Gujarat High Court
O.J.APPEAL/18/2009 on 15 April, 2010
Author: Bhagwati Prasad
Bench: Bhagwati Prasad
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?a??????? >? !)g?*?U? ?\?Q6}W? }??V~???[>?P??{ ???Y ? ???Y}W?EQx^??0s??bZk???y]In?C?]^K?? ? m?V ?0 ?-%RqO??Vi%�l?? ?I/ k? ???Y??^? ?|?)?V(?W3 n& ???R?[#>Q??muT6 ?Y ??, ?Dl7 Gx?p9?nBm<3?pgXlw??XR??vP??2 q4+`?E??[?E [?+??>W?p;r#???9?"?z ? ?-?Z??? 9qw???}7#? ??k Q%s .Y�*?e? ??Y??W???~??�/??n?*e2?l? 6? ;_ z?p@?9? AU?c 8Q?po *?* ?? ??:? +^vv?? ?u]?H??qi-{=?"V????:?W?y?????y,( ?}?? ??V?P? ?! Ck?tmQ%???.5n??t? ?F!? ??n?S?� ??? f+ !?\H?9 T ? ?f\0 ? 9??:????? ?K/????=l???(?G.???gC? ?AF$ ??!;?K8??:U?"K ?s??J??m?`6?7?+??&"?D&b Zl?????? ?w?c?N!?}2?4?.? X?F 0??q ???j v?ON?hH????9?oYv?y|???f/T]??8?????T ? ?yj6?? {f4?[?F??8 ???? ?8#?! ??X???,]? j??/?? pW1u:p?????? ?4h ?R??fN? L? 50?3@]?bI1+Xsy ??Y-oL?L ??RV?x ?EFru#HM.u?>;9?VU?N?0/??{,#:y�C? @, ??U& ? W?UY ?!A?Z??*z??M\???? ?? ?c?{{Pq??; ?C ?p? ???
?R4?????? ??`??]? - ?????W??? ??j g??T?2R?%????[ ?$X??-???
?? ? ?Z/iv??$? N{k???+3??? ?Z? u?(?z?????f??k?~1?H???!?> ?h?k1????? ?k??R ??8???x?@?:kx!???J??!??Sl??}?=??zw >T?go???>h???0?? hz?q??????6? ?&????2Z \????Q~???_~?? s?!?5??T ?u??�?W???KAz*wk??db?5???? ?l?|? iZX?]4!?*? ?#| ? ?hV y?S????^??d;?}?z ?'i???? i??? 0?\?;?_ ???$M ?h0??/O??
????? U? ???1?~??(?? 2??d;? Az? ]g ??0??X AF???[ ?? ? PN?y^^??+ ?!?? ????3D ? ?;??5z??2??F?; ?kT?X?- ?O?X t??#??3??89 h?????$? ? s???j dE)?B?? ?~L??C? ?H???%m?;??Z???fN??? c?3PC6tno??;?{W ????h?B ? ?C?r???;? ???t?I?7??? 8 ?b?? ???j[? ???????`??S ?K U??k?V?Q??e??ht ?R ??n??W? ?? D�?R?[f?8? pm m?H D0 x ??x??1???/? b}&?P?@�?? ?0 ]? 2LJ??}4& j O?????C? }???? jK?g?6 B?!?? ?#?? ???? ??=&?!? 4?@ $?~!?? ?pV%K1?^!?? ?1??? ^S?7dd ??y )4?@XL??:@?\ML ?"n????? G?j�b @YZ???8? ,?K3:?F?| ??D?`Xd|?h?z?? ???Pp ? ? 2 �"U? )V?$ ? lh"x?mp g�?#? l&Gy?\�te???y?1?? h ?dB??] W{??l?n7.WO< 7? ????n? ?] ? ????"?
?S? ? ?? G?Ct?o??
36'!?b ??e?'5?H# a? ? ?? ?h?y? ?O ?}?
?>p1%?.?(?j ?$?"2?oj???_??^?W???8;?? ??Z B? ??{k`x? ?gH ? $ \}?B}ZWjz??=K~?V??;?O??Z?^i~Ew?6j?N?^? H ? re"?]? ? ?} %9 �7? - ?] /?qRa5?�b JUR_ Xj?.? (f?B`*]j`Z?v?. ?K=?loY???^H?.N ?? DRH?P? ?�?Z]#?e?z ??T )??'?QaS DB?P?PA?6 ' cf??D??S?9{? ?`7WD!l? ?Q?z ?.?1K?e? SJ0tPw??? ?GH?o? ?+inj?%" (?*A???Q L??z??7???c ?6?xT5AR? C?4 =?- ?j ?\????? ??1$IB?o?
