Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Central Excise And S ... vs M/S Bill Forge Pvt Ltd on 5 April, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
{By Sn Ni A N2:u"a.ya:.1a, AC§\»'€)<?2:ii.E:3
"§"'§°§z":;1s CEZA is fiieci E.H"}d{*.3" E3e::':?;[.i.(m 356 635 ms: FI«'~*='-- " _ 1.'
Actt, '§.E."M-4. asmsrisimg Um. Uf <;>.1"t§.e;~:I" aiziied 22~2«-;?;€}'§O;_*;.. . . -0 .
®:re:§<%:r* N0.51é:é;'2O.H'), pmy':ing 30 {Q} (0 ciec:<:L{§€ 2V.h£:_§ c:§1:1éstss:&im;és%s«T£3?
1.;-m,-*' :~a;€4:;s.t€~:{:§ E'.E1:2.*.::."'<-:i;'":.3 {ii} SSEEE. aS~I;:§d("3 *ihc;3"I?'ina;i €3")¥'zV"tfEi>':s."--.[E'\3.w.'ff«E.'é3~.ff;>:f)ff)» 1
af§a'ée:%ci 22-M2--:2O'iO §;)&1:€:$:L§e£?i by 'g.1i(~3 Ci.i1..'"""§7/%"E'}' 'E§32:i:3;§§2%.i{>1f§r,'--3 V
ihfi: €f§%1ii.IE'1E,}.1'1€TE. as-as pm" mder in U'I"ig§iE1€gi. N_.6;5-%fGQ:'n::'1z'" E.;'f'E;;? <V'§é;zT_'§.:.:3:'<'AE
25/6[28@8. A '~ « '~= '--* -
'}''TE?13?::; CEA <.%:;'}m1?1'1;.;; u:~"s._ ilin" EJi€=§K2§R:§.fiC%?:E5_1;'{?)E"1 %..1%i§s~:s day.
N ' J" €i€;'%}?1'"'\i'é£.'.1"C€Ti théz §'0i.E<3\&-"§«:i;§§;
._...;..........¢ "m.___......_.........~.....,,,M...._....._._.'
fifinfimfimifi
TE'1:°s:e appez-:~:;5. V is "::»y' "'E.E':z'~rl& r'<~z*~¢.'.V<V¥':..tA_1m:'» zqigié-1E.E<it1'1gi.ng aim (N"°€i&;'.'Z"
p«;aa;s;~i:~:~sr;:<ti £33: tE.:..e:i'-."§'ri1§j'§.;._;:'121vi,1S€'é:%_;.§n.g;;.{§§:.::ie ,!;.'§'ie';: e::>1:"c;§s:>:* 'pas:;s_e&':d by" {Mai
.§;_o*w<":;* :é';1E.E.'EET{€T}K"i'{.J§<;'I-'If --«V._E_1'7(}lEcii':=;.;;j'<1.§;mEf my z1:'5s:§€:s:"as?:(=:%€:t §i22z¥.:3E.e M} §}E:k}?
§.m.,c::":;:"€:s:;«:E zmd ;m2a;%.:.3r""%'.<5r ,.'Eeif§<,Viz'1§i._{ 'athe (f3{:*.'m»*a£ trzmdii. ur.z.*:}:z':€g;§Eyw
K.../.1 " 'E'%1"<;*...iV_%§§<:VSus; zsftit zmé. in disspuu-2-9
3;, "*v§§'Ma~r.._z;::%;:%;e§ss{3r¢> is ezézge-aggeci. in r:.}."1e r"z;2a.m..1i'am.u..w: oi"
;:':'{::{a:r£:':%s&ew3:Ee:9}:--- ¢'§E* 1.'::":0§C:0;'* v<:*F;11?c:i@r;~; i';'=1E}Ei3;}.g mr':d<~>'1' (3.1:1.:¢2p'£:z:::" Si-"Sub
'V D""§tf-:rc:s.{§ .E€)9U <.;:=.§ (".3<:'.n'm~.1§ §€Z:>§."€ris§;c:: 'TE"a:*if§. "may zémir n~:gi:e'Ae:*cc"E
,,'m1:1cL§--¢::.}f i.§7£t:'T ('ffs:171.§";1'§ E;«:c%i:~:~;c Am", 1944?. '".F"E"m%}; a;3;\-mi (:{?',1'}'*Jé:"t.fl Cz'c:.*.ci'§£.
