State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Dy Engineer G E B vs Shri Manubhai B Parmar on 23 April, 2009
V \L/
was czsxzm Rqmt afitam, zryxzm. Et"6'*-K, ?ri'i*E.l<?~1iE.
wfiet_:3;,_§_1§B99§
>3z§3.€t~x?;:-~ "T9-g.a°{.:?4.-°.c?1*{le{2
9 °i5'Eld <sm,;'1.1:~;a'1 <>€t§
{e.s,aa- am <g;.*2r"~=.m ciiws .s;u«t"i ca.)
'=l§1.E.'%t.
Saga;
{i=s$L--s~a.:«-- sil ~x~;;;<=u2S <~.'t.*~aw.'«:
wtfist cwmsrz :?1ei":vi1,
3IéazLE1~m2,r»<-as vi.i,je3-H +1.3,
s.eits3, fEtemu1 1215, M12?
3&2 31:- 2&1 =t?:.=1.L2s'%..§;rs.Low.xL ERu45é1a:, i"r»m.,
J2. °,a'tQ*t =,:.~:la,, €$r°u=2§* ufgbe.
ail n4'.1.a?:.=+r,.<z3.*«i1, iivaz
23is<ijz?_;aa;m rnic €L'}.§:l.33 :£'t:+t.=»3s2t.=§'s:»*«..."§a-.r~s1z-=1'-.:~:ci1
all vZ1..s'i,~s.5'£
f'--'.:;~x¥z,-s-2 més : méz.
gs» :-~ afi =31=i.?ft..9~L£t1b1\t2i1, 51=.u§£l.at ikfifiii °-maél,
1.x§.i&'e*{1 mils: omega gmt: mzzvfl a<aN.~»'w Saw: {3{. F%re«a:_. M23 <13?-..R Ftqtwz =é'w1 ema1«{ia*aT1sur».«-£.a.: a:;f~::w'L v:1l.?.x'-'3_.:"§'_flOOé"lL 3.'L=zv1=. gauai sflaaétvfi availing anew. :r;u»1cwti2~1rq¢11a,x=mu.1r:1L bum mqani ?'=>l1€fi é. Q. u.z:tst€i.3L 21i.r».weu :3. $ve.'ima1-{t s=_"1ms~, {gm €te»$':.-1. <u:7?Lm fiaecatui »s':v?u5 351% %u3w. i:R&£'~?3. aqtézi MR vie; cm.a.m 5Eiu.-aIv{i .'.i;3«':m.'»:T"t-~<':i'1, M312':---*zj;, ==.«:u.a'2 3: '@131 mm:
If /' 1";-
'<'+1il5if:l Smi mam Edi M3. vim} mes ~i.o:3ao:a_.:'ooe:¢r.<;v. cm: 11.3% -i,:m;s«exEe:
wit mix {swam waa '%-«gr:-~-aeaaai -"étULv.ctHi =ou-?:--a.. Sr"-?:,'1llt€E*.ii wtzwa gm ruv--;*>ue '=31---"gr: "£<:f.:¢€J3. °5'kr3'~'>£lZ'.'{~~-Q9-*iE'?."i»~--'?;~i:'E*{: :§i.L+u t'~;~r~.ea aewa.-: €m'1~'1 ~::fim<sfl-e-$1 qty"-.13: as sit as gvile >.«uaz»-.1':. :-m'; arr": T2.~i5.:_<=.=:'.h-4. mfla fgL{:0 ail 3,t.qa\:,.~'~g. matg égg, wig mvg'e>uz"1~§=g.a12::'I =1::~:«.--r:3{i €%.=>fi;g (awaken "Klara mil. amita saxziv, mnzqzvmia ago 34123; ¢£'{%£¥£;t f%3,,L'-i1>.43~\«t'~4. 'ihu a{i<=s. zanievgl "Er wile: amxmulmiz 3-"scueil mmtfi 2%': 21%. <~*-u=:.rsue <'s€t2»;La-.'i'$':, i?>;r'm'i mail, 11%;; iftaa ¢'t~'E.GR mafia vzéi. snfitazsél-1: s»uc?m': gm»: uiiaz 3s2Sa. egg 9: '*i&%Pii wiiazai A3322 sy-£12 *=L°~{'»3.l¥L -{iuzfia ea': 'v¥.3t eqzzexta aa.xi«-Qulaui cam; raw. gala-{L viitsfi woo gefla-u qtmézw. 33a._.a£ma~«2:-: i"<a.L;,; M3-at %»Lm<1mi wéla ag, siiw-u€i.~+2§, $7»3%i.£E, gram »E'1.::»«I?w.r'1'.:.s=3x«u2w.-4=.z uuam -I-"z=»z1:v_j eve, ~.§.=1au wit: Qég; gag aaag <»{l.<:~v-ti °er@:1E1~a g.~+:{a~i": cmzm 391$, -1 ecf: 24% weag. bétct «ma 31:?! 8..*L-fl wit «L211 14%: *1 mt, $sc1i.q1€<zR -'c°§'~=1b:£ .3 1'1 -991 mi ::1m1.c:w1..L ;§'1éS aéisu waft écu étqta '1 ecu Emil art; a ftqra 321 2%.
