Karnataka High Court
The Divisional Manager M/S National ... vs Smt Mariamma on 22 July, 2009
Author: Anand Byrareddy
Bench: Anand Byrareddy
1 E EN TEr~iEZ- §'EE.(.}§-§_ {f{}L§R 3:m;{'"g:> mzza; WE 22;" §";f+w Q5 ;¥Z1u§?V_, ':f '"27{:s&:;é' BEPX}Eéi§£f'« "§'HEi 39 "B MR. ;:«;:~:;%;;~«:}:)%k22k%;:2:.;%;;":z§;:f:24;:':*' ms::%E:IT4:T. &3»3E{>'{A§S §':i:3T ;:§*?§:.$*a:A. *§;§;g%;,2:s5 «:31? 2% <1» 2;
"*2"
fin }'''*'E 5/3"' 1 ..
F5"?
p--4 L f*""Q ' av 371$ P A :<:}U$ yzggf ,x:i>;>::;x:?&%LL%i:%:g;§avg; :3? 288'? €'?vi":?} . ' E:~}:";.2'i.{.3§?§ {T}? 2%}? 5MV} .4= M11133 ':x:T:;.:2%i :35 £3? .2 V {w ks' '{ "
2;?_=':\:z'§ v'.7}i ,_s§:?§g§:;:1@:%L% V' _ ?§h%:__ §§3ia;'-i3i~:.;1}a'§ '§*zs.'£¢i;a--g:;:':*_W _ . §';'§1;73."i~}'gEi:}:z;:§'«--E sgaranss {.3=:>;:*2p:*.:1}g' "§;,i::1é%.sa:,€,_ ' ¥'">L§Qx:is§éz';§aE %?}%*§!%.a_.37€;3 Bharai §§.'»'s,:'2'is-§.§r:?g;;
R€at;ga§_:;s;-:%_ L' A Ragraacraicé 3:23;':
_" "§'h€'-Maggagsr, iéégfigaiurs §?;s::gi:32':a§ §}§§~::-2:, $:,:E§:r:z.:'}*§ €.L{:§:':.§'::%»i::>:.
' VV "§44; ?v'¥a}1a"§:ma €§:z3m:§§:é §%<'2:"is.:i, E-Bazzgaismz 3:36 eiifiifsi H. 2'%.i§'§'§%Z;EE,m».E° vi"
{gfi :2 ' _§°é'{_X§v'§'. ?s;&<;:.='§:aa:§2a? ;§s;§%:<>g::.%.::: 3%)? I?%sEr':;. Eia:x$§s;~::x;z2:~:} Z Agtzeii abuzz! 25 }a::ar:-3 l€}.S§1riK Bashaez", E350, Lats Sheikawha, Agzzd abmzi, 2? years Ag Residing at Kate Hausa? V Ammenxbaizg Bu§§}...rar Viiiagag " b' Mazzgalméz Taiuk iifihri. Animist" Hussain Sm, Mshammaé Hussainfi u Resitiing at Abduiia CL)n':p(3;;r;§_,_A. Gerigudazia, 'feiarmiag A - . "
Mar'rg3'§i£';s--'€; : 7;
Iifffze ?~Efe;§¢._i:2:iéa. :§$i':g.:;i'z;z}.é.§*a:,,ifigr-xapanjg Lizzziisai, }Eci§é}.:ai~--Raaé, .
EvIg§§ga§:3rr;4:V '%%%%z3.::§:;+§.;i:x:., Sasrssii, """
' V 'g-figaziv z:§?:.;;;:3;i"3e§' §:sar:-, V .S§:f3;
" A§{:::§£ci§::g."g.i§A 3§§{<}§r2;I2 Hémssz, T.hy'a;:1 '?;>.E::i;, §*5.',a11I£uIj Bifiififii %%[%k%:;z.k:;.;mg:, . 'S55. Hjgérase, ' Ageé afiaué 662 f;-"€&i1'S 35.3531; z5mi§»22332ma 'W50. Esmaii, Agcii afmjui 3? }fc.%1§':~;, B932 Residing at Gdéedegnri.
