Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

M/S.Mahaveer Trading Company vs The Karnataka Food & Civil Supplies ... on 8 April, 2010

Author: S.Abdul Nazeer

Bench: S.Abdul Nazeer

'\-

INfiflflflfififiiCQURTCNTKARNATAKA
€flRCUKFBENCHJMFDHARWAD

mmm mgsg '}T"§~§E am DAY Q}? AWIL, 2mp%'_ 

BEFGRE

"i'§§E §~§{)N"'BLE MR...ms:rIcE $.33mr;.;.,NAz:$'§:12.[_'  

Wm" E3*E:'}'E'};"T£(;>E\EE§ Nc>.6E3@€3€3/2E}?}§§"{(ii§M~?€;EgE§}:'* '~ "

<3/W 56.:?8,/2<>:'§<::-«.{.§}-MAWTEN; V 
EN W.P.No.656@6/26639 4
;B;E?:§;I&%ifi;_E§,N;:

MfE§§.,M.A.E~§AV.EE<3R mgxgtwcg.c;:<:>t~s::}Amf"»L,_ ' K ; .V
APEV§<;'i- MAEQKE? mi-327:3;j-sA:;;:mAi§f*I'1_    ..

mssgrz" ; 3E:,<}AU:\_&;  
RE:PR§,&§m*rEfi>.VBYi..}j _   ..
MRS" E%§»MAE£'L:Z':"'x N, '<7*:£--»;D"m '---
PRQE'§*»i§E,'T.QR,_ _     ...PE:'§'i'.{'§.ONE§{
{By &:;R;L:»":;z:m:,g:*'Et* M[yirgimc-:j;";m.m%:;cA';"££;

f3mE'};§._.»; 5 ~ " V t' 

 L  - A"L€'§~'§-E §§=AVARNA:TAKA m<;in:> 8», {3E'V§L
 » V:am1P;P.E.{:ES'«<;tt::§:3N. LTD.
  'E--:£E:A;:::>,.'€:3.§<'}§'§c:~@%;,.i.._1\z<}. 36 /I,
~M;L:,f&<:'.§<:?e:"_'3'?,;3:.f;:::%3é:; BEE) AR:E§:;x,
Kéugszzx NT. N;é§..--:;}AR
. Eififiai'-3G§'=.E.{)":2iE
 R/BY" fE'_.E3~£E IvmNAmN<:; DERECTGR

 K;*x§i£§«Nm*AKA m<;:::;> AND Czvn...
  'r.$UmE::§ c;:©E:m:2Af:"1<>Nm*13.
 V ;1::;H:*::%,<:><?>:2, £4333 C()MPLE1§><Q MAH'A_N'm::.H. NA<::;AR:,



W

E{AR.NA"§'AK_A. F{)€;}D AND iCfiEVE.L
SUPPLIES €'I€}«»(:}P LTD

13? F§.«C'f§{}R KHB CC)MF'§.,EX
MAF?Z.ANTE1ZSH EXT}*3NE31€f)N,
E:§E3L€3A'UM«~5':%@QE€3

E33!-.€;P BY
THE EI)i8'I.'R£(3:"§' 'Mf~'x.NAC.':-ER.

{L85/' Efwé. ssmvaam P M'UDHC)L, ADV' .Er§:j>R ;1§:: :g,§:22«;

"E'E*£'§'S:§ WP' :3 FELEELD uwrmg g.smf1C--:,§};5+: ;22e:;.;$--:.i';:::1: 2;2'?jéii't£~*' 
"£'E--%'E€Z {3E)1\I;$'3"1£'§;'E"€J"E'E<Z3§\§ cw ENDEA--..P,:'1?AYEN€3;.__T'<f'3x g*€:Wi}'\§E§i?aE:" -'mm '

N€j.)T1C'E/LE'1"""§'£€:R §:3AmD 5 / M}/L'.;1.f_)fG@_V §£s8§:«_:;:m av TH";-2:
m$AN<>,2 E€E3JE§{'fi'£'1E\1C} *1';-1:5; T{;}5.'L3?E%~.EAL"-~L.S'{.3P'P§M;}T'?i13;}~BY THE
PE'2'TI'E'I{}NER AT ANzx:ExU?+:E?je~U ':?<:>;?:V T§{1_§.,%1v;.r:N*1'H <3? A€i}~US'§'

AN?) SEWEMBEEE 2009 AND s";::*w::;--,VV¥'  ' V.
":'HEf;*."§E W§§€§.'E'ti€?.E3.1'§;'LE"ji3'iV{i§i5x§'§§V.::C.§3'M'i~NC§V' «:;::»*:§§ mm t:;f2Rm:;.-W,
TE---:{ 2:1; gyms", THEE c.:<:3L;:t?-;-if nx,s;aDr:_Timgg,'m:.::;e::--W1N<;s:

 L '§;§§_;13;§;3"';§E  A
'E'h::€',_ §<£'m.1%'z':i«:/}2.tf;ii:'il:;é2..VA'FQs:3'<;:E_ é;;2'1<:E 'Civil E?»':.1§::;;>Ei€:as C<:§z"pc:1"aI;..§<:1»r:
E;.1?n1m~:d :£z':\»<.%§_§.<:.:::i te.md:'%r*;3,_  9&1" the Natificatziarx cEa.€;<~3r::i

2€M}5.2F§7*{}?} §fiafi'1:§%§<:.ur%i'~A§"-;f1::r§5sassuppiy 05 T{2<>rda§. few" 28 e:ii:3?;.1"éC,t;S::

" >i"§':_ €}':;,.é=};§_"'~§3"§~'§;.2:1:'£:6:(ref %{@1":1-:2:-tzaka iii)?" the? mmntiz af Augum; 2m.c§

 '.':::.§Ei:;3f,1Lv€Z',',?.".*i},b£"3vET_v, QC.3{}'§}; .__'E."i'z6: §3a:'i¥:i.m'1€:1" m.1.b';n.it;Es.-:€.:i. an a.pp.i%.Qai;i<)1"z in

:"€3§b§_?1€>§';r:_;3s2 V%1a"3?"_i;;..f_7;_c' ;§::i§.(,'%. :'1c>E§Eica.:iwn 'f'a:;}:{* $L1g:>_p§y' 4:21" "§j'<)m"d::':§ in ':;i'*:e;:

  ET3%:'~:=;€§*i'€A:: 0;' ' T£?$<§Eg21'axn w'hie::h wag acmrgiiead by 'aha? I;€31"1<j§€:I'"
"- .fjj ~___éie:::€:pt..Eng.V__iéL,:'t;h0::":iEy xrifie a;>z*d<':~r dausd E3~®?vQ0O$} amzi $1.222

  j;:{:fzr§}ie%§'~«_s2n€e:%ret:§ .§;z"1'm {:lgf€3t'.?',I."flE3'"§§Z (§«':1"§€fCi 20,€,'}'?.20{}9 {Am':em1m+C}

'~%

 jRE%.?{§'E*§:3Ef'&:"§.'_S 3 '



: 4 :
£?iCC(3.?d.iE"i§;f{}}". Théit gaetiiioxifir ciéiiévertrsi T'€:>:1).°z"d&E mt thfi s's§:>eit€:ifie::3
d€:;3<;>m far i;E'1<-3 2:.mm':'.}2 of Az.1gL.1S¥;: and ES&p'E:em¥3:;*.r, 2699 aicmg

