Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Kamal Vithal Zalte vs M/O Railways on 24 October, 2019
Ss
| i OA No.171/2007
MA No. 252/2007
connected with
O.B.No.1091/1999
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
MUMBAI BENCER, MUMBAI
OA No.171/2007
MA No.252/2007
connected with
O.A.No.1091/1999
Dated this Thinsiey thedi™day of ficihbes, 2019
Coram: Dr. Bhagwan Sahai, Member (Administrative)
R.N.Singh, Member (Judicial) .
{Applicant in O.A.No.171/2007)
i. Kamal Vitthai Zaite
Arachnana Colony,
KRashircam Nagar,
Savakare Building
(Vedi Mata Mandir} .
At Post: Bhusawal,
Dist. Jaigaon (Msharashtra).
. Applicant.
i By Advocate Shri R. BP. Saxena }
os Yersus.
i. Union of India, through
The Genera
Central Rail
Mumbai-CsSt.
2. Divisional Railway Manager,
- = J Ged Dern:
Central RGLiway,
Bhusawal.
. Respondents.
iY
2
7
1/200
OA NoA?
MA Noe. 3252/2007
connected with
O.A.No. LOSL/1999
. Applicants.
3
1 ht .
red a3 .
wm 4d x Ad se yok
ww M4 Gx MG "~ t
i rt od 6 oO ip é he
x mE A Of Re oR OO ww 3 m4 B oy om
r¥ Om @ $4 @ $f OO Br is 2, " Dp od os
i Gm WD ted ef Ped ora & So ce 5 us wd tts
a 4 08 GS et ft Ct HS Q O % a a i i ga wt
ol QP wt bd mt oo ke OS ea + ag TH om it Ee 4 iS r oa
g HAOod oo Ba" Bein 4 G4 ae is SAS eo
6G + @ 3 £0 fe ma tf Cu GH o-«. ™ wm oc . > Word be od
3G a ey fe Cy 4d ow mgt Ur 1 Geto « OO = rdomy @ Boo tt
ta mo OQ oy + OOM Hr ST ou as fa mt Ca Woo 7s
' rt mt O O mm O O™ W xt SA art AONE . oe 5 id Os
b> OG a ford) bt eG Me Bs OD BO + Gs at mt & wl
oO G i a MS ED wm G3 * wy Da yeb 2d ford Ot Est ss, 44
vet ond @ i ef BB be TW Os 4 ert a ih
44 an 6 Od ~ SS Stet O Bt ow od G 4 th 04 i} oe
L a re @ DO 4 UE) Oomt o> ta a a WS ae)
ww os St > Cr dh wa SE th Go ao i ret
wt Chored sek | Rt Be OG te Wa ow eA oh} MOG mos
ve a 7 De ew 8 ©) ka rd et o Ae OR rh a red
@ et a RG mY OO 3 OH 2 Ps Het rea @ 43 6
Py Bs Ww st oe O SS O84 0 Oo 43 to. i O <e Mt Qe &
¢ pas eh Ord Ge LD oy g Bi uh ka Evra ag 6 a8 GD @
S ed ye os WoO SY @ + @ By 5 Go Ur
6 . rt 1) G os i 7 © ee ee be OO eed mt a
S o $4 Ba Mon, Gi wo d 43g WG et a cet bE FG ord Gp et
es 1 xa ord SO ty Cs Ebert an ed ce (3 Ga my Be gi oe "4 ws i BG
a& $ wy 40 SB to xt ay) & ba Wao oO Mm wh Dw Bm fay Fa
iG bg,
Pt ve i
pti Oo . + 4 ' '
Soe 'ower rt ot ms no ra Col
tad
OA No.1 71/2007
MAR No. 2252/2007
connected with
O.A.No. 1081/1999
t ea
ip
i
6B
Be
Bb
by
rg
... Respondents.
{ By Advocate Shri V. &. Masurkar }.
Order reserved on: 12.07.2019 |
Order pronounced on: 2+)-| 62 19
Per: R.N.Singh, Member (Judicial)
i. We have heard Shri BR. FP. Saxena, learned
Las a « a *. me yO -- ~e é
counsel for the applicant in OA No.PV1/2007 and Shri
2. In the aforesaid original application
no. d7i/2oo7, filed under Section 19 of th
44
hallenged the order dated 18.10.1999 {Annexure-A)
wide which the respondents have rejected her claim
for grant of family pension on the ground that her
2
i
B07
MA No. 252/2007
cennected with
O.A.No.1091/1995
71
f
OANA!
j ¥
6 co
4 o
Bod
I, 43
Wa het CO Ted FOO WH Gm a Th Dy Wosxe Om a . oO - i
Or Bw mW DO ow Oo Cot Fr a WO am cl bp cl og Oo wD ep ted
SG Wo be W Lf art 1 oO tt a ge eh a
wo at +t wet Met ay wow th iY w 6 ed oe oe ol
o wo ats od 8 wd owed ok gy BY om wy se) a ref
wy eh ge SE gy "py $3 G3 DE ard Cut ed wt MO ag Mop ,
abe iy OG oy G tp 22 oy EOD ed Gg mm
Oped 2 ag fe Qe xg ved el re Hoe g a
44 ot det ned oO oA ah ae re rey
+7 gh . & ie peng 4) FS ¥ Dy + ES as r 4 yi vet
Mort 6 oa a * Gy Ow og so a CO Ba
Aad M4 cD 2s) fe we oS en 0 sot £2 ot v, "hd fy bs @ 4
bh OO gt BO a i Oy ee od . yh ° Ot ses ned
ten, OE oH il 5 Fog A a i woo . ip A 3 s
4 a mi SG, iy gg vB " t4 as i Bo - 3 ™ aS 2
od BE ad OF gy wet ga TS a a 23 AO OF 6 B sc me Ba
Sg So Go @ Og ag Op Bd Ong Re "4
eet aye . fea CE Os P ' Ego Ge mm 4 5
oP at ew BH oOo Ew Gu 6 GAS } 43 ;
Bw at 2 go og OM el ew 8 a a oo c at
{ Tey PA eed TL GS eet + 4 44 a BS dtd fh 3 CO A & iD
a tS Ho oO et ye ch Es, HS yy ce eB Qi ag © yA B
Rong Qu 3 * od} a fy, Bog ma gy ee tea no OS 8 "A a
ay a hea 139] My ped aot vet ay & a 4 £3 ; ory bot a © ne a
D i ' Og at og 44.4 Pe @ 4 © Dri « @ wn hy De 5
a tt x Mi. t ac ae ' ta i, 4
ed ty rf Owe Kh om oy qy 8 Oe es Gt eet Hel,
gy Th red we 1 43 tt @ : 5 ry A ward ED OF Om Me ay OF as
bs vee WE Oh QAR Ey "" Ao Or Sh GD by OS by ' ny a
or 2° fs a 3p B Co ed OR 4) 43 B a Se 3
oy cE tw ce rt Cy os ae ES sh & Ww Ga 43 a0) nm a 43 3)
c w Oe te sp hy o , . 4 Fi) "3 ty OG Hog on
"rt o & Ss Moo a - in a wy a & aa ost HD O gw ty a ot
4 6 ed ep oo Cw bt yy LP 44 OG tm 4 mM a Fea) cS
CG en ved . * he SD Be a ve HOO @ O wp ct Oy U @ "3
et a w et "rf GC Bo {ed ordinrd SH doy tn Ad On. 6
ret ae rt co i Aho ur mt Oo M 23 we a
o a os . " a ame cot oon (By £43 om OA =" Sm fet So
499 ~~ S wf et a Le TS OD Hy ct @ ub Oy ae 4a OM OH Om OH 3
gs wm > 42 ty ~~ Coot GO 4d ~~ a fh wee Ga we OT)
@ : G4
oh
a ;
42 C
Far bef
Oo : . be
Gt SH fort
: ~ Gd
i ' rs 4 tg % & gE Ved som,
Boek e eo a p2 (M8 Qe |e
essa 9 & 4 @ 4 G4 fe 62° 2 1s
my oy mae . Lt Ad iy a " wo A w
ten EN ord ord A wn o rs cs t _ ee rf Th 4
re me Ee, oo Pe , = a BS - ap wre a mam Oo
m4 og OU 2 ie se : Boe 2
SUA fe G ° a mf Ba + Don et ky 43
wt BO « 4) moe Boel cl os a @
Oi > Ad ed ne ; @ 3 *s Doth Ba x 305
QO 8 > is er 4. go + co ei oe! om te moo = m™
Oo He eh wos a ' C4 i Gf gy,
Ch a O © "3 1 c wt + inn 4 ics] yap dea wom tee oY fe gs
_& & in ted ce va gr vf A e ehoad o 4 © a &
a * ; . 4 ' 6 eT. pt . feet c *s * 5
BO dy, od eB Uw OP EO EB EI S See fi @ go >
Oe 8 BO an DP Bip O M1) O ates "oo
© 44 "4 a a o $4 3 Sos
eg Bo 9 | fs Bow 2
aa t . > mo "* "< X
a + q * 4
Ei a fom Fg q@ oo ° GO Ow, oO
a $4 oS - ' i pt MM + bo Hy
o es 5; oS } 4 Bord & o
ig a ~ oS o 8 a 6 bt OU 6 oy
4A is : my La va "a eg oy fo
a ih a <<! 3 iG ns S ® a yA Ow
il 44 } oe 3 Sb rd a e 5 be
oo fs t ' os uy in B @ tj 4 Ed 6 ene
* 74 9 cs oe) fa - 4 et ay cs i iit Gri T
, a 8 ' rt DQ © iG xt che r .
es ao as c "rd ' oi a, Oe TS fa ke? cy a
de ig mS a y aT Gs Oo as
Gy tha "€s rho, UH Oo - oO. , mal ged
" M as ea i Ly te A wos ne
" wee @ re D S 5 eo to 4 S ri cS
Ae. > a
P a Be Ho ey is & re oH 2 wg eG
5 « 3 ( ; Dn Bo
ae © "ey a @ a Bb et 2 = ~ ocd Bo g
@ 6 "OR RB BUM le ~~ 3 a
a +4 a Q v z bo we et th cA sh Bey Hee
oe 8 % Ga} By oo. ip loa Bo &
Ses 3 i) y fe '4 oR oa i Ao ky ba set
% . red £3 o * Q 5 4 riod oy ct cd A BOW
a ed' a rc rf chor yy ee pee Bo hc
I, re co wD € +
& ~ G oO i i Ss 43 3 2 Wed edord o> mE of + a ws ®
4 ci 3 f3 fs fe ae sd "| Q "i Or & me rd SO Bs hy Gy
, 4 "f " tee oA a
S ond ae " © & in ns fe 4 * ow hop
| 4 ef ~ Q a 4a Q oA sd op et 04 SE T™
Moke Ce se hlUllUCUlU ri OD ob et Mee
a "s i 2) a oe wt "4 |
a ee @ eS gb oo ;
a tS e at eed oh, hd @ et OQ . ory
m ss G4 - Oy q oS Bie ay -
a th OU me tt Oo mn ae
applicant's
The
*
"
=
'
OA No.17 1/208
MB. No. 252/2007
connected with
O.A.Ne. 1091/1995
bef
B
£3
9
4
qi
74
>
a
ive]
QD
wl
V4
UIE
ts
Tenet Si
oO
o
cea)
ed
ved
de
=
por
m
4
ry
4
wed
Cs
god
ed
CR
Was
shat ion
n
prese
TEST
"A
Me ORE
sre
&
wy
5
4.3
@
fs
«f-
2
ved
rd
Pea
a
hes
wed
the
DE
¥
ah
s
4
aoe
%
t
cn.
=
casual
oy
wb
=
ere
Ce OT
xt
i
a
vow
Serv
oO
on
fae
Ce
NG
:
San
x
Pood
ot
hu
ww Ee
ane &
+ 5 --
plic
vy
ie
x
a
OA No.7 1/2007
MA No.252/2007
connected with
O.A.No. 1091/1999
MAaMMS L
of
Rule~Lo2
ae
Me
4
ions
»
OVALS
for
1S
reed
44
are
o
wnat
Yann
g
he
spd
tke
Ke
t
t
a
LS
eg
O
:
spammed
x
x
ry the hu
¥
a
a
Le
rendered
1
eal
cose
ctu
wnala
ne BS
BR
tn
ARY
NN
2
he ar
3k
x
Sed
x
she.
ban
X
x
Fi
pe
Re
Lenpo
out
cs
AS
i
ether
4
red
urpose
and
p
LOT
a
31.12.1980 as Cassaal
pen
ca
ot
.
