Punjab-Haryana High Court
Balvir Singh vs Pspcl And Anr on 29 November, 2018
Author: Rajiv Narain Raina
Bench: Rajiv Narain Raina
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M)
and other connected cases
Date of Decision: 29.11.2018
Balvir Singh ...Petitioner
Vs.
PSPCL and another ...Respondents
CORAM:- HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE RAJIV NARAIN RAINA
Present: Mr. P.K. Goklaney, Advocate and
Mr. Ashish Goklaney, Advocate
Ms. Rupinder Kaur Kanwal, Advocate,
Mr. D.S. Gurna, Advocate
Mr. Brijesh Nandan, Advocate,
Mr. G.S. Sandhu, Advocate,
Mr. Ramesh Sharma, Advocate,
Mr. V.K. Shukla, Advocate,
Mr. Kanwaljeet Singh, Advocate
for the petitioners.
Mr. Devaki Anand Sullar, Advocate,
Mr. Rahul K. Sharma, Advocate,
Mr. Sehajbir Singh, Advocate,
Mr. P.P.S. Thethi, Advocate,
Mr. Hittan Nehra, Advocate and
Mr. Karan Matharu, Advocate,
Mr. Sanjeev Roy, Advocate and
Mr. IPS Doabia, Advocate,
Mr. Ramesh Sharma, Advocate,
Mr. Monika Chhibber Sharma, Advocate,
Mr. Vaibhav Narang, Advocate,
Ms. Meena Bansal, Advocate,
Mr. Karan Garg, Advocate,
Mr. Vikas Suri, Advocate,
Mr. Pankaj Bhardwaj, Advocate,
Mr. Vikas Chatrath, Advocate,
Ms. Promila Nain, Advocate,
Mr. Y.P. Khullar, Advocate,
Mr. S P.S. Tinna, Advocate,
Mr. Avinit Avasthi, Advocate &
Mr. R.L. Sharma, Advocate,
Mr. Jastej Singh, Advocate,
1 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 2
Mr. Gursimran Singh, Advocate,
Mr. Ajaib Singh, Advocate
Mr. P.S. Bajwa, Advocate
Mr. Rajesh Bhardwaj, Advocate,
Mr. Gursimran Singh, Advocate
Mr. Dhruv Dayal, Advocate
Mr. Sahil Sharma, Advocate
Ms. Pratula Sethi, Advocate &
Ms. Reeta Kohli, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Rahul Sharma, Advocate
for the respondents/PSPCL.
RAJIV NARAIN RAINA, J. (Oral)
1. When CWP No. 20139 of 2015, Chiman Singh Vs. Punjab State Power Corporation Limited and others was decided on 29.02.2016, the following order was passed
1. This order will dispose of above-mentioned case as well as other writ petitions* tabulated at the foot of the order, as common questions of law and fact are involved in them which can conveniently be decided by a common order.
2. Heard. These matters are covered by the decision of this Court rendered in LPA No. 883 of 2012, decided on July 3, 2012,which orders have attained finality with dismissal of SLP No.20468 of 212 and other connected petitions. A bunch of similar writ petitions have already invited judgment of the learned Single Judge in Mahinder Singh v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd. & Ors. (CWP No.19234 of 2015), decided on December 23, 2015 disposing of the case in the light of the principle laid down by the Division Bench in LPA No. 883 of 2012 and in the same terms. Meaning thereby that the cases of persons who retired from service before March 17, 2010 stand covered with the condition that the financial benefit of promotional increment will be granted to all the employees who have completed 23 years of regular service as on March 17, 2010.
3. This petition and the connected writ petitions are 2 of 17 ::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 ::: CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 3 disposed of in terms of the aforesaid orders.
2. Subsequent to the passing of the order, the Corporation in its Board meeting held at Mohali on 02.08.2018 has resolved on the subject matter of grant of 23 years advance promotional increments to accord relaxation of terms and conditions thereof, which resolution dated 21.08.2018 reads as follows:
"Resolved that officers/Employees/Retirees whose 23 years advance promotional increment falls due from 16.12.1991 to 17.03.2010 be allowed the same from the due date as per instructions issued vide F.C. No. 62/1992 dated 16.12.1992.