'E§>§_) "E1ZciV§i.)}"1i;'-'iii '
015' may p;':si.zi'§n {rm W16 il'}j.'}LI§,f$g crexgmzxi ;;;I;j()mc1r:s Quid %':hc:% Eaxzabkt
£*".'§t".RriC?f3E": a,.:§see;a;'.{.i in me mznmf2'.:c>£.um GE' .E."im:a;I pmduc:.E I L)i,:;'§':1_,g4,§ 1;§'1ci*
.*3s«;::;"'m.§ir'1y 0:?" {'.E"}€;'. ER E [email protected]:"M fa? €':}'1::% 3;1'1<m't'.h wf a}t.11':'<:%f",2§§¢I}f(;'?; 5:ii;__xv;{i:s
e:3b:aa;er\res;'E mai. me-: E3_E':'rt~§@'.":St-'»'<L'?(:'? E"1.:;-xii i;a}§m.'1 ..,fi32<;.€f%?'S§3'=. i.iIf£§C§i"§ " --QE"
R:::.:'3}§E%,"E"?fi4K§&3-{)0 on czgxpiml g0c}d:§; F§1E"I:§4'f:;';§fi"EE '
QUE. "M3 tbs: £3i_5.§ft3§EiS5E§€€?. '"£"hs;é ,az:&3ss€:&3s:m:% '*§;);V 't§}c:%7v,.:j Viesrmqezf'. é'£'€'§§V£:l;:€V:%»
'32§€.>§§u2{>€T}"? a€imi%;,t:eC§ me \2\,r,z'"?(;x«z:g;_*,'j~. ctmnmf'§._I,%éi:::%.7 f:he'::m é-i.I"i(.'§
i'nfi">x'"r[}'1e:%(§ iiéim Rf';"\-'f3i"H.i(ifL 'i:E3zm 't*i*1§1c§'.iy"Iiagzxré'-.R::\:'«:*re3s{a€§ "€§Vze:: s3z.m'm in
5.:5€?.'§}E.&'i',i'E'}.:'.)t'*,_¥"a i2€}i')'?fi They mm L'<ia§?:>;é' :;§.;"Lé15.*<$J:=f:,V Qj::fi3r an as-r2'm>u:1.I.. :35
R..~=sT£ 'i.€*$S~3 E --{.}O iX'1':}')€'i;}'X1'1t:=:fii :E)'i::§?:«Ci.iV%Af_i&:!..jé}.i(iFgVI"1. i"¢:>;* "me: :m;2::'3€..h (bf
nfiuéy 2:v€,}'0'}" *-;:m7:i;5E ..§.ii3;b§i!it5r C.'.'s]3.§€",fE'¥'};E:}L§'.®€'E ':ih@'mc::m a.-H
R.&'¥i.,1?'3'~/P5-V'{_)'(:}. _ms .-'5:l§f§'7,1:V(:'.'C?'.V:§,}&?é}'7?,"Q?-fffbtfifid mt; flxeiz" 1¥;'>'fi;.A ae3<::m.z'm'. mi:
2"F.U§3»20{)'?."--, &,§E'"2<f:\,*vA~£:a-"LI,flrs3:s: ITl.()'i'.i('.'€? xwm isa;.s:»'u.<~?<:"i 21.0 z..i'3€~:. ;:3i;5'>35E9é;'..*I7«€i'f€:3:
~ , t z.'.r.:?:.H»?.,:Ii;:s.:;_2; v';,:.?;f>:w;; 'z,E{¢:5':':;«?Q__§a;§2»<>w' <:m,.me am in \-*my' €':§Vmy' .é+;h0::2iEd. mm'. '¥':>c;":
:§.'2V:::4t'.a;*:f£\;s§ §f*%;:'z_r1::.'; pésrnafity for w°'r<)':1gEuiE 23i\F"E:':§1.[11(fi§'H" Ca? f[T7;s:m~"e'-1:
€_§'1€?'.E'Ef¥.O' ihfiiy :s1..:§3:"rT1_it€,eci 21m: '£'i'}'m _E'£'"iIiE%¥.é;1}<Z.i'ifi {if
-V %a1.i£<!i$'i;.z.. <ér<2dii, E1z;1;~i~: Q{ICLH"{'(:',{'§ méiy in '£i.h£7't a'::z>z§3i'£233 ;gm:»¢:§::'a
" V§;:*m:::c§.§'i E-E1E?,€'f?i.}%".§E'1.§. ;:m.ci moi: in the <V}£'.hc;*,r a<?.::?<')zmt... m--x.zi11<;*%y Eng.) L1?
{ie*."<:'*§t:Ei"§ ajzzd smfvfce; La-*a;><; {%w.<Li§£,., 'E.'E:.e. a?a.va'1§i.1m::'z'E£. mi a3x'::m1:~.a:§; cjwédit.
§:E1<:%1"«aaé2;.E"E.€3" :=szVzb§<;%m" 110 the Crc:<;i17E'. E:%u.Ee.~t~'s gémati. é1h§%:1féE¥:"s_)_'1';fu*:._ {Em
']I'm*'m,nA1a.1. :i.:zi1m':zx1m ed :51 :se1*i<ms €i'3,"l"Q}" 111:1 sas::*i.§i.'1'1gA_g 33.-:§i_c.§{%' 'i.Vl§?j':§;;=:.. E%::V},_rV"<;@f'
i:"m:'.:*&:~a?«s'z E"r::m': L§;m. ciatiss Q1." i.ak'ing_;' £?}"@CfiT,. Hf: g1"£:a:<:» :.(EEf.13'}i:Ei5E'1("§~C€j§ 1§_:h£-T:=§_
Hi 15 at <':§@2.1,r Clékfifif cl}? "{.E£.kiI1§.7-§ the (T7i"€{'}::i"[ w%:.mz'2g;i'y--TT xV.i..a_?1"---::1:'1" Vi'zL'1:t.<;*:}3;..io:'1
g.
mi' 2.-nruidmg 3;;my'me*::'1£. of t>xz:tis:m:iu'Ey \r$r"':i.=_§ci§': m;{:";~e£' .Vg:>ei~:'m'§i.§}rVmj:.£:%.
'£'.§:mw:=:f'cm;% -gm: '§'ri'h'm'1.z"-zl <:<m'1zzM1'1iti'J&3.g:§A' :11. :s;emm§é.a '<§rz"c)§j in .s'V-'.~;s;::t:E'.;i:'A:_?c';._{
a.s;.11:::§¢::r {Em _§;><:mahy i1'z1p<V>:a+éC§'~.i:>y {hefiftélam;I:1.§':as;i011m".