\2vé.%:E3 ms: i:"1V:'3'i(:::%s: and 'ihéit i:>i£.E°;=a. it 275:: ihé.-3 cawaa Of t'}r:€: j:::c3"i;i.':ti§'«-::2h;';<=:v:s

théli in Ez3::"I."ma of {:}éiL.iE%fi3 11$ of tile: <T:§_g};"€3E'3l'1.'i€?I'1fZ, E16  (:;'u*{LV%,11:.§:L"*(.',~.?i»§';"§;.f;._
'Q26: E:;a.mp§e§§ cf Toordaai fmm H163 Séiock é:7;.V':'{::1<:§.%:<€f3; 32')?t*"€§iit:t;1?i'§'f»fL;L§i<:%:;?:V V
m %.'E"1€c r€'ae"~;pec€1%Av&: va}":<>1e3::11¢3 1:;<3i.m.::~'; mzéié &3cifné;..:fh<:é'n7: 'fan' r%;<::V*is§E'j:*-3:.:i§'E1rj:'

ve:r'if"é.<::%mcV>'2': {>21 Z£3.0é'%m220{}@ ijw 'F';V§T11sif.__p¥..J.}T}?1A.a£;£T '§']i€3£~31.I§}j:3. AvEi'1v$:1.'ti?;§,E.ii('}'£"1, --. L

}321:1g;ei11c}'r&:; {.?:"m: :~2;§*1{>1"%;. 'me: PH?) ft.) >éf§I;;'s}"}"§:'{?éV1TZ'l'1 E0' €"hé. E;Y'€'fl:§£'»l{.:¥.€:ii£A€'-§ af
"1'{::<>:"{,ia;zE  per Appé-:r1<:iix?B ?c=.i" F&FE£;§%'i1'1*:7g~,.A "I€§§;3;'t3. it is :f'(L\3E,gal,'1€:E}~{
<:m':£.<%rr:d<=:d tihzexé; {ha-:_.j?'H[ E¥§f:}._"3..?..fi.'c3a.,§'£f;';)C1r£fh€I. €>§3%ziiEig 'tfhzxé; Em: s:;m1pE<:

Swat. fcsz" z;:..m;1§§/si_33  Vt;h§3"-;;,>éit,£§i<'ur1E::7_ i':»%":;7;:;f:':. ac1Li§'{<::raEc3<;iV in

£"u=r€:i1'm.rz:mé<':---95 §:§'1;5t V€}'€'s3?::_.?fliCE},"Ei.17;()}T"£. <::§:1L§'s3@-"ii? %;h.<~?: terzdiar :'spc-2<:.%.fi.C2§L'{.i{>:'"z

a.:"1c::§ im }:?1,:3v?§'8'E_I"a€r;'s'1'1i";T'ei'f'€f}fV:'£:h<if »Q:"1c.£§_:_i* "da.€::::d iCH§}8120€)9 iC~3€~3U€:{Zi by the

 

€I)f:f'i<::::: mi" th<§5'LZi§'§::-3. §5a1:1VC}j_m:é:j;.{_i.t, Belgezmm, the (3¥f'f"ic:<3 Of '€::hs:a 23*'-'<1

..VE"f.f8pQi":é;%i@I1f"§'2aéi%L€:3 s:{)1.§@g::%:€:<:§. i§"m :~aa:*11p}€:;'~;: <31? '£"<}<)r<iia':'E s£.Lmp.ié{3:<§. by

 "€}'1{'3'A"§~T>é§Z§;i5§§(7%lTEE.E7'v fm_r":*; 233$ M} d6ipf}{8 m'1«:;'; Séim; the Salim: am

2:2.~{;::8}.g<}{§€%~'"_:;n§;<§~,'"$3.1 2"?' 5€}§:'%.12€}€;)9 fem 3c:ier:'Eif"§ct v<3:"ii"1,ca€;1§<;>t1

rm Erhér F-?Ef§i;* Th¢: PE"§E, B:a1.ngz::1<;;«r'e:3, arm aactiszmiféc ve3ri;i"ic:s3¢:ic::A1
"'s:Lcmit.:sV"' a:3a§y§;i:~3 r<:};;>e:>'rt upinrmg 'sh..::zt' :3aa.mpE<-: sent

_-'§02f'._ "2;::éa3.§fy:~i;:és {:a:2z':f'm*.'n':ss :0 {ha standaarciss of 'F<;}<>mie:a§l



'F23

2
\,3«?<

:  ;
am we: Ap§m2":{§ix~B mi" PH? Ruiess, 1955",). As per the ':<~:r;<:im*
SS§3t€{7ifiC€:'fi.§(}YE zmd C.Ez§:'z..mc': 11 Q? %:.hz: Z5\§{1."€€iET7.i€*fI"§§ 21$ An:'1exum«~C,

igfm :':<;:<m1a1 p¢:.z'<§<:><;§ m:;gu.m~':d far §){:1yfI"1E"3E'1's'; 05 the: 'Km is 

fmmiz the: d:»x%;::~ Q5 3235; subm§a3i.am. £311 <>';:>1;:;LE.:1§:1g E.%5;'f3";'=;:;EiV§':§:i-§,},f1Esi.;L;"'

E"€5§Z){'31"'i".. damtzti 1?.€}8;200© and {}3.{}9.2UU9, x"c:s;';:><f:-1*:<ii;<;>1'91§=..N'(;::;2«vi<.i.fi:"

<§'3ir<:1;z'§;1's" dated 1..1.U<~;%.2{}{}9 issued :LiT:§:i:"E3§?$£§,€§X:f'i.S>"-- '§;{}-. '§"§?"i,€§" f}§§]§?x€2f?.'

Maxizz-1g,>;m"$ mf all Ehfiff Ba~:pc:zt;Ea ;€VI)f "1§;}'1€3V"A'T'£3§§§T)C3I'1CiV{fii"'fi?{VA,N{}.Q:'; 551* 

a2s§7;3§7:»1*(:§.}:':'a%7.§om"m;§§;i$za.ti.on of 'iha ' «;~'3.f:3: '§§;EV?'.:E""E}"']%:€,"v%"€'f('i;;§?.iI'i"3"E".£3.€3I"lE.
Er; 115; f1.m;h.er wntermdezd.  <:».fv€i"A1e§AvVE:ri.1£ deimeci
€}L€J;§E%«2{}{§9 ;;i~:]0m.§g; WW1.  01' s;i:..Q<:.k; 2;-xi;
*%.\11'1.E<:3a?a<;1i3"1g; ps.3§3:1*«:,;_"'E;4}"'::f-g fig-_'§'E§"i<:;€.: {)fim'L.'#1."}¥:E3 §>.<:>'%;§u«ci<:r1f: did ?.'}{T)§; 1"Z'}:'":1,§ri'.€':

}3%3:\»"Y.§"i€:z":'£. {If   N: is; <:0nt€:nc§<'~:Ci iifm-:4': HM:
azmirL:2"1t. éégxre:-s::.@d   t.'E*;€: '§'c:.><:m:%;a§. by the p<":tit.i{')'f'M3'§' is
e:tar:*ymg §;":ég};":€::?A r':T=1U.:'*:    cemsmg grmii px"ejL,;<§;:iC<:: zamci
hm"C§;ss§":::%i§i>_ {:3  "7ii'.3*1mA*::f<$%"6}, _;:>5:t%ticm.e3r iaxejmerd 2:2 Ecgai mmice
'V*€:§§i?.€*€?§':L_:9:5.?}.E'1i{}..i2?;A_€f§{}9 "{V':%.".{1;1-.-1."-.T..'3'..§,§' ms§;>€md€m, NQCE EC.) ':"r:a1<:s3 §§Eii_V¥'I1?3Y1'§L <3"?
' _§;,b<%: i:3.é.§:§V  §}i;':&?;}TJiEZ§':i "that :'e:e::<':~i}:>§ 05' t:h«:~*: n.c.:§ic.e by
§1":t':€S§f)?€§i:'1(4,:{&'ii"'s"?.'§'Ni§}»:;§'V;-'§;}L€i  no': Inaciri 22:35: €.f'fc>1*t: to m2,1E<i<: pay'rm::'s'%A.
af' €;.Ah.§:   ce::>:ia.%;s:"2:g, a'§'£;mr" the _pe:."£mf§ of mqtmsx thaém €:\x-*0

  vmexizmsg '{"E§'§j"%§3%{)1"1C§»€3i"1'§' Ns;.>'?; with malafide im.:€:2";%:i€.3;"1 imtinmféezji me:

'"2



: 6 :
§."}€3¥;§'§J:C){T£{":'E" Vida: §e:E'%.€~:z dated €}€;3.1.0.2Q(JQ rejf;-:ctin§,;; the '§'s:><)rc§a3
m.V2§:>}:'sE§ec.% by 'Sm: h.im".:. £:z>nten.d§11g that it i$ ruse: fit'. far E"m_:r:1.2m

ax:;>.:'}&m.1':":;:>t.%<:>2": 2-md asked him to takfiz bzxck the f"37'«:?:é§.T5zfi<;§.ai.

