Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
N K Ghanghave vs M/O Communications on 18 December, 2019
J CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBA.
Original Original Original Original Original Original Original Original Original Original Original Original Original Original Original Original Original Application Application Application Application Application Application Application Application Application Application Application Application Application No Application Application Application Application Application Application "
CORAM: - R.VIdGAYRUMAR, MEMESE (A)
02) OB No. 5739/2014 RAVINDER KAUR, MEMBER (3) No 5735/2014 Ne. 190/2018 Mo. L71/2017 No .184/2017 Wo. 185/2017 No. 263/201?No. 2658/2017
Na, 266/2017 No.296/2017 No. 297/2017 No. 450/2017 Ne. 4985/2017 3758/2015 No. 5218/2015 No.676/2015 No. 6712/2014 No. 672/2014 No. 6738/2014 No. 674/2014 M&S Ae Wows xy oes the ie day at Bisco 20) 2 heant pe. Apple ' Se SAK Fy 3 7 is * x SS
-
4wACE me eh. BN ts wR BIKAR GA a Versus .
SS ARS tees = = we me Y ae See SR [oT Si8 ES Ey Sas PN sen Rak ara Reo SRY ARS SR a. ) Regpondants on OR No. 266/2017 02} go a cs 4 Es ip nt ob Z pat a8 tos 'hee we :
* ne ok Applicant ee < RA ae ANN, ondants .. Applicant . ++ ROSE ' :
art hot er 6m he, oy 3 sf ee eS « Me Mo 8h * . so ie ose G ea $54 Cho ard wt oy 1 aoe a an a, eo be 1% Qe ae " Wy LEE ee PSA i3 % ; : SoU 83 » ; ; ges ao 3 Gon yy 3 it OG BE ¢ aS age es £2 se $8 ew C8 fh oS ae oH Se G a oo 8 i t: : 6 ra g ned oF Ae ay fu bes ees £ aT B wo AG ea} ih ra a g fs ce r4 He) A 13 a oe ; * £5 fr i a : He 4 yersus Sek lee n 3 coat Seg oA a) .
* ' ' oy ee TAS, Hi ; a . nn aa it Cad £83 x iy EL <3 af wd e > Gan appl x ...Raspendents ,. Respondents woe Nw! i ™ ae ae ee ae we, Ma Uy & > - 2 "i 33 Ge sd bee Ls: . . * se ws ; Ka ee wD j pod ££ 3 * 4 oy bee] red vy tee oe 2 wr a xo. a £4 Me a a * Sout tA yes age : 4 My Ms 3 & ws 5 ie A i ae wot a3 gt wag a ' ny es by t ~ 44 md G ; iti el % w Q oe Sony a ey a j a a 4 aa | c 3 Z z a 8 PR E50 ; we Ep oe ye Eos ott ei: 4 om es fia tt f 9 4G ves as of het .
" ¥ "3s ; wh ts fa 3 & ; C 6 4 A Tay FAg om a 4 :
ne iu % a Pt : i BH hes * if} ey ioe ch ged Saft cy BERL :
eK Ss 3 Tey ty Sates < fe ney wet " x Sy fend he ants é 4G Appl ©:
' te ¥ le ~ : work "ES G :
G 4 A a ' ge 4 oe 8 i poh. 4 (4 es re at pact 94 toes hy FS : ah tt:
ug 2% gt wi ® i ie £% a 4 3 ae CF 53 ane Ae HY b> ~ # wt me ay oe 4 "
a ae 4 4 4 wet ot vey mB i EF a yi AS ae ES ; oo Ht G 2 iM rit reed:
C 4 te ay 3 ha m3 3 Brass ' uA a ba £4; iy +g 4 > 2 M4 : eed 3 x a * * ® vt £55 Ley ert - s " "
Je ano seek LOE aS i ee ae ad eoees pay Qe \ ty H , + Respondents ee HE . iy ' oS 19 2 oe 2 ae Q6) DA Ne 3775/2015 Ecant . Appl 2 oe st ay Versus aay Tie aR ASSASINS eNO ST Lek o. -Raspondents f a SR Ee % eF Nee .
GEOG CEE Boon pe Op og apt fT) MA ny 4 ee aoe :
Bee 'aan ie', set mes ER ES ~e aig 2 * * we * * *S BIL/2014 OA No OF} we fala het he TR AR Ay PY OS at a5 bs G iu oe * * Agpt .. Rasponedents. .. Appl erate) ASR Mes & Peeneaee Sa NS wf Pee we as Sue Bes OA No. 6774/2014 « 'es C # 3 i. : oe BAH 4 re oe os 4 e 44 Se 4 a ° sa Be 43 gat s i ; pone, ne 3, t Versus Og) ty ees wae Versus Respondents eS ws AN s ert ee a SRS vy E b € = ar a AY aS x z eg ne! Se et sae CP Sees, oer sy oy ao ae iy ay {205 816/ OA No 03} .. Applicant vod ood way rad pen ee J Secretar oh ais z "
oS PAY: Berk ARS, Ses yaey 3 EAT Noo Sea Sar aot:
of oe e Respondents Applicant * Ue oN . Respondent' iS a wee ris & 4 e 4
i) : es ES te 633 Cx ad £hs a :
eRe NEA * = OL Bfeoh?
: us S| : on moat 4 i
- ik es rae i ek fas) gt <p fest ee oy ; ; oF ake 5 c oy oh £ 38 OR No PN eee OA No H ese] 5 :
4 4 ry *) os 4 AS a pore: i 3 3 serney:
oO B og > ¥ » Pe ct BS b> ot ae ne ri ,. Applicant ke o fy L Be Oy BALA Caress :
Versus ES i nf x wae a sy BOR S sa ak .. Respondents OR No, 265/201?
i2 2 Sank ee 'tet seh es Soe SOF Ea NO ae SERPS xe BE » .. applicant ced be ood a OM yy iy * EOE EI EN Lae wee MER ES a: 4 PEO RE eek RE Seg ged EA 4 wt aN x a oe ws a A he raat RY Yarsus LLLLLLLLS Ls LiL OUOLTIT TTT TTTO TELL TUTTTUUTE ED:
mk Respondents * ¥ Sp PA a Aas RSS 4 nn, RK f Ps Se ae A aS AES oe LESS 3 et 4 2 ati fo 3 i :
BA Soft ret, eg ws "4 ce weg ;
i OAR Ne.bid Versus 143 peed
-Respoendents leant LOB 4 Appl .. Appl 4 uh 3 iB £05 4 As ~ E £4 werk of bee i 3 ' i $ ~ ue eo Sh ot C . ol a4 13 yo i be UF i #3 ie wy hs fis :
th y Bp 3 OA No. 184 25} Versus Versus Respondents ae OA No. 185/2017 16} x f ERS thas! Seay ay Oey Nae Ne aoe BN oe ce Ba 5 So x.
£Sy a tee he = ath sh Sok Be ey a yd 805 .. Applicant nts Responde a 2 Be he:
Seen t , f
3.
ees, feo eee Pe) = Ses § os :
Sh neat feat at OR No.263/2017 Varennes
27) , PRONE RSS sy cant a apondents wv Applicant ca g se ~ o &§ oa = apt fA ef i on 5 2 < ¥ Pa :
KH Mee apes eet TE 4 ay '* 3 AS a " aN.
SS a ORS.
ay.