\Z?????z? �?� ??2??EjA?!??? 1 @??1t?x~4:?q""L???+???2?? j{???z2.??6 J*!?[ ? 8U? CH?o g??]? ? e2?%? *; ? +???g??? /?jE"| ?(O1???? ? L??? ????} ? S34d| ?G?Q`?? zv??? ?e??R(???m?a?c?v??J ?a?W????v??Dk???J? ?j?c ?SH ?? ur?ER ???r? +?1? 4V=J C?B??V7 ??,?E,aP#%?qE8A?? ?X? K ]?h C?? 8q?? ??J?X???\?E?? >e?G? u$??? 5o?_?{+* ? ??h??,?{ ?e??: 2m?? ?$ 8?6??F*?? ?HG ???!?`?$ -?Aq ??8 :?hJ?\?r ?? ?'8Ewt??f]?? 2??EF??xZ?t?? 8?,????[ ? B?L???{ U/\?w??s?S?< ZD?8E??[?l )e?4T??y?8r@ ?+?+R%??I ? E?o]??l?z_0?|??Xn A???? ?D? ????J? �J]Bn{o1?k??i ?{??BAQWx??R? &??R???�/e???? gA%Z2)U?> ?f?J???#r?S}??8 \?Xq ?Ty?,v ?4 ??? '?p??o ??9#.g?? ??O?B ? e??? /q?k???? ] ?? hP?'!T ?? f??d? ]???h? ?1 ??t?$?&??E~??B?5?Y?j?Kya?? ? ?? #D?=W5????B?GUg ?Hy???>???.??3?'?
?Es???3 J?OZ ??i?M?? r ??? ?V?( ???7??R???l0 ?3?e?? Pu ?| ?3?sWC[p? ? ??
8Q�?sU???M[?l,??Y???i?9U?-??>|???UW`????r?0?:(??k?> ????B?? ??Vh ?O? ? PK NS?? ��:'��PK �����?a?< ??? ��? �� ���meta.xml OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 pansala 2010-04-15T17:43:18 1 PT0S PK � � �?a?<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png??uT?z?UPADJ i? ?Trhii? ? J??n?p? ?.? :?.? ??a???9ku??s??? ??~?????y? ?^E ? S{????A??{????z |:? ??w??V^?W " ??p uwA??_ ?N& ??* ?? ????? ?? ?h????8? }Q ?%$~? ?9wh?$V? ? ?}q'?w?z?x???|?tx?}?:??9gwx??.; /_4 w;S?|J???????w?(x????ji I!? ?g??R???CC???)??%R;?7??N=v?? ? ??kZ:?? '?? W ^?"?s?y???O9~'}?G?x??m???? '??^W??????-??????:uH!??3?N?3J?h2? ?>K??[/ ?1?J]???# ? MW???@?^? P9 ???? \J1K}K F?6?0 ??V? ?I\?]??? ? S| ?U??(V ??h?+??\? r ?u?H??L ??{?;?G?oOsK`?? ??gcrTB? t1?? B*?? ?
??]?
"6?? j??2?lO??t ?? ???VY ?.?4 wD*? ?P??3?&?E? x? ?C ??P?? JM?RK^|;?????`z??b'l|?
}@.v}?9 ?
?r|\ p??+?7! f ??S? ]SD?p|X???5? ?k ?O z ??P?t,\& O ??U???B,v ?> v?? &?????X ?? ???5w ?k0>??1????? `??7nf???3 ? J?9k?* ?) ??? B??;J +Z??m?? n? ???7?7'?=}?v?? ?^?+cm.^??r??^y}E??? USW???C?5?9??p?oZ ?MdW? ?|?"?