Hmtkaia Pusi, _ é Mangaiere « §"?=f¥ 18} RE_SP€};'EV}E?V~ET $$=%F2€>¥ Tiiiss i'viiscei§a.n::aru:; F2kfSiV,,ép§'.?€}éi§ V§:~s._ .§i§;:d*_; uVr;{.iVc§V2"' Sm:-iimV'1V 373(1) of the Mater Vehicisg RCEVV 'E .98.-'EV agaiVm:1t§§e juiigmem. anci axvaré {false} §T3.{¥9.2Q€ré;:s;4u;ssmi «§§'z"'E'vi'§r"€T Vi"~5g}.E§3£i§§ 19?}? an Eliza fife 0f the Principai Civii §u.<i§;'e_ {,:§$e:1.§{:vr VVI§¥ivi;s;i%:§:1,}, Member Meter Accixietwfs Claitrise Trihunafi V i _.-._N§:ig:ga§§c'>t'e awatrfitig :3:
cumpcnsaiiua mi" R::.1,?4, €'x:'>;'~~V:wi i§Li}x_E<:1"t.V:;&;1a::ii1:6'3*E;. M.F.A :¢g.2:a{;%QFVk:§;m {;:»5V*v'%;: 1: % BETw::g3g; % f _ The ifixrifiikifiéiééhiaaégfir, 1 M53. Natfiunaé .I;1sura:j:ce~C<§;<:;pa;;y Limiied, Dixri:;;;§;s:§r:a.§.£V)iVf1L:iis;,2.. _ V " » A%VBhs,%a:% §,:.::';{::ir:;2; % * ' M*d!:ga§a;r:.:_ , ' V V V Tim »Manag,a;;j'..-
j Banga}9rVti..R¢g§unaE Gifice, « I ', V ' -- .. V firgbhmmv .€§{};§pIe'}:., ' v~VVfi£§4¢V'?x:iahaima. (3a.m}}1§ Ruaé, V" . Bafigaisre + $613 {R13} fis.P'?§LL§.1'~3'"f' VV " "(Big $§3ri«Cl\;i. ?s.,:s=:2:;a§:ha&, Afizsusaie figr ;?VvE.?s. i,s:<;§§c,x3,;s} AND:
'[0 . A. Ibrahim Aged 49 years, ._ 35:3» Bzwa Bcary I 323:. Eamccia 1350. Late Sheiiiabba, Aged afiszui 37 years AEE' Re-zziciixzg at Kate Hausa, Ammcmbaia, Boliiyar fviangaiorc f§'*aE::§; 'V j V" "
3. S§2ri;".«51;s:33;§er ' S.:'0L M0ha£n:?:agi_ Vfn§uss;§£§:;,_ _ Rz:si§;§§ng;._at: A§:du«§.izi' {.:{}';TI1p§;1£§E1L§.) €3or2gudde§ Ve§en;:ia,,. _ ' i'«.:ia:3ga§:3é"»:: " ' A "
"T§1rz,é2f:'*~7§::t»=.< Aingfia }=5§;5;s;':3§"2:n£:¢: Cumpany Limiicai, 2 ,}'§::§§iK;:ii --Rc.ad, _ ,}'\i.'ié31{1:g:5;§i3I°£$«._ "_.
'-§'3y}z:i.K~.' :S:ur$:sh, é;g,e§.ab:3:3t 39 years, T S;'u.'T'L Vasu?
' R.;e$i<iit1g at K<3ya:1 Haimge, V *VE7§3yam Pas:
Kama: Districi ismaii, S59' Eijgdrese, Ageii abuui éé years
7. Smi. Asiyamma W:"0._§smaiI, _ Aged aboui 5% yes:-1:5, V Beih Residing at Qédedeguri, Eiarekala Past, ° ' "
Mangaiere M 5'24 I81 . RES?{;1.Z3Ei§§3'N'?S (By Shri. R. Rs§§:::gupa,§an, ...§La.s2;}on;ie::i :zm~:.i, 2, 3, 5 6 and '7 are served bu:....ra.t;2ai21ed :,::'}2'é§f:r»::;e:$,3*:ted) _ . $%$#$gVx "x T Iq.i:~;--..I§ai'§:ac¢§iizg2§:uu.g.: V1?ir:si"-;'%{3}:;éa.§ is filed under Srsxzfiun I?3{ I) sf the T2%'£Is.'::,§<3g* '2?e£;--é.¢ie3v_A_e;t_; £988 against the judgmené am award daitzii 1 3'.f}£3;2§3§}{:$'T{y4i3:;_¢{i MVC Ne:+.i§3§:'i999 on the fife sf ihe Pn3_<.:i'pai £3Vivé'iji:;éi'g¢"'zT'Seni0r Divis%{m}, Member M023:
Accidetais {L~{aim.<; '._'§':'%3;3u¥:--3¥ fV§ Fv'Iat'igai:'>:*e awmxiitzg 3 ce3H1;§g:§1';t-;:§,iun if Rg_:~;V.:Z,25,'{}G0§- wit}: inicrsaii at é%. 2~«:%¢.}.;:, :§%«:;7 0;' 2097 (M9):
Thc'Dixi§s.i:§323§; Eizianagcz", . 'V.I}£:'s. Natiénai Bzsumnca Campazzfg' i,i:';3§E.:::d. xéisiunai fiificcz, V' ' --§}?t*:::11_'é'§i' Efifiéfisig,
-- Mjfixggigm u " V Esgrcsenicd by:
" '"5116 Manager, Bangaiun: Rr:;gi:t.>nai ,:}§"'ic:.} Snfihrazn Cemgiex, 9 (By Shriif E213. Puunacha, :5s.Li'=;<3x;.a.§rs Eb; 'i'vi'g, Lcxpimxzzsé} AND:
2 1 .