Th€32"ttf{.}'r@, 'gm-3t§.ti:3§3<t1* fiieci W.13'.'N{3K65€39€5/ 2{)O9 for  .

m:>?:i<i:6:/}.s:rm:.m" dagied O€'>.i€}.2Q{}9 %:+3$'L1cdmEf.>y r<<:':+;';j'>t:::z.:}{:i;e:b1-4j'I':V: I*%';;;;;;'f?,  

rejemizag '£:h::* "i'<'m:a'"d2;«:i smpplixrtd bf; M31":  A2'm<%§a,xu1"§:~AE,JV"a:1'{;1f:'c:;r't:i;.T'

rz'1a:3da.mus3 aiireattifigg; re%3p<>:1c§€:nt»T'1\§-€552 téi '1"%:"#?§;§€("§  t:'}ui<:
bééi damd {}1.€}§'.20{}9f am pm" Lfifldtgf;"'»E;@€:(f§fi(?%;%'EEi{}%$'éigfid §§E"it ie:.:'ms~:.
2:3? Cris-;m$€: 12 0f {he}. 2'-1.gt"<~:<;§:'A:1:};§s2t: «..2'{}O9 «;fiz1Hd z»?3j1S<;2 €10-
maktta pajy'1:mmt <2i"tE1§§ in t:<:1*t:;§;':,_ $3§:7;5d--.§i(>n~§:>a3J1'r3.c3r1$, mi"

':h€% hrlifi,

 T§"ii<f5» <:t<}u_t"1§:I"E%'ya<:i,V §5§fam.t:<é{:§_Vz:z.:"2_ sT:*1'éf=:3""n"rz m*c%€r:" an 3'£?.(;)4.2(3(}§§
§;'E:«:1yémg;; {.116 _{);')«5frg1é;i.s§z1§-..Vé;%."  E"1=:s.__<:"'c'E§mmuz1ica£:im: at: A:'2.m3xurc:~U

aizflaid {3§fEa.1{3.12{;§€}?9>., 'if'5h<?: §.fi'§<2x*§'m mraiesr wzzm vz;1<:::;»m3C§ %.:>;y t.}]i$a {zcsuréi

',,.,_

 é;.>11--. i3>,v§35[ . 'f'§1£=1"e:=:é§.'f'éfe;sr, {he 2"" z'esp<1mdt3z3t. is;s;L,ze~<;?i 2:1 mi:>t;i<:.s:

('71::'<i7i.'?;6iV:'§ _§'3w; _I§<';.?,_  i.;m:é:"na°;ti1"1g €i.§'1<;it p<:*tit.ie:im&:.1" that the SEfC'L'éE"i'E§z"

c:"ie:};";=:::3i»31__:f. in  $11532 (>5 Rss.i":$,3E§,fi00/«~ hats bé-rem fC>}'"'f€3if€f§ :;«z.:':ci me

 .. ;}::%:.tét:%\z3.:'1<;%'it"héxss bfifffiff). biacE«:~1iSted. 3';'e::1:* a p<i*:£'i0<:i {pf five: yeam. Hie.-A":

  i%¢§flV: r;.V<§.é"£'é;CE<;2d %.i+::» m§<.;e: §;>a.<::;k *£;h€: 'T<>s1>r4iz».'zi s'up§;>E%€c§ by him fm" the

 ..._ Eéf:-€":sx"3%t;.3:"3 of Juzm, '...J%.:d.§,-r, Augusat zxmi Septérraber, 200%" fia: wank:

M

K



f.":_;':z*:.i"z.@;€ i1i1fm*mc3d. i'h;33;  <::."iméz1z.11 case Wm be filed. ag.;ai.::1;<5:t; 'aim

in aa.:cu;°dar1::<3 xzvith is-aw. '§"he3z"z=:fc>§'*{:, pc'3€;i;£'mr1.e1" §'1ei«'1S' §fi€":C§.

W.PaN<fm'f:§€f> 1."f&§/143.-ZC}{}§9 501:" qmmhAi.r1g thtt ;11":.E:ir:"1a3i:,i0:r1  

V"

«-

e:0::1t.a%:.r1<:%.%:rz.g ':;h.a-"H: tfimss n1at;:s2..:* mvoivsés digpxfijetd que;:$'§j§g)'ri.:=;"€3f '

"E"I"mz"é~r§€.):"€::, it }"1é'ifS 3:0 he z'€:§€.z"md ii') é3;:ibE"%;s"::1t§hc)'z";' fig; pr;%:r*.=cE%§:3.1ss€: E4 of

flag: agrm:§'n¢:1é;.¢ Thcs It,<I.é9a;:;:r;_"3\e1t2:1.%~:'é' '}."?5§j}:@ '=.;;x:"*zd C-%.V§.E'" E31;:ppii<»":s
C«z:>;"p<m=;."{;i<::z1 Lirimted its {E16 &x{1s§'<:=: 5-xgéir-sit §?;:;i§;;:7;Jvi;:it.'<§d '£:>jy the Si;a%;:3.
(I~Z«<}v&r:1f:<3.f{"[email protected] for ..§.f2m.;'C'§3am:i: a2;"sr.1;,:}&s;%.1.'1_;:';i:«v?§fsgTv._Q5 {;.:a.ri<3U£5 fond grains

2.mu::it::r t".§';.€: .Ak.:~3E':aM.%'-_&VE33-:a'$g>1?m._§g:h=:e::'1"i'%: day Mt-ME} as; iI'"1Lt?1"1C§f::CJ§

by ?';§:€;?: §?;._iM;.=3. P2;h.Ai"iKL"'_:7'3€I£:&'é;'§;.1; (iii V~:=.1Vt"§"::=fL1.s:. <:§é.s,%;1:§.<::ts in 'E{a.r'Y:aJ{.azka. En
c:>':i'de.r ms im';t}E€ms;%t§:.:..VtEiaV' Ems: 'm$}<><L>r1Ci€13'*;,:~3 'rzaveii i$5;m~3<.i 21

EéfififlfifA,§"1£3I§';i'fi{t¢E£:ELE';%'fi'§7(;%»i" sizpgfiy ca?' "F{::0r<fiaE.. '§'§::<~:+ ;.<>€~.:€1?I..i<)m;wz~ had

$1.:a'p;11vi.€:€d 3.--f'?r3o's'dezAi :§a):7"i:'b€=: month csf .§'un<»:5 duiy, AL1g§L2:s:I; and

'f3§5§3i;~::f::%>§:Vr;.  H ?<":v[._&i4§*g;1.s r"®q'uirt:d {<3 m"c:rd;u<:€~: a11.ai13rsm+; zV°@p(32"E; £"z*<;>m

?;i";t:< A'.Q_.'('TV1E1'1.}l)§,_"'§;€;"§"i.:'§. ':m.1th<>1"§ty' with regard 'CG 'E.he quality e:>f the

  'T§3<3?ciei1" V:~::Ai;1p;:>Ei?Ae::{i by 1".}.IiI"1'"}u H6: is; p1a.yi.n.g ihmd. am §'.h.€3
  "=s¢éé2:gpc)é:'§«cEa3x2t: a«m<:i _;:z»{>o:" s»s<:h<3<:>1 gainggg c;:hiEd1*e3r'1 why» am: ta1k%mg mid

 "'<r§;a":f,3 m@:a;}.. §z'::53t,ee;n:1 of taking m>o2"da,1 samples imam ':.}m "T€;)O:'d23l

