Central Administrative Tribunal - Jabalpur
Nikhilesh Chatterjee vs Pensions And Pensioners Welfare on 23 August, 2024
Reserved
(On 19.08.2024)
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
JABALPUR BENCH
JABALPUR.
Dated : This the 23rd day of _August_ 2024
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Akhil Kumar Srivastava, Member (J)
Hon'ble Mr. Kumar Rajesh Chandra, Member (A)
Original Application No. 966 of 2019
1. M.S. Chouhan S/o Shri D.S.Chauhan, aged 68 years,
H.No.1112/2, Near Raj Kirana Stores, Yadav Colony,
Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
2. Subir Sarkar S/o Shri B.B. Sarkar, aged 65 years, R/o 723.
A/1 Hathital, Near Good Luck Apartment, Gupteshwar,
Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
3. Shyam Shankar Dave, S/o late Shri Gulab Shankar Dave,
aged about 68 years, R/o State Bank Colony, Single Story.
Opposite Cyber Junction, Ukhri Road, Baldeo Bagh,
Jabalpur (M.P.) 482002.
4. Omkar Prasad Tiwari, S/o late Gouri Shankar Tiwari, aged
about 68 years, R/o Madhukar Shah Ward, Yadav Colony,
Tehsili Road Near Dr. Choubey Hospital, Sagar (M.P.)
470002.
5. Mahendra Kumar Chaurasiya S/o Shri Mohanlal
Chaurasiya, aged 64 years, Rio Near Shivji Temple,
Chaurasiya Farsh, Tilli Ward, Sagar (M.P.)
6. Himmat Lal Choudhari, S/o late Shri Hari Ram Choudhari,
aged about 65 years, R/o Near Jama Rahatgarh Bus
Stand, Baisa Mohalla, Shaheed Bhagat Singh Ward, Sagar
(M.P). 470002.
7. Smt. Lata Sonkar W/o late Shri Rajaram Sonkar, aged 68
years, Rio House No. 282/3, Near Sharda Mandir Madiya,
Vithal Nagar Ward, Sagar (M.P.) 470001.
1
8. Niranjan Singh, S/o late Shri R.P.Singh, aged about 74
years, R/o MIG 155, Shanti Vihar Colony, Makroniya,
Sagar (Μ.Ρ.), 470004.
9. Smt. Babli Dhir W/o late Shri Prem Mohan Dhir, aged about
65 years, Rio House No. 1700, Opposite Gayatri Bhawan,
Gupteshwar, Jabalpur (M.P.)
10. Smt. Dorothy Kerkette, W/o Shri I. Kerkette, aged 65 years,
R/o House No. 15, Bungalow No. 5A/2, 5, Narmada Road,
Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001
11. A.K.Sonone S/o T.R.Sonone, aged about 64 years, R/o
2074, Jai Bhim Nagar, Near Nagrath School, Narmada
Road, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
12. Arun Kumar Murab, S/o late A.L.Murab, aged 67 years, R/o
House No. 448, Near Bhole Baba Kuti, Shakti Nagar,
Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
13. Ashok Kumar Garg, S/o late Shri D.R.Garg, aged 67 years,
R/o Ward No. 13, Shahpura, Bhitoni, District Jabalpur
(M.P).
14. Subhash Chand Yadava, S/o late Shri CP. Yadava, aged
64 years, R/o House No. 594/1, Behind Samdadiya
Complex, Ghamapur Chowk. Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
15. Smt. Martina Tirkey, W/o Shri Nabore Tirkey, aged 64
years, R/o House No. 361/3B, Ramnagar, Rampur,
Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.).
16. S.C. Billore S/o Shri S.K. Billore aged 64 years, R/o Krishi
Upaj Mandi, Jabalpur (M.P.)
17. Chunnilal Kapoor S/o late K.L. Kapoor, aged about 67
years, R/o House No. 139, Street No.6, Sadar Bazar,
Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
18. R. S. Chandel. S/o R.B.S. Chandel, aged about 68 years,
R/o 1814, South Civil Lines, Govind Bhawan, Jabalpur
(M.P.) 482001.
19. Smt. Kamla Roy Choudhary, W/o Shri Roy Choudhary.
aged about 64 years, R/o H. No. 102. Behind Punjab &
Sind Bank, Suhagi, Maharajpur, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
2
20. Govind Das Ben, S/o Late Bhopal Ben, aged 63 years, R/o
29, Kawardha House, Near 2nd Bridge, Cantt Jabalpur
(Μ.Ρ.) 482001.
21. SK Choubey, s/o late Laxmi Prasad Choubey, aged 68
years, R/o 479, Shanti Nagar, Damoh Naka, Jabalpur
(M.P.)
22. Balmukund Mishra s/o late P.N. Mishra, aged About 68
years, R/o Near Kali Mai Mandir, New RamNagar, Adhartal
Jabalpur (M.P.) 482004
23. Ram Kumar s/o Shri Bhagwandas Soni, aged 60 years R/o
House No.12, Samdariya Colony, Kesri Nagar, Manegaon,
Ranjhi, Jabalpur(M.Ρ.) 482005
24. K.R. Satpute, s/o late Prahlad Satpute, aged about 68
Years, R/o House No. 89, Behind Kesri Nagar, Manegaon,
Ranjhi, Jabalpur(M.P.) 482005
25. B.K.Bhattacharya s/o late Shri A.C. Bhattacharya, aged 65
years, R/o House No. 1501, D.D.Colony, Behind Kesri
Nagar, Manegaon Ranjhi, Jabalpur (M.P.). 482005
26. Pramod Kumar Shrivastava s/o Late Shri R.R. Shrivastava,
aged about 65 years, R/o 2B, M.R.4, Janki Nagar, Ekta
Chowk, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482002.
27 Maroof Ahmed Khan, s/o late G.A.Khan, aged 66 years,
R/o MIG 95, Mew Anand Nagar Colony, Adhartal, Jabalpur
(Μ.Ρ.) 482004
28. Narayan Prasad Tiwari, S/o Late P.L.Tiwari, aged 65 years,
R/o M 36, Sharda Colony, Shakti Nagar, Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)
482001
29. Prem Kant Mishra, S/o Shri B.N. Mishra, aged 69 years,
R/o 790, Near Karamyogi Atta Chakki, Kamala Nehru Ward
Sneh Nagar, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482002
30. Narayan Prasad Sharma, S/o Shri Ranbir Sharma, aged 63
Years, R/o Quarter No. 196/3, Vidya Nagar, GCF Estate,
Gokulpur, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482011.
31. Madan Mohan Soni, S/o Shri Ratan Lal Soni, aged about
61 Years, R/o H.No. 389. Street No. 15, Shanti Nagar,
Damoh Naka, Baldeobagh, Jabalpur, (M.P.) 482002
3
32. Smt. Krishna Bai Jharia. W/o Shri Ganesh Prasad Jharia,
aged about 61 Years, R/o H.No. 1828, Gupteshwar, Kripal
Chowk, Behind Dr. Kamla Gupta, Madan Mahal, Jabalpur
(M.P.) 482001.
33. Rama Shanker Katare, S/o Shri Brindavan Katare, aged
about 61 Years, R/o 1089/p-1. Indra Gandhi Ward, Shukla
Nagar, Garha, Purwa, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482003
34. Ramesh Chandra Jha, S/o Shri Thakkan Jha, aged about
69 Years, R/o H.No. 978, Saket Extention, Champa Nagar,
Manegaon, Khamaria, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482005.
35. Sunder Lal Dubey, S/o Shri Jagannath Prasad Dubey,
aged about 68 Years, R/o H.No. 1514, Gopal Hotel,
Dwarka Nagar Ward, Lalmati, Lamti, Jabalpur (M.P.)
482001.
36. Satish Kumar Malviya, S/o Shri Ram Narayan Malviya, R/o
S/2 Gulmohar Apartment, Russel Chowk, Near School
Napier Town, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001
37. Sant Lal Raikwar S/o Late Shri Madhav Prasad Raikwar,
aged about 69 Years, R/o H.No. 2428, opposite Perfect
Factory, Gwarighat Road, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001
38. Sadhan Kumar Chatterjee, S/o Shri Motilal Chatterjee,
Aged about 61 Years, R/o B-II, 306, Anmol Height, New
Ram Nagar, Amkhera, Adhartal, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482004.
39. Mahesh Prasad Tiwari, S/o Shri B.P. Tiwari, aged about 71
Years, R/o H.No. 559/2, Sujipura, Post Office Milloniganj,
Baldevbagh, Ranital, Jabalpur, (M.P.) 482001.
40. Dilip Kumar Banerjee, S/o Shri Nagendra Nath Banerjee,
aged about 62 Years, R/o H.No. 1155/A 1, Samiksha
Town, Savitri Vihar, Lamheti, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
41. Ramesh Kumar Saini, S/o Shri R.S.Saini, aged about 62
years R/o Near Kali Mai Mandir, New Ram Nagar, Adhartal
Jabalpur (M.P.) 482004.
42. Pradeep Kumar Dubey S/o Shri Rewa Prasad Dubey, aged
about 67 Years, R/o Near Anand Nagar Post Office, H.No.
574, Chitranjan Ward, Ashok Nagar, Jabalpur (M.P.)
482007
4
43. Ram Kumar Dubey S/o Parasram Dubey, aged about 61
years, R/o 108, Metro Ashiyana, Bagli Road, Near Sardar
Patel Vidyalaya, Misraud, Huzur, Bhopal 462047 (Μ.Ρ.).
44. Santosh Kumar Swami S/o Premnarayan Swami, aged
about 61 years, R/o Quarter No. 3019, Type-3, Ayudh
Nagar, Pandari, Itarsi, Sukhtawa, Hoshangabad (M.Ρ.)
461111.
45. Narendra Kumar Vyas S/o Shrinarayan Vyas, aged about
63 years Kothi Bazar, Near Collectorate, Ward No. 08,
Krishna Colony, Hoshangabad 461001 (M.P.).
46. Arvind Kumar Garg, S/o Nand Kishore Garg, aged about 61
years R/o EWS 422, Nyas Colony, Itarsi, Hoshangabad
461111 (Μ.Ρ.).
.........Applicants
By Adv: Shri Munish Saini
Versus
1. Union of India, through the Secretary, Ministry of Defence,
South Block, New Delhi-110001
2. Controller General, Defence Accounts, Ulan Bator Road,
Palam Cantonment, New Delhi 110010
3. Controller of Defence Accounts, Ridge Road, Pachpedi,
Jabalpur-482001
4. General Manager, Gun Carriage Factory, Jabalpur (M.P.)
482001
5. General Manager, Grey Iron Factory, Jabalpur (M.P.)
482001
6. General Manager, Ordnance Factory, Khamaria, Jabalpur
(Μ.Ρ.) 482001
7. General Manager, Ordnance Factory, Itarsi, Hoshangabad
(Μ.Ρ.) 461111
. . . Respondents
By Adv: S.P. Singh
Alongwith
5
Original Application No. 878 of 2023
1. Ramesh Chandra Chawda S/O Shri Khemrajji Chawda,
Aged about 62 years, Retired Asstt. Office Superintendent
(G), R/O Cheeta Kheda, Nai Abadi, Neemuch (MP)-458441
2. Ashok Patidar S/O Shri Khyaliram Patidar, Aged about 58
Years, Retired Asstt. Office Superintendent (G), R/O
Village & Post- Alhed, Tahsil-Manasa, District- Neemuch,
Neemuch (MP)-458001
3. Sunder Lal Rathore, S/o Late Shri Kanhiyalal, Aged about
63 years, Retired Asstt. Office Superintendent (G), R/O H.
No. 28, Bheem Nagar, Gwarighat Road, Jabalpur (MP)-
482008
...Applicants
By Adv: Shri J.B. Singh
Versus
1. Chairman cum Managing Director, Bharat Sanchar Nigam
Limited, HC Mathur Lane, Janpath, New Delhi-110 001
2. Chief General Manager, BSNL, M.P. Telecom Circle, BSNL
Bhavan, Hoshangabad Road, Bhopal-462015
3. Controller of Communication Accounts, Department of
Telecommunications, 1st Floor, Doorsanchar Bhavan,
Bhopal-462015
4. District Telecom Manager, BSNL, District Mandsaur (MP)-
458008
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh and Shri P.K. Chaurasia
Alongwith
6
Original Application No. 1068 of 2023
1. Subir Kumar Sengupta, Sr Divisional Signal & Telecom
Engineer(Retd), West Central Railway, Jabalpur, aged
about 67 years s/o Shri Anil Ranjan Sengupta, R/o Flat No.
A, 103, First Floor, Kaushalya Exotica, Near Kachnar City,
Vijaya Nagar, Jabalpur( Μ.Ρ.) 482 002.
2. Gaya Prasad Mishra, Retd Dy Chief Engineer, PCE's
Oftice, G M Building, West Central Railway, Jabalpur, aged
about 67 years S/o Shri Radha Charan Mishra, R/o House
No. 22, Kundan Residency, 4th Mile, Mandla Road,
Jabalpur (M.P.). 482001
3. Vinai Kumar Sharma, s/o late Shri Vishwanath Sharma, Dy
Chief Signal & Telecom Engineer, PCSTE's Office, GM GM
Building, West Central Railway, Jabalpur, aged about 70
years, R/o B 40, Saikar Uday, Phase -1, Tulsi Nagar,
Cherital, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001
4. Khukhnoo Prasad Vishwakarma, PS-1 (Retd) to to PCOM
later on re-engaged and attached to Hon'ble GM, West
Central Railway, aged about 66 years, s/o late Shri Ganesh
Prasad Vishwakarma, R/o House No. 2118, Near
Kanchanpur, Adhartal, Jabalpur (M.P.) ५82001
5. Jugal Kishore Tiwari, Asstt Electrical Engineer (Retd).
Electrical Branch - HQrs, GM Office Building, West Central
Railway, Jabalpur, aged about 70 years, s/o late Shri
S.K.Tiwari, R/oc/o K.K.Tiwari, House No. 1922, Vijaya
Nagar, Opposite Survey of India Office, Vijaya Nagar
Colony, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482002
6. Shekher lyer, Retd PS-2/Steno, PFA's Office, GM Office
Building, West Central Railway, Jabalpur, aged about 62
years R/o Flat No. 307. Samdadiya Apartment, Civil Lines,
Jabalpur (M.P.). 482001
7. Shri Kohil Bhaskaran, Retd Mail Guard, abalpur, aged
about 66 years, s/o K. Alawar, R/o Sainik Society Road,
7
Shakti Nagar, Gupteshwar, 166-A, Opposite Little Step
School, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
8. Om Prakash Tamrakar, Retd Mail Guard, Saugor, aged
about 65 years, s/o Ghanshyam Das Tamrakar,R/o MIG -1,
129, Deen Dayal Nagar, Gambheeriya, Saugor (M.P.)
470004.
9. Karna Bahadur Thapa, Retd Mail Guard, Jabalpur, R/o
Hariram Sadan, aged about 72 years, Plot No.50, Maa
Narmada Nagar, Phase -2, Bilahari, Jabalpur (M.P.)
482001
10. Mohd Israil Khan, Retd Mail Express Guard, aged about 71
years R/o c/o Gul Mohammad, 120/1, Phutera Ward No.3,
Gowri Shankar Ward No. 28, Damoh Khas, Damoh -
470661(Μ.Ρ.)
