Karnataka High Court
V N Ramachandra vs The Chiarman K P T C L on 16 April, 2009
Author: S.Abdul Nazeer
Bench: S.Abdul Nazeer
mmvm wwusw war mMWI'M6WM¥?\J% mun fgwgxma M?' Km.%€N£§"B'?flKfi HEWW mmam" fl? Kfiflwfifflfifi Q?' mmmmm Hffifi Cfiififii' U? KflKNfi°V'fl.KA HiGH C
... mM. .... Mam». -..;M.m...
I! Tfifi HIQE fifififlii' Q?
3. V R Rfififififififififlfi 4' V"
313 LATE fi0§fi&§hE§E§%E?§
aagb gags? §3*$§ag§_ '
R$E.$Rg&S$§$E.$Tq* j_-_ _s;, '
REA? 121?; 2&§f&=gR$3§;»1$§fi waxy
59 gasag, 3?*§gga;§2§§ aggga
BMm%m$%& **'»= 'W
2 § E §§3fi&E§§fi§~$§§K
fiarga EBZS $33 25" gay Q?.fi§REL; 2§$§«Wfv
$3 §fi':€'E-'.3
?HE Hm$?2LE HfiwJ$§TEfiE 3.AB§fié %az§gfi'
wax? ?E?ITEQ§ §a,:@?a§ 3§*2§§5
a v»z.§.tx<3m.3.$5$«&-6:>6!'m-::§§ {8'~~&'<,'s .
§€G'%$TE E§§E$fi§§Y§%Z§
535$ EB§§? 53?EEfiR$
.fiTE.B§§I§$&§?
.A Jfijgz &Z§, Eifiz QRQSS, J§YAREfi%
«t*:%ra.«;a*+.:j,::2<&.%z:<., gmsrgazamwaz
.'[E"H7$3h$m§Asfi3KARA9§A
*__g;Q.xA§g EfiER¥§§Y%E§A
"REEE'fiES¥T $3 EE%R$
RT§;JR.fi$SIST§§?
fl~ .u§ :33? £3: 3%: fizagyg 221 RRRLE£E3A§
""313? §Tfi{'§E§, '§?}.'.I'€GE%%§E§§.G§;E'{
'""$H:§aQA §??E$é
K 3'§§' §$
3.3%? §$§£fiPE§
QSEE Afifiiff $8 YEEES
RTE? SE, A§§SE§"E'fi.E%'T
.. w...w.W unwwnrmva ummwm mm aw-wmawmawuw»-a. mu.-an wwwm; Ml!" mmmiwmammm Wfimfl QWMJWKE W?" (U;
V.' Wm
£23':
--.«2
#2"
§ T§I%ES§&EF&«KR§§R, §E§fiR&.EEE§E
ES? Qfifififi, Vfififigfifififififik
$§§Efi$%.37?2§é
2 a %fiLL§§§RCHRR
35$ nary g 5 Efifififififlfififl
asaa £333? 55 YEARS
REE SR &SSIS?R§T
2&3 Sifififi, Egg azsag, 2&3 agagg
¢.z.§.?ga &&§fi¥?; ?EfiQ§H£NR§A§aa
Sfiififigfi S??2§é "»'>
3 E agvaxfiaa
sfa LREE C $%fiFfiTfi£%E
A553 Efififif 5% Yfifififi .V
a$§,Ju§:¢E §§$:E§g. .~u-'
REA? 4, $23 £a5s§,=$§H EA:g;£L1fi7¢a;fi§?