2:. eu=1:<u<>u3s. filéiat want %{1".tC{li¥1l F1. €591 aw mvz aim «em: 3&3. Emvfi. 31% <a=2u.ct A314': €42 E $§"1~'-ilélril vistifieil cii.%"4;"'~{,-*'<:<:'rt=. £1? *fl2'~:«t1 a<~t=2s'1 étqmi axuézez mi; mo}. «.u.=ac_su;:;eru cm 11153. siianilvi eavnlszi <?zoEa%1a1'i.=ainu=.e:czLt1i mafia sag; >491 $3.'l=ua'ig;, flan rsmt»:.2 é't<s.:;;t 24,-': Ema .s?:.s$ua. usmil wii. *3. Starry; *ti.§g»'t aka $51,, wig $r:'1m.a"t2§i zimléwi. mél ,a*ec;.:-it '5='.~%R sia ed} ma 'RR:---7t:t\'3t'1C-t =t<.».<:<;-:.w1;::. aw-aw: g1.:nma---mg; <i3°o'<a'is; txaa M,-L\t'=ti'{i 1*£i51.éi. eg 5%' aw fiaucufi u==m§t;L +33.
2;. R. éwa =2.~l${r$i ma *«1s:Ls12"t=3t a::ru<3.=efl gum reg sieu 'oz?-i EL $'m'+.
5'€l%ua"ifr«1¥. §.*§ airs. «tuft:-1 ?m.='a' 'ztmtcamt stw-it bug rwiietvfl E¥.§'=.<%).*f\ 2st?.ws.e 3;s1%.:~1.L '9t=zL--mi ssia, Q WI. 3§'{'«?.v:1l M31 um: M33, 3 N31 ~.$$1tu;fLv{1 $?.'E,%u.aHi '\ «at 31;-'ta {9 let?! iii!'-lIL"~'-{!_f-'Ll z'Rfz%{I %i1a;>_ *% arufi. c»:<tmcm.i :>u&r2L @ £1 N4-94 siren, via} :43: Cauflsu wwni ems; $1 rsflcwg an": main gL.~3Gc>£>,-"- mi 94%: 14:31. mafia: Q: ==vt~'1 E1. {vain miss giau '<U.?.lv{l °§r'»'1c.ut'3¢»ix '2u=~u<4\ia1£; M23 &x%*». émEg1.z,m,ooo,s'--zHL 32iCiL<1i*§i '~93. 5:551: aia 32. mm <*i'*~:i '~catsz¢.'Lv{1 aeflrfi Max 3.52 om: axmua uwii (211 élsm gm 33:1 Q. &. M1 zvwiic-.mi gm <*s2'l2u.sl13i -rizélca écléiitfi-ii. M13.-:21 W': Finite-i'; 'ma. am? zéiéi '5<153{<i aaltéil -'c»L1a~-a (ma ;&3;r:t é§. ivlrrtve $:a-3&2: :15: %I.S*iS{l*'«'1l cm} ER.