TY
?
1
»
x
Lats
her
e
he
account
ERA
yy
*
Wa
¥
19.05.
QT
an
at
{ uy Ad bed 43
i Dr 4 a 3 S ka
Sow A Q 2 me oe 3
me 4 at 0) 6 £g
tee EM ed ed yey = ey mn a ops STO Og acu
oF oe ia B+ Ya ry SESERSESS OR
we OM a C3 ey rs mt aD M4) Se ig a S43 & toa OS
aes $a mS oe LE a G ty " "8 Ge me
Ze i 3 S si Ue pS my i ke ca
ego OG « ws wD oe w? co, iv 3% a ty ba Up ret ay Ye 8 3
~ 2&0 0 ia 4 o hig Ry Gig 8 BY Oe Code
ian) * a : 4 a OME eS ony ° " 43
ae wi an Mom Be qe FER OOH
«< wr . SS . ' . ay he 3 4
& G a (%} oO re} o j £5 3 @ Vi ee ry H o3 4 4 Gj 435
ma OG wo ha " $3 oe ro 8 4 63
13 « de , mK et M eh at xy rd th ry, "4 i) 7
oO €3 tbe$ me oy ME oy 4 oF ' th uy te
4 & ves 3 ys oS 4 i &
p oO bye tp r% 4. % nn ' is "
rs " s O ng, (3 ae cs
Bo , a % ne goo
" ia D wh a 6, a 2 i by ® mo ED
: ie f a oa af & fat a
, § Bow s oes oS Peek ask
t oo ™ ope itt ra ACS oo ¢ ay me whoor ty
Mm gl G ve ge by ° w "Wee wg BE
aps aM uy * ts % omy Oat 2 BO ao is
"3 oe oA ct) y 43] 3 f ny "9 wy 4 of : ial
0 4 @ " Ge YG moe Bo Mg Bem BS
os 2 8 goa gs GC gee BS eK,
vet os $4 4 A i} ie Gm et |
na m, oh, Doge ey ay ot we
'G 4 od rt iv ms Sy oped t3 'a 4 : a fey oe 04 .
syd o Fae) G i+ @ Wom ry a Pr ioe i) 43 mt 2 rey 9 ml
a oN vd me GS sap ° ue 8 Be gy Oa
wy Bow ci x 8 Hoel Te gcc} $e E @ ort anes Poa ® 4
DB Ww rot « "s $3 mM +5 Oo fy So a ; o iG . aS * Ee vod iy 8
$4 es $3 's) 46% 3 43 ce t) ™ a "th mag ED en Be ooey AY
i bye " ae @ -_ at ha tt o ba bd re Re ped ee yoy BS 4
3 im for r Ty a ' y at ord ay 04 4 oan : 4
4 See eo 8 OO | GaAs ; &£GE OP .gr go & fs
6 Om a veg wg US ed HO 22 ee Geek ac AB OS
a iS 4 ori Qo Bei 42 Gy mort QR Oe DO OOO
wo , at "a Uy GS 5 eo a Pri Oey Gey SO, % te e
- * - c 2 tw os Boy or S056 Sa wa
& 8 @ § oo o 54 8 en BER AReAee os Bei O 8 gy OD
bt ky OS ne SOM DO Gm eM OD OM b H&E
GR gy
; a Bo ot
: @ Sey ae
th hi aS Oo ie)
cs hy G ae Che i
Be sr the bo u u
wy ? $e eed crs
3 . bow @ ts aA v4
Ch ch as bt mB is; Ee:
OA No. 87/2007
MA No. 252/2007
connected with
O.A.No. 1091/1999
on
Bd ved
Mm AY OD
a a @
Go
ORDER
seat weet aia ret o qs Ay 43 Ci Q B Pa oo} ek + | apd srt ap ir vs % oe E "
mS set $3 a 2, 2 wy 4 4 ay g 2 £3 com G 8 3 gy is rs ty @ ay ey OD nh Ob ort 0} $3 of mY mG my ted AY G "rh OG $y % Ey tS a iy S B+ By com, TG mo @ eh Sot
-s
a) 3 ved o id, ya & ve Howe tes.
det aed ved ke, ee ved 423 egy aby ont ta rd y Ras OA No.171/2007 MA No.252/2007 connected with O.A.Ne. 1081/1599 1D ii.
CD i Al x w ' 3 a) 8 a 6 = 6 Moot ved o 2 ved as Q e " wo ce Ot ro} ay G @ a mag wed a ort ' eh 2 % ae he Aa a = ea os '4 ms mg oe Q ty We fy de th th hy Ge 1g » go mg Stomp oF Oe "ooago o 4 et Oo U0" co oy a 4 He 44 0 @B hy EY reg ving. Hag 2 ee . Sa i '6 Gg Cf 43 FE $3 Oy aa) en on a rc Ae fend _ ned HS et © Pa fa '< we os By 4 Ye g te a wet 3 i ts o 43 FE HY cg " @ e eq ao aS dd @ ay © res ei ef ie cS - m "ay ie ch i) ™ We ad ~ 43 ® pa 4 is wy Vs gp ty Smo, qo Bg Boos o 0 reg OO HM Ty 4b Ys o oO nee * Ss CG ae a Wa my SP "pe 4 by ub Ss met rt Ry = oh 45 SG Uy i, AS n % a "
a ne Bd 4 Bo CO 8 4 omy he OB ane 4g Bae Te or tn a Oo % "vet me MW may O mia a OF no a ert rng ALS As a3 SS wy TE OAS ey 78] nt is ot a | N @ CF 4 * a Ls s ms "4 Ae nt wg Be) St ted by 7 abode on woe . gs ; * mm "3 ian ard HO os r < re er rs oe 4 \ el > Fed gs r t ¥y " pt 1 a @ Se Ooo Sua i oat r a fo) cs o a . at ; ' £ oes Gog @ 4 C3 88 SSeo' sg eS ~ § goog 8 ae " ? a4 very Ey 3 ws v '4 5 § x Bp S888 g Pansss fe" 2 8 & Be S 3 eS ha} £ Th ges o ey che BO? oe Bd te} A ceed oP ae 3 th ba a " By "n, > 1 tmof G ua wd 158) 4 w ro by seg ey a) 4% mT Ro bony EH ood 0 O 8 % g. red o a Sted ty, og 8 as G Go Og 3 od ey e ' 4) ws = Or bey ad Tay rom 8 mt rd O cher hy a BS vd o & = xz te 43 Hy be ws S 3 eS tr Og I ie ai oy 8 ved is i 43M a5 my Meo © See 3 TS yk i te ' ci . a @ wm cog Hg a ts Sy Gag MB oo. 8 ¢ 8 a § Be oe $ 4 , = os . " ty f ze ™ 5 Q 9 é G @ u "4 5 Got ge WG 4 83 » - fs wet Ds 4 ; eOARY ' ee Ts } tod 8 Tm w = € * = Ge oD OS eg DD » Ga wo Lobe yy OG . ~ 2 5 St, & O WM von FR, ES UP we BS ted om 1) UB as 3 a : a ' oy we Moe A AQ & OS do OO O Wi ae Uo G * o re we ei 4 & a fly om 4d org seer a Oe fe wee ty OH OF eee OE ony bey ot By co rt HA . fan a4 ged ye cn ay # } W » ' Q a4 os a @ "ed ei a] 3 my © Gp So 6 ' it . ; eS ard + wD be mn he Mod eG fod a an + ta ra} 3s Qo CQ an aa! rey & OA No.7 2007 MA No.252/2007 connected with O.AR.No.L091/21985 i} Cg @ @ if wy ys 'oo a3 © 4 rod Ge C . a #2 mG 4 a3 ' ey by Q 3 KS oS 2 55 we D 4 BA i) noe ot o @ 5 O a a mo o o 43 +3 g & $3 an iS 15) & 42 o ref 54 od 43 be] oe} ved 3 Gang = hosel 4d a a "i ; Ry a, , ka 2 ty 8 DP $3 ba "i $3 sr) + eit " fa Ww * Oo} 4 ord a4 43 cs) 3 ubS co 23 a i od t ' e m an i im a o > Mg rt rs OQ y eg fe ed bed a ay oe ccs) AS) B et ed ° @ is : : ; ; ; 43 ® 3 % wf Q? , x et . f= 4 ot rn 43 io 7 i G - o vy A bey co " Cg - re > @ i a uw) . et nn, ws ¥ rt * an f on fm ic 5 a vod 4 rn a a A ord tc mA D 5 oo nd a a @ ; 43 @ ° x a S rv xd a vd 3 1 nm ' 4 co hy ha fda i @ Soha D 3 a a oe ; 4 Hl ip o i a x oe 2 "fa h Sn © ee a ' ve mn D @ me 3 ot @ @ Bg 6 " ¢ @ SS § @ 8 8 B & BoA FP Lf ti} 3.3 rp Soe) ef " a Ch ce wd e a @ 2 G .- M4 o QB 44 + G 43 boy Ss a ced & ws be i B a & ; i 4 ry 4 , a we 4 ¢ : : $3 {3 a3 'p nyt ra 3 +4 rd oy 3 cs rn ae c wd Of vet B QO 4 ~ c 6 3 te 5 am 43 45 a ard us i) aC i &4 C4 "3 se . a a 0 wD i ie bg w 8 a @ a " Che a " 2 ; O cod 13 3 } aw : O tA ws o is @ ° ~ G 2 bo BG fF 2g mw & & mH yy oH GS iy O to Q gm 4 % oe Fe "rf BS a whoa y * a 5 Mo yew t Ds be ~ Um Gh A Bog aa ns a eo 2 » Po a3 er o wn hod O oe) {3 ie: ce o i a a it D ae y Be ved : 4 wo , "ct o a ef ved "4 S v4 a "eh o - @ jg =O Ho Daw "eo lO o £ & gs ty a . apt a Fra] Sas MG 3 wd oO vf 4+ @ wt Rg @ mo arg - § 8 5 Po oy od j B pe gigs eB, ~ & 8 Gof Uv & yo . 5 ne & a. OS OG Ge 7, mo 5 * eo OG 8 y @ 3 2 xed st mn 4 ~ oS 5 #3 a in 44 ae Fy ° SS ord ec G ct ry os mt eo J 3 n a S oD 4 3 ty £3 + " set " = cs "4 ted uy . . é are <i ee x ° * Dod £2, ky re ed q hes th a c ~ a ay wu} , ' i 4 / a 22 ri 4 ok (3 sed he? ri) i iB ee mE O rd Re vo oO 3 tO a 5 8 cS a eS bom Bog Bb g " ES a 8 % y rd = 4 if ag ; € " «© ;
44 Q G a > e wy ons eg » & Si, " a a 3 4 a 44 ce oe 4 v3 : * neh on Ao & ao oO ce ut 5 ve} 3 o a Go rod Sods it a ; a im Bey m © Wom & oe { » 6 © & > Oo PF , 4 8 © gw B G cy me sg a el gD 6 oO _ ma Bo hi ' G in 44 tn BH 44 « ON oi : a4 43 a qa ny hey it wy oo Ad "ed wt ei «6 i a m eed oe D uy ot ao 8 hod Bo oe gS So DP 8 Se @ #4 3 ony ta 4 43 ye bef g Q Be aed ao tm Sea iM ct hg tt td 4 ie 4 G3 eed ts "s 4a E ed a op by re cd @ i {6 S wo " ed "S Me G w ay 4 G orf 4 o @ + i) M 5 3 ny G SS Sted o s Get » wy C be o 4 OG ved i & er f et a » 2 oD o cd to ¥ ser} ¢ io 4H Gy - St ¢ S ww & * mS i $. wt ao G i sy ry oO x a Oo os my OES Gg 4 MB % @ MF a nm Py 54 ene oO 3 a ci tS me Sot & & Cy a it 5 2007 ?
?
QOANoTTI MA No. 2523/2007 connected with G.A.Noa. 1OS1L/1999 ir aa 44 Cc w ht ved oD whet kd wv oa 43 wee} 39 « aaa aD we Were MA ved AS ord od A. a Ad x3 a
i) wee 43
14. ca) 1} aed at 33 a C ved i
3) os yey 43 La 4, oe Cy way zg a rd oF mW Ee ee Os ny ia er] % & een ree Ci oO CH cA cs} 1 a3 a> md wend pon hae de order of tne oh te Ls Sr :
CYL ~ m3 cS @ 'i at b :
Qre et ' Tribunal iy yon Q RS ye G = wo me M2 f 3 m2 ~.