EYRAS§flDR%; 3E§_§Lfi§${ E§$m_§a3a§a§%&
Eޤ%LQEE~11 =
s 3 §&$ava3a$$*.f;
33% Laws s'§£5££v§$$i = ,
A333 aaagw 53 3§Afig'«}'*<'
9:3 §E.&§SI$?%$€~ ' '.'. 2
afaw 2$$?§:%i1;«:a3a}§§:§*'
xjE"§£$flfi$u&%££&£%£%£E
g_3$EBELQE*i$"'
~3T*H§$§a§;§§gE§§
'fi_§;a*A3§§;'A2§E§
,'a3§§*§3$§T 59 Yfikfifi
'=a$a £S$E3TAfiT
afar 35x2? ETE sasgsg E§TEfiE*S Egag
a uV,_a?? T6 Efifififififi wgasag
' ,_*;:§sgRg5g§§R§} fififififiiflfifiwgfi
E? Eifi $%N§&?§&§fiV§R
" gffi £HEEEB£§§§Pfi
QQEE $333? $2 Egéfifi
fiTD 33 £3§E$TéfiT
§ é?, BEE fiklfi, 3&3 fiE%§§;
§%§§ §%S?QR?
.. ...,..---».,.»»«.,; Wu
arm-"'nmomw"warr'h2\J'i "awn fgmavynt ur hflmflfilflflfi Hfifié-W azwuw 0?' KAI"ENflTfiKfi %fZ3{'3§.fiW" 0? Kfi«.i&NA'€"Ai(A §~§§C.%H flfiflfi'? 0? §(flRNATfi§('A HEGH C
1%
13.
12
2:23:51:
$3.'? QEE?' , E3333 :_':'*{;'"§*§Ifi'I":§a§§eE4727#;'7"<.5's3%.§.
E§$§QE:.E.<fI3Eé.?$ * 7' :3
K 5 R.§~.J¥.§E€$z
gm K =3 gziaaamamyméh
mm mag? 52: EEARQ
RTE: Assrsrfirw V '
REE? 8, §:m*-~& ~
~.2:§~zAzm§: mmfimwa, am §;L=:'%!3§': «
JEEYE'-.2*'I?;{§?e.fi; 5%..'-*~'1?§:%.'a'.:i."I¥E.E-E:§§ " _ "
3 R mcmfiag
53%;: 2»: mmaa
3:332} mg}? m 'i".EfiR$ - .
Ema' Efiilffiéfi; %';~:~§ _ ,
33 Bmfifi, ?.Ag3A=§:%=:.ma;§¢.t" wigs §f''',_€',~.«~3;'é_? ; .V "
2.%:r_;.z;z;£2§2.z.-'; " 2
5 95=.2s:zr§ s§1:"'
$55': 3 gmuggsfisa-3;%;: ., .
aam .:a&:.":%.?'*:,*' "mi". Efiégfifi
am: 53, ':'--_«§s':3:';;i&;:%as?:5w._» " > ' -
JAT :.:2s:éé_L 433:2;
33% zvzgzfisgg, 'V-tzrm 2'§z§§§;..#: .--
$;'~.2::a«.='~§2".;;:§;3~ '93-2 " ' '- "
.....
$5'-r::2_. *:§;§:'£>£rA;:;;:~:
' .aa§;°:§ '$32332? :31" --ffEARE 1'§»37§'.--.SjEiVV'§a§3$_E:§fE§3;§€'E' § 1%; my éam er: §{,_fi,%Z§~fi{A.'3;i*1?~1%'f,*?E§E<{ 33,3 zzmggg 322 mga _ s3«.z~x:34;am--§:E~a'3 E: us: ,_3::g&" . EIJ5.
"'f:2;-5% 1%: 3 mfim ::%.?az~.§: ;~_'3::i::s" £55: gmm 'ask? 4'34, 12*}?-i zéazzgf 5%: 93-Lzagg :31: ::;«.a»,a.§.,,. gmzcgamgy-?a IIKIIWINILI' '¢lb'«"HmI""IIM1|b.#1\ warm .w-uwwmumuv-a iuvsamix uuwna vr nmnmnknmw. flaufi MMUKI UP iémifififi g mrfissi Afifi figfifif 5% §EéRS Rffi SE AS§I§Tfi§T 33%? §; l??fi fifiifi Rfléfig 5? fiE§§R §§§ELGEE*?§ 1% %@EAi%fi@£fi§flfi 85$ LEEE E&§§fi?§£ A§E§ 539$? 63 33535 Rffi Aggxgragfi fi£&¢ 6?$, 315? 333%; 1133 E fififififix J? fififiéfig $%fi§AL§RE"?3 17 ,LIHGEGfi§§A $53 3 3EE§E§$%E& aaaa Eflfififi Bi YE%R§ V V ETD k$$E3T%fiT - ,w».= RfAT 22, éT§:§"$EES§{ 1 . ' .:?2 Bffi :3? s%A§Eg§afi§gaQREe2§,--§. '"
15 g §a§&$rfiBA"q""¥. j*V* gfa 3 §g§3:EB%fi¥£§a$",f Aafis aga§T_§1 ?3gg§ ' 22% $2 A§$:§?g§?xf,'._-,. RJAT 3?? ii?fi4%JfiEfi%§;H3RE fififififi 5? %a§%3; Bfifigééfifififi '"
1% ragyfgzamfifiafifizm """~" ---- ,5" -26 §xQ'£§Rg$§A3:\' 4.