Further resolved that the pay/pension of the Officer/Employees/Retirees whose 23 years Advance Promotional increment falls due from 16.12.1992 to 17.03.2010 shall be fixed notionally and no arrear on account of pay, pension, gratuity leave encashment and commutation of pension etc. will be paid and only the financial benefit on account of difference of pay/pension fixed notionally shall be allowed from the date of notification (Circular) by PSPCL."
3. Further to the decision taken by the Board in its subsequent 71st meeting held on 20.09.2018, on the same subject matter it was decided as follows on 01.10.2018:
"Resolved that following amendments in existing instructions regarding grant of 23 years advance promotional increment issued vide FC No. 20/2000 dated 28.07.2000, FC No. 53/2011 dated 18.11.2011 for employees and FC No. 54/2011 dated 18.11.2011 for officers along with exemption of passing of departmental examination, if any, be and is hereby approved with effect from the date of issue of notification (Finance Circular) by PSPCL:
3 of 17 ::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 ::: CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 4 Sr. Present clauses Proposed clauses No.
1. He/she has the avenue of three Deleted promotions but has not earned three regular promotions in his/her regular service from the date of joining on the induction post/or any other post specifically declared as induction post for granting time bound promotional/devised promotional scale.
2. He/she has not earned third H/she has not earned three promotions promotion in his/her regular service upto 23 years of regular service from between 16th and 23rd years of service the date of joining on the induction post/or any other post specifically declared as induction post for granting time bound promotional/devised promotional scale.
3. he/she has not been placed in a scale Deleted which is higher than the scale of his/her next higher post
4. The increment(s) are in the nature of No change advance promotional benefits to be absorbed in the next regular promotion.
5. Those who forego promotion shall not No change be entitled for this benefit
6. ------- The benefit of advance promotional increment will be allowed without change in grade pay (Wherever applicable) and the date of annual increment will remain unchanged.
4. As a result, the rights of the petitioner/s will be governed by the decision in LPA No. 997 of 2016, 'Punjab State Power Corporation Limited Vs. Nirmala Rani' decided on 22.09.2016 and other connected appeals and the orders of the Supreme Court in Interlocutory Applications in SLP (C) Diary No. 30953 of 2017 dismissed on 13.10.2017 and keeping in view the two resolutions of the Corporation (supra) the further course of 4 of 17 ::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 ::: CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 5 action, in any, will be governed by this order. Relief will be regulated on the cumulative effect of these judicial and administrative decisions. So far as payment of arrears of benefit of promotional increments is concerned, those will be determined by the Corporation restricted to 36 months from the date of filing of the respective writ petitions.
5. With these observations, these petitions are disposed of. The entire exercise be carried out within three months from the date of receiving of the certified copy of this order and the financial benefits be disbursed to the rightful owners/recipients within the next two months failing which the amounts will carry 6% interest till realisation.
(RAJIV NARAIN RAINA)
29.11.2018 JUDGE
kv
Sr. No. Case No. Parties Name
1. CWP No. 4544 of 2017 Surinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
2. CWP No. 4545 of 2017 Kuldeep Kumar Vs. PSPCL and another
3. CWP No. 1033 of 2017 Balwinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
4. CWP No. 1014 of 2017 Harbhajan Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
5. CWP No. 1028 of 2017 Vijay Kumar Vs. PSPCL and another
6. CWP No. 1046 of 2017 Mohinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
7. CWP No. 1052 of 2017 Gurcharan Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
8. CWP No. 1305 of 2017 Amar Nath Vs. PSPCL and another
9. CWP No. 1306 of 2017 Ganga Dass Vs. PSPCL and another
10. CWP No. 1308 of 2017 Prem Masih Vs. PSPCL and another
11. CWP No. 1309 of 2017 Gian Chand Vs. PSPCL and another
12. CWP No. 1310 of 2017 Babu Ram Vs. PSPCL and another
13. CWP No. 10030 of 2017 Niramjan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
5 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 6
14. CWP No. 10041 of 2017 Mohan Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
15. CWP No. 10070 of 2017 Pritam Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
16. CWP No. 10071 of 2017 Kuldeep Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
17. CWP No. 10072 of 2017 Jangir Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
18. CWP No. 10073 of 2017 Maghar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