8. Pt;->::" :.:<):n'{.a'"a.9 the:é- 3':-=,~.:;~.';'~=:_'m:::§ <:.;;m.:;';§-,.e:;:_'.. e1p}::€ta~1:*i1'x.g3; f<.}'z' i.h<;*:
;?2,:'--?fF5e3T:€¢éf:§L'?.{-?. §::>a;>§.::"x3i~.e::c'§.._V (1%-'=.-..: it é.;_E1a!§ Vf-35e.«;.*.'i;;4,éTu':é':.f_"£..';_§_g{§{{3» {'t.?i_§')i"t:3E:':§%I}f gmaxnrjicrss
z;i:-mt: £,b;é"£' f?i':'a;€,:f{§=;fe5t is§?ip*9,y'éxbEé: f'.Z"{f?51:fi;VV3i.vE'1(f day me cimy E53 pe:L3r'e1.bEr3.
in <)'3"<1EeE*.3;a:$ gt:<;m"1.;3<5;:'§és<.2*:1f(av«_§.P'§i3< E§--'.~e*.\-'<3t'1u<.%. .i"<>'r £1%1<3 20555;; ssH:%sf:221.im%<:%. em
;1mm.u'1: mi' %c'§~:::§::=r;y€~_>;<:§ '_;3.£1ymt.r~:."1t 0'? duéyw fifivcaxtx in Rt.?E&"? 3:4 mm xra.-"E':£.c.':?s.
'_ :"t=:§%,_;§':::';:.<:c/3__i$ Q1;-1(.é€%€:§'; "{'.E?'§~fi'~«"-'()E'C§ u.se~se:d is; "'fE,§k.£f5Z} 0:" :,:'?.iEé;4ed vs:":m1g;2;§y".
QH}. &;fi<2e5.~3"7i'§{3£ ';~:«;é'a:;m H1211 xvisetm an <;?:n't'.:z*y is rzmticr in the: m:%<.:t<:sm;u,
1fi:k:;:<?J<;Wssi'; c3%..x5'§E';g;{A§i_ha.'§ z1ss:§§&%&ss3<at: "E553 s31'a'§i.1':'@ci 1.0 i,ai§<,;c% cgrreciiiv 1:2? £:E'3s;--: cimy
fl pzjud €.':;1'i:.;1}.mt:a; or Cz:1;:');i.14e;11 ggpodsg or izxpzzi. ;~.aes"vi<tess ih<":t
..'E:i¢;%:7:fz<:t;;"§.m3CE i.<::s zmy r::x*m:<':i.n ,E{ oniy. whim £'.h.a'-xi «:;;'mc§I:'E' is; :.a.i«<_e11 <31"
.'L4:i?".§,§'i.1+j'/;AE'.'t{T§ TE} {'.is1:«'§:::E"1m'ggf<=3 E'.§?:<3 Ziabi.iijt;y it» §"l&1}r' dL1i:_\y im .i.s;a '§T}€fZ'i{}f§§E,€'1(.E if
'£6
mcz?'1.z..§j'7::zc3€,:.Lrmtii an :'.'§'te3 a.v<;*rg; cfag; Ejfzai if. s;m:;~;-:5;;s;;:;._V
<:waz'.i<1xbZ<e, "
Tqi"}.<i'";tj3," aE:~i~m wok mate of 1.11%? g.g;1.1i<:1am:s3. ')T"§.('.}§..tE "2.'_m V€':A€'?§;i{'::s_:é:1'EV._iE'1g§;'»4
i..:"<::a%.'m c'-mi; Em' 1\f§OD'V;/Y1' which zisgs-' 'is'-,j"'€;*'£;-- . Qu"é:"_' E13' '*E'.1aé.;;:: ii.§."€Ci)?L.?¢:T:E§&ii..§L{i§'
J {sci g;;'11m'z'2 3. an pzezzra-~2Z£ am Ui"1€.§1{'§i'fi~
":23. .Le.?ar*;'i.c>(i. {if<)zI'g?':i3VV;<~;%€.?' _}'L<n' £:§1_<3 ":f?<I5$g;:?{,3.;'?c§.m2
zno2d.<;% re§f'E;?r(3r"ac<;? {(3 'She? "C}:;z'€{§).€:'r::ce§a'-.N'<.)£z:= €.>%'31V5:z.c<:£.é:.m.§27'r'zg;
€'r"m:1£.':ne;m,f fit)?' .I.Vfi3f"}.{,?£fi'§"-_ a;%_s:' 1{>§4:'a:. '§€'_"3€~"-._ Maz"<;'?'1. .f;'r?S3f5
£.:~;.<;me?d Fgzy Vim: :':"zs{j;_'.{.j;.£:e2V <..g/f_ CE1.£L:;*§.~c:2:?:-{iii;A§'<:?<>:.:.r1Eiosms Qf
.Em;>i'£s,:z.n _..'"1"!'%g-3 "C";1aéciiat1{?E3 ,f\7<3».iV<:}"'vkiegzis fir': pcw"z:1.gr"€.ag3i'z $3}
.b£;J'€.'{'3"i.,"i/3;'i??C()'{§§1:35i??§}'liféfiili1,§?'E€Fi~f5~E'?ii esases Qf €n.{m§'.;~:; z..:.;~;c:?z:i in.
V;;_{"c>:" ._';*<aE:j1;z4£'{m.._»E0 i';'ar._2§1i2--.g_facrmre off jTi;r"1z:i§.€ p2"od.zm'i.". H.
;«;'zr'§::€:.%':¢;A: ' ' V H '
V "if: 'E'§%£-3 E.igi2f of £:}'m eC'Ii§'3OI):';:*. :15 mag; be:
5€.<::z.iié;*€$v* -------- ----.»';n?.a£' M0a:£z_>a£.. :19 <3: }:>§"c.)-:7@{i:.z.;'e3
>. E:a>}'j_m6rs:bg; the 1'n(m.ag;'é:2:ci'.zamt" C.1{;'é??. mliiisw
jb?" 5peer<;:'§fzf.e£i1. ciuiy zm iI?j';)E.l.'eTZS
C§$gcz.i:Az.5:£ d;z.z.§,g,; g.;M1;;}aZ'JZe on fz'I'"2.a§. prayc/£2.zc{.:::.