gs} La.) Smi. A:~:yia._/ Wm Ismaii Agmi abmzfi 27 yams?
Residing at: Bimar Hausa, Harciwia "V'i}iagc:,, Iviazzgaéore Taiuk.
Shri. Alums-:r Husxain _ Ska. Mehamznad Bassaing "
Resiagnggg: ;é;E;du§Z'2: c:g;sapmm¢;= Cioriguaid¢;'~Ve1e:?gc.i_a,~._' « Mazgtgaiigrssl" .
32¢: "NC332?'§11di'aV.AsSuré§1':a,:§:' '€_?é1n}:za.n§s Limiis 'L Neiiikai E335' ._ A b' Mauggalgsre _ fSxui;1:'i Migsh, '~ gfiggeié-v.:;mt3§_3Ei? yaars, _ "3_5:;:«_ "'<f&§2.i4;"
' '§.5esid£_r;g at 'f<i§>j;an Hausa? Fsjgiy K333-".,'%¥_._§§' fiigtriat L ..§:;i".i1aiL 'E 35:}, %ij,:d:°Gse, fiagéd ahatii (:6 §:'ear5;
Smi. Asiyamzna Wk). isznzsii, fégeé zfmmé E3? yaam $3 Bali': Rrssiéiing at Ocidedegmfi, Harrséiaia Pmat, _ _ Exrizamgaiurtz A 3'54 1%} ;;~. ' §:}§3*«E as<=aw:=s2nzz This Eviisutciianeuu:-: F§:°:~:§' . i"E--i,::;i_; :£§2V<i?E::" 'Sec-iigzii 1'?3{ 3} cf {E13 Eviaier Vehieias Am, £983'3.gai:1:::.{§zej:;}:ig::3€::1 and award (iairsxi E3.{}§'.2ifiC*5 §;'££§::-;c<i.V§V:i'i~:f.:"{3 'l~§Q.§92§§fi'9€3'§ an fin; fiis:
sf 'E3/:6 Princigxai Civii JL's4cige_{g_e::_i2a:V"I'x§}i*:§S§:;:;), Rziaaziéer Eviéxtsr Acciciezlis Ciaims 'I':-ébzmai _.-.._3\»Eé;i3Vg£:3.0r<: awardizig 2:
Gem pegzsaiiam 9?? F';;a.;Z7,€}§Z}i}:"+» v.}'i¥h 'ézgigsgresat. 3,: " '*%. é;:..:zé1§3'1'g Q}! '§_?l"'£§'V£§§'!E}::§E~:1'i,3§1 ifiis €.§&i}*;_ firm Cikiéfi éeiiveréggi faéi-:,;:=s:.ii§g.'3:~"«v_ " ' ':'§1*e3c agfifiaifi arc; ciisposcgi mi' écwggihésr as they afs §i§r.::£§ by »ii:2i.--:--»sgs2 :~,4g;p$»::§ié:n_i in rscggsai us? ihé: 351323;: avraaréi 'i'E:z::;:(:: ezgamaiss :~;m: fi.?.f:d"*=by E§£¥:éLj---i:§.3uranc@ €.:£}fl'Ep::ifi:gf, whim?) haii izksagwd 222$ mafia? sxscshiitiaz ifixzgaixicd in an acciiieni. Tire :s::w.»3m§ ragga:-naiezms in iégsse "appé3.i:-; are LE2: iziaimanéez being file: injurtxi vizziims sf firs: ac-uiémi r izgiwixféng iizrwe s.«<:fiis:iv::s nanzrsi}-* ajt:§:§.:* hcezzizzg E*<§s>.i<:z"--'s. E*f~}:'~£§,-'ix-'ié, 3 5 ianksx' hcarixxg NQXIKCL 33 B 34352 sang} a. £wu~aaii2::::.§«}¢'r».__i}e;i;:;"i;1g N¥;;.KA 1?': K 853, The ::.=.;:ve1"a£ {}§,§-(3l§'{3fl.I1§'.$ mi' iht: vs§i'Eg:§%:>s;_ Em:-§:z£i_~%LE"i§'§c {§s::é,€::.;:s£:£§ dzéxacr c.>§i§"zt: ir1s.umu' _§¢:ep_ whiath '§§*%;g~15"§'!l:S££F$i;3; .§_;3}:'-%.§1é.=: agtpeigani. Thé c-iaims wtsm §}f€>f%}'§"t:L.§. i;»y ;_ 'i=§;r: iE§{..:-§§_:§;;,; ..