awn 53_£§a:$§ga@'p_* gafiks 2$%§;_2E§'g_$a§§s :3§.§fifi§R;,E§§_§§$§E E%fiG%§$RE4?$= %v K §i§g§§A3§A"".
w_ $Eg'g;§,KE§3§§§?Efi '%§£§_E3GET"§2 Egaxafi °"zR$§,,§35:§Tafi? EEQENEER EELEE; T"»R;A?.§aT 33$; ELK ii, 22:; °,'g;$§$g&a :3? yggsg, "fiaxgaaafi ?5.
. '0M9"'l!W".'w'ifl"5.!l .... n-u-«nan:-'Mu"'\l\l'| mun §._u§J:za Ur fiflfiwfllflfifl HEW" mmm" W?' KAflNfl'!"&Wfi'a, %?~s駀?..%§"§ flfiifim" 0? K£4\RNflx'Y'fiKfi iwlifiéwi €I{3fiJKT OF KARNATAKA 3-EKG?-I C 23 N [,1 C V Rfifififiififl Sgfi €x¥.R§§E$§é§ flfififi R§§§T $2 33335;
Rffi, 8R.E5§ES?Rfi?;
aggf 225, §@§:§§:§, filfifififlfififififififi, '¥; flL§ fifififififikfififi, 3?fi I§T §?£$E,_ fififififiéflfifi $3;
L agag$£$a%ng $§a EUQ&LIEEGQ%fifi agga £533? 51 ffifififig
233. JR. RSSEE?§§T, m_»_» g%w&,2mswmx§$,/ H' maxaaxxa a$a3§aaaa;«f_A{ :3 HEEER§J£EETE §AE§fiL6%E :3; E 9 afiafiavzgyaafi , g ;
33% B§M}VE§%K?%RE§fi§R&Q _ _ Afififi A335? §2=§$&a$;§af-.} ayaa &33:3?g§ffl_ 3= <« __ ; agar §%LE2,gg§3§§Lfla:Ea§"$$aEE?g aagavgxagsnzgfisafiaa$g$--&. BaLg§§B§&3§§2£§"4 V 55% $3§ga§§:§&:a$&%g* gafifigaagsr §:.EE§&gg :fi".2k;§g, §§3:$?%§$;
*. REA? §§§€_:3§ fiasgsg §GUT§h%§fififi£, vaégrxafigggwg 5?
F §5_ §$§(§53 :23&;= a afixaaas"
Vfiffi §;R§fiE§fi£§$EfiR%fi _nA3g§'&3%§? as ygaagg 3.2mm, gs, R§§E£?&§?, 'zfizgr é§é; ?$a'%&:£§ 33: zayagzg ' J$y.§a§aa; Efigfiflfififi ?s, w X§§A§§E&R 55$ %§§JfiE£E £333 gags? 53 yggfig, $5} uuuwwn . Wm..." ..,... ..........W..m Hanan W-V_._m U!" mmmnm nmw czzuain" FM' KAflNA?'fiaW% Mfififiivi calm" W MWAWWK W5" fim-W" OF KfiWMf'=\f<A W5" *5 33 " $ R?Eu 3§g:§§#£?;
m:'§c 2&3 E?AGE§ K§fi§R%$§AEY LfiE§fiT, ERN@fiLfiEE ?8.