Of ot Ti he ke OA No.l MA No. 2352/2007 connected with O.A.No.LOS1/1999 $y By 4s 4a ty TY By ae cee By Ry TH oe oe QD XS Ag 5 a by Oy ED Do Py mo mk OO we oO Gre © Go & B AX ® sr ba m a © mY rs S SG 8 4 Mort TS CE Gee ty a 4ky sy ® wet 4 oh tL ord | dQ bY 3 Stay MY ia e Om p oi yO tet sy vm pg uy rg YD a Hom Be Og HO Boy Og aoe gg G 1 oy & a 4 3 Oo 2% BO. o & got MY + Ona & "rj 13% "ao si 3 ke gg TA Orgy 4b US sey O bb tts hy. 5 3 9 . i ' u i tee a ' Go 43 :
a Ol op Oo ga ON ' ® Wo 3 es S04 EW ay gs G43 fet oct GY is ke gw 2 reg Tot & ow te oy Oo ey o En oS oD seg ed TON a ry BO Dog @ a Bs 45 Eee LY Oe f > oS GD ort os, 4 Pan 3 3 430 6% en , Uy TA ng a 44 4g ord & nD "es $3 ey D eoa "RG ee 4 Ey i, @ ety % BPEL BTS & CM ay NEG EE MES ee ee ee ee uF 5 CF ce Be y UG , : os f Lote ge amd te . ' it gy A by "4 FG Bl vp. o, @ pa oh © % rh a -e OU Gg me SF mo go o ws oj . we to Beypse = 5a abe ZO Mo oe Ma "4 'ath BaP 8 A SG ve in 3 CMM 4 tr aoe aad -
mw Ome FOE Sok om as Boe @ yf Om FD Kony Sa cy © cr x oo ms Oy by Be og te sy "4 gs ts .. O ms oy Na My £0 5 reg FH a % a o 9 * @ Ke Pp '4 Ay te bi : cE hy SR oO & 2B ou mH 4 oY Dei. | wo ee Bg Bose gar Oo Of 66 B® & a 4 HBO a & ' ba 8 ri ar rotor ES pe "3 > te "s "
4 acy BY Ss { ee om Oe 5 mg Eo. ye ym pe HO Sy Soo So Se owen eS Sistg 2 3 « oO rong ey Ge, og a ne act Ci rope ADS ne OR 63 vag kt 4 oO clo RE 44 'yy oy ee Sg ENG LO oe ca org BO "rs dd EPO tds ot on @ ag Bg ee ey Bn 7g 7 mt i 45 oo My Hy iy ty OO Sg ty 2 $4 wy weg Op Og 2 gp Ba G wm Mo Om a ty cM CR Oe & eo 8 By cs : em OG os * 3 Boon 43 ~ CloCf eg <Q gt ong ry 4.3 es toby seat wy 1S @ m a TG i. ren Sey 4 Oo pe OT RR vee Dg ed ve Dogs "« © tr Q, EY et by mg ox By "ent Cy rey res DME OE ey ey gb Dy, Se Bess a) 3 42M oo 430 Oe so ' or Dy my vb gy Xa 5 bty LY 4 Fog rt mS at ¥ - Ea op a4 ed Pep yg a on 39 My ey 4d wy BO Oe oD Boe Bg : KER os Oat O 3 Oe G 'ot Gort lice By * & : in Boe gy SS ow ee Uy O "rt bd we uy ey 3 3 oh, 3, Ch 43 a too 1G 3 wen od vee £3 M3 rt DY so KY wm ore w 2asdcdenopog oem Fog a Sh Meee RS AESy BLA a S Woh O Gere eo Gh &@ GO we oO ee Eg "~~ © Ss on wom hd "we ty $3, Ot eee ET m™ x 2007 ted i one OA Nod MA No. 2252/2007 eennected with O.R.No. 1091/1999 rt, ma Nae tee Ces x tat A nt x ~ B 14 or 13 ath won
15. ag et h oo is a a 43 co Si % oe Fl, & oe ce ae C3 bf wt O TO he cS $4 43 bd o (3 ah nt @ 42 <s4 3 "eed Ce @ a) sf ee 53 u fe 42 wo isd a ey & Oo & @ & i "ei @ moo ee ES 5 ym tH Oo & a io pp BS a wD Co eed OE a me Q by ord ny ; < 4 i > as oe io * a ® 4 ap as yp 03 % 0 eR ot " } ' = 3 - (} sg OD - gs S O Bo oo FH Sg ® cS Bt ms "4 on ape oa ' y . i :
£ re) 4 ot my rm & i . A ut ed 4 + Oe fel ao 0 @ 2 » wi mm OM gy a no a om xt 4 at 4 rd bot f ' in CG ss o) ' '. " ® LS - te D a ed rd vet Aa * oH he be & hy hag 2 ; 0 Wy fed + G a 1% hag wt Dp oy re qQ uy o a &a os a a Gd o os "4 8 me wy as « wn a . oS moots MO Be gt, a a po ond Ep vel & ™ Oo ° 4 a Pree fey " "9 % * @B feet it goed ref wnt an & a separ a Ch ' $.4 on '3 wy : 3 « Gj " w } 3 z mm OQ wy " at C std ee 12 6 wy Bs cs 2 ~ a i 2D ts ne ¢ 43 5 ay : ng a 43 vee a. $e 5 + G vge4 ' ids ' an mh 1 " o yd a + ti} iy 4 ~ roy - 7" ri) , ees fis as vgad pt 5 - ht ay is ¢ ' me : 3 a ¢ mw 5 se & Boos gg o ¢ @& 6 GO «a C SD 33 a a Bm "4 ' 3 Ms ' aged . O ys . 5 $4 44 ify rot <3 3 a at QB oe bea ri oA As aS os wa } i ord * 2 a ae oo g 28 & ~ SB WM mg : fo QB ft ved es a3 ry ae @ on a na c 4 in ved 3 43 4.
& Ma Ro » a mo" teh et o a 2 ® o " 'g rer apd at " a Le ; ved cy mo > - re $4 o ted 7. 2, 5 ad a th m8 cp. ee . vt OQ 2s " oo aS @ 3 4 gt oe sy 13 oo ad oe 5 + : ; cee ior 4 {3 a o~ fe 3 i i Bw ch we cs g a ie ao . © o 5» © BoP om 8 4" cf OO fe GS © ty ve a ef i ' i ' a mt a3 rot a Qi ° " fe e 4 st aa ih " td at rd Qa ood ae " chs Gs q co ee @ 4 * Ky o x it ; og OU . S 8 Ys a & 'eat '* + 4 ued 8) : Ad ¢ "
=f @ ae) % t4 cy ip bed hy ed a 4 ca fav fae a n BE teh Gt O, fs "3 4 sLYLS 2007 Th «S ty 0 a G ps BD } Q oe Bh @ @ g © e Cc ' "4 G a ee a co rd $4 As OG oO wo 43 $4 7 @ bg a . ey nt oy f.8 a a eid mn g @ ba D et c he b& of oo . Sus i mm GS , Booed wv wy wy oh is) iB Sa ip ed ay rr aa: © iD MM i o pha I XG On we OS Ted as Oo st Cr Ss 3 C 4.3 $33 xt as ses XY Wy wean, MA No.252/2007 connected with O.A.No.1691/1999 ue wey + } vel eae aye ANS A. x 3 4 2 ont oS AN 3 chy wer oes 43 epee wD red pean ¥ Y a <3 arcs nm "rye i. BRS Eo oN ey Ka ~ panes mee ee tN ws kK 6 *.
¥ PX e tars "
lad we Seda x Ne + Le syed ¢ ay im wed MOEN * MS sf th O,A.No.1091/1999 1/290 s oe OANat MA No. 2582/2007 connected w:
16m ee a a w @ ha oS qe ma ap w G Ba As 25 (3 & «mt 03 a w rp 4 arf AS md { 3 i ba e re z 2 - pa « ae wed ' B « ; ; " ee ee ee ee ; 7 a4 wa . m MA 3 2 w . ; . hed TH eM UW OW Db om a ft od ts fe ES ca Png O '5 es 54 oe orf id Dp a = OU OG Oo w G O m4 Oh el ay a @ oS " bs $e AE et ed ord edit OF Uh ah ke od so vied Sa a 6 s4 on rote be 43 WD wd i the 43 i 4 . i ke wo 9 7) y ON OB, ort oF i Sh, , ts x rapt c ad 4 we i 8 Boe Or odo k ~ Bu 4 SG eB @ & & , & £6 # o Ge WO Eo Oe yon 48 ws od mR ® |p "
a ra 4d sal "a B od m jut a th xed 3 " rot i oO oy a 4 ot 4 * os oe tg AE ne! ped =, at . i BD wa BOP Os Cag rt BR Bg re BG ae sehr Soe og 6 eA ht a) 4 - 4 e us it " a vet 4 UD " aor ved 4 a ig a : bet G RB Ad ved ag QU © by o cy, . m @ mo} a en 3 vet Ch wy Os oa ® Og a te i "rt et ved 8 os mn D yor} Q ' Br od a) eed oo Sk - ved 4 wo faa $4 4a , "st LD is % asd ee 2) Q om 5 e428 fe Sd © o : oy i "8 @ o Wg OD +t ~ gs ; we & @ so co Fw on Bs % ord , oo o 4g ot m 2 e-t ee * a Dh Aa be 4 oS ry i '4 ot un woo as a Wt be G, aw ues 4 a 5 can e wa wy "4 p © ©, en Qt : M4 Ce reed sy oy what 4 a ua ahd AS rf ae, ea Sa % / "eh £2 a4 oe a oHe 7 we "rf (5 3 43 rm; 5d bs Go rp S my 23 ad fh Ty ' 4 3 bo {H 6 5 6 tH : tt wg OS ae 3 im ey A - % g o ~ QO 9 o "a 9 gag sin @ -g age Gf x og oS 8 FG " Oo 6a BS OG aoeo & Bf GB wp @ Bf ss * > x BE 2 in . ho tal 43 x i 3 SO my ad oy" 4 fey oe ved vet fe od bye ; bel oy. te A , bd rot OF ery of iH BD a mg "5 5 Wa mo 0, & ta) o iy a) " - 7 tt © 4 ~ z x Ft t ° aS at Oo a . a ~ rm > cc > a ored a j i Q ' 4 > of we 5 43 C H BY te Cy a " vcd - ca a ev ra Fa Q 4 B Ge, Bow "eto gy UB as © § & % o & es gs eh Od ee ayy Dh a %» ae m OD & Me 's me KS Rey m @ 5 3 Pa ry Bs ka a " Hm i" } - {3 fe Rt oO a oe os " 1 oe gs Et gs in os > 8 eed . ad a et. 4 a Oo 9 uw 4 sed et 2 2 UGB wy OB wh BA eh pod 43 UE set it Oo 4s aera! ry oe uu us Se, 4 one oo m4 $a, ord g Rt TAO a~ Ip a oO ot 3 3 rt 3 Dat 4 Ca ca so OG OR Samed mom G Geir O@ Oe HH * by &, oe #8 © G ~Ow adi Be oy ao Be w B ~ & w os ge B & &§ wd : ' .
ef EE med OU 2 @ Ba) u mo sy wd ie ees ny 3 at wl ; srt f io) 33 wt 43 w 44 pe ® Ds 3 . ead Be Soa G 43 oe) iy y wo a @ G hy oO oe tH a tk 5 rt aed x ioe ty g M Oo i G OA No.7 /2007 MA No. 252/2007 comnectad with O.R.No. L091 /1999
-
~ on * 2 eek ' ve. 2 ioe 4 O32 contrary to relevant extant the Rules~-i993 and also x mem, i ¥ 2 £ me ete tt & 5 oe law settled on the subject. He urther piaces reliance on the judgment of thse Hen'bie Andhra Pradesh High Court in case of General Manger, South Central Railway, A. P. v. Shaik Abdul Khader, 2004 (2) in WR No. 10897/2Z001 dated 23.06.2003, para-~S i > cone into to which a reference he as been made by the Tribunal. Para~2Z0 of the Master Circular No. 54 iays down;
"20. Counting of the period of servire of casual labour For pensicnary benefits:
Haif of the period of service of a casual labour (elther than casual labour amployed Crt Projects} after attainment of temporary stabus on completion of 120 days "continuous Service if it is followed by absorption in service as rceguiar railway amployee, Lanary benefits. m il-i- 198i, the so been axtended casual * t hat x $y ry La O $2 dat
4.