IL3:.£.:'.gg £'¥'£i?df{i m.3<:cm on z'.n.pu.i:s is {Lgf z"fw
;r"a{m.:,m Qf s¢>i,~Q;f_}" a.um°E(;z.b£e;-3 z:zga.m.s:§ £:'?w
_g)cx;.;s7'2er'z.i Qf wcciser du.£.y on £'E"s.e f:'H<:z:Z.
E8
{E9} EVE. 'i':§2e.* sawarzci (,2£!:e;??"r'"e<c:::.£iLnc;2
ELM? <:c>s;:E' Qj"a'.r'1p:£.§'5 rn.c1.y be z"€émz"(i<:*<2¥i aé. 5-my ~ T
§.e:>£aE m'm:2z.m{ paid Ea?) i;?1é3? 5t.zp_;qE:€2§'« " T'
i'm?ims:£.:?.se2 Qf {he speeQzj,;"z"e(£. a;f:.:.z..§;_; an gr-zp.2_:;-:.aV.j;-.. L"
Tara» §§'?1é:.? €3.3C!.e'3F"E'§, ézim R/,f§1ar:2i:;:.q{ <if7'c=?o§ i'.?"' V
2:.:£.fiE€A:se2<2' L;'*c>r psqgrwwrki q'ff e::x;_.'c:i;~:éé 5.71.533. ?<*)':'1' ' V'
u;7é'm:2AE ;.m><:iuC£"ss, {.-':9 (T/?;}'"r'"E7(?;'v§.£.?"1'.;'5 <:<>u?E1e:§;_.E;%£<.>'
n
crresciémcl. so (:2; se%'pQ€E'cz.{.g% b£c:é:Q§:r'2.{,
M'o€£:.a<fa.Z' ai?:'e:f_;dizf' Az;¢;§.?g:?V;§£'v ._/1<;::.rg':>a.zr1r".'
im~.=~ Met>cf2.aC2.€;.__£}?'"e?dé2', A;2..2r:§:i£;g;z{_,1E» _}--'1;:;'g<;.)ai:2£:'» E'?'%.€;'
cm1<>u.'n: 63;" 1':/f-<.}A§Jiz.>?"::'2" :{%.:re:r:i§E1»AA_ §fi§§:jk=z".€.a%C£ "m
r<g%.$3.g§gé<:--§ _ Q)" §_{r<)rVLS1m 2;:2fii:i.;._r:9";; « Lgf '§.:'z;:>;:.£:s t.U<)u.¥e;f§
_.5;:ra:z* r'"é{r;'§5.£'gt;?e§*(i'qj'}""(.)-7}': E.3[§<,-r :1"c':»E"§2:.E <§<§sE. zfgj" £ng:}z.:.£.s
V .VV5c:*<;:%fja$»';.£zmékif'. "Z'?'1e:z' ;5f.',;'vJ£"»LViC2Z'.s"E(.'t1-,? <fm1<;2:,m2':
-- &a;V2'i'(.:.'.=.:.€2?._i.372§g z";éV:V._Vifh<».: €T?"'é:'C§{E Qf J':/i'<:»c"i.:.>a£' e;'.r's:25f,€Z'
" AL:1c1iEé;:'afi;' V.AC';I:_o7€s:'t'{ !"(':?_}/3F"{3S(;'¥'E.§.f.Z'E§f M"<)<:f.z,:m*':
.,c:r'e':-:'1ii£"._i.;";A~%"esp'e3<:£, Qf ing;m§' r'2o{:' t.*c;=2"1.:s:1:2..;"ne:*d
bz£ii=.?.g_1;jir'r.5;;&i;~"': zwmcic C(::u£(;£ 3:38 :i~;?"1.mm"2. in I:E[2;<.?
'"«f>C§§C§,?E§..f€9 sfieeai. as de<?iz..z<:'ITéc:rrj2. fmm me?
£;3(_I£..§.;..:.<'? €I§ffFTE,5é??1.£i'{}£"y.
" '€3.35 V
E9
'13 Tha-2: Apex €c;:,.m in 1;E"1<*r <:2x$€ mi"
MAGNET WIRES {P} LTD 'V CCE, rep0m3<:§ in
{SC} (:k*':z*fii1'1g \,VU;E1 )'.V.'IO1")V'A'"I' CI'<:'diEf. h¢:>;Ed ass m":':€_ir_:?.:',:V _: V A
7. in m's;?2j.:_a {Igf i'Ez.e c:;fE)I"s3s;cLz'»§_;i e*_i::;2j;';;s'"£<:§é:tfi.£)z:i."EJQ" A'
£')<:;§g:::w"'mteen6', ma-r $65 no v}'"F_:.'£Tl.'~f.i()?"'l"- u'.5E'%_:; §:'§1.£:?v-- V::3$§:§e?E-5.s:<5';3 '
(?CI;F'2N.€)iI rmfzzcuiesa <11 'fiebifi c':n{'r'y "z??:z.§»3 <:n§'d'i§,. aixzicijgzz;é€g?;§¢ff'Z")§9e;.?
m:m>z.:aE. :3" 3:? N2 ex'e;2'1pEj€;?d. 4§_9?'i?§f.IAé.£?iI.;' " '§fV_€I:?'i.!}j>5 {$635355
e:+*n{.r°§; is g>a2z~rnE3s£.b£sg "En beg? n;r,2;,VcL'iieI:r..q_ w¢g§~éc£,i:' e3r2£r";.; JQT)?" King.»