11. Manohar Singh Rajput, Retd Goods Yard, New Katni
Junction, aged about 70 years, R/oC/o RS. Thakur, 62,
Galla Mandi Road, Gaya Datt Ward, Narsinghpur (M.P.)
487001.
12 Hargovind Jatav s/o Shyamlal Jatav, aged about 66 years,
Retd Mail Guard, R/o 25-B, Vaishali Nagar, Near Park,
Damoh (M.P.) 470661.
13. Shri Ram Saiyyam s/o Bhangilal Saiyyam, Retd Mail
Express Guard, aged about 68 years, r/o Ward No. 13.
Shastri Ward, Mandla, Bamhani Banjar, Tharka Bamhani,
Mandla (M.Ρ.). 481771.
14 Mukesh Baderriya, Retired Mail Guard, Katni. aged about
63 years s/o late Bhogchand Baderiya, r/o Shyamaprasad
Mukherji Ward No. 36, Sai Shruti, Near NKJ Saurabh
Kirana, Murwara Katni (M.P.) 483501
15. Mohammad Ameen, Retd Mail Guard, Jabalpur, aged
about 60 years, s/o Mohd Shafi, r/o 75/11, Peer ji Ka
Bagicha Compound, Cantonment, Sadar Bazar, Jabalpur
(M.P.) 482001
8
16 Bal Chand Jain, Retd Mail Guard, Katni, aged about 70
years s/o late Guljari Lal Jain, R/o House No. 613,
Ambedkar Ward No. 18, Gayatri Nagar, R.K.Singh Gali,
Murwara-Katni (MP) 483501
17. Ravi Kand Acharya, Retd Choiel Trains Clerk, Jabalpur,
aged about 66 years s/o late Shri CS Acharya, R/o Jai
Narayan ka Bada, Near VishalHospital, Ghamapur,
Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001
18. Ashok Diwan Retd Chief Trains Clerk(HQrs), West Central
Railway, Jabalpur, aged about 68 years s/o R.K.Diwan, R/o
259-14, Ghani Chowki, Nadi Vaidya Shukla Gali. Maharaja
Agrasen Ward, Baghraji, Jabalpur (M.P.). 2001
19. Rakesh Mishra, Chief Controller (Retd) HQrs- Central
Control, Jabalpur, aged about 62 years, s/o late Shyam
Sundar Mishra r/o Adarsh Vihar Complex, Cherital,
Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001
20. G.C. Vazirani, Station Supdtt. (Retd) Katni, aged about 71
years s/o late Hira Chand Vazirani, R/o Jagmohandas
Ward No.10, Shambhu Talkies Road, Sant Nagar, West
Murwara, Katni (M.P.) 483 501
21. Rajesh Kumar Sharma, Station Master-1 (Retd) aged about
70 years, s/o Teluram Sharma, R/o Gali No. 2. Shastri
Colony, Chakki Ghat, Rajiv Gandhi Ward No. 13, Murwara-
Katni (M.P.). 483501.
22 Chandra Bhan Soni, Station Supdtt., (Retd) Katni, aged
about 69 years, Adharkup, Murwara Katni (M.P.) 483501.
23 Sushil Kumar Jha, Station Supdtt (Retd) Katni, aged about
66 years, s/o Shri Nabonath Jha, R/o House No. 150/151,
Vinobha Bhave Ward No.15, Rahul Bag, Mai Nadi ke Paar,
Gokul Dham, Katni (M.P.). 483 501 (Μ.Ρ.).
9
24. Anil Kumar Shrivastava, Retd Mail Express Guard, Katni,
aged about 67 years s/o late Vijaya Shankar Shrivastava,
R/o House No. 1267, Ram Janki Hanuman Ward No.18,
Roshan Nagar, near III College, Murwara-Katni (M.P.).
483501.
25. Pradeep Kumar Shrivastava Retd Mail Express Guard,
Katni, aged about 67 years s/o late Shri S.V Shrivastava,
R/o Rajiv Gandhi Ward, Near Dr Tarey Gali, Murwara-
Katni (M.P.) 483501
26. Suraj Bali Thakur, Retd Mail Express Guard, Retd Mail
Guard, Katni, aged about 67 years, s/o late Shri Ram Muni
Thakur R/o Ward No. 17, Bajrang Colony, New Katni
Junction, Murwara-Katni (M.P.) 483501.
27. Sheikh Nawab, Retd Mail Express Guard, aged about63
years, S/o late Sheikh Farid, R/o Maa Ganj Ward No. 5,
Near Railway Vidyalaya, Damoh (MP) 470661.
28. Ram Suchit Singh, Retd Mail Express Guard, Katni, aged
about 60 years s/o late Sudama Singh R/o Jain Colony,
Gali No.7, New Katni Junction, Distt-Katni - (M.P.) 483 501
29. Ajay Shankhwar Retd Mail Express Guard, Katni, aged
about 60 years s/o D.P. Sankhwar, R/o 48, Rochlani
Chauraha, New Basti, Katni Murwara, Katni(M.P.) 483501.
30. Sunil Loyal, Master Craftsman, (MCM) Retd, Diesel Shed,
New Katni Junction, aged about 61 years, s/o late
S.H.Loyal, R/o Railway Colony, Ballabh Bhai Patel Ward
No. 19, Roshan Nagar, Katni (M.P.). 4835-01
31. Prahlad Kumar, Loco Shunter, (Retd) Diesel Loco Shed,
New Katni Junction, aged about 67 years s/o Hiralal
Khushwaha, RB Type 1. 28/H. Railway Colony, Civil Lines,
Maharani Laxmui Ward, Murwara, Katni( M.P.). 483501.
32 G.L. Jaiswal, Ch OS (Retd), Sr Section Engineer(Electrical
Maintenance), New Katni Junction, aged about 70 years
s/o late Shyamlal Jaiswal, House No. 49, Rubber Factory
10
Road, Rajiv Gandhi Ward, Seeta Ram Goyanka Colony,
Murwara - Katni (M.P.). ५83501
33 Suresh Kumar, Fitter Grade I(Retd) AC Loco TRS Shed,
New Katni Junction, aged about 63 years s/o Mittamal
Sahni, R/o Near Over Bridge, Ashok Colony, Katni (M.P.)
483501
34. Shashikant Shukla s/o late Shriman Narayan Shukla, aged
about 70 years, Sr Section Engineer, (Electrical) (Retired)
Central Railway, Pune, presently residing at House No.16,
Behind Shelbee Hospital, Ahinsa Chowk, Jabalpur (M.P.).
482001
35. K.K.Sahu, Sr Section Engineer(TRD), Retd Jabalpur, aged
about 62 years s/o late A.L.Sahu R/o 56-A, Shanti Vila,
Sant Santaji Colony, Ahinsa Chowk, Vijaya Nagar,
Maharaja Agrasen Ward, Jabalpur (M.P.). 482002
36. C.P.Agrawal, Sr Section Engineer (TRD), Jabalpur, aged
about 62 Years, R/o Wright Town, P & T Workshop, Pandit
Bhawani Prasad Ward, Jabalpur (M.P.) 420002
37. Arwind Kumar Shukla, Sr Section Engineer(Works) Retired
Jabalpur, aged about 62 years s/o late Shri Ram Gulam
Shukla, R/o 56, Sai Colony, Near Deen Dayal Chowk,
Deen Dayal Ward, Jabalpur (M.P.) 82001
38 Awdhesh Kumar Porwal, Sr Section Engineer (Works) (
Retd), West Central Railway, Satna, aged about 62 years,
s/o late Shri R. C.N.Porwal, r/o House No. 16, Navikar
Colony, Pant Nagar Ward, Saugor (M.P.). 470001
39. Daya Prakash Shrivastava, Sr Section Engineer(Works)
Retired, Jabalpur, aged about 62 years s.o late Prem
Chand R/o Plot No.22, Sai Colony, Sanjeevni Nagar,
Garha, Jabalpur (M.P.). 482001
40. Madan Gopal, Sr Black Smith, Retired under Sr Section
Engineer (P.Way) Khurai), aged about 62 years c/o
11
Mangilal Ward No.22, Shrimat Seth Rishabh Kumar, Khurai
- Saugor ( Μ.Ρ.). 472117.
41. Tulsi Ram, Helper Khalasi under Section Engineer(Works)
Saugor, aged about 61 years, R/o Mangilal Ward No.22,
Shrimat Seth Rishabh Kumar, Khurai - Saugor (M.P.).
472117.
42. Hansraj Singh, Chief OS (Retd), AEN(East), West Central
Railway, Katni, aged about 61 years s/o Dhanesh Singh,
R/o Village Kothara, Post Dagdeeha, Dagdiha, Satna
(M.P.) 485 221.
43. S.K.Kundu, Sr Section Engineer(P.Way Relaying) Retired
under Asstt Engineer, (Maint) Katni), aged 62 years R/o R-
1-4, Ambedkar Ward, Guman Singh Gali, Gayatri Nagar
Murwara - Katni (M.P.). 483501.
44. Sunil Tekchandani, OS II (Personnel) Retd, aged about 63
years s/o late A.S.Tekchandani, R/o 265, Gali No.11,
Shanti Nagar, Near Gurudwara Rajiv Gandhi Ward,
Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001
45. Ajay Kumar Shrivastava, Sr Section Engineer (C&W)Retd.
aged about 63 years, Shri Surendra Prasad Lal, R/o House
No. 1126/B, Jai Prakash Nagar, near CBSE School,
Adhartal, Amkhera, Jabalpur (M.P.) 402001
46. Shambhu Prasad Gupta, Sr Section Engineer) C&W), Retd,
aged about 60 years, s/o Nanak Prasad Gupta, New Katni
Junction, Nayagaon Ward No.36, Katni (M.P.) 483501
47. Rajesh Kumar Jain, St Section Engineer (C & W) Satna,
aged about 62 years s/o Hukum Chand Jain R/o Gali No.5,
Prem Vihar Colony, Raghuraj Nagar, SAtna (MP) 485001.
48. Ram Kumar, Sr Tech(Welder) (MCM), aged about 62
years, s/o Jageshwar Prasad Sondhia, Near Holy Child
School, Gali No.4, Prem Vihar Colony, Raghuraj Nagar,
Satna (M.P.) 485001
12
49. Motilal, Technician, Fitter I, aged about 62 years s/o
Mahadev Yadav, House No. 1305/B, Adhartal, Uma Nagar,
Jabalpur (M.P.). 482001
50. Manju Vishwakarma, Retd Accounts Asstt., aged about 71
years, wife of Ishwar Das Vishwakarma, R/o 796, Maatra
Chhaya, Garha Phatak, Behind Chhoti Maszid, Near
Kasturba Ward, Jabalpur (MP) 462001
51. Kishanlal Yadav, Retd Mail Guard Katni, aged about 75
years s/o Bhagwan Das Yadav, R/o Roshan Nagar, Near
Guru Kripa School, Rafi Ahmaed Kidwai Ward No. 15,
Murwara Katni (M.P.) 483501.
52. O.P. Yadav, Retd Mail Guard, Jabalpur, aged about 71
years, s/o Shri Dwarka Prasad Yadav, 102, Aakriti
Apartment, Mariyam, Chowk, South Civil Lines, Jabalpur
(M.P.) 482001
53. Suresh Chand Sahu, Painter (Retd) under Sr Section
Engineer(Elect-Maintenance), aged about 66 years, s/o
Ramnath Sahu, No. 576, Sidh Baba Road, Kariya Pathar.
Thhakkar Gram, Jabalpur-482 001 (M.P.)
54. Shyam Babu Shrivastava, Retd Sr Section
Engineer(Signals) Ratlam, aged about 63 years, s/o Om
Prasad Shrivastava, House No. 569, Maharaja Agrasen
Ward, Behind Joy School, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482 002
55. Shyamlal Baurasi, Retd Section Engineer (Elect), Retd-
Ratlam, aged aboiurt 64 years c/o Ramnath Baurasi, R/o
No.8, Parshuram Vihar Colony, Near Medical College,
Ratlam (M.P.). 457001
56. Virendra Kumar Mathur, Sr Technician(Power) Retd, aged
about 61 years. Ratlam, s/o Mangilal Mathur, No.20, New
Globus City, Ratlam 457 001 (M.P.).
57. Kishanlal (Vadhwa), Sr Technician (Train Lighting). Retd-
Ratlam (M.P.), aged about 64 years s/o Hari Chandra
13
Wadhwa, No. 15, TIT Road, Near Old Dak Bungalow,
Ratlam (M.P.). 457001.
58. Suresh Chand Vyas, Asstt Divisional Finance Manager, s/o
Ratanlal Vyas, aged about 67 years, R/oc/o Ratanlal Vyas,
81, VTC, Manglam City, VTC, P.O. Ratlam, Sub Distt Alot,
Distt - Ratlam (M.P.). 457001
59. Subhash Chand Vyas, Retd Station Supdtt., Ratlam, aged
about 72 years, s/o Ratanlal Vyas, aged about 67 years,
R/o c/o Ratanlal Vyas, 81, VTC, Manglam City, VTC, Р.О.
Ratlam, Sub Distt Alot, Distt - Ratlam (M.P.) 457001
60. Rajendra B. Agrawal, Asstt Divisional Finance Manager
(Retd), aged about 64 years, s/o Bhagwandas Agrawal, R/o
25, Jaora Road, Mahavir Nagar, Near Pani ki Tanki,
Ratlam, Alot, Distt-Ratlam (M.P.). 457001.
61. Veena Chauhan, Section Officer (Retd) Ratlam, aged about
69 years, c/o Komal Singh, behind Anand Bazar, 402,
Prime View 74-75, Baikunth Dham, Indore (M.P.) 452001.
62. M.A.Robert, Lab Technician (Retd) Railway Hospital,
Ratlam, aged about 71 years, s/o Aric John Robert, House
No. N 32/ TIT-2, Ward No.2, Indra Nagar, Ratlam (M.P.).
457001
63. Manoharlal, Sr Technician (Retd) Ratlam, aged about 62
years, s/o Mohan Lal, R/o MIG 6, Deora Dev Narayan,
Ratlam (M.P.) 457001
64. Suresh Kumar Goren, Mail Guard (Retd) Ratlam, aged
about 60 years, s/o Kashi Ram Gouran, R/o 15/9, Gandhi
Nagar, Near Ambedkar Bhavan, Ratlam-457001
65. Mahesh Mathur, Chief Trains Clerk, Ratlam, VRS on
30.06.2021, s/o Vinayak Lal Mathur, No. 10, Near Shiv
Mandir, Ganesh Nagar, Ratlam (M.P.). 45700/
14
66. Gopal Rao, Mail Guard (Retd) Ratlam, aged about 60
years, s/o Govind Rao, 54 P & T Colony Gali No. 5 Ratlam
MP 457001.
67. Ramphal, S/o Daddi Prasad Choudharuy, aged about 63
years, Khirhani Fatak, Murwara, Katni MP 483001.
...Applicants
By Adv: Shri Munish Saini
Versus
1. Union of India through General Manager, West Central
Railway, Indira Market, Jabalpur (MP) - 482001.
2. Principal Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer, Ewst
Central Railway, Indira Market, Jabalpur (MP) - 482001.
3. Sr Divisional Finance Manager, DRM Office Building,
Jabalpur (M.P.). 482 001
4. Union of India through General Manager, Central Railway.
(Old Victoria Terminus Building Now Chhatrapati Shivaji
Maharaj Terminus, Mumbai (Maharashtra State) 400 001
5. Principal Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer,
Central Railway, Third Floor, New Annex Building.
Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj Terminus, Mumbai
(Maharashtra State) 400 001
6. Sr Divisional Finance Manager, Central Railway, Pune
(MS) 411011
7. Union of India through General Manager, Western Railway,
Church Gate Station Building, Mumbai (Maharashtra State)
400 020
8. Principal Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer,
Western Railway, Church Gate Station Building, Mumbai
(Maharashtra State) 400 020
9. Sr Divisional Finance Manager. Western Railway, Ratlam
(M.P.) 457001
....Respondents
15
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 1108 of 2023
Shri Alwart, S/o late Shri Madurai Swami, a/a 65 years,
Occupation: Retd. Government Employee, R/o H. No. 203, Bajpai
Compuund, Befoe Chruch Ground, Sadar Cantt, Jabalpur (MP)
482001.
....Applicant
By Adv: Shri Akash Choudhury
Versus
1. Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of Defence,
Government of India, South Block, New Delhi - 110001.
2. Director General Ordnance, Directorate of Ordnance
(Coordination & Services), 10-A, S.K. Bose Road, Kolkata
700001 (WB).
3. Sr. General Manager, Ordinance Factory Khamariya,
Jabalpur (MP) 482005.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 1116 of 2023
1. Kailash Chandra Jain, s/o Shri Lakhan Lal Jain, a/a 64
years, Occupation - Retired I.G. of Police, R/o H. No. 67,
Shriram Colony, Hoshangabad Road, Bhopal (MP) 462026.
2. Girija Kishor Pathak, A/o Shri Hari Dutt Pathak, a/a 64
years, Occupation Retired I.G. of Police, R/o 37, Dev Lok
Farms, Lane No. 2 , E-8 Extension Area Colony, Bhopal
(MP) 462039.
16
....Applicants
By Adv: Shri Anshul Tiwari
Versus
1. Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of Home
Affairs, North Block, New Delhi - 110001.
2. Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions,
Department of Personnel and Training (DOPT) through its
Secretary, North Block New Delhi - 110001.
3. The State of Madhya Pradesh, through its Additional Chief
Secretary, Department of Home, Mantralaya, Vallab
Ghawan, Bhopal (MP) - 462001.
4. The Director General of Police, State of Madhya Pradesh,
Police Headquarters, Jehangirabad, Bhopal (MP) 462008.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri Diresh Jain and Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 1135 of 2023
1. Virendra Singh Thakur, S/o Late Shri K.R. Thakur, Retired
MCM, a/a 72 years, R/o H. No. 332, Anjani Colony,
Richhai, Jabalpur (MP) 482010.
2. Ram Bihari Chaturvedi, S/o late Shri Ram Kishore
Chaturvedi, a/a 71 years, Retired Chargeman NT, R/o H.
No. 16, Trimurti Nagar, Krishna Colony, Jabalpur - 482002.
... Applicants
By Adv: Shri J.B. Singh
17
Versus
1. Union of India, through Secretary, Ministry of Defence,
Department of Defence Production, 44, Block No. 7, Type
V, Lodhi Road Complex Delhi - 110003.
2. CMD, Armoured Vehicles Nigam Limited HVF Road,
Bhaktavatsalapuram, Avadi Chennai (TN) 600054.
3. General Manager, Vehicle Factory, Jabalpur - 482009.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 1169 of 2023
Guttoo Ram Chaudhary, S/o late Shri Thakuri, a/a 68 years,
Occupation: Retd. Government Employee, R/o H. No. 1288, Near
Primary School, Purani Basti Kajarwara, Jabalpur (MP) 482001.
....Applicant
By Adv: Shri Akash Choudhury
Versus
1. Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of Defence,
Government of India, South Block, New Delhi - 110001.
2. Directory General of Quality Assurance, Department of
Defence Production, DGQA/Admn, Ministry of Defence,
7(B) DHQ PO New Delhi - 110001.
3. Sr. Quality Assrance Officer, Estt. (Armts), Gun Carriage
Factory, Jabalpur (MP) - 482011.
4. General Manager, Gun Carriage Factory, Jabalpur (MP) -
482011.
...Respondents
18
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 277 of 2024
Rajendra Kumar Verma, a/a 64 years, S/o Late Shri C.L. Verma,
Retired OS 508, Army Base Workshop, Allahabad, R/o H. No.
249. Goshal Complex, Subhash Nagar, Manegaon, Khamaria,
Jabalpur 482001.
....Applicant
By Adv: Shri Anoop Nair
Versus
1. Union of India through the Secretary, Ministry of Personnel
Public Grievances & Pension, Department of Pension and
Pensioners' Welfare, Lok Nayak Bhawan, New Delhi -
110001.
2. The Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Defence Head Quarter,
South Block Man Singh Road, Area New Delhi - 110011.
3. The Directory General MEM, Army HQ, New Delhi -
110011.
4. The Commandant, 508, Army Base Workshop, Allahabad
(UP).0
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 272 of 2024
1. Dilip Kumar Roy, aged 68 years, S/o. Late B.C. Roy,
Retired JWM Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o. Mangal Nagar,
Katni. 483501
19
2. Prem Lal Panthi, aged 68 years S/o. Late Bhaiya Lal,
Retired MCM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o. Mangal Nagar,
Katni. 483501
3. Smt. Pushpa Sahu, aged 65 years, W/o.Late Ramesh
Prasad, Retired HS- 1, Ordnance Factory Katni,
R/o.Vivekanand Ward, Lakhera Katni 483501
4. Ashok Kumar Khare, aged 68 years, S/o. Late P.L. Khare,
Retired MCM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o. Near Tilak
College, NKJ Katni. 483.501
5. Triveni Prasad, aged 75 years, S/o. Late HP Paroha,
Retired MCM Ordnance Factory Katni, Ro Shivaji Nagar,
Katni. 483501
6. Kanyo Hamnani, aged 74 years, S/o Late V.M. Hemnani,
Retired JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Narayan Shah
Ward, Katni. 483501
7. Arvind Kumar Bhalerao, aged 68 yrs, S/o. Late M.G.
Bhalerao, Retired OS, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o. Ashok
Sharma Colony Katni 183501
8. Achhe Lal, aged 65 years. S/o. Late Bihari Lal, Retired HS-
1, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o. Vivekanand Ward,
Lakhera, Katni. 483501
9. Ayodhya Prasad Gupta, aged 76 years S/o. Late B.P.
Gupta, Retired CM-1, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.
Vivekanand Ward, Lakhera, Katni. 483501
10. Vijay Kumar Sharma, aged 67 years, S/o. Late Sohrai
Sharma, retired CM-1, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.
Mangal Nagar, Katni. 483501
11. Saiman Mannual, aged 67 years, S/o.Late Antony
Mannual, Retired MCM, Ordnance Factory Katni,
R/o.Mangal Nagar, Katni. 483501
20
12. Ram Kumar, aged 65 years, S/o.Late Jhallu Ram, Retired
HS-I, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o. Ram Manohar Lohia
Ward, Katni. 483501
13. Ram Bachan Prajapati, aged 65 years, S/o. Late Pebaru
Ram, Retired CM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.mangal
Nagar, Katni. 483.501
14. Ashok Kumar Rajak, aged 65 years, S/o.Late Nanku Rajak,
Retiored MCM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Mangal
Nagar, Katni. 483501
15. Vijay Kumar, aged 67 years, S/o.Late Bhura, Retired HS-I,
Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Near Gurudwara OF Katni.
483501
16. Mohammad Nisar, aged 67 years, S/o.Late Mohd. Ahmed
Hanfi, Retired CM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o. Near
Nagina Masjid, Katni. 483501
17. Umesh Kumar Shrivastava, aged 65 years, S/o.Late N. P.
Shrivastava, Retired JWM. Ordnance Factory Katni,
R/o.191, Dwarika city Katni. 485501.
18. Suresh Prasad Pyasi, aged 72 years, S/o. Late Ghasi Ram
Pyasi, retired JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Sanjay
Nagar, Katni. 483501
19. Kamlesh Ram, aged 72 years, S/o.Late Bechu, Retired
MCM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Mangal Nagar, Katni,
483501
20. Prem Kumar Sahajwani, aged 73 years, S/o. late R.C.
Sahajwani, Retired JTO, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Karin
Line, Madhav Nagar, Katni. 483501
21. Rodwil Das, aged 65 years, S/o.Late John Manohar Das,
Retired CM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Naya Gaon,
Lakhera, Katni. 483501
21
22. Anil Kumar Shrivastava, aged 66 years S/o.Late O.P.
Shrivastava, retired CM Ordnance Factory Katni,
R/o.Ashok Sharma Colony, Katni. 483501
23. Hari Lal, aged 68 years, S/o.Late Phool Chand, Retried
HS-I, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.New Bus Stand, Nadi
Par Katni. 483.501
24. Ram Das Gupta, aged 70 years, S/o.Late Kamta Ram
Gupta, Retired HTO/MC, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.
Vivekanand Ward, Lakhera Katni 463501
25. Raj Kumar, aged 67 years, S/o.Late Prem Lal Soni, retired
JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o Masurha Ward Purani
Basti Katni. 463501
26. Madho Prasad Saxena, aged 62 years, S/o.Late Bhola
Nath saxena, Retired JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni,
R/o.Dadda Dham, Katni 483501
27. Ramesh Singh, aged 64 years, S/o.late ASha Ram Singh,
Retired TGT, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Asha Nagar,
Hirwara Katni. 483501
28. Hari Shankar, aged 63 years, S/o.Late Shail Bihari, Retired
J. Durwan, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Gunda Ghat,
Katni. 483501
29. Sushil Kumar Tiwari, aged 63 years, S/o.Late D.K. Tiwari,
Retired CM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Adarsh Colony,
Katni. 483501
30. Deen Dayal Gupta, aged 63 years, S/o.Late K.P. Gupta,
Retired CM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o. Vivekanand
Ward, Lakhera, Katni 453501
31. Hari lal Sahu, aged 63 years, S/o.Sukh Lal Sahu, Retired
HS-II, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o. Durga Chowk, Badi
Khirahni, Katni. 483501
22
32. Aggan Ali, aged 68 years, S/o. Late Mohd Raza, Retired
HS-I, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Ashok Sharma Colony
Katni. 483501
33. Ravindra Prasad, aged 66 years, S/o.late Ram Bahal,
Retired JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Bilgawan
Hirwara Katni. 483501
34. Gauri Shankar Swarnakar, aged 66 years, S/o. Late G.P,
Swarnkar, retired JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni,
R/0.6/187, Masurha Ward Katni. 43351
35. Harinder Thakur, aged 63 years, S/o.Late Jagannath
Prasad, Retired J. Durwan, Ordnance Factory Katni,
R/o.Mangal Nagar, Katni. 483501.
36. Ram Chandra Kurup, aged 71 years, S/o.Late K.V.Kurup,
Retired OS, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.PO Kuttoor, Taluk
Thiruvalla Distt. Pathanamthitta, Kerala. 639 101
37. Smt. Akhilesh Shukla, aged 64 years, W/o.Late Ghan
Shyam Shukla, Retired JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni,
R/o.C- 1421, 12 Avenue Sector 16, Greater Noida 110025
38. Rajendra Kumar Agrawal, aged 62 years, S/o. M.C.
Agrawal, Retired JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni, Rio.Jai
Prakash Ward, Nai Basti, Katni. 483501
39. N.K. Sharma, aged 73 years, S/o. Late Shish Ram Sharma,
Retired JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o. Vivekananda
Ward, Katni. 483501
40. Narayan Prasad Shriwas, aged 64years, so. Late S.P.
Shriwas, Retired JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o. Badi
Khirahni Katni. 83501
41. Rajesh Kumar Singh, aged 64 years, So. Late Bichitra
Kumar, Retired CM. Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Naya
Gaon, Lakhera, Katni. 433601
23
42. Suresh Chandra Verma, aged 64 years, S/o Chhoti Lal
Verma, retired AGM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Chand
Pole Bazar, Jaipur. 302 00
43. Sharad Kumar Dubey, aged 64 years. S/o Late JN. Dubey,
Retired JWM. Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Mittal Nagar,
Kuthla, Katni 48351
44. Banshi Lal, aged 71 years. So Late Phool Chand, Retired
HS, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Shastri colony, Venkat
Ward, Katni. 483501
45. Narayan Das, aged 70 years, S/o.Late Takhat Ram,
Retired Med. Asstt. Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Bunglow
Line, Madhav Nagar, Katni. 483501
46. Krishan Pal, aged 65 years, s/o.Late Gaya Deen, Retired
MCM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o. Vivekanand Ward,
Lakhera, Katni. 483501
47. Shiv Charan Patel, aged 65 years, S/o.late Ram Milan
Patel, Retired MCM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Mangal
Nagar, Katni. 483501
48. Net Ram, aged 68 years, S/o.Late Dashrath Lal, Retired
JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Near Shambhu Talkies,
Sant Nagar, Katni. 483501
49. Gaya Singh, aged 69 years, S/o.Late Albela Singh, Retired
MCM. Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o. Vivekanand Ward,
Lakhera, Katni. 483501
50. Shankar Prasad Berman, aged 69 years, s/o Late Ram
Garib Berman, Retired OS, Ordnance Factory Katni,
R/o.Mangal Nagar, Katni. 483501
51. Arun Kumar Shrivastava, aged 63 years, S/o. Late O.P.
Shrivastava, Retired JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni,
R/o.Near Rangnath Mandir, Katni. 483501
24
52. Smt. Abida Khatun, aged 66 years, W/o. Late Mohmmad
Ali, Retired OS, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Mangal
Nagar, Katni. 483501
53. Krishna Kumar Vishwakarma, aged 66 years, S/o Late Hari
Lal Vishwakarma, Retired OS, Ordnance Factory Katni,
R/o.230/3, Sigma Kanha, Jabalpur 482001
54. Ramdhani Upadhyay, aged 63 years, S/o.Late Ram Prasad
Upadhyay. Retired JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.
Mangal Nagar, Katni. 483501
55. Pradip Kumar Shrivastava, aged 66 years, S/o.Late N.P.
Shrivastava, Retired CM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.CLP
Ward, Bhatta Mohalla, Katni. 483501
56. Basant ji Pandey, aged 65 years, S/o.Late R.S. Pandey,
Retired CM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Amir Ganj, Katni.
483501
57. Ganesh Prasad, aged 65 years, S/o.Late Mahajan Shah,
Retired JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o Mangal Nagar,
Katni. 483501
58. Narayan Das, aged 72 years, S/o Late S.L. Gupta, Retired
MCM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Masurha Ward, Katni.
483501
59. Maqbool Ahmed, aged 68 years, S/o.late Manjoor Ahmed,
Retired MCM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.Iswari Pura
Ward Katni. 483501
60. Mahadeo Choubey, aged 75 years, S/o. Late Shyam Lal
Choubey, Retired JWM, Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.
Vivekanand Ward, Lakhera, Katni 413501
61. Smt. Meera Choubey, aged 70 years, W/o.Shri Mahadeo
Choubey, Retired PRT. Ordnance Factory Katni, R/o.
Vivekanand Ward, Lakhera, Katni - 483501.
