Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

United India Insurance Co Ltd vs Sri T G Ranga S/O Late Sri. T.N.Ramanujam on 25 March, 2011

Author: K.Govindarajulu

Bench: K.Govindarajulu

EN" "§"f"1]':'*3 E-[IKE H C€7)'u'§'€'I' OF Kz*xRl\E.A'[':°x.K5*x A71" §5;*XNC};'X.I;C)§Z_I§

}§ii)A"I'EE) '1";-£13 TH E: 25% ibzw <31? M.;;Rc:H 2.0 .1 2 j

I*3E'i F0 REE

'_1fm<:. ;--:c>1.\:§31;,£.::. EVIR JT;ES"§I'{?.§€Z K QQx%1N1)g:r2;m%Ii;:;, if-.  _

;'vTE~"A I\§C).€33E38 £31?' 2(Z?{}8 g;v;:xf§;'
§E3i§'1'\Az'IEIi1N: V x__ " '- . _

{EN'£'l'§SI.} 1E\3§f)1.A INS[.4IRA.N('3§3 (X). I;'I1'I{}u. 
NC). £53,' 1921., II §'I,C}(}R,  '
S(',)U'I"'i"I £iI\é'§} IZ{')A.I').

E3AS.2'XV:'-\E\F (3: {K31 a

£3£':i\§C.}./-\J..'()Ik'_I3_

zmw R§ZE3RI:?S£3N"l'I*3I13 £3?   . 

MA.:\%A<:;£:R, ;'2§:,£;I§i>1~¢g1;.-£>I3'tfIc;:;.    :
UNI"'§'E£'}I1'€IZ)IAIE'{§S{_E L.=f~;t:g?<i'.Iv::'--§i:=:::~f_1:113,  " 
N925. SPEAN ;:;A£'a';a;_~;'A:s§;:xV 1i315«.§r--,...r__>I*'~1'.J_e:::x,'---  ' '
M.<:;.R0A1":>. E3ji.N€2;A.I;;{)§{§3§. ' _  'L  

. 5 .A1'>m:I.,I,AN'I'
{IEEEY $M"::*:vr5T:.;i§fé1 ;$:*E::3.I'a'?%%fidf?sNI3f#; ;*=x1t>"af:j  V
AN§i): '

2. sr'~:1'-'11; r:;x:xz:;A_   " 
5;; <1) L;2.';*;': T1'.N.I?AMAE\E{E<.§E&I"f1,

~ . '_..-=*xCI}I§J_3' -:z:;.£3<:_>1;"1'f $0 Yb:-;=:£f%..+';>.'..:_' .

A ' ' ; 2.. 1 .I¥'i=S.§51';1QX§{f¥T$i§¥2% C; I»w~§<i;;>3.
_/'<3 T.§:~52Ia§' cf; 5;" f1{s3;§'>§(};'§:,

;-'>~.'<a::(_I?;'r::__;1rxI§.35'<'.v;:;'H':_;§:;:». j:s*:¥:m.a2s;. '

:3,  ::s1«:;{A.:<sa'§:§xx-fgxzia 15* m2.3'$H.:<i:K,

 ' T::'~; /<1} §::':R.i..{'.§  RAN('}3%,
'  3:; 123:} Arzaxzé :11? 28 X-:*§:g:-xi-1&3'

- H'E.>'E§"I2'§T§'{§-NE:'§'£';S; : 31:1) :3: zma :';:;;x*;?
.j_>~::»;:;«::.>;2;<:;.;gx;: E\I<j>.;2E":3€'>'. $22 <:£e_<:>$$?

.J:2%:~::%:azz;2:2\a ;><i>:v:'z,z;;2 :3 ss;:m:;-:e:§
_§x::.;g::.,:'s:=2.z:  §€:§{}<}'"f'§.

  

,a,»,,w" 1'



'' '':sm:.;-  C£7~?;.v.§'~{21':§£.

';.:_<}'i'iV2§3&5:7:sé ii

'mi

{hie _;:)c:{.i.tiu1"1e1" ":0 §')I'€.)V%';', {.118 ;1<'<:*;ic.i<::m. i.1'z'1pac:'t 2m{.1 _ple2=1d for

{;1§Smisssa..§ of t'§}<'-? cé§e'1i1":1 pc:i..i1i.<311.

.3. 'I'h::2 1<':a:';'n3.<i 2'11<;%11:1b<3::' (if 'she 'i'1*ib1.1.m-11 I'1;i$ am-%;V1r£}é::I.""--?