19. CWP No. 10074 of 2017 Gurjant Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
20. CWP No. 10075 of 2017 Satpal Vs. PSPCL and others
21. CWP No. 10076 of 2017 Mohinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
22. CWP No. 10077 of 2017 Sukha Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
23. CWP No. 10078 of 2017 Gurmat Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
24. CWP No. 10079 of 2017 Kulwant Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
25. CWP No. 10080 of 2017 Mukhtiar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
26. CWP No. 10081 of 2017 Sita Ram Vs. PSPCL and others
27. CWP No. 10082 of 2017 Swaranjit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
28. CWP No. 10083 of 2017 Jarnail Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
29. CWP No. 10084 of 2017 Labh Singh Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
30. CWP No. 10085 of 2017 Karnail Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
31. CWP No. 10086 of 2017 Jarnail Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
32. CWP No. 10087 of 2017 Mahel Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
33. CWP No. 10088 of 2017 Sham Lal Vs. PSPCL and others
34. CWP No. 10089 of 2017 Sukhdev Ram Vs. PSPCL and others
35. CWP No. 10090 of 2017 Jasdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
36. CWP No. 10091 of 2017 Kashmir Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
37. CWP No. 10092 of 2017 Deep Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
38. CWP No. 10093 of 2017 Kapoor Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
39. CWP No. 10094 of 2017 Prem Lata Vs. PSPCL and others
40. CWP No. 10095 of 2017 Balraj Krishan Vs. PSPCL and others
41. CWP No. 10096 of 2017 Jai Karan Vs. PSPCL and others
42. CWP No. 10097 of 2017 Balbir Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
43. CWP No. 10098 of 2017 Inderjit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
44. CWP No. 10099 of 2017 Jarnail Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
45. CWP No. 10668 of 2017 Mam Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
6 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 7
46. CWP No. 10683 of 2017 Ranvir Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
47. CWP No. 10688 of 2017 Gurdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
48. CWP No. 10690 of 2017 Balvir Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
49. CWP No. 10691 of 2017 Piar Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
50. CWP No. 10726 of 2017 Mukand Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
51. CWP No. 10795 of 2017 Madan MohanVs. PSPCL and others
52. CWP No. 10796 of 2017 Krishan Dutt Vs. PSPCL and others
53. CWP No. 10797 of 2017 Gurnam Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
54. CWP No. 10802 of 2017 Ram Diya Vs. PSPCL and others
55. CWP No. 10804 of 2017 Jai Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
56. CWP No. 10805 of 2017 Balwinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
57. CWP No. 11277 of 2017 Shish Pal Vs. PSPCL and others
58. CWP No. 11278 of 2017 Des Raj Sharma Vs. PSPCL and others
59. CWP No. 11279 of 2017 Pawan Kumar Vs. PSPCL and another
60. CWP No. 11280 of 2017 Darshana Devi Vs. PSPCL and another
61. CWP No. 11281 of 2017 Naresh Kumar Vs. PSPCL and others
62. CWP No. 11282 of 2017 Ajit Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
63. CWP No. 11716 of 2017 Baljinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
64. CWP No. 11717 of 2017 Inderjit Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
65. CWP No. 11718 of 2017 Darshan Windhg Vs. PSPCL and another
66. CWP No. 11719 of 2017 Malwinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
67. CWP No. 11726 of 2017 Ram Kumar Sharma Vs. PSPCL and others
68. CWP No. 11784 of 2017 Surjit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
69. CWP No. 11785 of 2017 Hakam Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
70. CWP No. 10227 of 2017 Avtar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
71. CWP No. 11786 of 2017 Hari Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
72. CWP No. 11787 of 2017 Gurmail Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
73. CWP No. 11788 of 2017 Harbhajan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
74. CWP No. 11789 of 2017 Sharanjit Kaur Vs. PSPCL and others
75. CWP No. 11790 of 2017 Ved Parkash Vs. PSPCL and others
76. CWP No. 11791 of 2017 Daya Ram Vs. PSPCL and others
77. CWP No. 11792 of 2017 Baldev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
78. CWP No. 11793 of 2017 Harchand Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
7 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 8
79. CWP No. 11794 of 2017 Gurmail Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
80. CWP No. 11795 of 2017 Satish Kumar Vs. PSTCL and another
81. CWP No. 11796 of 2017 Vijay Kumar Vs. PSPCL and others
82. CWP No. 11797 of 2017 Jagrup Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