25
62. Uma Shanker Kureel, aged 66 years, S/o.Dalchand Kureel,
Retired JWM. Ordnance Factory Katni, Ro Gayatri Nagar,
Dr. Ambedkar Ward, Katni. 483501
63. Vijay Kumar Banerjee, aged about 71 years. So, Late JK
Banerjee, Retired HS- 2, Ordnance Factory Katni. Rio.
Vivekanand Ward Lakhera, Katni. 483501
64. Kishore Das Sahu, aged about 81 years. so. Late B.D.
Sahu, Retired Foreman, Ordnance Factory Katni.
Rio.Ramniwas ward Near CLP School Katni 483501
65. Shri Ram Prasad aged 72 years. So.Late Gorelal, Retired
HA-2, Ordnance Factory Katni. R/o.Sanjay Nagar. ACC
Katni. 483501
....Applicants
By Adv: Shri Anoop Nair
Versus
1. Union of India Through The Secretary Ministry of Personnel
Public Grievances & Pension. Department of Pension and
Pensioners Welfare, Lok Nayak Bhawan New Delhi-110001
2. The Secretary, Ministry of Defense. Defense Head Quarter,
south Block Man Singh Road Area New Delhi 110011
3. The Director General EME Army HQ. New Deihi110011
4. The General Manager. Ordnance Factory, Katni, Madhya
Pradesh 483501
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri P.K. Chaurasia
Alongwith
Original Application No. 366 of 2024
26
1. Laxmi Pd Tiwari, Retired Station Master Nanwara Katni,
aged about 63 s/o Shri Ram Prasad Tiwari R/o behind
Mohan Talkies. Subhash Ward, Katni Murwara - Katni
(M.P.). 483 501
2. Late Shri Pramod Kumar Tiwari represented by his wife
Smt Deveshwari Tiwari wife of late Shri Pramod Kumar
Tiwari, Sr Passenger Guard, aged about 61 years, R/o 279,
Rubber Factory Road, Rajiv Gandhi Ward, Katni-483 501
(Μ.Ρ.).
3. Late Shri Sitaram Guru represented by wife Smt Vidya Devi
Guru wife of Late Shri Sitaram Guru, aged about 63 years,
Neel Kant Vihar Colony, Sawarkar Ward No. 11, Adharkap,
Murwara, Katni Murwara, Katni (M.P.). 483501.
4. Late Hemraj Singh Patel Retired Mail Guard, Jabalpur,
represented through wife Smt Shanti Bai Patel wife of late
Hemraj Singh Patel, aged about 66 years, R/o House No.
368, Near Patel Atta Chakki, Khamtara Rosra,
Narsinghpur(M.Ρ.) 487 001.
5. Raghuraj Singh, Retd Mail Driver, aged about 73 years s/o
Ram Dulare Singh, Naya Gaon, New Katni Junction
Shyama Prasad Mukherji Ward, Katni Murwara-Katni
(M.P.). 483 501
6. Narayan Das Bairagi, Retired Goods Driver, aged about 69
years, c/o Sarju Prasad Bairagi, House No. 919/1, Pandit
Deen Dayal Upadhyaya Ward, Katni Murwara - Katni
(M.P.). 483 501.
7. Lal Shyam Gupta. Sr Section Engineer (Elect), aged about
64 years s/o late DurgaPrasad Gupta, R/o House No. 2102,
Jogi Mohalla Pt Banarsi Das Bhanot Ward, Near Trimurti
Kala Mandir, Gorakhpur, Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.).
8. Beni Prasad Jharia, Retd Sr Section Engineer (C & W),
Jabalpur, s/o Keerat Prasad Jharia, aged about 61 years
27
R/o 3173/6-A, Ganga Nagar Colony Road, Garha, Jabalpur
- 482003 (Μ.Ρ.).
9. Jitendra Singh, Retired CWS - Jabalpur, aged about 68
years, s/o Balram Singh, R/o House No. 1453/F-5/Tandon
Complex, B.T.Tiraha, Garha, Jabalpur (M.P.).
10. Anil Kumar Chandok s/o late Shri S.R. Chandok, aged
about 68 years, Announcer, R/o Shivani Homes, Phase 6,
Near Hathital Colony, Gupteshwar Ward, Gupteshwar,
Jabalpur (M.P.). 482001.
11. Suresh Kumar Parasher, Retired CCI, aged about 68 years
s/o late Shri Radhe Shyam Parashar, House No. 1159, Jai
Prakash Nagar, Near Durga Mandir, Maharshi Mahesh
Yogi Ward, Adhartal - Jabalpur-482001(Μ.Ρ.).
12. Kamal Kumar Tong, Retired CBS, aged about 69 years, s/o
H.C.Tong, House No. Bungalow No. 8, Street Road Lane
No.4th Mile, Mandla Road, Land Mark Near Bus Stop,
Tilahari, District - Jabalpur (M.P.).
13. Dilip Kumar Sinha, Retired CTI, aged about 65 years s/o
late Tripurari Prasad Sharan Sinha R/o House No. 1985,
Water Works Road, Near Timber Factory, Bheeta, Jabalpur
(M.P.).
14. Ashok Kumar Dubey, Retd CBPS, Jabalpur, aed about 67
years s/o late A.P.Dubey, House No. 567, Rajiv Gandhi
Ward, Near Satya Narayan Temple, Murwara, Katni
Murwara - Katni (M.P.). 483 501.
15. Mukesh Yadav, Office Supdti-II, WC Ily Jabalpur, aged
about 62 years, s/o Ganesh Pd Yadav, R/o Bajzang
Colony, New Katni Junction, Shivaji Ward No.17, Murwara
Katni M.P.)- 483501
16. Babulal Sahu s/o Gangaram Sahu, aged about 62 years,
R/o House No. 11/12, Lordganj, Ganjipura, Jabalpur (M.P.)
482001.
28
17. G.P. Sharma, Retd Ch OS, aged about 68 years, s/o Shri
RP Sharma, 1216, Ganjipura Main Road, Ram Manohar
Lal Lohia Ward, near Jawa Electricals, Jabalpur (M.P.)-
482001
18. Chandra Shekhar Sen, Stenographer (Hindi) Retd, aged
about 69 years, s/o Babulal, R/o House No. 461. Village
Panchayat-Suhagi-Behind Bijasen Temple, Village Suhagi-
Adhartal, Jabalpurį M.P.) 482004.
19. Vijay Shankar Tiwari, OS-II (P) HQ, PCPO, Jabalpur, aged
about 64 years, s/o late Ravi Shankar Tiwari, 2144,
Shankar Colony, COD Colony In Front of Rajaram School,
Village- Panchayat-Suhagi, Tehuil-Panagar, Jabalpur
(M.P.) 482004
20. R.K. Vishwakarma, aged about 60 years, c/o Kadorilal
Vishwakarma, 64, Near Badey Shankar, Ward No.03,
Beobhari-Ourwa, Jabalpur M.P.).
21. Hitendra Kumar Yadav, Stenographer (Hindi) Retd (CRWS)
Bhopal, aged about 69 years, s/o Bhagchaand Yadav,
Behind Kotwali, Shrawan ka Bagicha, Englishpura-Sehore,
M.P. 46601.
22. Smt Shashi Kala Thakur, OS (Retd) TRD Katni, aged about
62 years c/o P.D. Thakur, B-8, Pushpagiri Colony, Rubber
Factory Road, Rajiv Gandhi Ward, Murwara Katni M.P.)-
483501
23. Shyam Sundar Tiwari, Retd Office Supdtt, aged about 76.
Years, s/o late Shri Mool chand Tiwari, R/o 170/6
Priyadarshini Parisar, Opposite Ukhri, Police Chowki,
Baldeobagh Jabalpur (M.P.)
24. Virendra Singh, Retd Office Supdti-2, WC Rly, s/o late Shri
Indra Singh, aged about 62 years, R/o Flat No. 807, 9th
floor, Anantara, shvatam Multi, Mandla Road, Tilahri,
Jabalpur 482 020.
29
25. Umesh Pandey, Chief Reservation Supervisor, Jabalpur,
aged about 62 years, s/o Shri Ram Niwas Pandey, R/o Plot
No.72, Phase-1, GVM Residency, Near JDA Scheme
No.41, Jabalpur-482001.
26. Tulsiram Raikwar, Technician-1, s/o late Laxman Prasad
Raikwar, aged 69 years, R/oCP.Ward Bhatta Mohalla,
Murwara Katni 483501.
27. Victor Clayton s/o late Shri John Clayton, Chief OS( Retd),
aged about 64 years, R/o House No. 1326, 4 Bridge, Kuber
Market, Napier Town, Jabalpur(M.P.)
28. Hotilal Raikwar, Office Supdtt (Retd), Station Manager's
Office, WC Rly, Jabalpur, aged about 62 years, s/o late
Shri Punnoo Lal Raikwar, R/o Katangi Road, Near
Panchamukhi Hanuman Road, Shankar Nagar, Mother
Teresa Nagar, Karmeta, Ranital, Jabalpur (M.P.) 482002
29. Mohd Saleem, Ch OS (Retd), aged about 63 years, s/o late
Sheikh Memboob, R/o House No. 1192/2, Jai Prakash
Narayan Ward, 1192/2, Lal Building, Marhatal, Jabalpur-
482002 (M.P.)
30. Anand Prakash Singh, Office Supdtt, (Retd), aged 69
years, s/o Virendra Singh, R/o House No. 206, Patan Road,
Bineki Sukha, Mado-Jabalpur(M.P.) 483 113.
31. Tekchand Kori, Sr Section Engineer (Works) Jabalpur,
aged about 63 years, s/o Kunjilal Kori, R/o Jhiriya Kuwan,
Paurwi Kariya Pathar, Vinobha Bhave Ward, Jabalpur
(M.P.) 482001.
32. Sent Malti Gupta Wife of late Shri Gopal Ji, Office Supdtt-
IL, R/o House No. 94/1, Narmada Nagar, Gwarighat Road,
Jabalpur-482001(M.P.)
33. Pradeep Kumar Varshney, Retd Station Director, aged
about 65 years, s/o Late D.D.Gupta, R/o B-61, Priya
Darshini Colony, Near Krishna Arcade, lagh Sewaniya,
30
Bhopal VTC-Huzur, PO Bagh Mugaliya, Bhopal, (M.P.).
462043.
34. Mahendra Kumar Jain, Sr SE (P.Way(Retd), aged about 65
years, c/oB hagwan Das Jain, R/o 205, Land Mark Square,
Bhel Sangam, Bag Sewaaniya, Huzur, Bhopal (M.P.).
462026
35. Atul Kumar Jatariya, Traffic Inspector (Chief Movement
Inspector), Retd, aged about 64 years, s/o late Dhani Ram
Jatariya, R/o House No. 12, Siwami Vivekanand Parisar, B-
Sector, Katara Hills, Huzur, Bhopal, 462003 (Μ.Ρ.).
36. Bhagwandas Mishra, Retd Dy Superintendent, Bhopal,
aged about 65 years, s/o Sriram, 127. Achal Ward, In Front
of Pathak Lekhan Bhavan, Bina Station, Bina-Saugor
(M.P.). 470113(Μ.Ρ.)
37. Harish Chand Jain, Retd Chief Controller, aged about 65
years, s/o Jagdish Prasad Jain, Flat No. G-1, Plot No.82,
Near Sagar Public School, 9/A, Saket Nagar, Huzur, H.E.
Hospital Bhopal, Bhopal-462004 (Μ.Ρ.).
38. Rakesh Kumar Narayan Rao Pathak, Retd Mail Express
Guard, Bhopal, aged about 68 years, s/o Narayan Rao
Pathak, No. 122, Sector 1, R/o Meenakshi Heritage
Shopping Complex, Shakti Nagar, Habibganj, DRM Office
Road, Huzur HE Hospital, Bhopal-462024 (M.P.).
39. Kripa Shankar Pal, Dy Station Supdtt (Retd) Ganj Basoda
(BAQ), aged about 65 years, s/o late Mannilal Pal, R/o
House No. 524, Swaruup Nagar, Behind PWI Office, Near
Railway Station, Ganj Basoda, Vidisha-464221 (Μ.Ρ.).
40. Vinod Kumar Sharma, Chief Office Supdtt, Bhopal, s/o
Ghan Shyam Das Sharma, R/o House No. 125, Meenakshi
Heritage Shopping Complex, Shakti Nagar, Habibganj,
DRM Office Road, Huzur HE Hospital, Bhopal-462024
(M.P.).
31
41. Dayaram Yadav, Retd Cabinman - Harda, aged about 65
years, s/o Rughaai Yadav, R/o Deo Colony Ward, No. 28,
Harda( M.P.).
42. Hiralal, Chief Yard Master(Retd), Bina - Bhopal, s/o
Shobharam Varma, R/o 244, Panchawati Colony, Jhansi,
Sub District - Mauranipur, District - Jhansi - 284001
43. Hukum Singh, Pointsman (Retd), s/o Baijnath Singh, aged
about 67 years, R/o House No. 242, Lalu ka Chauraha,
Heerapura, Nagra. Jhansi, Sipri Bazar (U.P.), 284003,
44. Bharatlal Meena, Station Superintendent(Retd) Ashoknagar
(ASKN) - s/o aged 61 years R/o Sawai Madhopur
45. Bhupesh Mehta, aged about 64 years s/o Bhanwaarlal,
House No.2, 3-10, Near Mahavir Nagar, Ambedkar Gali,
Jaora Road, Ratlam-457001 9 M.P.)
46. Babulal Rathore, Chief Welfare Inspector, Western
Railway, Ratlam, aged about 60 years s/o Shri Ratan Lal
Rathore, R/o House No. 30, Shubham Parisar, 80 Ft Road,
Ratlam (M.P.). 457001.
....Applicant
By Adv: Shri Munish Saini and Shri Amardeep Gupta
Versus
1. Union of India through General Manager, West Central
Railway, Indira Market, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.). 482001
2. Principal Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer, West
Central Railway, Indira Market, Jabalpur (M.P) 482001.
3. Divisional Finance Manager, DRM Office Building, Jabalpur
(M.P.). 482 001
4. Divisional Finance Manager, DRM Office Building, West
Central Ralilay, Habib Ganj, Bhopal (Now Rani Kamla Pati)
(M.P.).
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
32
Original Application No. 584 of 2024
1. Mahesh Kumar S/O Tulshi Ram, Ex Office Suprintendent,
Date Of Birth- 20-06-1957, Date Of Retirement-30-06-2017,
Resident Of Own House Near B.Ed College Taronda Road
Mehra Gaon Itarsi, District-Narmadapuram (Hoshagabad)
M.P. PIN CODE-461115
2. Ramchandra S/O Rambharos, Ex Technician Grade-1 TRS
Shed Itarsi, Date Of Birth-01-07-1961, Date Of Retirement-
30-06-2021, Resident Of Own House, Payasa Nagar Near
Sishu Vidhaya Niketan School, Ward No-05, Old Itarsi
District-Narmadapuram (Hoshagabad) M.P. PIN CODE-
461111
3. Tulshiram Venkat S/O Venkat Ramu Patil, Ex Senior
Technician (Mcm) Trs Shed Itarsi, Date Of Birth-12-06-
1961, Date Of Retirement-30-06-2021, Resident Of House
No-335 LIG Sai Fortune Colony Sonasawari Itarsi District-
Narmadapuram (Hoshagabad) MP. PIN CODE-461111.
