Karnataka High Court
United India Insurance Co Ltd vs Miss Sonia Lovina Saldanha on 19 January, 2011
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda
Bench: B.Sreenivase Gowda
IEi'~0i1i'1 arc: 1"€s:+i<'1i'1'1;§ at Cffi}. Eim-?i1'} A_jc>§? iTv'I2:1:*i.1'5~a,
House N0 5- {7}afI'y C(j)1"1':g"3<.}":I.1'i<:i.
Opp. L-a(Ej; H111 €ZE'":':1'1'z;'I'1 Hz=1§1, 1.g'a(§y*}1i1£.
AssE3c>i<;¢:1:2ea;g21.1'.
:3./Iz1z'1g3,'211c311? W E5
:1)
Sri f9121ggi'12::.*a21é.ram E3h;::-1'i._
Mzijoi".
E5/0. A(irI':1.ii.§'121 '{3}'1a1'..
"R/31"., K11I.'k211L: V-'ii12:1ge.
Sh€'iI'1k2'L1'EE})1I1.'&?1 Post. Uciu;).iHjf9;.I1.1k,.*'"'*---
U{i1.E}_3i I)i:3t:1'ic':i'. ~
{I-3y Sri, VisEawail.2}.t};1a*--E?:)<:;§;1::y' F:-i,
Sri. P. KEi,FL.iE'1é1}{€i'1T.ififiik', f(3":'._R}'2}T .:.1t1<.i R. 2]
This MFA as.:'m;.:;: L31/S 'W;3{V1'3-of MV A<7i.21gzii:1$f ihfi
jud;_._};menE' and 21w21:f*{i'% dzztjcgdif pas;5<»3<:i in MVC
N0. 9} 3 / 2002 on '£.h<-'.3 'i1E_¢ xiii' %}1e::='1I £«';{_3;riE7.: E'f)ist, tjllfiigfj and
MAC".E'«[11, E.;}_. K.__. 211 ct01"11_ps:r1sai'.;i<3n of
ii_.63q(?j'O(}}$- 'j.r,ri.ff3j i€F':1f.€'T£E'SI.V_@' 'tES'L/a~='p.21 from t':1"a<;>. cielie of
pc:<f_it:i<m_ iiiI3 .if£%%2j11'i$:'a.i'«§§'§i'}.,_ .
IN 364'5/zosfr-L..
V' JT;'1iij.eAg:i .{1"I{i;§221 £'1:"s.i-s2...':11*é,-3_ns..:::?\ Ca}. §,f.{.i,._
" Tfidupi §§."}C§_, " --.
.if§<:z*V{_'ni_';~_.-z}i: 3:
?€.t:§§E{'>2'12;il. {)ffi<".€:,
' ,$31.31;:k.§1;:f;;:A:1a.r2:zy2m23: E%:.2i1di:'zg;gs,
"§'<§{>. =:Z.i5;v§'\§?i {E E%<::aa{'E.§
B3;~:fzg_,§:.:ic>r'e _ 1'
* :.R€tpf€é$t?:1.€..e£§ $3}; 311$
.P9'§_:?::'1e;i.§;§;<2?:.' Sri. Peri ii}z'}pi;'i;;1'£h:.: Eiizm,
E\}p;3<;:E.§.a;r:i.
(E5; §'3'§"§. 25$ <2 SézzéiE::2;::';~2.m;=§ Eiizz-':<.:a Azéazxjé
» . _. ; -. ss''};:{€;a1';c'ii<1;,:}n
AND
E. SIEH. (f}.:*'1'11..1'1i:::z J(:)s1'1.21 Sa..I<i2;i.1'}1::2'a. NEEEE M.21{:E1a<:ic:;),
Ag€:d 21b<)1H 3'; jg-'€'4':iI'Sa
1-'xx' / {L IT.,2.1*£'e E?§;1t":1u{:?I E3y('1m:}; E'sf,{221,<?1'1;'=.I'1ci.<>..
R,r'2;1'i;. C /0. K€'.'£--"i.ii} Aj«:.>:,»' Me11'I".i.s,
H01.:s:ee N0 6- I (}a.i.t.y C<m1p<>t.:r':.:L
(3139 L9._:ijy" Nil}. C.'.h.1,2;w:;:1'1 H211.
Laciy§'1i1E , .i7\sh()k21.13aga1.I*,
M2ar1g;21it>1'ci= m E}.
2, Sri. Rz1gE':ave:'1ci1'a E-3':h211.._ I
IX/Iajor,
S/0. Acéimtha Bh2.at:.,' _ ._ *
Res;.ic1£1'1g§ 2:11' £'{ur1<;a.11,:\z'i}iagf<;: " ._ _
Sh21nka.1'apuI'a Post, LLi"a:.¥_z_.1};i_"1'a1£,1fi<.'VAT ' "
Udufbi I)ist.ri<'I;.-.
' ._ Res;3{>11c1<-Ents
(I:'3y sr:,_R.2 :1.:j1d, R--.V§ 5i;:1--{s::§{1)'~1'%.'
".£.'}m§f MV Act, zagexiilst the
}:.1ci_gm_<»3nAti"4:é._:'7.t;1V ?;N.»$»'a13f§if~«ci2€zi;eg%: E22006 p21S:~:;€:d in EVIVC
No.'Q1_"'if_,ff2{}_(}i2. "<31'1 01' i,3r1e E1 Acid}. Bi-s£;. Judge and
MAC"1?:I1L, DQK.."".3§'IE1.I;i§{§1'f(:§I'€if' £1V\'f§;'.1E"{TIiI1§§ 21 C',{3I1'1p(3I"iZ-3E1ti()I{1 of
Rs. 25.C*.()O'f:g V»-*iI'Ai<,1_ i':~~:'t'_.e1*es:si', @ 6% p.21 ;fmm 1:.h<a% ciatet Of
';:;f;§:2ti'é,ii(>1": '£11.11' é11.isz21.f E0 1:}.
I§i3F}'&H4V"S!346/2007
:':_E£:;£;::i'_*{i:":<1_ie:: in:s;m.'a:":.<::{;> {$0, E,(é:<§.._
U €i;,;p5i;; Bi},
V. " rL'.14"'h:°<5i,1g_:';1 i'é.:--i; R1;'?§.1_3;i(')E'"iEi.§ C,}'E'fi<':<:?:.£
u _ Sha':'2E{21.:fa_:1a§*21y;2z;'1a E§1:%§:'img;$.
N53), :1/E {:2 §{o.2,z::i.
