Karnataka High Court
Larsen And Turbo Limited vs The State Of Karnataka on 25 August, 2009
Author: A.N.Venugopala Gowda
Bench: A.N.Venugopala Gowda
E35' "§'§§§_2 E--iii}?--E €;?{'}§EE7€§§7 {E}? .§{fi%€§€é%'TAVE{;§ sfiii' Eiififié {§;?i.é{.f3§€i%3 §',"}A'i'§Z%3;i TEEES '?}'§E'3 §.}§'Cz" {:2}? GE;f%'Sr§' 28%)'? 2% E3; {LEREZ mzé: E-i{}£'%E"E3§..,§; M22, JE.:?S'§'E'iji'E¥Z ya 9: vza::ezns{;~<A>§»}ga:ga. <;<i.%%%5 A. 1¥.§a:-s{>,. 34? :19 22> '£{§:;L>E% ''?~»i{S'E°§ .. 8E."i"*$£' §:%3E3E"§_m;;
§_.,ar3e§'; 5%; "i'G'z§'i:::"<} %;.£m£":<s{i Eiéiifi '§§i¥§5§m'*: ._ 3%}, §{:::1"19.§'a§3'u;:«s?z E%:}a<j%~; .
E+3ar:gaE@:"::% 56%} ::;<_;:.:« "_- I Eéapreaerzzaai Eziézfciiér: _ _ V V z'1S$'L §*=f§anage1_'=7--~ E,:_?;%C1'ij,:%9:%;[:gt ';E':§-:%{.5:$§"* "
MS. Sha§1%;;hgs§a %;3§{i;?§s§§§'1a3"_,'*~ '-
I T. % M ,...§'i§§'?"§'7£'f§{f}E'=3'E%2§¥ zjififg S'.-Efi. iojiizfag {ix §?a:'€:"§{E;ie;§¥s, ,} 31% E} :
L '$36: $:,a%;,e sf §~£§::::i:§3La§{é=.
" < ,§'{::':§_§3"'é=%:£;z_j[%',:;%{}; %.i€3E'f;i:I7i....§.73j;«" $3 ._ §5*§%.::§:§.§::éE:':Z§égi;:j§iE:a:f$; fig} {.'%£>v<:;m.::m.t:1§: V' 'E;}:%§§a5:*§s;s:3.€i:§; '=:;;f E??.§A:'r*&2'1:t€ Ef§,{i§:8J§a §§§:it;z§<§':;::' E3331§;,?a§{}:*é: 4% 'jifsfiééé {R} 3 5 "_E"h€ ."§':1'f53§§'§.§"€f§?'V{:G§§"iEI3"ii$$§{"§§i§T?§'°Sf ' ' _ ":'?<§"::§1:1{:2f::%_z:§ Taxes _*§f£§:§¥3;é*:;$$§1:§»:§"s: - E 3} " T "E?'&'55.%t _'7¥§':'*a{f:é{§ iiifétfg' ijfiiigéaizzm ii ' 8ééj:§3gaEc:s:*§-': -~ fifiié {}€ii§.
: E5-if§§I§§§3'{i}'§"§§}:§?:?'é"'?$
2.93 3363:: §£i§{€i"} up far C{T3i"£SiC§€3}"'£§,'Z§{3§§} §:';j~; {E153 '"§"3'§§32,a:-'33}, <23 accounzt. mi' 1i}€:'_i"i€i€f3};"E{iy :2? *a2*a:;'i<::1$ reaaang. Since im:
g§"'8I}Ef:{§ by 'ilfifj ""i'Ifi§;3':;:"3a.§ hag €:3{;3}Z§"€:<;i, a§3§3§*£:h€i'1{§§2':;{._i§'?:ét,:I. .. E;"'€i'%:*€§if§"i.i("Z i'('iC{}'J€§"}'" §:;:«m<:€:€:£%i1'1§;8 Eilafs' be izxiiiattéti té:;__€:z:;:=iii~<-'.:,::V:L%; % baiariceé: €331, 'E:§"1iS WW: petiiiim has "bait: §'ii§:::=r'i_.
2. Sri. .S%1iva3:@giswam.i¥,-.__ 3eai"=:f_1{%"? ;%;:§{§'vi€%§:'1af_{;
C§{3V€E*fii'§}€3fii Aiivscata was <§;i:'é%€:--4:{i<:§ i_;e T'--%i'¢§;:{:'z1Gt§{:e 0::
behaif of' '§'€:Sp€}§§£i{%I;;§fS~ aijgti §3.i:£s;=e»'i<£-2 '"'s§§:§':::£3§';3isis3ra$ if} $153 maiigsz',
3. E Ikiaéé cozzfifiiii <23": bath Si{§€S 333$ pe:*:,:$:'~:<§ §:%:§<~:_ ré:::z:>§*:§., V * " ~ 4: ..§E§i:i§.sp:.:%,é.E:s§§9,V' é:%;§;: '§"wi%3u;1aE grazziefi ma}; far 3 ';;s5ri,§z:'§._» GE Aiiayfs. 'Tbs smzditian izmzsesaai 23}; this 'T£'§*i§§&:§;§»fif; #3:"V"_~v_§v:s'AV~:;'::%i*ci€:* éaiazfi §8,{}2,'2§fl¥} £138 235%":
§f:€;:::§3§§é'?:i s,x;--i::;f§/:;v "§'ha p€:iit;i<>:"1er has fiifiéifififié the E§8..i'}}i ES vaiié 21$ :6 $3,532.28 ii}. .%'§3:' :10 I» '§3_3Q£.ii%{;' C: f p€t;iti€;::"1&§', {E13 apgtseaé hag §€:t:r2 ad_§£:a::'::s:::§ {£2 / .
