Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

K L Sathyaprakash S/O K L Lakshmipathy vs Kothari Motors Ltd on 25 August, 2010

Equivalent citations: 2011 (1) AIR KAR R 211

Bench: K.L.Manjunath, B.Manohar

,1 N 3: Tim Efifil-i CQUR1' GE? KfiR;NA"E'AKg% M' BANGAl@RE mmm ms Tim wm my SF AUSIJE'? mm PRE SE RT ma E-imwam E¢m.;.}T§,¥3TICE K.L.MAm*:m.%;fs;}1':%%%T.;j: T T ARM mm E-E{i}¥€'E§.,-E 2vm,Jt.Is':§<1§E 3§;m.;§mH;fg1¢e%V%'% "

Rm ra°ms;m m' {SQL 1 §;_Ez'1"¥E-"EN :
1, 5*-3ri,E%igL*Sa?;E3y£9.*g:ra1§1:;$E?, k ' San af ' ' Agmi a?mm..w;..5:§ 'a 1.
E"¥a::.f&*§"'1a73»:,_.Re*md;g""~~-- F1' aw rmifiiiig a3_t"fi*;.fig§iat;:.a,. _' "

Eapxwamnfiaé _ " * _ " ' Pwwaf Q? .fl.€'§':f?£3.i"T§Eg$'§f ~E*§.t;si&m"

S;*i;'§§LLnSri1*;@:;°§§'§: fix»? 2" %fenfian1:. « :'§S»1&i.§§:L.§85réna.t&13 3f.@§"}§;L.E;af}€a§1rm7?athy, ._ .é.~?smt;:s:%l:"I;*3r{} § ' Rf m;_ }§'35€;sL.i§*f§3, fiuaifimmpa Rand, fvfivwrazaa " 'V . w.fiPPE §»LAN'E'S ' E7:.f_f§,X'£'.V3e¢3hafl Rm & M. , fixdvmfiataal V V V ' A . Mamm Limitadg, fififififfi Vmmm Rama My3m*®«§'?$? QQ5, A flmmmm 2'-'B iflfiflfiwfiflmfi under rm Qamgamfim 3%-mt mprwmxtm. 'ray ifs flirmmr Sx*i.3.S»ati3h Kammy M3F'wm-5?fi $24. .,..R}'§ {Ry Eriffmgaxmrammhag 332 C-mmmel fem' ,, $r~ifl»i'".§£Z5Eha"E*.,,i &dmmtm) ' mm m u.;:; 43. R3 ww.s@cj;%;%efcPE thfl :..§u&gma:m.t am firearm elated:
Gfiwlmafiigxgga mm fim fi3e,Tw_g§T,# % ifirzfimig Ifiymreg dwmixxg .3:ui€"'f$§$'* agmifia parfmmzanma mi" tim agrassgwfint gfiam ¢'t:e:€,. ,; "

fispmai. :mrmii\:'ag'_ gm --f€:,:+:f thia day, . %g.:a.m£§fm mmmza 'fm§Eawi3:%: ~ % Aj%%%g§_w%§MENT V' L. $.'::"¢ .e:;h.a:.}1@1'1git"1g {he iwalifq; and mind damrm gaaaw by the Myme an zamggma in M F' _ ®,$§%7£3k$f5'1'§':§§Q&"

' ~. f§;'§"x§: aygmlamta asmm fiefarxcianta in Eh»: gxxit. ' V' Wax {Em pfiaintifi' fimfnm the '£'r§.a1 Quart. Tkm ' amt Wm gam by mm jpiamtifl' to emfmém the: agrmmanm af mfiae §i*£a3.1"}.@93 mm? §§uQ=3.W%9§ m fiiraaci the (V n. 2* 115 'V V .'rE%;$:3:?:3Q3I'$ W -;=;-.3? Ejj; 3 fiafmfianza tn axmam the mks fimei in reaycet cat.' piaint mhedula pmpaarty $1" tifia altarrmfiva if mrfmxmazwea mflmat. he gammi, fiimmt. the &afa:;§1a§§;?;:§: . my a. mam uf Rm,.'??5@5flQQf~ Wéith i-nmrseat f 3 L. 1 V ma "§':*ia1 mm rm awm m¢4 C éfifmxdamm ta: azsmmxfie 'fiche aszlle . mmm mam Whififi the g;ai3.m-.g;s :;3:1:}i¥:$&':°1;V_§%"T_*§a gag. ma mafia &aBd ragifimrad iiufimgh fiw cuurt mm &ufigmmnt and it}. this 3,, iamzevd mmmrel far fim apmlmfltfi' «_.;a;:':fi ' Sxmim" cmznael, Sri' _v gespmzzdwxt.

2 .,'2;eja&i.z*§ ta fixia case am am hemunfler:

. * art: "b1"fl~t,Emr$ aanvci tha sehildmza. ' 16;?" mrfi Tiley are the awtzmm 0%' as aimmzm}. in am hxamrt of Myamm Cit}? in nmpg, Wfiww Emma pmcamimn Eaefida frem amp, 'me: prmgarmégaamm
-& aim E€m,'?'§E1% aitmamai at Emmnmmtap W i§ay'u2m Evimxcfki 2s.!I}raam§ bmmndaé mt: mat by mafig west. mam m.c:::r:'Eh by mad, math by aim fiQ.§ maaaaurigzg A' ts Wm': g3§*+gm* W153. mart}: ta 3 agrrmfi my $313 am pmwrigg £2125: 'a:'?m;m Qéri' Gm fim gmtarfi tifmt 1*? 'f*§{"a'E;:3»afli§*a§r~'ékmah Wfifi 33:": mhmad thaw' cizmidéfi €55 pmwrtgr far ?,§mW* fiim dmiirg Wifii am grin-'fi:::%as@éae "rim amnvza far gm buaixm$& '_a§Lm;d' fiismmify its %31mi1:'1-ma mfivifiaa» Aé,a¢ay:i;§gke:g1y&%§a'1aLL%%%b«am3§' mi' fim an fiafia 3; ' '?;3:1m 'power mi' attmmey hmider azztcrw. : ms emfi thae p§mx1t amhmdmfifi pwmrty am.' ta ml} mm mm: fear 3. weal
-- ~. fj - 4._'_ »::4:3xmi,&a§.',§f:'¥;£.:m af Ra.é,,58,€Eflj-. 4% mam. mi' Ragfifigwiiw in em aefanamm by mmm mi' pay mrdm"
i an Cimrgmratimn Bmzk; it Was; agmfi that tiw mm mxmidmfmtfian of Ra.§,Q@,Q@<7}i~= ahali be yayuablua by the at the 'timzaz :31' :'na%®tra,ti:3z1 mi' tim (V
- .:;=;;;; in the ggflmnt:
mix cimd hafem fim Stab-Rrmiatrarw Siam the plaipt mhmfimka prmmrty Wms m °vamm1t km afijéimatmfl Qwam Mu& iéiaiiixg and; -
'aim mlmmt, t§':;«:§~rc§§ 4' j%=é*-'§%3f;aT 1 ' _ 'bm":. mm mm 3? an wrmn ympemy anttfit V saz'13;§i" afisfir 9%-3 '-
mmflmritgr ms par fim ymviaiixaifigfi' Lfiilfii ifimiiim mfl Rwilafinnj 2f&e%",VVV:,'§L'L_'~£«?'?5"£"*§..}__"i'§':1§§ '¢3:a~fi3x1«§ax1ta
-: 'm mbmm imarxxsémssitmiig' tinw 'i3iT&fi mipxziatcd ta mil that mm» The ma pnarmfifisimzx urmfiezr at' man Lanai fificflim & fi&gui$jz?%."iai<1 furfixmr mm af tim plaixzmifi '&xV"i:V'V:aa1§'.i§}§::5'x.2£fi.a'5$.Vb".ax1 mm mm far gamt mi' " s':E1¢ fiA <>£rt;--------z%2=.t"'%.zwd me want pfifflflfifiiflfl (:9 am the pxmperty, wag enwxw intact kfimmuen time $33 afireumamnmfi ammihm agrmmxant §x€w.§:i¢5..ii£% the: gmimfi ta ezzompimm tha waxmacfimm by mm T yam' fiwmm Q@w9a§.@Q5 and it Wm agramfi that rim 'fiafefifim-$3 ahmuici mmperaiae. with that piainfifi" ms (Q/.
p¢x'°x;::1i&$.imm fifimr; fiie 1 s:;*s§'i13:§?&'%'§e,§& 1=i: . 77 1 af %§€fi:C$S'iitiX'% mg mm dam? ssmtnfi mmciim tam axmtzm the aafie dmfi is-*1 fmamzr elf the ylaimtifil Wemfamg piain gm, iamwci miagragahic mtim: an 3%???' 8ap£fifi2?§$§' zwa aismm the éafamfimm mafia an atmmpt ' cm magam mix. 9%, 19%, mm mm gsmma atf '£1213 pmwrty had Emit: :maa1aha§1'.Va§%xé?'jv agrwmfimt. Q13, "Ehfi gmtmfi piéixitifi arm? '£13 gwaxfflrm Evig _m'fi?;m.m%. 2523:: tiw gmzmfi dafancimxta am :{15f._T_ '%e§§$§%u_f€,a fififl mm fiwfi? the wait *i:w.VA'i:'§§:f£:Qi fiéfanfiamw ta: ewmum ?:~§:}.§:§~ mi" mm agrmmant d$."3»-L. {ha mlmrzfmtixm ta yam & fiamm fur a sum mi' §:§$ ..?w_ the; Mm ammmmi E3; firm at }$% p.a..
Tim t§n sa§;~:mdm1ta tmmzeamd fiw auit, fismmdizrzg ta 'a:;?i'm mix prawrtgz" Wm afietmfi in that granfi km EC.=B.m£m &ymmppa mm after 'Sim %f.ifis:ti°1 mi" gum gr-and fmkmr may mrewmciaazci m gm plain: acfimfimia pmgmrtyu fig the law in Qumtmm Wan an A/,, uffwam §rapvz5:-rty they ¢btaim«:3;. an wmmptiun mi as 2% ma} mf Eha Brbmta Lmfi iflefifam and R@.flat:3nn§ fiat ?>-F6? Emm thea fimrt. mar; ZMXKEQS-'¥rg Whila gr.a.x'1tix1g pa:*m;éa.:avig>:§§_;"»T. Gmxt. ha& Empaamfi 43 mméifimn {Emit fim lamfi A' W amlci, mmtgagmi M ieaaerfi in. fmmssr of 1 wifiwut pzwlnr §flX'1Ii§3J'5£$§flfl fmm fim i T f émfamflaxzm hm; im right in '-Efifl V u fmmmr mi' thaw plaintfifi' Wi."£:3;'1fl:.fii_L:=;;j»:3s_:'*%;.*=*zV:i* Q1"