E.'i::z:'é;;:,?2'1is:>:'<% Z _
Rf:?§,¥E"°ti?§r§i'fI'";'E',€;?{I§ %:.';j;..-»* ii»;
EX/§21.1':z,1§_{e?1' Sari, M €IT}<>;'3.i1;2;.1:f.§'121 Rem.
A;:2§3<=31é;:»1m'.
{E33}? EESH. {:3 C S<::é?t}3a;"21z:1a R210, 2'-"u::1v.}
AND
3. P2;:1:'1'1ec*,:'a I}':sm,.1?:a1g
Ag_§;€c1 aE:3<'>uE 26 y<.>a1'ss
Wig). Léflifif. F1";-z_1:':<?ise; XE3.'v'i€.'.§" '£3 S<>u7,a.,.... _
R/zit. P1:'1c*i{'{ H{I}L.IS'a'tE?. St.1vé%:"I'1'2i--.Raa--§i, M
Kzuliiarlzzcii. ]P<'>s'£.§ 3 .'
£\f1.'a:z'1g21§{>1'c A 2
26 Sri. R2;2g_{}1;avc22'T1<i;'21 B}'::.;1_f::*~..A
EvI'a_§<_>I*. _
S/(T3, £»\,r;.%}'11.tt}1a:f3.i'321t; .*"" = V
R<~:s3i.(ii:r'1;,3; at KL4£.IfR'E}l[1_ V'i}321ge.;. " _
S1"1a1:1}~:.2m.11;3Lm:1 PG}:-1'1 , ' U :i 1:1' p i__".I'aj 2.1. R; .
UdupéDist:.z'iCt:,,.....__2 ' .. ~
Resp0z1de:nt.s
""._I_'}:'1_i<s 1'§'£E.?fX":i:.s S 17E3{1) of MV .Ac:1:: 2'1g;§21i.r1St: the
j'L.iCigII3€;§I?I. 2.u1<:1'a\1:1§1:"{.£.--"{iai.cd: 3812,2006 pae~ssc2r:1 in MVC
'F§}§§' 33.26/2EI'i'.)_f2 {>11 9112:;-é file of the H Acicii. Ziist. JL:<:ig;;e 21nd
..'}J£ACui7ii'--i.1I. 1').K;;~~'3'*v'f';1:'1§;:21ic)":'e, gum'-irctiirzg 21 <':o:r1pm'1sssa1;:i_<m mi
, =~?g§}$.(}G€}/ »» xi-2:'i.fi:?1 i1'}i"eres;§:. 6% p.21-1 fz"<_)m 1.3.1:? cizztté of
V ,_§_§€??A?'i§f'i§}'E'}'v t".i§§_ if;é;;..E%:~;a-:1'.ici>z:.
Lfi§§mu§ggé25/2009
BEEWEEN
V * EVE rsg. '\?'s:'im'":i£é'<;*.d E'1.zE;»1§":'.2: Eff) f5<'m;§e,~:.
.&;;:{;-:«;§ @513 ye==;'-'::°;«>s'
{m}
''_».'i
(3.
I?'21}r1'1<:<%1.' NiS1'1E:1 Jr;*:'1if<:*.r I") 8011:2521.
£§§_§&?(.i 28 yc21.1'et~:,
Pr:e:;?=€:1'1:32i1 (i'4i'1a.::%1"1"_\,g-'1 E") S<,:»21:».:21 .
A.;;;;eci 26$ },='<;*~.aa1's;_.
P1a<:ic.i ;-:"x.Ei::?n E") E3<m:»:a,
A§_g;c?::i 22. yc2;11"5~:;._
J('3sepE'1 E) 55{I){,.1.Z£:1 .
S/0. I.a.;mr<':L.1{:E I) E3<,)s..1:»:.e:1.. -
Aged ab()t.2E_ "FE? yc32;:.rss. '
E\/Ira-;. E€l}_.i;r:2:z_ E.) S(')L.i:{I:'3,
V-V;'c:). Josseph I) Sc>1:;ca.,_.
Ageci 2211301411": W3 ye:?a_r.s5'
Ali 21.1%: R<?si(iii1g_ _V . ._ _
Piaifid H<;>L1s:e<:%. S'11_v;:£.1*1:'1z:.V1R,{>a_gi "
}{211":l:221'1;'4._ciy P(}:~is~€--..;.. _ V ' " "
I_\/Iar1g_::1}r21;fc%*~_«» '
.... t ,z~XppeI121:1t':$
§§i%3.f :'j§--:*§; 71%;'.-:;:i:.£1=:,g§"E{;;:*; :'¥'x<iv,}
AND
E ,E§2ag}1e1xre§i1<E.:f2;: «}%3hat'.
,3 Q." 5§u:?§'1 u H': B E': 211 E; ,
'V ..:i::.h;:'i.:;, ' ----
A at E{ur.E;aEu,
K1_1::¥;_«:;:g1u "\:'i§Ia§,<::, fEShz?:;rT1.E~:ara.;31.£m Pasig
{E-1 zpé '2':-:1 E 1.: kg
~~ V {.i{i1..;p£ I')i.s-strmig
E} I"1§§_.€;'fd E:1c_'3i2;:. E;"1:~;a.m:->::'1<::<2. £1720» Ltciw
E}iv;£:+;E<'}1'::«;zE €}i'§E::é{a E<Z'2"§s:eE2:"z;-1 €';'.<'>m§3E{::x.
{E E3 §322:":EE': E'€<>;'2g<§,
E3 ii N<'>J?§%§ E.E<§:3;:>é.
E..§{i:,:g.}i. 'E.'::2iéaE«~; zmzé E}§.s.§£.:'iz*%,
6
. . . Res+;}:3:>1'1{:1(:1'1i1s;
[f'3f_\,f S11 B C? S€.€?U":E'1Z'E1.i};'1£:E Ra~1<.>, Aciv. fizz' R2».
3":1{')'£':i<*<*. t'.«:7» R1 ('1is;::+e'1"1:sc?£:i ]
'E_'his MP1'-*3 {fled 13/55 ';'?'3( E3 of M1?' Act" 2?1<>*'?=,;i'1?Z';;s1at. '£'}"l€>
jt.1{§.;;§mcé::"1i. 2-u.:«::§. awz;1:"<'I c'i2,a':.e%c'i:1E%.I:2ki2,{}()8 ;3;2-we "i".i:§'1.v.E"~;?.3{'""\/If
Na} 123/2(}C}i2.C an I"..I'1.£.% Elie <')E"t.E'1:>: If A{.'§(.§. 1i}';s;1'r:.<j.~':..__§J{:.;:ig::rI
'§v1A{.',"E', UK" §v'Ia.1:<"1;_;_§211():'c, p2.11'1 1}; :::1Ei<:2xvi;::;;; ' "=e;:?£ 2_*i;'.3:":'1.
p€'£.§ii(3:'1 far «:é<'m1pc?:'1_$at'io;'1 2:-lmi .e¢,<;*E<;i1";g_;;~e»s.:1.EfiamL:z§%112:=:;'1 'é" af
(:()n1p@I1$aIii<';1': .