:2'

3" T}"mTr wé8p0m"ir::-mm hzzwsft féiszci :1~m~ 3ta'E.éa:"z1eE«nt'i€:f'._§§%;;:§§3:.r;:t:ll<§m:7



«£3

sup§3hr7:ci 'by mm, 336: Eoak; sampieta mf E1}'1€':':f Taerdal imp: in Erlizez
csshogm .zm<i 3:13:11: it for aamaEy'$is5 zsmd go: ;;"ep(;:r"zs as pew Am":<~:x'm.rc:é:3~

C} and H. The re:};:sc.m.s3 ai; A.1'11"1exu.:"€$«€3z E-3.}"}.€73; E3 (E0 not. p;e:z71:_:21.i,;fi.7fL_A<}

time "§.'<.>0:*cEa} suyapiied by him and 'ahcérefore tif:.r%§"'2az9.éf'*--..

mrcapécmtsieu Thfi. Zéiia ¥"m'1c'E:a;vai:. E-131:3; 1ff€':'C'¥t:.iv.§;§}<"§ "%3€V§3;£"'.§:j

c.<m"1p1a.h'1t:$ .t"€;:gar"e:iing EEK: pom?' qua§%.tj§?j_ 0f;-'&i2§i«'1"c;g>f<;iaf1- S1;;3V§:»L;35lia:i:d;.

§T§_§f the': pa*::.%;M.i0n.er. "1'h::*:"@f0r@y L§'1Te:-..§C'3}.'1ic~:'f""AE:>?:t:*<:L2.1:A?£:ré'M';;~£" §;h.<2 ::Z«*§:.}'?r:":. 

Pae?anc}mya'%: teak :s;z»9;r:n§3Ee::§ of £:}"3c{§L4L'vV..'f£E"k:><are"ia§ by the

1g:;e;":'£:i'ELi(:»2ri:e':z' {<1 t.h€: :'@spQn(%¢i*x~:s vkha

E.cV'%:L":I;aE¢':::v"§E':».(..>£.1'1?; anci mm: aim
Same to EPHE, fiangaiare. f_F'§_":E:._E~'E=*'§_ZV,  azficir <::hsm;&.e:2;:E

c~:a.*«:e:m§.::a€im': f0m.1<:*i "%§h_-;f.:i: ¥;.}*;€:. 'EV':i:»:;=:*V<:iaE' £55; €i"{C§11L7'Lf¥'f:3'E"&3~'§E3C§ and <:0z'r£;aima

K6 am ri d¢»::..7i*~ \-rv''E"i.}§.'<1f{I"1\fv ; L§:_Z'"."{i?'.  ;f1'1'£3.£fa V 'e£:0n:mmp§i.0:':. 'E'h<3:f'<;)rt:,
the W "fie Deputy C}em=:raE E\2i2mz>3.ge:t:r,
E%a.ngz-tais;3§7*e2, iffy €:11q'ui.I:'y' and :mbmi'E. at mp<:>rt..
.. T%m   t<><:>§<: mxxxples of Tiaorciai {mm the:
 '§Vg%a%.£g%::.:-j'vA%h§':~;I:"gj;}:>}§<:c§ by the pc':E;i.t;i0m':r in %::'m: pr<:ts~;e3r1<;:<::: <;>f
9%:E%fiEEQ3f.aér{*'§§'«Vi'§:v.;;>z'g;'$=a'é§i1tat§ve and 0t}";€::2" c>fi"§<:i:s:J:s 2-and 'fo:°\nrarz:§€:ci zhacr
.&»3a:;"si:c: ""%.:;  z'é3S'>f301":d.€31'":t fog" ::a}<in.g fm"the:r M63103» '1i'h.<;: W
w7Vj.%13fi.':~7*.'»"}§4?:.€:ix?2V15";f"'EZ.'逻Ei1E'3Ei tile Toorciai to 'Em: Chief Chezmfmsfj and .§3L1b§:%.c.

_ r.§"}.'€"f&{1.§'i::Eflfifiitiltfi, Be1r1gaE.0m. Afiskr Chtimicak m;.arn:.%.m:t.§.m1, {bait

K»

»»



Chief €§ih.€:m:ist 5:§€fE'1§; his :"c*:;:::<>rt with an opmmn t.}:}a_t thaa s~3amph":::»3

surf' "§'{m;rd.a1 contaizxed Kerari (mi w}1i<.:h. it:-5 unfit far h)_.2-zfnan

<3€.}.'£1Ev'»'L;f£'}p'$Z'i(Ié}fT£« 'i'i§'1at. is; why the': T001'<iaf. S1.E§3p1itA3(fi' ?§}:<,f: '€[.E§€T4

;3ei:.':t:.§<<>m«e:r 1512223., beam} 1'E:j€Ct€d anai exotica is inii.i>:«'3,tL€*<;£..};;%3>L-'E,1':&§7 V'

:"t?:s3p<>:';e:16:1"1rE-a a§g;ai.n31: Em: p<3ti?;io1't:c:::2:" 3;'-?:.$.'""&i%$€.3'C)'£"€Z3&11"1Q§i'A"§'§fi§L};f£».§:£f€.\?\f}.,

'E'E'1<3y haw: prayed £01" ciésmisaaé of ¥;}'Zi.€i {Kl-'z¢*3?et; ;;:><;?=:'t;i't:.%L<:2Ts;1-[  ..

45 'L.€a,:*m3e:i e::c1m1s=st2.E faint {ha p€:..f§i1i0n¢:r=.:§s'Lt:§:ar1fi'it${":Vt§i:~it i;§MV1<:r

'E'<303:'ar3;2=:.§ 31;a;_:>§_:>3ied by she: v'§3t%§i.ti021&.é:';";}{;:.'$:Liz2n'£ :0 {Ike éigreemcénti
at A:{::':{2.xi,1:"e--Ci 'Leg 2'1.<:;'s: é';'1.'C§;i._3:_§;§L,(;":3'"&;'%.§:;Z'"':{I§§ 3&3'-. :'€I?,(.}'?1'7?;€éE'§.Ci€?,'C§. by am
r@s3<§:):;3:*§<i<:~:c'z:E:€H it £8.-Si§%)m%§§ied.bth.a1L.§j1A2:£ii--ng 'acj:.a::~;§pte::-<3 Vthe "E'o0r<'£a'i,

Submit;%;e'.r__i by  pe;§€:iVt.i{:~mé.*'g"..__ _h:._' is fm:*I::hm" azffgued §i,}'1E§f; {£1.63
$€;"::"n.p§€::3 of'T'G'e::n"c£2:z§_s'v;:«rii E>y--.__fli'%'::;é" §:>e2.%;iE;i0z'mr for azzaxiyfiig iss from

'%;}"ifi'. '¥'<;3{7:"da'i 3L:§:>;}}.i.<i<:i by .§1é.:4:zi :10 ¥.:IE'.:€.*. reagmarwiezzm. [E23 :+;up;:>0r£: fjfif

 hm <::1t:::7g€,n*>:i=::'L§;§<:z1*';s;«, he }1z.§§§£"eEi€:ci cm thss: d<':*<:i:ei<'m mi" 111%? Apex €"l:mrt

"m  mt' INDIA Ann ANOTHER vs. CONSUMER

Efl?EI€j;f;zé?£'E'{"3.zV'»i;§3;.§\?f'm RESEARCH CENTRE AND OTHERS {.1995

ix

  '£5; scc'»@3?::3;a



1 ES :
 Cm !7.'m: oi:E1.<~:1:" Es.-a.'nAci, learmzci C{)'L;i§".kE§€§ fear the 3:e3p0nd<mt.:~§
5;u'z:mf:%.£i:~3 {bait thezi Twerdai s.:~:u§3p1i<-3d by {Em pet§.tior;.<:+:? vv'a.:1~:

2;mE'L.:.E.'£,<:.:"'a.'£;&%<,i. "H:'1£;' :"€spm":{i@m:$ héewe sent sampim of tE1c%.'1T€73'€§Ei3s'§11

:0 t;h<~:: Chfirfsmtfi zmd Pt.,zb1i:: A1m}.y:3tT ft)? V§:'.§"ifiC:a€Zi{)f}:::é§.§53[{3§"iii?-lf1'}1§§_3'
t.E1at {Sm '¥'<::30"rcia.E s;'z,1p§3E.i€:<i by égbe pm.it.;f.<mer is :"n:;€.--£3:.':"£"c}:*"'§?{u«r1;2.z::.:1u
sqmzf}.m;a;;"n.pi:im""; and t.hz&i: it rsamtaima K'.:(f'?E:':&7£,:)7i.,'Cif:vEii1'.-,,> 1 E11; "§,5~*{'§:"é.;:..:IjE?:;.§'§.tf 

mybmitiézed than tiara: mattier hag. V:a."m": §:'{~:§'<:"_z*I*e::<:i to12a'§?13i§;.§r"a;1'£ie:>%j1 eats 

§,;>:m-videzcfi in Cia."L:.s~;e3 W of the Agr'e<€§%1.~:§%:: at Afi:1e3€m*x5e~(f:.:

 En. {hm ifighi 0%' me Su_b;?:ni.s;[si.<>z;.0,6" "€¢£::}:-zrzziaci muzsmeri fem"
me-3 pEiI."{iif:Ei, Ehér fimi €L[£l€3S.'EIi,.€f}§"£'~.f€}€ <;:f<:21f§é%.'%.~:Mi%:i:':'--:§é:%A'tf3z": in zfhiécs writ
'E3c":%;:%'§:im1 L3; \>\a'fET1€?'5:':.}%§3{:i::,§i*}I"1'{:7' 'E3€rTEi€3$'3i*::§:r _ §1.2_1S" éi'<)'----a"\r.:'«;i§ am: aE$i{5:rmmve
z"€::':'1.€:d;y ;3r(w'ic§§éA{iT5f_%1";_a E75115 --:e§g1**;j€tm6.n.'E. The szatérjomi qL1e$i.i0r"1 is;
's2v}*mt1'1@r '1"h%:';'2 T:1o:"d¢;=§_ é;%.i;:.§3v'i§ev:t;i:"'b§} the p€:ti'£;io:1€:r is, m :::<:>mformiiy

Wi'é;1";s '%ih.:": .#s21zI1§>£€:73.,s<'%mi' by"-."§":c%.£n for <:hen:1.icai exaumrmatim: and mctr

h';:}:V3§<:>a?*1:~r:<:;'";:"tf»«;ie:;*§\{*i:«::}, by hi:-;fi"ia:§ per" Anm?:mm2s~G and H r€:s=;g.)s:.<:t:iv::':Ey.

'{.17.§z££é,.;g€ AT§?%~»--._«e:2»fVz_;E"i§; f\§?_1"€f:}'1"}€3I"1f. at A:z31"3ex.LLt'e--C p1*<>v'i<;it:tss fox."

a:"'i";i.£:r_';~fa%:ii>r;. «:§:f'"'§;}".;T<"i* diaputté '£3 2:5; Under:


{L In Case of {my dis_pu2'.<e in $upp€i<'--;?$ z7nc.:Eudi21g
' ' 'é'5}'::=3 §r:.zf<r3:7jg:>2*"c:2?1fatri<f;n {sf arty af Ema. e::Ez<m:se3/ aEa,t1.3es of I:i':r»3

ssaggmememé the mafier shczEE be referred to «:1 3628

ix



: E11. :

zi§rE3ii"razo:3 uflm sshaél be aefecréed mam mu;fiue:2Z
crmzsaarzé of bozfh. {he pa.m'e:.9 for afljtadiccziioréak The
w;amnz;rz.@r*a£ém"2..far me Arbiimmr" 55:h<:z.Z£ Em fixed 3.33; the
firéysfiraifar at E1113 degcrfptioru '§'he:'r Arbitraiian 5;-?'2,~:zZ?i. T V
hem' fir: gggggmzgrg. TE".he d€CiS€{}I"i Qf the A:*E:3:1_§%'a'§--{~,g;~v._  ~ A'
Shaéfi Eve finafi {moi bzindmg bet?-2 the pcxrz§e_;;§:"'-I}; 
z%rZ:s:f'£m:Zz€(m, and Cmzciiiatian ACE'; Q96 .9§h£7;_3§E"

far su.<::'§?; prmceedingss. "
W":

¢:f:fj"fi.Cae;:icm&3 m=m€:dy' is; open 5:0 3. §_iét.i.ga_-;".::.._., "he: :3}"1c}i2.1d_Ab§:':r<t<:;1.z2§:'*<3.<:§

ta} pL§E"'S11f: t§m.%*. fame:-2dy ;m-ii. 'q1."ji;}'; . Vt'€3i.t1?;2"<3l<:&: ihezr %:~3ps=:e:.é::fi

_§m.'z"§se;<:%i-:t,éc:r1 mi" "tthssa 'E-"£*ig§h €;3:;'i;1.i*'m{éf;» i:§.:::..';§;m, a §31i€:Vfi:%ga:Aiv5: Wm... Thr:

€:§;€;;"ac:srd_iI'3.z+::iy_§.L,::zti;ae.§i_g:_:%:_e'>:1 fr? ti}E"y<:3 (1%;-;V:T 23 iiwi: 2:: };}E1.f121C.'.€38. Em" an

%:.Ei:{=: zriaiziciiea W3::{ia:'%3--«.z;{'iijtiggzafit_.n";;:;'zy $.ufft3§* fmm. "£2 ;£.:«a time: that

t}:.1e €i'X§:f3i1€§E§C&3"€}f ':33' :§{i!V'&":'r':1{:§{ti.vx'3 rmmrdjg cimzss mm affézrct; tm:

_§m"i$di.m;§on e:>f~"*-;hr:': C0L._.:.:'t~.jt';c>".i..:;$sL1<": ex Wr:i'z:, but {ha existsrzmre of an
..v.E};§Z:i€?:(;hIw..'L§;%;':'£:?§ }.€::g3:a} mitrawszciy {Sui 'i:hix'1g to ix: i,z«:&<<*:*.1": imcx Ccm:§id<:r::1t..i<m
 iii: «?;';i":é:% 13i'2;:%:i:.5t_1""~:_7f g,.:"a.mEiz"2g writ. Writ ;§uris;adi<:1ii0:n i3 mg}: :0

§E':e:,cVi£.§.fg:;g%&:-- VV;g§.azg>i'&é=a:s1§:_$;:; (ff c3§:.>1i.gatio:1 x.r<:1':unt.a:'*iEy in<:urrE3c}.. Article

226 {>'§ t§'1f3' .§:@'L*':?*"E.?"':"A_-)??:';'i'i?.'L.2'i1f.{)E"1. of E:;1dé.e1. £8 n0'?; §"1"1€:'E"s.I'"iE; U-.7': imzppiant E.%:<;".

'V€}{i§3'i§E"":$§:'.j..f@3"1TE€3(§i.€E§ at §Ei.'JV bm. m3§"'<; E10 smppistmem. El'1f:Z".i'1§": £1":

 §:e.iw%ié2.L'%._;>h :2».-*€:'1.E 3{'<E?C€7}§§l'1iE~3{tE€.§. s§€..'uati0r;s.

ks

VT

1.