83. CWP No. 11798 of 2017 Sadhu Ram Vs. PSPCL and others
84. CWP No. 11799 of 2017 Karnail Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
85. CWP No. 11800 of 2017 Darshan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
86. CWP No. 11801 of 2017 Narinder Kumar Vs. PSPCL and others
87. CWP No. 11802 of 2017 Harinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
88. CWP No. 11803 of 2017 Mohinder Kaur Vs. PSPCL and others
89. CWP No. 11804 of 2017 Mohinder Pal Vs. PSTCL and others
90. CWP No. 11805 of 2017 Jaswinder Kaur Vs. PSTCL and others
91. CWP No. 11806 of 2017 Avtar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
92. CWP No. 11807 of 2017 Joginder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
93. CWP No. 11808 of 2017 Jit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
94. CWP No. 11821 of 2017 Samson Vs. PSPCL and others
95. CWP No. 11865 of 2017 Arun Kumar Vs. PSPCL and others
96. CWP No. 11866 of 2017 Malkiat Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
97. CWP No. 11874 of 2017 Avtar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
98. CWP No. 11930 of 2017 Gajinder Nath Vs. PSPCL and others
99. CWP No. 11932 of 2017 Shiv Kumar Vs. PSPCL and others
100. CWP No. 11973 of 2017 Balwinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
101. CWP No. 11935 of 2017 Tirlok Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
102. CWP No. 1307 of 2017 Mukhtiar Masih Vs. PSPCL and others
103. CWP No. 12475 of 2017 Manjit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
104. CWP No. 14649 of 2017 Major Singh Vs. Chief Managing Director, PSPCL and
others
105. CWP No.14650 of 2017 Harbhajan Singh Vs. Chief Managing Director, PSPCL and
others
106. CWP No. 14651 of 2017 Ramesh Chander Vs. Chief Managing Director, PSPCL and
others
107. CWP No. 15135 of 2017 Chamkaur Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
108. CWP No. 15136 of 2017 Mewa Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
109. CWP No. 15137 of 2017 Amarjit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
8 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 9
110. CWP No. 15138 of 2017 Piara Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
111. CWP No. 15139 of 2017 Bahadar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
112. CWP No. 15140 of 2017 Balbir Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
113. CWP No. 15141 of 2017 Angpal Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
114. CWP No. 15142 of 2017 Darbara Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
115. CWP No. 15143 of 2017 Baljit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
116. CWP No. 15144 of 2017 Harbans Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
117. CWP No. 15145 of 2017 Charan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
118. CWP No. 15146 of 2017 Jagtar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
119. CWP No. 15547 of 2017 Joginder Singh Vs. PSTCL and others
120. CWP No. 15549 of 2017 Gurcharan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
121. CWP No. 15550 of 2017 Davinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
122. CWP No. 15559 of 2017 Tota Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
123. CWP No. 15561 of 2017 Brij Mohan Sharma Vs. PSTCL and others
124. CWP No. 15562 of 2017 Vir Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
125. CWP No. 15815 of 2017 Joginder Pal Vs. PSPCL and others
126. CWP No. 15816 of 2017 Nirbhai Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
127. CWP No. 15818 of 2017 Gurjant Singh Vs. PSTCL and others
128. CWP No. 15817 of 2017 Ram Kishan Vs. PSPCL and others
129. CWP No. 10094 of 2017 Amrik Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
130. CWP No. 15819 of 2017 Darshan Ram Vs. PSPCL and others
131. CWP No. 15820 of 2017 Karnail Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
132. CWP No. 15821 of 2017 Harjit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
133. CWP No. 16427 of 2017 Harbans Singh Vs. PSTCL and others
134. CWP No. 16465 of 2017 Baldev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
135. CWP No. 16466 of 2017 Surjit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
136. CWP No. 16467 of 2017 Chand Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
137. CWP No. 16468 of 2017 Gurmail Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
138. CWP No. 16469 of 2017 Gurdeep Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
139. CWP No. 16470 of 2017 Jaspal Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
140. CWP No. 16471 of 2017 Rakesh Kumar Vs. PSPCL and others
141. CWP No. 16472 of 2017 Ashok Kumar Vs. PSPCL and others
142. CWP No. 16473 of 2017 Sadiq Masih Vs. PSPCL and others
9 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 10
143. CWP No. 16474 of 2017 Gian Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
144. CWP No. 16694 of 2017 Baldev Raj and another Vs. PSPCL and others
145. CWP No. 16711 of 2017 Subash Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