, Reference has been made to another extract o rra~ZO05 of Indian Railway Establishment Manual, OQlume-TE. Sub- para-l of para 2005(a} lays down;
f O07 a i I i ae OA Nol MA No, 252/2007 connected with G.A.No.1091/1999 78 Co By Hd Set ma ow Sow eugarooee eee oO 2 oO 8 op sb cos ants eG OD D sed O13 HO Goat mM oS at © wa TS A od NE OW my SH OM OW ob Mm OO Be tnt © Om, 2 Ge, Bo wv S OH Sy oO OR gag Gl og © & Oa rd & Be wh 4 HE 4 WY oy, OO E OO WW OU YP Ow it " Gra oC LD oh md SB Oe Ga Bot o aoe GO OD, Gog & wow OU Do gy BO OO "oo fg fi, MS BP Sy AOE Be OG 73 oy Ue 4 2 oh 4a @ HO ip 8 @ Yoh OP4 ver oi = co iL Ne pa aot toy Gg . 1 ocd Q py a ee et» 2 hig 4 4 3 eg rk gy ie oe # tow a 9 DOM es oy Gh wort oe mE oo & MnO 2 6 wi OB a Met 9 ret 1D nt be je $d 8 sg om @ wt a " © ih"
ay eo Om aA ge = 4 "peau Boa a PO eo Hon ov wor hs Ser as Ge eae x Sam og @ Sy Bt "a 5 OF OY yn & B, Odiag Qo CO Bae 2G i Oo GO wo HO gw 6 BY RU 2 lO, Get fe ou eB Bog & oe Ly ag 8 ot ES yg A SEE ogy Oe TG 7 ww 4 oa my a sp oO Sa vt U3 Oo * fey we ti od ow Q aa WD oS 1 4 reek gy YY 4 " © ved ry Uy (a 5 8 GS ha eed yf o we tn A % , Mt, wt a hay if _ , wae OA ft Pa Bg | Sg gu ged, Mog Gy Bg rm CE r ad tp red Oy teh eet Ae £m a fed ky O 4s 44 m oc - a YY we i Ea ry OS b Big By) Pog eo, ag ¥ oS a 3 HE paef ied ane mB 14 BM GT Hg "ch 4 "4 © md On ety, $2 i ne be Me yg pt hd my bs +4 z is) it on a B Cho bs Pt te "rf ioe ah rio nm oS Do a =
3 QO 4B 4 ws Qe Pee, Ga af aoa. 8), B8so° 8 S85 90 x red De ae Ae 4 fe (i 5 phd 7S TE 3 1 ' BOG MH NO 6A mo FOR" BEN Gray a yD ced "StS $4 eed ot Uh omg Wd Be 44 4 :
peri ip a be OG O 4s rt Gm ort
4) WS OG ba Ch ves OS set e 3S = .
* 3 x hh $3
-
ee wm OD Cy te 44 ib G
- od $2 Pp et e in @ s4 @} B33 Oa Coe Bo ow Ou eb OG gle ce BB gy 8 og sf @ Gt @ G@ Gy LF Ged th Ori tO OF hoy OG ob Oe oe Oy be mh ow hy Be OO So O tp an eH Cow Be A oy 3 oe OA No.l 71/208 MA No. 252/2007 connected with O.A.No. 1091/1999 ha @ wy non ce) ae bel G "4 ; % ' . 4s mH Od wom GO tt . @ ® Li 4a ug mus tm fF o4e ta be oa ft Rd BO Oo OH ci rt eA es OB OO ow ag oO @ mC Oo Ww 2 & bt Td Y GU oo a id HAO Cav a od ow HOS 8 2G eee Leu es" Oe Weert ha opEes ae ge aS 2B oan = ,a ona 4G gy @ oo 0, ort a Qo Cu gw Gg »¥ bt BE gy oy Rte yw eteng @ Ge 33 Bs ng OM we Oe a 6 . »~g Oe Ga Gyn OUG oa % io o ea 3 (i Ot OU x wo sort phord rt f V4 4 . a * ved * v em HT a od Opp 81 a bd Mog oH PO 4 "2p a Bo by hm & O fs GS fon si Q BOA - oe ny Meg rd og ty ord ret te 44 WU em ong HA 5 a 15 Oot 5 yD : ao Od Sm Be Gon i, I O Dou rel cP et Oot gy re) oy 3 ao ro ms £ " 4, * ot ree " : . wt ts 5 O es Ba y ch tn i fog Uf O wy 1 Oo oH a e 4 j Let a ® o£ HG ® of ofp Pe (EB part 8 4 ay ord ge rae eh ge a YF a3 wrt ea 1 ER od O wy a di o x co gy ay Fe > ye hook, f Hoim & 4, 8 on cf
a) 4 ord a fat 4s *D 73 ba m ef 8 43 ried 5 oe ft ved 3 c og a yg Bat & @ "1 Gg Bog i 43 a © @ vA 3 fr 2 z :
. uy it "oo 4 $3 @ Ba . 2 ey a 4 Do ing oO 3 "3 o a Bw we oe @ ot oY 4 = et a wo fy nd © Gone EY oR Ao ow veg MS + ou Boag & a AO ey 3 mm ® mG cag! as Woy § Ct Ba EB ge OG om Be | UB ee 5 BBO". ots Gor md th wg wd oD Se Soe fy, oO 43 =e wo Ye gr 4a bey an Ch P94 wi NIM a to Sede a x4 " nS "eps 6 rp QD we 8 a} 4 5 ay Be as ft BA mH we pt eM Oe eR BN Ey rf O opp pe OM 4 3 Se eed TY AD M4 ra 2 Oo & GO Ow vt > ' Te wo © wu cp o<4 be th @ Py CH a mE Gk, 5 v a rt che a 44 spd Cl 4b » ' os * wed sat O nS AG sec ac ma 2 Saag Si y oR ao 58°? 9p yess n ° n@; on KS hed gt % os A Aa hb bed j & e) . ' 4 cS ra 3 a ed »§ PE ae Dasa g4m>P Cog GOSBD He 8 + + DEY ow w G6 & we Ou ge WY 8 og pom Oo ot 5 cage UO Oe oO ee uy MY & OS et ag .
Word of Gt be " Ly O «5 ef GE bea AS OC) eed ard CRA ert ord eed * * iB Ad ved ub CY oO pe Df fe OR Bet a on ie et Fm O te & & DP ba ma OP Oo 9 OO 4 Gy Se GR 4 WP 4 AS RH D Mord Ce Ch bt Gi «a & QB OFF DD he Oe en POD HM eH es > Oe OD Oa Ht ew eee Oooo OD Ga Fa eo Oe OM OM OS Bet Oo ™ i ue OU bp Go go et MM DP aM et sr MP ee a pp ft Wed me Ww ow fe BO @ HU OG C3 a * ed mH as wl .
OA No ATL 2007 MA No. 252/2007 connected with O.A.No.1091/1999 « g zg zg z zg zg zg zg z zg zg zg z z so ad o> é Union of uy Cc ; ; . 5 ' 4 we ge ay wii 3 Pei TG TS ye bs Gomi + OW Gu eu Gam Qa tee aed 8 Oe Ue e m "2 8 OG b oo cd 3 CG AO Pee On ee a aes {7} in i ka te 2 4g) fh oct Gj Cs TS Le 4d > ai £3 @ S43 ort ge 1G Et } 4 hot RP WD oS SS OW Mort a & 2 HOG 4. G . m wb ® G : Gj G wy 2 Ow Gh MoM is, Gon wee ia ae oe ge Q - uy ryt q ; ig) ae dd G a o wo Oy he a ah " Ps Go ob Mk GH GB OO Bw seh OM a " 0 Ou, 9 6 OG Bo + 42 ag 4 e vd wd ogy OB oO ha © gg ce ha aH @ oy @ 4 @ CC e+e gp mt G MH 4 ad se i, 43 @ se @ bog i ®B y ved aod ct beat 4 2 sped o dt Fad ts hes a sty 5 Gh ch rte ' " OG 3 Gag AEDES x Me gi OB ot Boa Be g a oe Ww th fe ye os BO Mig 4 2 f-4 cn i oD es Ee 3 3 ei ' a é Hoe s a gS verd C bet 3 4d hd ey ; wd 6S . 3 ed (5 my Oo ' a a Mi ; OM op 3 , Oy we EU ey Bo, 4 @ gy di te UF oy ha ot hor i * bog FOO ee ved oy AE em & OT oped BR gy @ woo Su So ay '4 a 4 rot obey bd 43 Choe. " set 1 Be 2S "S bE DB pa us 46 8 le Sw gy Hes etka Boe og pad "ed Go riod @ | 5 be Met i By ed {3 hd Le w S of Ms Swe » & poy 8 a8 :
$e . wry Nee ey fe 4 hy ~S . A ryt in 4 4 Ly be os rt tis tt, ot A es ie ey RS te Tare a Ny oo Bb OO) +s vw g o Bg SG os or ¢
3 WW "Gt vet "t wy tO @ ry ge :
oon Xr & nr es a we XL c re Fk a zr £ q ce te OO 3 a CS ba Se gh i 9, hes ved 4d ogy ct i 3 "3 ae' aga & g@ ou Fa By w Oy oe 5 a} ard GR gee 8D Ay my Cg? (i. gr OS Ga a or ' ad" piliaw © my b oo © ge Wes Be GO so do 8B op On oropes SRap 4As cof: GO ak Gabi Drt rh Se gE ehoed UE QLlrecte g sy Ae XL & oY Shyam Pvare Yadav and Ors.3
£ Qn Q a CUS & OerLio) af ab) rt te bf OTS wD Ort eM OD w eto oO 4 OD Oy, AE 4 O Word ord DP GO ord WO WG A bp OF UF cl ued Keel SO OHO WW HO G 1 +f He ete ow Sf 0 MO bs eS Ow we dtort £2 OO i Tem MW Re a om OG Oy iy :
eed be Ty me AS on Nee ts E q IR OA No.171/2007 MA No. 252/2007 x 1eokbed w O.A.No. 1091/1999 + a OT (8 ved £G a
20.
sr rl @ a at, RA AK, an an £0 eferred >"
alsp 04 eed Pitchamani ¥es.
¥.
Ajias ¥.
Sy = a.2
SS 3 its) ty Li Union AAT L Pitehar the air ReaE wi of India and Aner.
undexri-
S as 5 cot ead ved 4 Bs ed es 4 a ved Q3 aed 3 «yt 8 Pt fed z ae aed 3 ay an ' 1 Serv ae Of ae Co cee me ty a < Le Serv wu a} @ ed > 4} 4 at OF neg 2 ED gq apd a ug OF ered rt oi gf os ot Dh dy Wy GO gy 5 xf 5 oO, dt hy og Oy on $4 nm © Sj o Ou ma fed $3 44 rt a a4 oe w w My wd 4 M4 woe * 1 eo 9 ¢ hs rnd poe a pearing & » a ng of vet © ae th SS nt a Bi u @ 3 33 aq 43 "4 bf ao 3 ny gd OAS.