E": iss well eattttkéd zhai '§}6_,?1'3v.Q.,Yj}' 'é'Li,V_I"i aEt."<:%fm:z;f,iV{i-V_afr':§ii""m:iLiaE£y "

5%. in g$"2""fi'}'E 0}? (AP. AND GTHERS VS. BRIDGE RQGF CQMPANY (INDIA) LTfl., the Apex Ccmr: has halal £)af':§f3:8 Csf di;<ia;:)L1.E;,€*§: :t'6:}iaE:11.::1g 1.0 %;€3:I:I1:a of pnvate COI:jL:'§§cf , . €II(.'z¥.J.};"'3-Efi wcmfid E36 ':0 f£*<'-2..'i'¥-::a2z* E236 nmtter for gz»A1A7fVE:>i.E.1'"at:'.:;>fi'U2%'.:3:73sVfivf;,u":i<)iZ:
af <:§.v.%.E amt aixcti mat; 31 Wait 'E"em;ion. E": is h.é:id. 2:12; :md<:ir?: cg/23. Tfzgare as yezi ¢3i.?1O€h€2?'"~;:'{:il/é}§?§'3Z5£C3€?"%.éir'C§E'V'F'€??t;I'S(}3»?!Q,'?24?<V7fjiV{;?f é2:?,£er"€a2'n,:Tr*:g 23%» Writ PeE'i'iViC*§%[' TE'}1éé~.c&§'rT;€V?a€:i'.';: in queasfzfln. <::c=22€a£*r"a$ Q: .{:§au.s:3'"pr*?i;f2}i£§i'n.g :77*§,f;e3?*:;/zAZ€<:é" }"<:r:"

se€:€Eeznmrz: zaf ::£i3p::m*'fe'%:+&'jb;y'.Lrc§fc3;ré?%'2.-be. iu., _arbziz'm;€2'on {Céauge 5? of :§'2,e'se §':Qr:2f%fc2'c:j;._ :Ti': é*A'r:£éV{§:;V<at0rs car:

decwicie bafifi. 'e*;:;ii»£V€E'.:'_"':?€3'tj)?';2;'&? Cg!}'i§':':fi2C1f<.V{x'§'§',:2;:;2¢§3vEI {gs quazgiziam, Qf fawn wgzm s:e;:§rz7ir4;@;;?§ E£.3a§fp%joz2:;:Ees"fc:r a made cf e;e2£z'Emnér~a.2':V iififlorzi the cronzrmzzt, €?*iz,s::%2;"e2 aL.~:; 'jA:%;éI(i2r'[v:3*§:.?'eaz_.§;e;:>:%'z.' wéégg. pr2.r?;z'e5; ahaufci rrmzi jbilow a,ncf"':1e:fq;n€Vghcii«'i?é;:37zfé:»si§--~::;z{1;q? z*m2c>Z~.:ea "the extraordinary jurisdéééfiafl .oj'"VV£f?";éV ;§j{z§;h:_"_.€3azu'£ un.zr§ze:* Arzfcfe 2263' Tim e-:g«::esr:s3rz<;:e?V :)§f".{:VfzV'a:gf]§%_,rctiz2e a€fe?rr1m':iue rerngzciggmin 2.';/:22'; g:r2f@22ide5£""'i%:V the». corazrzxct iisezf «-- is 52 good ' §=;rj:o;<A:,:'i?c;? ;';;%7c:)T¥r' --._€he com"? 230 deciifze Eta erxwcise €173 '5 g3;;:#*t2fi%'g»§:i§r:.i§:'rg;;§. jz,.¢..ri.g>dic::z'<3n tender Amtécfea "295. The '~.:§mT<:€v'.A.zfi§§:Eé was um? meaani to Su,ppZa.n:. the c22_>::"is£'mg;} r"e;r;;e'<££ees at Eaw Em? aniys to :§u;:ap£er23,en.t §?z.err'z. iris AA ' 7-?'j.:E?F'"?:€V3.?Li?'E u;,r<»3?E£ W -recognimed simcc€§on$." , E2;
( : 113 : (3. Again in A.E.L.,INTERNATIONAL LTD", AND ANOTHER V23. EXFQR'? CREBIT CORPORATION OF INDIA LTDW £iND QTEERS at pa1'a.gg:faph My, ii 'if':.23..s--.a "beez'1 haid asas undsér:
W ........ .. we heme .speczficcxE§y érzqlxired fr0_3?§?§«"'"t?--é:3V-. ' gm.%f€ie3:;<3 to ?f'z,e?r go'Wa*sen.t a;_9;:>ew:z;E E)s=3f4:>re 3,1,5; f1(:.€;§_;f1e:* H' been mid {hm zT§1e'32"£2 is :10 such VK'-'x$L'z""AE§i£'"'i'"t."'Zfi().i"'f'"& <:{<:zz.;i.s2vs'3 iré. am: c?<mm2.<:£' in questmnh IE is We-13.32 §€.{'T;'0'i.,(;'F"i. ??§fz_a'€~ mzrzfieszz to 5»: aiisgvute had zxcgzgagggfcf; to S:9._EI;Ee:? €}ze2i§mgmIé$xfiuze E32; m"£2iEra£2iam and if th.ez~e:"é--s."an aqre%e2riuc'~m.§":ir1"fhai rmigarfi thee Comm zgxifé' not,§eémrz.i'??"»gfec":c>:,a2*s:a.343 ,:im,; ether r@r7*2.<~3dz,; u2iEhoz}U£.. muck':-zrtag '_2f1r€£é' ~--r€:r'r.ié:~ciu by wax;-zg 0f §§£f;i'fim}E;§§'Q,§iQZf};WL£?Z.§€88 of cauzfsfiboiéh.-£E1é:~.;§fm_g?§.£e2s to file d:f$;p2,5.zs3 a:z.gr'e§é-._ anj :;:.r9z?<:2:f%e.e4;4a. '«;z:,oc€e§2« Cgf <:i£spu.£e"2 *2 r"@::sm7.M::Tc>2i;. _ ' V V'{ééVrnp§":czsi$ szgrgyfiicari) 1(1)' I %'2z:1%;rs§ g-ztrmi' 't;i"i:":'}1:§2»;}':'~..&:§"£z:*'{'i§f.f€:r€:nA§. <:71auS6:S Of 2-3g.j;z"€:c::z1"1Aé:m; and :'.3€..%fi.é=%_;" w;"2a.€eE:'ri a..E:;..g>121{ia2c£ Tam mcord. "E am of thrzf V§(')'W 'Lihat .€:"fm§s:3 £3 £3 ?..;c1:m%;t';e j2;*iJ§*:<--::'<:V'Eé;1{i*i"u23i 2::<,i_jL1<§i{::a.tiLm is; §".H':1CE:$$Ei1€'}'. Anjy' é:1§_s§j};1_t.é T2:*c;:i:3;j:Li;a~':'z:g4:0"§z1t@z7prei:at§c>.n of the tr:~r17m:: and <::<mdit.'i<;>ns_s {sf i~§'L1f.':}"'t,__&'-AV cc);"j:ij'r2s.':§t:.':'c':a.m101: he a.g£'§a'£:e:d in 3 Wm. 'Pé:t:iti<>r:, if the 'g?::«f.?u#téess §"3tfi.\N§.'3 agreed to :':;e3:%;t1<': iT h€'§§" €iiiSp'L.U;i§i% by :3.r'§3it::"2;1i:.:%<>rf1 zmd if ._ "t§"1«:?1:fé: 211'": zz.greem.er1t in ¥:,}"2:21.E :"€:=:g,&1.1"ci_, Elie C:;>L;3"t will £'}€.T)f; permit: : M :