IN MFA 2826/2009
BETWEEN
1. (',yr1t",E'1iaV ajgsra21;SéiIci_é11'11:£e1..
:5'xg(i'.C1é1b(j}1.I'[.33"§5'(;5d_I'S,_ V
WA). L2-1i<;;% E52-1r1'11,.1€;=1.T_ E5yc.h2'e-33,' 1\_f1é51*i'f f§§;i€l{},
Z3. Jcasfi-:;:gi'1"M2=ic':h2ig1<>, V
S / 0., E3,21i\sf3 (110 1*:-3 5.\r'I:-:2<_j1'1;2-1_=;}-(fr: V
. E31-ézéiv ._'_;;i<:i.e:'<} --~
V-'\i";fg>.* r.I()§5:'{fF);£§_ EV/'1;a.:i;»L§:'12::c§<3.
. _V Agetfi 2;'0c:~.:1.§. 66 3-'€:2-11%;'
Agtid' 2i'i.3<>_1.:11;. ?21. gm. _*
{J3
i,A;<'%_E2 "RX 21%; (i'f'<'§5.' Kevi::": Ajay 1\/1a1*tj.i:&4,
_ .,v§"';(')%.;¥.V§.§(:T. N<:>.6~ 1--E3, Gat:t'.y {"i«:9n":g)<>2.1rz<i'
_ {;§_§);.?>§ "i',fa};i3z 'E-iii} Cf%'1:.uf<':E": M21111?
E.;2:7€_,3.§,-* V E:=*{§1E ._ A:'=~:eh W12": 2-: gig I' P€}:'=;:L
_.?v§:§ij%.,;§2:}{}:*i% ES,
V D A;);;><-::ii;::'1€..ss
{§%j..-V 5351 £3 §{;Tu'1.::::a;2§<;21.z1 A.(i'v.§
=
E , §~1i24:;.§E 1 2:':*w::_:<_'i:.'::1 B E"; 25:51 . N .'>7'W§;"' ""0 S/0. :'\<_%1'11:i.3'"1a B1'123E".
A:'.1L1.1't .
R<:%si(iiz1;;_:; 2113'. fi{1.1I."I<:2¢1§1:, K':.11'ka-1&1: Villzixggcz Sh.2mRz11*z.:§:>'1.1z.1 1' P<>:::ai:, E} c:"1:1;)i 'ii'a11,2k, L?cf1.1pi. I)i.s3r2"i<::'t'.
av Uf.1i'§it'fC'1. I§'1c:i:%a i1'1$1.::'21:1<.:e Cc). L-'ECIEH .< Divis:4-:i<ma.E C}ffi('I€'.. K1'iE3hI':e'3. (.T<)r:'1p1e>z:,----- {}.E3.P2;z1'1t':E1 R<4>2:1£i. P.Ei3.N<3.T§%;
Udupi, Uciupi '1'2:111::k emcii E)i;~3t:1"i<:i .R.@.;:::'e.,.se.1'1'i':<'=_".~c1 by itiss Ir%f's':'2':_1_3'1(t.l1 EvlV2i.1':21gc?:f;"' * ' E{§;ésa;)<3I'2<i££:3;t.s5 {By Sri. B C V<S€i§.é'i'h€1'F€1E§1E1. E%Z;i*<3."A.civ' for R2 Sri . Abdui ¥{:_i'"1-a.da»1*. JAc_i_v'.-. far ' I?" 2 , R,1_ W 1"1c31;_i£:e., c.iispe.n.sse>t1}'. " ' "I'i;i;s;"§\:1E?*'~A--'i%3'Ii.E§:gi"EE_/iii' i5}'i%( I») of 3\/EV ACE; agzlitast. the j'L1dg1I:_e§n_j{" a?i__:'i§_i aiivez_:fd<}:.1:1_fc:d:i£E§.I:2.2OO6 gjaasseégi in MVC No.914,z2'@_02"-cg:-.;_ the-_1"i2ea£,.t1~;e H Add}. Dist;ri(:1" Judge, I\/{AC'T$ {)"'fiIEfI,. ?«fI211'--1g;'2:i;1:31"e;:,-- ;321:1't1_}-* alic>WE1'1g the C:lau'.m p<3ti'::i<:n':1 '50:" éécinizg;f>cr11$sTai.f:'0:1 éxmi :45:-':<;%Ki11g.; f:fI"ih&13'£(i€fi1'}€'?E'}f of (:(>n'1p'a;:}:'1':é;e}.'Li_t5:3:'1.V ~ Q: MFAu°2'z84;'2dG9 _ ' .. ..... ..
. "E'3}f')I 1&3 . -'E;--«:>2::r"::s1 S2.1;Eci2mE'3 21: . A Ages} 21"t;.<'j;1 mi' 26 }-'t';?'£:i.1"S«, '.£};":::n__'§;z:1.?:é3? F§"<:E.E"1i('§;':~3 X£?i's;"E€"fI" SE§1§{'§.'cE,i'LE:L_ R/H3. {T/(T). Kc>'\fi1'1 ;%._ji:§}-* ;'\/E231ri:§:s, AA ,Ei£. .E'%:'"::':>.6~ i.~?.[.%. C}£:fi'f'},-7C{I}37}1p(}13K1d. C}'j;§}3. :,:.m5,z Hm ("_f_§'f1z,;2.:*<*.E*;; §~4;2-122; VV "E;z§1{iy E>f§i§E$ As--;h:f>E<;'z':z:.g23..:' P{>;°:st', ;:;':Eéf;:'é-? -- E3 D 3'3». g1: ';:';»€ E i 51:12 £1 {Efisj}; E-1? ,'r{.§?i.§I"EE.§E.;;-i.§<;§E€E', .5%{'§'%:.;% AND E. R2;1g;"1'12.1x-'€?.11{;§1"2z E3E'1z1%, fa. Ea:.:111.:f.E'1z--1 i-31'1z»zt._.
