Gujarat High Court
CRIMINAL APPEAL/849/2002 on 8 April, 2010
Author: S.R.Brahmbhatt
Bench: S.R.Brahmbhatt
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?d???K63?�?W "-y??pH&????l? ??oc?MD??
?Z???U? ?oJ?{o??_N??g5 HW {?M?"??
b????@ ??oJ?8 ??U ?? ??hXuj?Z?|.? t?*? ?T~?2??tZ?6H?~ttT???U?? ?? ?e?c ?=3?!I?(8? z ????[("?h?>? ?Q?�?�W??87?1?){q?xs???5?Mu?$?^&????�?X? ??O~&??0? {S:???#???8? - %6PF|??x?)?J??NS9`?.?n??L%?Dl,????]m"?"?? C? ?`A"?? y4d?w?Q? ??u?{?l\ 2???V]???6?? ?GO???g? ?f: ??4????= | K?LCdx??? ????TVg?"?W??n"???Vl*=,??J?Yk?? ??G?/??xJ??9? B>?b ??9]?S??]? ?
? ?54?S]j?z?/+?(S?8??*???>?kV??v?S/?_w}h???u? x'?OXa?6lc?y? ?T?=C k??S;4 ???Z?*?ZOZ?EC?zZ?? ??^?q?kU:?Gm?. k? d?J???dC???"?????(?[?#>?x?e ??f?P???o1?+o??{?"?d?F??L? �?? fg?A ? ?g???? F? Cp?-E?+?x?e?[?c9???? ?? f ?? [??@vl*?p ?)?? ??
]?_?< ? ? ?'K {??? 7vk?r????? ?? |e?zj7>E?w??H8??@?G6H?V?O+ ??y ? ?F!? ??4+?K?(qU?????_{?g?? ??Q ?#'}q?Cw??/ ]v??a? Q?8ta;?% ??t- >Y?y?? >|??g? C?a?= ?*?>k??U??3??9v??(?? |1 ~?#?m fN?q??d>?? @??? ??=N ?u2 ?ooJ??? }1 G[? 3~?]Q? ? ? ?Q?V+:=F ???Pr? ??fO k?g??s?j>???g??^q:?g???L?v???[?z k???:| k??dm?y?+?$???????s/}??q :?�M?i?^??F??<9}{N ??^ W??U:??a?w ????????=??-?????m???????i? n ????a??????? ?~?t ?nT? 6?? 0|W? ?h?Y}`!S?x ? ??CTy?"?
!S??3 x?N '?8N} ???? ????
?{zuno+????.?.?]?rz ?=}????;)?>o??Y?` ?r ?_ ??~ylavsf?R?U??".!?? ?? Dj?4???- f?S{V?g??{tX{K[???J'?{??3>? ??D?A.??x�q? >?2?? B? # ??< uU�?q? ? _?]?w? ?^??U??rqs??uo???\?>F???w?? ?3 ???:??1 U? ?=`?W????? z?G?L???? ? ??~????n?7?/??? ??y ???b ?Q?@ ? ~??>??n/???i?? ]???? ???????? ??9o? ,]8 l? ? ? ?q?P1n -?? ?q???,�T?}??^??
d?????*?[?q#?|=b? hx ?vX?5?N?^{H?u?k 1?b????z}q?+Z??fu??P??? ?? sG??E0??q 7? ???Lc?0?Z???])????'?{?_?=;`?S }??m?S?!;??f?c7&k?#?v?? )"??Pi?. ??C ??n???Ly#!??U}X ?Q??$? ?*x????O ?v???Jy??%>?rC;n????^!? ??�???>�?y ~=??? _z???u%???@?@???.x t?GR ? ?J???? ?? ?DX?E?T ????-ZUW0?-+,~?iq ???x ? ?
^�?=??B ??n?`, U ??a ?%?Y??H?? ?? ?t?O??, F4????X "? |p%d V ? ? 5\J/?Z?#vD ??Bv7?$?k5?IPy;;?? ?G? x 6??T`Z2]? ??;????a?o ? rE%?G ? f?� L??q?0?{6 ? 1pyF?} m??p?xv$?Z? u?]4* < D"?L?7w c??+ w?>? ??? + ?