21 C{")I1'i§,)t'3'IiS§Z1[..i{)IJ {if R&3.§.7E3,¢1O{}/--. }:*:23r»zi:€.€i 2r£_::ix:'{)t§é1ic ftir. fiiizté

221ppr:?I122.1'11'. (30m.€1'1c§ 'that am: of {he E1L¥'(TL,I:§)'1Ké'.If'Ii.SKK>:IT1'ii7f3{tid," §'fV!2f(VA):"K~A

am': the irgcresme {ax :"eé.111"12s:. ()n_cf"'z:<:&p()2"i";>ts pa:é;r'  {he

'Swat' }**'o3:1':'1 fer ihe yzsm" 2GO4wO5_..._£'fé€__c>'t;§j;er  fb:i2{0Q:55~O6.

4. Cawczfui (:0r1sic1<3i':;i'§;i'0n':0? f;,h€_'{).3¥fi1i'{TL.l§£?LI'E§ in these

d(}C£.2I"I'1tZ%i11 S wm11vci :e;'1"1v<;_x>v" t_f1&* §§1{':;>;:'_;€%*£:'f. f;,'r1<: drziitiasscéci iss Shown

as I'{s;.58,5S2Zf--"'i§'3 -Iivlfic  I"<:{1_'3f1_17::i' '-f.h€~  s21':21ry' u'r1.cie.:' the firs':.
1.

"€.'p€3'fl.., 1;': E11161 ';s§.<;34c:<>2'*;t14 1"e..p'c}z.7_'. E'€:=..76,7 1.4/-- sshown as the ;<s211a.r§,«n In Vr€'g;a1"<:3. _t.{:% ..jtVji:«1e."c_u_1.A1'*'1'<~*.r.;'~" i;1<?om<: of h0u.se: p:"opa:--:ri,y is cc>1}c:<:;fm_:dg iE.V_é1\::'.si1'z:1.'t)1 c eiFe1;'1 af*;.<:r the de:a1i.h. M11116 pe:*s<m St}, 'the C1ai:'1'12u'1i..s;~.; {:::111n0'r. c1aiz"1:1 EE.1"1:,:' §€)zv':. '§%_": aX'§:3§_'.§E-":1'(§ '£0 {he pI'£1pe31't.y. in E-E%i.iC§"é 23 :~;E§'u.aI.i(}7i:

m.i«;i':::;gg: i.':'1.f.{.:s'"fzzm5;i{irsm':.i.<>:'1 Eh:-:7 §§'}€?(}§E1€i of the :§£;>.¢::<:21:3e§L 7<ja7fl(71411Ei1T:?:E§E;. 'Z,h.E'. in(':{>1':1{é at Rs::.6.,409,..!'~ ':33; 'His? :%0m"t. 'i3<31.<)w iss "«s.ii:'1. Va-1 "§";*§.gE":£s:* §;C21§<%. 5:30; ii. shsétliié $1315? s;<7.2'2}ed {fiz:sw;':» )2' Vmw 4 4:
5 0:2 T.§'1€;? <.>1I'1er 1";a,11c§, 1c=:ar1'1ec.1 z.1<'1v£)(':a'{.e for i:.I'1<:% <?}.z1§.:'1'1a.1'11. :3z.:':31':1it. ihaé; the. §§'}(f{')X'.'{lt'2 tax. 1*e1':.21'r1:':; .Ii:{.§?;~TFV "z;z._is§a::_ <':<)x:1tc:':{t1s.e; §}'1r3 C1OCL11T"i'Ir';2I']1,:'-.3 an w'1"z§<":£"1 i§'i{'f(}i"1'}(;'. i':2:1x' 1€«:=§V§','z.1'1';'3;5_~*;' féieci. '1'h<,-":3-V v.:'{.>1.1I€,:i siztiw z"1'1e E};-11"§.i(',':§1£1i'E5' T118 'a:1"r:, 110%; :1Ia1'E{r;:d 3'11. \:'i<~:-rw of the zstd1t';.is3si%Ji'liI.§I zi?'r1.€*'[,s;é:L:°z51"i- iz3~ié"@,211e:;