dL:..i.f.i,e?9. ;;)aid on {E18 m.p$.;:;:§ .:fi:';r'z.a.gi'm:%§.'z,£..:*'er Qf
'2'f:?*"z¢;% féngzf. §2.7»;f{}%t'r;;>E:'{;>c;f?_'_3:.é:'a:';£f cizsissieaci in. {he-::%
€).?(?{T€')'E..&,fE{'S:1_(2f'g: '£29,. ffrji 53iib?'2. a :i;§r'z,s(1.£.£€:>:'a. if
{stir-'zz'm£; _E:re.;:s%z,:éc>I i'T.F~:a£" 'f€.%:é'§;:. c::5s.'>:es:§'ga<é"f1(z:r E£:I?r€€ez':. ct2*~e=:zr1?'.z'z.fzi1:r"
Em: a7'iiV£{'g;;.j.v 33511555, .o%':;.._ §;fi.e-- 'z'npuz:3 z:;2i'iE2"e;e3d. in {has
:'¥1£':?}cz.§,fm.?§,aam: .rf.f'2'k:-,-;._;_?j'2:T%";.«i§e;£" ;f::<emg3{'<:3<::Z g:'2r"o:tEu.<r£' :m.e:€ez* Ekiazfes
.3 /A. Lin, oE:.heer_ m.:mi£§;,_.E.i1c; Lizxzmfcjr e2<'é3n1pEz<.m mg} (mfg;
jsiim _i'jh,e> d.;$;;f»;V.££:'e'cz' g'00Ci.3 <:ar'mo£ be d.m'2§e3c§. cm rm §}Z(?;*€T£
'"£}2,ir;';: am aV;~f~;:.+:<3s'$é*éé'§:3'E'Aza:~; §.:<:z.kc;=.'n <:rc2(:ii.!. Qf" E..}"z.e.> 5/{u.€§.; pa:z",(:£ on
=.fi?'1'£f iI'1Z§i«if"§§ .:_zsedi. in mama.gf'ku:t'a.:m «cgf z:m-my gc:><>d;:';. "
'"E7'}}'c§..Ag>2tx Czmrf; in the {Ea-1.86 0? CGMMISSIGNER SF
€'3E§;iV"E"FiA§i;wE'XCISE VS. BOMBAY DYEING 82. MFS. Q0, KITS.
..§"§?p(}1.'§T.fV:?{L1sii} 200'?{2i5) EL'? 3 {SC} heid £155 m-166;":
kk/fl_,..
BU
Z_fnd€z'" ffle? r'20§.§fic.?0:I.'i(;>z'2,. m<)0E.:::.> £33?" ;:>ag,}';I5rT'i(;!:;é.L'E=VT.
$10.3 mtg" E39132': prees<:?z'€be<::2',. Fzmimr, wce;T--:*:;;;:-:g-;'::T *'
g:;;€z>en €10 {EH3 finai _;:)rociur;'I:§ :?':€1r"r'ze2£;J;,..§g.ri¢%§;.ufixfirigr
':..mc3Ler" me Cc3:'V2.i'z'aZ I*}.;'€Cfi.;':'£e£? zrm E';?:L*4éh §ge;_,>g; ' {sf V;=m=
m:zfzr':Vz.gfa::z,<;r£::;'r"e but g;>ag;:'2'1.c?m, ~'. a7t.( iféér :..z"z':m3
<;::'.era:"a:":<.te::a. U'nc§.c2r' {Em fa€?_£;~--..:;»C>z.g,;:%;:.e:.r'2E <3" dz.:v:f§;}:;»~:.'x..¢_§;§zr§'?
Fsazfi. 50 be at Ehe :~;pmd.£.c3 _ E:-_j€oiL::¢3i>fc;n'~gV'u..>?'%§::': we:-2
¢.>0rng.e (:0 {W3 I"§3('G'!"§"i.p€.?O'f£"";?'VT{i_i'§.'}iz;§€£.f:@031 _z\i'§<_§.=§_ L'%f f3{}(;?L2»-
{TI.E:?., z"Em ?"(i'E;1li,I'F'"£-;T§§'E<;":}"§f7 z;L::«§z.{s} if1.b{E: §e:<fi%§:2:.'%p':':'£cm on yrs-,>g7;
j?ctz,E.m'c'.s+; a..:2a_rs.~t c1<fi.rA}-:;%§§:.;<;_:i?r3ie* --.$2.;;}5?:éi?f mi_'--::E1e'.> €2.:s;;2:<:3s.&;e?ce
;:>c1.§;£.3-'lg;t;£2}£sf:e; :.:T)?1 §}.;arr2;2 §:>~é:3}'1:im"é.»§C;:iVr'z2::;i1:;;; cxe3m;;>€.fc>?1 cmd.
5~:£,£;'.;;§}§€§c:?z, ';}t:::V é'T:*:'e':'%'_;:z£;
==;e:=~r:.*V 3&9{"'%:§'£ajz?2€3":§; C?I:?N1/AT Crce:2fi§.
fbiéf;fi()Z"é:?. _ i<;:::ou' _;»-£;j;~':,} 4:2',i'<;m,1p:{V£(;>zT;,;§ '§~=f":.<:* qmasggiarz :1"; j '
:.:(r,»c¢>r'§tjgfi$:§.é;.;'¢_&&}";§o}'r":.-.§j<:zQ§'rTa¢?;:;%: Qj' dui§.;; am. greégg fi1E;m'z;L.~1;
z<::§z"¢'>'s:§3 an :'€,'§f" gm» sgtczial msw ai?:<m.(£i.£.'ion.5;. E :1
£.E'1§f.§;L.._4¢t;se.x ;')_z":z;;._i7'2c-%s:_i..£: of ciu.£.y cm. yevz.m an z:ie§}L>rrec,i
' " §::sg.'z:§;tl$ E:'€;<?i_V§g§'€c:.<:£~: beg ,{1t)ra-3 <.?Ee?c:.§'ar':.c?c3 Q3' ' §;':'e2_;,r __{E.1?.;xr"f.c7s am
3~,§?:11§'1.i'€f35f7§.€i'XTé;??§ifi"i'i€f%'3 was (TZC£i?"?'1t?C'§. '§'i'm-.*r<2;f'Ei:>r"e?, p(,ag;r'1*Mz.s;:+r2,§T
" _ ""2r'2r1:2{1(/z:fi<:e be,j_fo:*e3 {Em sa':¢:zg¢: {)fG,Y€-?F?'I§)'?f.£T)E1., S:'z'n.iEcu"E§;.