32 E E YQ£fi&R5EEE& fiffi fififififiifififififl fifififi EBQET fig YEAR§g REE, SE. fi$5E§?E§T§ 35%? 2831, 2&3 aaasa, cH:§E§§a'» fififlfiflfiy Sfififififigfifififlfifi smaazaaa 55% me; .. * §REE%KHMEEI fiffi V}L.E§&? .
fl§Efi %BG$T $2 ?EEKS§ RTE. SR. &S£Z5?&R?; V f Rf&T ?1fl, 5TK &=§TH fiRfi§S;"
EEEEED EQEARE:?E¥§£E,a3g§aEa:§;¢, f ¢a£§aRagA££r3Ca$§§$L@g$_13.,ij fifififififiifigw , sfa fiHEH§E&E"»fl 2 '»_ A§E$ EEfi¥T §2,$Eag3;»= awgg §§$I£ffifiTg- 1V'»_~,, Fif.3:.f'£' :;.:3es.§*;_3.§;;;_ .-- :§.::;::.:a.:;*a, *3' ggaagg 25§'5?a$E;_a§3&&:msfi&a; $E&E$;fiEE*l$. "
'fi.c mA$Es§¥&§V, 5£fi'fi$$E§fi%3§*a"M fi§E§,&E$§f«EE'¥§AR$g afar ::?:g%3fi?§ $3333; . _(./._:':v"g&3.:§E;i§:§%i:?§£':L§ 2a€sa:aaaE 2:3:
v i 3$T $'fi$§:;EEa $§§"£HQ@§a§§a .§'£§Efiéa§$v? $3 Ezaasg R§E§'R§$IS?§§T, ' '»§:&$ 255:? ggagyeg Layavw, "=.§v§E:EH& §§L¥&; 233 £355. "E%fiGEL$EE 33, H-M..-H *m9'm"uw'I'\l 'vii au~uuu~amu:-wuw. nuuu wvwna wr nmmwmtmnm mama LJJUKI E)?' Q; »-gw 3? §§YEE§£ §Efififi Wig E K R&E?E 33 3?
£323 £233? as Yaafifi, RE. 55* éggzsfiawf, R!&T fhaT£m??§ ?*?, *£'EL€K as? KEEN; :2? sagas, §£L¥ER,B&K L§YQ3T, J;F.fiEA¢ ??a 9HAs§,_M, fi£E$&LRE ?&u :
K r razaxfizag §§fi ?K§fiMfiEKfi A923 agaar 5% ysaagg Rffi, BAFEBAK, _ _m-._»_ agar 2&2, §TH fiRQ§$,'5f§ §:R;;.".
93% LE§g§?f §AxagLR£<§$§:%i[; *' §'$§RE$WfifiY - ;"°«' gig. aA2A2hfi&E§g_} _ { ~ mm§am%$é33m§$~ *_.;;
awa afiaagzfi §Ka::;.KPi$L=-; . xgggsgzvgagaha aa,a, :3? kg? ERE§V Ekfififihflfifi %"§$ '*"
ea TK gazvxxug Qgwfi§:*»fv.» 25$" K§£;2%g§m%£A»V A§Efi_&Efi§§V¥3_§EfRS"
'_ arg§xE€H@fixz.§av§§ E§fi$& '~._§m,:ea, 23: flfifififi; 33 Egmsgg :3? xaza .§mfixmn$a§g%@m¢ E%flB&$RE-1% éi "?'é§fiEAf$$fi§"