4. Hargovind S/O Umade Singh, Ex Technician-I TRS Shed
Itarsi, Date Of Birth-22-06-1961, Date Of Retirement-30-
06-2021, Resident Of Own House Kailash Vihar Colony Old
Itarsi, District- Narmadapuram (Hoshagabad) M.P. PIN
CODE 461111.
5. Umesh Kumar S/O Baboolal, Ex Technician-1 Trs Shed
Itarsi, Date Of Birth-05-06-1960, Date Of Retirement-30-
06-2020, Resident Of Own House Mehra Gaon Near "C"
Cabin Itarsi, District- Narmadapuram (Hoshagabad) M.P.
PIN CODE-461115.
6. Dinesh Kumar S/O Chhunilal, Ex Senior Technician (MCM)
Electrical Trs Shed Itarsi, Date Of Birth-10-06-1963, Date
Of Retirement-30-06-2023, Resident Of House No-B/11
Vrindavan Bihar Colony Jamani Road Old Itarsi, District-
Narmadapuram (Hoshagabad) M.P. PIN CODE-461111.
33
7. Santosh S/O Baboolal, Ex Safaiwala Railway Station Itarsi,
Date Of Birth- 01-07-1958, Date Of Retirement-30-06-2018,
Resident Of House No-1547/48 Aamrahi Parisar Saket
Nagar Bhopal, M.P. 462020.
8. Pratap S/O Baboolal Ex Safaiwala Bhilakhedi Yard Itarsi,
Date Of Birth- 30-06-1956, Date Of Retirement-30-06-2016,
Resident Of Own House Indra Nagar New Yard Itarsi,
District- Narmadapuram (Hoshagabad) M.P. PIN CODE-
461111.
....Applicants
By Adv: Shri S.K. Dagor
Versus
1. Union Of India Through General Manager West Central
Railway, HQ. Indira Market Jabalpur M.P. 482001.
2. Principle Chief Personnel Officer General Manager Office
Old Building West Central Railway, HQ, Indira Market
Jabalpur Μ.Ρ. 482001.
3. Divisional Railway Manager, DRM Office, Near Rani
Kamlapati Railway Sataion, Habibganj Bhopal M.P.462016
4. Sr. Divisional Personnel Officer, Drm Office Near Rani
Kamlapati Railway Station, Habibganj Bhopal, M.P. PIN
CODE-462016.
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri P.K. Chaurasia
Alongwith
Original Application No. 378 of 2024
1. Fanishwar Kumar Shrivastava S/O В. N.Shrivastava Aged
about 61 Year, Ret Juniar Works Manager, O.F.Khamaria
Jabalpur Madhya Pradesh, DOR-30-06-2023, R/O Flat No
34
303 Samdaria Complex Old Sheela Talkies, South Civil line
Jabalpur M.P. 482001
2. Sapan Kumar Hazra S/O PK Hazra Aged about 61 Year,
Retired JWM, OFK Jabalpur, DOR-30- 06-2023 R/0
2636/2Azad nagar Chandrashekhar Ward, Jabalpur M.P.
482005
3. Shambho Singh S/ORAM GovAged about 63 Year, Retired
JWM, OFK Jabalpur DOR- 30/01/2020, R/O Hno.323,
Diwanwada Manegaon Khamaria Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.) 482005.
4. Ram Sumer S/O Late Thakur Deen Pal, Aged about 65
Year, Retired FED Fire Brigade, OFK, Jabalpur, DOF-30-
06-2018 R/O H.no.-575 Diwanwada Manegaon Khamaria
Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.) 482005
5. Garib Das S/O Khusi Ram Aged about 66 Year, Retired
linemistri MCM OFK, Jabalpur DOR-30- 06-2018 R/O 1384
Deewan bada Manegaon Khamaria Jabalpur M.P. 482005
6. Dinesh Kumar Patel S/o Chunni lal patel Aged about 64
Years Retired JWM OFK Jabalpur M.P., DOR-30-06-2020
R/O H. No. 1122/1 New colony Cherital ward Cherital
Jabalpur M.P. 482001
7. Sanjoy Nandi S/O Sunil Kumar Nandi Aged about 65 Year,
Retired JWM, OFK, Jabalpur [M.P] DOR- 31-12-2018, R/O
H.no.220 Shubhash nagar near St Gavrial School
Manegaon Khamaria Jabalpur M.P. 482005.
....Applicants
By Adv: Shri Rajesh Chand
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Defence,
South Block, New Delhi - 110001
2. The Director General of Ordnance Factories (C&S), Ayudh
Bhawan, 10 ASK Bose Road, Kolkata - 700001.
35
3. The Chief General Manager, O.F. Khamaria, Jabalpur
(MP) - 482005.
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 381 of 2024
Deoki Nandan Swarnkar, S/o late Shri Purushottam Lal Searnkar,
a/a 73 years, Occu. Rtd. Draftssman Divn.-I, R/o H. No. 1274,
Indira Gandhi Ward, Chhoti Bajariya, Garha, Jabalpur (MP) -
482003.
....Applicant
By Adv: Shri Saurabh Pathak
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Science &
Technology, Department of Science & Technology,
Technology Bhawan, New Mehrauli Road, New Delhi-
110016.
2. Surveyor General of India, Survey of India, 17-E, Canal
Road, Survey Chowk, Dalanwala, Dehradun, Uttrakhand -
248001.
3. Director, Survey of India, Vijaynagar, Jabalpur (MP) -
482002.
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 394 of 2024
Jiwan Lal, S/o late Shri Shankar Lal, a/a 63 years, Occupation
Retd. Jt. General Manager, Date of retirement 30.06.2020, R/o B-
36
65, Krishna Green Bahavani Pur, Mandhana, Kanpur (UP)
2092017.
....Applicant
By Adv: Shri Anshuman Swamy
Versus
1. Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of Defence,
Government of India, New Delhi - 110001.
2. The Director General, Ordinance Factories Board (OFB),
10 A, S.K. Bose Road, Kolkata - 700001.
3. The Senior General Manager, Vehicle Factory, Jabalpur
(MP) 482009.
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 412 of 2024
1. Pramod Kumar Patel, Aged 60 years, S/o Nand Kishore
Patel Retired A/Mech (MCM), 506, Army Base Workshop,
Jabalpur. R/o. 1279/26A, Diwan Adhar Singh Ward, Jai
Prakash Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur - 482001.
2. Kishore Kumar, aged 66 Years S/o. Late Shankar Lal.
Retired Armament Mechanics HS II 506, Army Base
Workshop, Jabalpur. R/o. No. 52, Bagicha, Central School,
Near 1 STC Sadar Cantt Jabalpur - 482001.
....Applicants
By Adv: Shri Shubham Nanepag
Versus
37
1. Union of India Through The Secretary Ministry of Personnel
Public Grievances & Pension, Department of Pension and
Pensioners' Welfare, Lok Nayak Bhawan New Delhi-11001
2. The Secretary, Ministry of Defence Defence Head Quarters
South Block, Man Singh Road Area, New Delhi, Delhi
110011
3. The Director General EME Army HQ, New Deihi-110011.
4. The Commandant, 506, Army Base Workshop, Jabalpur.
....Respondents
By Adv: ....
Alongwith
Original Application No. 413 of 2024
Nikhilesh Chatterjee, aged 70 years, S/o. Late Shri
H.L.Chatterjee, retired Asstt. Director, Central Bureau of
Communication (Song and Drama Divn) New Delhi, R/o.
H.No. MIG F/348, Vaishnav Building, Surender Palace,
Hoshangabad Road, Bhopal.
....Applicant
By Adv: Shri Shubham Nanepag
Versus
1. Union of India Through The Secretary Ministry of
Personnel Public Grievances & Pension, Department
of Pension and Pensioners' Welfare, Lok Nayak
Bhawan New Delhi 11001
2. The Secretary, Ministry of Information and
Broadcasting Dr Rajendra Prasad Rd, Shastri Bhavan,
New Delhi, Delhi 110001
38
3. The Director General Central Bureau of
Communication (Song and Drama Division) Soochna
Bhawan, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-
110003.
....Respondents
By Adv: ....
Alongwith
Original Application No. 342 of 2024
Yogendra Singh, S/p Shri Hira Singh, DOB 30.06.1961,
Retired as Sr. Audit Officer, Principal Accountant General
(Audit - 1)-1, Race Course Road, Rajkot, R/o DK 2/392,
Danish Kunj, Kolar Road, Bhopal (MP).
....Applicant
By Adv: Shri Vijay Tripathi
Versus
1. The Comptroller and Auditor General of India, 9, Deen
Dayal Updhayaya Marg, New Delhi - 110124.
2. The Principal Accountant General (Audit - 1) - 1, Race
Course Road, Rajkot (GJ) - 360001.
....Respondents
By Adv: ......
Alongwith
Original Application No. 415 of 2024
39
Girish Datta Tiwari, S/o late Sshri Kalaka Prasad, a/a 68
years, Occupation: retired Examiner, R/o H. No. 267
Jagdamba Nagar, P.O. Adhartal, Jabalpur, District Jabalpur
(MP) - 482005.
....Applicant
By Adv: Shri Anirudh Pandey
Versus
1. Union of India Through its Director General of
Ordinance Factory, Head Office, Ayudh Bhawan,
Kolkata, 10 A, Slhahid Khudi Ram Bose Road, BBD
Bagh, Kolkata, WB - 700001.
2. General Manager, Grey Iron Foundry, Jabalpur,
District Jabalpur (MP) - 482009.
3. Principal Controller of Defence, Accounts, Draupadi
Ghat, Sadar Bazar, Sarswati VBihar, Colony, Ashok
Nagar, Prayagraj - 211001.
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh.
Alongwith
Original Application No. 417 of 2024
Chandra Shekhar Dwivedi S/o late Shri Rameshwar Prasad
Dwivedi, Date of birth-13-06-1958, Date of appointment-16-
08-1978, Date of retirement-30-06-2018, Ex. Dy Chief
Personal Officer General Manager's Office North Western
Railway Jaipur, resident of house No-D-149, Aakriti High
Land, Gram Phanda Bhopal M.P. 462023.
40
....Applicants
By Adv: Shri S.K. Dagor
Versus
1. Union of India through General Manager North
Western Railway, General Manager's Office NWR,
Near Jawahar Circle Jaipur, Pin-Code 302017
Rajsthan.
2. Principle Chief Personnel Officer, North Western
Railway General Manager's Office Near Jawahar Circle
Jaipur, Pin-Code 302017 Rajsthan.
3. Principal Financial and Chief Account Officer, North
Western Railway General Manager's Office Near
Jawahar Circle Jaipur, Pin-code 302017 Rajsthan.
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 429 of 2024
1. Aditya Saxena S/O Late Shri S.V. Saxena Date Of
Birth-01-07-1962, Date Of Appointment-03-06-1985,
Date Of Retirement-30-06-2022, Ex Chief Office
Superintendent Drm Office Engineering Branch
Bhopal, Resident Of House No-55, Aawantika Avenue
Phase-3. Berkheda, Bhopal, M.P. 462023.
2. Ishwar Lal Meena S/o Late Shri Deviram Meena, Date
of Birth-01-07-1961, Date of Appointment-03-06-1985,
Date of Retirement-30-06-2021, Ex Chief Office
Superintendent DRM Office Personal Branch Bhopal,
41
Resident of House No. 23, K.N. Pradhan Estate,
Extension- 09, Arera Colony Babadiya Kalan Bhopal,
M.P. 462039.
....Applicants
By Adv: Shri S.K. Dagor
Versus
1. Union of India Through General Manager West Central
Railway, HO, Indira Market Jabalpur M.Ρ. 482001.
2. Principle Chief Personnel Officer General Manager
Office Old Building West Central Railway, HQ, Indira
Market Jabalpur M.P. 482001
3. Divisional Railway Manager, DRM Office, Near Rani
Kamlapati Railway Sataion, Habibganj Bhopal
M.P.462016
4. Sr. Divisional Personnel Officer, DRM Office Near Rani
Kamlapati Railway Station, Habibganj Bhopal (MP) -
462016.
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri P.K. Chaurasia
Alongwith
Original Application No. 430 of 2024
1. Ramgopal Verma S/O Late Shri Mangali Prasad
Verma, Retired SSE (Diesel) New Katni Junction, Date
Of Birth-01-07-1951, Date Of Appointment-03-11-1976,
Date Of Retirement 30-06-2011, RESIDENT OF Own
House Sbi Colony Behind Of Rajghat Colony Jhansi
(Up) Pin Code-284001.
42
2. Vijay Kumar S/O Late Shri Ramnath Giri Retired Chief
Office Suprintendent Operating Branch Drm Office
Jabalpur, Date Of Birth-30-06-1959, Date Of
Appointment-31-03-1982, Date Of Retirement-30-06-
2019, Resident Of House No-45/A, Infront Of Asmani
Mata Mandir Near Nagar Nigam Tank Nayagaon New
Katni Junction District-Katni Pin Code-483503
3. Mukesh Charls Sao Late Shri Samual Charlas Retired
Commercial Supervisior Jabalpur, Date Of Birth- 06-
06-1958, Date Of Appointment-13-06- 1981, Date Of
Retirement-30-06-2018 R/o House No-13336
PRAGATI Sheel Colony Near How Baugh Charch
Narmada Road Jabalpur MP 482001.
4. Krishna Kant Garewal So Late Shri Ramadhar, Ex
Chief Commercial Inspector Kachhpura Jabalpur Date
Of Birth-26-06-1958, Date Of Appointment-30-11-1979,
Date Of Retirement-30-06-2019, Resident Of House
No-4 Deep Mohni Colony Behind SOS Khajuri Road
Bhopal MP 462030.
....Applicants
By Adv: Shri S.K. Dagor
Versus
1. Union Of India Through General Manager West Central
Railway, HO Indira Market Jabalpur MP 482001
2. Principle Chief Personnel Officer General Manager
Office Old Building West Central Railway, HQ, Indira
Market Jabalpur MP 482001.
3. Divisional Railway Manager, DRM Office, Infront Of
High Court Jabalpur MP 482001
43
4. Sr. Divisional Personnel Officer, DRM Office, Infront Of
High Court Jabalpur M.P-482001
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 440 of 2024
1. Purushottam Das Tiwari S/O Shri Haridas Tiwari, Aged
about 65 years, retired Postman, R/O H.No.44 B,
Mahakaushal Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur (MP)-482004.
2. Ramesh Prasad Rajak S/O Late Prem Lal Rajak, Aged
about 65 Years, Retired MTS, R/O H. No.1543, Abdul
Hamid Ward, Yashwant Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur
(MP)-482004.
3. Kaluram Dahayat S/O Late Bhoopat Singh, Aged about
67 Years, retired Postman, R/O H.No.2489, Azad
Nagar, Supatal, Garha, Jabalpur (MP)- 482003.
....Applicants
By Adv: Shri J.B. Singh
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of
Communications, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, 1
Sansad Marg, New Delhi-110001
2. Postmaster General, Jabalpur Region, Jabalpur -
482001.
3. Senior Superintendent of Post Offices, Jabalpur
Region, Jabalpur - 482001.
44
.....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh and Shri P.K. Chourasia
Alongwith
Original Application No. 445 of 2024
1. K. C. Sarathe S/O Late Shri S. L. Sarathe, Aged about
62 years, retired SPM, R/O H.No.1, Sai Laxmi Homes,
Near Krishna Mandir, Khajuri Kalan Road, Piplani,
Bhopal (MP)-462022.