ifficta éjyeiir Qiéifi}. 'E'%:<i :"'{:a5{};;1 fa?' a<iw§:32;:"£1:3;1{33':§. iié ;::i<:a§ :33; 'EEK:
§:':3f.2m(:e cf' '$316 ;":<~t=:fi%;i<3r1€a'. §§ii";::€: {fizz im;<::*§_:'.:: ::>_:'i§s:.:*;. zigkzizzh was. $6171" 18%} €§8ff«;_£S, has é;::>s:p%1'%d,'E'.§';:: 3.§3§}E'*f3.§"ifE3};"}.3i£{§27}. :'33 Q'? $15: ;;2<:é;%.'{§9r1€:* is j=;::$i:§f;{:<:i. Sizzciz $316: pé:ii,§iic>'{::§i*' geiménaiy app1'@hé:1"i{i&; E.h&'£;, §'{fVCI§%Ji;f,'f E:r::;:;f§: ' §L:.fG{;{f{%V{§i _fi}E" ' raaavasy {if aha: E}§;T§1{}11i}'§, thong}: '§}'i{§1"€3__ i%*3_;::: ;:§.a::§%:;é»_ " aréiér anéi {he §;'3€3§;§§i(}fl€E;£"' aigéx, ::%:":E:}§}§%.é§<:§ '=v§§.%ET:V"1.»ééééé camditfmzzs im;;:c:$<::%. E33:-5 *~.._%'§}s:=: zifiégséiéyiiaizz 'i"':"i;'@sw:1/aai, ghaii 21%': Ex: ;'r1§§{fiE}a§'€:{§ ' '§f{V; _.~g:§1:;i§;§::i'{;_'_. in am: Ci:'<:u:::€aEa;:::£:;%:g, "' V "'§<%.:nj:'1${2.. Vgidéifiiifiégiai }::":2'er:'1::':<::'1'€, Aégfasaaie :2i:g,%:*§:§:<;§ 551*.;:":¢:f;_f2iifi'e:;é;'§;§.""2as.::a3 <:sf ?:.E";s:; §1"1%.'€i:*i:':'1 <.}:§2:§{:;1 :3. in i§*_::':?«.V <:§:fcm_::i';§€a:i:$it{:s, E {.%<»:<:';:;1 E3; §}§*{3;3€:' is' ::§§%s§}<:sss3g:;%§° if;%":§,$ aI;rr§é,;:3§:E;i%i{>:: 91$ §£}E§:';?§$ : V E; '5E'_§":{;:§¢?*£%;é*s,A ?é=:E,i'§:§{},§i: ig a'i§0w€::§. §%?;€&§p@r'§§§;:2'":i:$ "Sara: :2:-:V:<§%;":s%:;:§1%::§ {mm ézziiiaéiisg &{t'é.§(32'";. ;§»=i}E"""§f€E{f{i§§'§3Eff¢' {réf }¥3:§;,};;? §_,8€},'e}"--}T§j ~ %.m"£:%§ EEK: V . , %¥i_;§:'-:':zai::9§{.a §'%_p§<=:.'é§a%.e '§'ré.%:sm'3ai sgii;-3;3€3S§:$ :3? " --_ A.;"3é'2j{}§ 3z:'£}§ii<:% Ea EEK? i:<3§"1ai§§'§E.§.e:3fi iigzaii, 'ks /V' gm;
r*°+ "he: ;:'3e::iéié::>:'":{:£' sa§;aa§.1 :"_{:2";:::w ?'.}Ti§? irfimzk {§'E_i8;E'&'E"i§,{Efi'; {mm Eimzii 'i1{:e E53116, {iii '(E29 said §i§E?1I3€53§ fifi'}éfi}§" (§i'S§j3{}$€f€§ <3? iisgfs i'E":€;" r§1'E'"§?E}'Li§"§8.L ._ . Si::':{:a Emgé-: simaarzé <5? :'§:%;<;::;:1i+:aA §$_";:;:§'%3§€<:E[" ::'1a:?:%,€r 95 me: c{}:'13§é§:re:':'§::_:é'~-35": 'i§'é;%: agéggfiaté §3m";a§i:'3g "{)§:§%:»r& {he} §'ri b*:.1§3.&E A. "T"a§'i:{§:' ~»Tf"ri"§3a:§:';a.%A ska}: <t§;:;:é€i.i¥.§é:z;:';zEj»: j_€i_§.é»=;§;e:;%::: {:35 aihe ssaié ap::2{~:;:--:.§~.j. ' M 3uDGE rdx