aggrmsai. af" firm Gum. mi" " fim flmfmmtimim &mugh'iAj§3m§rm&;F5E3ix;sI§"t:f {be Ga"s§1:;

"Em 91$ 2,,:.g»s"a;~ 'téagaitm by {ham an mm mm. ,a:7miég5u;;x:t;§,:»e;; Mam gm' mm * mt' aypmaahad xtizzeé cm firm gzwumti that ylaizxfiif at in hujgrirg ami awsfiim thee:
»m?m an idea 9%' i mifxmiuia graumrty far a pmfit'. by prism,
-. : ' ~ 'f}'._t&: gammy sitf fiw piaimtifi" Cimvnpmagg emtarafi V' mrerrsmgnit ta ptzmham ma pérsupermy far a sum $1' Eg_§€;§5;i".%Q§GB!- mi': 3.§a§%1. Subjam 'km tiw 'karma amfi. ~' mnd§;fim=ma mi' ma afmmaid agrmmmtg thaay afimfz tkw raasmipt Bf Ea.5G;Qflflf~ am admxm amla mnsifiwratmn. ('fix 'Ehsy fmrmar agwi m mmiw 'aim Emlanm agks manmifiexatinn at thaa him mi" ragémtrafimn mi" $'E,.1.£i ami mw mum mt. gm: aha }:*x3m%mim3. {mm 55E;¥t'£ * vim m: m emxzéitimm imWa%d%jw%m%Lmmc 2432. mm mm agmammt. a:iW3,am awagtmazg baa £9 Em mtmuted wiéhin £3: fifim cm mzmlmt. of z1am'1~\a.c'mg:u.z..'cii11gV-----:,+;Vf Gwwmmmxxm them waise §aIe-::":.'2:'E_riv'*f:A~f%:s.3;§'i'§~:**:.'*;r':n1tada They"

aka admit tha Qxfififfizfiiangéf'; amli flaw wapimfim which the aaifl agrmmmfzt' ta mmxx in 'cmwxm Eggfi fism mm wag mcmnciafii by 'fiat-; '3;<::wV3;f--.;¢a cmsmpfimiza 'fim "wmmaafinm "i':;a& ta mbtain pfian 93. iii; mm. mm mi' é aqixarm mzfii aweaw 'aim the aaiaa dmmi fisy payixm the: wise % m~mifia:*afi§mk W ma 2, W:

at vcaxm inm mdmtemce aw: mma 'aim mn@;itim:t:$ fimpsmd '$1: 3&1} ma by tha awa, zamrdam m mm, the plaintiff mt. mmtruat $3.9 huimizg as agreezfi ugmm, airxm the pkin€1?fi"°'wmna mm: maafiy and wifiixug Em pumhaaa them <9"
21
3%} Whfifiiflf am Plaintéfi pmwa {E-'mi: hfi wast rmay anti wfllim tn gmfmrm E1213 gmrt ef aammm:-1 mi' agrmmaemt in $311?
2} Wha-thaw' am mama? % fmflfmrmnw af flw allmed V:
mmvmn ma§m,i£~:' am my magma, 1 Pfiaixfiifi' baa "basin gzsut ix'3"';g€£a"*xa;¢$ka{ic3E;'12_V_€§'f pEm7;:1mv::hmfi'm}& g2rrmg:»§x*t.y'?_,-*~ . V' :33 Witmflxer am Eff'-F6affif£Efi$"&.::?Zi?¥E$I$&:'w:3§§X"tVtt&'§a?'«;'2'¢ z2m,& time: Wag the e;§aaa§::§x:;§=3' of 3$xz£$¢f§t?§'3;¥:£aé§reé mm §m*tWma%x:+g'}3i£ §§.v13iiiL'"i5?V';¢1E%:d.VfE%$'gééfaxjfianta? %} §"§aT}1£=;:v1";1'1::e_§:~.A 1 I gwcznme that the Fkmiifi imfi'®§;§i;3itt$§i"3fJ£*m¢h evf mntizaasf? , '_ 5} «ffihfefifiafim pram fimt they .A =.;c;;3§;::r§é§:%$;::i'vA"'%E:@ right of magma-:.}§.a.£iesn af ma ~a.gx'm&v£r"s§i3.t.A'fVtsf:§" 3&3} bemvmn {aha Plaimtéfi" am? x»:.:1§:*e mggggm amrsa mmaiwr the &fendfints prcfim that suit fig §zm.23:1U§aim'mie fiififlfi pnmeaaixzm. flf the p§&in'€ mhmixifia grnpami baa mm Emu mmght fiy '(Em Fiwififi in $11329 mac?
362/ '£9;
*7} ma Piaixztifi' §mW.a flmt ha 33 mzmitlazi for apwificz mrfihrmanm af 8} What: mfim" $3" dmrm?' En maiara" m psrmm fiw Manamg mrtnmr at' am ylamfiéfi j;r.*as'?vi@:§;}§33:31xz1.er3;"'aa:Vét An mmipeiwym mf fim p1min§:i§"% aw PW?' 'Fhe péaimzifl' "'1Ti:;m fim dafanfiani ~ Szrmm' get SW1 arsfi am: mfim :.zp§;i%i;14m:z?ida§.**1;i}s$:a and 3 an& Exmfll fig; --Cim.:rt mppmmiatrizmg rim emririefimm 15;: haid iasum»-1 and 2 in *"' %m'&xfiz";.-:_3 is $3 fin nwativag, isfiuawfl as flaw °~2°.fmf§: --:§;é':i*. jmrmciaratimxa. £mm=rdir%i5r,, {km wit M 021 zzmuams &imm'ng am V Execmxta 'aha male clmci Wiihifl 3 mmxthfi
--- flm pimintifi' 7% at iikaarty in get the mim '>'régiat¢-pm and flcmutesai. thmugh. mum Being 'am by fim Juagmm: axtefi fiecxm mi" the ma: Cmum tha prmfimt. aymal is; ffififia {L1, 23 59; We Iwwz § Sx*i..'R.%aahagiri; Ram, iaamefi mmiml appawing far than aggmfianm. W3 haw a.1a_Q_ ham Sfiuyngmmmaimfm, iearrmi aanim wm.:.3'"1m-:%i~. apwarim far fim 1%$pa:':.ci@::1&., fl. Tha xmirz. mnienfimn cxf the :2-.'fi§peiA7§..a7;"::";?"¢;a "4:.1¥$ 7 fig ihat the: Em} Cmwi Ema mmmitims::1'.a agéfimfi$v fifiwar hmldiifm fimt tiw Nsairxtifi' was xflf' lfi gmrfwm; ma }i3fi§'t arf' the e.?:§:*1§ra¢§V'§§§1'§§fjg.=sL}$e::._Aer:u:xi§3.e§;it.t€§§ an amwr in tlwrt firm ts: pmve that am {me %§i§:"'a:§mtrac: and further m9mmit'ta§.,,,/I\.;1:}mt am &&fe3:1dm1m em mt mmmméttati brseamzh mi 'kwknzgtragkézfég; is; za3;$§ man: 9:' tkm aypafisznts that the mu aexmr in hnifiixg flmt 'tim-
ci»sfa.:'"1a:§;€aéL1f3.fa%V_A'fi§;¥£{s;:' ;r1mt ma-rciaefi "firm mm af emmllafisrnn
- -. 44Q§.&gF fli and aha errmi ix"; gr§s,x1fi_Ig_& flwcrm. mammal $16 the .. .%:{E1;3pe1mx1'm, mm partim haw amt fiisputwfi. we ag t enmmd iztzm %aetmr'&ven mam an 3-3;.--1*§J'§1 whfimunflmfi {J :5 ma bmcssma mt}-axwutabia, am mm}: an agmermnt caxmt £35 mzfmsrcfi 35.21 any murt mi' Law: 8' Ha furthar ambmim fimtg ta QVEFEHIEIE ai@fl ta Em abtaixmd fimm. me: G~a*:.!a.*er1'11n¢:f:'S§t,' 4' .' yhixxfii? émricafi; 3 gfian. ta wmmfi". v:z2.e:'*_.4 :«3.&;2:1t.' };»=.~*a.V "