m.e';m'1.,z:"'s;e: is any Qtiaerz" W:n'15:<iy 'withm3;t; mv«:.>kimg tbs: mznedy 1:3-y way 0? 5;1fl'I}iE.F&EiGfi, ii}. Th.€3= dacissiaurl m.Ei5:.d on by the iearzled <:mu;z1$eE: VE::;~:{ :'%;?§3:E{ péiézitimmi" in me am' INDIA AND ANOTHER vs, : ' EEUCATIQN AND RESEARCH CENTRE' AAI1). C}i'f:?ER5 V(1'_'Q'95, A' {5} SCC 48:2} cigars; moi amist the .:;>§3tiE§i:O §?J:<§I'.KK"~ <:i<3ci.ssim1., if; 13:; hsitid U:1a.'i; tfmtr ai£::V§€:}m$ €>f aVp§3a':'.'s;;{1':"':é:&s.. 'iisear * gmljbiis: a::ha.r'aa::£:m* Wfiih ax": §:_nmri:1§.V_Q:§::';;§1;%;;V§'§;: i1;fit.e'r£~r::~3_§ gfiézmexit in the'-32;? <:>ffié:"$ mgz~.u"ding tEA>r;r:*1s; a.*:":t;i L.<:ef:;i*;%f1'iti%;§'}"§A;§$'ziimzntimmd in £t.h<:3 a'g3p:r0g3z'"§::-its: tabia iJm:a:'> C{m€::"a.<;'£. Qf fife: 3?Vn&;umz":€:e3i a1 j5:1§.;:.ae_T V."e"1.1'.'W%f:TV§. :f?;§.'1;i#j%){1.&§"V'§3riv<E1t'€3 Raw" digpme:
Vw'i'§.}i"3z'G'LIH; Th6E"€3f{'}E"f:i, {ha writ.
53€i"é;E'.i.<;>:"; the valiciiw of ism: <:0:n.d.iti{;:na Eaéd in f?§a;}.>§e 58 ttfimm. poiiarty lanai "£33.62 party need not be rcriegatstai fxtb. t';;5=.vEE. i§'.%;.\:t§iA{"2t:1o '}Z'}1.éV"é.i:.'€;i.0:f1z~3 of *::}":<:*. State? "£113 iI1.E§§j.1"l.1I}€1CfI"E'€Ei:E.§ty, %.:m;13'}'Vpéibkfiii»..;§A;:t1:1sMA;%*1§.f:y or p@I"E':"~OZ'} \I\fhOSf:"i ezaztioms %b<%zr irmigmia of pTu.b}.%§:: ia..'vv «*:r§.<3:':'::;1«;i*:n.t; 0:' pL3.':;>iic C.ham::1:&r are a.m€m.abE€ $.10 §s.:di.a'.:iaE '.:".¢:v§::t*w andA'i-the vaihtiity af smth an aactiom Wolfld be mateci 0371 t:..h<:t A1"§:%<:i® 14. Whiit': exe1rC§s§.:;"3.g; the powez" mfzdm" Artickr was (low? w'0L:.':eE be cimrmnspect; ":0 aVd}udica.z;<': t;h<:3 <iis,;_pu£:ie:-:3 E : Ni ;
z«:.1*§:=;mg,g§ zizrmi of Em: <:<>m,:"a<:t <ie;:><:éndir:g on :2--1:: fact.s élfid €I,EL"t7ILi3'1i'}€§°5jéiI1Cii?ES in a §.§§v's:r; (233556; Each :'::as:'~: has K0 be €::><:aI;":'1§n€:c:§ {H}. its awn fan»; maéi <:*£:"c:u:'12ési:Ta1'1c:&3s;s to finci amt {he 1"s.am::e mf ?{'n<::~ 2'~1ct.%.vi'£:y 01" s;<::i)pc3 artad 1"1&?.Ei'L.&§"€: éirf 'she: c<'mtr<.>v{ez*:3j,r. ';1%7jh{-2 &i$;T;im":"$:i<.>J:1 bstmrmrn pmbha: ism' and privatfi law r':=:n':§:;C.i_'»_/f i};'.~j{';t:':;fi.>§* an a:I.*:"mW:d dmvn.
':2, ms: n0?;i<:<:<i abcrmz, flit"-3 §x1;.-'3;f:Leir"'« ;,5e:;w;;_:»:=:_:;" «._§:1<f:1:.s3;e1§ &C'}j1,E£TiiCa?L"§0I'1 :.<zm§ égfhe aa§__;r<3en1€r:Vt <"31'31;§'i'!'_'€iif;"i',V'§p£".J;()* 'i.:§E?EiVV¢?€ff{} '€12-":.;t:* pa.r't1':*3£»s. prs.';v-idem fever em &.}ME\Eft3£"1"1a*'t§;'E',}:.'»."'x"?_%€3'U1©d"y xvarhi£i:E'i'_;i&aV":V:1é§'E§' cmiy ae7:1:=3q1,1.m::t1 bras é7&:§{.> eff§<?a.<:i:1§'F¢1.£;3. Tth.';§§"::5?~:%;};':7f'§i\£. «::a§~;:-;t: °W'}..*i®:"5® vs:§§<:§.if..3; «:5 time: f;e::*m:~; {If am z:1g>;:'€<an'i€éA:1t' %31<3._:%i :;2e7:*:s:1 i:.hf'<i §'»:1r3:.i€:s urfiiiiflif €;':I%"[email protected]_;,'€ia in {')'f Hf1'<"";t'.g":i:if}ff)v'iF£C*.a¥1§§W€3I° E0 t:h<:*. firm; paint, ighéi sr::<:0'nr;:i psfsimfl h;-':23 :0 .E:2%é .§3;'.::5;é§,~z;_§*é%:d""'by the a:r*E3it:m'€..m". 1 r 5.43" ".E.3u€;;}§di2€3.1_{};€..E:i*:§ C0'uz'"£:. Emsis V;-1Ca:§£ic3Ci %.h<~:: ixxterim {>L"<:?z.€;:z"

