»3§:€:£ azgaaizasé: Ema"-. A ._f?%2:: §,F.,¢s;:*i;i:g::* st:a1i<:m{::1'é.: :3? Z"€S§}{3Z1€'}éiE}§;. z":::;:2 am'? $15 $;ia'i::n:€::t £21" ~~:::<ai;g§1i3<3::::'€I"s éiigeiéogsss iixzai fthsrc :3 2%: §;§:s:m:;g <::.r»,z;$;s mafia {3.2:*; Z5115 rfispaixéiizzi. $0 s;r:3m1e{'€ pé§i'i€ia;am'::'-«:2 aiao "$0 the '::37f§%:*:1»:"::: :»fik:g€.{§¢ Sf, ';'€3xfi}= ?(3?i'E§i)i}{i3" .1::z}.".;2 E3 in ms W'f:'ij;-" / ' ma c:'r€m::€s::te{£ £Vi'{}'.i EEK: aikgaci =:':1:°im:':} 321%: Cf} nit}; have §:>Eaa_('1z*:£'i ibr a:§,is<':§1argé: fiefbre €315 aria} {:us.:1*i, 'tE}'1€:2"s'f?:s1*e it £53 11%' :9 §iE"ii{3}{€3'. the i§13j1.f31"€I};§ ;3ove::*::*s 11:16:63' S531?/§82 »::_=.f 1:31:37"; E' *~s3{:§;:'E4<.t£:. W<>:2;i{} Es rzxercisttci 9:13; in 31:3 __m_:*::_$'i: i:if.':v;°a_1**'a'fl:~::a:fi;::=§§' '§['h€r::£7€s':*::5 £1: £3 }"}I"é3fy'€C}. 11:29:11 Efizfiz ;3é'=';;E2§is:;;':"1T§:;I[«V:»*; <:i"isré1i:f;és;'t{i,..V'LL"-.F 7 3}. "Baa lsarnsé E-£€:{3+P '§3j§'fi'.§1§I1i'{§§ €.f%1_3€. i<:;i:"3;::z:V":::E§.§€a3*g é-: 5;E1€:£%'i. has hs:€::1 fiiszti agzaizisgé... 'ti><}ii1;1::§:--'::: §3f:'ii::ig:3z1s1*S; ':»:E3.€..vV£s at £é};>¢::§"%;}; :9 sea}: ff}? cii&cE1arg€:"'h6f§2:x:_ Vifiai _ E--£€:1<:*.<: prajigs fer fiistniagai {$59 iifliiiimxg, H V' '
6. 'A E"-§2';{:-:::1*:;i.&_' figs: .arg1;.m€n'i;s of C::3:..::.z1s::%1 {hr fihfi §3.:>3rt:?E{:~3, Ts1::>%.=v',-- Ev ' '§5fi,1">'r§Qx';Tif_?V:€'§'§I»§" ,.-$0 we wE::':the:'* ".:§§1€:z"£*. is 2:1}?
;t'€s;<:°:3:abi,a:1<:'€* sf", r::.:a.tss--:*ia1s is cixzfiisgzzzii ma cralméziai §:_z'{;¥'i:€:¢§i:;';gs §1ii'€i.:a.«::.%.f:;%§I%, agains': £116 E;3€ti-{.§.UI1€E¢S? §*E£.:-<;i:;:,.z%;;t mg >t;}1:"3€:.r~::j3,$ '"';;.:_0.;2 £3 Iihfi' wiiie sf '='::é€;§§;i<m:'é:* 520,1. "'§'1'.:e':§1* '-2a51;2i1'1"ia;g';:':t'V_"se*;*3:s:;up6:*i?:::;3:m£::i 2::b{;:':;§' 8 },»'€Eflf§§ back £3 E3 333:; 1153!: in {i:1:§;_3:['1"§§=3: €E;;$€, (}'{Zi'E. s::xf {E16 Said 'W{i{§§0=;?Ei :3 <:Ei:3L§{§:'23::i1 w=*=::*r: 'éxmi "V ..€~3f:€i §€'é:3§_3£)i1::§€:";i.~2 is 2: isagéiifitz" E)}:* §}§:}f:*.ss.%,<3:: xi-'='T§':%::'€za$ E381"
' V§,'E*1;i:E;i:'i}&I}(.§ ;3€iif:'ie:33::$:° 319,1 '%32;*i:.:&.g 3 civi}; €i?:i3.g§3fE€if:'.§" 15 w':>1"ki;§:1g ix:
__;<;E3»:"z';a<i £3 ;.:«:3'i in d.i:;;.;utz:z Sf <::<m:*:§§g 3. sass sgrzmm to he mgistemd an 33:16 133318 sf a typxefi mmpiaifli, h.s:>#1*?éf§*é§fL' is net} sprzczifisz: avert actg affézifiuteé against §;§:;~ii;';:;a',:%§'~ i a:2; paiafi of pagefi sf' thf.' cempiainé; ;i§Ls§t:;3s:s s<¥:$ ? cxf {aha ccmyiaifiafit figs %I'a7~.{:6'.; i5f§Ta:1=,§&=--: éitv ti1<:; irzstaneg 23f his aw}: sisfz;aV1""§-2%? ..