Karnataka High Court
Smt Sree Priya B S vs Sri S V Suresh on 24 January, 2012
Bench: K.Bhakthavatsala, K.Govindarajulu
3% THE HEGH CGURT GF KARNATAEQ EXT BANSALGRE
§i3CfE$ T§*"§%S '?E"*£E 3%" 833:' Q? §.i1J'éL}AR'f 2812
?RESE?\%T
THE i~E{§§ii'§LE QR. jgssficg :<. g:r§,b§§<f§:-§Av;s3f%;;:;$%g~_.. «
AND
THE HGMBLE %V£R, jL%STi€E7%i.._GQ\!§"%'>§§3:iR,&}i;§'i§.3j 1.
MESCELLANEGUS FERST fi\?PEAL. §\éV§.'i§525f'E$§:?'Vifslfif}
BETWEEN
E. 8:21: Srae Priya B 8% .. ht
W56 Eats §;r'un §{uma:j v"¥jan";13as§::1Ve;r';_;'V..:
Agé: 26 yearg.
2. $r'i S S3::3basi*€é5;§
:8,/0 133:6 SI'§{8;}3'§&-v§§fi1£*;S§,F§;'1;. *
figs: 8? y€a:'ga_ " ., '3.
3. Sm: €3aya:}:::€, "
Wgb S Sazzzbashéiiggng _
Age: §§ }iea;j,<-:._
Sf'; .E§ran':'K';;s:na§ 3% ' """ " 'V
8,!' {3.'S3E'i};1;':,aS§'%.-'_8.f3_§ _ >
Age: ';'3:L_§'§{;%a>;;;*:~z. M ..
. '<.,:'--':1§ gm: r<:>s§§§::g 2£:LA;§%?32%'a Nafiififig
Magish ?:s'Eé§--:1<>:*.,._" ' "
_ Z*E%:j'Vi4Z%§a.:j:éi;a §'£§§a.}»'2:,g_
§~":=ij'i--:::i2;:.E';aé}§ Fviain Eaazii
. 5 i'§3?% P%i2;§s:} ;;?.? Nagzazi.
.
,:%g3ps:§§an::% firiéi E/viasisah §3§1:i}2% § §§s:'~';0a7é:1i€:a, fa}: 2::g§>€§.%:::;§S§ bank £%E'€ {B 1, 8?; S E? Szarsah, S/0 '€€§:§ia:a;*a:13a§a%;.
Nai 12, 6113?; Maia Eioaé 2%??? bieck.
T Eli Eéagarg ~-
Saxzgalgmi {R C Gamer}
2. The Bixisienai Manager, Umteé Endia Ensurancs Ca; Lids;
S Q~10,;'~Eo«2.E, St. Patrick Church Buiiding, V I_\i1us€ur:1 R036, T . L ;, , _ Bangaiorefrfifl Q25; " _ i " fia:fSf§enéer:i;s {By 8:': B C S€etha§a:I:;é;'«T:?R:§fiag §;§V:; £759? .. V This i'sF':¥:§V_S:e;:Eai§éé'c:V;2V§_»""F;T§3iiV"';%__§;>§aE is ffiéd amdgy Sectéen 1?'3{1} :3?' thé"j?§}{;ii§r">g{é;;é:Vi'::§é'3..¢:A%:7:'; ggaiast €239 juégmené am awayé éateé1Qff";2§®§_;:5.aSS,$§~..§é §v%VC §*&Q.?fs_§i,!2G{}4 an the fiie a§.~:i.%'_:$.r;ifiV§.;§;,:§§'z:> £5 F?E'e':?::3§§r,'V%%?%ACT; ?i'§Gi§"§§}€}§§i%E": £55, Sa:*:ga%§r§ "a.E§®¥¥§r:g mi?:% céaém jaeiitésn fey gemgenfiaiian am 7s.eéés:é.§§g ef':::.£Ei:%av:9§§'::§%:_f;e§:': Q? {§f'?1§E!"%S8§§§i7, "§§3iIs._ gaming am far imaging $33 $335, $2:
...T.§«'3.§2.aéfihaazaigsvié, jag dgiivaeé the §S§§G%'si§:"'%§:
JUSGMENT The agpeiigntgfciaémants a:j1g befizfé'-._ i:?:%s_'.."_~C'§:s:*t éfihaaiement ef :§mg3erxsat%3r;. V' . ._ 2; E339 have beam §earr*:__efi C0L£_!T1.$_€"§._flf{}*§7_V thé <';;§ai_:f::a_r§t3 and resgenéant §'x§9.2j§nsL;ra{1§e CeVrnfir"ar;yA.? " 3, Perusefi the 1 _, 4, The Tréber2$i1._»§1as§T'as;:;3Vr:§e:i_ €®nis;3en'£a?ii-s'fn in favaur 3? the Ciaimants as ursdezfi ' «_ ~~~~ {in 2;;
{3} L653 Sf§VE3§.;:EE'}C§€fiC§f '~« _ -
{€33(EGG?-X3;2:§<..l5;{v2}53_}V' ' Z§,§f},§8G-Q9 <32'; LGSSé'§._§€2%71'%Vé§'.'i;$'é;z§§'!" masswaa {§§§} ..4.§§§';3i"'§'.'3{3§§""£éf:§*f.3§'§V_a§'I;'T§ fime:'a%
-.,.e':<§s"::>r':3§3 """ " 2$;G$§~G§ "=::é_\.:% " am? affggtéefi 3.5,§§:;-«gg V Tats: 2§,.3.§Es@§-«m . V .
'% Léa:':'e,e;_?§:1;' Cmmgeé fsr the agpeiiarzis sabmits ihai: i§"2€ gr: 2'?g§.2§Sé; ms: ihe %;:v;Ts,s:*%d dieé egg': 27;i:;£T}.2$$?é; 33$ gérvcg fine meficgi §§{§€?'%*i:3E§ 229% {"€3§E"'§":§i}L§%"S&é, ?:%:% Ciaémants have ha': daimed any Qempensatéen tawards m§d.i_;i'£=z§ €><§€E"éSES5 §"°§€ f:.;rth€:' Siibfiéiifi that the giaimanig xxfiz,;'i?e'§§e'~§}"§%:£§__" mazher cf the éscegsefi have resaaizzeé 3 sum :31' ?é%,_§E§g_'€)"£}§';4§:§a_Cii fmm %%§FC E3354 iawafds 633%': 3? Arum i'<i:,.é.§'"§}3é_': $&fi5§§_§§§S§'i~if%.?a.f2~§.§;i§:ii' the amsimnt Came? be deductefi fram ihé'c0%%2._§ensé.§_i::'§i"as §--§7 § " amaunt is received 3:': acceémt 9? ':;'::;1?%::.:'%b:.:ti<;>'*:3._V :":<safje"1.,byVVVihe fieceasedk --
6. Sr% 8 C §€€Eh§§";3_m& C'%j'zVe.:.'z*:A:é-$;%,»V§~.'éppearing for f'€S£3G¥"1C5€!'3t NG.2;'EF3S§.§féf2':::»;é_£§:i:j;:«i'é;:':'§;z .{_s':::$t:2;5'%'"t;:---»e.:'E1at the Tribunai has awaréed ;§':§d'Vthere ES rm gééé grsuné f3?' since the :§ain':ar3*:s--
wife arid m§:hV:esj 9rf£heVVVV%j':KéL§:é§':§{3»«iréceéved Es aii amegmting ta %"§;%G,§fi§;'« _t_<:g:s:a:§§% f:V'?:£3..".de 3?:h "'"i§3%n3 seit%sme§z%: ihmugh the €m'f;3E'-$352? é:3§TF.2%;§"3i?;'---.§C§€v%:€3S€;V{§:Xi'§;i§;H P G%aba% 33%: iifiw izhe same E333 ta bé: :'e§a:'§: Es $3535 apes '£313 degésien 5:"re,g::;;a:%sd"égé"'§;§ flé§;§5 5:' 32%' {MR$. 5553;? 5" 35555.; Aim f::?:3";;;;?e§§ a/sf ii§;é:{~ffi§;%§f§?"§,£ 33% 2%" 83%;? ?":%4;Ei,§,~95§?"" Céfiflfifgi ;¢§;é2:2)14;;§§{;?':~5§,~',§}'§' '% 'JR 7& .fic::e§d§r2§ is Ex,§:?, 'she §mg:si§:;&r sf the d§£e§_ss2:$T'..4§}é::.s ceytéfieé the wages gaié :%r§:*s: the mgnth :3? fiegtemtser 2§§££ Tha §C:':%C§€§"i1Z ©::::im§:§HmG:': *?