2. Ashok Kumar Namdeo S/O Late Shri Krishna Arya,
Aged about 62 Years, Retired PA, R/O H. No.76, Balaji
Residency, J. N. City Collegae Road, Nabibagh,
Bhopal (MP)-462038.
3. Sunil Kumar Jain S/O Shri B. L. Jain, Aged 63 years,
Retired LSG Postal Assistant, R/O H.No.200/2, Jain
Nagar, Lalghati, Bhopal (MP)-462030
4. Smt. Kalpana Jain W/O Shri M. L. Jain, Retired PA,
R/O 652-A, New Ashoka Garden, Bhopal (MP)-
462023.
....Applicant
By Adv: Shri J.B. Singh
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of
Communications, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, 1
Sansad Marg, New Delhi-110001
45
2. Chief Postmaster General, M. P. Circle, Bhopal-
462012
3. Senior Superintendent of Post Offices, Bhopal Division,
Bhopal-462003.
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 448 of 2024
Pradeep Narayan Khare, S/o late Shri Baldev Prasad Khare,
a/a 69 years, Retired Master Craftman Vehicle Factory
Jabalpur, R/o 2389/1 New Kanchanpur, PO Adhartal,
Jabalpur MP -482004.
....Applicant
By Adv: Smt. Madhuri Khare
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Defence,
Government of India, South Block, New Delhi -
110001.
2. Chairman Ordnance Factory Board, Ayudh Bhawan,
10-A, S.K. Bose Road, Kolkata - 700001.
3. Sr. General Manager, Vehicle Factory, Jabalpur -
482009.
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
46
Original Application No. 453 of 2024
1. Khusi Lal Rajak S/O Late Murlidhar Rajak, Aged about
75 years, Retired Assistant Foreman, R/O H. No. 182,
G/6, Patel Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur (MP)-482004
2. Mukteshwar Kumar Shrivastava S/O Shri B. M.
Shrivastava, Aged about 69 Years, retired Chargeman
T, R/O H. No.3657, Vivek Colony, Adhartl, Jabalpur-
482004.
....Applicants
By Adv: Shri J.B. Singh
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Defence,
Department of Defence Production, 44, Block N0.7,
Type V, Lodhi Road Complex, Delhi-110003
2. CMD, Armoured Vehicles Nigam Limited, HVF Road,
Bhaktavatsalapuram, Avadi, Chennai (TN)-600054
3. General Manager, Vehicle Factory, Jabalpur-482009.
.....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 455 of 2024
Ajit Kumar Kanojia, S/o Shri Chote Lal, a/a 60 years,
Occupation; Retd. HS, Date of Retirement 30.06.2022, R/o
House No. 9 B, Gore Bazar Cantt., Jabalpur (MP) 482001.
47
....Applicant
By Adv: Shri Akash Choudhury
Versus
1. Union of India through its Secretary, Department of
Defence Production, Ministry of Defence, Government
of India, South Block, New Delhi - 110001.
2. The Director General Ordinance (C&S), Directorate of
Ordnance (C&S), 10-A, S.K. Bose Road, Kolkata -
700001.
3. The Chief General Manager, Ordnance Factory,
Khamaria, Jabalpur (MP) - 482008.
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 460 of 2024
1. Kishori Lal Kumhar S/O Late Shri Mool Chand, Retired
Chargeman T, Aged about 70 yrs, R/O 163,
Rameshwaram Vihar Colony, Raigawan, Madhotal,
Jabalpur (MP)-482002
2. Ramesh Singh Rajput S/O Late Shri Garib Das Rajput,
Aged about 72 Years, Retired Millwright HS, R/O
H.No.527, Sarkari Kunwan, Ghamapur, Jabalpur (MP)-
482001
3. Sushil Verma S/o Late Krishna Kumar Verma, Aged
about 68 years, Retired JWM (T), R/O H. No.D-8, Arjun
Vihar, Hathital, Jabalpur-482001.
48
....Applicants
By Adv: Shri J.B. Singh
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Defence,
Department of Defence Production, 44, Block N0.7,
Type V, Lodhi Road Complex, Delhi-110003
2. CMD, Yantra India Limited, C/O The General Manager,
Ordnance Factory, Ambakhari, Nagpur (MS)-440021
3. General Manager, Grey Iron Foundary, Jabalpur-
482009.
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 476 of 2024
Rajendra Kumar Jain, s/o Shri S.P. Jain, a/a 60 years,
Retired Postal Assistant SBCO, R/o H. No. 137, Phase -1,
Near Uday City, Arihant Colony, Vidisha (MP) - 464001.
....Applicants
By Adv: Shri J.B. Singh
Versus
1. The Union of India, through its Secretary, Ministry of
Communication, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, 1,
Sansad Marg, New Delhi - 110001.
2. Chief Postmaster General, Madhya Pradesh Circle,
Bhopal - 468012.
49
3. Superintendent of Post Offices, Sehore Division,
Sehore - 466001.
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 477 of 2024
Smt. Usha Singh, W/o Shri Deenanath Singh, a/a 69 years,
Retired Senior Auditory, R/o H. No. 1272/1, Jai Prakash
Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur (MP) - 482004.
...Applicant
By Adv: Shri J.B. Singh
Versus
1. The Comptroller & Auditor General of India, Pocket-9,
Deen Dayal Updhayaya Marg, New Delhi - 110124.
2. Principal Accountant General, Audit Bhawan, Jhansi
Road, Gwalior (MP) - 474002.
3. Accountant General (E&RSA), 53, Arera Hills,
Hoshangabad Road, Bhopal (MP) - 462011.
...Respondents
By Adv: .....
Alongwith
Original Application No. 481 of 2024
1. Saket Bihari, S/o Shri Ragho Sharan Chobey, Aged
about 61 years, Occupation Retired Sr. Trackman, R/o
430A, Jhamandas Chowk, Sindhi quarter, Kasturba
Nagar, Jabalpur (M.P)- 482001.
50
2. Ram Kumar Singh, S/o Shri Gaya Baksh Singh, Aged
about 62 years, Occupation Retired Sr. Trackman, R/o
RB-1, Qtr. 2, Tulsi kunj behind railway hospital,
Jabalpur (M.P) 482001.
3. Pramod Kumar, S/o Shri Sahdev Singh, Aged about 67
years, Occupation Retired Wireman-I, R/o Gram
Vishambharpatti, Post Satthin, Amethi (U.P)- 227816
4. Sahdeo, S/o Shri Dhana Ram Vamankar, Aged about
66 years, Occupation Retired Welder, R/o LIG 17,
Phase-I, Rajul City, Tilhari Jabalpur (M.P)- 482020
5. Gyani, S/o Shri Butiya, Aged about 63 years,
Occupation Retired Trackman, R/o H. No. 325/3,
Bajrang Nagar, Karmeta, Jabalpur (M.P)- 482002
6. Kishan Das Mali, S/o Shri Ram Nath, Aged about 70
years, Occupation Retired Master Craftsman, R/o H.
No. 1801 near Durga mandir, Kanchghar, Jabalpur
(M.P)- 482001
7. Smt.Indira Bai, W/o Late Shri Pooran Lal, Occupation
Home maker, R/o H. No. 1808 near Durga mandir,
Kanchghar, Jabalpur (M.P)- 482001.
...Applicants
By Adv: Shri Anshul Tiwari
Versus
1. Union of India through its General Manager, West
Central Railway, Indira Market, Jabalpur (M.Ρ.) -
482002
2. Ministry of Railways through its Secretary, Rail
Bhawan, New Delhi-110001
51
3. The Divisional Railway Manager, West Central
Railway, Indira Market, Jabalpur (MP) - 482001.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 504 of 2024
1. Ram Chand Kori, aged about 76 years, S/o Late P.L.
Kori, Retired as-Office Supdt, VFJ R/o-H.No. 1582, Bai
Ka Bagicha, Sheetlamai Ward, Ghamapur, Jabalpur
(M.P)-482001
2. P. Narsimha Moorti Raju, aged about 66 увага, 5/o
Late P. Venkat Raju, Retired as-Chargeman, VFJ, R/o-
114, MIG A, Subhash Nagar, Maharajpur Adhartal,
Jabalpur (M.P.)-482 004
3. Jagdish Prasad Yadav, aged about 75 years, S/o Late
B.L. Yadav, Retired as-Fitzer Auto, VEJ. R/o-3767,
Ratan Colony, Banarsi Das Bhanot Ward, Khamaria,
Jabalpur (MP)-482001
4. Mohan Lal, aged about 68 years, S/o Late Khuman,
Retired as-Durwan, VFJ, R/o-H.No.-1122/2, Belbeg
Toria, Phootatal, Ravindranath Tagir Ward, Lakdhaganj
Ranital, Jabalpur (MP)-482001
5. Ranjeet Singh aged about 65 years, 5/ Late Chhote
Lal, Retired as-Weider-HS, VRJ R/o-Gram Dundhua,
Post Bijadandi, Mandia (M.P)-481 666
6. Bharat Lal Payasi, aged about 63 years, 5/ Late
Ramdin Payasi, Retired as Canteen Attendent, VFJ,
R/o-H.No.2132, Badi Santoshi Mata Road Lal Mati,
Single Quarter, Jabalpur (MP)-482001
52
7. Jeevan Sahu, aged about 76 years, S/o Late Brij Lal
Sahu, Retired as-Asstt. Foreman Tech., VF.J, R/o 474
Purvi Kariya Pather, Sahu Bhawan, Vinoba Bhave
Ward, Ghamapur, Jabalpur (M.P.)-482001
8. Waman Rao Pandagre, aged about 76 years, S/o Late
Arjun Ji Pandagre, Retired as-HS-I, VFJ, R / o - 2225
Chandmari Road, East Ghamapur, ( M .P.)-482 001
9. Shubhendu Majumdar, aged about 76 years, S/o Late
Arbinda Majumdar, Retired as Jr. Works Manager,
OFK, R/o-Plot No. 14, Near Mastana Chowk, Raksha
Nagar Colony, Ranjhi, Jabalpur (M.P.)-482 005
10. Komal Prasad, aged about 76 years, S/o Late Gore Lal
Sahu, Retired as Chargeman, OFK, R / o - 1523
Sheetlamai Ward, , Bai Ka Bagicha, Jabalpur (M.P.)-
482 001
11. Samir Kumar Majumdar, aged about 76 years, 8/o Late
Jagannath Majumdar, Retired as-Asstt. Foreman, OFK,
R / o - 218 Durga Colony, Ram Krishna Ashram, Ward,
Ghamapur, Jabalpur ( M .P.)-482 001
12. Ramdin Kol, aged about 76 years, 8/o Late Ghurau,
Retired as-Machinist Master-Craftsman, OFK, R/o-N-
Type-232, East Khamaria, Manegaon, Jabalpur (M.P.)-
482005
13. Prasanta Kumar Goldar. aged about 76 years, 8/o Late
Surendra Nath Goldar, Retired as-Jr. Works Manager,
OFK, R / g - H , Bengali Colony, Complex Manegaon,
Jabalpur (MP)-482 005
14. Moolchand, aged about 77 years, S/o Late Pancham
Lal, Retired as - Line Mistry, Master-Craftsman, OFK,
R/o-H.No.420, Indra Nagar, Opp. K.K. Tailor, Bilpura
Madai, Jabalpur (M.P.)-482009
53
15. Bechu Ram De, aged about 76 years, S/o Late
Hrishikesh Dey, Retired an-Jr. Works Manager, OFK,
R/o-205, G.T. Road, Bellurmath, Bally Municipality,
Howra, West Bengal-711 202
16. Mohan Lal, aged about 69 years, S/o Late Keshav Lal
Sharma, Retired as Asstt. Foreman, OFK, R/o-
H.No.303/E, Sanjay Nagar Colony, Ranjhi, Manegaon,
Khamaria, Jabalpur (M.P.)-482 005
17. Phool Chand, aged about 64 years, S/o Late Jurra Lal
Birha, Retired as Welder-HS-1, GCP, R/o-Qrt No.
116/1, Tute Line GCF Estate, Gokalpur Ward, 68,
Gokalpur, Jabalpur (M.P.)-482 011
18. Ramesh Kumar, aged about 69 years, S/o Late Hira
Lal Adhikar, Retired as MTS, OCF, R/o-98, 3rd Bridge,
Sadar Cantt. Jabalpur (M.P.)-482001
19. Shyama Bai, aged about 63 years, Wd/o Late
Churaman, Churaman Retired as Fitter-HS, GCF, R/o-
332, Belbagh Toria, Jhanda Chowk, Ravindranath
Tagor Ward, Jabalpur (M.PJ-482 001
20. Mahendra Prasad Sharma, aged about 70 years, 5/o
Late Ram Sukhi Sharma, Retired as Chargeman, GIF,
R/o-H.No.2825, Near New Virendra Welding
Workshop, New Kanchanpur, Adhartal, Jabalpur
(M.PJ-482004
21. Ramesh Kumar, aged about 68 years, S/o Late
Kanchhedi Lal, Retired as Office Supdt., COD, R/o-
Near Gauri Shankar Temple, Katra, Adhartal,
Andhuwa, Jabalpur (M.P.)-482 004.
...Applicants
By Adv: Shri Gautam Prasad
Versus
54
1. UNION OF INDIA, Through: Its Secretary, Ministry of
Defence, Department of Defence Production, South
Block, New Delhi 110.001
2. Chairman/Director General, Ordinance Factory Board,
10-A, Shahid Khudi Ram Bose Marg. Calcutta-700 001
(W.B.)
3. The Principal Controller of Defence Accounts
(Pension), Draupatighat, Allahabad (U.P.)-211 001
4. Sr. General Manager, Vehicle Factory, Jabalpur (M.P.)-
482 009
5. Sr. General Manager, Ordnance Factory Khamariya,
Jabalpur (M .P.)-492 005
6. Sr. General Manager, Gun Carriage Factory, Jabalpur
(M.P.)-482 011
7. The General Manager, Grey Iron Foundry, Jabalpur
(M.P.)-482 009
8. The Commandant, Central Ordnance Depot, Jabalpur
(M.P.)-482 001.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 510 of 2024
Gopal Krishan Shrivas, a/a 64 years, S/o late Shri Ram
Sewak, Retd. Senior Admin Officer, Office of SQAE (GS),
DGQA, Kanpur, R/o H. No. 406, Chhoti Omti, Khalasi Line,
Near Durga Sai Temple, Jabalpur - 482002.
55
....Applicant
By Adv: Shri Shubham Nanepag
Versus
1. The Union of India through the Secretary, Ministry of
Personnel Public Grievances & Pension, Department
of Pension and Pensioners' Welfare, Lok Nayak
Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001.
2. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Defence,
South Block, DHQ PO New Delhi - 110011.
3. The Head of Office, SQAO, Sr. Quality Assurance eStt.
(GS), DGQA Complex, Ashok Path, Kanpur (UP) -
208004.
....Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 588 of 2024
1. Ramchandra Pawar (Retired Postman), S/o late Shri
Nannu Singh, a/a 61 years, R/o House No. 14,
Rishipuram Phase-3, Anand Nagar Bhopal (MP)
462022.
2. Gunvanta Bhoyar (Retired Postman) S/o Shri Pushpraj
Bhoyar, a/a 67 years, R/o Shed A-133, New Ashoka
Garden, Post Govindpura, Bhopal (MP) 462023.