\ qéia *<?m.:31:et. =?z<a.3.<=u2u cm"! Eel. <:,§£«a n'2..:iLe:E. e.L°:s'=a as-S aéiaiz 3% £9. <at«'¢. u%mi':wfl aeftslk 91% E33 mu-E eilila :3.
e. 2«u 3x%i*'fl aw. ~es,é.«'is.=d1 iatfil um: esma éicén. mi. 3,:.a.oo,r2e<::§-sfi um. :>um.€t an -'evils: fig; aw um menu "e'*4.t'3; ?=£t§Hi §;.sr:€1 e's*=+Li {an ém M3631 :;m.~.su.cs--2<: am' g4,w3u--s*~m <-ik»; ?i'*.°E gs.;3o<:ac:»;1~- '$3. Viéviz 9?: gs». ,a2<:.1'«-ti M.v=?=5IL £3: :3 3{$£t<>§d. ?.l'~'i.¢ti*ti =er:.i_¥'3:.e1. £9 'M9; 31. gift '+~1.1{1<:-1. Q3 mt um 33: iinu saw 4191 gem =.»1.=.w3ti :»u3zM '32.
¢. $31 $iL%LLa'1v1'nw»2 3&1 -91:3': £9 .3, Stag; flea v4.¢H1g4,£s:1 $3, 14,2' 5; étm-1_'¢Li.*31£'-'*.t. 3&1 {rm £<'3f1€£1€¥.'1L"{18%*£'1 €m'z'3,a2"£'»+i %L.:sz2<.I§L'1 ssacti. '+{1a2 =2»€:.'é. '*£t\'§;*i uh. eéi mu Bani <s%":m'L2.'i=31 an-g.2~u%'1~» éag->»>ae2'1 xeecgg *%Sr ofia. zrg is 9. %?x:tLé1£'»a:;; qism :sea::2. 2:13. wag czizm wax »3»s2x2 t~:Lu:.c1<~.:. 2}. *2cu;t% 3-flan': 15;: ommqmi 2»1L9:-3 2%, 2$?.e<?1 ma taaiaasti we 31% afém sun. @ 3:, séiqték-3 man. 51135. -L egg, uigg. \»v.1{i*§:::1.s,g1 N31 $1 51 wzizi. *1 t§.g_,'g vi :a1e1.vu cziazwmi 23: uatfi Svzfita 9:t§:1m., Rig '2«'§?1l§_§ +:.EfL, iiagi. '>5 -jufl, wig 2133:; 1*lI.'~'i3g..§m.t £§ Eicii -{ht Miami " =?:§r" camcii észctmi 2»:.a.»=flA :3. Man mba 2'1€'tV=s's;r§;V2»L:*2'i~%<-Ng=a»z.:2'1 mascara f-mm :».2w.m Vila? 1-uz-{1§;.&c: gm; we gacm we é§. aitag; °a' rm': r_'~'~4.Rw.r», am?-:e:'ui"s.':se. 'tficicricvu 1~u«mout~*.z:_; aim. ma: :'r?.°iw.eE2'§1 23* am £9, °3s*»s.i atag qiem nu M33, 'u.:s.9ggL q'L'~>J.~1 ~:-39:-.2: rstctmczmi «~su€z.<s.. :3: :a.~'t ofla g-{1a=ti1{C2O'r§t ==«+.is.s'1 omtqqwgi -'e:u.ia. £9. -3-Cc': anucuuuak Ag aia 2.~u mt aaaiwksiiag ceila =;?u~:u ab:-13 aim ~x~.3<:=¢ atrtzczczmi :»ut'1<21 233 M91 uzetg qiv-H 3&2}. <>1.<t1:=:.cL1.=1i 2»u?-a:~:«1 9} MA cmmzru was rzmzqctmi 2»u€":;+:~z 35. «W4. éiilausilli 55: 6&3, :»uu,c1J.ui 2>u<">';r.--L {£2 EH1 um 31.3-Siio}- amzqqmi. mafia £9. <2s*~.:% =mv.uwsu+t'i ~(sw€Lss<1 218. meoeii W-l?,L-"ti; °§mL gwma-«ma °5iazmw.i %~tz3.(-1 ii). *9; 'I °sLvg;=rLn'£~%:§=»a1a.'1 9.3;-:;c:v.i $.22 "«'il'*£'1§_§§d «Em «Es. uzzimfiulai *4..