%'f§2€:_ grass sa%a:'y far the manth 9% Septé=.§:1be$ f2Ci€%§; . C<f3%f:'»é':2__'_V«:5;f ?39;§6Z?;'~. £1' a gum sf %'2C1G;'~ §a;%?§.¢__:owi3";*=jE§" ::::'::2*%'Ve:$*:=;}.=<:§::j:.aE "i;a.§<'; %4g333;*~ paid tewarés Encsme tax '§L:=:.;j 2':,0é{3§--:':g§Ed.':':f;:3§%:arc£s transgertaiéon its 3%! amsur;{:§_§E':g déVfi Aa,:é"1Ee<:£§ fie:
saéary games ta ?3é;§§3§«i». 'E'h§:f§3"'§'sV.V an rewré i:Q Shaw that {he d§Cé;=2§:éé vV§€T§n§anentEy% Sénie the éeceaseé wafii 'me {atia Eaicé dawn Er:
Safia Verma Cerpsraiiea & Anether' {gegarteé in :2%$:%?'_(§} mgziiigiier '1?' has :3 be apgfiéfi énsigafi the Trémmai. Sérsce a§pe%i5:':i: §\3§<::;'a'2g€§'§"et.§?;_§;:::' 'figs c§$é';iea:§.aa;i was absut 22? 3'8§;¥"S§ he WES mi ée;p '€:A%{i§.§'ég-.gn..:§*:§v:§é§*:f:§r:gs sf T:§';€ zzieceassdg 2? wife am garsnts <._;a;er$ ii; tysé ta?%<;§--<§j;'--: f%sii:s isrégédefatiazg there wage wig ihffié kijep§r':§&r2f§_"'£'Vé<;e§*é?:.>r§, 1,33"; :33' 'mg Enigma sisalé be dedzzited .1 tééyfisfgifi ';2§s§§é'%gl €XQ§§3S§$. éarzuai §i%'%{:G§'I'EE $1? ins §EC€§S€§ €'%§é%;§3é«;'~x§.2} %s:,§a;4::3g;a if a 3255:": 2:}? %?_,3§,:3§;> ES ' .__d§«$é::i'§€fi tswayég §€%"§§§"§&§ €>:§§i"i§€$g Eggs 6;? §a;:;§§'::§§:z::;z sameg % :
ta %'2,?2,2?2;'-- gs? amzgm, "§%:g Trihuaai §'l.§S '%§%;§.§:e7'~§%:§.igi'%*xie_:;_i camgaénsaticn iawareis »:emse:*:{iV<::V:':_a§ fisafiws Cansortium, E353 cf Ewe and affe:ié£:ri;»:_?é:nsgeaffiatiénV-39$ 'funeraé exgrenses.
8! Ea the c%ecEsEe:f:A'reupar§::-':6 §:if: gupra, in para'34, the Apex; §<;é%'ie§e the emgaieyef' Ensures his agfidéath arigirzg mg: cf an azcident, ariiaigvy such insurance an the haggerzing 9f 's;;§i§: be an amcgsnt §iab§e fer éedagcfian, ; 'E~%e=31:'2€e: ::2. s'u'{:% 93* iii-;5G,.SG$j~ eash paid ta the wife a{;.:2'v.§:1§tE:§?::. §f £:h;;e §ef:'es%2$9..<i iézreugh emgieya teizazazég deaiifi <:fa§§:: 3ei§'iem::~3n%%§fVi'%:e §$€€8S€fi, has :5 E39 éieéaciea g E ¥§'a §%§§?"%;§§i5%i, 2:322 §:§E§§¥T§3%"§§S $55 enéiiieé fa? flfiififiéfisaiiéfi <,, 'a, iazss éf *' {éfi 2:';
{$3 1333 of Sepengieracy {%2;:%'2,2';2;~x:?> 45;28§52ai:§$3 {ii} 1353 sf CQi"§SQi"t§L§!TE 1G;QG'€%~_ 'G§:AT..: {iii} Lgsg Q? ¥a2;§ aad affeétiaz":
{iv} Trafisgartatém 3*? dead beéy . _.
