Central Administrative Tribunal - Cuttack
Sri Dilip Pradhan vs Archaeological Survey Of India on 6 September, 2023
a alithe OAs} 2} Wye pn, yet "hee wea aaa all > as 4 , Poe.
itt 4 wre, baod pane a % on) we, " tee A& i | tes af :
os, feten, ra | , : vers : rie : pene, af "4 : .
are frm 3 . x fetree -- neenee f "4 Un ae CLS ;
Ch es j weewes, -- bittnws 7 ae EE nee Sonn bettas , eevee 7 aM ' Prep? fw, we plan '5 | torr £ psd | 7 ~ noes ores, heen ott ; .
weep ~ ated Pig i :
obey | : :
, pee wage my 2 pew se ten oe RS : ere 'nape ne , ot £0 aa es) tne ee ae : +4 ma, Br : S me ae) heeirne "
te ot: fod Nf AN > ;
fOUE Nene' é .AN yore an an ven wee peg Susan wees : = pees fis 3 od :
Pasa pad oo ye ra 2 % ge Pree.
ms f sn
- om log. ¢ ae ts ; |
2 pe een, : oe pes Eon ae Pee Lenay "aaa fen Fig ange see gy, pom poet pons m2 od Lh pee net La San.
bre ges By ns * oe pea acs ir) Pa coed spent: anne aed.
--
. ann hed eae oe ge fees, 4 a ee ea Rtas $ be, sd pas Gow 0; Th Z ae ca are pres, bog th nent ret ae OS are aman fm, 4 te.
'ot OES a det om, cork . ", GS esd cca aaa' ere oon es ae a) " a $ o Ss eos foes en 6a a oe warer cans wee, : hee? 7 yer Coe fe gee pan vere Leh a. : Ded aeons ° Fass) Se ryor pe : it ; a ye fs ver ea on Sy ieee pees frodee a thn nh Lu. fe een ren va of pri, bey, ones, we "anges vod jee vf tt fe = 2 4 yee rat aot tab ne, Be ah Ba Poe Fae wo weet ahs t " oe of: * % wed 'Goedk * wo Fae | £L% > cs oe a, on ee g FS ae ° Meer rae ae pare i wed Facue aa) a 'nei 7 He: Eq My 5 ue ged Rane ae i we ra ne wes », . ae erat At acy oy ret Soe, vat at , rs, Su3 Wray ae ak ee ree ' hd peees, £ . is oy pa a deed ee a So ye gh " ; a oy i aS is GA 74 wP roe Stang ee kod : 3 Bard ha 'sagt Cea So RE, ae es Seed oe is) my beck A a eS & , CR rere geen be bad Ps ry aa oe ed ew npg EB ar x baa a ee OG & ch atom Ban St an, vith ae wy aged, on, hed oe poor 'nh Hy, bat ben boned mS eA Ra Ce me ome a x Fase Pr ot on aT tn, See, pet ", $ ee A bead ae WE naeee 3 Ni, fe es beet pate na? s Nr, won % That : a, ie Cp ae EE aa = Oe : Snot om gent LY: Net oe nM aacd ie tot prs, tft Z : arene * ae zn oe Wa hog a Diag prod ROE ite tal ¢ gre on rh boot Pres Sal et eon t oe bes Ps as Seo ta oe Co an Fao | Saba OO ak ge ee 4 a if % bea pie Este * oh Nt i Nat on on one er pes Stee et wees a 4 £0 ee kot ees net ices oo ingens face aah Fa fen hE pee we ies * 'tes, amt int pa Seat Pat pie OR ett ee isk PA Facet oo yee ews. pe wht Nah 'Aig re as 2", et a oot ms linn, spon one ee r S Tae : ~~ roa ad roo : eon 3 at ie 'nad ont Pe pa ati, a jemee wr Sead oe peor) PS wnt os, roe al % ~ a Wea lest fe Bt ym, ters wa * rt, a5 Sat ae; : ae oy, aires fr -e oad : aS, Eaoeed ; on on pais ae ads a on, Seti, 3 arett oe S ra oa yr, ca OK, yee' a rm 6G Sg ' mE 3 eee, peed ae pene = ° uy cat Te we 2 bee " 3 LSS pies on IS ie ah S Z : = & pets = 5 o = . aed 2 we, whore See oa ae ka 63 . a - Ce Cuz seal caer ne co 2 Pg g aren ;
4 vee ~ ca) ws ca " Pf, erg Pout eZ " ae " oa z m pane pratt eae te = :
we wenn ' ; am = vas Ay S ; « ie a : o oe rey = a ie ra a, nt oe = pn AG 4 oh < Som Z : ) " -
fas cs " 7 oe aol S - ae 2 iS a er * ae sien, = ~ c iat jet e ue é 2 Ltt wt 2 2 2 We ra = e x : ware a) toad 23 pot * orn roe rae e baad ae Sore ;
: fa . ~ re Xs : 3 2 im . 'i 1 om * . AR fied :
spend ron on cn we ws, "eee sae ioe Fa} eS Penal " geri Pub my wooo, sad Me, i 'eit deat cee i cares ' be : s wh 5 ye as) pag m -
we} "4 Ley % -
| ee werd re ! | oe, . nen ae 3 mem onpbe pa se oe aed 'ease : 2 E
- an aes ee "
y . -
Fak Naot wa oa of pone, om aoe fos ey | id Noein as ad Fat 8 > es oy ed n. = : ~ oe ret ws, i o! nal 4 "nae wen os | aS : Fed pit fea os a es ' t on ra em poo we " ; E 3 ra a ae "a Gm os cs a 7a we ween, oe ;
Fi 2 rate os "s oe ed Zz i mS 3 £ ff & Z a ) ~ ae feast wen oa , ae ; | | : a" rei % fen 'os a og mS :
£ em _ S 2 % g oth or ut x nego rae) [ans wdeen ca eek aed nea * ao wD Se omens hed pk ~ i & : oe rH : S74 "nk ¢ oe "
set aed oe 2 3 : = jon ee, rt veo Se fax ed ~ wee 4 ann. ed een, ont bao : . tat 'not 4 we foo" ap re ft a . Zs ie "a ome ~ ~~ bane ah a mt : itv, ms me wares, "ne ver mS co, tus fs a Z ; :
om per, te & . S moi en it ea Laos "ms ee mi Sy a = C frp foe os wees < , a oo food "os "ee lost vom < é ae > 'eon wy Pea Fee #66. ae Lak facts "het oe z rt fuk prved ~ on pe om : ioral ° -- on : & = z hex 'esha aad pe 5 = 2 . pans * b x fat - ; 4 = ion: od fetes * ony es "-- ve ae ohh oe Lad Prd et . Sat to TUNE a ¢ oe paw;
A ae Or = ac be pes eo wen 2 Pee poy FES ind Ee Beat Sab tre. CS we aa ° EG age fn tae er Sar aenet CO 'en be en _ ey a ceca' fod re wen, pe sh nepeg eR fe 'ell GR bre pom. a sag! een a, * a4 tat res rae OAK inna oe) eae ane Saat ee ; ae % set ae as pa oi meg es rend ri es fae ert Sed pees eng, OE feed ee) gm gm aa os 7 po, diet pas a a oe
5 hen Soot ht oe "anna A pay Sect Won, neeed Ck * wn et May pets pes ney 23 Vagos oe aad 2 ae ee noe. Ba? Hy. ak a ate ot om bec nn rn?