23:
OA No. 450 /2017RA Versus
18) Yersus SS ed aS NS ae % a a aead eee Set Nea Sia she = hohe Te yrs yi dents vy) ReSpor eres os vA .. Appliican B a af Kee 5 SP at ¢ Pees co Brey = Kt, da SESS ube Versus ser Cay ning ch & t ay aed ey 4 st SANA:
Set SS we ARRAS sake awe Toe Meo KEES oes Lae a oe:
_. Respondents (By Advocate Shri S.P,Singh in Sl.Nos.d to 21, Shri V.A.Nagrani for Sl.Nos.212 and 14, Ms.Sujata Krishnan in S1.No.158, Shri c.S. Temburnikar in Si.Nos.13, 16 to 19 for applicants. By Counsels Shri BR. Shatty in S1.Nos.1 to 4, Ms.Naveena Fumai. and Shri RR. Shetty in Sit.Nes. 5, 8, 7, 9, 28, Skra .V.S.Masurkar in SL.Nos.i1, 23 and 14, Ms. Naveens Rumai in S1.No.12, Shera BR, Shetty in Sil .Nos.25 te 13, Shri NR Rajpurehit in S1.No.8 for the respondents) Reserved on :Zo-11-2013 Pronounced on : 18-12-2019) R.Vijaykumar, Member (A) : ' : * i " 5 . =o "
TRB Xo ek bem ea Oy POE ty 4, 25 2S. S PAN PNAS FRLS ne Sez LS Pye Nu Ben feted my af : x : . HEU AAWTR ESE ES whoa Gere Pnitraliiv SRP. bCanes Wh NE DS ESS Do ad ea ty et aa Ree A A a oy 4% ne we ee "7 ca = me Re Ae tas ER ee Bek ent s ' ;
me > wos . wn ' Leese Tye a et Oe eA geet Bey Os eS Re Lb@eC See EIA OAR Sa de NS re bol y os een zs fe me Se Sea. Se ale et we TY iy REO a IR AS me SES Se EYS CDSE Sg St Me ss SOON EA SROEN & SCORE om ARS SEN SOR EAS x Loe 3 Saba s r aoe aes od x 5 oe 3 Tey, 8 OAS SE ee aE BAUS ON See RR Rees reek Boat fe ERP ee. HEAP yt a <r oe aR SAO GE OPS YS eR, gs PSNASSal LRORG ARV Les LOAN:
SAN . Ey Ph 3h S Soy a or ee AGUS Ss Tae BREA QE. Soe : 3 NT Te eS oka SC Sigs OES a ay Sed 'S SoS SNS ah ee mom HONS oe SS cos < é 5 eos :
yee a Srexcm es 8 SOR ser SE ROR LAGS saryek ne SR TRE he ae ae Seas A Sa aa Na ae ed Ta. PNR. 5 , s Sek SEN TS Rote SR Te EO, BAS " es x, Poy AAPA aS ee WSR Re NS TCA RA OTe nf = oa SR tre. eR eks Ses as 2 hw wee Be A AAs syce Pe ees CNS ee SRS SACL SS SA eS hee See FE Se my CASTES GATS SRE eke SS BOR es DRS RS SL ee SSE ay Ses cx My eNO oe tae SA Eg SS SRE NAL SR . ¢ , soos oo SEPT TI ee wae st So SES PERO ENS AL Ae EN TREE EE NSE a RE fede eae. ATR Yt eS SA as foe ke. Re Boks aR #eESEM oes Ae ES ah. 2,8 & ces oe Wo eo oF AA Ra we ee tS Sadi NA, eee Ma SRE A hes SA ka ee En Sey seas TOR a ge es Fee oe SaaS kee ae * be aN AD et Rae a ae SAV Boe ana We AS Aa oR SNARUA AS: SANA Sasa SR OEE So Soe YOOSL oF S933 oN Naot ew Rey Re eS Seay SX YAE ae LS BMRA LY oes So j 3 42 sel ky
- Beg a} np s S o LF © Si au eet : ot AD. Be a ? oe e oS s gs 185 "ey ae vi o : Bs aged 4 2 te i} 6 aa ve oe bt ae :
ere a = 4 a4 ; ; bn ; ee is oe oo i bo cg x 3 c 8 2 og e t we Be Shot & $ om iB Py a oe os oe i t * +4 4 x ny = a _ 8 "
* - 5 é sek eit i ; a ie ERS ye ee e Ps py i S 2] 3 : @ i a) : ig : +t 3 5 ie fit ' 43 wy ben Ch * Bes m4 Cy oy at : es * eee be, 3 oh ped ad '4 Pt es . oS wD eo , a ie bf 4 4a oe 8 $° Lf cry: * ge phe . 4h: ¥ ony a 7 OY o a gj 3: BE Ey aot be an ot vec $5 ht YE oF $4 iy gt ry hes ' * Ce ¢ a Cs fey i 563 th Pia € & LD = TULUM oon f2011 OA No. Sh India and Ors., = oe Union 3 Reger ov.
.
ha O si es Dhaka Sa Bi Hardewa & Union of India a No. 58/2011 OR UOT & OFrs.,
-
v4 PAE a BaP MA ex VMAS dacided on 16.8.2011.
i 5 a 4G ge Poy "ey aD.
WE as SESS Ade:
oe SS ss dekard a ee ck SS oy Ss & se STE ats a AS:
ES = a :
at <a CY, OS adie x 2 s Bhanwar Lal Regar and Ors. { t we ad = ;
= oN Soot & e
--2
x ry .
NER eae Set whe, cs <4 y fae 2NN ao a2 ety 3 ¢ soph © : ¥ is Co if Ee seh fx} a tt iD wh 2D eed $4 ives S were x SPY SETI ET eee ae ay a oR wey SR SR £ z he .
* i TON a crag p ue tga ay, eth Sa = ¢ sea = .
yA REEK A hae re £ Es as SERA €4 x 5 3 Sak ete 4 :
oe SS Soy Sa NS Roe ek oy ee Na 7 pee cae Sa EMS Nee G ot 85 ed 7 a Rice. Research * i Bivrector Ganeara £1 tt aye wb 4 ay a us ig es bs ca 4 g Se Me AES Cubtack & Anz.1
ot $ Mt Sha RA Peery STEN a ae @ 3 a + "4 43 wi g +H % a PERS :
ee Boo Re.
Lope Rae oy s NIN tt Be a8.
ar s tent ses Sat SR R a AN 2 ae Se de tas nat 2, FO OLED, O14, E9QLOLS LIL os ELS en See y AX Sh Se Bes mo eS ASS % caer * Rene os as ext Soo as RAL UA: Sets.
Prasad Sharma v. UOT and Ors. in OA No.321/2011 ete.
Seley ey eS 3 Nek A ¥ Rey ey * Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd.
We R. Santhakumar Velusamy & Ore. in 2011 (3)S8h0 353 pahen SN Se ~ SAS es ENE S Na SARE RR eh Aas Seat a ta RSS ee SEGA = . ee Soe id wes & aaa 2 OS so Be NES eS x Reh & 2 KOU ay ed SVT : " oS BUM ge SOS a Syl RS was Eade ote Ses Ina ita SAE WAN Jae NN, * oy ~ ER! OR ee RARE A AE AS oer EN Ra Ser ae at os Sa Sal st Avi SA es Bhanwar Lal Regar ha oY ake SAR NR Ee RS 5 nee y « < a ee Peeks See SS &
-
eS ae ¥ o & , #S 3 ed ok Lpek 4 a 4 } cs ' ad 2 B ng ims ; a i S4 oa 4 oS st . ¥ a. g% i at Aa Se si i G os a 3 £3 es on or 3 Gj a S ie bed 73 4 eg by a ee : ' vee as o¢ 4 an as oh 5 ae pace gy tet "4 4 freer} oe " a We & fe $ fot e fe Ge ©} 4 ae Cs ay rn] wet iy os bee.
ges h Nae SA Na RNS PEN a Haat AS i if Pt ho - ci Q i my ut s cy i oe ay £3 4 4 e Ge i : «4 wok Bs Y ue . ES Pe eh 25 © hy od Be eh ae ih Be a : ae Ko Bs 4A :
Ramabhai M ba os % fe : n eh ws BY "a : & : 3 wd ivy 42 ; 5 6 a aoe % wy a oe 4 S os ka g 4 5) Cy ig Fhe oF: ari : fe is Ma fs gt $e a ® & 3 AL 4 i ' Gola :
Rome eb h a f & A pt Vey "
3 io as rg : : 44 i: oe
- - ey ae { ' ee wed 4 en ee a 1B 43 oo Ne ar Lal Regar (supra) raxd Govin e of India ov.
4 é « wg g $a us ; 8 . ed vg ved f a 4 cr a J Lg Eo me 43 a is G @ a Se Bo ory 4 ig i poet : g i By oy : at ; ed hed a bs ii a we Be e d ve "4 ws be i ea A. : @ Pe £65 a iD aed ee 4 . a ry 53 " e4 tye 13 4 ; a es " on £8 2 iW 4 3 Be 3 :
os 4 a a " © "sig aa : 3, 6 na ' a ee " oe 43 ys "3 nS gs 1% a G ay ES ng S ae 8 Ste Ma £4 co ba ms # D me nA id we 4 $4 eng ty ce i B od ig ' a us) ' cd pe ae gs ase & ° be on i "8 a3 F4 te:
Peg & & 3 a w "a ma w it bi Dy a 0 ee £3:
ee aS + Be SA at daqdi f £ 5 Sey Vos ay we Cour mi Ors.
z LB Enea a os RE SN EN oy a Nat has Sa Nae ~y ore ¢ az Tis ete. Bet S.N.Singh Bhati, 4 Seow ¢ wy ws eet Ae and Ors.