146. CWP No. 16731 of 2017 Basant Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
147. CWP No. 16823 of 2017 Gurdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
148. CWP No. 16824 of 2017 Kanwaljit Kaur Vs. PSPCL and others
149. CWP No. 16825 of 2017 Viru Ram Vs. PSPCL and others
150. CWP No. 16826 of 2017 Sant Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
151. CWP No. 16827 of 2017 Mukhtiar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
152. CWP No. 16828 of 2017 Niranjan Dass Vs. PSPCL and others
153. CWP No. 17137 of 2017 Jaswant Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
154. CWP No. 1769 of 2017 Harpal Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
155. CWP No. 1776 of 2017 Harbans Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
156. CWP No. 18089 of 2017 Hari Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
157. CWP No. 18150 of 2017 Garib Ram Vs. PSPCL and others
158. CWP No. 18532 of 2017 Hemant Kumar Vs. PSPCL and others
159. CWP No. 19041 of 2017 Ajit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
160. CWP No. 19047 of 2017 Gurmukh Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
161. CWP No. 19344 of 2017 Ramesh Chand and others Vs. PSPCL and others
162. CWP No. 19370 of 2017 Joginder Singh Vs. Chief Managing Director, PSTCL and
others
163. CWP No. 19584 of 2017 Avinash Chander Vs. PSPCL and others
164. CWP No.19627 of 2017 Gurcharan Dass Vs. PSPCL and others
165. CWP No. 1972 of 2017 Thakur Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
166. CWP No. 20100 of 2017 Jagtar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
167. CWP No. 20250 of 2017 Baldev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
168. CWP No. 20251 of 2017 Mohinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
169. CWP No. 20634 of 2017 Dilbagh Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
170. CWP No. 22391 of 2017 Shavinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
171. CWP No. 22720 of 2017 Buta Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
172. CWP No. 22759 of 2017 Nachattar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
173. CWP No. 22803 of 2017 Balihar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
174. CWP No. 22995 of 2017 Achhe Lal Vs. PSPCL and others
10 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 11
175. CWP No. 2380 of 2017 Harbans Lal Vs. PSPCL and another
176. CWP No. 2381 of 2017 Nain Bahadur Vs. PSPCL and another
177. CWP No. 2430 of 2017 Kuldeep Ram Vs. PSPCL and another
178. CWP No. 2431 of 2017 Shashi Bhushan Vs. PSPCL and another
179. CWP No. 2432 of 2017 Hakam Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
180. CWP No. 2562 of 2017 Gurdeep Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
181. CWP No. 2564 of 2017 Varinder Kumar Vs. PSPCL and another
182. CWP No. 2565 of 2017 Lal Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
183. CWP No. 3025 of 2017 Ajaib Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
184. CWP No. 3428 of 2017 Milap Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
185. CWP No. 3604 of 2017 Ram Dass Vs. PSPCL and others
186. CWP No. 3630 of 2017 Sukhdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
187. CWP No. 4534 of 2017 Gurdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
188. CWP No. 4535 of 2017 Gurmeet Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
189. CWP No. 4536 of 2017 Mangat Ram Vs. PSPCL and another
190. CWP No. 4537 of 2017 Naseeb Chand Vs. PSPCL and another
191. CWP No. 4538 of 2017 Udham Singh Khadial Vs. PSPCL and another
192. CWP No. 4540 of 2017 Teja Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
193. CWP No. 4539 of 2017 Jiwan Lal Vs. PSPCL and another
194. CWP No. 4541 of 2017 Harish Chand Vs. PSPCL and another
195. CWP No. 4542 of 2017 Inder Jit Vs. PSPCL and another
196. CWP No. 4543 of 2017 Hari Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
197. CWP No. 2575 of 2017 Sangat Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
198. CWP No. 2604 of 2017 Gurmit Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
199. CWP No. 2605 of 2017 Tajinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
200. CWP No. 2938 of 2017 Inderjit Vs. PSPCL and others
201. CWP No. 2965 of 2017 Govardhan Dass Vs. PSPCL and others
202. CWP No. 5185 of 2017 Sewa Singh aVs. PSPCL and another
203. CWP No. 5950 of 2017 Gobind Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
204. CWP No. 6019 of 2017 Gurcharan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
205. CWP No. 6020 of 2017 Vasakha Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
206. CWP No. 6021 of 2017 Jagdish Raipuri Vs. PSPCL and others
207. CWP No. 6023 of 2017 Gurdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
11 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 12
208. CWP No. 6024 of 2017 Gurdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
209. CWP No. 6325 of 2017 Hardev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