nob Lae! mea 3 pad Seok <t ae oe pony otter. we os tet ie een, g veer a ae t St ME ceed shot ict aags Sea's ' oe ee ee vers "wa ¥ Fahis! Shy eee is gS Fey tego ah 'prood 7 F na het oe oa 2 g eS o ie fh tt ie Eee Te Aes eet Y sep ne EE eae as an er, a fate ew pena wee Tp tft % 3 fons, ont Pe iy) ni Co Re oO weet OG OO pw Bl Sa "eat > Sena : ra oe. rap A pe a a ae Pao an pee pon yw, Be veers thi' weet cee. Tew | aR ES wes of eek pe shed pen rn, Losi ap et aes ew ont i eB ee LOR, on, en ne 2% me. So TR. pints ey pe Eases anne *. fom Saat wets, Pecans ca: 0 pes:
Coon vena ON ae, ns ty RO % Shee Cok Pade aaa es vo, Ce fet Of nano: Smart om jee RL pe eee "
[OG 50) coi ci peed pas 3 ge . Dene ' fer pas ie sg: Seng 'weil 7 ae . oan sy NC:
et a a 'i at ead Ft i os, os .
toad ope' ye po Soe ae, a were £0, wees, Peae] wow TR pres porek wn, aad Cook Senet ere z wa, | fone "et ' eee wee.
orb nee vr Mh a me te 4 ta, OCS ¢ we ee Ky et Masog wort win hd aoe rie LS go oe ok a ee nw, Vy Ow eee Me a Mf be ae mm at PSE Ok peon wore ek tree Le ZL vw ese foe ee ten vat. eg Late where, Sony geen pay ' ¥ 3 rea z ' Z - cn Zz Foes! 'eet soon : yer ood wy ¥ ord 3 en oO ee Par ' % heed Os . rae AY Pe tee ww meh Ete ee or ace S05 En angel Saad meh as Sy eh ha nrc ie, who rettn weong ES tb pron Hie ante spot fae tp pon ne a pe ot ted * dae UD H pee 4 4 fue 8 ¢ S nee oe Bove. beh 9 Oe roel Pres a ies oon ; ond yer, oy oy, oer pe Wey ea Cad " wee ee 2 ya oon jew Patel re: he poe a nae wR, os tp omg om OEM te 4S ; Sh, "at ce s _ oe St wars J o arg) Senet on, ae hhaog 7. . wn ay TR A bah wom tah yo, he? Dewey wt a SO et ae" gon net rn Ce XE re, a3 +e oo, aad fe ne me G2 ty tg yg ED Laat rh ; care} ° Fa oN, ph peat what «OR ee em 4 on So ae . no mm 4 We oF Bx Oy Es a +" vee eed Ceoens tat ? " Ay fe pon, ed ocd aed is oe og an " te % Lanne ae eee 4 hes Fe ? , ae o aad nope : oes ened. be B ta va guns oe ie aren, (aed , 4 nnd aed. ae ob " ee oly gee we hd po oe ay aye To ce Ta @ a _ ~ eof Rh ee wi PG : ae) Se mpee ED 7 aa 'ets pa O98 x ni ag wade OE A on spe, Nee fy as ess Mo tS ee ve wherd, Ge baa =F) Fig) "and ie fhe a aye S Beit, ad eet ' fr % tewp, CO cet fin OSS bet paw me tage: coh pees Sua poaed nn 4 aaa rs aad rien S egies Pasi 4 ih 2 ern ed vig eg ¥ we, OD Died as to, aot ave rE oe ew cones a 1 ton we SO ar ok 'et iret . ee on Sab ? r ft lated 'neal a aed ay eee ment 1Lt oes lamea eaees "
Po nat a 5 pened, oe, Q ay vat at we ~ ald Sy on hen oy hp me fat ne Zod wed 4 Sood a5 cae} Oe nen fens tele, ma. 7 ck wee 5 ced ; heoe im, 4 we OM we ws co aot i ogy te one , eve Seren: moped mio wee aoe Pa nr as ons he ff pores wt on, wee om Seen aad ete, Saad 3 faa es mead a a ef oe at Cs ee. the oo tah : a4 aa . res yom € pas ~~ "i on fe ih gem. ies eee, : : : m © gM jones mee peer :
a ue how On OE Fated a ws f we ' gen aed Fao gam pon "™ Pa ay ' dew ann, PaEcasesl Ges pais oes 1 ete RY so i a ass in Sof 3 Ae bs aa oe pee ta en tS $A atned --gt, ae hace ie epee won pee abe fed etd mm we wet. pate wow nd xo ee fen Py pa Cpe Sees eo Lang twee wen ae Pend ad " "na ny of 5 sea IE coal 'a oA on rand aan hab 'aad on ' % _ y oy Ge Gy ae ected ora Pore nant a Ne, 4 os ; pa d 7 food yO 'ae os pana re By Wt ihe o ie ze a Pe te ne ES wee ¥ " a 2 $ £0, "4 eee) jo on ww ei ae Oe ty Det We Pea awa ay Vasa ox ae fen, pe Ne bead ee "note eee we Peed shen ra rm a3 fo oo honk fa, rn ees $s bene ma ms fa * pes wy Heed me, SS a eos , we we it > ot ney gt tS om Cet id . ond on Peng spent bail ny we I te . te «pen, os! Lae wn Nagad Foaal an nae i Oy were T re oa aad 5 Be ps nd wre i Gut ey wf we os at ees permed pe eee in ES 4 ca an ot, a om CS Ce atte Sovke. base Bet ged we poe, nee esl is were
4 Honk og Mra, eee. Cad ay tetag BA Son Te were ae , a 3 wm OS om aoe 8 SG 4 fed pe be ty " ns a ey boot ase "De, Faas ans eee pe ty rend rd ET eees aie ae ae bod wae rae ad s ans ' Data we ~ aapod: con 'ovr. ern od 4 pipet, +3 on ~ a gee pee OS L nod Ge a7 ot ont Focal ae rot ed . of ~* cy oa ne, ay, te oo ' oo oy "a ra 4 if "e eee wes we a we Spo Oe EE $ meres wed ae i es 2 2 gp eee oe aaa a op ied : ee om, Seek ere mE, rot rem ot nw a, st iy 3 t 'gh . fora ee, a3 ang" Raped P par my wn ne 4 'sa Pat " had Lf wy ¥ Proved "ae wow ee Gp pot Se, ge ee Se baie tied pes, a pe aa ada' essed Sone ae wind ty ie bea com oa FE GS ™ 3 be ae OF yer. % en ok or ae 43 x weed: A om, pit eed ad a net ;
Cae fie ety eamese gf enenyeg) Ris CSesee QP tabs eds a] y B3 arder canneh Re on could up course yh cases in a have their own policy for mer. But as per pou ea ang < ees should be consider N rar BORK riiculated in the order the decision fo a casual worker ta ger ios afa regula ji has been taken by the t ety ¥ te x oe pacy ea ge py ESE es : a : ~~? > eee GQ ASHIYE. Ce ES lar faire & a yA ayy DY, One ing is clear that t ol ap ais cam be summarily thrown cul. The Respondents need te keep their cases under consideration under suitable criteria for conferring 1/30th status by following the guidelines as the Government as laid down by the POPAT in their OM. dated 07.06.1988. fis also very important to ensure that discrimination and arbitrariness should be completely avoided in the matters of such consideration."
