Karnataka High Court
Sobha Developers Limited vs Bruhat Bangalore Mahanagara Palike on 10 February, 2012
Author: B.S.Patil
Bench: B.S.Patil
. . . 1zV.\\\\\\xxx\\\\\\\\.\\\\\\§$ ¥\ .\.3$m\ . H H. .AAS\A:$\x§\\\\\\\.¥.»«.§§§§ §mfi§wm\Mm®wm\ \\\..\...o..%.\\\\\\\&.\\." ..~ x : ......A\\i\EAx$\\\\§§x\§»§»»§m"\M\$Mmmm §§§ .2...
..\ \\\ x \ xx xx \ \ xxx.§w\\.x.3$\¢V\§\:¢\§ \.xQ\\\\\\\\\\
-.
-.
-.
-.
.h.............xix\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\§§u.N~u MM\.V..W\x§ §VVW § \\\\..
W.WWW..m.wm««w<»»»w:ezz$m\«v<<ss?es»:$§é$&\?»\\$$<\§i%§ 8 a2;3ar£!:1€;:f;s3 {(3 v3.r"§i>u5; §}L§f§.?héiS€E"'S; ?;Cé<:==::rdir:g {,5} 31:6 p::§;§ii:>.;1er, in t€:*r:::$ af E338 Izzadéfisé 3313:": gazzstigzzéé, €he:*c:*~ mfg blocks 10 be C:::n$t:*uci;ed, Gui; G? which block E\?c?}i <8/§j:'[E;VVLE3a:r€ aiready hear: czazzgimcéaci {er which C'C\§§i'}39..I1C'j <:er§§iiEi':3.:e=}*;as'j 3388:} igsued %y 21:25 Bangabré {3€v{»io;:--:::A%én{ 26.529}. §,< In f:,1rti":erar1c€ of geem sxecutéci in fgveur of {h;:cd :8é§i§~.-.§}.E}:§:ii€'S are Sigieé is be in gccupaiion 5:" The eansiruetiafi in z'€$_;>V;~';%:_t in the writ pefiéian has stageg, in 'ihais while are netaréy grompisted and 13:5 stage 9? CGf}S§I'1lC§Z§GE1. in iacé: {ha petiéiezjés" Qamg wig': 2:: fi1€fEE{} éuiéngg Q36 {3GE,E}"8€ Q§"3;1;;;j;;§§€n"i,s,_ 5:26 mere eccapansy seriifisaée isgzzed '$32' 1';%:t;v€:§::>p:1":e:1?; A::fi:e:°§'é,j; an i2.§;,2G'£2 59: {E25 a3a:1'§t':f2:;1'_cigé§;§-vr:f6:3»i§2éi";vt;;ié:E béesie: 'w§i'§3 E84 fix-véiiézag Li£"§}:'§S. aggiefi 0:: EQESSZQE 3 is £323 2?"? §'€S§}€}1'i§§€§'f£1 L Em' wad C2x£;f;iin§;§ 30 as 3:; EQE}? 'éhff @§<:3=$§r§.«::aj ":;::'é<;::';g::;{:§:n<§ iiabk far iii-3 §§E"€}j€{'f£ from '(Em Eééizigafiafanaézaééi " V ' $::.%:--$i;aé§a:2. Eiésre :32':/:3 31$ :§$s§<::::":s5¢ A2":@i;h€::* 23é§éQ§§€;?§'é.§{}§§ 13215 $5./:E3:2'3§'é2,€€% 'i¥%.H;2G§§ :*€3::§.2€r:§E;:T¥§g/5 :35 V';-)$$v' ix M »s.:::%,».:"""'°* 'éwxxxzx m ////éfi }/97 %fi'¢; §%;§j§Z@' ;; g¢:%z»;;;;,,,,,//,,m,,,,~w,,.....W. .4 xxx"
\ ................§i\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\§"§hwt .\.§«\§\m\m®\m§Mmw\\.W\ \WMnN\ &N§ \\\\\\\\ \\\ \\\ \w.\\\\\mK\vxmu.\\\\\ &.\ .. E .. .. \ .x\ xxx Vt...\"...... .+.u".... ..xtxxx\\\\55tx\\\\\\\xx\\xx\\§n~ NvwV\V\§$§$L.§w.@vWwm«u%x$ \\\\ \\\\\\xx \\Vx\xxx\\\\.k..§_.u.u..\\'.\'.\\\.\.\.x ..........HA..Sxxxxxxxxxxfi§§§§.&~§v»»v»§»»»»~§§\m§N§$ mum"
W4.nnvc.«\\\\\\&sN~V\\\\.\\\.\.\\\\\\§N oNWV.V.\§ .\....~..~u..\.\\\\\\ IZ§,3E§ zgriwzzsfrszmed :"}':.§i€~3E"E;E':§Z% «.:%.z:.i"ins::é {E233 :%":a;§2g}; §l€aSf}:'§E, .:%C€Q?§33'§':g E3 auiharitiés is reiérrsd U3 swubséaniiats éihaé ihere W38 21 Eiagzhghéz 35332 argé {he N313 in €;5{i€i€§3€_'.€ in the land in §i}€S'{'iG'£f;.~...__ ' » '
16. The Bangaiore Bevelepmani; Auf_h.Qi.'§_i_§;"
gtatfiment of ebjectiansg Hewever, learméad £;"°0e;:'ns€¥:Z_:'€§;}:":;%sé;§':i:§gT the Bangaloree §€V6§Q§I1'£€1'fi, Azxtiééiiiggr V. Elaé goughi 2:9 jugtify the action of further contandeé that theugh §:I1:1"i'i':_%*l§'6"!fC~;V:_€1%é€f§h__.éfid map d€piCti:1g the Eiharsb pczrtietz 1:; the ':11' qfigsiiéfiv,'"£é:::'"t0p0graphy is prépared by tbs Iaizci Aatquisitiarz office af the Bangaiorig said sketch dees mat seem ' vaffaira. He has placed rsiiarzce Age}: {flguré in the? saga sjf Mfiazvmzaig. vs i§;sk:g:zaLv,:m9:'v;§V;£;ivD 033 399?; 3. sec: 388.