V';:;;i_*';»,;:;ag;2»;-ms: Qf" ::.iz.z.£;.; on £"h,e3 mpuf {g ;£¥.1'"fl} {EM
,_;:::4é5:;,c:;4;:~;.aa%rzr gguf. {hes <'.'r'ed.€Z" wE'::.z'.{':2'z :..a>a5: ne.:*w:%z" a.:2'.iE.é.:2:m:é',
" . }*A"'¥zca.§l bcj;"<;}:"<: z..L§f1'§:iza:.z,£ igm. 1:516 cr'1£.r'y has iaeeam mvzsrmgécf
w§"z:'.{??'& «::;:mcm.n.£s; EU no? £IC1l}CiI'1§} Cr'@<:f,f!"'. §*:%21"m<:, En. {his-3
<'.'€."I.;~§€f?¢ §;<)£.f'2 {he (3()?'I€§i{§(>¥'?S mas: ;;ai:'é:gj1'ero§,. Hc2zz.c<;r §.::e:%m
mm. Qf {hazy 'é".{1§Z)§.€' E30 I\fi:2:jfE<:a.z':£.on No,.E4f£3()(};.2?w(;T3EZ';.T
Lm2..2.E.d cxggzgflgg and czx3c'<'}rd,z".2'2gEg,g me gjgrey
aa><)uEz"2', «:.>2E.z,'rw:>§. mi! ram qf'z1uzy."
. E3" 'E'E"m% G 1;1_;Ta.1'a.fi. Hi?:_-{h C01,: If I739: '--i;}.'1A<--:: <.--§:'§" V j
W' CEN'3"'R& EXCISE vs. ASHIMA. ';':z.47;Y£*.'}(:?£i:' in
mm (232; Em 589 (Guj) m:~@;:~;ug V:-QT'm:»~1.1;:;i:;m;:,;£z~a;;>:,z_:-'
Mavzgneai W2'm'.u=.~: {.?"}Li'{:E.,. ifiaeid L£,§1d.¢r'-"',V:EA-"liw~. '
V . . 9. O:'ic¥; ' C2g;:'g;ri>g)r:§§fi§;'i.c hmza? baam
:'2mde2-.3 in 2'he. ré3g}i:;;;ae:*;v»£§fg'er'é9-- _;r2.'c:r..V:_"zrfii"»:¥;> ;.v£.:,'::'u71¢rr" E..£.J§'EfC§"£.
'i"E"z<=:? _pr*(3c.;Y;§3$éijj:Li§§a.:Ed _§:><?€Lre;§£,:e}*Sc:;fi';~V.' EiF'{£€3 mm" 27.5212?
c:§V:~.%:~";<33;*::;<3:§<:;Vc§ _'f--'r3.a§£Es" '§iq;>'i: Em;-1'V;"A:'Vi.<:a:if:2;saefri».:sapa.ra.£:'<sé <*;'z<;:<':0:_:n£:::; or
§r}*¥§ --5;§?%&?V % i;i3:2.§{t'.s:. __ z:.f§§2':se2e:"§, jar m£:zmg:f'<:s.<:.!1.£r<3 Qf"
a§z.;a's--i§:E;2E.gr '!ai;F:'£§i'g;.; j'}"€£? g{,><.}ci:sx 4:25; 5;§mu.27€§
'5'*2m>e-,¥ '*}':3e:.>e:5?'r'y V€3 QI' 2£i?.5» Em: (L*0z.:.ré""$ cu"£:er2,r,z'mr1. zz_.v:z:'~;:
fZx*5m:;~~g 5;; " V:.Egg_ ;if..c;3czr"?::ne:>r"smi a'.2V'<:z..:Zc2;r m?<'7<)z'<'fiir"zg;2 £0
'zfxig cz <:<:>z::;e where gm» z'rm.ra:4gjTc1c:§,zmar _;.<'2mcim:e2.'3
--:"£:';::j'::.:*.¢:f'::cfeV}:;?Eé-,*VT.(Q3433 pr()du.<itf's omd aiao fl'f'1.€ii. §;()::'::c§:s: u,:?'z.i<.;r?'2
are _,"'"m'm Chzty a2"::"i if 2'3 H.512? re:a:~s:0zm§:rE.§;
g:V2e--i£<_s::;<3fE;ifi5<a so 3eg:r"eg§z.E:e €upz.z{:4 z:S,;i£és;ec:i in r2'2.(»:m.,;{7czc>i3'ama
gfffigfi 1' Ezhe? c:f.'u£[z'.a§3Ee3 h_,}"E'.i"2..(,"/ii ;)r<)€m<?{.s j'?*{m'& {E153 f:'.z'mE
" prUa*m7f"5.s u.:f'1:icE:.. are axe-smgzzij fimn :",f£.ii",§j,, £3a.1se=*¢"£ an
£ET:.§:s;§ rm; (T3c>u:"i',' ?2.e3i::"§ Shaft {Fm mamgj2:z(7§:?;.e4mr" mag;
23
§;m"2<a§f%'£' ?'1m~s 3.0 be g:i:...=r3:t of EM: z19£'é}"i.e:?c2.£i(;n. §}F€£f'i'§.f?i;L,_{%"* V
e,>ce3n'zg3:.i()n rare: ("ff :fl.m'.g; an £"h(:% f:'n(,:£ ;Jr{')ci.:.z.<?;jsz:..$'£,z';g§%g~:V:
E'-(E-'£V{-II!'/') re3zT:=<:>z":+:r:2.E Q5' C2":-aaféti «rm z'i'2,<:+ 'm;;>z.s.:[ mm; dm-:;'2:.:;:-'3 af§Ii..T§*:§§'"&§§
'£T'z'"i.E3:.z,:w;!':s: s£.<;;g:;e;, Whfie a:*riv:";2g Q2! this;"(%{1';'=€{rEw:e$§€e:s:-'3.'_
£'?2.£:? /%_E£5z§mE;:c2L§ H19}? Com"! E"2rf.':s ?'{;j';*_'41(:,-§I"'.:¥v'€:"'€','{: 25:54)' 'L%§1fé:):;£:;§7 'V
:}¥.,é.€i§}§IFZ£:??{ES zu"z.d<-27" u,=P:z'c:Ez:, smfi'.:jz:£::§%;sa;e:z€
8£.£§3:T»€:?qi.zc:'z'"i(Kg; e:m.d séiii éQ"2.§?'?;2s;ne3f"f£." =V¢,;cz:a:_ gT1é»:e..;u;"+r"a:._:£:¢;;~~£.E'§..g%
asx:<:sa:e5:;s;a3<9." b ' AT ' I' V
'1. {-3. Wm: Apcsx f°LfC%..2:_1"1. ~:':r&E' KTNIGN 'SF Iivflifi 333$
B/ifs IN_Q--SWI;F"3"' LAB0RAT{>R§E3 in <:m:§_ Ap;'>ez.11
Nm.1:<§,¥?6/Zifikfi. '352:;§§i'r:°1:>z°é:i.'i1}gg {ig~. 5;? €.jZE;N\,'A"E" C:§."('_'E3..i'i' §"€:':':§¢.:~:s,
§2;€Tfi€'}4- I5 #"m;3;€:!
L' :2» ' V/?;;V.AIE'3;i:r?:«££'--..%f€§dbIir':§"; of fhsi $«c:2.i{f. R[.£{€':? z,:;3<.:»u§<§
_ _V€z'2cii.1f<;rE2:'£?»::;_:V £Ev'r.xfs.}"r fffi'€;" V§':%"£!;1*_I'21,{.;'b;CE.2.ife,?I' 0:' Ems: g;>z'ow£<f}1m" Q!'
g3:sfg;2::.éz' ':';?'.é.-'€'_1'f'.¥.1'é".€?(;? i)z3(?¢_)r":'1€;<,; E.z'a.Ir3£ee :50 gzsczgg z'ar'3.£'.<;z;r°e:e:2f:
_ve:fA"J:.f::f>;Té--g;'§fi2'2;'iif?'E. {'§1.<:> c£a.xi.g; w§'zere;? C:':'£'N'E/AT (f}"€;"{.?§,§E" M13 §:3¢-?<az':
" vv§:{*J§§a"g:%:w',V i€.f}5TV.:iI.E.f§'§Z€3'{T§. usz"<:)r1gi§; or hczses 2';3s~e3g-,.>z'1 <2->:'"?'(3z1a»>?<:>z.:$£.g,:
§f<jf'.§';i:1r §§_,:{€;:*{2% <;m,(;T film" in fhe case? (sf am.» q;j'l")r@:sm"c:i.
. §5sA{'x4E.{:§'<.e §'§"2.<;+ {J'?"f}i.?iSE{)£'E of S<2<,?iz's:m. E £.A_E'3 :..m'uZa'. {_:1;3g:)E.;;_.;
<;f}{"/7<3zj?£'z'ngf.} Su;C?"r mc?<)m3r°§:;,
.
A§§'€>»\~ 'par ;'E§€:{:E':i(m 1:.¥.~f~k.§:'?%« "'fl'"1€E'}."£:'.{j'€.:1."§':'. me. Apex (";m.:r'£.. i::'2i,e;."xi'" 1::
ih ear _§u£:§§;1.'r"1.<;?1.'1:. 0%' £.h:>: E'1mja'§3 szmci 1-E21r"_§rz11m E---EIi_ggf1'1'*«€T;' :'.%§.§i§':.E.Ejq wzjéivhzxci by {he E'5»et.'i.i§@112e11t. C:€)}f¥1II1iE§&i.€Efl:__.i:%?E§ m,i;i:;~;3_:fc.Er;: "fig":
:e:sm>;<:§~;+ zmd 'ihe:ty f<>u.1'1{§ fauii. \Vfl..h 'i;:"it'f H}fig€:7fE"§j'3j&§%'{:é1§'i:l§'£){:1 -.V§..>v3;_;:~xV :m. V 'Ru..§e;:.=: E432. V» _' Ah Av ' %' M}. R1,.'£EEi'. 14- mi." '§h(=':% C§¥3NTiJ'é¥[2' C' 2*r;;ri.ii :"<::221é'é5s 215:»; L.s'm:Eer": ' Ram 14. "R¢éév-.e:;y:' credit wmng'Eg;_ ta.j!c"e3ii:: }q;v' "ef'1fcn. e_o;i§s.ly :'*efun6ied.-