bufidizm @rmpm*t3,g pumuant ta 1°:2"}\'1i;€':Ej3.,'f§f1.#::§: :7 exxtarafi imam mmtimr A§*f3~__§i~ per the aemnci :5:-395, 'tfifivymirxtifi Wm £13,113?' bmmné has .;Wifi"x.i:m am yam" a2§é§_V.V;3:3r;:§x;§$;$§.A:'i§1€: buxficiimg fmm Elm flea aaim msnsicieratinm.

Thae. Trial' flmiirt "w:Ef:1m1]x.';£ Viihfinfiag "iizat 'kw was the ?:':*}.:;:sie«aesm':£;;:%.*:_."":'u§_'.A£:&.:.;«-42;. m1i§tm;e::t.V ta: eezsemgficte aha tmzmaacztien fine yaar Ram ;."%@--Q-1;Q95 wd fimt £1:

' awaa '§r§§:V"% ta cshtain p%3I'IY313"$§;$£1 fiwrm the , j;- «Sb-mpatef1t__A&ufiw2*§i}* in flfliiflmixfit tiima bufidmg mad tn %imm and plan, in azrciar tr; put; up £3; fiuilding mmpme fizm buifiizg Within am year hag ma mi: in faumur mi" fix: piaixzitifil fimmfiing Em him what Wfifi requirad we Em rrimm hy the ciefendanta E»?
tfm in was: any ms swim ting: pmirxtifi" m gm parmiaaicmm fimwrciim rm him? tiae amiamnm sf tha fiafendanm maamg whemwmr ahaér afigmmmzn am mquimfl; my _ m%f1;3«f_ *-. fianuxmmt ia mmm by the fifiaintifi' ta and a gplam ta gm: up mmtrmrszzitzrzfi the: ;:1fe4fe::fi;é:;131%';Vz:v?'§&1*¢.%;'A.V rmuum m gut their aw" .atmm;'= ';
fimétumanza, fismrditag mp " t:1%__3.¢:V m-mgwz-amfi§, with the r%éa7£5ans,. §hmt iwmwfl Em tétm plaimtifi', Eiaeaasm anfi phi: 02313; 93.71 E~fi§a.'§.:'?Lr;i'E?:;&- igfe: a§ftn:~:.z;' the awcczrlfl aflwmantv E 5":aza§§;:mfi a $213351 an $3» 39% gm; Lzixaugiilm }b%?<ém::~m1 'film p§an an @»a« § dié mt ffiiéa cmsmfitxmmtimm anfi cfiifi mt 2 with the tamm agmmant dmmi 2"§«9~1Q§§. Tim ' ' mmaiciwizzg "ézhmwz fmrm wmngiy fin tl§:m 3~mmaiL1siam tlmt the piamtifi' Wm ready mm.

parfmzrm E35313 pmrt mi' film mxmmct and him timer:

fiiw maanm {if 'rim awmtract by fm'gfi'::timg that fimfmmfigmxm hafi agrmti ta ml} @116 gumgmrty far {Emir 1% mmmmity as pm? the agrwmmtzt datm 3-3.--19§f{ far 2"
a sum mi' R$fi,5Q,0€)W- by rwaivizg an arivmm ammmt af E$,5€§$€flfi}'- axfi fimmfier tn mmpiam the tramamfiwn, may axmumd mmthar awmxmnt 2: E-x.P,§3 fiatafi '£%9~1E--Z3§S. Ewm w*§Zt§mgQmt fume? afivaxxm, with a spmifm mzi:%§it3'¢m:'..?: h:5a;%: wmmaefiinn shaii be mmp1et3&'Tw'«§;fi'1ix1"un:e W§5lfl§'£., ma VfiI1d(Zr§'$ can Ewn my a?m ymm, ma p2ai119m5§%.;:;&3g$' §3:<f«?"1§:: fi"'§;::*:f5:;1.i§: 17'§»L'%;;3; aale {max by f1,11fi1}7m ibammv the " 'Elia gala wmi&a:m.téa:§; Cégart §§*§;?c§1:3{;tMa@pm»¢iat?11@ the m°ic1e-arx-saw $57 Wrmzgiy name 152:: Tim mmiusfign WM xmfiy anfi w:x3h1' "lg ta at' fi1é:"'£x3mt£aG€..
wnmnda thm: 'tiw flmmrt heiaw hm an amrmr in mmsfsrzg tic» 'aha mm-}1;m§m:1 "2§".:.a::=: Wfl$- xméy mui wifiirg 'Ex: puarfarm E3113 tmmtraat mniy haawi ms: aha avermanm mam W p;m'm.. Ammsrfiirzg 'tn him} the pragnafi has mgaradumrzi wrhaiim fiflfltfiflfim mi' Specific: Rafiiaf fiat 67/ 3% witimmt were Ming any widesnm ta: fihmv that tha M: Wags atzxmiltyé rxmdgy anfl Wfilizg m §,maz"f:3:'m mt": mi" firm mmtztmmi... Ba fxzrthmr rs.-mxmmia témi; A' fiaurf. havizg mmmitmfi an fiwrar 1 T piai:1fifi"Wa'a mmiy and Wfifiifzg tax 'zagf _v j mxmmua did mm; mmmifier the.-gage".;{;§.t'%:§se£':"V'é'"?§;r _v . dafmfianm' fimmratfiizg ma him, Tmifinéfifified. tha me:1t by fiaumg £:s._3;'; Septémmr Efififi by emmiaa1Tx%Aa. by them as a;éva.2'm_§$j+_: £7£.::px;:;isi£€3!93ix;a.t;i;é§xf§V9V Si3:'1fia an attempt was» ' mmatruciian, firm the Pailsxme $$aTJr1g,' that the _p3m?.1'1?:,i§' wa a; _ wzxmam mme Wfifienm ta E53 f£?flt}§3$$i€}'ri"&t£3d mmmfafimn azr1z:i thareafmt, "§'it*m ffimxrtz ziifi mt crmmifier Kim ' V' cf mriim pmpmiy amfi am a.r:;~m'a.m.t mf
-. ayfifimmfimné mi" m.zi&a:m.&;. the: Trig} Cmirt baa " mxit, 3%. Ha fL1.z*ihar at-mrimnda that fiwuggh thg Trim} Cmmrfi ham dacremi tha 313%: éixmtizm tha aggmflanta $3/.
w».
'$3 harain Ext": axmum: aim Mia flaw Wifizin at gariwfi af :3 umnfim, fiifl mt mm: z§.ir*emt time gsiaifimtifi" ta fiagmgzvéfii the hamrwa flak mnmlzfiamtéxnn csf Ra.!€a,fiG§®@0f~--E mmh a &£1m2;:§m"1 haw zmfii beam iammfi the A4 ta: 'aim p§ai:mEfi"m ciespmaii thm: baianm mic > of Rm,5,m§mw;«,, flm pzamfig mama} ' Wag. mafiy smd ts; §_$1"fQ:1';f£} }'i;5fl:
mc:§:'m*m3't..; fimmmrfiim -m § S3 fimnthag time gzamzifi' a1§g:%%J%jm:&%dsgwgig,'%g3,a§a::§0cm;,. 'mm mm 'gamma mafia ca;2*:2s'fi{e};:=.a§,t§;a;;fg i%i§".wamufiam patizian £3 ¢.é::s"m*$; mmuw am aaim (41% male mmaifierminn amtmt Q? fmrflmr cmtxmndg that :_~*z'i"x':;.m,,g}':: §;:3;m .§i¢.~«:,m i7a"1:.aa*c$a&d; an Q1-fl»-2'.EW33, awn. may '*3' the date vi" jmrigmnt and dmzw bean depmaitamd by thaa 3:m;'x>ndm3.i.- ixmw. Ha furtlier mnmnfia fiiat the fiacree ring am Tami Cxcmrt: has 112:; be: mi; as: $513 eniy an . grmxxzfi. He fw,rfl1m* mmmmfia fimt flm 'Trial
-*I§"§§m.1r?: tiiifi not appfmiam that ma mzii prmgaerty fie " aiummd in imam of the C~:£'i;,a* mi' R ii ia mmm fiwn fir' mm 3mm of Isanfig mm. mi' which 0!': am dam $f suit wag mm: mm tkmn sfiagiflfi mare zzamafi flfi szm mday 353 nmre tjrami 3 czrewrw. Wm': 'aha ylamtéfl" Ema ma ax aémxm im mnly Ra.,5€}§fi3flI~ i-.33. 'thaw: yam" 1%}, fimt flWfit E§::.ga.1 was antearm into b¢?;%s:?g§~vfe;V::' 1 Tfiawfumfi he mntenda _V j dam:-wcmmr mm; mm :mrcia%;:§;:»%%:;mi»::« a::;::; b':f:"V'e::;;":.§§1,§e=cs'i._i'§ % m rim éefenfiwm hag mt 'and mmiaiarmi 'my the Quart. s.i§r;s:;x2.vL'.t;3*1e;e: whw is a %un%immammn iIk?fiX"%'£fif3:"§fl:"v'§I§1§3f£?}3§:§§¢"fifififi WEE. the pmggwtyx LI1§;éxsfi@.',- 11c '_'i*&q{im&ta the flmxrt ta and meet aaide 1:215:
judgmnt jmxfi fif Quart.
f*;:;1z;t;§i§3§"~-agxbnflta '(Ems Emfcrra: the Sam": 'mlmw, mm prayam. 'flaw 5373!: ymyrr-.:x.' in try n fifizhéiafanflanm ta eamum a gala fim,-12$ by V bsafiarm gala mmxwifiimrafimmg Hmwewr, {hm far mm reafiena bmt klflfiwfi tn': -it" did mt the piaintifi" m &aapmit. H2" pay me balamm mm V' wxmiaimfatimn fimmmi ffirthwiih. Tha gamma prayezr in {V Elm p§aint 37$ that an osffimiai mi' 'aha CMLRI"? fur and am ' ' ' mi' éassfaxxdmm W dirmmd ta axmmtm the male dam'; in rwwct Qf the': mhafitxjie grsrctzgmty in fimmmz" sf §§&iI1m3fi"m1d the thixirfi prayer £3 far a fimrm H da-fmnfifiasnm far rmmmxy 9%" R3,.'?,3fS},(Km,:"~ aim 1 that it'%w- p haw. apnmit tim maid:=.aan":;*zv:x:3+:.t'4A;a.;:;:di' has Ea Em raamvmrmfi; wixh i::1"t;w;':;2eatf:.._m: aimmmmmxmm, 1 mm3ae1_<_L:"'ffi£ ':;%_f$:r1£i;:é1:'1m Qfifitfliififi that £11 tha mai &:aT9!;Ta:_tAe'A._'§mt.;a;§;t'i?:a;%:j3s.% mm City mi' Bvfiyzmm 'meatww ikf firm iamd Waa Vmzit" %a:£.'afit§ anwaréag them wag gimp fig mfly R&nE§{33QfiG,'~ WM as m%z1§¢4"i:&d:%3a...":,.7,§:sCaAaAca?sv._a'»'3d"'f'z:Lf2u warm wem figpsaitw Ey :.f'i,1?1e__ x':€;é$9;.&'§3*;$a$ wfilixxgnaaa Wm mt fizamrtfl Ha aubmxim that the 'Ema' 1 mnaiaris;-awed 'aha mfum mi' afimmm i::5§__ 3Rm.8fi5$%]- the deiknfianm and tha any apnam E133? the Eaiaiziiiff mwarda thss: queafimn. Even 'tfmmgh, a mam :1?
'"° Wag by ma §:sEm?_t'm?fi§ ma avidmwa b V. Wm Iami in £313 piaimtifi' in ahmw am km why anfl haw 'V 23.2';
ha apmxt arr: nzumh axmung, attxmpst €313 amcnmt fiegzsoaimei baifmm flm €33? arm fimrgmrafimm mf flit}; mi Mymam Ct2"'€3.€:f' ta abtaizi iigmma arm. pmrz. E1: the A' he raquwta zimt by afimwixg tltaa 3 T ciefezafianmfappaliamra may 3% d$n"z;%§:.v":;%*mxflj..:.'"t';€§v X; T afimnm afiwmmfi mi" figagfiflgflflflfé -gm." fii':§;f :§cm,:~m 3 ma plam tiff citlmr ta ahtairm fisséifzéfé ané" etxrfany payment. m&&fi: aitimr ahargm m"