< L& Ad see Ese pea way AAS %, x Sot ide es p at 5 pe So £ $ ie ge.
co) Oe ne ct rm a oe os g f é 3 fa bea] be .3
G rt ¢ 1 ' Writ Patition Le a be ; 4d Sb FY 1B - pee a 3 % y f i G sg a ted . i = co eo a Hi - ag rf M ig s He ay GC 4g "OG § 4 a wh Oy he = : cs ro :
a * 4% eo © « Go g : a D is 8 : " & 2 ' oe i i M 8 0 och ph * ved wy 3 a : & : 6 & * ba 4 > a i 3E4 PA | Bs. 4 o i oe: 4 ee iy ad © 4 re ey - 3 a 4 iG A a Ss fy o ae a > Rs a3 é g a) oy :
. fs Ss 3 <i opt et oo to oc rn a : bet Ci 4 5 om . ih tg $a G a cr ay a gs : a ¢ oe 4 : S A a 2, o S iy 4 a G po "5 xo is) : ri wm ky :
z 2 nh is by of 3 #4 . AS a be e as oh 4 aj oA "sd in Be m 45 es ws 4 ' nt j yet iy * oF (3 te aoa '3 fy ae ne wt an i £ oe Soy Us me Am NAR RS = Sao! ay 3 é oy a ES Reaeny Beak :
Aw 5 aA er aes As q we haw Xk sgt a3 £4 we + 4 the 2 D3 4 a 3 "
i G wd cS vey % Be eS KS tak 4 Me ry Pee t BAS : "n oy eee Sy aoe hg tee ee ae Se ty A hey t 4 wee ~ Badd +"
2 Ne No. it414/2012 es sg Me oi Noe x z ¥.
ee A LAY Sek See Ses rac Sk:3
Set p v a of x st =.
es gs AS a 6 upra} a SS fs = vot ard be ca G ae Ast Xess cling oh e 4 4 % oy Ser Sat & Eee SA, Seige Dhaka, host Bhanwar Lal Regar (5 Eres £ ver ee AS con ws Sa NS Ot 3 ° 2 p Ses ae AS ey aN 3 4 ayes ot we = x x oa we kts oS FF a Hardeva Ram a et wa = iat he x AR ek XK Aah See ye BEEN oS Re Lal Regar (supra).
oe Sat Se & ~ as Ros g ay 0 a cf 4 ted viet on "i # me Ss Sere wes we 2 eo TI % E LL7GS/26013 cP a:
mis an Ne.
aed L Lk 2 wt tS g & a mG a * Q 9 bo 2 Be s eo . ee, bos aes } a' "A n cs kd tts oy ey oe A o i 1 oy 6 Stk gb i eee a Bee ord babs 3 BS 4 mee ag 3 4 weet bed ee & 2 £h Bb ;
ees ra by tps BAG CE RA ga YE £3 we 4 ee BPO GR ed Dev Beran Mahala and Ors. Surendra Peepliwal wv.
it oy te et aos Tat an SE es v4 q Surendra Sey 2 Crna teas A as Me 3 & we x SS a4 G % s '3 MG Ee Se Sen 12 wea eS toy es 5 ue es +S OA No. 808/20 ¥ 4 > wz foe ee Feapliwal tend w SA Aa Sin St ee vakash Bhatnager, YS ES 'mes Sa y £ Avand FP $/Shri Mool Chand Kalawat, ad SA € A Oey 'i na My he s det
a) os oe oe 5 £ t < & APM Neem Ba Thana MDG & 3 be! ~ cs ea es mG wy .
sae eae + 4:
* = aa sa et hes teh Tie oe at Ee.
Ex ct ae iS a "4 ol = as a = wk.4
te ae ~ aS y ed eases Sees ae CULIULTULLTUUULLTT TOUT UTTOTUULULU TTT UULOTTUTOPUULOTT OTOL TLTOLUULTLLLTD Cs aE co k oh oy ced ies i MM hy a red "-- fe n B: as Le Gy A 4 4 et 6 w 5 : oa OM iB 4 i ry ~ i i a .
iB fo Sy € 2 ee 4 ¥ ey ye ; o 6 4 On » oO Ae : % sraptigen nae REN ay 4 & eb LLeR Fe ing j : a, o re ee ae ' wed a ON Ae uh "i C3 eor$ ay oe 6 x Xe ' af India and Se SSS:
SERS as, ae oy & Sa x 3 se my N BS Writ Pets we a re S Oe The Union :
Ae 12 a"
% Bat Ay g a a mt a 4 Basanna Roe Sak eR 'nee ee oY oN 'i a mt Ad 433 at md a, t dot e wy > he, Bhanwar Lal Regar Me Soy eof a # M4 re : aa i os O a oe 6 ii 9 "es CF £3 : 4.3 4 pod ; ah k, ee t .
a agape os kee is Jeo & c% 13 re GS :
e a # & heb 64 eo 2 iF 4s "4 "GS 2 ra of fe & AG ce be iy eek * i - & 4 Cy, LE is a ag eee Pad, oe et o wy oe Ka o Dy ~ i a a © Be ' ca he, 4 he et eek ' ihe ' sy 3) beat ek ey Abed » rt get i AA ep et ies teed :
gt * : eras be ae O g Oo . € sage ot aT A, 1 3 ;
or {C} awd SS YN é S it 4 < 0 S ae 2 se ff ae Meat ae me ee + a = pat a % a Ase ty Las ae ~ * tne and Ors.
es Ct
-
Ps a me 8 os "3 fa eo "es 5 G 4 « # 7 . is rs god ce " : 4 * " 8 a ee: % -
63 3 y 3 3 3 a wn a te ee 3 ef uy CO Cs g G 4 Ro AS 3 w@ 2 it ai G gi oO he a so we & 2 i C3 nao XS et fa ah td; 43 ty on 4 be (rh ay Makwana te so 5 Age and OFs.., VOL Me # 5 Netvarbha i © *.
et me Nk Reger AS x ce Pe ee Ee Departmant hed UOT & Ors., Ahmed Burney hee a apy et @ wer ;
Bhanwar :
3ty 5 ratan v.
Shakeel BF ; oc yy
-- d 8 é a Do cpt * ot oy Poe / . et » @ % 1, te + a " a 4 Bo 8 : 3 Oe gh Ls ne A we oH i Mes OUR a oy op ts of eS a so fF : . a "a 8 a Pe nena by 8 £3% % weed 8. Ae ant "e bf nt CF ee 3 os. Fs 2 8 gy YD a = 9 ; = 4 3 & y i : i 3 i a oe ce ; ; 7 be ns i ee b a " Hed e B Gy pete: 4 o 9 rt Be ps Py as E ca 4 piae ee a o rh 43 et ' ps whan ie wi if gd rs oo I go en oy D ue a S og a ae "
ipa b: 4 2 b "5 od 43 at 3 os! oS +. 3 poet a ah & oe eT igs BA cr ey : 1 ot m4 BAG
- Ae * need pea Bo 3 a bag OE a es TT ee $3, i 4 at "r4 - 3 A "th a Oo % : - 0% > 3 ee Bi ae ed pooh rs bed M Q ® by ad % Sane {supra}, of Posts sea hae ar EPP DA RE ERA p =e ee Pe iN A Nes tS No See ls hat See SS PASE BGS eh wot = Sai gts, Ae oo a 5 Pace Mae oS.
ry na reek in ae ee A ee cee ches ee RANA oN NS Sing Sate Aas RS Se on Paral &.
Bo A ~ y g ae ws pipers 3 EUS x = S ee MTN % an a Re Wh Pe ee ay re GE " Ci o % " a ee a G ts € fee wy : * 5 Gio ary is C20 AS he 4 Py ES :
- £5 cs ey £ fet hed had 4 ot 4 $4 yt & oe ® as a s : % ' apg Dp Gog ve e g he ey AEN.
¥ Res :
Nua AGP a ee ae a) Ste a SSP NARS Satake Se pal te wy .
te oy At ws Gi oo & oer aS ' s 4) 4 we a i
-
a on A hog be va cp Ha ey ard oh pe EN ss € ef be 5p Ls 3 SNe Ro ONE AEN ALA Ee = oa as + Aue tRS i aa UD gs 5 "
ora fa 5 Z pe S i Se: 3 oy i £a oy So 3 poe ES ae oO Oy, © oo een eek oe tet ue f 5 ve ee - fe od 26 Oe Be b Me Be os w o pe we ff i ory Fy RA tf Bee Go yeh oes a4 Zid he a oe co CC fe "Bape o 4 QPOE) a , ta GC. te ct nt Es UY ba by A a Bw ab ser 0) + "a BO wy es ae ee a an Lo phoad ep Re 48 Ch apr :
oy a = le Se ne wrag ay SEEN = de NBR cogs at 2 Soa ees Toy at Nae SS.
wa Mae Sa ES re eS eS aN %.