A{§1;E§:.. .V Rcésiciixagf at I'§I..1§.'§<_'21.1"£,1. }{14::'ka.I:..1 Vilizige, 5 . ' E5}'zz21:'1.1<;a.rz1p1.1.112. I-'3'c>:-st. "£}'c§1.:p§ 'E"21§1.:§~:. ' 'L_Eciu;::i E.i)§s;%.1"ic:~t:, U.z'1ited I1":dia I:'3ss1.1'm:_':1('<5: (L53. I,t.ci.} H . I).i.ViSi(')E"1E1.1 (I).ff'ice., E{1'is--3h1'121 '£Zc3iI:f)I«::xQ = (M3. P3:,=mih Road, I3'.»iES;';§?{:>.7E§A..V_ V' Udupi 'E'aI_:,1k I{j)i:3t':'*i<'i_I':."*~ E~2€:p1"é3sa<;%1"1t§3»:i by L' E3r2,11'1{é§"; M2-1.1"1z«;gtt:.;'¢ :£~»«} _ Rc>s:sp<3n£.i<::m:ss (By ssrmis C &3ec:«:-J1::;;u:::m;:;R;i¢;,}aV;sa;a for R2. E ..;«»"_'.:r1o':'_;1_{'*:<:? ;:ii..s;p<;*>:<'1S;~*L»éj:fi.1 V .:~.
'1"r]1.%._% iéé E'iI_é.d _{,}T_/"S' 1'?"g'3{V1} <3? E\:1\F' Act: 'c:Eg;21i11S'i. 1.116 j1.1dgI1'1i--3?T17{ "§3l'1{i:1:g}?}~?U£i;I.'§i"-_(i€iTiC'C1~I~1 5%, 12.2006 }}'c'.iSS>'('?(.i in MVC N051 I2?,?'2%€j}.()2V3<,aVz'1 --1f'}'i'c3._'_iE1::2 of the H Acid}. Dis"t4z'i(:t Judge, R/IA€?'i'," 1.}.K§' .:':§\./I'é1:.1vg; (§E"'§f, j{::a.rt1y 2111()wi1'1§; the Ciaim petii:i(:.u"£b1"a.:<;>n:.§j«:%1'1E::ai'1:311 amzi se:<=:.ki11g er1i'1emc~.cn1er1t: of (fC)II1p€I§i:S§11if'}'1'Lg A S M}?-A_ 282 (}f:2.(}09 'A .E\:§j:"s: €.?§,%=:é:_i3§i21 <T.f<.):=~;1.":a Se~:idz':::1_%1e5:, E\I€<;? T¥'I£31{.'h2.iC§(,). A-63¢;-*,:<?3:,' '::17:.::3'ui' Z323 xx'-?2sz':»>;'
3.... A ..» Wm. iéiiéi' S2:n'm.1eE Syd;'1<?_5; E\»'1z:::_:}12:;c:i{'}. AA ,1':_§;" aig' C/0. i{<3'vi.1'1 Ajqjy Pv'i€1I'USK, _ . H{§rEI1f.~3€i? N<>.6-- 1 {}2;:¥':i'jy' ()<:m1;)m.md§ "£;}'§::;3: igaaéfg E--iii} {"2ET21.::":,L:§'1 §~§2.21E. E.J"§-1{.§E';f?E<1£'E§g 5-fix:-=;§'mEn<,u:1;1_§___>_;2»1':". ?%r§2::'1;:;2;1'i<..§£'"a" ~ éfi £%§:>p§3EiEzI:.:.2.'%'.
4% '?§':'-:
9
{By f:3.1"i. E3' K21m.1'1;'1.1g2.21', E\{'1V.] AND w Rszgixave.1:'1(§.1'a BE': 21:: .
E3/<3. A<:*.}'u.2i.h.2'1 }'*31'1.a1.t', .Ac:E1..: Ii;
K1,2:*k.;sih.1, '£{m°k21E1.1 \%"ii11agg:x; _ S}'12i1:.'1kei~2.1'ei1ptna P€.):::t. V. U d 1.: pi '3'2'1§L.: K. Udupi 1}1':~';'t:ri.c':2f.
U1'11'f,é-iii Ificfiiel 11382.11'2;m{ft::_C?:"». Li't:fT.;._ ' Ef}ix,.» jsi01'1a.i {_)fl'i<_::e, K:':%s;;_E:1:';'21.(;(:e_mpI¢:X'.-- «:3. 23. Pam; R;;ac:, P513 UciupiT2.11z:1k 2111151 TI;"}i_<is1__1f1';..:f{T. " "
R.€§}')I'€Sfi?!"lE'f.&3Ci byH_iV_'{.i'5 V ' E3r2m<>h _ 'av? ;_1:'1.a.g;é::1*." ' -
1:3 Respor1de11E;s S--1;_'iu§;.V£?3 ;'-I~;c_?:'viE:t:1';:'-;:r"e*1~A1"r12i"gR21(), Adv. for R..;?,-§ .... __ "E\1_()éi{%s;3; .11') 'E_€..E__ E:.iis';3*;:x:t1_ée.éi with) ~1i~,'r'S I 7£3{£} of MV Act. 221g,f;1.i.1ast the Jz.:dg_;1*;i'::::_1.i'L ;';;.1'i(.E_2m:e1::ci"_;:iatied:1_8,.12.2()O6 pzzsseci in MVC Ngw. 917',>'i«?;'}_(f)i2; .«:)::>'n {:E';ac?fi}€ of the H Acici}. I.)i5'{rici; Judges. §'.'EAC'§.'--{II. 1);---K, E'v'I:11'1;§2x..1(i)r::%, _1;:»;e::.}:'E'i'y a.1I::)wiI'1g the (:Ee1iII'1 ";:>(;€t:i%;i=:;§'L';':1.'fkx' <{:<,):}'if";"é"::':1s;aI.i<i>:3 amci as-3%<:éi«:iai1g; <:::'z_h2'a_1'1<;:<3:menE; 0f ' _ " {'i}Ii'}.§:1fLi11E51..'j1'§'.i£.}?£'1..
H '-- f:1*~:" :§iF,gi:'2*:z: 8s5/2009 §E£E?EEN «M37 31%/Eés.-_~;:»s:~:« S<i>z1:a Lm;'i:';2:a. E£a3E§ia:':E§z1 E§g§::i z;:E:}<}1_.: *t' 52153 §;@:4'::'s:;;
E}/<3, §,.2;1§:s: §+"':";«u':<%i:<«; }{e;:v£:~.:;" E:§2=s..E<.Ea:'1;2« 21%;":-=;x {if};-°;::é'E':§;.: ;§{2s;;';;.z §§%;:iE{i§£:i§"§;L_ 3'-Eggjsaii 2::.E'><.>:,.3§. :33 §;{*a:.2*§§.