?? l??H? ?? ?< v??R`0,#?c&S A??)??j??? ? ?)=????4?h??6?�?il? ? r)A%? ?c9\?0???L?? _d ?
Xv?a2 ?ep???)B???I?A?? (?@??p(? p$,d?
?�Vx[??p?%??? M? ?8Z ??-?l ?Rx ?\:??
b#A@?$??Bz ?? |? n`yb 6?9?#???6,?3S??�~q-??l? !?9?i???^? ?j??9 ?bA? ???"i??g??U.?d?t$?u?JKC?]CY??? ?qpo?? ??S???s?l? ???I? N%? ? ?D?? I ?
i?88?V ?? ???K}X?@?? ?? ? ???
]? JE` ??H?Ae+1?"??2?C?A ? ??O?t??["? ????s? ? ?S6ZL???3b?5r? H ??C?xv1 ?W&?Q?[???? ?E?P`4?cb ? 5?? ??O?K??I=?Q;fz? ?\I??`g>??b???????Aq???6??N? ???7?0??} ??M?G?D?c 8?a? lu?x??? ?Ozo? ht+?&\?'? L?4?R\?U ???Tc_gc? ~ ??1 ??~ J�????/ N??B ?# ?2K( .
Y?? V?u? t1?/??h ?(?Fi???@??+sm?=?
$^C?" ?q �?? H,? ?=-??y??6+Y?q /K]?m? ?I?YH???;
?I?b??5? ?$ ????%j?w%?Z-??b??< ? ???6 ???@?T2 ???x??< ?-6 s??9?? ?R ? U?D?X?"??~?@?Q?}?L>?Q ??d?{?!?l? ?dlP?? ? ,[??l???8?2?x? . ??Y_?q?#S???? {[j??? S0?}?6 ./??.? ?u� ?n? l?V ?6?? ?@ ??$?Gj?? >?g?E?$?kQ? ??*?v? ?j?*dla??0X?
0? H?vHK^?MQyk ??? ? Q6X%i?
?=? q$t1???\ W??]??, ????B?ii?JiV ???. t ?-$?y ?.^ }?/??
??k??{ ??(?0??&?.? ??b ?,??+Z??3g?YKR? ??fzIe ? ? r? ???2? ??h>?h??0??????????9??}5?2?U?L ?V? ??3? ?"?n?7??Y ? ??#? ??V?? ????? ??)??I?@�5`e??E ?? ?? ?X??MG?[}P?
n?oK??_@????m???[B??0x.?&*?? O ??_=??7???_^? PK }?? ��+w��PK � � �? ?w??_?%?? sA ????? ` ?????????^.?y?V+ ??Ey????'X `2 ?Fx?m??n??e???!??`< ? ?WL3{? a? ?d/Z J0Z m s??E+�8??W?Do???v???|> ?~x ?a N] [N$?5x? ?P ?NdiGh?� >~Rt? E??2;? 6?W R8?Q" /t??? ??'"?? ???0G? ??? ????PJ???=??E5? BO ? {?rN?W??KAm???kLA5x?? ? "#2 =!Nt? Y?q?8?Q? ?? ???�???kkd???
q?=bK?x {??1h/$N?Y 8h[ ?:d???
?IQ???5GFD??C?qI???3?VlP6>( X?;o4 ?YHh??\?? !???\??P u? ?O`8J >????)?"' ?? ? h?f? UA}?K?? h c?=?$? ???P? ?I$?D ij???0=?\6?Jh??h?U?P???[?D`?? ??*7?i K /?s\ N?O?F8V?3?%??s??!L?@?r*9???Ci8?p?? 1?zQ??f???#A?:+G?iV?*??O?? Y e!4bi??5????: 2??? ? 8?R6??F*?? ?HG ???>?`?$T ?Aq ??v*? ?)?gr)?i$s?p b(k? ?j #?u? ? ?
???i??MFf??HV _oe? $T Z25?MT?pI????uN?? h ?? ?6?m|�?r?iA??? s;p? ?. W?W??? ???L(?~?>g???q?K??r?:y?Z??/ch?�? # {?yo? !?(u?