cm a esal % bad itt o ® a 43 7 #8 Le ts, Q a ee Wy Hh Ry oy y, sa nore a a fa wh 4 oy 4a "Py 1 ey 3 ay 22 Saat Saw 3 No. & G tnt eg ® a sf z fry ra 5 4 rH o> sp s OA No.171/2007 MA No.252/2007 connected with O.A.Noa, LOST /1955 of HO 8 Og OY c raed vd are ry od a ree ig Se GABE SARS cna oy a ag : a 4.3 AS > a 3 G sic a Gra G sO om 2 - At xy 43 hi AP toe iy a & Se ey bt GP Ys mY Feat Sh hp RS Be Uy a iB es me DE ry 4 q © = " it 8 Oa uy 'bet "ed he s 2 mG BE ag 4 oe Sok Iss hy a AQ gn 4 a % Ft gy Ee a Me ed ei - oe ih " 3 3 oe thy i " & 2 e 2 wy G ~ S 2 Be BG & qe ey» © "1 os 9) 4 ne 4 4 3 {3 poi Sh St os : a i a 5 3 ot Wy Got MS G na m te oy et ox mo thkace HO Ba, Sa et) tty Cy ey 3 My Cy re ced BS 4 4 9 sey US o ie ma ay IS & 43 ; a a i Ce ms " 2 m4 ty SM Boehm z a aa. my & BB MR y Hh uF ', oye a} + red +54 My So ey 4 oe <3 ie mS as Ry ey te iy @ $y 3 43% 3X OS uy Wha HE og © Ow x ho mE SB 8 ge i £3 $3 De me G a $4 ho qe c > ba gy oe re 3 cs ee) eA ry by om fs c Toa GB 4B on sed q@ © es te EY Cpe, TF My BY ted ey womny ted 3 "5 o mw SOEs 4a oy gy mi tS eT or ne Ky 4 4G a ce Ry gis ga bong mae bp © yA Ad Md | ge o AY A ee ee ots me 8 "og oy 4 e288 Be BOS Gy £5 ME oF OG Sy Peng an Ae hee ted ON taf teed oye of -f OG Ge" + @ mq Bay ry UO G@ O& b » te omy hay OY gy Gr RG 'aio @ tet La ed OE Ok os 4s G ep FH mz N UY fH MS SW he @ ty Se Mi Gr Go o ie OB Wh 4d He + £5 hy OO 4b 42 Ch hp ba hy an "F4 wa Bos oS wm Oe Ky ee fo © & ty, Be OA No. L/2007 MA No.252/2007 connected with O.B.No. LOSL/1995 With iddiieeededeeeeeeee, fy cr Gy Ease 4 YD oh, fb Wy Mm Oo YG OD mw me Bri COM GY ES O& O hy GOO 8 2 Ew Gh Sa 43 TF a UT +e ne Q@ Ya 43 aa ioe ted ord ced Mg ey wo tO Ort ay Sh or ar D a mw Oo 0 bE OR dd B 4D % a Mw 3 4 Ok, are ne % ke ¢ 1 iL % @ 43 ih a g cy es i iH AQ mS Ca try oe Lay, 43 2 3 S or Ss Sb £3 QE Gy VY Sy By Qa oe GD se ig 0 ba G & & iy te Box oy Soe BT G py isp, Sy Bo Oo cs i G wo by @ @ EB g ao TS a, me Bg Mo fe © my ay 6 ow 8 a wy <3 3) c3 m iy 3 "AE % & a 4g Tt ce ag @ ik . 6 Bop ky iy 43 © g 43 cm EE at ae boo ae ge Uh ong Bs 4 73 by Oy s oo 82 29 So B 7 eg &" g © aM yw Bw Oo 6 be ego "Hh Bt G BB 8S UA OM Gg Ba f ® ~ Oy DY R™ gos 9 eRe eg Oe Bagi Be Bm © to os BB Gy A og BO
--~ ORG DG Qe 6. OS , a ep Bo G8 OS Hom a og a we BY gy ma 58 Pe & GU O Pet He oI ge Ong ty foe gc Peon hg MR % wy gee 2 yy Ts egy Pe Ogos eH eS G5 GU & "OF mak ce m Mg BE wig St Boy Hae ROBE Oo So fe ow BB ge omy aq 3 e gy s . sree gy hee ng Wo gy gy © wus * ie ote Q, sap % i ae Boe oO, i 5 9 0) OU ' oR i fg 8 ea ce by in ¥. 4 eat ad 3S G _ 43 e os Wag wD Oy €. ms moe Chg ay TY Be kG Ort oH nag 3 OD ° Bod b u, OP» 22 8g "Sei OC ah oan kyu Ui Bo ag 2
- Bs? gee rp A A hy . ogy a ay sep) 4 a - 4 a a fig Het ee SE a i Pa, ow BO 4 Pe mS 4 m % oy a A gy Meg td mm i a Cho i n aH oo ta 43 mt o md Ym %, 1S ey rep 3 ma S wy my th, 1 C3 og 6 Cy 0% i f os eS GH Bag Hee BOO , 62 oR QAO of wo Zi By woe eg SBS 8 8 yg, Be BS 'Dae Bae By "aM wm 2 EY py . a be by , 7 1 ¢ ms wan OOS is, Yom Ag Bic, 2 try | ® 2 ee St gD m4 Dy "amt yy te © O 2 o wa PM eG ty % yy oo He ~ Hae on Tw a n 3 veg 4 4 2 TL, eb 4 fol Ooas ae eo 43 43 oy epg BS st PB Ow o + st 7) Ge ts by ge FEM ea neg TS ogy On Thy be ~ . ay oF ow on 5) Sy gy Ry os Gp M im te a go a OR veg dd en Oa, s », G28 Oo Br ty Bo eo ' fort ong Ba 2 Go sD rm) a ga Gy eg bs ay © Lr gy enon ta Boy Ma eeg mE Gord te Uy o 'EM ge og Sh og OS fay Dp 9 Oy aa ug Boge OY ey m Oh OSS I gt ea 12 0 tT | Oo Soa a a a 3 are hi gg ony wo we gy "eq moor 0 0 4,0, 9 Ga 8 PO, ® we @ oy Bog ae 2G gw & Od 3 eo Po MD orgs HH Ow A tp DB og OO! og Ss $2 OG SB a B B45 Co vy Th, @ "hh veh ted "og OR YG OE GO er Gre A ct Sb pa CTE Oh Ch ® DS yp Bk th 4 mM G a HG Wt @ Maw Wo we Os OD a Dr i My in S 4 By WD by me Om @ G&G GAO Oe OO Om sy O93 Gb O07 O BM EON mo Ono oo be oe "ATE Bs Fe cet Hf ed Om mo GoM ee IN ey oe OF Ae Oy ee a i mR & eo BE oe he GO, OA No.l T1/2007 MA No. 2252/2007 connected with O.A.No. 1091/1999 cAS M6 mH 4 om) We Eo fA bey a) 4a mS ff Sp cep 2 Oo 2 ty ty 40 Gk os, 4d "ed a ce by SCE ise wre OY ved ot ty om Ha ky &} x2 Ss, of 'a 6 sed xf ra. Mea i AX RS ee 2 Boy 4 aaa oo wy Og BA 4, @ @. ay cel a © Lie ted Os reg tee Cy BO ta a Rs bes co &§ 3 iy i Oe Gay % Hoong fo 4d © o & ty 4 EY oes i> c 4 a 4a veg ey bet Cy Bey 3 ay red es 4 4 by ba TS thay @ GOH 4 & Wy ge # came 4 fF sy Oo ip ® ws rd ray , & @ % @ , B oy 3 Wows oa) Bo. ' PO ay ry * ee oS ty, 7 ' * on / we 4 cE ty & ¥ qj oO ay Pr ons 3.6 Wg 3 mt Bos g 9 A ds 4 8 A SS oS Gu GU Aa ty pl My We BOD gy! . 4 Ad hd & 1 tee Oo 43 > kf tran ' i} oy PS oe (3 Noe ted 2 oh Oe Shay ; a 0 ge 8 wo UF "y ved hy we hd tS ey ht AS moO a, Gy $3 Ne EL and Hs ns a € 3 é oe Gy , a OE eg C Bo QB 2 a ° a 8 43 C Qn tt ie Oo se _ 4 Sm 4 OE is i or w i tS 5 Re) mF SE uw Bo ir gs iy oe LD i na ty} FS 04 hb 4 ong ; red a r Ay rope » ys nN % ms Pe +a - 3 ped hat tu ra "rd ° 0 beg . es ty eg ha * fy Ry 4 @ te Sy mn ESky on re ih G ee oS "A Ory Bots i 0 & "
2 13 te fy vee oC aa , mad Cy TY ee Gy 4s 4 ky Aad gly ©, Oo hy ret Py "eh 43 :
iy Uy Xs k cs ar 4 iy CY SB, EX ted By @ BD Meg Cy veg ee SY mt ME LP NY 3 my OF £3 net ced ET Qs ay oo.
ces tc tr toed +t et dee WOLLLL LUT UUTTTLULTTOTOOOTUUTLLLTOLOLULLLTLTOOEEEL, v~ oe oO 2993 © bs, F fm Ua he Q kgs UE OTS m4 @ ct ® Tiny 8 rt QD by GG 4a A ot Ome: aoogs a hy S58 Cosa eee e ee Qu WO 4a) Bo tw D od ~ an fy 4a 4 mike A 4 ye af te et ng Oh Ot me fe - ay ed ay iy Sy mB Ya Gord as 3 8 OSS OBO BR S 5 gi BO "4 Ny th ky MS OBE ord 43 SBS SS oo toes us
- NM g re fg! C3 mq ny Oe sg tee hdl im) @ + bs OV KY ch % " Ad we ts Bet te "ge Fa. G4 0 tm 4 " '4 a "to g 6k 3 pe Gus oy rd wD Gs oy 7 bo 06 2 a & & ge y co wy oo. 5 3 a © $3 8 mr rs uy Th % "ed ¥; & of 5 r 4 @ wy . BA 83 hd ' ' . ah mo ea
3 5 ea 8 ae fe an oh . 4 ad 4 + Fy 9 om cs) a ce " a ® & se oe gh 8sE 52ahy Sty SEAS a as S 3 Oo 3 ao a DO - 3? g oy m 8. Ba i q pf ay u v fy Oa 3 n 3 £4 @ et Gh ony a Pes = 5, © fi ay oe a "ed EP ep 1 og eo om 2 8 Bees sg one Besesgss ses :
; tg " tho Oe yo 3 ee yong Yt é 23 4d Pe 8 my toc Hp RQ wy, owt 5 ge 9 & gy PU S ma Xt g Sg Ry by g a 4 5 . i veg hd 4 ES 3 i t OG ms ty ue eg yg rf Co % Boge ba Oy "4 t 3 i rg OD mR my Eh Mog GMa rs 4 4 2 oo cy OH) Bok Cp Pe aw, PB BS a mt we 3 o * Soa, . . ot 63, ry ap Beg o Oat GW wow rs Y Jet ol hb moo veg GD wy op B SPO Rm 7 9 Gas 42 a be 4 Ss mw %8g "28 4 He, 88 8 Bh oy ea gaa 3 6 Q ep sign & » 2 ao geR Ngee won. 2 Ga ie ny + a be By qd 3 Oo ty m4 fey b fay Ge a tf cr hy Ct s a 4 te Ry org OF OW 7 we ms OB AB GO tr sey St ' ay NM " 2 Bor] ' bos OO! OG TF me AN . 6 fs 43 See OR "ef x 3 3 ard, ay oh 8 » & i iy YY in ot 43 Bay US ow Wf Oo 2 9) & te * ag cM Qo Ry sm Oy tf gS a3) . yd We ty Te UE t "3 4 my 43 we iS ES 3 x as 8 6 v5 ie 2 ¢ Wy 05 ff se 44 by ok a 43 try tog . co) ; "9 3 ay C3 Sp oed CF ted a ith! doh . th sen} 4 Shove RS 163) Nye - ts 4 2 a Wy ef OD $43 TF 45 OF 4a @ ro) i hy na ' eof sted ag i gc ry i 6 ¥: re foe 4 ve ' EQ te . oe! 2 inf Fe rd " » ba a Ee. on he % e "4 food % a ss a ce 4 a he 6 a ted ae ~ te mi yok & & ' wR S Ke a a heeded Wh OO Gea a G7 Bom Og 4 ORG A ep te wD q kis ian % eat peg Se ort od tt me gy by 4 . w i @ . | "et iS tel is 43 ed Ae mom, Mm Mob 44 Eo WA cm © a PL AQ OL Mo} ka ga os (ome ee ay ss or ay OG Ow OO Oo Ooo OOM & aw bio, go BG 6 ey es 4) ® g PON F HOG OURO ee Owe GQ gm oy Oo Coe gle & sot be 'at a ° bi i a el com o ab ED iy 9 ;
ae OL, 0 Oh 4a ® fr oe 4 ce ood & SEO O GN ED Om bt © My we oe "ed SM im DG HUA 22 Go be ey G BY a * OA No.7 1/2007 MA No. 252/2007 connectad w O.A.No. 1091/1999 ith 8 43 "rd 8 Gs $3 o th Are: 4 +3 oT 23 mS 2 > Ong iy om ny od ay .s
8) A ny 43 at rd a mS A od 4 SY 4s . re} a oe whe 43:
£4 s.