113 D/<3. _Le:21'C f~='1'z{:.:":r3.i;~_5 E~i.2:2.vier Sé11C1&1I'1E'L E'r30'::1'1 21.11' R/ 21:. (fI,~*'<:_3. Kc-win A_}'<)y ?'vq2,iI."T'.i$9 H<;)t1se i'\.?(>. (BM 1 (i}2'm:j.f Campoumri, {:I;:)p: E,2::<:Iy Hi1} Cfh1.i1'('*.§"1 P-32.111, .L,2';1<:iiyhiIL 5\$1'1(3kI":eT1.;5;"é'1.I' Pt)-est, 1\/'E21:'1;jj{2»x_.1<)r<;r E5 '-- .. _ 1 ' . - ._ A§_:[_p~.=:}£z: 15*: _A 'w (B3; SSFE, P E{a1"1.11'12jaka:<14 A:ffv,] ' AND E, Raaghz-1ve:1':c:%m BI'12.1£..
S/0. A(:::}'11..nhz'1 _E3E1e'-it ' Adult: _ Rc3r+3ici1':1 2.1': Kt.1:'i;2:1 :1 _Ki:;z :f}k::i1jLi iV1'1;1g.-ge. SIa21..1'1k2ar2,2}3L1r21 P<>'s';1i». V .
U{i11pi'1_'a}2._.1k, H ' ' V _ _ _ U<:i1,2.I3:i:'
2.» U1i1i..¢('ii :. I t:':_diz;1" E11«s3iii5;?.~;1'1é£% C Lid. . if)'§v.i:si'm.121I' *§i.;3f'I'3 C'<«:,"--}{1*i::iI'I'1":21f "C011'1pl&-E);
G. I{%f?2m1_.1"1«.}%i:;>2q("E,..¥':.E3.; No. 1%.; i3'{i3_<,:1.>i T:-2E:x'i'-Ii £}E'1_{i"«f::7"E'.¢3EI'i(fi§... IT3éi§_3§"&?S(':1'Ev'1€3d }i)}Z '$1.55 4' V I}3raa~1.<'rh Ey'i2.:._1-22i~gcé1"~;"
' " ' Riaspcaxzziezits _ {£3}? ';i{S»._I*i. E73 C' $<:?¢ri%'1221';"a1::z1 Reléi, Adv, far R2? ' _ " m_}iic:e diss};)::r;'1sser:1} Li/Ef?;'i £54; iiieziii UKS E'f3{E} 5:? Mi!' .z'»'ac€. 2:g.,§e2§1'1:%;E {Zh.€i'f ;?':.3'<:i_gg;é':;<:':":E_ zmd ;,n:v23.;*d e:1ai::%<i:iE8$E2»2OQ€*3 pa.s;<:se3s:1 in l¥z'IVC T\§'c3.9viZ_-57%/;E€}(}2 an the: file: <1>fth£.% IE _;e'x«:i<".iE. §').£s.:-;f.ri<>:i JtJi€i§.§{-3.9 1M,.z{fk{,7"£.'--§EE'.,, ¥"}.E<Z& .E'krfz;z:':5_--__zje-1_E<'>:"%;x §Jéf:1'E'}js,' a§}<.3a*e::':'1;; ?;:E':::? (#321132:
._ " ~;fss::€iii'1?<'>n £63' <":<:'}m ,}€7E,'"§ES;E-i.'§iE{.{}§"1 gmzci :~";a%¢:%E/~;:':':{>' €21§'1.;:.:'1:;:e=%m'2$3.': <3? V E E _ 'E a'::_3:*:':: pz%§'1s~';;'-1': $1532-L 'i"E'::_*::_;~;:_% ;':fg:§.,>::;:Z_;<; <'%:m':§.2";;.3; :22': fz1>s' ;%e;:iz:':§ses«;:é<3::., §§'E§Sé§ s:§2:}-2 §'.§'§::* €'TI:..}z.:.:*'*:% {%é:§.§::'{::2":T%s;'i 'ma--* §"€";EE;<.m.?§.;:'E§i: JKEDGMENT As: iT.§'1e:;<' ::a.;3pea11s 21:1: 2t11"isi1j1gg, (nit. <31! a <:<>mm<3:'1 1*(:av:i tr2»1.I".1E<* :1(*(.:i('§m".:t" <T2('<'z.11"'r€:<.i Cm 3()&E2.2-O§f)71_"a_z'1{i 21 €;T(}'ITf'1.IT1(l}E'1 «j1_.'1<'ig;:.'1{:1:'3t: amii i.I":ciix:i<iua1 21'x_3.féii'i"{ti--«ée;'_' --~ :.._j'{I}"1_<:: 'I.'rib1.a1'1aI t'}'3é3:g z;;12'"e h<:2,1.1'<'i i:(:'>g"£:-flzezz 2i{1fIT!.'.§'5z,'i'i??fi:"éifitiv W;it:.h__ fife? Cf}I1S€.I'}1 01' 1<?:':.m3::-:<i C{)'1l1"ESE.'§ '»§3.p:{?{<i3£«1;I:9iE'1;'~;;_§. f«(}I:"T.1'iaf§ '=..pé1%lfijifiis tiley are di_s3pos:s<:-:<T1 c:«£' 133,: f:'F":}1';'3__'€'i'(I)£1'1.£'i]()i1j'L.ECigf1§'§iI'E.{,m
2. For t.h:-=2 Sézi}-{C Qf c:L'>11\;_<=2.r1iie:11ei:s:V ;}e1rt.i<::ss:._g11ic'3:*efh*::'red "£0 as t.h:';>y are rc'§'t:;"z'c%::1'"i:>£3": €:I2;1.'i_';:f:1pté'%ii'i{)'1'1.