???(?%k?: (/??? ? ?:? K ?]6?}?" g x)????8 *RI????p4?TR??-? ??kf?)??
#???b??s?Q)?Hq? ??? ? ?r?>????9[?"X??9?? ??9N?2u^=??a ??
??$?
b?d??4Q??Z?K?}Q u C3f y t?$?&??E~??B?5?Y?j?Ky??? ? ?? #D?>W59???B?GUg ?A?y#??< ? ???Q{??j*;R??;?v???t??D???q?W???\???????@k?> ?? ?I"?
??? ????E?????enP??v^ ?O??aj?? ????%??: ???
+? ?e ???yO�?v ?2??JT??q??? o?U??q??*??C??f:n?1u4???=???? &M?k?r?????U@ ??_?0? ?n??J? ? \??h?d>s??J=?v?P?? ????f??1RX0?~W??? ?oG??~?7# ???c`?a�?Yz??z?@ N??It?vq?i>)o .????w?)P?|???O?n? g?+?, ??�[ ? T?z??kK???????U?x???U0??? t?
?^.m?K?j??8? GR? S?b?-?9??X 5?? ?S?bZ??q??}?????_??V???|W? B[?(????X ?>?? uG`\o Z?
??l[? PK \?gx �� '��PK �����?
OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 venu 2010-04-09T13:06:58 1 PT0S PK � � �? ?JI??g g?UQH_?|C??Hg?A?Vf?a W?? (? ?_SB@] A??????%S?t`n -K ? : ?? ?7z 8?_?? ]^????\?:?nWZ???& f:???F2 ???:R
-?pU+[?pp'm?rc (?e ?T?i?B ??$ ?aST?.R 8!?y?a@ ???0 ?\?h??DM?&??U??+?q??]W R??? !x??UA?? ?x?qa??I?o?QU7Vb??B|:??q??? 5EYG????o` ??u?l? ? !?4?y?% ?I~g?n???Y>7_ 2+??? ?N?4?|? N?oK??|?1?? ~?? ??k~b???O ?Wo?? ?? ??3??!?^?? ?yY?&?D?6}_^????w ?!?? p%?>?-???? )8?zMPL#a?BpqG??_v)A?8???j??M?b"g?aMQ?i? ??p??m??u???}?k??E?+l?< ??;2?w?
?4?\???(> ??!??{???}f ?\?< 1W~8???8? ?W??h_????V?? { ?_ ??N?{>4h v.Od???&?=m = @d ??D ?? ?? { ?lQ ??$??. ?Os?/0? y2???
n ?^.?? ?_f^ ?:42?: ? ????_3? Q?K:J???~5?,?C??uw??????�? ?H?bB ?? ???v}cH?:X?r????p8?-???D ???f???y3?????j?� ,??kJ?? '`#@?/l Z?????c?4 w?A?jJ" S?Zk???P?V??@M ~%+?? ?yU.?_??7? N/?| a ?m8&?R v? ?M?.-??p?u ?88 G O?m??%??f[?@?*?T?4-?"?d?r? B??0 ??[?.r z? ?{Pq?}?i?s{?? RYr? ?5??b???z?Kb??l??w ????KfNA s?"?Eg? CqS?g??*D?9"J?0???&?Ug %K`>??j9i .rb?? ? ;??5?|?\ h?v?q ??? ??m???? ?? ?? c?l???? ;????2?cO?d??;&??>? 7?R???N!MQF# *N??? [?? ??j?O ?PA??JX?
?p~c:\ ???9? ;H_{*|? ??[? ?e6??-?~??u= ???q???U?8W lY??Z??? ?Hb 8Q?? ??O5?&~}????? ??Q???H?z#AZo~S??i??} ??B?! ?G????0?u]??? A"?
e???