=?
jased on the above order, OA Nos. 497 (2017 and &7 (2015 earher 4 gi aw kl eevee SSEERES { respectively were e applicants fn DS ed of leaving the matter to the respansents for ronsicderation as per the earller carder referred to above, However, in all those respondents fled different-differ :
ent writ petitions before the Hon'ble Mish Court of Orissa and the Hon'ble High Court of Orissa wes p feasedd £6 disposed of the writ petiions with oirection that the respondenis to ~cordance with law, the order of the Tribunal and Pee v wa a yee yee.
pw wed pee pew rin > "
ates PS ran banca hao on nx aa ee:
Lt of rd tend et * eve rm vat ra the scheme of 1993 and grant the relief to the applicants, H they deserve
8. in erenotance af the arder af the Hon'ble Hiei By Me wet reine Sonne ao ead peel eet Booted Respondents comsids $ red the case of the applicants fndiicual faim and communicated the reasons of rejection vide orders impugned in the QAs. On perusal of the 29.01.2020 (4/9) impugned in OA No. 627/202 is extracted hereunder oe "tn commllance to the arder of Hon'ble High Court of OQ dated IS.07 2019 in WRC) No. 5180/2019, the claim of Shri Dip Pradhan, Ex-casual worker In ASI, for grant ¢ hs 3 neal of wages based on 1/30th of the pay at the minimum of the relevant pay scale and other benefits was considered in accordance with guidelines and instructions of DOP&T contained In thelr ek Vek Tecee, TEER aael oe fsege abeha pace cree cte ameter OM 7th June, 1988 and the facts of the case are as under L. The e applicant Sri Dip Pradhan, was working under Archaes logical Survey oof india, Bhubaneswar Cirele. S Hhubaneswar. The applicant has never assigned the duty of the erstwhile regular Group - D post or that of Multi-tasking otal ( aT 2 most. Ia fact, the applicant has been working yurely as casual labour under the C onservation: Assistant of pu a Bhubaneswar Sub-(frele, Bhubaneswar against sanct toreodd estimate and specific work and the wages are bei ing ps all tes ead ore, iO "ae! 'not as Pang Saw.
a few s "n, Faacl fete oa we wee, psa cael 3 ves S35 wi tant ht 4 4 tht ke fees, we = ay ee fan ee cases cS ot ne e 'te ee os LOM pea om et fe OS cowed sep case pes med hoot, D caass 'ad * PR a a ened, Pea ae ee ae coe x Oy oy Bort nes thy | 00m, Ay Pangea Tae a3 S ens, ee Saeed wy eg nt As Ga, <a na Mer ar <oMecene. hs dent chad " "ot Beg Been, ie. "ee ae "
Rood wae pes oon se eae cones By So wm, TAO erin, Ps pivot om Te dhe od fo ree ang a ine tad ¢. < ~ on % o wt ce aad pert, eh we eds ites ie] eas Siem Heed See COE fone *. . weres: mt Fe oi csr) ah , Tae ' we 6 freee need, fre Set we ys ee Weser we, few As bad we as 4 ne wa To ped th a wn Spek ze ¢ ie , py IAS: ne 7 YY Leo Bad nettol ae ieeser4 ~ coo = S ste LS ome phan 0 bl TLE ops NE ax fare ¥ Bes ae ee, " Pee ped pacesel poe cs " eet oy UE: Bp. we Gy Sond es aor a ¢ ye Re te ae aoe, ty Cad MRR, een Oe Spa want i» GH oo 3 te, neg . os pire yon tf, bok i orn OE net ge wee fred acon a PO peers Home Te pee pe . Pe ee Te cane cd 5 ac, A See : Pm a co Tod i cea ; POS oe ance 16 MEE on braid Se eon reed nin: ee Tac) pen OOS Log Nene oe ES: eR pms a a Sed te By Behe ES Q : Be IRE sig -
» oe nS Boi ge 2 eo ' ; pod z 4 24 Nh OM pee Se con cet oad on D past or that of MTS {Group - C} toy qualifying to get L/30th of the minkviam pay, 4, That, the casual anon reys fave been engaged as per the vara ty of wo ork vision kept in respective estimates, on SPE ng ta availability ef work and also keeping x ~
5. That me Archaeological Survey of India pe forms the conservation, preservation and pr tection: af Centrally Protected monuments against various estimates. These estimates wind-up after completion of a | yticular wurk utuler speciiic estimate 1 APY Pea yrticular manument/sife, So providing of regular work for entire month or entire y year to rhe casual | le Hb surers is not passiine. However, labou rers are being € © ore require tient at work as ms sgsition. No wark woul be une rovision el eithe er in ne «yee 'ly put ; .
Br CAMISOIVE at ian et ed manumen iS. Therefore, Such centrally "protects od OTHE nts is "not perm anent an perennial In mature, partic nua work the "casual abourers are diser veaged. At times Pehem are also engaged In other subseq uestre ei wed ¢ o jee.
ee , Jeotice aed on oo a we eas os, iy wee act boa me yee a nen wed yes "ant rete ve Nae
- 4 Naot ew wt © e some oft stimates where there is provision of work and availablity of fund and gomelhnes rot 6 Merely because one casual labaur completes 2) days in 8 year or In 3-4 years engages dd against one work or the other afi not automatically make him eligible for grant of wages based an 1/30th of the minimum of the applicable pay 8 cale, plus allowances. In order ta be eligible for rant af said bene a he has to fulfl! the mandatory criteria laid down 1 NOPST OM dated OF.06.1 5988, Le he should have been engaged against werk of regular nature.
rantof 1, o discharge the eee, em ber ted fen aa oe pd 'eons : ros Nae min a the tran 0 POG TERR é x x x EPO "hy + rer OH Perec' OS, suered ord :
eiy prayer 2 x yse th as apl ¢ % $ e of the a Cas the ts conestin % g Jar polt 'aken sum » i SEP vd ta "3 2G seat Wt Esaieial £3 rad aa o% a hes = ce A waadl 'oe respondents in ther coun wing the reliel in grat xy ;2
at QP Camere t a Sr a5 = peers, hed fee ele a LLL AARP PALE wer ae anne food ay Sd.