§§*.v:3i'~.i%:t.: =:<.:fii::'§::-z»; £22-wfivatai, namcigr, §§':::: gimp wsui i}2r:_ig11;ii<;e;r ;i:i'1n::n in 2; 2212;? ncgiigeni n1ar_2;f::=:r a;1l€:ii_.§i,.§s.uf;;_ §§«i.:§.:;§;é:zi 's§:§*§§;':":~;aa:;na: 1:12;: ihc: £:'£fi.':£:é<.§':{£§ frzaé ua:«.::.::*:*Ted iféviéj £w:§~s7a3§2rc:§.:§.r:i";""v2'§iés:}": Wicitsi .{%,2§'mw§:1g Em: E.:-miger hzié ai2{§--::z*a3§1s.::;i- inité'.§§i€;«.:;é%*§:;<.:.-§"§}»' zséziue €.?§ §§}£i nsgiiggstzécaz gm §j€E§: par: g':f_VE;§1t_*; t.§:§":xgt:~: V2.15 E315 Exééii s2e::§z§z.:ia:~:. Tiéaa {i'::'£_:-'er :3? fim jctssg w'3.:~: aim éiztt uwmsr gaix ihfi xrsiaizzfrc aizéfia §za:;§ :j§%¢:ii in fine :«,:<::.:is_§icz2i« §§m:.>§a.;" as £§:t;: gaaszssngarx £3 iirx: jmp aw: {;::3sm:::r"r:r::(i, 3252:": warm 3%: e.>s.:a:s.:pzm§g in aii éncizsgiéaég ihz: _;§z°_§:¥€t§;*, 22:15 2% §?a3§:c:§;_$::r$ $23.2-5:: Eaaéigaggi atiaémg §};:»2" £3-§?§E§§.'.¥!3§E?§%§'§.':€§'fE'§,; . .V_§=-§%:§£:.§1 wag ragizaészzi E3}: 532% a§,_3§2I;:§a.§§é §.'I€.:E"';i§§3, w¥:;> r,.:a§§:§s.:::;i5£fi.- ézzéa-3"-« aiia, iézai EEK: %sz;:§1és':§e xaaag magi in %s§.:;;§2:§%;s:': at}? aim ;::s,':»§%;4;.:j'g«' :;:>:1£.§§§§2:s§::~:g 6 E1 was §>ar£icu3.arIy' tzunicmdcei $131 $1: ziaaxiing e;:'fdg2zzV;.:%[§Vj;,*"La§,'f $11: ' ssahigtic wax: iirniissd and E}:r;:§"e;:i1.:err: E323 :§:§i:z1i7{:e;_i ;3<;:~;i«Ei2;§::'.i§2ai--.€§1c§::: wart: E8 peupie iauizzéing $25 giritisr, 'irafisgiiiazg :::'_i é§:«.£::'~ i%m'e~ <§,>'§ mzuiécnl was. c-ieariy in vi<.rEa§iuz: uf"i,%:§§' ;:',«e.3Eia;}é ~;_:m:=.;£§s.m::;s_ This has been :sp«:s_:i§i€3§1y c:::;ien.:ii:dfit1 5€_.§2s:i- 2-:iair;::r;_:é5ni 05: a:5:3jm..:i.iuns fiimi bcfizm {he Tri§:3un;gE;-- V "
3. TE: T_1f%§.3un$i ~h::if£=§.'j~31z,§i---- ..E}-axigrsti an ism: as regards films:
xzéuiaiign sf _£iA1?:: p{2_ixi§3yV u:;;§£§{iun..insufar as fiat: Saki aflvjccéisgn its uuncernt:d,. §:=.:: TriE3LL*§a§ _ i'1:<s;.§"';§;ii;§:rr:§s,@:;ii {Em é:{.'3f°3i€fi§.i!;}§2 m.§:.=.t::.i in _ I=§u_i§2€~3.f§§9'§' Eézzi hazigi Liza! the agptsfizitxi herein haai 1:0? *;::€:~ri:.2:;t;<i"'::s;;}g':;:1a:r¢ri:¢zi in Su§§§}v;%:'i cf the L:<mi::n£§u»n éiraai iim sezxzzziéng £.§L2.p:«;2éiijg,? £v§V.'