:S?VV^f?!????s?y????' ?I:?R????$^\IHG???9?o?? ?????%??)Uk ?;???v ? ??(??�B?;?XeU?e;^??? ?? o?? ?????? X!KX??;???\?+[?>? ???}}?}??:,?\fTc????l]?S?I?^ p4 5??? ?C ?2l?y?l ?PN?? Yp8???y??a&??3?u?r?' ??? kW???b0c???G(*%???rw???p???Z?x??\-?a????x;�?r`???F?;=I8?&???y?"?????0 r????!?A????? ?????�v?? ?BF?"?W4? 7??`??h???? .?76 ??n???/Wm?s.jt ??h$ ??` Y@? ?MCVUZ3?K?(?XfB? ]??E?V?0T?r??)ukG�/g??A??m?:?y8c5??g?$5o??
M???+q??+FS??3a ??? ?q?9?? Z? t??1`????? ? ?S????G?
???G?m?c?W??EVi ??N ?m / ?g4?I4y= %?/D??)?Fn?$ ?K ???f?;??3C?? *??G?o!?L?Y?? ??{ ???=;??&C?q|u??]> !Df?B??N K?>? ?[qi@w???R?M? _??6?)e???H? /?e1??? ???NBC?'MT?}?[? x? ? ???'? ? +??????? ??UR F W?G9?` 5cO 7.? D ????K}?.n ?7T ??M! ?? ?{? ???R??????9yjJI?a(N?up??w?I??V?0 ?sX3??h U3?5?: 6 *(.Q???H??Kt."???
)'?_?i??;LKGi??dUy? 5? ?G K?p??= 9?? ??B Y\x?3? ?N??& d???7??f J?$-FV?T?#: ??? +?5 r?/U???h??? x??B? C?L??ly?? ??????6*)?? ? $?W???P?
c ?v????M ??XZ ??OPk~5??d� ?Z?'? ???X "???GW? l 7 ??4y0?l? ????$?@??? ???o??~?y?,?? *?rh rs?Vk>^?kO WLC? � K?})v?~?* 7[??5 ?
?a?l???>???@0??G?? ??u??Crdwq?(??~???_f?[??? ???|k ?J?Z?u$?(5??�?)?? b?? ?T??^?Xz?M |
-&?R? ??� _???eg{?(?h`,[ MQ"??-_?b?E_P}?????fB ,#?
I | ?h ?W???>?P? ,???;?s`??? ?[??m ?~?g?J?p?D?,???#6?i??Z? ?U?O????| u??i?0V?K? :?a[?H9F? ?K_ %??TX U???}}? ?-??h??%??)?????? ???? PF?n ? r?KzX?n ]?? ?p?? ?T. ?? h?(L@k??02p (?????uT;.??y ???s? ?? ?? ?I3 # ^ Z??Z V?6V Xo??8?&?h? 7??9 ??? ??? KS??U~ ,??GD?R ?????} ???0$?$??5?M%???*`?f ??|i??
q?P3G1?`! f{?x ?I?N??}M%??E ???? ?? :$?9?{ ? a??g:?,?2t`?z????JB?R�#.?B ?x?R Z? %???w?A???Z??a?? ??
???Y? V s?k|j* ?B?v??z?? ?+??Z???4Z?q??z ??
?;3 h??b?C ?(??Os?H*w[E [I'??? ?w3@ yq??I? ??� ?" ?( %?H??x &? P????_ ?2E?C???x?? ?? B?m?Cx?H???O??Q?u??XP$r?l??"vm??fe????????S? )??? ?iOt????)e`???)5???{V ?? ???_rJf? i?? ?Sz`?@?c??0?5]c?$ ?nn?PC?Y??I ?F??E?????U?}? ? 6?R??) w5?f/= ?@iS ??% ??B K Kv-???5>??4>Z?=a?4\m?`?(;???x?Z$ X5? 6?"?L?[ ???u???~ k?.v ?? _? 5Mr??K ??%??X j?b/????5Q?UEm???? ?5wL6}??I?? .w???y>-'9?es ??? ^? "????H??bd?y3 , ? ?-??\ ?~?X ???n ?W????\ ? A?"?jS?M??5??L?NI?_?x?5:J?c? H? r?C:??}?{? �?p?9n?_???E? ?Xr? ?(?1 J'??hjL? "?+ ?? ??? ???d?o?? 7j??V?? W? ?h?P}???j?)u ?S??D????? ?E ??d?p_?q?Op??3??? ??V?X K?n? ?~ m??U=7????2r?? ? ?}5R ]?< L?????*s{?b?? 2? A{?B??eO? ??2?? A?[N%?t?K?? ?3?R.?A??6?9 }??T V?}Q$? ;{??? "???m?