210. CWP No. 6026 of 2017 Bhola Ram Vs. PSPCL and others
211. CWP No. 6027 of 2017 Karam Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
212. CWP No. 6328 of 2017 Jagroop Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
213. CWP No. 6029 of 2017 Ravikant Vs. PSPCL and others
214. CWP No. 6030 of 2017 Sarman Lal Vs. PSPCL and others
215. CWP No. 6031 of 2017 Ranjit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
216. CWP No. 6163 of 2017 Boota Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
217. CWP No. 6324 of 2017 Gurnaib Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
218. CWP No. 6356 of 2017 Bhajan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
219. CWP No. 6479 of 2017 Balwant Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
220. CWP No. 6649 of 2017 Mohinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
221. CWP No. 6706 of 2017 Narinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
222. CWP No. 6707 of 2017 Ishwar Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
223. CWP No. 6022 of 2017 Pritam Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
224. CWP No. 6708 of 2017 Radhe Sham Vs. PSPCL and another
225. CWP No. 6028 of 2017 Ajit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
226. CWP No. 6709 of 2017 Prem Bahader Vs. PSPCL and another
227. CWP No. 6326 of 2017 Roop Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
228. CWP No. 6710 of 2017 Balwinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
229. CWP No. 6327 of 2017 Baldev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
230. CWP No. 6711 of 2017 Dev Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
231. CWP No. 6712 of 2017 Harnam Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
232. CWP No. 6714 of 2017 Samsher Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
233. CWP No. 6853 of 2017 Hari Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
234. CWP No. 6882 of 2017 Kishori Lal Vs. PSPCL and others
235. CWP No. 6918 of 2017 Surjit Kumar Vs. Chief Managing Direction, PSPCL and
others
236. CWP No. 7002 of 2017 Gurmeet Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
237. CWP No. 7003 of 2017 Kurshad Massih Vs. PSPCL and another
238. CWP No. 7511 of 2017 Hari Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
239. CWP No. 7520 of 2017 Bharat Bhushan Vs. PSPCL and others
12 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 13
240. CWP No. 7527 of 2017 Harbans Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
241. CWP No. 7781 of 2017 Surjit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
242. CWP No. 7818 of 2017 Kuldeep Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
243. CWP No. 7933 of 2017 Piara Khan Vs. PSPCL and another
244. CWP No. 7937 of 2017 Bhagwant Rai Vs. PSPCL and another
245. CWP No. 8007 of 2017 Barkha Ram Vs. PSPCL and another
246. CWP No. 8023 of 2017 Nirmal Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
247. CWP No. 8127 of 2017 Gurkirpal Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
248. CWP No. 8133 of 2017 Kartar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
249. CWP No. 6025 of 2017 Pritam Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
250. CWP No. 8139 of 2017 Ravinder Kaur Vs. Chief Managing Director, PSPCL and
others
251. CWP No. 8182 of 2017 Sinder Pal Vs. Chief Managing Director, PSPCL and others
252. CWP No. 6713 of 2017 Tej Ram Vs. PSPCL and another
253. CWP No. 8204 of 2017 Sarab Jeet Devgan Vs. PSPCL and others
254. CWP No. 8293 of 2017 Krishan Kumar Vs. Chief Managing Director, PSPCL and
others
255. CWP No. 8299 of 2017 Satish Kumar Vs. PSPCL and others
256. CWP No. 8304 of 2017 Kamal Jit Sharma Vs. PSPCL and others
257. CWP No. 8305 of 2017 Sat Pal Vs. Chief Managing Director, PSPCL and others
258. CWP No. 8339 of 2017 Bhagwan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
259. CWP No. 8842 of 2017 Karam Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
260. CWP No. 8843 of 2017 Darshan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
261. CWP No. 8844 of 2017 Gurdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
262. CWP No. 8845 of 2017 Iqattar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
263. CWP No. 8846 of 2017 Jangir Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
264. CWP No. 8847 of 2017 Surinder Pal Vs. PSPCL and others
265. CWP No. 8848 of 2017 Amar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
266. CWP No. 8849 of 2017 Amir Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
267. CWP No. 8850 of 2017 Puran Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
268. CWP No. 8851 of 2017 Hukam Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
269. CWP No. 8852 of 2017 Ram Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
270. CWP No. 8853 of 2017 Mehar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
13 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 14
271. CWP No. 8854 of 2017 Piara Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