and fzmeraé €X§')€f"§S€S "7iG,,§§'{3-'§:3j§ _V
iv} Lass af estate _
V Tfiégj .é5,§8,52%3,é§'fla
Less: Camgsengation aTv§_arL%ié»c§»V _ J_ by i:h:='-T:r§bu::é'§" * ' " 26.,::%3§Q9§~G§ 1;, ;:§;s8,624«0e Les;_s}__:V Ce.§fripé;;3sa:.é§:a "?z<=:;:j+;3 HD:9;}'€;" th~:jéugE: t_:Ei'é __e:":1;:e'E':;§3;;e§':'»A " - §,QG,@§§=§Q % §fa=s:}:fs>::é 3_:,§a52s,--«$e ééé :h%;¥L"réis1tg,zE: we msg fire felizawfig asrfierr 39:~§<é""1%%;a:§§*é%g::%% partiy aiiewed hfiifiifzg ma: the ".1-gufipgiéa:':tS,;§*i>3;逧i:é ' V€:>f iha desaaseaé gre aaiitéed 53:' E:§d§i§£3i'%&§ {c.;aT%*;:'§i§z3::s;::::.é':3:: 5% %1"§.,§8§§2§»;1 giaswg wiiéz sastg am §¥"§'EQl'€$§ at " "%i_:%:f:e.éj;:té~;3--f 6":/<5 $8? &i'i§E%.§§'¥§ fmm the fiaie if §6t§'{§a:": tiié rfiaiégaiésn' V _§\::§::§§'a*i'%'r*:§E;r; {ha imgzjgnéd gaésgméfii aways; are mafiifieai *5 The afidétiefiaf CGF'§§§€i"ES3tEGZ'i amezmi aéarsg ss~;§§§*: :§.s%i_iS..€aj:%1V:i %_f":§:€¥'€S§ shaii be agggrtéeneg amsrzg céaimants L2 ffiiéfi a?' 2:112 it £5 made flea? éhat gince apgeiéarfi??és§[%2~;?:E'3{§::%ar3§" Exéaév is mi: 5 €;§§;:3€§"§€i€Efi'{ <3"? the fieceagedghe V f Camgefisatéera Respsndenf; §xE@,2;£::s::§a;.:}Ce Qgm.-§'V{:*;n_y"§s C§§§'é{:'?:'E.{'T§ tiff degesit the additianai campensatieéé'vém§:;_§'%}F: va§Cséf§§,:p a«;§tE': CGSES and interest with the Tr§bu:f:ai.__wit§:'§'?:"3-- Sat 3? $13 :i;sn";.5§'::=;V:9i'§é:'*:Ec:%*i*f:§-:3*%":;i:Vé§--i 'agsaféefi ii'? favsuf Q? the €%aEmant!a§pf3§§1af:é"z.. %'f»£a.if,§} $.53" h§s ""iéi$ keeg 53% $1' the £$m;3e:2s3:%c3:é"'.a:é:,9a::7:Végé"E%xe§'*--€f}é;::os§: fer a §i}€§'§Q§ 5%' 5 years; éazring :r\:?2%c_%: ;§és*%:::.Ci* sééi-:_ S';:$§i..§:e at §%§ertg is araw" peréséécg Eiéiéiéfit i%'§é«i a;::::.:e§ G51' i:»%:.;se.::ée;sa§§i:$ g f§§§§'§