'eat Paaad Foaal ne, Det pate Ee abtey eae om, i" "aath on & oun fee . ms As, Saat th pee on ered, ween aha ae vos, , oe fed Ln ven Ciné on ert of mets ee, sot ete bes he ape ns oon wet oe Pt iow ot shoot pan Aa Babes 4 oe ai ad 5 ¢ Ay Enagl pee:
eee. oe) ' i beet A ar ad x ure India, Bhubanesw + lah .
UYErs x a alee in et * bees Ly we 23 pated fe, Cv"
a wt es ft peed Bek aaat:
. Tada oe w es CoA pent pe re ere ie Fons " ents thee ;
yee rms Ieee on yore, "ott wenn we Send Eons yee ae Sa eel ha ged shook bai LLG Sab erage * "nee ~~ aa pen cel weatrads pee oe hove e am, vee, i o " 'habeas daaee ae # Coe " fee Group-b, he.
i 5 ee oy us 'ot. pees + con "Cpe, an f <4 ed vo erty we ed bre aad % A ms gy Peat Sone "at ee te, hes wer tes er a Yorn, deans ab me et tenn aay es rae lat oes be pawl, : tens aed teen bea wr e and, thes y ;
fone , [ae 7 he ued, rs re o .
poled:
QPori. tt has .
} x nh ottement dated 1S Jerts that ¢ EHAY > s arbitrary and contrary fo th ny ine er inte ded:
ae a ook fey re rt res aad' eed ot wed Yo granted Lyst ets s whe had been s prerseRcee ss CR R 3 < the casual | gree « & % AS Coot & $ e z DA, <7 a mth as cl ef s he rel fort red 4Pay ts h an appl 1 &, x suinisel fort af <y nthe ei x t x mission mac h e Su ere fF ye ing 'aly rs hand, ?
othe & BES +:
yd the m a x Sy di the terms Ka & 'a4 rey ZB 8 = a a SE SA ny ae : ne eed alee eee bers) Ys ty Sh an peered, buck. oe noe worn ee ' ns we, arewed wnpek aes aot bok ott teed aA sheet wore decor a3 foe, pai bei See "wo hee 6a fr ae £ om ned fe Bo bees wee weed 2 pie al oe 1 ater, ae SAS? Sh ; we x itt %, at P we hee, ree a, ik fate' aaa . 'ha nee * praed ws re oo be hood of te aot Mop, aga aad to were eee, see sek bein 3, soot neon Lneee pees OS ween, ss ee pats wn OS yee porrk bow sheet rho iy ga vend 2 ae es sees ra A, ° P Sat baa te uA $Y oa peeee, $a, ae hve, Kear sbne! ess " Me Nai 3 Fans ~~ wes ; z beet y pee eds, a bs ania ec ty Lo fone ¢ Fea oot Sn om ye tet oa neem re os 'ot, . tase ae bene ny Mot 0 nprine hk Net @ wo sen 'rab th. ra nos he. "tek fea yom eee, ted a0 pa re "he fas, jah te, gen ts ; shot Som as "oS P, cng 4 tea yas, athe hee ue a oe "4 ate a4 thee Lh Iasi Io rook me ORS ae on dew me ~ rein we hx " ise week ee 43 nosy Fan' A; Ad oe asi ' send 2 cae4 wees, awn, hand 'ae * pas Se aes * Paar td Ww eZ, iad seen tei Lead om e LS ' : seat % a ed Cr . pee a4 Lang cael 'not o: seed oe ee) og boob % ap $8 che het , va 34 wares ' 'Nt berre par $s, * re, a 'ct < Aaa er i '° isi a fn, Lewes "ry 'tne " ape % > ¢ Lad ' oe wn Pane writs petbed, peers ei ene Ay aaa ra Fea shod a es wap, in rn fe "net ae "ah a aot ead nee % Senet ' ta? et tA Whe ee re nen heed woeoe ween ten oy Pore, eo z ' pe thnk nee Pant "at LG ey ron cones an a 4g ot ' coal &, on Pods det wen, tua 'atone tee on pani psa " pes wile pod Fog' ot n Paces hy nana, 7 on ys ae Sot. ws ' he me, tend paar) tts ere a "™ hee, wh " Jean pet Fore er poe oe, ey ree power rer [ap Pass om -- wenn o, pees t pn Sue Nie . i = % oes em] wy wet pe fot sone ~ x need st Ps ane on cad peur we. eepe oy pone Sp, howe 2 we, Ae ot on 2 eaead bine S28 paces 2 Le ; ee we, £ pa on , t th ree ceed aren pa na ne ee As iene Lt com oas ded Seed x epee wry aod rood Syd ms on BAe As ' wpe m pa , ee yr woty nat gre eer Cons nel Ane tek % a "seat ood a tf aa laoened f%, pauraenanied art ae ead uo ws be Ee eel a3 a ne rooek tomah aad ae, went eae J poe post mn Pag en eed ie go sien beg TT gen i dent ent oe wee wros, geen wend fe, PP on oth, ae Canal sot c EE. Pach (sw dees YS wr" Suet Lael WMA ae wee, ok ig "nad baed iS wren f 2 ride wn aA wee bes 7a) ms nual Dy fos 4% ms aed 4 Oi eass) waves ~~ at Sat es al fed Sad erent bu oe Seen rel tA weet 'asst biel ed ne yer et tay, ri oh se Q As ond eet. ws perene enees nee anes oa parr od FS Sat fey a - Seat foe ES aaa te era mx foot wee Ay an oy, tS om rae Ah, es tLe ory, oad wees tat Pas boos oy "pat z foes " Peog yok we ward wey. ' Le, we "nin? i, "LF presets fe gear, fete ee we ra coed . sere, eres eee we hove 2 wort xo ae) jeteed dvd "at wh tone "x3 whe ae es "te a ae A, ae mas agen Daa mse oe ye ea Le pe C3 hes eo see! reek , foo wm oo po pee. Pa i Ae tee 'as ee a vaeee were ey, oF tot ~ sore Fe view en wa ben x3 a Uy vos 7 et pe iow pe teat we eed tet Soe of rn, my , eet a 03 : ses 7 % "4 AG bees pled ora Fi Ls , a hh ebro ; hn ae w pont oo ts Pano ~~ ae ene Ae as weet: deed "se anal Ewad ene e oo, wo oe a" co a my Sead eet eyed ay fay aed prec, cot tard ran wet ws el et, ye) Paes "ee po we whe at & pease nt eA ft ron ia ae pivot pan ic a 'ena 3 pd at Leng ate aaa 'ee ry wees o , toh 4 ue aoa ed oe : £ be os rm, pork os oe) hon pan Sa ae Peas rage need An aot 4 a roo het ae agen ¥ n <r . srpre 'apt "are on ad weted an Paot erst ele, ' en roe) eed a baa oA * yore, yet Nin i" goon Le q 7 'hed oS y Pr noe ; Ps nd on, cated 2 Pg om, Pa ays iansen oo en, aes, on fone ropee thd Soda 'bia 'goes 'oe pars coed Lo a won, fea pee ay a wa ty on ahead oo ps ee « haved oN vt es . -- fy bose) ia ed paces aed oh. pre as we a fees 4 woe as, wee a as Be Li oe an wy me os a ra om oy Ai Paks nn fe aed Be . peas ead eae! cand ae) 4 fs . a 4 Sot cet pperes ro B Fh eid a ene wal Py | teen "ad S. po ogee pen. pren , ef ee Pts 764 Saad weet anes son ey a aes panne, "3 ; oe. fabtee wn Sake ar .3 toot hed fe nee ry emt tad we sheet ae +s bes me pa sheet faa bao bige ene a on a She yn heed vo nae : « me ee nad A 4 * ares Fair a q m5 he ibe.