~':E{:Hi rug: -$1 vaélsa =»w:1cfi °@:§S:?1,, -flag «ufi La.wua1.w"~.x=»"z film-1=. zcfiiaazmi mew. g«-{i;:~{i wm2m~:{t «Eta. 3%'! £9 =3' @.u;€as'm aél;«x1":.%tL1v'e. 1L\»m:i, amt suggn. usril «tail, site-:3; as raél gaktfit ma': {am 231v7e.a12.-~-rsfizti 43 %'ew1 faugzfi gum «Eu 23; em mm': mag; qiim. 'i5':$Of:-~£>3. ~»fmqt.=-ti. =«u€a.e. Q, 2113:} 9:1: eélsn we: °§1m 2:133; =:~{au{3«fi. ealsul nu-mi wean wil uagu wit »=.2f1.. Hm, Er-:i'a.a==+. eilaerzix izuvl amar, °s=»:w{ 23» 3: €r=~il3.e.'4;'.'mi *3: viiaixeil data 1&3 {in {mi gm aswfit qélqzni smile vwii. «:51 :2}, vu§'3.u2 ~93}. M13; *1 ».»Im :11 Quinn: e.a'L:«{: =.«w:z«r: vgeii. LL+L:sus?11--'L %uai~--33Lx{ia.-3} bile: 25.33-r{l~rU-fl :~zmcu<:m31 gme\«a.c~;'~~_; miia <zu:.t-us. 3,a.n*«-1<:.v--~vue~;; an aullf. mwqtai zwzita Evil 1:4,:-m:é'L ma: <'s:§u,a'z.. vii. mm {w.1a~rL ».;a'l:::Ez 224:3: >.'v-mi m~u<1Lvu-E: twzmca 2413121 am €12»: rtrii mi srzm.-eilvii fifiiitafii am '1.t*§;;*3,. 14.2 Q <5: (64,. $5291. ma awe, s'3.c«s. s}. mi Gm. :?;'1.=a-.-:. sélssriz "=.«*-M. ('ma [5{. £?'a=z.='~'t cilwii étuueii ~w:.zce,wu {am at ii: § ::'1';é 23% mi.-=2 ants'. :»:.v<.1<1.¢-£1
-uaa um. au».:<:wm =»wu3'E13 ha?-it £1 a':.%=r=>L=~im H9: iibit «£1 amt! [=u=:'i§ Ev-£1 "'t'4.'%.'i.l ss2cu--i'i'§ E>B5.\3;i Cm ve,<§\1.1€1c~.': £9 E 'siiaq-«Ii 2:..emL=,a'1 semi 5:233 cw.1<a.a"t imilz ma 213:6. 25 021.31 iavsfasrt Vcm;1=+. saw': W13; 21.1%.: Es::'¥.%ua'I«={{ £=€i*ur«.H.i «sq =u§;H U3 s,'§, twig E61. §w'».. 0?: -:.m~;2 <3:.c<%*»; $9-ii gL.1,c»c::,r:c:o,!~ m»~Lm.auu5'~1 gwqlrfi gate. aixet 33;» 91. we: mm R91 :31 Ml aéisa wafi. 3; °}':3+i Nazi: gm 5:21 2,139+, Saaxia. 9:, but-{$1 ss1=4,s:».Le:'1%4. 271:': "2: eéisdiui aimil ea=4:E_:_j3:§i: faaizqa '{i°L<,"tl -tail « smut eslaril wfms. q§1~:< 2:1 .€{~r{l s«.=:=R<«$a. mix &«t'il :e§,=~L<t, am? 2136.: «xiii E ::u:=u<:u<suvi1 ga:.s.'m Em. Em ?=1i*t=fl"¢§1'§1:1,'?%;?\ 3; g;.a,<>o,ooo,=-vii 2.51%: am': =:aliL 'Java wuéi %--'le§3l<i was} eéhll, wuég a=£1zus£1vt'1 scale) fin: 93m; £.=ma'La-rt aékm uvwazfitiii 53 32%. EH': Ea. §.=2x€m fmv. mi-Re. ® '3: m».:;:uvu°.1 *3' 5: ails. =»m1eus.'9 9.