¥ y ip a3 B oN iS PS ns, oP ane > x PO] ee = as 5 * NeNSS Sf <Oaeae SARS Nae Ae:
oN eae]
--
fs TE ® 3 z ae FN.
ae Ra Ps LAee ot SUPE ae we = nA Sa whe Se he 3 4 Sn, Ae wee Me AEA ees A'S:
* NAL SA, ee.
aN.
a :
:
mo Ka! > et SUNS iy.
2.
yy Bek aA Reta 4 aN a a, es Aye Nee A S23 Aer Ae ae x e 4 xa im $ Le 4 J it A ¢ Ps me a Peed ay tet SOUITLTUUTTLTUTTODITOLTUUT ITU OTUUU TTT LLTLUTITTETETLT TALI UOT NOU TOOT TNOOTTITTE:
Oe hy ih o oO & "4 w 4 at &. 8a 8 BO ag a4 8 iy me i) oa 4 og DB eo is Ds & bs ats:
i : 4 Lyefe of ay oy & eae 1 ie a hed = 4 oot T5 oy te 4. MW 9 Sy : <a wh th, th i ts be he 'pe * fal e cf 4a as £. el it 2 u 4 3 & B i ve a g ia ae 3 cok aoa, a # He go aa oF s '3 a 43 a od gt ' : BE, 83 ° od % Ry eck teed Se re i 2 3 A o bd $3 ao tgg Be Ba ny : iy 44 " % al et £ FP 4 ay ty oo us O54 eS 4 64 2 wy + 8 ay wei a b: we G4 ee 2 hes u oO & TAs 3 ; e M4 a a ane pos The be £ See ee Shs « %
5. i i i 3 4d aa £18 "hy 4 % ~ a iy 4 rang foe Mh fe we al bag be iy og by 4 wa ed ke i tok as : f Bh gy eae ifs pa & Cpa Ef ks et iy yes a ' Bi. ts et Ba es dud « 5 : +4 , ES <3 hes, "
wg a Ke tet % ae! Ra) a a SO eo
--
ord ae ae o4 ory oo 5 2 ols a ee a8 + ea "4 3 4 ay O44 at fe,
3) ' 5 ES pa & ey 4 he, ett nae sag es G oy a bo woke ey é a 3) 43 cy fe is 3 ty ay bee Key yw e od * "he oye.
Ne yale 2 a * ts ow wD oh Boe g £3 Bes ¢ i A of wos aa AS ~ re .
ASR Me i} ah $4 cs 2 SP a vet a Se : oe WER aed "eS £3 at vat iS ? a & 4 Se a AS ae Sra tae ae es SRS EG SE etl Gy 6 ms be, gs eS Ch ed po Of Sep He ka KG is oe ay ase Oy vet t. i a i cae a ; wi A + wS gy vo oe 4 Sy E HL et et grt ee as ae e a Borg G} os (supra) ;
Set} NRE SPOR = oy.
ue eae fey Set Nk % Se
-
i, Ja gi GY Li ce ae "
he 2 * ae D, Sivakumar ¥ Surendra Feepliwal (supra),
- tg 3 ey .
: 1 ft oa vee oe Meee ¢2 e a ssok ee oy wi oe bay uh C3 4 , re Eas uy "a ee a 8 és ah ' ¢ - of Be 3 ss 3 ¢ Fey: £ * ss pa a ad Bert "rh oe ray a 4 + ;
us co , a i oe ged « 2 4 greef « + bed a * ae ib. "
Ch + it ae et Sys beg. Whee LTT ;
Ek Re Ry on of te ae eR ayers whe.
4E iG 6 + iy 6 se © pl eS Municipal Corporat:
aN eS .
'mae q AIR 1997 SC 1125, ; ie
- ih ay 4 vs a8 2 8 pt. * he & ky ts co es #4 oO 3 Jt oes WA tA a a a : om ra , fief i g i G @ vo ee a4 bed i 4 a Pe Ch 4g » " Vie Pe bea i ae. i i at 1 oy oat 9 iy 4 2 fat : 44 be 3 4 a ig " "eh t cs 6) aE te Sa a Se £3 Ed ie 3 ed & Te a a £ e RS.
wet aes x £
--
x oe = ye t a Tndia and oN & :
EY 'ec Tah Sa Pot = a 3 3 en of = aie a ee Pe ns tind SX;2
b eM ¥ et Sa tates Me sy per :
~ 4 x = % A ar nes i y Ee Aw Sey Ek:
a Ya, x.
# Met ce $ = Nowe Sew 7, bod is 3 w ms ms A. t he * AIR f Ors.
od oA at Te BE a 63 < AALS ke Aa CA Be x Rael ke Ae s Ae ve, Yee! = nan S % Sr oa (supra).
iagh 5 Uttam Shida he Se ey Le os Gr ns a 8 g Ab - 4g an 4 ; $4 Ae: oS 1d 9 g a be % e . 8 a a 43 oe uw a B M4 64 tes Ba Lo: et "3 ' i 3 - Lh od ts ea red @ a 3 Ee = TV OTL oy 4 a x wh fs os ay x "a i iby a en 5 * Ee bo #4 on Hy "f be £8 oh £4 ved iS 4G be if Ae * "4 P ah. ° at oO a : 3 i 6 as et 5 ee i: ct] £3 ss cm a fo ; " " : fe # weed "£4 : of "4 he as is a sl ey e 3 seh es ey Ace tc} iy 44 te ow x o "E :
* $ ee$ Ne: : epek £ f es Ze w fet ' - u 4 ing Kulwant Singh cok rn a ES "
ae a ved ws re uy 45 et et . i 0 Boo AS a KE i ' os 42 ;
& : 45 = co :
v4 a v SS ayy & as 7th * Aaa No. 3868/2008 Ram Karan RKumhar v.
ig "hg : G & me et * , rd 4 yh S am * oF ie a * ie ye Aa j £% 12 ba # ie oe lens Bs aloe oer § tuk See eet § & £ £.
hakeel Ahmed Kumar, 1ve Sais sek me NS Se ?
ra * 3% NS Nate bt RBasanne Naya Shri Sharma a ar Govin +t.
* ney, Bur Kumbar BPran a Writ Petition No.3988/2008 > Pt wy.
Nae Nee a te ee er se ro jk mabe .
AG :
ae ", PS m= BO AT et saa £ 3 5 3 1 oo we ¢ Na £ =, Ram Karan Kumhar, ea ete poe Bat net ie A < Nh '6 e Bs 3 a G 2] 9 % % a3 = YN TE ~ fa EE ay Rey Sk % &:
x wah.
ee we ts Sy Ss a ao erate Ne ey ee & ¥ = Ta ee al area ue tf ia ay a Bee Lorene
6 eS ts g D CURR he % sd G Ba & c hy BS ie oe om i tet Ed : rt Sy : ms is Q Gog Ss a e 0 i sd mu + & ey * wh Ps coed es wel wer 4b 4B cs i 3 ed iE ms Bel oy e : :
o a o D Ras No. L709 Set aaa eR RS 2 st wR Neath de En Lees pees ot Sa ad Sharma W.F. Ss pe fit 4 eee 4 (gg Boe Pee St os Cs 3 ms ca t a 7 on oe rey oA a3 wv ty Ct bed 444 oh th 7 x ts fey ar ¥ ated r ea uh ih "3 eo , fa ep ee Eo te rs ig is ; * ard CR fo BR UR nyt i Fe eh mG aS : o : Me e $5 ves he aed: ; 63 : "3 a3 Spd ss fet qe £8 yes TD. & e any a oe et = ee KS CG a oe o a 'p ES * 3 | ? ' 'i " ay +e eS vod TA oe et poses eC yy we ¢ ' oh tS a a : A oe QO bs "4 ie ths aa ot s se sat St Bs { « ae = co * i Qo £3 Gy 4 i fe fa e q £3 a fc t a Goa 8 Gs BB qi RE aS Oe cornea tints a Se See Ma te, m.
et SARA soe.
e MY anys. RS ot By Bs 4
-
oa = sek ae ae =p Set pes Nea ao as be rae Nee:
orn ae NE At © i eS ee
-:
eRe a a Tie ioe ake Maa ae Lye west Tak ao aes MA A AES as he on 5 Sy ee So Ra Ae Qa eM ee es ek oS oe SAR oP ~ wa Nok eens Por REN ey ry A Se MY et ate A: g4 Ad ae he AR A oS.