3. "'T%:*ig;;if . 1':'2;1' .'i:.e;=-- <i>"i"-.11hc:=: pieadx:-é«:i in i;1'1<:% claim péstii.-i_of; _a:*<3:_ ' " ~ 'i_'£€:'1i'. "<12:'.':i;{3-V.1.':2--;'2O{)E \>vh&é:'1 't:h,<:: 0EaiI::1ar1t:.s wen;
.,1:f "£iVf3.Hii'1,;§ {'1'} £§{"""T€Zf'.éTl E'S:,.1;m<:2 be;%21z"i:"1§_§ _rc%g.i$t:.1"211i(>'r1 N0, cm NEE mezzi f:'<::1f1": Ma;1g§a..I{m':% to '§:'€tE2?:*z1?:§:é:.zé,i 1'T1::~z;:z* E'v"£2:1{iz"e:::~; .':1fEi£'?"I" Ei'Ei'€.€:I'Edi?E1_;_§ 21 II3EiZ"Z'§2E._§§€i3 £'z..u.'£;:i.A§%;>1: at Ek/§;=:.:':g;2.1.i:,>:'£%, itzim s:-;2-mi 2?:%Ir1i::t3;<-3 met' w'i.t:}: an r _;1§'fA:':E{:i6:z'1:¥ at S%h£:":»'1<.i§; {lEh2.:i' in E3ui*.::..1r 'I_""a1?:,1§<.' ziimr it} ':'..E'1<:% E r2[:,:§§': ;::.:'2::3. 32¢-%§§ii;__:;{'é:':E <.§:.'§.'v§.:'3§§ 135 'E'z2.2Ea. §f§E§i'1'E€'3 §'§j: Eisejs {'§r§:?{:%:"
2:: :":>:e;:.:§:, €I?.§§,_;jh2. §§:'::_"s::2<";:::':.s.e %;'2»m:<::E§.§:"2;;§ :2: 'E':;:i.2: $§,1§'§§if} %5§5z , I»-1 <?<;:»1";«:rm"1'3ez:"i zmezi §I.'§S3L.1I'(?l' mi" '(M3 c_)f'i'cé1:<'£_i1.f;§g 'i"':.1%[a Ej%:1_m_<"; is c;r_><;(':s1'1<;-%1"21i_<%('i §'r:m:1 i':"1<%i1" 1ie.1.f:>i1ié'y £0 pa=1}; C011}p£3i'1S§3E'E.fi'i()I'1 :10 HIE? c.::i:;1in3a11'1i':5 2_11'1<i t'.§"1e=' iizfiaiiéifg its fi><c<?§ 01'} 3:.-:';=:'<;:%g>~::;::a;: 0'1""
{her £'3i'i}:%1'1('ii1'1;_f 'i"2'1i:;:.: $L.EIT1{"3, 'I'§'1_a~:: (:I.21i1'11;i::;s"::"'.:--__+ 2,.i:i_{% zvxférVi.i.VEi:=::€I"Ti'.§{'T to? z"<3(,'~.c>x.='er t..E'1:;: {'(>1'1'1;,:«m'*:s:s2;1tEm: 2..1w;;£_i'<'i<;€{:E' 1:ff>j£~I' lag? '§"i"§"&i}_: tV:'::1E' fr':'::m 7 i'E'1::2 «:'>wr:ae;:r {:>f the 0.ffez1<I_i1";
Th :3 Sé3i.'d'é.L1'[i(')1"}7 2:m;:>1:;ii:VV.._%i2%}}'(>Siffli I zV:-T1V.§313seI_12';1:!1'é. in their 2~1;3pc?21:¥5 V :4 I'é".'.*Ii';';II'%%i'1f§'.(.".': to Ems? .e1pp€:1£a:'1f:;s, :1» _ H 'V _ In MFA.
"V<:.i<3§.aj\; :3? "F455? {iE2»1ysi»; in fii:i_ng i'.}'}.£:' :A:3'.'pp €3;5t.1.' A b T ..}3 O, 7ThiS i5.i~:_a case». oi <Eez;H..§'1 czrf <m<> F:'2=1.1'::£.'i&.s; XEIVEEI' »"[}"f:"§{)z::.2:;'3,%éigcici z1'0<'31,:i_ 4%} }_;sz11'é.«: at. im: %':%:11.<:? igf his: ck-:2':'t' 11 in €--E"1<:% éis.:--fj?§<':{s:a'i£': €;fi'.'Jid€.*.§"1§'. 'E".:'°:>:"z1 p«:)Si': m<'3:*:.<::":2 ;'<ip<>r':; 'f'h:-:2 <;}E:;_if:1V2'£.1':'t:.;~3 in :€=§i..1pp(.')E'E' mi' 'i..}1@i;' <,?c.:sz"1i1:3mi<.m Eémi'. 1.133' L1§.C:':<i+;':s<:£"§ w;;1:¢; <:2<.:§.:"1g__§ §r.'}:.:.:.~;i::.<-.-=:'.:<;s.:'; in :%E":2::'<.?: :':12::"§<.ei§. mid €r2'1r:.z§:':g; zi','.€"}§'1ES§{.§(;?E"§31§i}}::f 2-s_::§{_n.::2:g %$.f;3<;"§'3<'{_'E. 2-;~;>;.2-:.::':i_':":xEng; f;.E'":<"'* 2%-"%'§':5 3:? é¥E"2<;3 ::.E:%a":é22:s:;::{.E %?'x»'a:" E4 E':g23;:r*s2% Hi}? ;>;_*<'::<i_i':..::.:::;%s:% 22.22;»-"
$8 I?