ggg; Tfilfififiififi . aaam 2353? as Efifififi *,fiECR£§IC sawz, ggwaz 7_R¢{ fififi, VEERAER%ERR ?§£ElE ESRB ' K§E§E%§§$%E? Exaaaaya m?§ .7*§§'1;mAaA¥Axa V"§ffi. H Llflfifiififi RG23 fifififif 52 Efifififi RTfi.; $3 EE$ERfiI$ KFT$L §§.6igE§T fififififi, 2&3 Elfififi 'i .,g........u Va av-nnzurtimsnfll ulnar: A:\:._x.{n;.g1re*.m WE" mumnmwk mam €.."OUW§' 0? Kflfl¥\iM¥"fi"%ii¥§ai'3n Wfifl CGUW" 0? KAQNATKKA HEQH COURT OF KA§NA'!'AKfit HEGH ( £3 4% 423 4% gram:
§E§°EK§§fiE TRX Efiffifii Efifl$ALQRE *?E 3 vzsgagag §z&. T Eggs Rfifl asaa §BQfi T51 EEEEQ ;Hm_ RTE SE fizagaazc { '.1 §fi.?é, ETE fifilfi; aafiazagfiéfiaxagfigjf 2Afi3ALaRE ~ asaazz *2 R canasvaxaa gfa. KEERGEEERIHR "_._--_ HESREEEC GR-I, fiSES.fi§$flTf$2"?§§R§ m3.543~E, 33$ cac5a,'3&§%;a&s3'<%A'» fi£$A?EEfi%EEfifiE$£E; sam@&;GRE:~?§ T; g E KRISQEA :
53¢. EHNEf&E?£ x__ v;_~ agxg $593? 62_iEfifi£. "' fiE€Hfi3£H&a~I:;Rgv xvV1~._VV; §a.2?, 5?H"c§&a3,§£§§L§'azefiwsaaaaa aaA§; EE§EEEfiEEhEKfiE§$$¢_Sfififififififikffifi aaxagmekg, . =.w =.'»'. fifilfifififififi V533" rs§&a3&:§a "
,°3¥g3&;E2¢Hmzc '~--~ -------- '-,gs2§ fiBfi3?_§3 Egaag %§ '=as:c2;. 2:_:§:§.':.,:«";»,=%.,¢«V'% samzfig» 22:32 gzmxs: RaJ§q:xa§g,,E§ma§:§ -- 1Q _33m@ fifiifififilfifi 'fixa Ranaiaa " =g§E3_AB$§T as Efifikfi 4_"R:m_xgaaag:$ GR ~11 _;§fi.22, 15? EEE'REfi§ «3RE §RQ5$; §E§§UR§E?Q§§§£R T f2a§aAL&gE ~ :3 G Vfiéfifififififi §E§fiE§ Effis L&?E fiBA¥ER§%fEHXfi¥&£&
-mnwluvmw ww-mum wu nmrwa\a'u:e"Inr*lnl'1» nwww Mvwna wr a\.M¥§.NMlM§&.:M HIWH MWUK? U? Q a 3;-
fififlfi £383? 61 ?EAR§ RTS Efififififlifi @R*Ef§S§T B¥kq"'"'%* I~2?C.2.:8E.:'3£); '§RE.E?'§I'E,R2'§£8 2323973? 3;..3'.§'H 3322:, 2% 2:; mm 993*: J :2: mam. gmzs, ammgpg ~55 éfi mm: zsfa rgrruraufigzag 9155:; :'~'«,E£TFET 5:: ygmg . 1 * RTE3 m=::..r+:zs:%:::*.% $3-I3';,_§i1?E€1l£.»._ NQ.i?; am: mags; s2:*r:..,;~2=;.m. E3:¥2S.:'%R.?%I~I?~..?;I.sI; §a:=:3;*-3.m§'*%~--?§. ' K ERSfi.'x?1?%..B_;§ .