mxm almxg wi1:§"zhTmm_m$§;. 'V ' V

13. Pm" mnmjfi, :'1é.farmé*;s:§ Sanimm C1-mmuzmei mmhnfita timt. tim-

apma} ma 4_ bag &V%3fié:§?:ma;e}:*.i,. £11 ms mama af tha- .g x~ammtisg%; a§peflanm* munmi are '€fiI"3.fi,%M« V. am piafmtifi was war ma§§r and mm of fiw grgmimmzt and flmt ma fimt ha Wage macly "ta izakm tha aalez ma builfiirg' Em ma fififmldmxts ta mxmmm 3, M13 fieaafi aftm mnfltrumtémm '£9 mmczntae the aafie fiaefl. T'haex*afme iaauim mm?-.m, the plaintifi' ma film': & mil: in aniizzamm ma {V 23 agmmrxxmt. fiwmrdizg in him, timm is raw: thus: aammm mi' 3115. mmwmm mwé <tim- diafamdwxt aiial amt czanmi agmmemt mi' aaie am Kim: dfifflmfiamm haw rm -. V maxim} "£*:§m V-:

mi: mf aaia, aa 'aha piflifltiff ammmt. %3mm*-:21 mi' agmfimmzxta aa mz"JE2§$:;}E~';l._ &3':);,¢£§'§.,i;,1:A§£.f,§?.Vf'3f;"'V'V Ha iamiy srmntanfifi fim: axmn t}1:;:_L:§.gh V' mt: fiimmm film piafixzfifi me dépcgait mg aim Magi? em mt depwaiti *~fi*m my an aazmwrzi: M' flmffindanta mart, 'i'%£mz*fi$ hm 't§'1é7_{3£:é§,xi*% fit: {€iém;ia§AE:he3 appaal.
13. zW,gnm Wm: fa m M mmiama by us ix}. A ~. ' tag .... y' E; "E Wag 811$ ' » gyarfarm his mm uf firm crmrx-Jwmatg Wiiafifiéfi fiw 'Lima was tha mmmm af the n T ric;:xj'fc:*acwt, in vim' mi' E-XRZE awmmmmt;

V': "'~ d$.~££fi fi§~=€+.$1995.

A %Tmwmm1mr ma "ma: mm fig juatifieei in gmrxtixfxg the fiimretiazmry mbiaf wf ayficéfiae par hmmmm; ¢/ M W} Wkwflmr "Eim judgmmzt amfi flcaetrrm fif {ha 'Triai Emmi hm to be mmmad am K 0? ?5a:imt§fi' mt depmaéxzim the ~ awe mnsiacieratfimn ammgfm... ,_9;:rifi:;i.fi"" ' pezfimd mi" flirm mmtfifim-'P I h ' {§}W}1mh«&r 'Elm _jud;;gmm'1i*V__ £«;:j;d far miarfermm er zmdifiéafiimn? _ V M. 'mm feilcxaving fam:7sA..4_'_£§«m 7_§z0}:..A thfm fi }a 'fim plaint mhezcixxia pzmgmgffggf iaéii far a sum wf damfi 3- 3n-1§@1 axzfi;

xmiwsi Vs§;2"€}L¢:. §:§g,*§§ii37.i.éi&%1*a€i»:2six mi Ra.5GgQ@fi/M glaa ;§:$§a uam R) §:;§°._fl§e aéymmmi, in View mi pmhihitimn V. A'11§%f¥~§.+;*.,VL"§;Eaefv"'Afiiirezwfigfiwgix mf EELS Act, ma fififemcianm awmfi ta V}:1'::a a§:*."1'V'}£;§.}:;p':§;:_i::,é:.t,§1xax1 fair" aeeurm 'rim perm' aiun far gala §:;:?wm"t_y in fasmur M" 7:33;: gafimintiif, 'rm mf ammrfig me:

"'1 in nasimz {he ciefiemdaxxm in "' fim pm" ciatw W} af flag agzwmmsantg, Wiflxizx £5 fiafga fmm the am af agmmaexm the fit:-.;fe;ndm1ts M 25 tim gm-;§mz~*'$g.s' faamur af aim fiaitgfmifi" mmiar the:
pmvmfimm ms? EELS fiat wag mjacmd by ihfl flamrnmaaqt am a rmuit aaf Wfifimhfl EXRE has bmwma '?L¢¥.IfffE,%7£73ffif*$?!?é;&3}ii':1;f§§3'<'.:."'.V_ amfim" firm law,
15. M 1% airxa mt in fiiaputa fiimt :
haw mtemd imim a aupgiarxifinwi ::xgrL+e§m;¢i?1--§::"V"'c:s1*i 2Q»'~@~i.Q§5. am amfxfi §a§"e;@g;x1am@-a:mi_;;m'V'imtm m:a§?m;c-"satin in {km haczzlkfimya cf rafumi $<'_:_f "'a::§ mi} me:
pmgwrfiy in favmmrfi' aha LS Am 'rim pfiamfifi" :3;"x'J;§%-s'r?:§}:;}§ building an 'aha pmpfirty Kim': a_ tn wamlat fllfi':
pgmzamtfif gm» wmgmgegag mf ma bumm than:-shy far gram mi? Eimrma. If, far ~ '_i%af:.a dam £3 mt mmmtm by him % v%&¢fmié&am %%:"mm« mi' am pmimm, um pfsaintm' ix .. flags afiuatum put mg by him 3:3 pm"
':?1;a¥;i:§§sm_§E'} mi' Em": mmnfi, agreammzt &afmd. 3°'?-%- 1995 at % %%2[x,?;%f:3, {31mme{3} fumam mafia. tlrmt if fim gfiaimtifi? sm % we aim am am wsmn 32 mmmrm fmm m-.@-mm V. film daferxfiflmta ham & rigkfi: am mmcal we agr%az1t émvci 6/ am}; Wfih ma prwpmty in any Xzmxnezrr by rafmnfimg, am ac{vmm- ammmt rmiswiilby fimm fiémm {Em Eubjwa m was aémm mmfifiwatiamg 9&3 ee$}:m3:' c§au&:a$'_'»s:;{f..V_ mm .'3--1~1@§1, mmairi gm farm, "I"Ii2§i45e5fb:f§2j:;__j:. Ex»P.J3 tiw awmrzd agrmmam Va.' '4 eamtsimmnma .; _ :_ -

 

 

ammfi in film smmmé  " 12
manflxa, him  hég     Ezfiuilfiing by

mbmfimixg }?mamag;§sr.x;._ci 352:' I Eiafendamm mm m ;x;+a;;§:§;;z gL'L'§;;f;%3a%éxga §:ié;in1?i§f' m ma-nabfig him ta asbmirx baxmtxazct. "flaw h1.3.11&mg' " 'W§fi1in §f":;§1fi'v_méEi:$trumtimm ia amt mafia anfi if tm gxisiixzaifi' %é.¢ omm we gain gem Wifinin 3:2 « am at ilfberty 'ism ctmmi the firm advmxm amsmm M"
% 3;fis._.:% EXE4 is Kim Farm nf ammtimn iaeaszuafi by {ism VA fiimrmratimn af City at" Mywre fax? mmmmfimn :12? a builfiixxg 3:3 pm" Exfifi thaw plan? is. fiamd fiwfiw 19%. it fla €~/ 31:1 nf Ex.P..l
- - and a dimzinct agfexsmaxitgv.
3% zamrz fmm Ez«:,.E%§ that an &ppii<:a.t.:r?:@n baa Emma mxhmittmci by pmmfifi in fim mmne inf tha {§.€£'ifilIIfl§.fif.V.3.V'.§V.§.#'Ii$:'>._V' mi M5-39%, g nsmrxtkw mgr fim mm mi Eixfifig, 'the p1a§1I1tii}' "wag z'm'§.3;i1*a£3; 'bu,fi.$§;i1rf:g an :29; -piinth arm 6%' fiiéfiffizfi ::§ q,,:*j;:t_€f:¢i. a latmr datseé 19-9«§Q@»fi &fi;d2*éna9.~:§%t£i Q13 . Evfijsa apex Engmwing. rm qum;mm?£':3;1 mf Mfg' fikpwa i§§fi to mmpifita 'aha buflfiéng ii': film Camtrwawr 'tn _ réf'ie«&~nmm~ *$fi'im amzfi as >;tx"::a;..1ae;<;?:; a fihraqzia fax' a mm as mg3am;»%%[¢£wggm;ma mxfi; ma mamm mmunt gmf ha gmayawe can campiefiam csf ~§En1;a:.PQ. £'§r""*§;23?V a ammpfiaint. 1mm@ brzfew me; Wiiaag Myaam Eity dam 1'?*3;fi-- 19?"? ' 'v by aim the &;cfm"r.aiax'1t$ am txym to jflgiilmrffim" the !Bi§I}E'€1'?.1C'¥.ifi1"1. fiamrfiing W the ';'%1.'§3~9-3@§"®, rm Wcxric Wanna aimmat mmplamei . §'m?mhirg wuchm vmm twqmired tn: ha fiimnas fer §;§h3Eaa§":% "E ms' 3 fiaya iima Wage and Exfiiw £3 fiiad afimr the imatitutimn wf firm Emit, §3'x&F,,1'? 35 3. W E531' teisaagr-am iammfi by {Em pimmiff m the defmmanm an 3&- 9~§.:%fi matixg that the mnmmumtimm Ems haesgn mwst. mmpiatmi Sn 2?-Q-}.'§€®§§ an afimzmpt wag hy the fiaf fia in flt {Em wmrk by Ex=P.1§ ia file £10-firm iaaueé; hey '£133 I mm mm fake piaintifi' amfilng my mm :.'§:;%§a§*~.i§; up firm mxmtmwtism. amfi fiaciéicm-...¢f V:fi§tf¢i*é§:et:§.t:s«' put an anti ta fiw mnwafit by :{;E&.-Zrgfiéfiiifiiiiig by mmmfixm {Em £4civa;ncsa"'é::§;:::§a*%_;§f~.{§if w by gmy mi" a -;--.::a 2- flraifcga fig Vvéant by 21% fifiwwflm Wéf" 'ta; "'_&z$i5¢ir1cia.1'1ta' adwmta. Exfififi :i$ ';::;a¢ tiafendamm an 2i?.--~3.~-- §@@fi§ Kmfimg tém Ma gm 1:9 mfiamit appiicafiizarm, d1£4+««c1;i;1;?,z:::gé3;1@$5.'Aj::r¢;§3»'z;a "§ubm7maim:Ia,, E'E'§Z¥;1Iit faeag' chamaa mxfi. : tn argafl. yak up wnmmzm'-t.im*; an ma wit .__?éSaaed an them: fiacamfmnm; we 3; é F.W.}; has dapeafid hsfcrm flw Qfiuyt that {Em H wam mmiy amti 'Em pumlmaa 'rim yrtamrty 1 ' « " pafifixg ma
-2 6.: stale: cszvwsiflimfatiszaxi and am dfiezfimm flffi In mafia rm mcmum firm aaie fiewi 6,7, am that gmumefi that {Emma ia am wwaiatiam in the: vakm mi' rim prmpamgs, we aim: dagtxzaa.-ed wfmm file Cuurfi that the mmt.ru€.:*£:iw3. Wm srmmyfimm in 9.3 rmgmcm. What;

wmwumfisn was, &m;: "ta be mmplaamfifi file mafia mtg aztamjgkt is"; éifimaliah "tém mrgygg,

- Dimctm 'iT<*:5}3f§1~.-3*". .V ~ %§rQga--' at iaxfifilu 11': him ra1"a%E:a;fm:a1"«fl.;' Lr:t;a:;i%AL§$3x1;..,_VnE1e..a:;;§;§fitg'»»f%¢h.at E331 Ea EXWD3 am the: "4t:';::':.~ § }:?;é;:Q'~'*.§{_VflP§w¢ xmmm {if mmwuafienm éfigaifi; by fim gaiwfxxfifi'; '§m°tiz:::x'a (sf aim in as. ammli axélézg £3 mafia m put up fi:m17fim.t'im'1. E":::~.fi33"2 sham fimt 1 32%: aqmam wan mrmmm;m;a.j s.»«§;;h Mwxza with mud tnartm, a 31156; by mW3:r-- and an attempt Wfifi < §i?£3%é$L;v§fl.*;§D:fl:§§';§*!»7£;;t3"%" that film pfiairatifi" Wag ready ami ta" ,;:@%§*fmvzr1 aim mt mi" flaw mnwaxt' . in award tn flue .2 saw m;mmi¢§em,':§.an, in {km