15, Re5.f;35.{}{§>{};'A» axx.2;::.1"<..io{'i bjx,s' ihi' "'§'1':'b1::'1za11 14:1'";€ic2:' c:iiFfe1'tit'1t. Z'1cé:1ds ofc:<>11v<::.:'1é...%o1'} is: _j1::'::~;{ :;:I'1{;§ }::':'<)}.:43§" zmd it Lfi(3C'E~Z Mai: (#5111 R31' §1";1<:?:'fr:?r<::'1<,:c%. in mm} éhx;-? TI'iI.JVL:':1'.'.1 £:i..1 has; 1*igI'3t.I§; £I1W*2:1};"{7I€?C1 £1 {_";c)mps*11§;z.1t.i{;1.': 0%" E-5¥E:~;.:":3. t:'h::>,a"n+ is; :10 5.-'~;(:'<'.>p¢:* f{.>1* €EI'E}j'123I'1:.?{?I'1§C'E'1i.. 16:3. .E§,\»'e1'1 m;}"1eI"wi:s<=:* {he i:':<:)1f«;;1%'1'1aim' a :=x§"«s;ir:='3¥'2'1j;? <3'£'.f?5'E§hci2i:y$ I in fiiing the appeai is 12:31:;}1"01;>€%;'€y ?::=-'x;';_>};11f'1'2-"MIA '
17. He1'1C::é, thre .21ppr3z:1§ is 1:, '€'§:*x.?<§i<i of n1eritT iaoth on the g;§:':>1,:§;1vc,i'««:;>{¥" <,1r::'1_2:1y;.j_"u€(»..Eifi {}'1'"} 1'm%1'ii'; In MFA 2820/2OO9L[iLE7VCV__j%._1:_'§"{' .2e?:;g§
--7£'1'é€1i:.is':1'<:Eéiy,.<5'£7.f?éiE3 <::i2;1:_v;ss in fih;':;: ¥___i'1.§:% 21}j:>}'3ca1. Exie-3'1VViE7 iéfléf :,11£i'i i"r:31" is <é{_;'z"1ssi<§<a:;'"s-;: {'31:} §.'}.'1£3I"i§'., {Gr théz'. 3-.3'3i}'1.1I'.iV'€?éj§V'E§':'.iés1.e1§1'1€€4i %:>y' iihss a"12:i.i'm;::si as'; r1'1<;rm':i{.3m<::£i * c':ert':.ifi.<:e:E:<: zzi. £5';->;. E7 E. Y" 1.3:: 'ghe E-€_.'E'.A.._ A i..§3. {Em :+g'{?:E.i§' 2€;3{}'E 'ihéi :.*<..>mg'::<%:1sé;;1:{'§{'>§'1. £721? A M ;m:aa;:'{:§e<_§ ';k.:»}.-* i.E':<.? '§':f*i'i':')::n;_:§ K_§:.2:+;'i. 2n':£:§ g_"2:°<:}'§'}<::"
".._;';,:'é{% 'the-:'£:.'=. is 5'32} .%}'>{..'Z{}§){? flay <31:E':2.1_:'":{ts:m<:1":E. £3»? c%:::n1 E351': 32;: E f§.{I}'!E. if-,'». Eivem ()U".§€?§'*s?»"if%€'? aim. <_::':.1.ir:a.I"'c* d{*§2"1._'g" as? 748 r:.i.2;::~,;*s in 'i'§Ei:'1;,: :;.3m;,~. ;:q.>ps'->211 is 1':c'>'t' ;:}r<>p<-.>1'"E.§: <:%><p];2=:.§;'1{'%{3 zmcii 't':1'":<:3*t:f<>:*c;= the 2,-1p'}['::6::a1 (ii:~;11*:i.:a*,&;+<;=*rE as {1c'~.=~'<:ia:i of n"1<;;*ri% b<;)t.Eiz. on n.1m*i"£':~.'s 53:53 we}? me; 011 (1012-13;.
In MFA 2784/2009 {MVC 1 127/ZQUZ) T}"1(';'fI.'{:'. 51631213; of '?:'39 €191},-'.i%§ in fihzagg 'iii 19¢ EX-'91': if the 1n.:1t:t'.<:é1' :£.:--:; c::c"3:;.1si<T1€.'1"<.=..{"}'20:1'mé:rii,, E131" £316 7 i§'1jLi£'i€?S sisL3_s.~3i'.2n'z1e<i by 1".E':r;+: :_'%1s::i1'1'1 ;:r.:"1"£.*..:_'agmi :i1"1{fii.c:2:':¢t.cécE Vin 'r tkie waxmd <tci%:"t:i;{'i<T:21*;.e3. at 'EX :"~.P if%§§e in E.§:':_;_:%"';~$fI'AA;,. c;3(é<tL1rré3d in the year 2001' _t';E:ia'~::*~. c:.iV>11':pc%§'1'3:;s:a,_éL:£r:;': of Rs-:.,E3,3E%,0€)O,'-- awarc1<:d by tjfic: !}"E'i}},1.E1?§§&i}V i:*i':::;=:z_'c--4.5:}... 5-1:. E59;/E.» pxa. is _§us"£'. {'.§}(i§7._p"§"€?}pL'fE" a-s,~r'§'c=§.u 1:.E:;é';:%g2"vis~: ' mi} :'-.;rx<>§2e-;: Em' til}h2'1i'}(f€EiE"i€E'§11 <3? mm p6-{fa $21; ti{)1'i'. . V e:u1ex1:'".:}'1'c'?1;:"w*£ss:ar;: 2.13"}, (>I."(f§'i1'EE:¥f{.f_.* <"3{'-E;-1}; mi' 1759 eriexys in pm} 12% 1'10? e><p12;2izu;~»::§ §>:':":=§._>a._*:"E§; a 1"EC§ t".he:'<;éf<33:<;% A v';1.*§f':'g'f_»:f:e¥:iV:;.fi'i:; is; <:§is.:;:11issc?§i. 215 c:ia=;=%v:>is"i {>3 §EZ{?E"§i b<;>¥;:§'1 an 'i;§'1<3 L;§:*c3a;_f;§c:i <31' <:1=s:1;t?1§,:* ass: we'-iii 2.15; am :m;::'i:_:'==a. " MFA. 2'?85f2QG§ (MR3? 928;'2§{}:.i} 2%. '§"1":a?:"é:i.* <*i:.%:§2::f,;" wf ?f§§_}3 <_'i;T;:}.;'s:: :2; %?":§%:";;;>§_ éééisei; 231;} 3:13.}. T'§':.i.:e is :2 <..':m-ssé-;? <1>§" «:.§{=3:;.::%E": ("sf aims: fiiifiéi ?*=¢E;~k'§*}<-* ':5 2-:g;V3V;:>c:?e:3;' V' §~ I9 Sa1da.1'11[::1. Shifii was 2'1g§£>c'1 :»'z%3<:>'1.