§im'T:x%éhic1%: ingumi was lizzziieaé and ihai iizt: gvasgcngsrs far axcéczgiflai figs: gsaikzg uagaciigs. Whereas in ii}: méiuszr claim geiiiignfi inspiis 4:3? at aptsuifia: Qhjsuiign %;a2«'ing Egan migfizi by Efiie " _f;§:§pz:§§an§, fifit rffibunai has faéiazai iv: aaidrssszeg firm tame. ii is Efzzis rimani azenianiiun ihaé. is sosnhi it; be: rajgcai in 32$ 2;!' 3% £23 , E szuzzicmi ihai, $325: Trifiugzai has iéiicé firs aégimss aim maiariai Z egesnsiaitrraiizm igauiizr as Ehs agzpciiazfgi £3; <.:-§,2:1e:s:"n::zi in fa::i§::i:;;z:g' {Eat Eizéiiiiy in ihz: Séxiclli {sf L'i{)% uf E}!-53 azaaargi rziagirs i1'§..~§;£'§'f§}~*.£_l;"€35 {E33 :13 imarfiés»
4. That e:m.:nz~;t:§ vmufd ;:in§ mg:;§=_£}L>n3 .55.;-::'* »}'114f:i[€;;¥:'"'i§f:i;§V'£;*1f3;V rr.:~co§*d_, namcfi}! {hat poiécy 9? é':v:§.i:::1m:::, *'n...?«.{i1'§'<».:-.§'}'.= i:;"gmar§<kce;i as Erdzibii R-5'? iimi file: .*:s't::;t.i%}f}.g'~..¢;::{§3;_£§:§§}fx(;y§j§§:%f;§§.§3£:p 'A.-'a3 v7t:I"§: much can rem-urd and iiiai E: was "L.l.I1{,V§'.E§f££i§:V€;.',-91,3 --":.~§e§<;;::2_'z:::<r§*ni. Vfhez peéicy L3?
. . . * i % I' E K antsumnec 1m_11§_,.;;i.::: ymzdi §,.&1¢.: saaézzzg :..a.p::u:2§y was. em}/-I (L Ema:
agimiiieai'-;:§L:§:iEic:n xizam irawiiéng E3'; £316 jeep wmzié inciiazait: ihaé ii {gr <.:.?é§.:-{:¢i;§*:(§ii:§ acccpicé sssmizzg ami vmuigi §°$3§:?.§f:'.I"
"V'§.§'}'€:v'V'i:'(:f3}I;i.'2'i'§?: £'§:«.:::;_z;:;r£.::.§u$-.'9§j§: :,::;a:-;;3;m2§§iz:§2iL: zigzi hmte E33: apgmiiafié L'--wa;:~;-§;ié:z:f§,};<_;::i§3$§€::§?w:..§ L)? Eiabiiéijg amiss Eéw pg.:sE%;:§n Ti:.;:: *"i'r.::$p:2n:i~::z2i:e hzwingg, btrczn Scswcd remained * ££A§§2«'=:'.';*-.§'¥'€$t :'§°§i.$(.§ except 3%: ifistzrsr of the £xaaL:~z&I§':;:c:§<:r, stain: is rft"-ps*cé:::nimi by ctzunstzi. Sins:-ts E22 xvam 2§b3€.':«§vt:d :3? gay fzméi ami has my ciaim in $33; pyasczné. §3§'0£C€f=€_§§£g§s', Q16 prsssni appsais have gmgtz l£¥!£:fL?§§§fi?}§@£.§. "£3322 g3z»e:;%tg:>%k éiz-:1 i.;;§§}§i€§f énzsejzivsni has Exzsz: zsszzrvcai in sszzverai €31' {Em zzzppcaiag whiesii 2::-5; aii cer1i'$é:%;ii:£_fi'," }E§'z;:§,/,' Msv. rcmaimzgi 1.i¥1'£'§,3ffl'§3t-lt'Z!}§.'.;2(.'§. Thgmgiz :§e:rf;€i£ié:"§'s:;::-: 2:25; _3:*sr: e§:.;:§§3::a§'§::{§'--én ' gems of ihessc agpmiss, Eh: 25313;; is nuiV__;ri2:§::r§:2&, 12%: =s::$£:§"g3a:§}g has remained cxparifs in uiirzcr £3-§,?V;5§*.;*1t§€3§€:{.§ a.;js"§.*::_;:3:a§:;,V§§2 €.'»..§hit.:§2 ha Tfiar; btzitzz 31:,'-rwszi.