SR PS Ta.
cae cea eee PRADO ie te a mg a oy 9 ae ed 8 fe gs tm ® Q SS New Ss se a De ye EE, Howey ed ae a Sas aaa we Sh nion Petition ' ah € g} se = Do a 5 Bo £3 a4 a 4 E e as * a a 6 a bg Bk $ ee x eg Es ey oS i zy 2 eG a nf a g :
sod 3 a a Q 3 & a g taf o a a Q os H oO hte "4 ye a : 3 ue ag Fe eth ef te eA os os oy
1) 'p ot a tt "a ry ; - 3 ' ey os ia ~ " ah ted ne rn oo fe *: * of 4h HB Py ES wo + oe 4 ees a 7 3 mm Pog ee mS a =: 2 Hoe 3 OAR os 4 Be 2 wD ld ey o © iu cv es w Bh o ag ba 43 wpe NS ed ce * , : w SEES sai ° coed £5 . G *S ce rk oy ve rod "4 ey 1 'a ZF Oo ir eng ke i i a ad wi ' "Fh uy eek og So iE 45 sh et fe i .
Sy a apy j ay nD bea i oy 4A ee is Pec be ip fs g ay % ~ Dae Ad Gs G ey ot : "A 4 : ' if i , 2 3 vd Ld 4 ei ae aS a 3 g be i sO ES be ' ety 3 a wi es a y D %4 i 3 ws "4 oh, a4 3 Da a o bes 2 ce.
S z :
el ie oe i a we 4 aft ea ea ' * fee 4 a ry . ; & os ao 8 oe a 3 : b MU Ty oh 4a si - rr ee ' ot ifs ws ee oN ] et ha 8 a a" fuk 4 ort ui aa Mi © ye Gh 0 ig a 5 Se Hs ans A 42 "4 a " 3 fe Mi . go og g a a4 hy on Be ey id ' $03 & eo . 4 B hee "e 4 or 9 ot 'by ; oe ; ae j eee i sige i a " fl sie 5 ee @ a g 4 ce wf o v 4 os deg fe EA A 4 o Fo a ae oe : bs a 24 ish . & Pe 3 a : oo rs : Bes bi oe : 2 : pe oa et) : "y = Be i yee D we 53 be i : ard 2 : ' oe i) bs ce @ & i oO ay 8 ied q ' i oe 3 © oH 2 " ee 4 i moe 3 Ba Bo ag o a me fe oA vet be Ps 4 4 oa ¢ wd ot g + e C + Bo ye 8 Bog a 3 % 9 w oa i oF a4 43 4 4 ; . : * @ os S i$ Set ue pe @ us e and ve g 2 % ef a & ad a "et yo ie G 3 gon s on aa ° 2 3 * ace 5 3. on :
ae "3 a be £4 i ' z oO & tS * a ey Q G no eH ts = = : os Tog Sige Fe BS oo ooo m --~ 8 gg : Ps S44 F § e oy ir @ 4s be :o) Ba ; 4 ond "C oy ae rae 3 eo fa ° "e ¢ no o i ad 9 o y ws @ re. wi ths "t m4 a o Nat sg ts a 2 Br be | @ % a © "ey os ay fe vate G hi rd '6 * f * a nl iS bt ord * ° i 4 Oe Go ; 2 4a mg, A fe oe » "
Be feo. hee fe Q ; i: i ' ; rs] ' ° 6 ay ES ve "4 a } a4 te ' 4 . < ot S ¢ : eae Ay ty : - eh " 4 % be G3 i wh " a ee ee fe ew Go Bog om 4A u ne ot A a8 nu ag : & a & F a ee we a a oe ua ; " ; ty in = Ha " a nt teat HH sts 4 4 ¢ 3 3 6 e ; * ct 244 mo oad : 1} net a z ' ae as i we g es ue 3 Bg oe o g 6 » : " , © «2 Be ag iv HS ib Be - ve ze rf Hg M tp Be a i w 3 4 eo gt a & a a ~ a ie a 4 Ae at . vet GO 5 . we es " fet a at 6 a u 4 33 iu a Be ot 4 & ere ni " iy Q c i Bo vw @ & & a 8. @ @ % ¢ » 8 " wo 8 23 on by Ae 4 4 4 a : ts cs $4 4 j Fit 4 ot me MS % . ~ 'e be 8 : 6 op , 43 'eA wo ; Se ee co 3 ~ ge) ® 'es : 4 ; ry m4 Oh te 13 3 "4 3 itt - : 8 £4 O cy nt cy 3 f Bow BO mo on Hy Hg 4 6 Oo £2 8 BS a ek Eo & iy if "4 2 , = S 5 s e oo ts Z « a 7 £3 vt ee) beg wee] al ee ba " be} . ; ee " { Y < 3 a 9 BB a a 5 3 3 8 Ms 5 5 oes rh 25 eh 4 we ao % wd a * 5 My a se fs e * a Fe 2 3 a we i ' t ny o s i i ed 4 3 ee) by e g ic & < a o i yy od Py 2 £3 é a YY ph ay 1 es SE AR Pg og to is " e * a 3 3 oh s me a a 5 ie G5 e "
a a5 a3 . ey a ts " ' ny : :
a eS 9 8 g B mM we 8 = 5 0 & oe ao ad A rod 4 5 oe aft . 4 OB 4 eo ow 8 Q 9 te, net i " "3 <3 c Ae rs a ¥ oF ia % £4 a 43 " fee Os r ey ae mo wee 4 +: 7 th
4 ab 43 ce tea a bed 44 & " a te & a i 1th g o 4 a oe & "Y ors 3d c g 43 oo a 5 orf BoE fe t w a i, s 'i iB s ra : :
SAY ae at Eas NE Qo ot we a aes : ; Be ts if is cy 4 f+ Las iy 'i 4 bis th ie : rs bed i o es No .S7938/2017 im % i 6 2 "
et & td 4 % & io ud Aa a walingapps decided on c iM 4 O $23 we 5 ay 4 tA f4 a a « oe uy oe iG 4 8 - ta % os v9 ; ot 8 8 GC Bo fh ye Re g "Ss te Ba 's ae . - . te } Newt fe vd -- G ea $4 bad + x oy , ok da 42 fa : ® Que yg " wa Bos 4 ch * 5 ie 5 % 'i gt . ma i ae £ o * es 23 5 5 ie 5 ee oe * * . k. we £3 : is 7 i gD os a 8 * oy By oped aA a we - | " 3 ae : be GB eg eG 3 mn oo 33 , " a hee % ad be "
! te cs P is eA oy 4. 8 tA ig ee os th id 3 cy eS as M4 cod % a OG "ai bs eh Wo a i ot 4 a 42 4 A wy we we
- "ph ct * he - 4 :
2 , ob 13 o a oF o 3 Bh 2 G - a A . rf ve : Bs bef hs ue at tho i : 3B %y wee fe 3 a "8 eo 3 a ke 2 Ts ree os ad oe q " ay - a £4 fe ae 3 ' co oO g ue Cs a " wy 44 % Be L i ae o % eS Sha . ~ r$ ° bE "4 ee B 4 o i pe 3 ae e by ys "es : Dp "4 a £4 C iy o os a BS es fe So 63 . of : ue A et re iy i mm ae ia S J
5 ub iy ved 3 oe oot "47 +h 4 4 $3 a ed eel id bog oe ie wm eo ¥ a ig w . os & os ee « a ins g z , bee 3 An reed od wv a et t iB ve eo 4 & 4 ua fe ns, Bo eh ag 2S et BED Be @ is 2 "3 Bb one iS O g xt i Ch ys eo Fs ig @ e Q 6 uo B gg ve Pe 4 : me ee PO eas Ce Ms rH OOM a bo bo" a ge & 4 a ' a vy b os ES a Mi B Og 3 re fy 8 a 2 ERD nm G ee * ay $ by oa eu 5 5 > i ea] a a Tht * <P : iB Oo ost 6 an ea, 44 BBS 3 See Oo 2 i & G 4 a4 is rt ih3 ik3 % og cS Be : i .
~ ¥ Sees ake "rt rr 4 vy i.
3 ie ha Sh 4 5 . mee wp ee » + fe s ra o iS > w w © a 2 o ¥ ok 3 % Kerala ATR BOc0 Sc 258 set $5 "
és # o oh gm Ge @ a A ag be (5 ae ret _ Si ;
2 6 $f te % oe a ' ge "
ee 4 ¢ her OS, 5 Be bs my EO 22 a B 5. :
~ * " u i 3 4 es By : : WG G } "h M fe w iv . 4 € < ie w% ts i :
a es ir .