¢18m é dge Laifiy Paifii 1.0 has {fig shag: agtrfi has rexcsaréed the 3t;;{t駀fii--. what: haw staizaci abaui: this iilv §:i%<é'a¥;§1&1;:iV'i§:ga_{§:e mgggama '7, 1: féei getiiianarai, fampztd 'aha baii candifiens ef the ksiaii and staxtaéi fizz}: petitimger B62 Wha is "the Wsman vz%hi>;s € Vhimbfiafid. is régiéiag 1'3 ahmati W33 sager is * _ ha? §;::g$§3ai:§,§§."""2¥:i:1sxz1:'£ 'C' éisciigsgg that 331:: frseziuaxztly V "{§»13.}b3rga '£3 ab-maé Via. Eijgésrahad. Thaw ifi .' #3:: recsrfi by'rss}g.:Q:1é631{~=2 ta shew that chfidren af " geiifia-gar 3:6 stizaéggzizig ia the schmi mm by her fathar " ~ §::"'4~.§uiba*1fga.= if .i:%m fatjlszér :31' petifiemzr Q92 refusaé is any flozzumenia, them is was bar ta shtain the fiaié éacamenzs fmm the Edlzfiafififl 3333:. that patiiiezmr 39.2 is §§er:£:a;11ez1fi,§* settied hem in Gulbarga 3:16 125:" chfidran are
32):"
um »I"'"'\ M...» £3, 'é'?:e:::"cf%>:'t, v;k':.£:': §E'1:=:1'é*. is 11;) S§.}e:{?i§E£: :,».§ga::fm§:§*;.'E's E1':
€325: s;%{}m.;)1:.?1i;:;'i 3:3 ;:'s1°:':s:z*:a»i%ia::i€ E3.::}§{;§ E333 '§i}{'i§£'}f.{*i').'€";f;'%1"'*';'%"L"..§§;'i.'§;§':i_;f'_ V' ziaziy {}§fEf'E'1{'{i5 the qz,2.<::$?;§:>::3; :3? :n&ki§:g E1532'.:i:;»"'.§?:2:§Qbti*:§:«:£ i::3.__:,Eia:. ;3:E'ss€:}€:é7 0?' '£315: «:;)%:Ei:e:::* a:::<i:'%i23£3:"E i._;~%., ;t'i€:f::':«-3;:a:A:'?'E- is E3.-,§:::';§5 ?EfX€i1"<.'iS€. "§"i1i'::':i?§<::1*::, E 523:: 0%"-:_?:r:: fL§'§'}i§1'§Z§§'E %:.4E::;ait' 1'";g§:':;é$€ {SE37 ram: {",'.8.§§{?:§-3 ti} §z.1v<;k:: fizz": }"_?§"§"e='?}'-§"~;§;*;._(f3»1'3.'E§V of §~3§;:::48'2 ti; @2333": %'.%1:;< £:m;ir€: _3;:"<:><:%€:a%:f%i::;g§s i3,Zi.§",3:é'i§Vi'.{§. -'_21§g2;%..*3.i;1V_'§*5;'{.._;:=¢§§i.i=::a§3.§r;" :';:::';.3, {)5 ::><:'11r::;:-':
{'3':::':§':':=: 1'v'€ii'fif'. :anat,€:i"ial.:'~3 <;§;§V1 i'"£::?f-{>"rd {Q }'}f'C)§f;i'--§.'§§.3L{3 p{:'3fiii€>§1r:31"°-- .1 wézsia is sajzi £9 Ezzggiifi :.<:1?3'£;£é;>:*;{:<3§ i;7:;"é- :'1:;;:::*:%iag:a..V- ii}, "5??ia&_:"€%i§:)1'?;':.,'V "é:«33é-3 __}'3::=."cii;i.e:}':n. is :§iE<3xa?::<.i in §:r:e::r"E. 'F215': g31"9<ré:é:..:'§i:3--g:s '%;né§;ié1i::%{i--.__ 1';2::gzz.:;i3;:3i 1,2?-'"3 ;;:'*':§%im':§:§ 31:: {7;:*.%i:::': E'éQ,j2{}i§? V<3f'_ §}<>§i::t:t st;.~1€.§0§1, {}'L:§%.§a;'ga; Ejéflfiiiiiig fié§n3 fiKt§?é§dém$k%X: fiufixfiga fi;{lC£%184f2Qfi8 3 _§"i€?§"f:§T§:§,.-'V.{,§iE'E5iS:5i:f3(;%,. '?h€ §L}é'ii§ %;>0;':{§4 suzd. €%i£i'€3"¥,}" héfirsgiié if {sail}; _ €:%;z3s:::i%::f?£§..,:';;23g.:§;:%%,iti€3§3.:::'~2 sizeiii :s€'a:'2.€§ <?:ezI3;»:?<ii}(i£§. ,»_;§'.i"§,'<i? féfiiifigl}. ffififii. E3}-" p€§;é"%{)m:2.' TEEQEE ifs: §::--:§'$f:':;fg; éiigzzsiizézééiii.
Sd/~ JUDGE b 1*: '1