§t. :1»-é-i },2w:-%:«.;-1;1- 3:,-=5 ma ITEE": cizlic of 1'16? cieath in I".E'1E? :'a<::("*icic*.:'1E. ;-1:-4.. cxricéa-21:1' {'i§f<ii:;:£1 piizesti I"I"I{;)»'I"i{',I1'1 1'<:>p<:>r{. Ex. P 33. The C12--mm;-m§::a~: ézjjg J~:e:{z'§:i4§'3.¢:>:r1{4 of their (7<>z'1é',c;%1';'I"153:1 1"h2'1't: $11? c;1<;'.=<.*c?2--1s:.::::: ¥:£iI*':iz_<i1T1g..V Rs.E3.(}€§()/M by ("1{'}iI'E§_§ £E<>w<:a° ':;-i.1:;E.i''1:*:...:sg;,7.<.*x~:';.;:>;._:''a«.=;>;é»i':'r1i:'i1r1g§ 7. me cia.1,sg.}':'tr;'-:2' of i.E'1€=, cir3.<;%c..'(1ss<:%<;;§ ._;1?:.f.-'Is %- U} "i'iz1=-jvkf. 'amt; pmciticted 2:1ny c.i<)(:1..1 mc*rI.'}.ta.f'y_év:1(i:1 :'1:}"<;:__iI'€'~ .9":§..s§;:."e=:g:1_1'ci. £11 {1E'1er &ib$(';?E'1(jif;? 05 pro' (:ii'7._L)I' i_f':<?<:)m:j t.h"c,:,'§'1"i't;maka} Eu;-"is; 1'ig§ht:Ey aSS€fr'éS€3€i E 1'1.€ i.i"1(i'()II".1§§v_(5f._'{.h{§V(J3i€é(:é?é5i.5§s€"f:§v at :§'-"V);L%k:..f}K'€--){-réi)/V'. p.n1. {31z1i1na3:'1E4s3' {isf"s<2r. iL:'ii21'1"i*i::€i'-V"fi.2z.:.:_;;.§§'1.i._a.:~2 2;_1.i'3{'i aI1m.}1er ¥.::1I1121.r':*i.§éC1*i:_ :i;;114:gi;éiisiflni1,-i"1_&%'1'c'fi>3*:% Vi,}'1:= 'E"x'i'r:::2.:;2.;.2a§ i".:.e:1s'-; 1'ight:.1jy' ci<3é.1:.:ct:¢~3dA'7§i3v{)%V "«.{)3"g1€1'{t§f ir1_c:::)n1e "§:<_.m-';.-1'1'(§$ Em" g:><'->r:~:<)1'1al exp<;2f';se,s. 2,u'.1:»:_i "%1'2,«;sfa} ""ii,3'.'l:€%:'[1 th e I"("f¥1EEE'i.i.I"}i.§ :t3€.}% 21$ hf?!' <j§:'_31*1:;:fEbui.is:;::,1_fez'): her :fa__13';iE}r The;:rrai::::§'i.a-'=;' :.§:":<;= T:fi%3;:_;121i :m.;I'£§pli<=i:° of 11 :15; 2'zp;>'§%.:*a-:E.;i:;3 an 'the V"..§f§%l.€i;\>'2i"}'7:§i_ '~,: fg3.€)EZ'1.1{ £3?' E§.'§}1€:'. §"E2w. 's"i;:%:2.E}_,.-= 2:1w21:*{i€:c§
-a 'i.V,E}E§;'i}{}€}_f~ *:.<.2v«£2:r{is has if{Iii..'§}£"§1{%.é-'E1:'jg' grzrzcé %§'1€I°€: £5; ' : .;f:<)i_ §s<:ai>pe 50:' <31:1h_a:::z:::>:m€'r'2tg
22. I%1s:;.E.E3,(>(}€);"' ~ a\a»'az"*<§.t:%c.§ E33}; I"}'3c 'i'1"i¥'>1s1m1 L;31<.1cr;* (iifE"e.1*e3'1.i': h 'E}(",§S~:» Of {',()I'§V£':'.I'}1i(')I'1 is Mjt.1s2I'" a'1.;'1.c'i ;')'1'»:'.>p<::"'----2;:.I:<.1 if «:i<';n<::s; $1.011: grail for" HIT€3'I"fé?1"'f:§I":(T&f.
:23. In i_0i.£§2..l t'1:'1:% "1':";'b1.1n2;1l E":2.1§:; x"ig_;;§'1.%'§€;". __ ;1vx:>a:: é'L%:'.i{=:r:;i_ j 2;1 « «:,%c31"z31;)::1'1:--s:i1i.i0.1"}. <1}? §i,3,€){)a;§f ~~ 'w§_'1§*:..f1:'.:-:' " 2.1:":<;1 pE'€;)pi;?E' emci t.E'";.c%1*<% mi) s<:<}.pc=:= tin." ::'c:€}--t.1e:._t'1..ic:);;:1;'.; . ' "
24¢ <i',ve>.1'1 «:>f§'1.c3.r'wis3e: 2211': i:'1<JL:"<i»i'r;2:aVi.e :i:5=-.?'.1--:'1¢_§-*T '(SE ?'$§3 <"12;:ys»s in :f"ili.t"1.g.-3; iihczt appe:.;:-ii Vm_:if p1'c')pt:V1<E}§' "e_>_iq:)1'::;~.iz_'1<=;s(i.
25. .é3;:%{:c')1"ci.E_1i'g:}y i:Tif1'%§%"é?1;:s§;<%éiE.:i.é;; €.ii-S.i}'ii'$$€?{"§ 215:; {'§:3v<i}i<;1 53%"
131€:1'°i"é1'bt.:E1h";>:'1 i'}:€:-- §_7,);'iT'..)>1'i-}_"1(f.'1 £11"? '§,~1~~$'_E'éE:y' war}! as <31}. ;':1£;;~1"if,K
26. F'{>:f §j}"1£f'. 1.""t='f:§If1é3§{:'}i'}.f§V""f$'I&I¥:fI€;?C1 é11,')()V('f'. 'ihéfi 2-1}.:»;'3:%2:%s:; f1'k%c:i by the _v Es15%;1§i'£f;.i":('?é:§ (}Ti':;«,>.r1'§p72a:'1},:r am-=;r a.E1r'3\a::i.:z§ in é.1"u=:: 'é'.e'.%:im:<; .i;'i1éi1c:.i.z1Ji:.:%<%A. Ese1':§ii'i""::.':3oV<3 zzzrzci ééiaa agypa'-%2:a.E.:':"~s ;%'.i_1ec:i by £316 " .'<:§2:£:3€e:V;T;%5é «,§ §;:.* s;=::3;§':.;:1'm:<%z'31«M115: <2"? e_ite::>m§:)<3m;2:iia:*}:"1. a.;'{:~. €«344ié%IE':E&.$~E%§;:§§"} A2235 iévvzéicé <1')? §;m;'%:'*;"E '%::s<>ET:2 am I"E"3;C ;;§:"<.3z.m{§ <:>§ <"§<%§;2z;;_. £1155 w<:1.E 2225 cm :'21r:riE..
£71 In View of «:iis;1i>(')s2=11 of I'1'121§I§ 2.it}.)}3:.";;é§é~. gsil this: 1.33 s1:.aI'1<"1 <'Ii5s§}::$$C::i M as §i'§'1{E}§ {ii} .«,:.1:'vivc £232' {:<:>:'1s_sid<:r21t.i<)z":..
$5:
Vb/W