TA ae PS others he ae %.
i (Runhayanmed) another, and sae "an as y a eyes ee BAG wT ae EN % os Bd :
£3.
i of * ce) Bt 43 £3 he 25 hs "3 = ee 6 eh O23 wo $F 4 4 S 4 ned $4 fia fob is i fel ie uy iS ee eet, adel Yo oS com : cd 33 ie SB : nh tr
6) i's es @ u wy SI an Re mS AAS Nos That Saat ses % Po 2 apg pnt.4 5 4
ye 4 £3 t "2 u3 ig ba Be Sc it s § on st Sows a eG see eee gore ey te Nat A Se % PN CS "h £3 hes © "4:
ey, Ue " *e*. 3 wgee aS YN ia fate S Sethe * = v y wa Sx my Uae Aw Bs ' yor ee es aw ae tt mm Be x SY yas rig iS sesh Sot Tok # ee *~ =.
> BS t 4 ta bee' \ ey RS SRS zs oper Se ara cae S + Rota PRS we EE, en § = ws A Sek ed SS Se NN AES gS fy x ws A as yy "Tie tye Ey xe ie eet So & Ma Re Sy B23 . :
Paw SSE Se ey ae ae oe & ee REE AE Se hee! 2 oh Xe a oN PER pee ey : INES ee Aa ee es aA Pea de AAS therwiks SPS e whee. are moe 3 ae aye te a ' LESS REY wee oe EPSELaN AAS Tee Ey a oper Ae wo * : AoE Se Ne SREY ANURRES SRS ET ct . hak 5 = Sees fet AA SAN o eS Aor Sc gs Soha OS Pe ee EE A RE < CE _ Se SNES ON, SAT ey YR SS os x SCAR Se AS AA Y BSS Pass Sac} "at os oe oko SR £3 od £ my, aan ey te DAES & nege 2 Aa ak:
Sees Ay BES Sh 2S a ~ any ee ghey As CS Toes : ae oy 2 : qi 3 vd i { es é ns eo 7 % "
ee Y ae 3 Bt a ae : : m4 BY RS oh re ay: He oa < as seed i ey ' 2 A ie * oes yet eo} 's ae oye: a bey * ey tye Lob ie:
ib .
' i See we cs A Se Xr ks EAS i a ty o % TES & ' < 4 : A ok & = xt & ¥ 4 th fess es got Be; a ey eh i a g wt wa Oe 2 on i Pa rt 3 ADS eed ee ben me cg By Be fe $i ig sas og vO "rt , $ A oy . ba : a ores th eh : nS & Re rt oa be a 1 oy Be z ths
3 1 ca uy ba is 0 oa a3 43 4 then 4 ee ee vt bo, Fe rs Fey tS : ae a wed it iD et a (yo et B Ej ee BS 1 Be Te Ae tH $4 i uy eae i ' by 3 TEE an Writ Pe by EES C ve * Ko ao fo od " 3 es #3 eae ™ a s yeod : : ee, Z % ty :
ca og £% i fo wed £ Oo " ua Ly i a 3
4 ¢ Bhanwar Lael Reqaxr Be oN 3 $ 3 3 3 3 4 3 a of % 3 3 3 3 3 3 % 3 4 4 4 " "4 es : ta "5 i i . oy ' oy " 4 th or Mat Se cA fe a ak e e 4 a Fed re ug ved sr % ei o ret A to bed sdecy i 54h ae (po ad & rt @ @ o aS oe s a B ed ot ve fe ro Bae 3 c : YY at 4 :
Sad oh g w , ah Q oD ag a wy a Y Sek eA 3 $ Aa 4 ci i oped wd at pet q 4 eA 7 i S 3 Hi a a 2 8 " wv BS . os 4 ; iy Oo cS ee spa c A bt * Pa gt rs] ei ~et 4% fe oh cet ; Eat P pee hed gd 4 : Beg Sos © eo o€ gy oe Oo bee hed ie not a ped ;
i G g Ho og a Co Bw be ved we # ce By : oh, Ng By oO =. i i . peed oe 1 A oF ae . 6 Y te ie) e ts i i :
es B 1 ' 8 3 "3 vl 9 ee, O is Mo fa SA s ® 2 1 ; nee hs a G ("$ iy he "3 i g th ' : ; t Cy ° e 5 as a ts es e "a . wed a hed ig g 5 Cu fen' is " Cs Se * 3 a a "it . Se i iB 'ed te © 3 8 ra he re) sot a3 ee 5 b4 1 ra , 2 a et ay 4.3 * fo i ee Sek . un 3. * 2 ; % os iM b fi 44 vir 3 w a 1? ih ey EF & eh 3 ot 2 a 43 % a Md rs ies "rt i 2 a oe int a a os es e by 4 3 Re 4 j ee SS : "E o pel 3 BS a & a w 3 2M ay > oe oy re ie * .
ak ' a ae, be hi i ip th Boge a : a , a Me? 3, 3 f 44 we Be wee bl a vk i is go B + gp . ty ee oA tt & & is 58 ps aes re cs e a 4 i "i Oo fo Be
- q % mS mA wt 4g { mg fo #8 & 6 i bs 5 oe 8 6, a vee} BY g ed pa i et : 3 re £45 ay 9 i 3 os : pes ig cs o Ad or Boo Bae SS ob 8 33 i Boe oe MoE oe Oo Wow ret g i is : : A % :
; a i ' €3 E48 Ba 1G Hy ' Oo oh wD % we rm a3 Re M4 , a 4 ce oo a e ta : 4 £ iy ; ihe 3 2 am ' st % po i o Se m re) 4k & re a4 Uy i ah % i :
aya, Basannsa 5 Shakeel Ahmed Burney, Har Govind Sharme, Dev Karan Mahala and Ore.
vakumar and Anr, 2 ce Bam. Ravan EKumhsar., D8 a3 igupra), s Be ngh Bhat 3 a and &.N_8 x aran Kumhar (supra) Ram & De
--
OPE x ye et 4 a and ar x Fo Ine 5, # § 3 4 mes i KS Ajay Panday v.
a :
AN Singh vw. Union o Man PB. {C) No. 28R87/2012 'e W S. "E3 ved A to rah, abe?
Cu, * 8 2014 (14) x eine UR xt LS ¥ Q gcc 352, (2018) a 4 and Ors., ay pe we Ee Ae Soumya §.D. Mey SN ¢ 78 os Se.
AON Load = ae 5 Rae a was ¥.
+:
syed Ss x ¢ et B ot a *s % ¥ Sey Sed wae BMA s a aN as 2 '2 43 x ais Ne we ee Sao a.
eS son Mea ae ya ies aca MS ES, x & Les & ee hehe Senet Bt a Sy ACA ANS 2 Sle AEA tan AE:
Director of Public be 6 a s Bs) g & 4 pt os a kA Enstruction s x an.
Nat ay CALA ASC, SN Sad hae tena ae EN oe ey oss Lee UR <ee4 we $ wk a eax LEO k ae oS Ryton on eh we PE Ste x Ne wok, ATS Si Ye ae RE iy ¢ Cree a.
Xe glee oe ta Ry Set Q eS a te os SEES Bae et oe ae ar on a:
SOK IT waa cease 3 So:
sae rhs at an oH a we ot ih Ss mes at at A ROS Seperate % Syke erat Sa he s 5 ae ae AMANS AS 8 er Be oh f oN eS 6 ore.
Maree, e aS at ae oN woes Lal SAS how SNS SS t eR ves Bhanwar a Xe OC ke.4
Ke * oe:
with Saye eet Rete 2 2 RE Tt Bat ea IA, ig @ along + Se) +t BS RAO u No. 5558/2001 OA 4 a $ Dr .A.KR.Dawar vw.
yee ved SOAS Set EA oy Sy oN Nw ee at cae S * re 5 S ¢ % ip eS Ls :
ao ae ror ae a Sieg ae
-
sgh a, fete 2 ee io sey Sano SS ent me * Ve Ss. Nee at ke x het $, €:
UN oy Sis as £3 tests:
Pa ee SR NA eae 3 = aS one 4 + Sa +"
Aa RS.
Poo ¥ LS ~ % x & ot eat a SR NS a Se AR NS th 4 ¥ ~ Bhanwar Bad Regar y aa aan es has San Nee?
z ss $ ar ms Ahmed ot % @ vibe % ike bo] 4b £3 "4 ow . a 3 wn me $3 by Sa oe tees 6 _ Fant Nea ke a eer try Pk é Sc ip g an ° 5 ae &.I.Reoplal and. Anr.