T, o 44
5) oy g Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z OA Nod 71/2007 MA No.252/2007 connected with O.A.No. LO9L/19ss IP BU OH Qa WY oh om w Cy Mom Nae NB te my OD En D ® + sO 6 o So ct 4 AL mp 5 Ny Bg 1 oy OF Gy ort ot RE a Pot a cy o 3 OS ° ic A a me a 3 = on ht "of ay oT 43 0% 45 sed Uy veep ted od + te Uy @ a w £3 2 eo 4a 8 rg Fe Sitet da oR ee TS , ®t tH WM ty Oo CS gy oG HAE YS & mo oY ne oy DS GoM Q fey oe OTH A OD g a 6 oS SO 28 5 "4 wm ¢ c kh weed CG 4k a. OF me) ty A og N SS aw Be eG me Ge ge" am Go MOS hi SQ, me & wb ug fe fy tA Ms ay. b " th aoe ae a Abe & 4 36 8A go M tr go Gu 2 qo ® my 8 OO Dre SR Gn, ay DG 3 wy or hy OM pap bet REE be gw poy EE % wy sy tA PH a OU ved in ES oo fs aa w @ & Meng Uh AE GO Oca & 3 i a fy Ry mE he, - a * hy Yo ts wpnh Ld Bre i 1 & % % 9 Bed tee fd i Po Be HB - OE tg Se Cs 1 43 3 hogs rho My et rd Pe ty go> 2 MM ae ry Ey s & % ois 4 Os ao, 2 2 @ a eS % gk BOS hoe Bou yg @ TD Boy ma my g HB D % . a @ ge Be gy mp 8&3 tak gsi C fy oe thy ; oy bey ¢ ef 3 my od tree AEE Sa gw oF Oo a wa D by B mt ky ee Gog Boa SG % aR da Ry omg Re nt og Gy > $3 ty B88 E88 C88 SEe ou ehh og Shag ane B ky tang y P . ge Oy MN @ © GB 'io ot a oS i ma tay Ody BD nF ay G&G yO & 43 OG HO Gy fay g 2 Gas ha P&S 6 fe a bie Go 8 im som eg SB gp hwo yu Bo 7 SG ° Rm gy Uy ey ard ea mh tom my ae ad XS Tt oo r A oN @ Soap ce cee YY @ ory a 0S Mon ey Fy Uy te uy hy tor tiem Be ag 7 Boe no rh 2 ts td Mo O x we 5 Woon G , . seat tn : i at WD 43 oe Feng Ps om we at 4 me inn . koa 4 We op a £3 % ay » Y 4d io Yay 45 HS Haetes Pf #u SSgad., 8 4 a hs nC 'B.S i SD Oo Og Gm S o Po. ay BOD Gh py my tS omy. Dy Oo 4a a set Dy re ty G3 Mog go 8 ON gs gH om ® 43 ® Moi DM SG ee ct ED Oy at ty @ Be 13 a aa TE By og CR os ry ¥ Cy mm tA Re Sy EN "eg OD 4 ot Ss, 1 o, rent ma AR Sh at fot gs 4 "OU ie) By m4 ° Go OO 43 SH 0 @ ge OS th fh OG my as ety "4 io Om & Gor ; ty SSG i te a Ss i ky Ba "Spor ey m4 rey BS 8% Ob Gg Pa GO By og an 2 eng 8 Gays By ay Bos OQ oe Re lo Fla ew ks @ mBsSoR: Ca kw a Geyer ay Gg HR zs OB 29 re oe 2&8 Gonk by gh meg yey Oo 6 ™ woe oS ea Of
3 C4 ty mp ore Shy - RS Oe & 6%, OOS .
MM 45 ty be Gb ik = 'af "s ved DY Ry ACE Se \ ry Word Mm £3 0 3 CoM Oh oO SP at oO wm my ay eng cod "t t
20) Q é nee OA Nod MA No. 252/2007.
connected with O.A.No.1091/1999 Q ih % iS £2, reed teveg * S © 4d t no e ISN Po & ed se < oD mS > reed ai.
oD oS Ors.
Kumar & Rakesh Ve.
ne $C 274, India and Ors _ ££ ion of aris Tete ak ¢ fast urid 2017 SCC Onl g B ed Q me ae t.
~ Ra ved aed 0 3 y yet {4 "12.
the on on of India and * IE & ?
Aah oo ess; ben, =e uae a MR, LOS rp » ty Anandrao Shankarras.
an We ~e, £3
-
Ys.
Sr
a) Myr ce orc st Nag ¢ 4 ANZ,
22. i ek LS adamant Ay 2 ¥ GA No 172007 MA No. 252/2007 connected with O.A.No. 1091/1999 Art cd far a ed a Gh ae oy f OB bed @ sy vo ot hace Orcs' Nene uddan j ea lex x¢ x ar oa OF OP ip im wh ON OS Cb 1G CoS Ot et TE eed eto cdod Te 1 b> cca] Me 8 oh ted oa we } i ct ' 11 tee wi gy GO wg Mt OG 4 i ko GO Om g Ler = a aa hae ohtt gS wa @ a aa 44 ca + os bed oy Ad £9 MES x :
3i aed X = hal t A. B = of ioe we * te mee ti % rl mn Aa he CS ert Bh Ae rat eed a an rp vot hy ae oy ko bet 4 is beg a Ged on 4 44 % a, % oO Q ant he mm wi re 2 ig fo fa bee wy te Sad as bef A ae SSTe ac os z P:
a vee} w aps pe Say wee} in tet yp tf re pw ah Boga RO po Sod et rm Sm "Oo fof .
: y mt 4 ER DM et G th ba o Ort OS byw @ o . OY gO m ha 7 @) OD op od - 4 Ne has re 4 4 rr cS ee a 1 oA OO et fe oct dom ut ge 4 cg et . . a00" BS Oe bod a ae" GREGOR SS OG BOSSES ARCA ROLLE " Ao ; ra aD Doo Prd Om & it aan VS Dt os 5 of es SRS ay kid a OBR Ama Ee woe Ba ae saekn ks = aos G * 'a we HE ' coe pad Ee a6 a en O . aw foot Pee, 8 ge dg 5 4 eo iB MM on 8 8 " 4 he pm wo Oa gay 88 wef WBE od 3 o i j ie Oo Cpe eub Sa a Oo O-d go OD a oy oA oe 8 mB oH gaa a 8 a oy gpk ag sy Ges ea hs why © od cH ° ra) ~~ ce 4 y a : Ch, Ans Be ea reed : 5 2 Bag B w , PO ofS & BS aa Bo Boy agord y a a "3 a ch ea a i Ty @ So , 4 we SER OD + & e OF ae hE pep cy ot + 8 Eg Bee Bee a 7 a it i, am A ~ ay gb ort am be ned a mG tog & oa & POH pe toy ES ZS 3 pe 8 Bird on m cB A ;
. . £3 = f "er i? een MA OD oR 4.2 w sc At hy ow ne 3 Se . Woys oo Me og O ets we 43 wt gy ye Re t heb fx) Ad seed i & - oh Ay i mg a 5 ts G eo Yel gt SH ed & y md 4 ogy MG WF © a, Dy TO Oh wet ra 8 a o @ wy B need vc rd foe dd 3 bs a wy 5 "e god Mo ® n LS > © ao. Bo Gay O FF eo # 9 us BA po © Cg a 2 oq Oh Am a ey a amm @ = i ooo de 6a 7 2 nd Gm OO G Rd Sat aung "se of a & a in ort 8 a aye OU MO mM oy Gy OF " it oad ord « a4 4 1 toy n ao ot OG & Cc cot os vt 4 ao ® oe ay 54 oe " 4D 2 y eg vo 5 "A . S ~ e & * GQ e f : - G a 4 ey ed ey gy og wy we Me os ° <4 go ad a c U4 by @ iv 4 aw GS oN ay 4 G 4 Ep Boe 43 a = yy Ch, 'et i3 a GoM BO Oo ® 5, & Ram MUR wg mig Ho, MM apd SH TS ae % 2 w 4s ond w@ QR on 4a @ mm 4) wy 6 % OM Mes GS SD 4 Bek ew Bo B® BS OU Gao Da ut $4 ee ao w ; wboard ved 4d bd Sh 6 2-0 3 Qu ao Se Be Of aa Om 4a wo 2 Bd Ue Up be @D M4 4D flo-rd VY a O-4 Lo ud onl Ee aed ; Lode 4 + ved A 2 gt a yo 2 y £ £ "4 ¢ rh te Oa DB 6 LOGE SOD eH A iA OAD © ht 0 G on Get G OL Go GF SC ooo Ob DE aa Hn Ae Cw Be we og a a mB GP OF wo " BUSS BRERA R ROTO A BBIS OES AOS 8S POOPMD OM OoAaaD ee as Setecas ms BOO OA No.t71/2007 MA No.252/2007 qonmnected with O.A,No.1091/1899 sf QO ch = W Ra a a penne \ OO GD OB et ta bo O th Se Ghent Roa WO ft Pe we *, +, "tog = 7 4 . + yy Ew Da ae ug nem ew te DO ew OU Ge ee P.O He OD oeAG Se Oo ~ wD OD ret FD 6 OW Gaede ed OO So Ew Dom OG Ao Gg OO 8 Orbe HO OO eB GG ct oh, tt OF us ay gy © 4 tm 1G Si 43 That OY OE G2 Hb) 45 43 Ob) a 4 4D Kay Hed Oo Si cs i ed beg ON Hogs 4 in 3 ip Ux BM ret we ue eq DB o 44 Gy cae ie SH WM De % Do rn c c oO a Re yt . cy ot ' eh BA RO oy Bs nb et aA Bu Ben & s ics) O Oy 'A & a 6 ous = oO Bw Bo 1 OE met ge RE ag oe a a ce 3 nS ee we M OM gs, @ 0 a oo . @ we MA SY fy Sw Bs Go G Ht ay ee Oe tA TS G Gm gs oe ag is fe 6B Cm OR ae fara 3 Ooo KS gy 85 »p Oso oo Oo cs 4 og MS OS ot ad ow BS 6 € os ef i . Goch Gi gy EE e a QO tO yy rd wd h tact a me c aD ay & fi, tH gon Tony ae a a3 my dd hbo ct Thad TH A OG m ly Mi gy St : be 3 Pou og ops a ey ~~ * 2 ay my 8 ed © eo ee ee) is @ ne 43 set LO Fn OP gs od ot Ea Oe 4 v3 Dp rt Li bed 4 i) os ben es Q D ug $4, O bl gy woe Seen ae" os 7 md vt ied oO ee o fo» OSD 5° 268 C5 , mG ol MM WO ge G se aw ne BAe Sages red ay og $4 " ww ny - 43 (3 vet weed pnp Ted ' a fn i Se ab ow Fl ome CO go ay BE y 3 ; a 4 @ rt! w mn th @ 4 ne GO Oe SM oO res tl dt 3 wt ct a wg me he" ap ort baa" 4 2 rt > en ede 23 a Ss O Bs o cyt oo Bho & is a he zed he gy Sed gy 4 y a t OF Es gt rn SOS oc So OD wi yy ta i HA ig, wy bt YG et Hom PO tea Oo B Soy WO ¢e ra OF 4 {4 fea 43 ts thy 687 a: ' M . re CJ i vo on * OG a 4} it 6 Aes oy: a ; WW 6 ay or ws BW oR yy By wu as a Yoo ao BO ' ts "a Of Hobe a Om Oo utp | da dt ' a 4 u Bow ey OS ° ay ; f cat 4 oe OD i fy Te Med ba co @ G Y " CoH MM 6 G8 @ fea $4 ay % at Oo Se ed fy i OHM uy @ 4 Go ooo my eo 8 oc eG BaP ww 9 hw ou be tH ord ed ord 3 wef $a 0) oOo .~.8 GO mo om + peme "rd sed ore O DS veg At OF 42 4s oe » Sar ™ 6 fi @ Bed a OF Do e 8 Koved Oo th Gt Port HE or OB OO 0 DP um Oe AD 0 b Gio & ew Oo fo Sig LD 7h me oH Og BO H&M em mm « neh Sos g "3 3 % Woo G srt Oo 0 OG BO a Oy BO ot 4 ¢ GeO OP Bel OO BOW Nr LO Dome DO BR Dm et = z xy & qh w i ¢ , th O.A.No. 1081/1939 * ~*~ OA No.l 71/200 No. 252/2007 MA.