:fi3.r3:{1z2.s€E.A :7<:jf'»%;E1€ :'€Spsnd€§3:,~,:8BM§ C0::%.:@z::€ES 'shat 'ihe peiiiicfiiscvsa G121}? éisiuzéeé and Shifififi ihé f}8:'€1,§§a:1 <::';::§3e §§3:§',"i'*3: ${":%3m wéiiséa wag mrzzzizag acmgs the schédzile > §}fe.pér::§_'fm:i%3. fierih ta Sgziéh gagging £:'aQf€3SS Nefiisszai Eiighway ?:':5;:€ %:a"aIe 3:363 bfaugéfig fiawn Q15 Siiifi Csf V622? way of ihe '2>s.:é?,a;¢3*3*' Gamma ihzérabfg increasing {he sssapa (3? :m&:«:§::€{:<%;e(i féaaég '"€f3 \ .w.'.h.'............ . . ' . . " . . ' " . . . . . . : M\§MMMNm\m \ 3% gé % § 5 § g § a Y?
appfovai ané ihé Same i3 a§3§>mv€é. T323 BBMR 21: I39 3f£;7ggé!hgd §'3;iS€€§ any 0bj€Cii{)f} IE8? is Ehsre afiyihizgg ta ShCé'i5.%' thfai' had raised aay Cxbjeciéon ta {ha csntenis 9:" ih€_.re:r§s§fi"--§iaSEef"
Plan when ?;he objecticms ware calieci 150:: u§%T';e*;%ujsé3t:'i'1K/;§3._s *i<::rT f Ban 2015 has Came K1210 effeci on_2,5.G8.2--{}$"?.. 'i'}1§v7§>2':'é,?sté:r Cantaing shaving sf !ar:ds3 straeei i*esflé':jv§::ci fcvr parks, giaygrounds ané rjfizgr 55% pubfic purpoge as 2.130 areas sf ,éifiéj§§ire§9pm€nt. in such circumstans§:.$«;':_é}§:% Cerperation 3.3:
the siage Gf conneciian is the accupants of €;fij§i1S{i§€fé. Sectien 505 of "£315 Karnaégfia Ac: 1%'? 8, makes it deaf éhai exarciseéé pe"§7€_ré'.' €337!-~z"§'}€ Sorporaiien shafi be in §?§}§}:fO:"§f1.7§?.l§7 wififz EE'i€""'~§3Z G__?§§SiOI1S 0? the Eigrnataka '§'0W:: 351$ i3'::u3";i:":g= ?'§$:.§§f;i:Eg .i%C_f§ §§§L wit}: reggré is zmy maiiér ffiiaiing is égézgd" ézgé'V{};:§"fi:§$%%;é§$§::i€§2E; 33 dfifinefi 3:3. éha Eggiasaéian ta 711 36631013 SSSSGE1 Z?'§'fa:E £2? 'i§hi':' §'a:':2&§:a};a "§'<;>§%m & {:$§Zifi7i£°§%" P§a:2:3i:5n§.;' .' EESL givsg §§"§§i{3;8.C}>' if} 232 %;:he p:"§3V%'§:s§€:T§";:5 affiés Aeé Daze: any V"'A»..g%;4f;::~r §§'8'J)§8iQ§"ES sf gay ::'£§:":€§* Saw; ii is :26}: ihi' €f&S€' gf file ... ":*€s;:»a:3.é€%::?;s; {baa if'r:=€:"s3 E3 3:23;; viaizfiégrz {sf {he Lififigfi E§E€i'£E?;éCé?{§<:*s'j ~e44a«4m:.'...'.'...._... , //f¢:% «§-gt-¢$§?':$%€*":%.55Q5¢ f«?«?%:2%))//////////////nanu / /
-:-¢"'7:»""" /35!' // «arr/;.4.4.4# xx/x/' ..§.xxx\\\\\\\%~§&&§§§ §.\w»M»Nn\\\\§ .\ . w \\ . . xvw. \\\ %.\\.\.k\x.R'..\.\\ % \\\\\\\\\..
- ,..~,ua/_Jd _?bV\'/ 2} Q"?
§M%¢%%.%ra%%.fA¥.»¢§uZ£¥£.§:
mad suiting :0 15:}; E};1"Ed€1'§EZC%L1.fié Qabie in EéC€f01"§E£E1éZ':€ W:'i;':i"--Ea.:,:?, E, sxgeéiiiauséy.