"03 ne 8 me Aa ag bis by 4 ea) 2 a ae S er ah ie oy < eS 3 os oy ah Sea 5S ' i Ba a eed cod ip ih vat o3 oo qn $8 . oe A] x whos a a Pe aa ret ae ya hob gi id : es "3 re nt "é gt oe GS i co oO & wm ¢ 3 i wy £3 et eo te ; 4 mt by BS 'a mR a mo 3 Shag i" i 0 i a oe a ' i a 2s © a 3 : mag x o # i EG Oe CG iy i oH ky "y eda yD 4h, in : "4 " ; ef co a 8 38 . a : wh . P heb a "4 A bs gol ct ee ; ~ : Bas eh $e a e a Hl G c 4 : o co, 4 g
6 us Ca & a aD ~ cS 8 > £ aH "ery be of ts Ph:
ad G3 eek ay ' $5 ri "3 was nk A 2 3 AG 3 ne ect ek Ba dat +4 " a th £3 43 &y * wb '5 EE a3 oe rt Be 43 th wo bed aged 4 ts a3 tt {3 4h - ot a bis$ oS et At he uy, it ert is oy ed * ' £04 BS eh 3 = hs ee 4a 43 phe sf aA "cd "
cat wk x3 a "8 Sa x 14, 8 $732 Seen ede ye 4 :
"3 83 ; i3 a oh i et 4 a ae oh ee S "
seed BA oh ed q a 43 A ai es ig iy 42 ts vt ty i. Le a " 4 i bi es oe : . 2 ay 4 . aS A a ¥ Ds noe He wy tt ba fA a o S "Ed ry, De cas ae rank, o = ap % 4g fe @ B th 2 4 Ss é po ae we ids 43 vy - ne % & xg £ wad SE 4 % og got eG y a ce 3 hed be ay 1 2 A = ye wa ¥ ae % er se Ss Ag AN v "s 5
-
g coy ace Se ne & 3 Be Tn AS oe ben « oR pe how © = £ 4 * 2 3 ui Ne eS Seeranes ETN ma SRA ary Mot ae ate Mead L * rae + mugs ine)
2. a rt oh si eh SNR, wat = ee ees aoe ey ao A OTe ee y an capes ¢ ig & @ e & = wa is % i o a as +4 S & i-t M4 o Ss Go ved ot Qo ae Saat ret ht Oh r = ox.
ada "yt te a SoH een! es =o ™ 2 q ad wees Dae Net Ey oy ay AR ess wa e 3 me or ame S = we a we ea 4 s aN, $ a yey A Stn ake! NEN, Saket 4 4 By me, o SANS ts '| Sarees mee RN, = Sh pt Pers = ¥ & t 2 4 ae Se $ #.
ax es tet ~*~ 3 cog Sep = Me.
ena a Sey Nae arte te Na see Ne:
pa tae A we & a £3.
of f Aa red fe Ra Be 4 ws eS 3 Se % x & ek ae a ete ENN 4 4 oe 'ash 3 STR te wu :
et ke ek +e % ow at Nae i 4, oo :3
¥ te oe * + w= oy es AA SS EAt 2 ¢ SON ae wos Se os x Dad os 2 Y Or SD Bed 'el Lb BE SG AD e oe aa ty ead ai oe ity v4 rt a 3 . ao x eee ek ¥.Najithamel and : $4 is te oe she ip a Ch Ae 4 ved . 5.
¢. "ES @ , © G 2 a hay "5 me "w 8 4 a + be 2 2 es on wd 4 at $4 fe wi 3 . ag -- D 3 v8 fs . rt pe oe as © ey ef A es i 4 a We cS @ er oO ae bod tA ry Shed sy a £44 vod 4 mc 2 & is q } 3B Mo 3 ce sue * BE ips red hg eh Pee "er q ; a if oa a3 a med ayy as id Pi Bog LA h § iy 7) oa we £ a is 6 f be ee | ved co :
Gs At , KG 6} 53 i ci ;
ot y aa Hw a iy i "
Nw 3 Soe See SAR ESS = Ska ek Bey Set na $ = Nat ~ ey wes Sox we EES KE ee ata Sa Se & cad oe w oS ft a q Se en 43 $2 3 Te RS R.Santhakumar oy 44 coe teh tae. bas A she a ¢ a * Velusamy wees = Sak SE ae he VAS i.2
Sats A x & * a AIR 1973 sc 1461, agoe % id
2. we 3 Soe o PERE = SOF od See Pan Non?
pe va 4 i State of Reralia, Y we s eos Bee 3 i
-
was Eee me ANAT Sharats ey 4 £ 3 peed Ar and:
* oN ae 8 + sAbdullakoys ce ELF i t y Noga ey eke Saw SEAS "
Wis Nee EN exe! » i B ee ees x A ote madkutty vi 5 et 2ig, a Nae War da ae Se & tT Li a ry ek Co:
K } a 2008 (1) BLT eS Se Ettappadan Ah 2006 (4 x, = eR EO q way Be ee at an ate aN ¢ os 4 'sa NS Ss San gan he ;
aed ;
SRS ore :
ye (Dead) , ye Pi Swe nt oe ve Kanhaiya Lal See Sy.
wy MS Sao SN te oe Ea en Mamaleshwar Prasad ¥. Le t, t a aN, BAe See 4 Ret hake SuA a AIR 1975 Sc $07:
SNS SRS cates fe Bae SS BEER AF Se x geet £5 5 eg ba ee £3 ved he go B eae i ee Gay ¥ os 2 ey aN doo pend to Us seg poy
a) 4 cp 2h ' 64;
to a 14 Sor bivad "
ao ae ewe Nee my SE eRe s Mazdcor Cengress DT...
we Transport Corporation .
* Supp, SCC 6800:
{L9o1) oP.
MP DOR AS = .
ee £ : ey Aa Ra ey Ser Sw.
& MN ES S = CRONE = ¥ eN we A age hs See om Ne MOF Ba oN os y eH as MLO Synthetics & Che & fs Db a © ' 2p tg as uy oa) wy
3) ss
o) th.
S Sanat wa os ay rd G as +4 <S Ao AO SS:
~ Tea x Rion aA < te Xe ihe at city of the Corporation 1 nicips Mu (1970) Chandulal Shamaldas Patel, e i ASS 4 hmedabad v:.
ws Mx os SES tha ew et tes VN 5 (1977) & Ch B jJassel 83 2 aie Rolman , 'Pampton v.
i , 4 (4 i ae sad Ft cy Bee et at 2 1% oh wd ey bE h tS ed a at as 5 i ae 4 nt "
eo " we a a 4 ot M 2 me < oe on -- Ve ar ki a oy oe Te 6 B $e 4 or : bet PS es Bristol Aeroplane {1883)24 Ch DBD 633, Ke te Fay 3 = keg i rh a S ard "A$ e £3 3 a oe : * A «e uA fag ne ud "8 os sna at ia ved 4 o «a s a ue : a
- iH et om : por & "£5 of ect ¢ % -- a eo . ( vt "ES £5 a ot 47 = os pad $n wet a a ie i ue "
e rf wy cof ea hi Bor G § eee m2 wn o it , : ee A ea * a ' G ba 1 ae :
> eg oe i. 3 "
: $ oo : . % 8 ay a fed iS " a a o id iy oe Snot és a : ; waza 3 , "ES fet a4 oon ole 83 %G 43 is 4 , ZO a Oy i 6 . " ai ond fy A 3% .H s B® a i ' C3 eG iB Pa we BH ved AoW ek Mo @ n "< ae # we a" ree e + WPF ved C2 2 Be eA As > oe Fe { . Fi mabe wt of Ae ort go ; eet ka 5 ; 44 1 « tA 4 es
2 "oe # he. a ro te "rh rd ia ay & Oo 8 BG : 4B 43 43 sw eek Bf 4 et 4 os g * x + me bas $34 84 bas gy eo Chi 3 fae "vA So oO + fry ca) oe % pais wy ag te oe =e 3 Lr aN ts Se o Rand 2 sy eee' Ras Sse x .
pap aaa es a B 4 a 4 as £ 4 y ;
t TaN a RS FE Sy:
y wee es oy an s ~ ¥ Lge i Ss Tan ye 2 q Pat "ts.
* ket Y = wie ASO.
Bees tnien of Indias Sow Sy a Ses 3 es 2h ¥ ae "
¥:
a a Se tes SAR te were Employees v.
¥ YS RONG v y x "5
oes Nan AE NSE SANS s, fey he sae er ee eye nce: me , eS wat sa National Unien of Postal vt ae se LS y Aad me Naat SS nts wack y A Ss a ne Net y, e
4. eA oo ws ae a e G a 4 a Z & oY = 3 ue apd eS a Re ad Wot ee SAA.
ua wy oS aye Ke ey ee SS ae see SRN * Surendra "
24fe ¢ 3 be Ste, 3 os x pos s 3 3 ake we ae $ NARS £ 2 a .
oe eens Sh gS s at 3 Ah e ae os he NaS Se at oN ee ae eee Nes 4 We cf ale.
ee * os, & 3 4 2 hs £8 Peas aaa!