connected w oe @ Bl ae 4) bef % aa 0 i co 2 wn 43 4 & ot we ed ts $a «s , bed @ o » oO es Dt 1 43 i OO tt & 4 yi Go OG 4 @ eh og 6 a a} 5 ig % 3 Oe J 2 4 "ed fe} a ord Ort 3 A ref EP wD & 2 mi aa . t O Marg Ho mH , a og & 25 5 oo "4 eH v ~ vt ery Pm Bde OW 4) Soe gt OU a PY ey 3 43 SS ct ts «5 5 thet fied ON U Ge w @ ak tony Ch yy GO a 4 &y t rae % ve i 4g 6 ony wed ny be po ood eh "4 wy C2 yt ved Th; - wv im of £5 - A yon seh ml aw ee a KS o i 0 (a 'S) @ B43 wi aS hy 7 Moat ope OS ne te wef 4 { ied 4G 4d et ta or Mf gee is ap - UY oO es G we : - gy (7 sh eed es BE ; 4 4 % 4 + @ gms ore oy a a as 43 "i C3, or aged ie ord 3 3 0 , ' 2 a wep Bo Lo kea gy whee SE is ant co Ay " bef «94 Ch by OG gt Oy a: ies oo @ eS Boy ka So iy ny no a) ba ont th oN gg a ae es » AS 4+ 4 a od "ef . qe any io ts feet : 4 4 ae Deed Mie 4 erfoon a C fea "th a " 1 Gp gy et gy mo! ogo Wg DL at GW gt Hg ary wt % " v . a 4 % me ly og Oo 2A Mh © iB 1 Ho Goo | RP 8 B "Gepy 2 Me ow Ba fd we a sg j C3 8 : - wy ty tong Pay ne et OM ha 3 8 oe ay a a a n & 2) e H a g 44 Mee pay ch gy es % gj no Dv mo cd ty BO Me Oo 44° G bey tf a) od * ud ; a aM a cy yt G MA st ; a4 @ n - 4 ogy © ty ey, Both Cy gt Gy. me 4 ed . : tt : rs ¢ Q ey OD M5 Oo Bo @ a sy, me eos 'a ye oo Ma veoh "3 ti wt a i OG rs Fey ne SS 9 Oo 2 yo 6 Eom "
eh ge ® gy x ee ee ee ne a} aMh gf 8 BG Be Yo Tota, Teg tt cs a pO Cw og - a oy & & wd my tp ee Te " wy % 4 44 : 5 Oo ee a) 0 cava ade Seo @ g 8 y goo Boh gee go a ebb" Ben a Qo 8 cs Y & 5 - ug oa a oD a, 2 " » VS 5 i ad "Ue rs a wo 4k Ut a @ OC eh oo 6B oH mp eGo gc OG 0 & GP th end "te 4 4 i} i 3 (et es S wt sbouty orl Do oc a 4 oc ot _ ay a) ke 4b 2 So 44 es ved on @ co Es 4 ct Es cy ES $: & i wo eS OU m4 my ao mo BG hy rn AS i get an Lo fee 6 OE Be BG by WOU
2 Mm EB gr 4 uy] we " ne mt Sh ot e rd QD we hd rn Bl gs us uo By fo) ENE gs Cont U BE gh tos 3 » mu te we FS ey Geet Sort OP Go et as aa Oa Be Covel af ; Pe Gi GT /-Or OM Ha AN Ged BO Dy So » 6 § © 1. B gh a ee WM + 2D ws a 4d ME ty td A Og De DON GUM OE OMS Oa 6 g i & " G i & © G un O Pp-d COM OM Hin 6 we hp sy 4 "t a «50 nn, ' vl Mo O ug ' a3 r L ¥s.
ter cs ion an?
At 2 ord 1 ea Q ~ a ch " g 2 cs @ g Cy ree o HH > ths an is rs mR o GO ant 43 r~ OD fo. 2852/2007 Gonnected with O.A.No. 1091/1999 rd OA No aa rey MA a bel ted geod w if isa eed be od so
24. oO a} 3 ae i whee 4 $a ht t v 43 te ued G & a XS
a) +9 iG os) ay $b a ied Go hed loyee ie * ws mY Ex! Ct aed o ba 344 tunate ad BALLS Sr Art 4 & %
25. ple ainab! QLTe , H on & rt aa Railway ne sph oy ot wd rd m ry be 2 "3 a 4 set BD vet 0 © 4, hon oh pensi 2 x a ayen that GS SUuUoRL x LLL TOOL LOLITA OOOUTTUTOOOLLLLLLL QA No 1/2007 MA No. 252/2007 connected with O.A.No. 1091/1999 "t TY.
% MUSH shock Qa 4 x ana U4 avd ond oy 5 ww a 4s e LONar z mo mS n> pen x G wag wm "4 vet et ONT ED Yet Sat 2 ew Te g
26. @ t mo ot 5 el ny a mo aed feta ishnan 2 KR. &:
India £ * mion o Radha Kr Vs. or case Qn ' 4 kh.
&SC 217 if < reported 1998 (5) and. Ors.
YY Kh Go plicant ap Bumar Bakesh Radha Brishna G. ~ i Bos oe qe Ci ay OF ot oO f c 6 ri s a ae oe 8 a Soc a or * n a wy 3 in 2 rd iS ex ~ am o ao © yp & a 5s Ss 4 & : m3 3 GS ard 4-4 ty Ce "3 e Bord ft 5 "mt n . bef i $4 rh & ty whee 6) © ° ct o ct at 3 a = « 3° Cy od '. ip He us € is Ww + ai ¢ 6 ® a ee ty cd 3 te4 M ie ct a ue ha " he os 3 o ay c < ag om as rh - SOS ef HOR OB Bo 8 ra nm 2 o Bs S 2 gm a Gg § m og o » $ o * 3 8 ° bad a En e 3 "het o 3 4 % ic o Q Go on! [6A 2 o & Oo | 64 iv . aS ad . & @ oe w @ geod aod wy Ki . wh 8] rf: we o 4 8 ~ wn Pa wt ES £4 ~ Es is het i wy rs wy - xe a Oo ro at 4 a hy wed at hey is 4 cf a Ye wget vt a a um 2 B uy a on re Q e & , & me 2 a gw » oe 8 G '4 BS aS D gM i 7 y , i 4 Be " : 5 (. f aD go " PO Gob Roo 8 Bg Som. uo 8 8 po mt Bo ee cs ft 5 fo op Ss & & | ais 44 "4, © @ oe * i Y te a & gj i oe a i qj OS = a) i y a cn % "4 ad LV cea) 2 _ a] "r Co Pe ® ot gc 2 Y ut oe ng £2 . 44 ng mn tea 7 ° 3 of "4 2 rhe ¢ 4 t 5 at c + i Sa e & Lf hy es) 43 Q oe vd '3 & i) BS a @ ny as : ord xd tt ae x c Be rod Bs 3 G x Mi i 44 rt 4 A i t3 g cs be o ro o i Ch, a : % a Sa = veel = em oY G& & a qa 8 eo wD G4 G. g a oy a a 8 so Bo FS mS _ + nr:
Gt 28 2 4 GY Sug Ss 3 Ug go Gg Oh "if ES w ao oe + =O o Pe eo 4 . 5 g a oo & mM ; fy moO er 5 @ a @ 3A 3 uy = a i @ % mG i 42 ee Med <3 o G ny a s fe Q « v aD er! Gs . 3 ea % wi a mS ; a & % G wt A ~ aS o ® ym . ml OU wo 4 8 n o , med is sO a G 4 4 @ gt ve es BR : ; x Ga a oD 'sy @ on fc 5 @ an: ; SS js ta he ¢ oa Os a my OS 5 8 a w % a Oo se yo 4 HH . ga } Hed x Ci g @ ot 2 : 3 in mt x Ly Ch oot oD Oa if bey = Sa * 43 TG 5 et rf 44 ™ @ ut < wf et e " 2 as v4 C "4 5 ooo rt » te 2 6 oo . os ot @ uy @ hy «|CO 3 : a " Gy ny OS t Bu OU 73 gO > oY "a og i . o & a 8 So Bp & c a a : 4 cj wh ao oh q ; a a o o '. ah G3 apd iy 4 aed @ 4 % OQ ' © £3 4 ue 4 ot Ut a 4 ; 1G c4 uy te a 3 dt ae 4 rt ny a we Q @ £ yet i « : det % i CG OS » m » 8 % 0 ae & q Gi : 7 @ "e ae iy ee hs re) 3] @ 5 iy 40 % ; th rod & o ort Q oe 3 oO oo Md a 5 it } 4 or fs = 'O w 33 ord ay c w . naa 2 M Oo Uf ved QP eM e 8 po ad ao Sj we fe 4 % 23 aa oy © ; 4 i 4s ® 1 G a $3 mS v 4 a yeh @ | ay 2 ce Se soe hed a " + a Se a] t of ts t oe a my : @ OG f we "| B 1 os gS °° OB 5 eB wy Bs » m 5 & : a a G O ae a @ re "rh on \4 a yD we ey "A ard 5 Soy cal a" S tt a. KS ed ts a v g f me 3 v e a mp w 'Dy 1p wy oO ; uy 3 w 2, oe '4 o Pp F an: Se a 5 & ¢ e i had rt os 4 So 6 my chy fis 42 * 3 oO a wp } 43 Meg es ' o p ft OA NoAT 2007 MA No. 2582/2007 connected with G.A.No, LO3L/1995 tty 6 arf aed p "4 bet ot ea AS iy Ad 'ht ag ro a xa wo M tft i a vet eet Q re SSiGes, ij 2g.
@ ed 7 ae wt ree wy ce Vs. has the the Pr en rio HE S 3 3 ot Co a q O D & Re to ty r m of 2 Wa 6 As a a @ wv ti rv ey) hs % 5 Sa a4 4 « yy ie Ct gc us ge hoa & vend by on ved 4.3 4.3 ey ot , a <3 od be oO tm oO a / oy t) oF ta eet .
os wot M4 rt B nt g) $3 wheck Cy mc 43 4 my ei! oh a ord " vert 43 eG eed ey «$ ht oO oo co Fk nA ue) , o 6 og 4 rd i « " 4 wha % Jed ree
- wf "
a3 ne 8 "~~ a 3 ae re) ha ni D CH " Bs oe Ga a 0 ra Rg we i "4 wd o £2 wy) %"S red ved of
5) 13] ad co f
29.
t- ft hy 4 ce a ty y : ' : . = Oo 4G QO st oo Le a ¢ 5 & 9 Be ' t 2) ie os @ hed a3 ' a cs aoa of be e i DB ¢ 7 3B a Ay ed % ba ~ a. wd ao Lo * AS 43 4 fa i a an Pe a a w C 3 ve pe rd ra ad mM rg a 4 A em og BOS Ow OM gg 8 yk = UF UH 3 Qa od ory if. : a3 ved th t ry Gd wl xs @ a) in f ef m 4 t 5 A us ;
oO ; 4 a8 Go om § « @B 5 GO ye LS Fas Bd et a © wo OS "4 ; 3 ' ge DO m8 DG @ " OG "ou-: " a wd os Q 5 on 5 @ a 5 - *, 4 ce t Me wv ha "ct gb od ' a 4 uy me as 8 3 CG Dm wo Oo 3 } O Mm & # 8 bg a s a O A x oO ° nm G 13 "> 7 a @ q a fb « i a) a Ba Sony cn O - G . C ep m ay hog 3 cs t of : 73 vt ae ; wa vt reed . Q Gd ou « & eo a 6 2 68 4g GF QB a G (ct H . ea a el sed set , opel re 3 ced wel a "4 4 oy haf uy Fat itt a wD 4 5 n 1 is8 w m Qo oY Bo a5 0 veh 4 o 4s : Db £8 @ A gt z go 3 fo SN wn mo 0 * oi ' ne) fogs a 6 Os } C as - , ort 7) ® 4 @ Oo ip 2 5 43 oe t3 cy re ed o on 5 SB x "7. 6 4s @ 4 me Mad "
Gm ot mS Ag ys oH @ 4 &§ G 8 9 "« 2 g@ 8 8 & ; ® 1 ; Ch G 3 i C3 Oo ro : ' G % yt uy gO oO ; ns ey Ho id ce ie) ® ip ra om ' ' c G 9 "C5 / is # Ya sd O a cs pH a eo & i as Y ti honed fe @ 4 oa © O og ocd 3 bE gy 43 SB 6 is f& - 8 ~ He 5 Og og UB ~ me G a ord te we a Q 3 4 6} ¢ 6 a [a , on en) a 3) . re < : "rl c 2 \ 4 ors On) Sg m op mk, £E m iG 43 » & 8B BS te 3 et SH O a a 5 3 od a os cet hd veegt . a eo w Kt Bu C SB ¢ € 86 &8 & »% 4 & & 8 moll UC Oy eed 43 & "3 " ° re ( a & fs wu 3 ' '4 ia 44 a 3 oa » 3 oi t . eo Gs oo» . 6 mw » @ & ¢ 2 8B &@ 8 BZ 2 ss GS 9 8 oe TD eet i mt ut re 43 cL D a then G % <3 rd ; oS 43 a} a. "
go 2 S BP e GF FO RB a eS Sy, 5 ay OM re ted 5 : coh * OD g a 8 c 2 "oh ag ih uy 0 o a v Bs LR ® a © vot o 3 : a ba or} a Pd 43 iS. g G4 v Bi 1B e An ct 4 5 ~~ . 4 ~ «i 4 is as O oa verd no a 5 3 . ae D " f ee o . KS ce) 4 oy 8 x a 0 ~ red HS 2 os Gy i fa Bt ge u - 9 oy i fm mh OO A Fa « ae foe ty ut }.3 : 2 ond QO a wy * a @ , : Q " wef o crs o $3 nm o 'as Ch G . : a & Ct @ ha me 2 & "
44 ea CO a ind 4 4 so D uh & o n a3 "rk hy red a - in 6 Dy Pee BS w YD me ot 43 wD a ") L eS i £ be : ha © dl a 2 ae Os eo Gg Go 2 8 KD Me wo 4 o Gt OD eo 2 2 & © & SC 8 G8 OB How YF BF 2 % O a oy a : s wD ci ch ed a 4 ek oet ot 4 co Cy 64 me Dy ad B 4 4s G o be ord an ig4 t aS iG ; ta $4 . . yy ' G, te 4 i fy et a a ® @ od er @ 6 © o rh ie e ane % jar oe 4 G cE ped @ ff ed wn HO Zz FH % 3 tS . 6 mm ¢ 6 @ ® + 8 * - * o , @ a Ge os 7 M4 @ wy O 4 a ed B - Y | } 1 * tot g) n if , Sogn og 3 8 :
o 4 Le 7 : : -
er w v4 A b> aliog a b re ees ao Oy a ae ot Ms ri good hes i is oS 4 "Tt a) a" "gd hy yom ENO es oO 8: . oe Bed 1 a by oy 6 me OG 4 2 tg 4d THAD gi © azéo 6 £ 3 A mod ooo ee © S 8 eg a 5a mo gu: a a i m4 on BO ay "ry Dy a DG - ~ as S} AY 55 TR, OM Sy Mas Oe ue % bt 8 4a ba ted O o » & a v a By mt 2 a seed ved oe! 3 "ee LS ory fe oo % A " sg "4 ih Cy ee ga a
4 $23 2 es m Sq me AY eM & Fe rf 0 °% , i oe 4 a i tr ok oO 3 ed eH ay Oo a a 4 0) wo 8 3g ye vd @ So. a tt Ey vel gpl ha r rot oo R4 ~ ge OY 8) ON a 9 3 3 wh w Og . Ab 4a Q a XY .S Or oe « Aa M cop "ES o ws 4 ree} sis dy a ce © so i rt a se a » = i ca] ue «rt O 6S ogg mA) o weg a » cb ig », a "4 : mo +f S43 Fang at 3, a 2 » "™ &§ @ 'i "
snatd Te ct ae) von, OY a wy be of tg 4.4 oo ws % G , Tt ME vy mye ty Bay S © " fe doe é Aa GeO BBN Sg ° 63 a "at om we ay rh bd , 3 rd 43 B iS oy ct Bo $y 43 Hed ; i "4 sen a) +4 & «rd 4 43 be M3 ro & a hy von £ Sct eh 4 iol @ oS oe tS i % ft "ed a 3 aL gy hy ih D 4 wd o "nt 43 as t Q d 2 od ct cS chm ed a i ~ 2 > ue G ane us ad yea x Foe, ") 4 it ; "4 4 fh 2 = e > i Cb hi oH gp
i) oO ae % Oy m a rf 09 ss a .