---§55s!idmm mi" F*,W,1§ it iii mm pmpmrly ezliaitmi rim wgard ix} ma fizrmxmfimi ecapaaity 9? the pimfimfifi. Ex.E"'fl3G ia the 6/ 32 axzmuénta nminmixmd by the: §ia;¥.m;ifi'.. EKPXEQ ix. 9. mpy af flaw Bay Bunk Imintainad tha piaézlfifi' dfwcimaea tim mflauxxt is, atmadixig ix} ting: :::mdi';t.;'_"'5<:>'f' _ Thaugh P.W.*2; Mahaxfimmjgvaa 9 Wm mszmmamfi ecmly -m mark ammm «:£<5;g11t;n;e§;,*ai;t$'*TT9j.:1?s;d5"%2¥§k'1e31§ag; aviidumma éw wf rm amiamssm 0;? VA bah am: gamiaaw _ V V

19. we mm W m.»*i§i%m1:£%;%_ gr mm ia c3..mfiamfiam.Nn.2. DJWQ mcamm" ed in akww tkmfi rm {Em aaifl 'afifkégwme. wf mxwxz and fi,"W..3- Em at' m aaaigianficm. ' in he mmieiamd by _v mm cgggwi 52:1 agaprumiam the rival mntfimtiun fig :§ffi.W.3 §{.L..8rix1at,2m He hm caagaaeg Em wmd in @1333. 'thae gnwpmty £31"

k V m gagmgmmny my a mum mf Ra.a,5@,e>m;-A himfi tha &afaw&m%a Warm bafih in neaé af .'.'1:31§r;§§é.r"A'ss11ai fihey xwwwad an admmm mi' Ra,f:":0,00Qf-« T flfm plaintifi. Tiwugk the apylicmimn gm by fimm xm*m3;m* LELQ Act. Wfifi mfuaw in away ':10 wmrmxfzm am ('V 33 mma, him gamma agrmmamiz. mam firm axiataziem. tan him} Wifthim mine yam fmm fiw E-x,P..f3,, tha plaixitifi' Wm rwuired ta amm tfw é%--§ie A mad» tém 1.3% wag 'aim mmanm mi' flm <f:s:sA1.";.>€r;§1a;mt{ ta him; ymamaiaxz M' rm pmparty §:%;3;.a7':£f:o?»% fiéiifiéfirmi tha pfiaimtifi and am nnly 'm7! jam: my mgmtrumfiafl. ass ag;t.."Wd mizfigr But the yfiainfiff am mt firm fifipumtmi "izirm gfhsm mimmpt ta mmmmm fim &aya prim: to tha axpiry wf tr; mm, the piainfifi Q --~ 2 W; mqmam 113;} 230 an Emight'%vzi1J'fM fa:-.§:a1:AA"*w»""iV'fi*,i.»LV fabricated mmant hakw I-':'§31'§€?§9% k3'fiufi»A&k "" 'Since thxa bmiliitiflg wag mt atipufiamfi mm: imuirxg legal Wm mmacilad by rezfimciing film mmiflfirafian of R&,5fi,_fiQfif Ammrdizg «t:Q;" : pfiamtéfi" mght ham apmnt Rsfi,Qm;'«=-= in h far mmawuctian, Ha has mam amass- .§4:;:a:m51ms:i at 1engt.h.: Thmugh he Ema Emmi: arma- " mmmirxmi at iamthg. £3 aaiisaimfi in xfiamfl m W 33 wmtmzmtiam. put up by ma piafimtifi' ax pm" {ha mrxjga amfl mmditimm mf IE;:;,;?,&.
9%, mm M; {Em-urt has new my 3:113 p1m.ifififi:" T T ready magi Willim fiam parfarm hfw §:§$.§"t:. §:: i'jj. titm' 4Q'<:«§1'ty%;s::__'i;§ A 3 maimfiégg mfiyixg umm 'aha araé awéfimmé' :F.W mmaisfimfim film cirgvwmnmxmajv §€é*§..§?;?e::1§;f:a& 1 ma p1&.infi§ aiisfi mt afiéfir hia aapaaitgr 'ta purcham haimzw:
gala    af mam
yam; flag   mm mnelmimn
'rim? fim piaintiff im gmamaixsarz. ami Kim i a"'i::"";{;%m3:$5'c;.;é§9simm gmmuamt ta Ex,P2.1é.R "E'r;}§;§ illamrfx the ghmfifi' was ready and €52: Mia part, mi" fiixfi cazantmezrt, maifily wrra} avifiexam emf mm wifimm:
Vmmi&éi'i:%féba§.VaEac11manta13r mriaflmzcm "£'h.@§1a.im:i.ff diefi ' §;;-::~m4§fmfi:a any damuumts tm sham" Ma aa;pacit3* m tim przzapcrtjg" by payixg rim baianm'. wig "a¢§fi§é'i&arafian Within the matenéiefi, perinfi mi' mm gneaxz 'm@'Fria..1£2«:mrt hag aim mafia {cs ma mnclzmimx that tha H 3% fiafanfiaxxm haw put "gm pimfintifi' in waaamfiimm and {Jim pifiimnifi" Ila in Ismammaian pmmmmmz Em Exepafifi The fimtzrfi. baa alas?» ham that, {Em tima ia new ma aas:t.;ss1:@1'3, <:%;§{i*§' '.§ééf«T "

the mmijmcrt mniy an the gmunfi §h£x'i:_.aa..33a3:z°' piarirfiifi' Wm gmmmitmdg Em :7 mm gmuxfi; am mg cam 2:;m%j 2m1a fawmr mi' fim §K&intifi gmd L.?c}ai«':3. '"x;h..at § Elm defientiamm have mt maxi 'Lima $3: 310%. me: mmmcgm. --?4t:§'--_3?_h¢ ma peimtfi whim": grim %§;%1?:?3 'iz1§:&r~--§im@§ we tmuhci daaimi ;m§:":ji:i2§::s: 'z;::sg$fi1e&"'i::'ih?m apmai» Q19 fig the m'mm.m;:t5§.an in mat':

«in &?m}f2'£?§'.tE3 """,§'%m éi$1:%§;:;i;.*;;aM§:»5:
:31: 'film pmnufiwvaa may and ~m1':z*ng ' V V. . Elia pmt. af firm cazzwamt in wrms wzf Emflfi'?
 A'    r- fim {mime wag firm smsmme of the

 

mmtrmzt? mad
the plaizrxfifi has cmnanlittafi
hmmh er' rm?

 

<9



E

9%» it fig a fact that in ma yam' W9} a& pm Exfllg, tkm fifif t5 hwm 33;: ta 3&1}; 1:123 wkzxahlue pmmrty sf 1 amt in mm Ewart. sf City fax." a mm$idm"atin;t} Rafi-gfiflflflfli» fm' timir dire rmeci, Rmgxyz _ &am,m@g- is aim mat in. éiapmm-. "fine §ax*'e;ia;§i::1ic:i"~§«€:x:$;V dfiwymm fim mfume mi' parmimimn mafia? 'aha am: as: 3.3 a ;:'m%i_it--.._§:»f éztifiiéfifi V bwma mrmmihrmbie, In theta pamfzmimi ms 'am Q Qammgmtant ,Pmthm*i$:y,. at : u:';%f".T,i§;1fi! mezaezarfl agmmmnig' amangg sxismfxm an 29-@-was mafim' wrlrfimh, am grawg the plafixmtifi mg m WW5' z;:+;.»;~; %L1_.§.ki;3i'sg by amgmamg meme ma 'vpém #§é:1@'**€g&ad by payim Em Eaaiance aaie A.:::il§m&;ner E;sc.P*3§, tkm antira %urd.en sf : up. ::.:* §;*:i:§;..a.:a§xw.:¢:,,*%;iz3:r-3' Bea 01:1 {hag pmmfifi" anti mt ma. _f%:.a fiefaizgiamtm. T133 defimfimtm am rmuirmfi in m- With tha p1a?mE.ifi' ta get gmmximimn frmm tiara: .i's;"V.:?g_:_::*_ip::€.=:m1r1t: Aufiwrity. "I'he plaimtifi rmwharé aaya that iéiaiay Wm Q-auaad. in aefitairm mt: Emma mfi plan om. mmwunt mi' Eamhea an the part af the: éefenfiamm. A3» a W 36 matmr mi' fact, E£e?=5@a fi..at»&:£1 2m»-1m%,#, {Em fimfendanm haw isauezi mm-:'3h_jact1wx"s in flawaur aft p3a::::sm Manmm mmtm 8at.i..$h Kmrxm _ fiaama mid; }mr*m$ainm am fheiz"
Cmmwmnt; Amzhemazty. The p}a§mi.ifi':i}aa_-:::é;?; :ja_i§:;§ m why hm gm mm: file am.&pg1i§~.@fiQz§ £m»}a}2;;a§g;~;i:g<g A Emma anti pfian gm tkw z:urrm*&ry, ma ayyficafim: g;t?';a;m:«';;' efgxf was mm Q mmr1m$afimrEx§P.3,V V . V A. 33" 3% Wm fgbe, fE§9x§;?5'.4'§,:"'§3iexrmia$i0n Wm 5 En mum mfEx.P'r3¢, the buiioiim ma my the iiizmms and F giant J pre-;aa«;,:;.¢w gm mm. What Wm muim 'ta by W: piaintifi' mmdm' Eexflfi a plilmth mtm, The p}m:a;. rmmia titwsat Em hm: tn *mr2g§t:: 9*::2§:t"'v£g éazfifima-rcém zmmglax, Smm Rawm, Shaw mxfi « flfm glam Wm mhtaimw; by 'aha piaiutiif an when fim p£ai1:1ts2fi'Waa rexguirmfi. in cmmgfiam *.:¢uv§rmw*1mfi.mm mix. m' fimm fi8~»9«E.W§§§ fig it wmifale far K123 gimmtifi ta mmpkem th@'buik%2'g W'ithin mat: marith We")/A' 3'3 amah a huga ahapyirg mmgzlam with auifigfsas ma:::m3"fima3mis3x:t. Afm~ niatairaing yian an yfiamfifi' hm fifltimfimfi ths mark fem at fimnfgfiatzfiff'. "