'bere awe aoe Dewi net a ce stove ape hi med cas "oot % OE, we andl oe, A, eal * we. . 2 pe, Lor bah s pes Ceaad wee x an pa Gan taal. at aed on pases nevi need aed net pears hens eee es pane me < ae Fatal th fer x wen, ol Paes Ba pars Sos oy ted ers ft aie fee inti ver fons fas} n a wa of, onore 4 eed at Ww : ay Led a3 OOF on hd aa ed me pees "FS ree tA aaa sd pee ea z . we Poel pone . os teat pon, ; oa were Paead --_ ard wy, £3 Fesead et. hes, ty wenn Ww pes sod nee My oa we on, yen ceed od aetitat on oof st as as ne te cop we i ies fhe Se oe ws os * Ser oe as) . of 4 Ps oe --_ cores ne * + a ak a fone OD ~~ best ihe ack we See ooee we wt wee, a3 "5 Cred 'ah Pagel ai, veers aed an Ke, heed et om ee raed pee eee ne mp om € = rea, owt fae herd : hp ners = g ga were ad "s ot hf ey pe ss So end pad we ied "ad a Me vn on "e gene aed a ~ mS a a z IA, 'nad "anal wnt pita, en are seer bone Ete. ee poees 2 23 ot acaad mn fs 4 2 wey fata wet Sy weet eds pans yg te ich poet eG , bea soot ' ie von MS pee po ;
on Ines pas 743 ai My, neead os LS res a; -- eat et, A : D ne mnon we a, 4 ' : ' 4 ei a pews Ay att weeny 2% ae tect Sok , "at oe teed " a it as ao ay te "sae ive a oe ap ane CS fa is ee on cheat os pave te om nt Ly at wares th ren ine bee ae wren Nee? weeeee enland ae oe bee 3 'nat eno oe ae oo wo as ses on et vs bee ee bn en Aa . a rope ee eas on A os ke ene . ot De > i aS en det mo rove vet a St ae on tas Ceaed bm Sheen, we 'aed. yews vere poe "ee on , ss ote, ae " ay "7 ee oy wena ~~ on vx ee ne 'she a eeeen, ' a sat nore canes oe) oa Ceoecd Pood gy re rere , wen ans Bork "wee a tae ped $ "Lb et open owe Soon hae fas ry hos one feos besaos a hee om e% , 5 ben met peter whe Bess ae read ax eee ve = Gast eat a4 wn aft - weet ay tee ad nan ye nen a uA ; cf my Theo Ls ieod Poo Sant on aa ae Peal a fo "ee "iy ONE ny 5At yen "nett ms . wf ben New ean *, oe , fad a pao parr cae Tot Wet Mere, Speen pent 4 har ore. "ae * wet al pee we wheel:
so, i , Ps To Pe , < Fas ropes fen Sas ea 4a, or A ce RAdE om oe, a oe shot ae 'rad ws nes, nein Ba, were F raps eon rs ot, Be ES ges ety 4 aie aeenk rt ioand $3 te ted me cere Lo a3 ead i, ned wk, ' n a 3 cies oes a eres Sei ae a 'wate, Sei :
ty ° ae a8 fn, : "geet vi a ee Seca vay cai me es a OF a 2 on "ee on sane aA She on ep * ace wo, soe BL pe one fio a3 Re "es fat yea om ee he 3 wt a Ln 3 ey pes "Ant eed : Lt me be wt ee ho oe ia é Boe € tea o oS 3 : we 4 ¢ . 'ne? ff oe, %2 wld het sot wt eed Ronee ners > pe 44 ' f ' yh, ¥ fat hed tad al Socata Oe Os reas aa my ec' bey on of pat bes ont we a rapt, wee, fat ad Soa _-- od wept, oie ° So gaat : oe pend ot bee, nen 'eek . os , ren. rae es sobre as ete 1 tog ro i es fee fey, iy 2 i: wey, . Eis ' 9 tn 'ei ae: wen a a So OD ae ved ra pore a sing ee ? ink Lat sy Le oy ae, ne arcane Lo ond y oad a py, o eee : 'ert we " hed tt waned ye fn, 5 4 on is z aa SL leer oe "0% Sr ; oad Act Bod pas Pes rm ee, tied 7 . ro Or wrk os a oe , Mi pens eg MES coed ac' ment, ' ee x "aed 4 as on on re a on = ner £ ns ce aos vies ae hon ay a ws ood wa ve) aed head os a ra pags ae gen ad vs, ws Kona %. t OL: were os tig ead on, feos : gon ieee ten s Ay fos ae pon ey, oa) ee os eae A fen Z new, whe eee. Fi Be Sry : Soe, ' Seon we ae ie A ot. ws on ay ' Rea wt fe, pee tf :
ad pee) Pal Pe, oe oe ye we . ue i woes Paae aed yore we vt ae. 2 EL vs wig me I agth. the we ve "bok pe EE os Meee om OE e " . ;
oop fe a . ra oad fee : wa om, we hag aes, i ; ge 2 Cm Ss ff on Cont fans apne sae $ yo va bol . 3 ee eee d eg tet oe 4 [is a he me gee ee it ten a (eeu a a co Os nr 4 ee Ak An ee Te OS . ve Ay he Oe font Pane ' . ie & 2 ee Se ap ey a "3 k tts, ae: oe: we gen 2 wee : ed ' ' : pan pi past og oe pa on Ses OTR Che aS Be piss A an . ae ra te site, ; eh: ? . Neca Pye, "
ae fr Lb sgt se Lt ME cot ak ee , ea 25 p we aoe Sed re ec pee ae Sa pone. pepe me rt OR ony TOR ce DB Gea It we feel ae pa fi a ae root ao ie a HG ween pen, ome Samo? Sa a J " ed "ant Ded shank epee peed nnn ra NO peed. den hh eee' gern, rot ' ay y yee. ed ea. Be took £r% e 5 i o> det Bae. We ' cpags pices ae SF Sat aegiay. meet det wie ipo on wren NG putes SR ee AG eA 564 ped ", dod ok agi pe: 6 GS ae a ne ben a ee " oo wee wee. mm, ey oN) oh. ry thon 4 , aie tage HB gee mS oA | ween pon feos tod Se ge ee ek By heed oe 4 'dl on anne a, cr TF , hen a "SS he D3 FC cane ote, ' .; "ey 'nah sf _ fa be Lt a ee oS é peal o§ , t 25 eh me ca wy te, ten Gales OE Siew scene OE Sg sed ies A ees ted 5258 i om, ge 'nb ¥5$ toead Koes ., peed iad . bas od} oe, pee th won on ao we wy peed i « root "oe Fane -- wes, Ft o ass é ; ee a bok th foe ~ tik aeons waae, beet ed aa iS S28 & SSG aks the faliowlng causal is saged U 2005 and campleted 240 days in B year as on 201 NY One & o1 1 are allowed to perform: the wages © 1/30 ol f the pay y » scale at then y MAME val Gragg "D"
: .