:"._Vgg:'V"§?éz;:"«:f£;«a'-3965?. W.fP.N<1€>§€>96f '2;,O{}'2¥u in <:';th&-:1" v~.»*0';:"<:§&§, their 59,.

_ L §§'1L.3:-€33"i«:f"':: egfsm €35 Gf Anz"1@x2,m;:~--U §2;:"ami€:d 'my' e';hi:~;: <:0m"E: "ham; 'br~:<:m v.2_1:;:2";'s*;:a:2<:'; _ f~*E'§":;;1i;. Mfxy the I"€8'p0Z".i€if:3i"fiZ.$ hax.r<: d.é1"a~:~::*;{:::E. t:.I%3.€:

' "".}§VE::»?.§A€,i:}r.1&:£"g§::§ Eéfi emci "Ea?-iqa ba.cE< the '"i'<m§."daE s':s2:L.zppEi<::d by "him E m 45'?
I 15% :
Eb? t§':<-3: :"mm%':.h:«;~; Qf Jtzzze, July", Aug;;u:--5E: 5;-md Scztpzcirmbaz", 2G(f29o Tfimy haéve e;»i.£:\30 fc3:*fc:3it;<:*.<:i the §L'.1\/if) amci :~2€<:Umi:y ctiepoesit {Elf Rs;.;:"'3,35,€}0€}/--v and ?LE".:<-? "§I)€;'§i?;i..('}i'1€i3IT hag; bcien %;.)1a<:1§:<Eis'{:.<3c:i far :52 p<-tried ()5 fwég": j;fE%é':1E"f:-3. F*a;1.§*t.i§f;€:1g 11123:}? Eaazve 'inf0::rm:<§. the ;;:;se:A£;it_£.::*:2:;M3&::"' Efhzaé: aa§.:'=:§:'2s3 Wm be: t;a1«:en ta} §3I"<}?5<':'C3'L'l'fj(? t.h<i*. peE:i'mZ(.:z.1er. :"a:ge;a.r"«:i 11:: t%':.:3 ii:-;u:s:.s§ azxci €3iI"C'L;i}T}'l%$'C€:1"£3C§i2S of Ehrsz Célfafii, i.--s:. 1':a jH,E}'§j 'éii"}.{1§.v_"' * gifififipfiff m satay me biaz:k§i5;€:.§'ng Hf ilze? §;>€:ij;§iin3:1§:.r, f'('}I"f.1§i"i..?A;%;;2ij"g? s<:<::'L::*£tjJ ciepmait mad :£:"2.é.'é;1E2:z.€é0r1 of <':r:mifu::i 'pr€5c<3et:.iizj:g,i~3. ;:;§=:r3!1;:i'i«:."§;;§--. <::1¥i$§:><:»:'-92$ Qif iihif E:1§'E"}iK4¥"E3M§,i(i}I"1. }CIII"(1:€Z3t";'V¢';€T§:i'!f5g':3»» pfb0'wri<:%x":<i; €1--Ehflvifi-7:VV'VE?V€éVti¥'%Eé'n®V fN.a.§i»<:T-:':~ss s:?$;€:p:3 U3: é.nii:éz:e:€c: £i}VI"A§I.3iU'"€:1'C,?T;€};F} '[:',e,'£.".€i,)£:_?A:ti";"*EE_<;§'f§"§-3_vg'§S 'e2v§f;Ir";é.:r3_z;3,;;3<:1"ic:ac;i «sf t}:"m:'-:a"-'5 x"2"1<m.'£h$ fmm tine cILai'?::;*'M of 1'*1i"3C§';<":'i.§3%£;'/f{§§r'§«3'}>' "35 mm' 03"d'"~73V Eiiemsxrm", €;Ex<.-2-pe$E.;%.?:éct>1'§.'£E:; E;-Q t;;:E<'cV.?t;»¢£<:}< {he '§'oo17::ia1 guppiied by him": iT"1 g(}'E"C£€'3I'WC}'Iii/"Z)'f'::C§>r,fifE'EX.§;iE?1; €i¢3tt3ri<3;e722'1%;:E<;.)x3. Qf me 'F0c>r°CE£i:'i, a:f€.:.€§::* %"€:fLI.)£"1(.§.i.):T?Lz!f:'_' V*£;};"is,:=: «:,1fn.;z':j¢:=.f ?4;ij*:<3:..1:'"1Ei :"s::s::e::;EW::<i by him frmrz the ;fa::§§3€>r1i§£.§=x1:$~ for t.}.ir:;~--..::;p:ppi,y' csf "17'{>s::>miira,E far the :"m>171Lh.::§» s:';§'" Jame: *:{m.d;31_;Ey, i"§.€}~";; TV' \ , M-. En: %':Ii"z{*:. Bf the ai:b<>v€: <.i§ssc:1;::5sssi€)n? E pa2s;;:a:: {M3 f<:>i}ow1'ng '.*L%'%'"d.§«-21°» .. V W : ET':
K&f.P.NG.€>E?%>€¥6/20{}9 is d.ie3mi3$ec1.. 'fl'.<>x2vt::'<.r<?:z', m:;<=:r'£':;J is ;ms:s<;:rvr:ci m {be [3E3?i';§*{i{)§'..1f;':I" to avmfi :c>;'H;s:t":mtiv<: rc:tmi:.<:§y :s'2va:é£ab§<3 in §aw*'. Ali <:om:.<3;'1 t:.i<.>1.'1s are keg)': <.3§::e:%n. '"i""h&:*. 13e:i;fi§<J3:1:3I* is e§i.:"e:cE.<:%(i $10 take i:ra<::1«;; E€éLE:{)p§§EfiC§ by him for {he month (>5Apagust.¢éi;§t;%---f:§§-3§jf€tVm'bVc:1';_ 2{)}€I>9, wmzizz a pm'i<xi of tgizme If*Xf£C3I"i_11'§?;E;':Vf1"Ci:$f1'1*7£}i£3' ¥:ji-'§;':;:;§ '{;;.f7¥ ractéipz of cmpy <31? Lhiax order} :E1V,; 15Eh.¢r semd €..a§.k.c: back the '"?<:>e:>§'<:EaW fur" ther m<i>.mt..§f:E.~; Of Jam-'3 3} 3-V'Eil.'A§',{..€€'i'?._'Vffi%:EfrtE.1:1Ci§f1é)éA ighe e'::13t'§g"<;': a.m1€.mnt z"e':e:<:é3:§:c§ 'ELZW _.?.*.s.i.?T:1j;% within 2:
gr:-:'§"is:)c3. e">f':i",2%§§:&€%;1":::5:i§s":,:':V£i'";s:: ifrkign §'E3*€3tE:'i[3'{ 0? €LTfV}§_3!:'§: m§ thég :::}:°{€*::%:V;cj. V. Mt: 3-md Eléiikfif back. éma T:;<§:§;§a--E r€::3a;'-::°v<a:<:i {€22 E'.§1€*. 2'"f:1E3§.)€}1"1dt§1'"1tE~f« ta :;@§V§"*.f';hé@_ "E{é§<;'rfi,a;E" .:3:€:,:ppi£<:e:i by the ;>e:ti'Eii<:::m?:s" fm" 'iihcé. ..:*;:z{)m;i"*::3 s;[:>t";H;2--:z?1;<:=:, JL1ij_\,g f\&,1g'L}€~3*E. atmcti Sapiaznaiswr, in :3 ;:»L1%t:;}i{t §.'alLE.f;¥L;i'tZ"3§'1'.;f.3:f'iC§ the: armyunt. E"f3&i.:U&§€3(§ {ram the: aazszitt 32:; above " --.:&,jhz:££E« __€ié<€§f.)h:;=,iI;£i:L"§ in a nzxtiimaiésed ba:1'?~:. ¥TJis3i3'L1.m¢3r:1=:'~:z1§ hf t%;<-A: sa::'1£::§ 2-.a.1'm.>u;m wit}: aa<:<:1*u€:d inmrmst tE3e::'€;;r<m i8 mmeiiis A , EsL2;bu'15"e:*.<':'{. :15; 'EM: rs:s«mift :13? Ehezc :.>i.\.vam:i o§1:§1<s: :«;n"E:>it;:*a':'U::>:"A by V' :EEé:
iii} The fr;;rfeit:,u"c3 {>5 the saecuriiy aiepoéait Im a sum <3?
E:€3.f:*,3*51,0UG//""? bie%1(:}s: Ei:~1€::.i:3.g 63.? the: p<%titi0nc:r_--.§§§2:'1d it'1iE.:ie1ii0r1 <3? c:1"im.ima2 prwctestdinga in ierrrzxss mi' 1.151077. 'TtZ.§:i"€'.':1.,€'?.:"I'1.".V£-'3V.'?;_' A£1.t'1€*:X"i;iT€:'~V (Er: W.§".N<:}.€f3ExE?8/i20€)9) its §<Z{Z"_'§'3t-'_.:E::IF:'§I umil i,.lr1<~2 <'i1?:3pm.~;:;*z} of' {.319 E'-i"i"bi1L.§"a<'E.i't';:r3."»E..fp§"{i).i1€i{i*(§§i" amggfsg is;
mazfévs. 53u1':;j€<3t: "E10 éfhe m:.m 0f' '§i1@";=.wvé:;_§g"{"i" 'Qf ii}:.s: arb.£§.re:fm~: iv} E? T§"§€': §3@f;i.1:?;e.m{::r fame; in 8.'}.;'b?:£%iE%§Zi§?}:'év:V"%Z¥Egf{})ViZ:€?ff'.l'i'i;"£'1§3.j5-3 'w:é§.;hi.:?s 2'2, pctrézyd mi' 'E..h_1§<~:e £'I."J¥LV":,§['}_:'.':.E£.i"V:1A-:'*';..ff'é)§'?': 'E:ET.1'€':" r*<:<:s:ip$, 5:?" (30§_}}*" of E:}f1;.:~3 €3:"<i%3f,; -_m"¢': [email protected]:.<% Em §_":X.'"<i}€"jE?€?:di \»viV§};-1'. §.h<: -. swith the in [T£1E1T}EiTI§§.).?T3 . ':§'1IT1vI"J.':t":'g~'s"'"i:,§-3ffV*E*.4- V' N0.€:'sE; 1 78/ 2€;){L>'{~.'£}. W A P . N:;3 . €f5'€>.§V"?E%€.;/ 230"? ":~.>.'zj.Aé:;91V<::': '~L¥.g €7i§ :~:;g:§§:ia:3c:d (sf, z::C<:c3rdimg2;§y. Na"; t--:<:'>5~:$m~T:w