-
Peeplival oF aged oy ahs = aos oe 2aT?
S 5 Neat ee No. 5009/2012 MF ed 3 Sa.
PP otreny + OUR.
iy Kunhayammad & Ors.
Cee Se oer as ey G Es) Es sd a3 a bt ua g i vet & et i a gt 3 os Sys a ed os z BANE Cae ae hee Says eee SSONORE Sy Weel Sat ose Mat UA amt RK. Kulkarni ee ~ we 1259/2014 Bhanwar Lal Regarisupra) SAK Ne ee ke ~ Sgt SINN (supra) .
SS SE SY Ors.
OA Nea.
oy 1 * a As sk RE z os Basanne Nayak (supra) s Shri Wes Bhanwar hal Regar (supra) £ °2 hat Union of India and Ors.
age é et 13 £3 os gat ER Swat SP ee : --
Sete ove
5. RRA RK ae "t Se {supra} PS SAE Fag a SAR kat e z SS SARA A en Le Taka Se yetes Te ae os Shivalingappa ar ey Rees a 2p isupra) M.Sc.
ppa ay ate Se a (supra) cin tat as SA SE 3 alee M.G.Shivalings Ae ey at haw ea oN Basanna Nayak Rar Bhanwar Lal Regar, "+ eet mernks Sel Nh nag ARTE wees?
ied Gt re yaad Ae Sa Nae CAA et aS onan & $4 a 3 tm ree! ig wd B a x 6g g Gi (supra) phe h Prasad Sharma (supra) ts vw sere NA RSS vy Jagd, AZ.
oF as:
eo Natrac' SAA ae, = x ana thamel ay.
Govind Sharms YN " a ep oe as ifs 3 u : ood Be © AD po 3.5 GG cae ' Oy is Set re ws es Spd rs O a ts A oy ix ay oy hee: es 4 4 = Cog 3 3 :
be cs a : % ey Bs § hoe ay ved te et ot Fe ° We ia 6 t 2 eA a i ee e o ee phx GB $4 4, if 4 é a bon e : a ie ; S ' «& : ae §: 3 ES G44 7 Ss . 3 es me Ss :
oN Sg 4 Bes . 4 .
a x 5 a re Bog 3 ' | : M a a . fet ae rt best : 5 :
fee ae 4 a ' ms oy ir ' £ Bs 4 e oh it 3 a % D ra), : a :
"e 4.4 is & iy S oy 4 5 ¢ 4 it % 8G i gd & o on opt % 3 . ' 3 . bd < 0) S "ed a "4 & C4 % a BB oo ay ee & e: . 6 Z s rt ye " & " 5 iy ws fad a 43 ed ibs i a . aS 3 4 £5 oi £3 ie x a ® ig 4 ay ' . epee * woh re os : "ah cs rg fs Mi Bes G e 8 & a fe E 6 i} be x * sf 5 ; : fe me ' G a cs Q id 2s 5 io a a 8 on G i ; ¥ ° : - : ose t ¢ as rf 8 e a3 oe a a 4 A A My ee Le 2,8 ae, a ce ;
ey fe.3
is 8 ny M4 fe bh < aqdis ad ed x rd i a z 2 ig a wu xe Ry tek oe.
¢ oe oa ce pee At oe = Pat (supra);
Ore.
& Velusamy Santhakumar x rR e APR Satchow oe 3 Nas Ch 2 of eles nb raeet os WethS ott A ae Nk, isupra) , Bhanwar Lal Regar Bhanwar SR.
Har Gevind Sha Lal Regar oe CR A Ae ae {supra) Bhanwar Lal. Regar (supra), = Rory ay a Nt Se ES Ee Ne ¢ £05, ao + ™ Cees De NE AEA ew ANS Sar Qaet ae Net SARS Sones:
pas 3 bd x i ¢ Sy oe St SSN RR ony Shue ee oe s x, SS a x OY CA ¥ 4 ay es
5.
ote KAR x %, Toa (supra), Uttam Singh gay oe iat Nay oN £ Fes 3 < ' $ $ ar SS xy:
Se as VAS SRESEOS ae ae AE EN A at MS ~ s! ye a SAR ARS {supra} s i g ie % q 8 he 2 ts a a a g fe a ws ea Se 2 Xt .
Pe x = SAA,
3.
ey Na a Si) 5 sek {supra} ¥.Majithamol and Anr, ras ort Peg Recah ac met oy y 3 Na os Ne:
f ee ous ya A Pa ss . Ss Tas ae re re a B. of weed t nf 5 o : if iy £1 4 s : :
4 oS whee BI o Gg MH op Kx a os Gi as 9 a x bd cl o pe BA is a Ae 4 a fe u 4 a 2 ms t - Le 4 " aco} - et G3 #E ay a ' es Sd i a :
" be GS 3 ay ; Gy ed nf
- yo Baas i a ua 44 ao hy red bee *K im rey ory i . AB ay Mee + "
4g ue s go & iA Go Sy e tf P Et oe a as fy oy Che ify ih ' + 4 gon¥ a ; g By 4b ve 3 go RE wv A 3 is be Gh co aA ° 3 3 | * a2 ; od 6 a ; 'A 5 ay s ae a « a ks ve . i "i : Ye "4 rg a3 ie oo i aa t ee ea me a oy i 6 =} ved " gee G Ke i ogg i i up aK a wy oe nt = wa fa "0 ted m Whlttihiae ¥ { pot 'eget o% ~ 4 i) ' :
i tA he bt 3 % 46 ¥ cs. tt oe 6.
Ma iy G i ; @ vel a 3 a ih a, & ae Dev Karan Mahala a:
h4 vt ae eo & :
ay & i 4 4 5 ie Gi O & . ced Ls a a A :
en ' fet 84 % 3 Ram Karan h Brasad Sharm seth Be ee oa Bh er act ew £ i it * 1 ip ved os $f y 8 a is As ip hi "ed et 3 a oy wt sp oes C ry 3 a .
eh Q te a a a My a ; =, oat +4 v a ss : : a a . a mF a be OW oo ios fs wt o ke ys ? w Gy " ' v4 Kt @ y ' co] Bs B a #3 : ie) @ eg io ae ty ed aes % od C ee Be a ts C3 Oo Gg 43 ad 3 os od tse4 (3 by of a i a o t CE be u BSG 4 a e i ae ba 4 ca $4 " hy ae ¥ of} Ad cai £ G 13 ing sid ad G ta eG ta net a iy eon " fig od 1B oe $33 % 5 % ed a <a iow (3 alee ix tng os ha iA 8 fi a oe gy * 4a 4d: ¢ aa a ey 8 oo ry a a a Pa 2 bem on Q tet ai [a a . ee KS : "4 oy oy m3 : ee " ee ded oe os : bk web:
ae ci % hs ey $ eb bt w a i 3 rack eG: des ged, oe we 63 SS Bt rh é " ; 7 : eo 7 i % .
ES rie es "rd . a 6 ay te Gk Cs ut es aa ian ont Gi oO ¥ ij om 4.5 oe a as o ved v wa oa aged ry ul iG , Natvarbhad x t af i} "34 a a "rt So 6 | by . a @ 65 bok aH he md is oe at ig 3 } ard <3 os + Pe 4 ae ut ct Ry ae oy "a ' att he mee 4 ee ee 7 3 ieee A 4 " 3 Be @ eg 4 3 ui ors Aa B tes 1 . a a A v4 . se a ie 4s : g 22 4 "8 a 6 ® 6 ea & uy G 0 me - : x fe uy ea by at Bee. f % eo 8% . B "3 . 3 Boog Bo MG Be aa OP u a w 16 uy a co ae) a ae fe ; a B 8 ch ae o et vf oo & Li - ce oe # a ei 'si a 8 wt i 4 et Q & is #6 " we $s g 43 i ae Bye : "4 @ 6 * P MS ged a : ve "eS * 4 st UR o wv mx ree 8 g vk ey oy y ' ec "xs ea 4 ged a bo % G Ss s ae 4 et | a3 chs a ia ced ah oy e 3 Ci Ei * i % . oo e e h eer * nt 5H Es an weet iA Chew iy & aged ees RS ve a Bg 43 ra o el i 4 Sees) 3 a Wo A ° "es 3 gy a YS OF BS bab org Bs Leesan
-
Ye if 2 ree.
yeh een cane aes CRA A Ti ete, SUAS RRS eae Nee ok! ees Sey ° SATS ~ a aoge sets eee Lt?
| i HS ~ = fravke MEMBER~"(A) RV at (RAVINDER KAUR) MEMBER (J)