. ; 5 4 a Sa zw i "e it 2/2007 : ed .s O.A.No. 1691/1999 oo OAS Nod 71200 MA Noa. 2 G ™ = Ish w 43 $4 U4 > © Hel ae ret et ty rae i Q po) s oO sped fe ig cs 43 Sed sed OY 3 43 So 6 Ps) wt i " Fe ga wl a a % =e sed % v © hae GO oe DH 6) O GT Qy ee ta MY a Zz wt i 4 4 / goekepe B&S8hRR8 23 | lO . a tf Q OO AD ts mt BLD a2 GO + we ; ; O is si Abort a m Qcq 43 ay & 1p og 6B cy 4d . QO i bab od kas a gy ac & 53 4 oo ea 4 ot | ue a a 9 ,o Bg ee ae m $3 G "A Ba ty ne Pog re 33 % EY qt > "4 i et ' Com tf, a © Way qo, BO ty a 4 3 a i § $4 mn he ky, Gg ork Dy ae 4 @ e ° @ BR gs ct hn ad gg a ue "ef TS a me a o 4 8 SH gy yy Uh org ss, EF Ga "4 4 a4 ay Gs oct wf | ® i cot er a ; ned woo Bw th by a ~ 2 w a rd <5 tS 4 5) hd ay Gh 3 eS 4 ea ' wre O GO c 3 aed id Say oy D 4 Uh es ™ Oo a he Be ; ao o <e } 4-2 Os . Bom ay OD @ rol R ty 43 Gq 5 @ :
AOS eT ao q NM @ PB Bg wt 43 may MOR AE ces BY : $4 Cs 8 ty ord Ee td ny ip iS gj cs Mey o as # oo OB ey 7 ; "ed Oo ® OG w ' * ase 3 a hy ved c i 43 vig by g BE yee 24 At f13) C1, » ie) St pee UY. a "ed AQ . tet i va <i 3? nS Qo my He eae Ob a Sy 4 <4 a ea ree a Ma mo a a rq UP ST a . 44 oO wv a ( e oe cpm TEM SR e a an 6 Gg By 6 e § & 3 ' .
GO Dei 4 Bo # © Gg e £ a a @ ® ma Bog 9 OQ & '6 fg gt te iB SE Sy 4 Pa "és ord " QB 43 "ef 6 . & @ 33 os _ <p 4 4 a 2) hy if hy 4 o °F td cD ent @ rot ' a 2 eh ME GS ots od Cn $5.5 we ; ry "i 3 a3 sep Ad veg hI ts wot C4 cae 3 x7 A rd wh re ood 43 fon, Bord wz, = SN Wy thi 4 Eee ° 3 Ow. og oh A, " i a fo) . ved in O je v BD ey Po BG ue Bed ta Oh, ts, @ os my mf eet or Cs ie) ot SS . Bmp Bo Sy Y aS i . cs o a Hy > oe Gg b8 » ® Sf fF we « @ § 4 EB mo mp OB ye ee wy Oo ® ad id hy oy Ei © wy 33 iB ey Soe UN got , tah ay om , ei $4 % Om « O EO al BR ky 43 3 - ed Da 3 ce Ww aye 43 o ® pe bap Ack rp TR 4 &y QO a O a3 rt od ca "4 ui Gh 8 BR RS G . wo 4 4 " ES be ed ut cs & iy Oa UR oh tet Oo OO OB eH oy fry wy a «i = G w Me OO bh O Dy ot Ef <p cei oO C £4 w 3 O 3 th 43 sey A EP OO 4G oC MW mab Uh O co srt 6 se, "4 C3 " ny 3 "ed Gi $l 8] ex iH oo u a a ei a arf { food oo by 43 © art od ty a x ons Sa os om hy a ' * Oo boy ed "a a ot t 2 mp Oy bf e O ay 4 @ @ @ yp wy Gh fhe Si -- Fra ond Ma PR Be on t Be 4 on a w gy SBS 8 i @ } wD Ogna af 2 § 2 2 3 kn ad a hed z ES eon 3 a ms eS 4 £ a AG a BD Sat al 8 a ¢ Bog 4 a wom ¢ Sabo Sop § 8 8 a ¢ 0 8 8 « £ Mg oO sid te > we 4 a iB reat ay . Be et 44 "e4 ard "ga ae ci Me he wt 3 v4 x tb gS er rea : a Se ae wha GQ re ms * ei tes 'b Dp A As £00 8 re ws By gt 2 OR " fa is Om eo 2 r B 4 + Oo 4 ie ts on ved a iG "
1% 3 oa 3 hed i vel 4 Ae " 44 'a C 44 43 43 "4 £ Fh a moO » & GE 6 5 OU Go wt as Cc % m4 B <3 4 x ® mS & os cs i ms 4 3 G@ 5 8 & Boog § Bog Be SS ti G ~ Fos oO 43 i, £3 4 a) u ap i e ft a Ps ua wo , & ; 1' 0 : ~ : fd v + i rg rf e v ved ord St 7 ty ms 4 « QD ed wed »4 @ vs om a oO ee C4 . £ 5 reed . & 2 ue @ : 0} % an "ol o os o & o Gog 8 4B BT HI BBG a a@ Boo yp GS GO 8 og mG ' Og ww «=O OB O% on 44 xi } Ch 4 '3 ved a" D3 "4 '1 ag t 4 "
C3 ko cr ng $4 on is 3 7 ad C5 Us "
% cs cy ete i , '0! i 2 ore a} & its ard es iD 8 ag O D i @ "4 mq * 4d 4 ; os Se Soa - , + me OUR " , bf . i oS % Mia 4 "| t ; gi ao 4. sf C ms L3 Ms - wD a rd ® ¥ toed as 4 a ' mo 4 i . a a rs f be - : s is q ot ~ apt vs ok 3 Nod *. age . ed $4 "O mw tt 1 " 43 «3 io ee 8 3 "" w oF bd '4 g my on ag at 4 ont et G a tht os S bes ay hy if} Se is - re @ Q if Ww ne a Be it is ; "st or! ms ~ Wen - pt @ SS he ka is é & > i @ vet wy ha oof ep wn ws Esa a rt ra a a ak . & 3a i . 3 a ty B "Fh ba a reed 'at & a a e we 4A ~ tp OU a hat he ay oa oo ® Ci "4 $4 a fs ® "ss "4 es oy : 2 5 ard oe 4 ves G a 4 . Ka a ra @ am a 4 Gy Fa ; " Q a ad "sd td m4 4.3 bp a ce? eo wR ae OS ~ « & GH @ a id hes it wt "4 a4 t 2 rey bes iG wy es rth he "13 ped i Qo é i) a G Ri OG ve " a a i a ra a CF 2 @ 4 "3 wal Pa ot ay CO § j Oo & 1. rs + 43 ral ka ge 3 Oe @ , 8 cf} as a wed of a 44 ok 3 '3 if in gh OG Ka o © Q % wen ie be a 4 yo nO SG i) re a td ;. <3 5 a cc ay 4 or] " i rag i i w " 4 Ye A 1 ch ya . 4 mi. a os ay ft ; ao a3 va % j ae " sor} hea w red € od as et eg ~, aloo mo Se Gon oF oH O fF A OM sO y a 8 ae Se 6 oR Sy Sg wo 2 8 a A 4 n af oo be cg {3 Spey a {3 fi aed i ~ £3 th w gO Soo wom ag oO eo @ & Pe Qo g) A 8 o wo w 4 as GU Ay Be a . $4 ED g a Hm fH a eNO 'G mB wigs 4 fh , a e cH 5 = by ' ae 4.3 a a " Td AA 5 ; / 3 Bt Go g Oo 4 ~o 8 ao ee ee ote "py y Ls eat od S. Qo C3 3 ¢ fe 4.4 wD a4 nee woo om & a ® 7 OU yo yp oO 8 m= 8 $ cL O @B fh C 4 vet D 4 4 - bt vd 4 . 3 a * a q wv i 4-4 eg $ ey 2 oa 3 ' w is] Yt o os x ms Os rt . *" ig a & ue Yo Q " a ind red o 2 " ao if> fy Hea SS . ae ne " ue "3 4 © r en xe 2 GA Nb.U7TL2007 MA No. 252/2007 connected with O.A.No. 1091/1999 @ ba 1G v4 2 hed us « by y WE f N gad Sate hem Se q % £ cy ba "4 aed ix
36. the ew that xy v and th Q hd ag Same a ~~ ed Ons:
e4 Nae the z Lirec at, y om MY neixr exe 24 te C or es Ce sianary pen res rene oy .
s@FLt SN aa ct Not 7 G CS x eon 1a yonden resy cnas Ne worn syed oneal oe w 42 wy aed bi M4 kK iS § O nit a det hy gp fe3 mM > OF censien = Or DULrooEse * Sear RY y You _ .
ad qualit & * them
3) ig Ths all ' SH = w fF to a Me i o 3 wy bE {ii).
1;
awn ama ' x 2 i above at view the Th 1 iu fy wre See o ah 3 c ee ek.
bs relevant kh the ow.
% t lance. wi OA No. 71/2007 MA No.252/2007 connected with O.A. No. LO9L/1995 EN sr arf ee See ALLrearcs oe wo cis Q) ie} "ef m3 ve Ba Ey oy G3 ip, G @ A 44 3 f Sry, ai
5) ed A os ved a4 ht wer$ S > ve B sed @ $4 B yt 44 x 2 imstances, mney 'at ard
37. oy C?
ty 8] ae x {A} Member (Dr. Bhagwan Sahai}
h) eC N. Mamber. (7) » a ee Sing {R. Sem, we