< fs 4%504 13h DA as achnissible ! <> shall discharge thelr duty d ensure proper conduct at ENT EN PY EVE EEX . near ke yy peppy MESpPechyve WOOP DLICE. The expenditure will be mef out [ram head Fs PPS Law gh ms Clacaweint emer THEE OAS [N/P) for the financial year 2013-2014.
ement i was arre edd UPR on ow of r ede ws a ¢ aes ori % oe eee teed pee er wer vee, oe vey pa oe {Do Fi £% oe gene.
ie e:
tay Med Th settlement having reached its finality, the Respondent-Department cannot wriggle out from the conditions stipulated therein, There is no mention i the said settlement that 1/30 pay would be allowed te those who are x discharving the duties of Or D/MTS. Further the arder dated 12.04.2013 mi EnS wherein 1/30 pay was allow condition that they are alowed to perform the similar nature of duties of Group "DO and will be paid TfS30 of the pay scale at the Pe a eel ny "es ey A - , dene en paced head fn non tne Cot prs ss bee ran oe veo bagel yet $44 a wee ane shen pots weees oreee waved, 'aaah tet Shh tod abet bet ak At. Ve ae gen ee Poets * oo. oped ea Se oS Lend pasa few as on 7 ox ponaaed f As joe see repen seed Leste OPS on ccced Bagd vat eee ' aaa tig as ie eee Ke ad BEE peenei od a ay oe i ae aan GA . Lees fin, seed : ° pen, wet, a com eas wh ed morte, pe eee pe beer aN ve og ~ 'net ae ew ws heat the Sethe " eek, Sot: ten fae od " ene nek. ws, . 4 pen Sey. oad poe Sook ey wdees 'ebeew viet tat ge ve "? bar eve ite no we, pt me 19663 Tarn, ow . z ae -- Efe ms Set ere tony. Denne tet: on et me ht. fey fu ; ope 2 at pon hes ae Eva "yee pe Sah seine Segoe, Sceiitd antenty Took vaca we nar enn wy tat ant, pees ss : ne ere ene Sieh od fey viet, mrt pat. ed nt Pee' aid a ee Sag aw oe 3, we aged Boe eee Rad "ge: te % 27h den Sood bes ma' ¥ ee apt My oes 4 " ane 4 Wy gy is os " eat ae oe es wa oe es % pind So; ise pen Be a pnd pas ae ony ee anett rf i or oH Ken, eae cy oh a ¥% Gh as Boe fK ante, ces] ied ry 2 re es s st if we. Some of 2 ™ ae vad QB oy bane ie, fee. a he , peer ot tad mt LS oe wy 2 aed Fay ' oes ' asl % neil, " 6m: dane oe ema opnned ere (5 Ss Neil % ' pp 'sig $ *, al oe amt [an ty aa ai aaa fee. * Sane Sot % Pas es % ad 'oot » £3 wre eS ; ' ware ona net & iS a, (aan ts oe 4 et oe a wen Gt sane ee m ged G} 2 cS : bee pel Het a oS aod ' : ts : % pas , on a Gerd a a. . $ 'ood fae, Siac ise e ft oe peed f pe ete, ie , 4 A baa pass Soot ea a3 fonod y es we Boot oF ee genet bed end oe © eee. aos Fe Sone $ aotton, :
' 'ad 4 on " is oy oo we Rice ee ae pa oe re od aad tes i 4 me enn J ae od ies Le ie ee os my : re be a: oA eS oo aay a yee, soft fen om, mee m4 are big a Piss toes, ee ee "orn, we pes hed ee a to, bes He nae lan oy * toh pene es ae were, wareinee, pak r oy Iti ee "enn Sane ' mn ia 2 ane 'seit a ft, ve ie eet rane! iY en ran Beas bares eae ee ebid we ae word ce: eed - bod 4 £55 ret " na, . ners on, cg! oo eh oe $ mae f ob pe : weeds ie eeee ee ; io, goed cae . pen ooo ' seed aaa P : a $ aN 7 porch gre wee, eee , wre, fen ey ee dene ae oe ne 'nae? tne : coca . ee cae Pea OT ad oe on wen, : rae an an) oe mane ies wteod, por Peet as pear "gs - we oes vet 'a aot pa wn ne Jone ret Had. we Li 2, % Par ws, Fg Lo hoe net wert, ys, "a "anal yokes, pe noe andes ot Po ae ay . Saini £, 23 weer, < emaad «. ae Pash >% pens Sound reds 4. z wy, pon ciet La oad a4 food Witte yee, « Feeagd arn oer 'eeneat ne oA tne beh tft Fass vores ov 4g ot, cn ; 2 0p ton Eee} . oe, "abt he. we ae Pod a ws Seed se re Log K se et ant pees wr wake, an Sad a on pat on *e an a L$} Arar acon Sette oy wee t ~ sent, 4S oe we ge wy pes: a oe "a bean oe Regs baie ny oS En pam woth oy, e we Gt ben Seen . ol oe: a es on" neta as Aad te we fal 5 bey Recs oct Tee & Ra Eee) race aw) ae watne 7 yr See aad 'Ae Bras, Pps a ™ wd 4 4 %: 5 Sa eee. LL; Fangs eset ey, Sed wes, tows +5 weet CS vi OMe mae om ea > i ih " Bree mo io 2 aa a yoy nn tae? is Parad a parka ara aered 55 oe * pow ee, acl ' £ Pace ee tree J vee ela te LY pom paw ict aed Fest bos wet ae A rod i aa a 'et oe bean' tet: a Ww om rite, e3 ees pa aoe ad or Sond a os Ss 40 ¢ ; rat os were, pad ee eel por regen. ty ase' aaa | i aes 'net ows: 4, was Z herd * Bo Ber * waren aiteee, x, sank aed sheet enh, ° ore set peas aa 4 % er el AE 7 Bot ors wae oe. nee isis oy re ae he se Ts on steed wore oss ; Ks al "ab on poe he 2S oa Bibel wees "~~ . s end Gs 4 Hae ;