{ax 1*et:L11';"1s3. 'E'i3e 11'1et.h<)d ;1{i{)13t,';é}:§-_§_~;,:,; £:héA .r;1éu'mz1';a;i.S '§~;~;.Vprop~;3r.VM 6, I.\/'Ia'[:c*,ri21i §51,lb'I1'IiSSiU11S W(> i;:.3_tI p_;"oba.b;:- iA_is€"21c:(i;ic?e};1'L is 21<;imit.1,ed. a'~.1(:i:i(m21t3i€. 11cé§§1j§f§'e:":(:<.% is j1:i'o«*,_ :ii${)L1t:ed. I1. is c)r11y thc: cgae-1.1'1mm Le. C1I'S1')LIk?€1"._V_ "PW~1_ €'§§21II}?1i1;!IC1{j'§fi§' an ::3.CEVc1(:a¥.ie, pa:"1;§<:u121:<'s 11z1'ri"e1§£-'1:{1- " in "--_1'@g21'1"'d "1'*<:s_ Vti-7Eie....Qé?c:..:p211,i<)r1 of her Inoihezr i§'f"6L1'1"2gi:if;1i, ;>'.é-3:ig,{i;<:> 4i'~p£'.t:*21 ?' .f€ie'it:{s as Lxnder:

' i'_'"I1 is-»; §'txi"'i;11éé:';f._S:.1E)i';1%£i.e£1 '{,h£~1'E'. my d:~:<::r;=;2-zsed I1'iOi.h-"a:I{' was"x.v03*}{;3'b3g'--..aé: V21 Chief ML'-Irlagt-31'. ECHCI E3a:'1k I;é1j1':i'i.r»:y:.1,~__S(;bh:3.~7F'<:arE. C011';:11i:;21:'iat. .R0a::i§ :'£"3£5"1:":\Q;.'v;1I¢i}1'E':"»§E.I"iC1 §121'».*f'i rc{1'.red in Augufist. 2003. I i5iiIf'i._hC?j s11.b2'i'1i.«I....i1iI.2:i; my ciecteasseci 1n0i.h<?1" WEES aim V Emi'0i':'1.<~3f Tax payee. zmci I am 21136 s9'L1.b:1";ii'.'t.i:1g 118:1:
..Eas:»1: "E.r:i<;:{>f1'1c:$ I"t';'fiL,L1}'1'1,E'-3 for 1'Lhi;',. yam' iZZOO5~€}ES . 23§11;v-:§ '«§2§00€>%:Q.'~§" for the 1111351 (:0:";sicié:r21¥iior1 cf I?;.his "E3-{a;311":[:=I.'L::-. CJ ")E.E..i'L 5?. 'j_Ti\I<)1.i"1i:":;__§ §'}:)u,:':d $2': 1.1%: chiézf £:2Xz1z'11mz21t.§{3;'1 {.0 sslmw _ v~.?}1<im} ":j:h,e §'_§21}"§.i('1L.1§é1I'f'§ in {he <:1a.i.:'11 pc'*i§'£.i(:)s2'"2 at R$;Z:IGGO;'-- ass ' §.I'i{§ii}EE"1i? 9? %'E':e3: €T§§",'{'_.'Li',é-'3E45£*,{'§ <7z1':: ha? §m:z"€:;2:s;€:{§ E10 .§{.:'::;°€'"§.4€}€},»='~ fizz E.§";%;é i;'11p1.1.§__3;:'}<;>=:W1 Gztiexi Se' {'*.z:)z.z1"t'. 1'1t')I{§s; 83.21:. i1'1f;': §:ec;L._1i.3res 3"L"§(.'.(j}I'1S§{1E?1'2fl.f:{)I'1 anal ézlfiéééei'1iC§£1L§()1'1 21f2"es§2."S{3._ T.hf:. s'L1I3%'12£_sf:§s3«i_<t>'z~1V cf the, Ec?211"1";€?{i I.n5:;;1.11;'2.1r1.c:r;> C';¢m'1p2'111y a{:cte}3t'£::i._ 211*i€§. '€}1é'»..._' 9 " V. i1';1;mg,f1'1<-:(:1 am-'a1'<"1 E1:-ibis fez'; be 21siVci§:.b
8. A(?(?.{)["{1i1'1g1}-'. tim apgaz-321.1 "1;111c}§%:£:%{i. r'I"1*'1;3 §z;%a:9_r"'r:%d7 :'1'1en2b:>r of {£29 '1'r-i13§:1'1a1} is c1i1~eL:%__é{3....E.:) cIéé::ide.'{,_1"1.€:. c:z1Vg§Er*--;1fr:,%sh in z1::(:<>i"ci21;'z{ée w1"1:}1 law, "She 211z'1QL;i'ié.é1:=_§ie:;;"2(3ssi"i; bvc gxiid back is the I11$sura1'"1<:t2 C01'11pa1r1§~--. _ ' O1'c%erc<i A. P15'