3. Waman Rao Hire (Retired Postman), S/o Shri Gopi
Chand Hire, a/a 67 years, R/o H. No. 132, Sudama
Nagar, Kotra, Sultanbad, Bhopal (MP) 462003.
...Applicants
56
By Adv: Shri Deepak Panjwani
Versus
1. Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of
Communications & IT, Department of Posts, Dak
Bhawan Sansad Marg, New Delhi 110001.
2. Department of Personnel and Training, through its
Secretary, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances &
Pensions, Government of India, North Blocvi, Lok
Nayak Bhawan, Khan Market, New Delhi 110003.
3. General Manager (Finance), Postal Account 4th Floor,
Postal Account 4th Floor, Dak Bhawan, Hoshangabad
Road, Bhopal (MP) 462027.
4. Sr. Superintendent of Post Office, Division Bhopal,
Bhopal (MP) 462003.
...Respondents
By Adv: ....
Alongwith
Original Application No. 587 of 2024
Mrs. Sushila Sharma, W/o Roop Kumar Sharma, a/a 67
years, Occupation Retd. Statistical Investigator, Grade I, R/o
H. No. 74/1, BX Sector, Akbarpur, Kolar Road, Bhopal (MP)
462042.
...Applicant
By Adv: Shri Deepak Panjwani
57
Versus
1. Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of Home
Affairs, C-Block, Ground Floor, Pushpa Bhawan
Madangir Road, Delhi 110062.
2. The Registrar General of India and Census
Commissioner, 2/A Mansingh Road, New Delhi -
110011.
3. Director, Directorate of Census Operation, M.P.
Janganana Bhowan, Jail Road, Arera Hills, Bhopal -
462004.
4. Senior Accounts Officer PAO (Census), AGCR
Building, New Delhi - 110002.
...Respondents
By Adv: ....
Alongwith
Original Application No. 347 of 2024
1. Ramesh Prasad, aged about 69 years S/o.Late Shri
Vithal Anand, retired Senior Audit Officer, West Central
Railway, Jabalpur. R/o. Plot No.80/A, H.No. 2917, Jai
Bheem Nagar, Polipathar, Gwarighat Ward, Jabalpur-
482008
2. Rabindra Rai, aged about 65 years, S/o. Late Shri
Sarju Rai, retired Sr. Audit Officer, West Central
Railway R/o. E-115, Sigma Kanha Colony, Mandla
Bypass Road, Saliwada, Jabalpur-482021.
...Applicants
By Adv: Shri Shubham Nanepag
58
Versus
1. Union of India Through The Secretary Ministry of
Railways, Rail Bhavan 1, Raisina Road, New Delhi-
110011
2. Comptroller & Auditor General of India, 9, Deendayal
Upadhyay Marg, New Delhi-110124
3. Director General of Audit, West Central Railway,
Annex.II, 3rd Floor, Platform No. 6, Railway Station
Jabalpur -482001
4. Sr. Audit Officer (Admn) West Central Railway,
Annex.II, 3rd Floor, Platform No. 6, Railway Station
Jabalpur-482001
5. The Financial Advisor & Chief Accounts Officer
(FA&CAO) West Central Railway, Indira Market,
Jabalpur -482001.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri Sanjay Lal
Alongwith
Original Application No. 344 of 2024
1. Varsha Sharma aged about 61 years, W/o Shri
Pradeep Sharma, Retired as Senior Section officer
(ACCTS), Western Central Railway (WCR), Jabalpur
(M.P), R/o-506/3, Vatsalya, behind Rai cafe,
Gorakhpur, Jabalpur (M.P) 482001
2. Mannu Lal, aged about 68 years, S/o shri Tulsiram,
Retired as Senior Technician (Manual Motor vehicle
driver), Medical department, Railway Hospital,
59
Nishatpura, Bhopal, R/o H.No. 158, phase-3, Rainbow
valley colon Lambakheda, Bhopal 462038.
...Applicant
By Adv: Shri Gaurav Sharma
Versus
1. UNION OF INDIA, Through: Its General Manager,
Western Central Railways (WCR), Jabalpur PIN
482003
2. Principal financial Advisor (PFA), General Manager
office Western Central Railways (WCR), Jabalpur PIN
482003
3. Divisional Railway Manager (DRM), DRM office, DRM
Road, Bengali colony, N-2, Habibganj, Bhopal, Pin-
462024
4. Senior Divisional personnel officer DRM office, DRM
Road, Bengali colony, N-2, Habibganj, Bhopal, Pin-
462024.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri P.K. Chousaria
Alongwith
Original Application No. 341 of 2024
Smt. Madhuri Gupta W/O Shri Rakesh Gupta, Aged about 63
years, Retired Primary Teacher, R/O H. No. 4, Vashundhara
Vihar, Mall Road, South Civil Lines, Jabalpur (MP)-482001.
...Applicant
60
By Adv: Shri J.B. Singh
Versus
1. Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan Through its
Commissioner, 18, Institutional Area, Shaheed Jeet
Singh Marg, New Delhi-110016
2. Deputy Commissioner, Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan,
Regional Office, Jabalpur, GCF Estate, Jabalpur-
482011
3. Principal, Kendriya Vidyalaya, Ordnance Factory
Khamaria, Jabalpur (MP)-482005.
...Respondents
By Adv: ....
Alongwith
Original Application No. 340 of 2024
1. Hemant Shrivastava S/o Late K.R. Shrivastava, DOB-
12.06.1957, Retired as Supervisor, Accountant
General (A&E)-2 Gwalior, Branch Bhopal, R/o- DK-
2/353, Danish Kunj, Kolar Road, Bhopal-462042 (MP).
2. Riaz Ahmed Qureshi S/o Shri N.M. Qureshi DOB-
23.06.1959, Retired as Sr. Accountant, O/o A.G. A/E I,
Bhopal, R/o- B-93, Housing Board Colony, Kohefiza,
Bhopal-462001 (MP).
3. K. Kali Prasad S/o Late K.S. Raju, DOB-20.06.1960,
Retired as Sr. Accountant, O/o Principal Accountant
General (A/E-I) Bhopal, R/o-56- Raj Saamrt Colony,
Phase-2, J.K. Road, Bhopal-462022 (MP).
4. Vinayak Shyamrao Walke S/o Shyamrao Bhakru
Walke, DOB-01.07.1951, Retired as Sr. Accounts
61
Officer, O/o Accountant General (A& E) 1 Bhopal, R/o-
17/18, Balaji Parisar, Mandakini Society, Kolar Road,
Bhopal-462042 (MP).
5. Pradeep Kumar Jain S/o Sujanmal Jain, DOB-
18.06.1955, Retired as Accounts Officer, O/o Principal
Accountant General (A/E-I) Bhopal, R/o- E-8/244
Doorsanchar Nagar, Opposite Savoy Complex,
Bhopal-462039 (MP).
6. Anand Govindrao Godbole S/o Late Govindrao, DOB-
01.07.1950, Retired as Sr. Accountant, O/o Accountant
General (A& E) 1 Bhopal, R/o- Duplex No.6, Mili
Homes, Urban Heights, Sarvdharm, C-Sector, Kolar
Road, Kolar, Bhopal-462042 (MP).
7. Mrs. Krishna Ghosh Das W/o Dhananjay Das, DOB-
25.06.1961, Retired as Assistant Supervisor, O/o
Accountant General Audit 2, Bhopal, R/o- Dup. No. 35,
Virasha Heights, Bawadia-Kala, Kolar Road, Bhopal-
462042 (MP).
8. Indrajeet Salvi S/o Late Babulal ji Salvi, DOB-
29.06.1962, Retired as Sr. Audit Officer, O/o
Accountant General (Audit-II), Bhopal, R/o-390/39,
Samajwadi Indra Nagar, Bharu Chouk, Indore-452001
(MP).
9. Abdul Lateef Khan, S/o Late Abdul Shakoor Khan,
DOB-17.06.1947, Retired as Sr. Accountant O/o
Accountant General (A&E) Branch Bhopal, R/o- H.No.5
Near Ravi Das Pura Regiment Rd, Shahjahanabad,
Bhopal-462001 (MP).
10. Syed Dilshad Ali, S/o Late Syed Hafiz Ali, DOB-
01.07.1950, Retired as Divisional Account Officer
Grade-I O/o Accountant General (A& E)-1 Bhopal, R/o-
B-358, Tilak Society, Indra Vihar Colony, Airport Road,
Bhopal- 462030 (MP).
62
...Applicants
By Adv: Shri Vijay Tripathi
Versus
1. The Comptroller and Auditor General of India 9, Deen
Dayal Upadhyaya Marg, New Delhi-110124.
2. The Principal Accountant General (General and Social
Sector Audit) M.P. Audit Bhawan Jhansi Road, Gwalior
(M.P) 460212.
3. The Principal Accountant General (A&E) - I 53 Arera
Hills Hoshangabad Road, Bhopal (MP) 462011.
4. Accountant General (Audit-II), Madhya Pradesh 53
Arera Hills Hoshangabad Road, Bhopal (MP) 462011.
5. Accountant General (A&E) 53 Arera Hills
Hoshangabad Road, Bhopal (MP) 462011.
...Respondents
By Adv: Sanjay Lal
Alongwith
Original Application No. 324 of 2024
1. Dinesh Kumar Nigam, S/o- Shri Surendra Kumar
Nigam, Age 61 years, Occupation- Retired Senior
Section Engineer (TRD-ELEC), W.C.R., Bhopal, R/o-
Rao Ganj, P.O. Kalpi, Jalaun (U.P.) 285204.
2. Padm Narain Mall, S/o- Shri Paras Nath Mall, Aged
about 69 years, Occupation- Retired Senior Section
Engineer, W.C.R. Bhopal, (M.P.), R/o- D-12,
63
Vardhaman Green Park, Ashoka Garden, Bhopal
(M.P.). 462023.
3. Tapan Kumar Mistry, S/o- Shri Tarani kant Mistry, Age
60 years, Occupation- Retired Ch. Office
Superintendent, R/o- Kunjwan Colony, District- Panna
(M.P.). 488001.
...Applicants
By Adv: Shri Prateek Dubey
Versus
1. The Union of India, Through its General Manager,
West Central Railways, Jabalpur, District- Jabalpur
(M.P.). 482001.
2. Chief Personnel Officer, West Central Railway,
Jabalpur District- Jabalpur (M.P.). 482001.
3. Financial Advisor/Chief Accounts Officer, West Central
Railway, Jabalpur, District- Jabalpur (M.P.). 482001.
4. Divisional Railway Manager, West Central Railway,
Bhopal, District- Bhopal (M.P.). 462001.
5. Senior Divisional Personnel Officer, West Central
Railway, Bhopal, District- Bhopal (Μ.Ρ.). 462001.
6. Senior Divisional Finance Manager, West Central
Railway, Bhopal, District Bhopal (MP) 462001.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
64
Original Application No. 296 of 2024
1. Santosh Kumar Sen S/o Late Shri Mannulal Sen, age
about 63 years, R/o House no. 74, Raj Samrat Nagar,
Ayodhya bypass road, P.O. Piplani, Bhopal, M.P. Pin-
462022, retired (30.6.2021) while holding the post of
Statistical Investigator Gr. -I (S.I.Gr.-I) from the O/o
The Directorate of Census Operations, Jail Road,
Arera Hills, Bhopal Madhya Pradesh, Pin-462011.
2. Vinod Kumar Dubey S/o Late Shri Ganesh Prasad
Dubey, age about 63 years, R/o House no. 45, Jyoti
Nagar, near Kendriya Vidhyalay No.3, P.O. Vidhya
Vihar-3, Bhopal, M.P., retired (30.6.2021) while holding
the post of Statistical Investigator Gr. -I (S.I.Gr.-I) from
the O/o The Directorate of Census Operations, Jail
Road, Arera Hills, Bhopal Madhya Pradesh, Pin-
462011.
3. Mrs. Farzana Yousuf W/o Late Mohammad Yousuf,
age about 64 years, R/o House no. 6, Amaltas City
Campus, Near Adarsh Hospital, Shahjnabad, Bhopal,
M.P.,pin- 462001, retired (30.6.2020) while holding the
post of Statistical Investigator Gr. -I (S.I.Gr.-I) from the
O/o The Directorate of Census Operations, Jail Road,
Arera Hills, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, Pin- 462011.
4. Rajendra Prasad Arya S/o Late Shri G.R. Arya, age
about 65 years, R/o House no. 51, Aradhana Nagar,
Barkhera, BHEL, Bhopal, M.P. Pin- 462022, retired
(30.6.2018) while holding the post of Senior
Supervisor, from the 0/0 The Directorate of Census
Operations, Jail Road, Arera Hills, Bhopal Madhya
Pradesh, Pin-462011.
5. Mrs. Masroor Khan W/o Syed Wazahat Uddin ,age
about 66 years, R/o House no. 69 Baboo Colony,
Shahjnabad, M.P,pin- 462001, Bhopal, retired
(30.6.2017) while holding the post of Senior Compiler
from the 0/o The Directorate of Census Operations, Jail
65
Road, Arera Hills, Bhopal Madhya Pradesh, Pin-
462011.
6. Mrs. Rekha Pindawal W/o Dinesh Kumar Pindawal,
age about 68 years, R/o House no. 2A/1, Sudarshan
Complex, Govind Garden, Near Bijli Colony Gate,
Raisen Road, Bhopal, M.P.,pin- 462023, retired
(30.6.2016) while holding the post of Statistical
Investigator Gr. -II (S.I.Gr.-II) from the O/o The
Directorate of Census Operations, Jail Road, Arera
Hills, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, Pin- 462011.
7. Santosh Ganpatte S/o Late Shri Narayan Rao
Ganpatte, age about 75 years, R/o House no. 60,
Chanakyapuri, Choona Bhatti, Kolar Road, Bhopal,
M.P. Pin-4620156, retired (30.6.2009) while holding the
post of Statistical Investigator Gr. -II (S.I.Gr.-II) from the
O/o The Directorate of Census Operations, Jail Road,
Arera Hills, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, Pin-462011.
8. Kamlesh Kumar S/o Late Shri Taiya, age about 61
years, R/o House no. 242, Priyadarshani Nagar,
behind Narmada Bhavan, Bhopal, M.P. Pin- 462003,
retired (31.12.2022) while holding the post of Statistical
Investigator Gr. (S.L.Gr.4) from the O/o The Directorate
of Census Operations, Jail Road, Arera Hills, Bhopal,
Madhya Pradesh, Pin- 462011.
9. Balmukund Mishra S/o Late Shri Nanne Lal Mishra,
age about 65 years, R/o House no.268, Kanta
Shravan, Jairam Estate, Ayodhya bypass road, P.O.
Piplani, Bhopal, M.P. Pin-462022, retired (30.6.2019)
while holding the post of Statistical Investigator Gr.
(S.I.Gr.-1) from the O/o The Directorate of Census
Operations Chhattisgarh, Janganna Bhavan, Plot No.-
10, Sector-24, Jhanjh, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar, Pin-
492018
10. Gopal Krishna Kamdars/o Late Shri Satyanarayan
Kamdar, age about 75 years, R/o House no.C-2.
66
Chanakyapuri, Choona Bhatti, Kolar Road, Bhopal,
M.P. Pin-462016, retired (30.6.2009) while holding the
post of Statistical Investigator Gr. -1 (S.I.Gr.-l) from the
O/o The Directorate of Census Operations
Chhattisgarh, Janganna Bhavan, Plot No.-10, Sector -
24, Jhanjh, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar, Pin-492018.