dee bad nen pee an 10H, pot t mt pan) ys, ae Pea a en wee Panes ened on pad Pag 7 as pe. anne, °: eal " . ceca J wae 7, pow sheet ees SS Wy & Pedy coed oo Sood ' pa me yon piae dock ad ieee he a we ms Tans ey od 'ont "ye, es oe ras bas) mm ~ ae lagi we 7 cad pene ot beads Nad cone eben fof se. & eee, awe es "aint pes As 165) on at i Bert. wee, A fo, (or. ey on 45 oon ord Peas ae ve ee yee nat $s Seed Np Sat yee, tat me wn net it penn Ta wen on Pea bind ieee (m; ces on, Ae * raeood jon po "b gee mes yt £ Neat Laeened eee Oe coed coe ; Pie sd be pei us base ca roe wets Saad, oan bed oe ns ee - in Ess ad oe a a e oa bo B oy a) S ss oy as ms a r cae fab. £4, : peo ane ee os 9 psd ooh eS <S seen pos be pom Ss fen, wad os tere on ten aot oa re ik bee aa Od nt Sra nt aed pare. peoooed peeee 'noo "earn, ae was oy, Fars ead au aeebe neds we sot ed Ewe vane psoas Ft ral acl oo pi tad 2 wn Nae "een, oan Foes LA when whee peau Sng bo ween: box Sey < aod om ment a ee oa me ool a 4A co vt set om a oo a oA wbod om fea pon ot whos a aad capes os ox a " 2 a _ , i seen 0% asad " wy , od 'hook eo yer : L od Lt 3 ee . tien iw . bat Lined 'de rs im root a eed ad a con "se we / fea rex bok on Nb fos ve eae 4 ad ot, 27 vee z a, pet 3 "nnn asd et oad 4 ord ee) Paar 2S i" on 43 toe pape ; ~ tent int ae peree tn anor * ed rr, pai' pase ont get yn 4 %, % pies ~~ . wo ents we aon Sad Ann Sapna ae ¢ oe eon oe tp hot ny ao " 3 Seton, Fes '09 ae poms * wee ; oS , £3 ms Se eS, a :
eae os an sce aes es wy 'mit ot pases y pe pot pes hs yes nt id aot The Ba ; ee bax
- ~, w ° tke we es 3 beet, 4 ' Tabet : A as o feed et ted pon Lt "et Ks fae a oe sein pe pes ; 4 coal i y sw "s te led, fn ae ee oe me ae ee oa a aA ue ae) ae a i we eed 'et Py hed Naat oot aes on Hs seen i Sy a3 cad "4 ov von , fen wes :
. - ft nak oe y , paees pad
4 ens cz oad soar, cad ie a3 , Pal a gevel as Poy is on fove 3 es ; oa é : oe wn " the my . - tp hw 3 a aes caged ae bates Nans wey $ ase' ~~ eet wine on, 4 ices So a te od ised we mee f os "yen sea ea ' ' Seed ais pen eae ; ~, Pas eB ie oe ay in oe fs wa KE o at a3 x ad ey grr, ocd ed my ria 4s wget beats me "BA 4 t wo i Be Veet bees "aa? neree aoa os Saeed wy cei yee en, ws "Ant whe ii aea' wn, Peet iaaes be 4 ney ms yee ht wees oon on Qeabn aon, Beas os won vag o ak Sy wo bas ones ue i" we "ee . " senen, so "eat YEN ne cons woot ee op Foie faaal 3 vee yee ead raped. y vecet ae wy ree teed steed : Sao Coad a dnd 'tad Ste ~, ay en, oe By Sail 4 -~ soe " i? om os 'mee ean fod "owt mois tn boo om Ws ones pes nore eS ae jet A; We pees oe ve se os ed . 4 SA 4a thew we ' st . ws pee Fama x ww he wat tm eens we, te eet sed, wee pend Ee goa oa soli nen, pe tre, see ae oe Sue BF ec a or 4 bine ee nes a Lh oe pao "a a ms a a ae Sent, Ve edo n bees tat woe yt ae get pee Pay, on pn yee, ors wee pons Le pond fooeead Fant poe eal "nal teeta pest re aad ink ~ seek , hee pees ad Seoe, Ira, rok aoe en foe - severe Fs oe ee a go < o A: Su 08 . Stes nt o iy eats pen baad ty ie a ae) Co Ma on on, ey. ha oohe wan abi oS os o oo] fake, re Coy ron, Lee pon fava aw ae ' ; neon f rad pees md ona re Sore ae ed 4 ere, Ls Ua nd 43 ~ we Th a Pen Ne aes, ' " : ¢ a3 : Pern, tty Sas and Wg - t uo ae tad Bh ny jad pans end, ee cad peed, Seen ~~ a3 raced roe ~, we es wn mS f oe eee oe, " coe oes x oe a fet a te gee % 4 ir oe Let < pee ores z g mm tes aeons ve cord, at » 'ned mA shed bapeed nm, ht iat fe wees sy ' a fe 'mage Me, veeene win ve ~, a Es cn, Fo oan ", fiat oe LG tet pees, we 7 pee pleas ead os ae not Fam ate 43 con Pas aed a 'ne fend pet t Se . boot os neag, "ae A, a "ee an . aes Sh ee P my - cs, aro ye sean se stress pe Nowe Saaed ' cat ee S eaad rw Zs 6c # ry nm "S me yy ones Ahoah ae 44 y* " o~ nae we a4 Lone oe, od " aa w% ae a, FS ws uth ik heed whe ; 'net z me a test peas Spot es cas 13 wee oe baal Ba Poe re oe wes coed fo se " od pao oe wee eet ws weeey x ee aa oi be pane Sal ts ae cs haa Ler ee a a oo a me om 4 sia "2 a gee eg < rh ps in 4 rere 'ap ' we mr, nione. Fas' bi bo ~ " "eee Sent: sae a ae Wo "at eg ot et nu, oe ae: et me ere,, pe) dent an fh oe, it 'ant nines rts; ot * wane As pape ee re. we shes Lose oon tee Sood St tere id a fe, Pad $ 'oe aot cad pont m4 ore, ty wy peed Ay ~, Sn, os we Son "aa ef. es aed em] fad Babee re ' ew oy pon + ms to per) a the oh eres ane en a ae el ee "~ gn . 'eased honed pay ' athens a giah ~, B wear we Pus oh 'nat i wee wpe wat vee aed tock % . ng shoal as "73 aes oe om aes So ms can 4 wn, oo L$ oy we ted * lod Sood ead wees, , "a ae H not an -~ nh, et, aos we ; " ene "oanit » ene pa Coase! tabs gem toot athewe feet a pon . a png aed a ven we pm be a Leaaed al : By Ay ane Bw id 'seal Ww the how "ad ww see .™ ss wn ws 'a tad pale Son ees 'Bs hea as Ion ~ set he "_ 'bnew on yr Pas! as a oy rand one Snot yet cae ns ~ ws ae tees Bb ote "ae bn fo oe ron aa ' fod 9 io x2 won 3 ven os BL, ie t. o bee San oti, wn a tae Food ahodd wr yes a om ws a Ses yee we See aed yoy pare n Shar ube a ae oS pans mae Ps 2, et Sore Ese ra pn Nab 'ah ree fan ped ere 'at hod Foo om, ps ee plans a re z v, os, M3 As "et lao ce ? vipers when foe Pie The A peal 'at a Fags week ny, ones : ' AQ 2 5 G & a a ae oo. a = a , oh, ay gts, fot wee, Pie f Fone Beat oad ae te ih wo ye tnal a ee wen "