334:5. zmyazm _ .% ;
asm ;%§C:s"€ji"Ei' 62 332235 12:23:; mg':-mszc ;r3;2:«2---".:*z:;:é; at-rgér-:23. ; .V "
mg. 9 8 4 ,, ':~:2,'3%:a I*%.:2_'aI}§L--.§;.$'E' "351-.::>;_':__1V<;i' :-':35: yzaaaa;';j'L'_§s_3:;;3g.%;§_:-:f;a%3§;w:;g3,»«.a EP~..}~3G3=iE2%1_v":E _ '-4 "*2 9 " V' U! 1 :31 vEi1§e;':§%:;2:;*.z:., '§§373'.f§$T&§;3%:*£?"?%»?;'~ _ ' ' - .%.$}§"§i§ fiE$'§}*§"=$JZ-";-.<' :=i.fE"£s ac::;2:e.%%z«m;;r::-:.:11.:3d'a::V 33:2. mg ,taj»:§:n;_K"~"' 3433 ; ''=;?s::§«.Es§z<s.E§%..:;:;*;:
" fl%3a;T3'e:}5§EE%§f.§~3aE€; A. Efiééfifiiisifififi, 52 RgE§E§ ! -
SE53 ;- ..1§z;;§:::§{3§§z%}a""
AQED_fiBQfiT*§i $E&E§ V _a:'m riszmmzeiit §~E'**l} ESETQL 'fl auA' Egg. 1% ~ 513:: 3%. mm gzeawggwfiayazsavgfiaaaa " v 'E.§;;::=1¥£,?:.¥5E;fi':'2;E - gs ._ f'_¥=..,AI+?£.€?+7}55..¥~*.'£.IR¥'-?zi3T'I~§§' 'mix E*$§§.§~P;fiA§T¥3{§3 %¥sEE}EE $3132: %{:'I-@«-YES am--1, E€E'E?€':L .. _j.mm A3Q§§'Z' 53 §.'Efi.RS ' z~:a,.63, 15*': 2°§AE2~§; 22% mass KflE&H§AEfi£§§E§ .* W ..w.,,.M hf! amwnrwmamwn mvra Ijilflfifla ww mmxwfiiimwa Hwrfl i..'U&m'¥ U? W@§'-f €30ii.EW' 0? mmmmm HIGH CQUR? OF KZARNATAKR WGH C 3% -33- '€§"'£'§'§'3zL E K§.Vl§%L'iL ,. £ia'~':.L§;E §.,'§-§'""a!E;§sE7'».§;.§i, §=i'§...§§{'§§*;L53 RE - 3 fifii 5 EATE *L*i-+§EIF$§s$E;§§§§S§§§;?Z:'E§.?%xl'il RTE }%iffE~3'..?{i'§EC E{'§'§f€i§; %'_':»'R=-L, _ ?:§E§3'} §>.I§*."§t"{F'£ 62 ':'E?zEi.S§ I a3'E'£I{Z§<B?s§TA¥.>.%E?z §€'f3$'T.' fififififiiflfifi wga. ._ u&; §§§:$§$§§§£' $3? 3:: B¢E.§ER§£§§fi;.&fi?. fimé"
K 1311' m
3. r,gm@mm%$& .H fi;aA$aA¥3y§gAaaa&R, A3v.;Hf._» THE ¢H:A2§A§'§,§--??c ;¥"«°73u.a ¢om3?::vw§§*$§3$aTEzgsiamfliry REEQRES Ag? :駧*~.'§v'* : = fi$flPQRA§$ $§§:§§_ "
€&3?ER3 §aE¥£fi T,'_ BfiEB&LQEE;; ~' 2 mag 3$a$E'$§;KA§§A§A§& 'fig? sf §fl:§fi:EA3'5E:EEwAa¥ ,gg"$, avzzgimav .,B;a,»gaBE$""$'¥Egm§:
R31"; §$§»§'EE3f§'E'E "{§§,séi¥§,¢;§aa2EaEa3, gmgfi 3&2 §f$.§§QQ?RL§fi ',4Lg§.A;§;, "sax gaasgzaaaa Safiéflfifififig gag? $33 32:
v,""mHr§€wR:? ¥E?K?EfifiS6flEFELE§ §§§EE fiE$E£LE :j,23$";¢a: 22? $5 ?§§ éaagswxwvwxsy' gg xxszgg PREYENQ 'ES 'f.§S"%J§E 32-. ER}? IE'? "FEE 2%?-'s.'§"%3E.E GE" « "x§§§Afis ?% A33 :?.$% BASEQ ygwgzawfgamzzy 'ygngzag EE 3% :,?.2a§§ zyaafigzvg 5? 19% IZ¥¥".{'ER..I€%i RELEEE" 5Ps?¥{.?§3»°'fI§I*=?E.Z3 IE3 fig GREER £3? WE §QRP{I}R§aTIfIl'¥1'x§ EEEEEE Q?z.,E?EE a§,11,.?;fi2'}E '#3133 R33" é.é7*§;§fi§%§-'ks NIH!" Q...' 3 E 3 § 3 K § :