272. CWP No. 8855 of 2017 Lal Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
273. CWP No. 8856 of 2017 Darvara Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
274. CWP No. 8857 of 2017 Jagroop Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
275. CWP No. 8858 of 2017 Sunder Lal Vs. PSPCL and others
276. CWP No. 8859 of 2017 Manjit Kaur Vs. PSPCL and others
277. CWP No. 8860 of 2017 Hakam Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
278. CWP No. 8861 of 2017 Chaman Lal Vs. PSPCL and others
279. CWP No. 8862 of 2017 Gurbax Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
280. CWP No. 9149 of 2017 Bhupinder Singh and others Vs. PSPCL and others
281. CWP No. 9382 of 2017 Kasturi Lal Vs. PSPCL and others
282. CWP No. 9389 of 2017 Charan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
283. CWP No. 9573 of 2017 Kashmiri Lal Vs. PSPCL and others
284. CWP No. 9584 of 2017 Harjinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
285. CWP No. 9642 of 2017 Surjeet Kumar Vs. PSPCL and others
286. CWP No. 9708 of 2017 Sukhdev Raj Vs. PSPCL and others
287. CWP No. 25166 of 2017 Mohar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
288. CWP No. 27962 of 2017 Charanjit Singh and others Vs. PSPCL and others
289. CWP No. 16829 of 2017 Charan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
290. CWP No. 16830 of 2017 Paramjit Kaur Vs. PSPCL and others
291. CWP No. 16831 of 2017 Pardeep Kaur Vs. PSPCL and others
292. CWP No. 16832 of 2017 Sandesh Kumari Vs. PSPCL and others
293. CWP No. 25203 of 2017 Raj Krishan Vs. PSPCL and others
294. CWP No. 25205 of 2017 Baldev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
295. CWP No. 25206 of 2017 Sohan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
296. CWP No. 25207 of 2017 Virsa Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
297. CWP No. 25208 of 2017 Bawa Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
298. CWP No. 25209 of 2017 Piara Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
299. CWP No. 25210 of 2017 Sukhdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
300. CWP No. 25211 of 2017 Surjit Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
301. CWP No. 25212 of 2017 Himmat Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
302. CWP No. 25213 of 2017 Bachitter Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
303. CWP No.25214 of 2017 Prem Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
14 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 15
304. CWP No. 25215 of 2017 Gurdeep Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
305. CWP No. 25216 of 2017 Kulwant Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
306. CWP No. 25218 of 2017 Narayan Das Vs. PSPCL and others
307. CWP No. 25217 of 2017 Jugraj Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
308. CWP No. 25219 of 2017 Boota Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
309. CWP No. 25220 of 2017 Sohan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
310. CWP No. 25221 of 2017 Sukhdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
311. CWP No. 25222 of 2017 Chajju Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
312. CWP No. 25223 of 2017 Ram Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
313. CWP No.25224 of 2017 Diwan Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
314. CWP No. 25225 of 2017 Karnail Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
315. CWP No. 25226 of 2017 Karnail Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
316. CWP No. 25227 of 2017 Mukhtiar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
317. CWP No. 25228 of 2017 Sarup Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
318. CWP No. 25229 of 2017 Sita Ram Maan Vs. PSPCL and others
319. CWP No. 25230 of 2017 Hardeep Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
320. CWP No. 25231 of 2017 Sukhdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
321. CWP No. 25232 of 2017 Nachhatar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
322. CWP No.25204 of 2017 Lal Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
323. CWP No.25234 of 2017 Harminder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
324. CWP No. 25235 of 2017 Harvinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
325. CWP No. 25236 of 2017 Balbir Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
326. CWP No. 25237 of 2017 Jaswinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
327. CWP No. 25238 of 2017 Balkar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
328. CWP No. 25239 of 2017 Ashok Kumar Vs. PSPCL and others
329. CWP No. 25240 of 2017 Gurdial Chand Vs. PSPCL and others
330. CWP No. 25241 of 2017 Ishar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
331. CWP No. 25242 of 2017 Jagbir Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
332. CWP No. 27971 of 2017 Madan Gopal and others Vs. PSPCL and others
333. CWP No.26873 of 2017 Pal Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
334. CWP No.26874 of 2017 Sukhmander Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