12%/¥'z§ér's;:V;1iT£;?1.%;J ;€If5;f9;1'E\i€'x¢',k1*{'I' {:'V?'€;.f().5fE'.f! "5-:;vc'::as fi')e?em i'c:aE<:a-R: or z §£z'.E %¢..*.{,1'_.&V Tii:.;:>:'<7n<s:ig;.?g _<:.)r V 1"?2{>z5; Ezman, e¥'§'(}!1£5(?t,£.s{§.} 're5fE.;s%{§€:§c{§~iffe <fz,i<.:2I2g; wz'.!.:h E°¥'iET£;?2'£.?5~';'Ei :§3'2<:2{E Em ::g2?{:':::2.g?;<a*§*e_aiu\fif€js'n:§:§m> z'2'2..cé.:'1.z.;f?ae;?£'2gm 0:' :'.}'w g13r'c:.m£d.c;>z' aigf E:m§;';r§'.z.I: S(£E"E.,?iC&? zuznd {.319 pr"<>:,;E.s€,<:m.:; ::;§[" ;é;3e;r£E<.>:'":$:V""E"}«,¥a and I IAE53 53;" gm» ..%f%L',><m':e;@ Am". mar §§'e:%gff:E.¢3r2.5 E753 and 75 Qf my Fi¥?(1.f1.{'3E.? /-3&€.Z'?, :j;E"a<fz.§.{ *"."_v»a:p_;.;g»E§_.; nmicizm; mzz€)a.r'1cii3 f3:>r z1jfl?;'?('{.f!?_§§ ;'.'§E.£.€".'h .-§;:*:.:.r<;az,*<;>rz'.@.«s,7 31 A m.z1<iii,1'1gg c>.¢;." mas: a1f'<:;m3:~';sa1id p1"O'U§.$iE).EZ1E3 m::::k,<~té:s;5; it 'V'€f3'F}£",§§§€£'_§§_'Ef'.__§,hE}.§". flat? 5:s:r.:i§i(% ;M"e>v"%&';is'm 21.Eiir;;w'E'ecI \2\Jhm'c% me: Ce;t'1'1\3f:,i§i:"C %5_%;:-d_:i.i' ba=:<::::'.2 'ta.i:<,.<:*.::'2 m" uiE.iii3?x€:d w:"0n.gE}r or E"1.a>;3 .E3<--3s&:ji'V._m:';vf§;§m3:e;as;:¥§aEj,abV r€:§x..x:"2d€:;c;E. in "2;-im-v of {$16 af<)1°<=:s:;ai{;% _]§:L>,1€Ti;_£_-.',1"'_E'_'3{V:"';i'}V.'£'. E}? i.%3€i~--A§:;£i:'i__<Ii::;;:;:'rfL. iiizm qu:%::+;§,'i::>:2 mi" E"@£1€§iE'1g;§' 1,E1.<i> \7VO};'"f'f ':9ma:i"i,1'1';:aEa€tej:>',E? 'z:>;4" 'W0 :'§;:1d"n<}f£1., £;'%.31".§::f~.'»€§:?A I': afisso H.) be r1<>{i¢::{3d '€;jE*":.gi*t.' in Jilhéf-%1I;.f;{)'a"ti;fE§«£1itEi Rufie, Elhifr w:;;>:s"<:§ ";2xVa.§i' is»; rxm US€Ci; J '"§~7.}).e=: x$;*{>:*ci:éj":¢,%;r:::.C%'«Ema? 'iaxkétzf 0:' "e..:t.ih.?t¢:t€i av'1"<">ng.3{E3,:". §*":Ta;*t1rmz' ?:.h<«:<= &;az?ic§~ E}1"f }'\5'V1:.€%.:IAL0371"~.§'i':l"<}?:}&v';f_E':$V~~ii". (:t'E:;:a3;' t.E":;z.u' {he §E'Tfl..%31"€3t:$5'E". ,a*~;E1aE§ be fm€f'¢:}\:*<;ta5':(;:ci iirwe. .7t::3:*'::'I1§§§ §(_:'>i".. S_(§{f'€i{) 1'1 { UX emci ii 3 £53» 01' E. }"."1.§i't AVE .
_ '3;:é;;.ic:E d§e:s(t':.zss:53:'.{;>x1 what, &:m<::1"gg@:§ m " E«"mm E.iE2a€. 'Wm. cm:*;«;: m;;:.§" c'x.:_.:iSct cimiigr in me. :"e.g'i.sf.er E"I'}2;1ii}i.E"iifl{'?'fE my 'é'}"1:=>. :"~se.1E§§:'§w;:"jpa:re§{:? "ES é)':1.E..};....sa' buck {t¥1{I."y. it mE.g§§:i be mEVi.i£:'sm::E ii;1.é.t:t2* £312.14";;my:';::{:::"1'1:~_aféi.' .._<3.:><;£:£ses:«E: ci=.:ME:y <:>1'1 We (?1X(3i$,$§."£§3E€:T pmcizzm. M. 35:; n'?:2'zL'€.iE.f§r:f<;'i 'Mt: 'éI.';as~3€j i=1.l"1_a a::"€:c:iiEl E-iii. an}; Eima, 1:};'1e3"e:a.'E"t'.er w§'1st~:n n1ai.ki:"1;g§ 'V §:.>;.?:.j\/nVi«:*.};.1é".§3£'V:7::>s:<;.:i:ae ciimy on 1339 eX<t:i:;sa?C::x}e3: ;}r<.>d1..:(:i".. 'is ;'1"a;:z.Vt.:.s_ms:+s i .3w'§1e;~;<;j¥_.¥:.%'1c3 €i:E,}(i:.,V§,:E;€1E:)E.t'..'?: ;mi>dL:<:.:E. 1"<3<:<-.ziw'-rd i'r<m1 Ehfi €21<*;10ry m'1:t% 13% . :%:;a.;j;§€;? fsisr p£%Ey£11C%'I'1§(' 0%' <:><<:i_s3t't {:m*;.jy is 'rem::§:¢3Ci. Az';'t'{.ua1Iy4 me? ]%'§M,,»""""