...Applicants
By Adv: Shri Abhijit Bhawmik
Versus
1. Registrar General & Census Commissioner of India,
0/0 Registrar General & Census Commissioner of
India, 2/A, Mansingh Road, New Delhi-110001
2. The Director, The Directorate of Census Operations,
Jail Road, Arera Hills, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, Pin-
462011.
3. The Director, The Directorate of Census Operations
Chhattisgarh, Janganna Bhavan, Plot No.- 10, Sector -
24, Jhanjh, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar, Pin-492018.
4 Union of India through Secretary Ministry of Home
Affairs Government of India, North Block, New Delhi.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 295 of 2024
Tehal Singh, aged 74 years, S/o. Late Lallu Singh, Retired
Daftari MES, Jabalpur, R/o. Village Chargawan, Post office
Bhakhlpta Rly Station, Katni.
67
...Applicant
By Adv: Shri Anoop Nair
Versus
1. Union of India Through The Secretary Ministry of
Personnel Public Grievances & Pension, Department
of Pension and Pensioners' Welfare, Lok Nayak
Bhawan New Delhi - 11001
2. The Secretary, Ministry of Defense, Defense Head
Quarter, South Block Man Singh Road Area New Delhi
110011
3. The Director General EME Army HQ, New Deihi-
110011
4. The Chief Engineer, Military Engineering Services
Bhagat Marg, Post Box. 84, Jabalpur Cantt. - 482 001.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri P.K. Chaoursia
Alongwith
Original Application No. 294 of 2024
1. Sanjay Kumar Woike, aged 66 years S/o. Dayal Singh
Woike, Retired Gun Carriage Factory Jabalpur,
R/o.Karav Parisad Duplex, No.2 Zedas College, Road,
Tilhari, Jabalpur 482001
2. Raju Bain, aged 66 years, S/o.Late Dhanriram, Retired,
Gun Factory Jabalpur, Carriage R/o.H.No.532,
Maharishi Arvind Ward, Prem Sagar Post Bai Ka
Bagicha, Jabalpur. 482001
68
3. Beena Soni, aged 69 years. W/o. Shri H.S. Soni,
Retired Gun Carriage Factory Jabalpur, R/o.Jawahar
Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur. 482001
4. Suresh Kumar Gupta, aged 73 years S/o. Late P.D.
Gupta, Retired CM (NT), Gun Carriage Factory
Jabalpur, R/o.H.No.1077, Bai Ka Bagicha, Ghamapur,
Main Road, Jabalpur. 2482001
5. Bhojraj Patel, aged 73 years, S/o. Late Shri Dev Karan
Patel, Retired MCM, Gun Carriage Factory Jabalpur.
R/o.H.No.3295/1C, Sanjay Nagar,. Chanchekhar Ward,
Ranjhi, Near Rawan Park, Jabalpur. 482001
6. Hari Lal Gotiya, aged 71 years, S/o. Late Shri
Chandulal Gotia Retired JWM. Gun Carriage Factory
Jabalpur. R/o. H.No. 36, Near VDJ Gate No.4, Suman
Nagar, Maharajpur, Jabalpur. 482001
7. Rajender Singh, aged 62 years, S/o.Late Amol Singh,
Retired CM, GCF Jabalpur, R/o.H.No.65, Richai,
Suman Nagar, Maharajkpur Near VF G.No.4, Jabalpur.
482001.
...Applicants
By Adv: Shri Anoop Nair
Versus
1. Union of India Through The Secretary Ministry of
Personnel Public Grievances & Pension, Department
of Pension and Pensioners' Welfare, Lok Nayak
Bhawan New Delhi - 11001
2. The Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Defence Head
Quarters South Block, Man Singh Road Area, New
Delhi, Delhi 110011
69
3. The Director General EME Army HQ, New Delhi -
110011
4. The General Manager, Gun Carriage Factory, Jabalpur
Madhya Pradesh.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 275 of 2024
Faggu Lal Kol Aged 72 years, S/o. Late Samman Lal,
Retired EMU (Civil), 515, Army Base workshop Banguluru,
R/o.H.No.154/2, Narmada Nagar, Amkhera Road, Jabalpur.
482001
...Applicant
By Adv: Shri Anoop Nair
Versus
1. Union of India Through The Secretary Ministry of
Personnel Public Grievances & Pension, Department
of Pension and Pensioners' Welfare, Lok Nayak
Bhawan New Delhi-11001
2. The Secretary, Ministry of Defense, Defense Head
Quarter, south Block Man Singh Road Area New Delhi
110011
3. The Director General EME Army HQ, New Deihi -
110011
4. The Commandant, 515, Army Base Workshop,
Bangluru.
70
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 241 of 2024
1. Phoolchand Sharma S/o Shri Ramshankar Sharma,
aged about 62 years, Occupation Retired M.С.М.
(Senior Technician), R/o Jay Prakash Narayan Ward
No. 51, Golapura, Harda (M.P.) Pincode 461331
2. Chandra Shekhar Tikariya S/o Shri Devkaran Tikariya,
aged about 62 years, Occupation Retired M.C.M.
(Senior Technician), R/o 314, Shivam Batika, Ward No.
28, Harda District-Harda (M.P.) Pincode 461331
3. Wahid Khan S/o Shri Fajal Khan, aged about 62 years,
Occupation Retired ESM-III, (Technician Maintenance-
III), (Electric Signal Maintainer) R/o Dev Colony Ward
No.28, Harda District-Harda (M.P.) Pincode 461331.
...Applicants
By Adv: Shri Jitendra Arya
Versus
1. The Union of India through General Manager, West
Central Railway Division Jabalpur Indra Market
Jabalpur (M.P). Pincode - 482001
2. The Union of India through Divisional Railway
Manager, West Central Railway Division Bhopal Office
Near Habibganj, Hospital Huzur Bhopal (Μ.Ρ).
Pincode-462024
71
3. The Senior Divisional Personal Officer, West Central
Railway Bhopal
(Μ.Ρ.) Pincode-462024
4. The Pension Officer West Central Railway Govindpura,
Bhopal (M.P.) Pincode-462024
5. Senior D.S.T.E. West Central Railway Harda, District
Harda (M.P.) Pincode-461331
6. The Chief Signal and Telecom Engineer (C.S.T.E.)
West Central Railway Harda, District Harda (M.P.)
Pincode-461331.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 76 of 2024
1. Chhotelal, S/o- Shri Ramma, Age- 63 years,
Occupation- Retired Sr. Tech, Engineering branch,
W.C.R., Bhopal, R/o- Tarae Fahtak, Shervarakla,
Talbehat, Lalitpur (U.P.). (284126).
2. Laxmi Narayan, S/o- Shri Budderam Sahu, Aged about
62 years, Occupation- Retired Sr. Tech (Pump Driver)
Engineering department, W.C.R. Bhopal, (M.P.), R/o-
House no. 1152, Near Bija Sen Mandir, Talpura,
District- Jhansi (U.P.) (284001).
3. Ved Prakash Dubey, S/o- Shri S.R. Dubey, Age- 62
years, Occupation- Retired Sr. Tech. Electrical Branch,
HBJ, Bhopal (M.P.), R/o- Shivlok Phase- V, H. No. 64,
72
BDA Road, Awadhpuri, District- Bhopal (M.Ρ.).
(462022).
4. Smt. Asha Nagle, W/o- Late Shri Ashok Kumar Nagle,
Age 54 years, Occupation- Housewife, R/o- House no.
27, Naveen Nagar, Aish Bagh, Huzur, Sikandri Sarai,
District- Bhopal (M.P.). (462010).
5. Mohammed Shabbir Khan, S/o- Shri F.M. Khan, Age-
65 years, Occupation- Retired Divisional Cashier,
WCR, Bhopal, R/o- E- 8/130, Shiva Kunj, Railway
Colony, Huzur, Trilangar, District- Bhopal (M.P.).
4620022
6. Arun kumar Jha, S/o- Shri Indradeo Jha, Aged about
62 years, Occupation- Retired Senior Cashier W.C.R.,
R/o- House no. 1/204, B.D.A. Colony, Amrarod Road,
Awadhpuri, Huzur, District Bhopal (M.P.). (462002).
7. Anil Kumar Lahariya, S/o- Shri Shiv Dayal Lahariya,
Aged about- 65 years, Occupation- Retired SSE (Elec),
W.C.R., R/o- D-336, Raj Home, Minal Residency,
Mogali Park, J.K. Road, District- Bhopal (M.P.).
(462023).
8. Narendra Namdeorao Gohatre, S/o- Shri Gohatre,
Aged about 60 years, Occupation- Retired Asst Elect,
Engineer-B-JR, W.C.R., R/o- Daporikhurd, Tehsil
Tiosa, District- Amaravati (M.H.). (444707).
...Applicants
By Adv: Shri Mohan Lal Sharma
Versus
73
1. The Union of India, Through its General Manager,
West Central Railways, Jabalpur, District- Jabalpur
(M.P.). 48 2001.
2. Chief Personnel Officer, West Central Railway,
Jabalpur District Jabalpur (M.P.). 482001
3. Financial Advisor/Chief Accounts Officer, West Central
Railway, Jabalpur, District- Jabalpur (M.P.). 482001,
4. Divisional Railway Manager, West Central Railway,
Bhopal, District- Bhopal (M.P.). 462001.
5. Senior Divisional Personnel Officer, West Central
Railway, Bhopal, District- Bhopal (Μ.Ρ.). 462001,
6. Senior Divisional Finance Manager, West Central
Railway, Bhopal, District- Bhopal (Μ.Ρ.). 462001.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri P.K. Chauraisa and Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 71 of 2024
Satya Narayan Singh S/O Late Shri Hari Mohan Singh, Aged
about 65 years, Retired Foreman, R/O 1663, West
Ghamapur, In front of Krishna Colony, Jabalpur (MP)-
482001.
...Applicant
By Adv: Shri J.B. Singh
Versus
74
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Defence,
Department of Defence Production, 44, Block N0.7,
Type V, Lodhi Road Complex, Delhi-110003
2. Commandant, 506 Army Base Workshop, Jabalpur
(MP)-482005.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 922 of 2023
1. Lal Sahab S/O Late Shri Panna Lal, Aged about 76
years, retired JWM, R/O H. No.49, Mahakaushal
Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur (MP)-482004
2. Alok Kumar Bose S/O Late Shri P. N. Bose, Aged
about 72 Years, retired HS I, R/O H.No.2430,
Umanagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur-482004
3. Abhay Kumar Jain s/o Late Shri K. C. Jain, Aged about
61 years, retired JWM (T), R/O H. No.318, New Sahu
Colony, Lordganj, Jabalpur-482002.
...Applicant
By Adv: Shri J.B. Singh
75
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Defence,
Department of Defence Production, 44, Block N0.7,
Type V, Lodhi Road Complex, Delhi-110003
2. CMD, Advanced Weapons India Ltd, C/O The General
Manager, Ordnance Factory Kanpur, Kalpi Road,
Kanpur (UP)-208009
3. General Manager, Gun Carriage Factory, Jabalpur-
482011.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 459 of 2024
Bindu Singh Wd/o late Gulab Singh, a/a 65 years, R/o
Sindhi Colon y, Behind Qtr. No. 6, Kanchghar, Ghamapur,
Jabalpur (MP).
...Applicant
By Adv: Shri P.L. Shrivastava
76
Versus
1. Union of India through its G.M. West Central Railway,
Sough Civil Lines, Jabalpur - 482001.
2. Secretary, Ministry of Railway, Rail Bhawan, Rafi Marg,
New Delhi, New Delhi, 110001.
3. Divisional Railway Manager (P), West Central Railway,
South Civil Lines, Jabalpur (MP) - 482008.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 591 of 2024
Suresh Chandra S/O Late Shri Girja Shankar Sharma, Date
of Birth 01-07-1962, Date Of Appointment-20-08-1983, Date
Of Retirement-30-06-2022, Ex Assistant Divisional Engineer
Shivpuri Bhopal Division, Resident Of House No- Rose -421,
New Minal Residency J.K.Road, Bhopal, M.P. 462023.
77
...Applicant
By Adv: Shri S.K. Dagor
Versus
1. Union of India through General Manager West Central
Railway, HQ, Indira Market Jabalpur M.P. 482001.
2. Principle Chief Personnel Officer General Manager
Office Old Building West Central Railway, HQ, Indira
Market Jabalpur M.P. 482001.
3. Divisional Railway Manager, DRM Office, Near Rani
Kamlapati Railway Sataion, Habibganj Bhopal
M.P.462016
4. Sr. Divisional Personnel Officer, DRM Office Near Rani
Kamlapati Railway Station, Habibganj Bhopal, M.P.
PIN CODE-462016.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri S.P. Singh
Alongwith
Original Application No. 586 of 2024
78
G. P. Hedaoo S/O Late P. A. Hedaoo, Aged about 72 yrs,
Retired Sub Divisional Engineer, R/O Plot No.17, Scheme
No.31, Sanjeevani Nagar, Garha, Jabalpur (MP)- 482003
...Applicant
By Adv: Shri J.B. Singh
Versus
1. Chairman cum Managing Director, Bharat Sanchar
Nigam Limited, HC Mathur Lane, Janpath, New Delhi-
110 001
2. Chief General Manager, BSNL, M.P. Telecom Circle,
BSNL Bhavan, Hoshangabad Road, Bhopal-462015
3. Controller of Communication Accounts, Department of
Telecommunications, 1st Floor, Doorsanchar Bhavan,
Bhopal-462015
4. Telecom District Engineer, BSNL, Chhindwara (MP)-
480001.
...Respondents
By Adv: Shri D.S. Baghel
ORDER
By Justice Akhil Kumar Srivastava, JM Hon'ble Shri Kumar Rajesh Chandra, Member (A) connected through video conferencing.
1. The only question that arises for consideration is as to whether an employee, who retired on 30th June of a year or 31st December of a preceding year, is entitled to be extended the 79 benefit of increment that falls due on 1st July or 1st January of the next year, as the case may be.
2. Since the issue involved in all these Original Applications is common in nature, they are being decided by way of a common order.
3. While the applicants in some of the cases have retired on 30th June, others retired on 31st December. They are aggrieved that they have not been granted the benefit of increment, which was otherwise due to them, only on the ground that by the time the increment became due, they were not in service.
4. We find that the issue regarding grant of one annual increment due on completion of one year service before attaining the age of superannuation has now attained finality in view of the judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 2471 of 2023 (@SLP(C) No.6185/2020) decided on 11.04.2023 in the case of The Director (Admn. and HR) KPTCL & others vs. C.P. Mundinamani & Ors.
80
5. Since the issue involved in this Original Application is no longer res integra as the same has already been decided by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in C.P. Mundinamani (supra), nothing remains further to be adjudicated upon in these matters. Accordingly, all these Original Applications are disposed of with a direction to the respondents to grant the benefit of one notional increment to the applicants due on 1st July or 1st January of the next year, as the case may be, with all consequential benefits. The respondents are directed to verify and ascertain that all the applicants fulfill all the conditions stipulated in the order of Hon'ble Apex Court in this regard as mentioned above.
6. Let the needful be done within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. No order as to costs.
(Kumar Rajesh Chandra) (Akhil Kumar Srivastava)
Administrative Member Judicial Member
/Piyush/
81