Eepmmhm' iwfi 4% W E3:;.P..1§. fiy pfiyiug v%§Tif7 A' Raflammzmn-. Wmheer rmfiy firm w&;;k;%~§m 1%] 3. figym ma mafia Emiawxz "M "aim $3;§xfx.x::%;_:'§T"§.€s't1'§;'$.ic:;£fl€i2*'-*Zi"1ssi%a1 mt mm examfimd by the mm-*=.11 £3 wmifiemd fifi it is aiamfi 1§»~%~m%. §;~fga:.m§ the 'iauimirg hm ms sepzmm 19% wififim Q 'cm km mmmuctw.

ii1§avE..3ec¥§'EL§é'.'?L.1% whim': 13 fimm} 1?=-i€3»1§@fi., mi' mm mm the pzammfi ham g¢mp»3;:a£iz1¢.szE~ EM €10:-mw aianer wf Paiiea, Mysore City " by 2'E3~Q-- 19% the buiidim was mmplatmi in A ,£#;?£E..V'1"»3£s'§mta:a§ wimp: fmfmkmm magma Whiflh grwuimck 52 Q3' 3 fiays. in tifim hamhgmvgndg la'; 11% mcamixm as X Wham flm flicmtraemr mum haw mmmmncfi am mammtrunczfimmn Tim Casntramtnr can mmmeme tim 'K,/4 38 mmtzumtimn aub3w3,zm1t in mm}. fiatm }-.§¥«-9»-3;9f'§?§w Ewm if Lit, fa mmifiwfid fimt fihe flnntmmmr tha czamfatmmmfimxz 2%?» 3.9% imalf, fig ii. §m>a$ih§3%;----fe.*>§£: A "

C,m1.m"&x;*mz.* 'tm mmtmmt a mmmfimifié mm Sm: mmaurmg mags M_m:é:2.€£f.1"5's§.A_ *s4si:%"§¢':}"x<1:?'x';:_ €LE§_ fimmfmmfi tfm mmfire avvi&a:£ica%_:""'~€;zf amzacmvm Efinfm-rtzznmgkfif, «%:%;s::i%"%*f;*;:~;;;a;3%%£:mm%a;:a ms me:2:.2°xm3?fl;s:-223;' i:}:1e52 eimmzmenta ztiéfazaémam. :33, in am §gg%¢1§g:~aun§§ mg mg am%mm am Ex.Ei.3§ ghazwmgmpfifig ééffiriéiamtau ?&¥?.3;, in tha 'mfifiimmma of E3133. 1 in Ex.Il3.. Exfii fihawa e:'*;;<::w;$.7'ti5ma:V'é3f »7m*'£It'2 mag in aa small area __af 1%" '}.,fi% E»x§E3;;2€ 3% }£1x.fi3 ahaw that an mmmpt 113 A'~._m}a{zi~:2: fixer a--<m3tm1¢timm by mam haiimw bricks awn by xmizfg figment. E3; Enmldng V gizrzm Exflfi 21:16 am: kmrid that. ix 313- mflznm « &- 5 Unfmttmnahaiyg rim 'T'rial Smart __ apfirwmm we «:§V3€eEm*m:& Eat. in 'W 'tlm mrmfea. 'V V axamirxixg the cicémmenm mmti \. tim msiziemmg tkm Triai ficmrt ma mama to the: mncluaisn K"-/u 35;' tlmt rm piaizxtifi" was maciy and wmm ta» gaerferm ma yam mi" 'dim mtxnmmmt.
3%.. Emu if Wfi mzmpt tirm mwmsamm    "

M't"."&'"mgmmraaim%1a, that trim  .Wa.~$.H    V

 

- '£5: parfiamtrze. hm mm mi' fiw uaivxatfagéi' mt €313 magnum mf Canmactg tag' mnfium wf firm gmrtriam .5§°he sail thfiii" vaiuahvle :f:'is:fv mi Ra..§§5«€§;fi%f~ the piaizmiff has: wags $. fiwiay in gautfim 7.3.3.p__ --t§£.:z*m Qf E3333 3' ma piafiitifl m:.a§;§ ts.) pay tha fiaéanee: Mia mmififiramn Emmi cmfid have appmfiatw fgha p§aintifi".. It £3 mm {kw cam of the-:
afmr amtwirzg imw Emfl}.
V V aztafi émiade an atmpt. "tn ajfiwizam fixes gxmmrty ta partimu fim a1@afin::':; im tha piaint as» well tbs? Widenm £3 fimt: {Em ¢::ief¢mda.z1ta takirg ' nmga mftifm wcggiry af am yam; txjgzing tp awid tkw wnirmm EH1: is flag mm mm mi" Em §_m.fc11c3..ant;sa is mam W. am prafiafiim ma aampmhim Time aiefandamfm haw Waiteci &am 19%}. '£0 Nfififi. if "they am txxmimla in raaaive film mmmfi mite': cmrmidezratémn fill Wgfi flzm Swan aammpt fimxh: with that «maniac? sf the ma advama ammmt mf Ra.5@',%QG§'_:f-. V * 'ifrtxfl 3 flmmft. witfwm. mzmidemxg' qumizag ma d.aa?mim1a af fim §+i5z::;r;'7éa-Ea:4:"&;,i§}3:;m*xea.»f£'3:>€A'1.a**;' this» Quart? Whisk are mt app§§k;;fiEh%a in af fim mm Ema 3u_i't é§.f : §§3is;§r1tifi§,V"Ad3rcc'AVV am tim pimintifi' m macaw this paricari (ref 3 2?. ammm the suit and;
A*'b.*--fa§" ft':.*:>.-:£':®e::w;aa ma aaie éefl, baa» mt pay mgmait that: balance flake mi" R5.6§flC¥,GfiGf-v; hcxxwr, thme Malia *m§€aé§¢'f--.'. im hymn fixed my tam Trial awn ta aafie fiamci by 'dim fiafandammw Even if the ' in fawm" af 'aim gaiairxtifi', firm mvmdumt mf H piaintifié in must fiapamitixg tha mmmunt Wit,§'zm' {Elma
--. «~ :3s3.m?1t£m amd awn as an tsafiay, rmwly aawn gmam afmr {V thm fimmfi £3 gmmm by 'chm Triafi Qimum, an Qmurt Qan dixmt £113 a§::yaUw1'm~defenfimms /ms emecuba fimei fm faimur mi' 211$ maintifi' Who: wag mi; * 1:0 ygarfmrm his. paw; wf t§7,a.m§ntxfaE'3 t} "

am gmmaifi maid haw amgmatea am T ;s{§g:¢ f mmiflmafimn pf Ra. fi,Gfl,€%€§;. " fi£.§:'ifl magma azf {Em warm mgr with aft ifitm fmrm flue flaw flf tiw L§L IE£§ a V «.