E 5 3 § 5 § § 3 2 E mwvwwewnswuuucrwamr-w mnnwwwm -mr-uvwwuum urn In-A*'|I\~1ir'qur1gmp"Q magma H ma EETEB.2'v§lE€A'Z'Ef3§>€ £22? §.m?3'.§;=e:*;:': ygzzgzm EAEILY .§EI€EZQE%" ?Ef§i$E3L5..E's"'E' '32:: ragga mi. 33,3.2z3m_V_-«._'_'-V._ V193 :'«'aE*§}§-~J 32-; 5% if-'GE. sag 1*}: fl€}E~I£E§.§§S ~ §E'r:'r;:m"r5;Rs mm 32%;: -*'r::a am Eawxwzaaaag E;'§§'%E"".i.8EI'J'~v."'*-- EEEJSIGE mm z*g2z'§':z32x:§.R::' B§3€EFE."'E'§ ms *§Amj'_2?:;33:$'V. mm swag? max my 45%;; 2€3?33_${'.3a;?j':}E'E_'§4§E1¢%1"'i«."T£fE'Iri"' m*zg1~'z.Es::= :33 23% gm. mm: mm £12¥s.i%.fE'i' RES§£t;"S'E'3?.«"E gammy §§.:§§$:::::§r§a5 :»=.:*§:.,:"' A§.:Va:f£:é2-£.£"~;:I§z::§' mwzz. mm mg :a.z%.ma;»s*§ 1"§~£"1'EB.E$"li' age. ;3°':;%.'::'3§'§f'E£Ei; mwzfr. " ' mm was-s;:':~ $S'::'£*z'_m%«:s .~::2~::%§ ::§§.__ ?§.Ez.::»§mm2..2* 2+$AREI€{§~ 'Er "r.§§§.,{§U§ ;§.1E;E>§'..'§§xff; Em $033? 23532:"; 'rim §*::3:éL£s%§:2rs::;;. -- 3% W = gM_ Q Q Eaarnaa. §%fi§£§i£{f§§f EgéLVgggiies submit tkat the; §éifii_ §fi"fli%$ue M£% theafi wxit peti:i$a3:afia--§%§@颧°§y'tfig figaisiam $5 tfiia €aur§.i£1 £;§.fi¢$;E§§%~22?1fE$§§ fifiagafiefi. Sf . Qfi i£?QfiaE§Q§'EfiétQaQn firi E.§;Puttaswmih °4nfi;ét§§§% %§§ E&xnatak& Fewer Tranamisaian Sa:§$ra:i§$£§imit&é§. Thgy gzay fig: éiagaaal "~g'Qf tfiéfieiwrit §atitians in tgrms gf tha said 2 fififlifiififig
2. En the ikght sf th@ aubmigaiam Q: the iaaxflad Saunfigi fig: tha gartiafi, 1"
"mwrm mwwam Ur mmmmmaflhfl mun gwagxa WI' mmawmmwn Nflfifi fi..'W%.§fi'i' U?' Kfifi%$'%93-<'¢Ei'fiW€% PWGH CUUKI U? Kfl¥'1£NA'§'fi.Kfl HKFH CUUK3' CW' fifififlkiflfifl HEGW (J n-n13--u rssganéant is fiixactafi ta txéat the writ "
getitiana as ra§x9$§mtati$fi$ $3 §h§ Ff "
§&tifiififi%$3 and éifigasg mi tag aama i3Hfi§$m£$ wf tha affixeaaifi §$ciai%n.§f thi§ §§§::Wxi:fi§n, "
a peziaé mi thzas mfififihfi tim$_fzamufihfi d§$£ fif° racaifit af a £a§y'af thia &r§§r;V fixit gatiticna v:*§:ef? té§$§%$eé $2 aaaarfiingiy; §c casts: !LE V.ifV;L _Q . M .. @ 1wL;' 3 fi§fl/.
KEY?