k?b? ?+A[? ?T???g??Q ???1?G ?Q???"FC?|?FXoQ9?p ,?[He`k?????W?? b*?+1K??A? y?B?#Rn?????>;n????G?&?,?? O?U? U? %???0?;`?:Q"g?? ????????D??h*??bW???????????a ??'?_S# ??L?I> ?bx?i??}9??
?:?D? ?uT???? N?h???M???X?/????m? P???*?I$? ????;a?\ ?Z?w bf??? ? ??S??@?????c?_?z ??e ?f ?E?,?? ?~?W???[@?? 8? ? "?
+L?R ? l? ??c???~ ? ?^? ??H?]??? j?,?? ro??>??=Y??E?ez????z???? ??6> ,/ l?Q?`0????^(5#?g\?s4?t^??=?-??d? IcJ ?B? ? ?7`is????r""2/+???0? ? " ? ???h?}+z?5 ??(?< ???????? " oG?`4?? ??S?B??????wHY;?^???t?Xx????? ? _??^K?C??X?H:??St?~^d? ?Ei???}? ??sG? ??d?'???jR??$?r???L+?S5?`(? ??? ???? ? v?5?nLDo% 8?v????-?*??I?![ ?\???/??jI?? 1 f? ? ?MA??w?%?J"y?7?bb ??M?? ??< ?)????Xf??? bD?>?+nE,?!?
? ?S? jY?/k ??.s? v?@?]?9?? ?h????2 D? ?e???(%rYJ??SOI???LGCu @? ?? ?d|Q? ? 2? q? ]/????QPp???C??y???0Y ??DVs@y#x1m?$? ?]?'???!#?v{]S??????rk???????? ???m! W?w?? ]r"H8>?~ZG ?????HPS,i^??v]0%:}?! ?u? ez ?3 9p"??!?&� W??�??`?k8?:?o?a? ??b??x?@. @?} ? ?d ??3??v?o???{?qoH?kMJH??> ?u1 e? ?4??? vf`Y," ? ?? ? C=???? ??? '| e>? ?N~?? W%DO? PW???p?7?K?
D?? pz?_" \ %?u[#??K??^? ? N?f???[??x*W?? ??x? I"?Q>y?/ ?? ??g ??[ ?}?�??�[?w 9V???
??R?? *$????#?? y)X C ? P?PQ?I? s?9? ?HT?J?R?e??~??K? ?/???s_+ >?2!z???-?pW?*??g? SEu ?z?????*g?z? D \&I??( ?P?;[????gy? ?$k?PC??E?�0???q R#>??4??6Xp?q p" y?)y??8X[muL?a?|?J -W|x9?WS?? ?>?=?7?? ?????G$`3 ???K???q???}&???' ??D R:?
??? ?c?$??q?2?ve=*?V ?4ey??M??F?f????R??????"7??? fpW0?'??H??=3u???LM2i? ??V?h??{?i?^ W?? ?k?Tnps??-?kf M?v+?x?[? 9???:h?e?4???0 FJ*\~ ??Rp #^xz~?bi????{???OcE ?^}|?id}9S"?9}??~? iY? ?oOC? ?O?{????,?:????"?O ?O? IA~w??y?? p? ?=n?4h?)?:?0? ? 1 ?{?? ?VV??M?????%? a ??c?_??x+???M??%? d ?.?
o??2;^? ??p?? ] ?~w ??0?? ?? I ? uf&? +?ke?\3??1?a?Pm(???00?^? ?-??i?)c 1?o??^?*U ?? ? ?x:?