Q8» flaw $er1§..:::a:* Qimmmezi mgard is; that an a-.cmmnt:'-.§3f appeal, the plwlntiff has mt figmpwétsazfi cmmifiayatimn. Such. an 2; aaufizaaptgfl far tlm fmiimwixzg rmammm:

.%&fi§itt;:i%i1}*.,_ fim await is dmxmd an 21~6~QGfi3§ 3 mafifizfa grmutwé ta axmum thg warm by rm ax' hfiam 23--§~iQ@§:, 'king piminstifi was ta fiapaait thxs mmm mm txmzfifisidaratian ._ "['."m§1§.m13.3:1t mi' Ra$..§fi{},§{%j- Whimh Ema 3:32:31: 13%-era tiapnaitafi by am pimnfifii fix: baa mm mm': mm am. §./ eisi axwgttutizm immetfiamiy aim? "aim wgyiry of 3 mantha by mafia mxmfiaramnx gmyfimg 3%. 'mm prmamt apmai is fiimi 1332?}, 5»-'§~EQQ;'3 mafia? Wag ymamd far aé.m.is$im'1 ml "
whm mm; Kim jusfiwmmfi; am fimxfafi' ms a:»§m«:,k A Wfifl maymi. The appaliants wage m»tb€;g:sA.§a:.1ia::::a§;§e~ fim prmparty fit? ammmmr thfi 'zlmw pexxafiixzg fifiapmmi mi' th¢a;;9ma=aI§;" thm piamfifffiwlmnmieni fiifi Wltaat Ea fimym é3?11§.?juVe:1g::1é::1: ans? demm at' the: Triai C1.¢;:E¥z.2:;a:*'£:*;,.'_ b';.1fi yamkfikififizl far him xw§:u;>2i2;ci§~;a;mt~§ie%i:f1a'::i;fi"V--. '~¢:g;m:n: tha mama ma 3 K?"»7'?X'¥fi§;'%§i§"$g*s.\i:fi1'§ xa::"3§ }afa"':::t;:»'t*i mfiay, mm mppkimtrsimn £3 fiiml by mmrmimm mf Elma tn flapmsit fiw ' mmsajgfl mclfirmxzxfi, rm Sam wmzfifi aempt 'aha ma iwnacig Smlinr Cmzrmal E":
:é:§ji3?.,éfi%§?gm€a?$ mat the: xpiaénfifi" ma rm capacity tam mymit male mmifiamtiwn in spim tfi mhtaining ~ : 1&«a-Qz°*m mi' fipwiiim Wrfaxmnm. Ag riglmly mum. mm: by tim Emmmfi gramme} Br;§,.fT.i%wh@g.:r3i. Rm: thm. thmm fines <9"

as:

gimp msnmiatiexi in fim vaiwm mi' land in and armunfi Mymm é"f".¢ity,. an mmtzmmx af IT am ET pmfiemta-. The agrmmmrzt fig es?' fiw max' was: and am s;Ta'i;};¢j mxm:"m§ara..ti£.:n. zaagmw. tn Em in R$,@,,3G§€§C}f_:,__%§?7§1¥§t' "'«V hm hm: pfiaid by am yéaixatifi' ia mfiy an 7m?' T K §a»5a§ma;--.. Am an fiw am my W?
Wm sa amp amaiatiem in cm {mat §i"«.;ti':¢ yrafiam? fx*§3;r1 "« 'V Efigfi amwmwdfi. fimmx"z:§.i::.ag m *az§zék};1,::é';.i-13 93;:
data mi" mm was mara a _I::-;%i§_z¥:m~:,'.:§a.$ awzi £0§§&ay, it ia mam tiwgi 3 H sum $5 R$.§{%0<3j€Z'sj:~ fileixafifi in ikm year EQQ1 grantezd a almma fur mg;m:.:ific S rxémmt mi' 'aha pmparty wnrth 3 Vxxzqmrefiv-it,}5'Lmj§.;3 fifii"€'.'.$! €3%§T"x*:;:pm anti if fiuafi ea fimrfize. ifi nut gram hmflaiuip m the a§.:x33afim1tm§ anfi . ». it bae:.éL:§ii$fm*imimtian mafifi 'am the agzpaiianm whim fitxifsafkisfi hm $3: rm {Quit emf fiwm.

tham £:irm;ama'tm1e:.m§ Wa am af' ma mpixlimxz that ' gmimm raiaefi tfiam" .a§§ma3L are is 31% mmwmafi in fawm mi' that titan mid agminsat "aha :*%pm':&m'1t.$ W M Wa haw M mwxm Ehfi finefiima $5 {Em Tm} flourt, as:

w::t°'wmm.
SQ. fiftm rwemirg fim _j.1.xdg*Hmm'§: and aflmrm mi"
parfmxmxwm Wm haw ta mmifim" wheazhm"

is amizitiw far an aftaarnamive mliaaf _ V p§&i11'&1?fi" mg aeaugm. far .9: zimrzfm izitermt at 3.E% pa. Lm.v fimf@:*m'Em3%-.a;Q:_mflam.m. ' 'aim mmma mf big wgL1mmt§ tat: minim mfzxm $§"§%&;$§3§'€3(§(g}§;" fig '%a&mm am -am mtual mwarxjia betmrfiwnt cimmwx amumt awn": in mafia? m axzéi 'tfrmvplan am $61' Exfifir mini E«:s:.P,5 '£fiQ"$§flVi:;fi"§i'3",1!F*,;:1"'.gf.5:r:&§'4:it:"E.'ni.' .. 5 mm 31% Eat in by : - aajhmv the aging: mmum agmnt by him in ~ ~ j - «.___dz?*d:5:1" m" an mmunt Qf Ra.'I?gSB,_€@f ~» as Eiquidatw; But, ma fiamumanta pmvfiumd; by 'rim plaintiff mvxaai am Ra..§,QQ,3?fi,?- ia mmmally ma 0:"

~ ' 55.a§m$itm§ by firm p1aEn€if§. in addifiianm m that, wa are aha": mf fim ayimimm 'mat the pimhrxtifi might hava spent {V
-$3 awn: Ra,f?'{}§{§Q® raw: R3.$C>,i)QG;- mwarda miacrciianwua :- Em mhmm 'Elm Emame mud. :§§£'&E'7i» Wa mama 9. mm: af Rs5.w2,€}Q,,0{}{§g"- mWa;:~'&é:.' mmpamdimw §:t"3a:"::"L1,¥'}:'®d 1:32' the: giamtifil Wae &r@.§z}$g 3 V' b Qfimififl mm rim piafmtiffi' £3 af:;fi;z?.*£.1:;<*,v:i§. fj.i",.?:;»_ %s::'f:s:1§,%'~~..fisé§7.,i:T Ra.mmx;- which Wm gaifif-<___m Mgggggnm advwtxm. Tmza, ix": 3}} tfim $3,' fer 331311 {sf Ra.£§5-fiwif ~ wkfim}: d§i:'£e.=;::2c§,anm aiwm With. imtezrmii at tljm 'ififim thm dam :3? Quit "am that;
Efiavsaiue af ma pmyertfi aim fiw um Ewnefited, We aim:
'the dgfgn&aizta}' gum af RE.-5§%§tfi.fig'** am '3i;c;%:.1i:3§Etma3;*¥.. fiapmg&%;""WEflah anal}; mm mm; fizzy mmrmt A§.fi ;w'aznt ahall he mi& Within $ mmmtim fi*aaa.?.z.'.a_4 %m&i3~;',r"'«: L' the: mmkmst as Mfimrmii £3 mm. g tkm m;:'1*3r ixxmrzmt at fim rate mi' E-4% pa 'm he ' fmm tmciay.
fit thim atagm. mm flmznaei far trim appaflmxm A V " V mxbmim fltmt the: appmfimxta haw aima-fly" ficymeaimd 3. {fix mm af R3'5Q,€}%j- re.m?1ve§$ by mam «RS mixmmtm Mia mxmifiasrm:im"1¢, §%ffl1"fi tkm Ewart °'mImx?n Tkmrefarek mlbmfim fimt ma flafanfifinm ares }j;a[':3}$ ta: pa§r;V~«¢fi1:~$ "

aum m§ Rm2,.%'fi$Q®E}§- which Ema bmm 3 paid w thia mm. Im :%a $0, 'him m~m&m;m&r@ fm pay any a gum mi' Rs;.L2,$3,§'"»{.l.fl§.§ «« V. gwan

34. in 'tim fmult, gm af:a§2»;~.§aI;§:}."§v"1.i:xi§£"::V,%.f;§'v€'§;«?:sv"'&s;§r@«a3}.a»23.m iaa LE '£123 Prinmipal cm; ajudge" %{ Vfiv§.'i:~:«,-éi :.:.2m--:zw3 in Q..E%X*¥n§:£51§ mt aaidm mw&i'fyiz1g flue

-sea? ".;:a-.

3:I3EI""'; 3"" E." 3 aifi figiviagniamfl. Tim d;af@mfi;an&:$-appm11am>s am ea. gum af Rm-i2¢%.,.€§€3fl§- with inmzrmt «Vat. ' fi'.mm ma date mi' tiw amt Whiakx ammmz " 3 mmzthm fiwm mday. in mcifiitimn ma fiafmmfianta am aim fifffifliflfi Em pay a mum af 'V V 4 §§§;C$,,flQflé- which ahall aka Qfiflfjf ixfztmmi: at the ram 6»/% "t fxiad hy tkm ma;mmv&¢nt- .

£3 arf 9% pa: ms M ca.'ia:ulam& afcm: iha. ¢xpir'3!' mi" 3 mmrltkw fmsm tmday.

Km aéfifimx ta ahmm firm piamiiifi" ia aim: ,, m Withdraw we ammxnt mf Ra,m,<;sm,:~ dapmaiaéé daafwnémts hefiret-2 fim fimmrt balawc. Pmtiw mm» "mm that mm: {c.*>m~:'£$;;__ A' J