335. CWP No. 26875 of 2017 Jaswinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
336. CWP No.26876 of 2017 Bhagwan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
15 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 16
337. CWP No.2297 of 2017 Charan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
338. CWP No. 2298 of 2017 Ruldu Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
339. CWP No. 2299 of 2017 Piara Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
340. CWP No.2300 of 2017 Darshan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
341. CWP No. 2301 of 2017 Makhan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
342. CWP No. 2302 of 2017 Lakhbir Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
343. CWP No. 2303 of 2017 Dev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
344. CWP No. 2304 of 2017 Kulwant Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
345. CWP No. 2305 of 2017 Gura Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
346. CWP No. 2306 of 2017 Jasmail Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
347. CWP No. 2307 of 2017 Gurcharan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
348. CWP No. 1704 of 2017 Bilour Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
349. CWP No. 1758 of 2017 Mukhtiar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
350. CWP No.1759 of 2017 Bachittar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
351. CWP No. 1760 of 2017 Santokh Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
352. CWP No. 1761 of 2017 Inderjit Vs. PSPCL and others
353. CWP No. 1762 of 2017 Avtar Krishan Vs. PSPCL and others
354. CWP No. 1763 of 2017 Bahittar Singh Rana Vs. PSPCL and others
355. CWP No. 1764 of 2017 Prem Nath Vs. PSPCL and others
356. CWP No. 8767 of 2018 Balwant Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
357. CWP No. 6001 of 2018 Bhinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
358. CWP No. 6002 of 2018 Major Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
359. CWP No. 6003 of 2018 Baldev Raj Vs. PSPCL and others
360. CWP No. 6004 of 2018 Nirmal Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
361. CWP No. 6005 of 2018 Sukhdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
362. CWP No. 6006 of 2018 Mukhtiar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
363. CWP No. 6007 of 2018 Krishna Rani Vs. PSPCL and others
364. CWP No. 2512 of 2018 Harminder Kumar Vs. PSPCL and another
365. CWP No.4462 of 2018 Inderjit Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
366. CWP No. 4463 of 2018 Rani Devi Vs. PSPCL and another
367. CWP No. 4464 of 2018 Bant Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
368. CWP No.4795 of 2018 Subhash Chander and ors Vs. PSPCL and ors
369. CWP No. 10694 of 2018 K.K.Sharma and ors Vs. PSPCL and ors
16 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::
CWP No. 1013 of 2017 (O&M) 17
370. CWP No. 7147 of 2018 Gajjan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
371. CWP No.24282 of 2016 Uttam Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
372. CWP No. 24314 of 2016 Maghar Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
373. CWP No. 24336 of 2016 Ravinder Bhushan Vs. PSPCL and another
374. CWP No. 24380 of 2016 Bal Krishan Vs. PSPCL and another
375. CWP No. 24381 of 2016 Jit Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
376. CWP No. 26378 of 2016 Gurdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
377. CWP No. 853 of 2017 Balkar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
378. CWP No. 2868 of 2017 Manmohan Kaur Vs. PSPCL and others
379. CWP No.5726 of 2017 Joginder Paul and others Vs. PSPCL and others
380. CWP No. 5727 of 2017 Krpal Singh and others Vs. PSPCL and others
381. CWP No.11262 of 2017 Sukhdev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
382. CWP No. 3707 of 2018 Bhupinder Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
383. CWP No. 3708 of 2018 Gurmail Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
384. CWP No. 3709 of 2018 Budh Ram Vs. PSPCL and others
385. CWP No.3710 of 2018 Uggar Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
386. CWP No. 3711 of 2018 Vijay Kumar Vs. PSPCL and others
387. CWP No. 3712 of 2018 Baldev Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
388. CWP No.14407 of 2018 Jagdish Singh Vs. PSPCL and another
389. CWP No. 16222 of 2018 Tara Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
390. CWP No. 16224 of 2018 Kamlesh Kumar Vs. PSPCL and others
391. CWP No. 18527 of 2018 Som Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
392. CWP No. 18528 of 2018 Dharam Singh Thind Vs. PSPCL and another
393. CWP No. 23965 of 2018 Harbans Lal and others Vs. Secretary, PSPCL and others
394. CWP No. 24537 of 2014 Sohan Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
395. CWP No.25233 of 2017 Ajmer Singh Vs. PSPCL and others
(RAJIV NARAIN RAINA)
29.11.2018 JUDGE
kv
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
17 of 17
::: Downloaded on - 01-01-2019 09:21:22 :::