S. Aa;cL}:é'%%§§,f§y, its whgéimsr iim Tri7m£z2a§ a:§4='f§'¥«'é_; :3? fix atswré mad: an §.§1*::- appeiiiani-§§2s:::':a1;ce caympafigi', 'v@3 :*;'aai::r§a.i 13:: rcwrai £0 ém§§%é:2s,§.: ihzgi theft; 'xaizgss 9. £:§::.af '*s§QiaE'is3§ 13$' 31¢ §}£.'i:§§:}f' a::3§§£i:éE%:..3 En fizz: afiazégiaic V' Eszitfséizzg §;.z£:t:¥; {:$E!1"§{}:&L§t:-!..§ &§:s_;nei fig szzaéingg C£i§T}?&£:§§.'};H !§§'E€»:'éi€§f)§£§'1§i§<::L§ ariraunzsiangs iizaé iimrcz we-ya: ES pasgzfigarg agaézasifilc scaiéng ;:a§2m:§i§»* asi' é ssigtariyr ytzgsiirsrt:-ii iim sass? ax {gm-: ' Vi.=%.:5hezA*'€ iilféffi 'wags vizziaziémn §:«u§i;:}i a:a:s::<§i§émz. Eisacg, Eb: '§2"%§3::z§;»;§ ~--§:a%,:'i§§g Eigiiezsai 32:3 e:m23§g§:.*§ éirgég mi}:-aéizxzniizzi .:.'::~:;:::*'-:,:i 512$ Ems €:3§°E€;}§}t',£3£i?§§}§ §':«::§§ éimi iiizzrrz: was, Em zgzeaixrizé §?§:»§.£:%::é 6:2': r€::.:z.2:"§ Ea} acgtzzpi iii: &:{>§:is::;§éz,}:; avg? fix ;.&§a§:<~;§§a:zE. $11: §,§é%;s~; ggawzgzgsi :~:.i5a_>§::v,.: éém 8 35 a,pp<:i3ani---§n2;:;mm:: £3-€,}£}lpEiI}§/' wu:,;§e:.i siami *¢b:su§%:mi :3? any Eiabiiiiga The aanuunis in dcpusii in 522.53: of §.§"m:§.g ap;3::::z§s"'s--E§za§E biz: re-Ecassci in ikvaaur (pf fiat: ::24p;:}::I§;:;::i--§n:~::.2r2:nx:t: scn3;3a:7,§_::_._ 4' » ' ~ Ac£:e2r;iing§}¢ fire appeezis arr: a§§:_>2,='w:&"'in§~:<,:iEi';*. ';+1.V:~: ./éiifi. appeiiazxi-insurance a:-mmpan}! is e;-<3nr.:5::'me;§; .."i"1':§T»a;§aé:£§;:.nVi;é"';:réiiétfi £0 ihctir remedy to I°':.?£Z(}¥'€'.'-I' Ehc :»1_'..-xi-':2_1*d zxfixvzgzzi _§r::m"'VE,§:'cVvgmifnmr 1:??? fizz.' §333z:§rc:d '2j't:;§;;£fa;T}.t:.(H If} A