ah eneee, pote xe ey boca ee os, eas pa ; ire, ow. aera faba os Pond a 3 oe oe apa? tot on, ed oe Dice tad pene me - "at ben Socks, Sem Abad wo ; ne! ses fam . Paved pan al ; nae = eae sie G3 a a tee fang soos Se ag Go Pa o fe re vy ike om cnet pees pied pa edt craw a uo & 8 @ >, 28 2 2 & ; Le y : we Oe ees toh "Es ft reed ty es Ton ood foe pert ; nee a Dae ». yen ee oan we, aie oan Bees we an her :
stent ' : aged ins on toon Nee ' Son ae ee ey, "S . aed pes 5 Neste, bre, oa eng ae a nae Bae, Sat ee a £3 tat ied A Be a oo aa as Neb fe 2 ee Ls see Bees ak wee bees er vate 2 Sif oe * we rere ye Bad Sinn whe 4 a wr = Es SS fon tes, re pen ws red yor Don a, gers Sp, Sader ones feet som tae ee sad teed ae aces pane ret to oe we ee Caed ion x foal "y Beas * ipa or re, sna SS ay peer we 2 Saat pe aon wht a : nen tat ; ener ye Pat se no Pet, Ses eae tore. ms £% aod oe Lane od * He nonrn, "raat ma wee Le 53 nad "hat eet oe fn, Ws wh moose bed ty byot ° 'neil ee £24 Po Bey at fen , $a8 ab et oe Pag oe ys yer "pia oft iB rt ferent enkg apna : oo in ae ' ae) mt wenees, * eS ° Fa is¥) pee, Nad bad "es " 3 pad ba oa z ah eer. on ita Fad ro dl ed peso gon we ney 'ed oh ~ ey fee foe nabs ed ne 'inl pees, fart en oo, were wee re aeoe ch pee 4 4 Feed week ona Pod we .
¥ nen Shes ted Ay es. Soars om oaagd peeees the a penne, Mig hd saa "2 ogee: ee pre? we nS ee on te, en a * a * a Ee vps ect pn Pond soe ae Ce fee an a dod wee pa eed ope bec ates xd ee Pca) fate bors bead ae ba ea 3 pa we ve ee ae wh oe we eee Faced a, qerees ie bg ark nt oy Hod. 2 poe pee wees pees na CS 3 pea oe "
Jn : As i files "od pe x : 4 cp a yee on wy the pon. ede Saale pares om vend load. en co ponte eee ead tad f% " cara pe a4 "3 soit er os ; és a eS 2 & & ep. ons ere " Pee, 4 Ss ae ee ; o os Rohe iS Lana he . ae ht im oe z Si we s) a " s Salt cased on 0G gen pee ey, an ond oe ah ; iarsert 23 ae si a3 oS oA be ° ae el: nih: "aks a pees bon can es) er ons aren * oa Fe * pet vei 'poet a = ea os See mes : i aa gn eed "eS veo Seo gm besnad ee me gon "sy "aed pana Saw pee , Pew tA mS aS neta ewe "ee io pee » wae, es ed. "ond ee past Be "tei : ons be Se we. ny wegee , wey Nee bc cs re pas cone Soe £5 wh, Pa teed ass td ' os % o es ye ad a3 ay on nes a GS Be a3 oe Ee Pen ss) pe ik i bent "ma kas? yee por where Mey ~ pen on wed ae soon eo ey, 534 Seed eed were ane Seah we, cao ao Sa "eS od oe) ; nz esi ~ aeot nod 1 re hae oo tig oe, io se wi 4 oat os a xo fee as = sane: bas crores a Da yore Easel 'ad pes Sot $4 os ' ae pen Fees oes banged Fi as ' at j % pues a3 hod om won 'hee & tk heed wep aeees pee Fy mays errr & hn PF ass aes etree week eae heasy same, or to say, minimum 8 hours of day, they should not have been heen discriminated against by stating that the applicants have never attended' the duty of Group 'IY Le. Momument Attendant (Now MPYS as per % vitth Bay Commission} Trite is the pos re a x x ation ef flaw that discrimination va within one homogeneous group is contrary to law and the muarulate enshrined in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of india, Eniitierrent of L/30% to casual labourers came up for consideration before coordinate of the CAT, jouh pur Bench in OA No. 8317/2011 decided Bi { Abdul Kadar and Ors. vs x, Union of India and Ors.) which 3 1962020 Writ Petition NodO/2019 titled UO! and others vs. Abdul Kadar and others. The relevant portion of the decision is quaied herein Psa ae After having given thoughtful consideration to the rival submissions and having examined the record, We are unable to find any jurisdictional error in the order Impugned se as to consider Interference in the writ parisdiction, AS 3 totic ed above, | by the orders dat ted ¢ ea flo ? ike LEG 2E and enhaw ne ement af faily raies af t labour eps, The orders did aat draw sn y Casual workers holding lemmporary s workers. As noticed, the dep: rare h ad cons CIOL earlier the memorandum da where the aature af the labourers and regular empl Lybourers would be pakl @ 7;
nes bes the, Same, Path afthe pay at the n ahs eae i eS on, ben ee cates :
Nat 4 bs fn eked.
Sagat eae"
Fae ae wt wea cic porn et ae fe: sed Coad : Cee ee 2 aed, * tonal ;
nF a g ee E _ ine » -.
a wa. Parte' : vont fine OM ts Sata LE Ch 5 Oy "
dood oa Peed we As os oe Sead Stee in oS b peek Laced on pees ae rok, Ay ~~ por ed ' o oe :
s i ~ aren ws os eee . Page 4 eB os i et Sete heeb Ay paws os i eg pon poe jeee ee
- ue ead ee, " ue re, we esa ee Wer neeed heed Ps dee evonsiis ry \ JPamof th t Ne YS FAS ¥ 2