32. acu um 93». sq. £?tQ'H.rtL zlicit gm, tum was. :s.':w.cu1u-=1 :13 =.--zmLcu::u:3&.
$il%u€l»"1 "L.30oo_;'~-- mi 11?: sctcu. exam Vauitssx éfiscfa '2§'=.<t:a. 41% 3 {~15 am gm szczmi =c»r;5. an _:. JM. 1 {=3} wila avizm: 33*: 21:1 iiggz smpti =»u5'z {s ['11. $129. ::mu<mu¥'; '% --e».ua...2 éicwieza $54; gm.,cx;,c><>q.:7---- g;3<2,~=urE:. sic»: :5 $1 an saqmi wii £9 M9:
<»u§iv{1 ?*<vi'\fl<-.1. 2%. .&Q<§,.l'~*ti 31.19% 13?. 2-'taésg E? {3u%;'L§<t 3;..°¢,r;sc;«,or;>-$2,!» i3.~t<'u~'--t 53 3&5' isufusd. gésii aiea s§ E': '<m1q<<. '~iLW?il1ii énzzfi 5%. 23.3% <3 «£1 ma =»m'1c~t»'{1 eagilacfz 'rival an-uu °.3'v"ieL~e "3':lr':§t 3: =:e.m<utrv;<?1 wfimell-'2. 2:m'k<«v~u mi '"122 0345.1 g:.amc:,»'- um 33%: Etcit r~?«za.w. 'Mai gm azami 3.431 {$2.
(13 qgui :am:.q1=»u3t. Em-1:, «€1.39. 21.sz»3.»1 2uc:'a:ritgc':.a $'~r'."6 wmrunil $31 ash §.r:.cu~<3. agaqaé mmczmi svuii 9 E M. s.za.e«.z}€L31 teilvwg 2'1 2'19; ::212»Lva mil ~21 '£3 2% zusum. "2fi.€'~.'<'. -1veu.+i1 cam mfg "-i$§t 2:133. Istwt :3': E: 2u*+;m<ru £i'+M=. awn <i,€5l.='-'ml a:x{%1.ata'1%-€19: fiuilsct gavu. mauii.
1211 gazatwl Mil ma aw-LL<m,1~'e ma must} Vmvk zmucagwu am: -58 £1 ,.»~ :»:E*>asn"L=»€L3: §§%a,~+..1 vszzii. si 3: <"m.-:.L zit-{tact mi'-m,1 cmausu 2&3-:sa'<>1=»i'1~'«. am t«us:a& cués ai 24% azgzl ?§i'*.L>:§l Mzuifi.
(3) ziziwé 2.-are': sfiazmwii A-u. =¢4,\=.'iiet amci sari! qua}. gLw2«;><>;*»{rz»i3s ygfitu uzaila mm 3%} Wu gazmzvg =zew?z es': éiail izvalau wait «am 24.:=m§t'l 311?:
15-11. Qua. W3l€{t'u'>1 --=2{r=.s* aefiu-Et zfinlavaviz vuwin 2P:,sa.€sv<a {HS 513 zaimwa-«.1 qsletiiivi a»:,Lu.<1.tvZ':. w?1»{,L ?¢°fl~Z§'13t-ggéfit azqmi '~*>u5i 23>. aw izar d\.3£~3,5B'}C-Ezfill it": 351%': \;§ee{L araazeaxmi %tt3.'~1 54%. E.
-.----v---'-------r«-----*'*~~...\+.,.r.r_».----».\,_,_,,_,..._%;,_w__"__ _ , --.--...-..-.,"__-_'_V"A_'m_._wA~W_--' YNHMNM _ _J_~."A~____,_,,.....'_-n-«A-.'#»' ff {W-'i.°a'1.§;éiL?=£t§£IK ) am' ' "(<1<.=::t°.:~:'vs{i} -
RW42