?T?N???x??J???{??? &$me???q? ??d? ? ?Z?z??I?s???Gy??(?b?? ???????2?kf? ?q?7?? ?] `?yNJ????? ??fa?c?D??j???&???7# ? n? ???????1 A??h u ?u?? ?? ?? k??`? 9????c? #?`??#? r??5]? ??Zmy=As?7?C?3??w???? ???? vR?z x??xf"????E`>\aH?M$? ????ZK(?N?e?7ma7Q?f?|?[?}?k?E}?#0A? ? 2 ?7??Q??@???0??bh??F ~???R?s-? (df??9?= ,?k??? ho? 2?c[?+c*t??}9? ? .c? O?? 4?i ?????? ??! ? }?Q??v?U?5 ??Zx�? *~ @??^?S????V?????CYm(Nc?'?7 0my:Oi !??m?a?w?+? "x?eX1?�????H?4V??? ?
>??? {?g ?9?y??_ ?z ????|?6m?I????{?L} ???!??+f ?? ? # D??????%?[u8J h??? b ??+K??? ??z?&ec|N??Yk6z? |?v???+ ?a?Gb?eo?1o?~m???"??9?i?5TcAWy?}????~? ??bT??1?????C?! d?BA .j�??
? 2 }Jj?R0?F? ?7z?? n ? -?V ?C?.RP L)R?s?>o?? 8? %??o?r ?i%h?? ? ?? ????)]?n?E_??K ? %?.?W,? ?u?[?V?3x?�uB? 2Z?????tXkA?(??9? ?$1-?jH? ?=?!? ?q? ???S?; 7?"?Y???E??D ?8??�F?� y?1?rn??!j ?Z ?E?]N ? y ?? ?e??y?]???t??e6?Vz#D??X ?x?v ? /?a??LV? 7? ?k,? ?k?8 y$?yzp%? ??@? ?? ?ZQI? %?z? j< ?r?,?.?^n}0]&7 ?�??6Kb ;? D??O???b?=? ?x ? ???r?S?????? ??? l??W ??:Q?HT? ?Q???K? ??qM?S?. 8 8 ?hr $P?u????= )%o? ?x???c tq u> :??S??kfB?@ F???< ???*I??� ,?? Z?}???k >?o ?bCK K? ?N? F??Q18 ?d?k?? U????po???_w?????y ?a? ,%, ?.D?? b??o???8?e? n??r ?/#Q M?? )?E?%??H4 9?y,?h??u???|?&??i:7?o??{???_?}???ti?pU?S7Cc?$?D? W??"7Z\V?????F%J??????????z?p???g?7V?$P???j U?r y:a>'?EW| ?{?? S <(8?"$e??�e ?X? v? ?Z ?U?? ~?94??4????t11)0'?% ??? ?(sW:?q?D?F{?? /??'AYF?'P E{???y~? ?????I???x b? ?`?d?|n _?
?
??r?kw? R ????O?L F?w ~????b?,? f??p? sS,`3S???1P?1i???IJW ??? [_/$i ??h? Z?????Twu?Z?? ?> ?? |??M)? ??.? ?)+? {? 3??1??(lQ_+I?6 Y !?R! ????? ?? ??u?R ?mR F?,?7;??I ????v???T ???$?"? ????t??? ~ &??!?y?:,?vHX ???m ??%')? ? L?5 ? k?!i? ?????H)NH2?E'???W ???????uht??e?W?? ??|a,?@`L? ???+??N6 wFJ w/\???,h?Z ? ?$?|?8?S8l?? `??r?a?J??h?:"? ?G!S?a Wt0???+`? [1??
?)?X??p8f?WP???? 8P? ra???z7n??j??H???| ? W ?????o?^??8??@ LRp?????T ?0? PK ? [?3��?5��PK � � �?].
P??? ??r?d? "~??lu?&7?W????? G??n ?}9?(??/D???S??.??? ?8?CH? ?) Pk ? 90?uL?=?!q?? C >f\?
_?YR?D s 7}?=??;??r??????Q?? ?^? r??? y?J ? YR?}??. ?UH??3?? ;?-hW?P?]~- ?@?1 |? ??7b<$??H??P?`L"??????N?*?$??jfW???_? ??@??9?? 6? ?; ?R@?u?D???.2x? ?3U: /L??HO ?H oH`/n4B????0?l Top