?n?i? ?v??0 To>' eNx??Q` ?^??z?F�G?o& ????n?q�?O?4?C? 5???R`^?fF? %?|??| A?Y? H????Ot?Pp ?Y.??P??? ?? ???>?? ?Ylr?t'(s?O????? ???h? ?? ?? ??)j??^?Sv???? E?t e?j?;Dq?9? ? ?5i1 ;B??v+ ?g?a???d?B?#??x? ??, ?=O00y UZP??{???8u?y?????{3? B ??w???4????C?????????d???mTR ?us b??4|?0??S???,t ?$x?F?????^x ? ?d?p? ??:??OR?m? .?6??E:??? E?n?? ???!??B?.?}y??RO??,P�? ?)??|r?6?*^?? ? ? J?O>? ?YZ?0f ?_?X4?? ??X)}5 P??c?L???[* ??R|7sI?:?$ ???'=?�???/???vB?UB? B???% 2?F5f:613V �?M9?* i?????[??
er h? ?K,?S?0'W5??\? *?'??eX??6? z??' ?`??y?h??? =FfW??Ttl9?J ?X?;? ?? ??r? ??zX ?iC ?ET?? ??? ?? $?_)\@?x??L]?9mXDwh?.?6 =?L?=?H? ????fu?? ?6? c?A9P?F???s?n??C?$??'?? ?? ?e +?U? ?? \M??? 9�?????TQ? ???? ?? y??D??hg?j?7)???0 ??O+F????I?0Mw?? ?Y? :g{d?W?? kL9z V}?#??j"3%? j???H? zW?{3?\ ??i?H)??{??4??1?? ??A D!? ? ~w?9=?Y?? kJ61l6 r?--M?????? ??X?}? Y ???9\???i????i? ?{ c ?_??A a?mZ;?>??gQ? ?=/z ?3?P jku??_ ?|?M ?(? ?
? 2{ ?:??h5?????% (M ?(< |?*?S?K??S?y?uc?~?A???$??fa?J(9K"?r ?? ?#YBoN?K ?p?M ?[9$?@`? ?!'? Uw??Q????? ??TN^?~? ?~?T ?o*'??? U?H (H??? Q????J ]????0"???[DS2Q??/??Ve?9? ?dX`Z??pW??h\OH6??d???'?L ??v, ?+A ?H%????^N P G? /?F?"??~????@#??
??mB?Uj??K? ?*?W ?zuh?*Us? ?x?b??%E?-? ? ??,Oe?PC C???? $/?7?5?>??`?~#??m \b?o ? ?8 ?#!=v?? 1??2??jL???P????N?U;� @?? ?X?oV? n?n ???h? ?
S?&. ?B?L%7^?? ?I l?a?? s?@???7D>???G+?? ?? KOV?nS?* {?? ??O?A??3?Rz?]?
?0?]??B_?/c?d{?i] Si.?-|?Y" E]] *-??B? ??_F ] ??? 9 M?Zx| 2?(k???_?9? ?No?n??&??? 8Ho?zl?!??1 R?? ? G>%?7T???+r ?%?? ?x??3QRr????u9?? }?*! ? ?D?;? ??{t?F"?u~|?#9~Ks? ? ?]?2? ???B?? pLsr???I????B?G^?
m?C? ??|# ?x??Z i 2?u??= Yr??s? +i?? i B2??o? v??W ??"?73? (? ???<"T QR?+RL??#?? ??+Q ????X .?uGf}ge??M?A??
y ?D????-`J? ???L?H!? ??6B??}? ??w??M ? _Aj ?KD .??ow? @y:^Ms}i??bT??W.`bM c??nM???i6c\? 5?
??+]??]?^H|?q?????K?Pi?|?�b'^h? ?? ?o ??T?[ c?e )??
? ?? ?e ??H??? m#??t{??Y=^O?/??? L?
?5Y7?(EoF??)%I ???'D?tO???>L ???{?Z?V? ? G#UP?j$?! �?m??; ]???? vw???(Vr?????zz,?y??,??`??~?p??n????sq??@!Hd ?br �'?=????\??2??c?c ??? ?? ?t?&???t]c?G?~???;5?? _o???P9w ??_,~??0??1??? 1?? s|? ??? *?L?_x?dB7g=C?O? |\?]???? ???nMp ?????/rl??|! > ??Z ?y????vK?o????k??A. ? X? ???n?ww�:?? ??s?u@?`HG?{;?y???{???+?? ?? ?hx?? ???S???T?k ?:????W?% ? ? = ??F?eI?Mc?? ?h??e?Y? ? ?M??a?Yf?7R_?f?\D?Gvt/??Bl:.C?}:?e? J??6#???c ?]??p+? J?/ 6???? ?,?a?Uv??Y?U??U???"k =?NZO?zqn6?? ?DzS {5????[?br??sJH?> ??MV??o>Wwb?X???':??1?P?"?Z??fX?0?GVFF: S?s?k ?l ??6S?H? ????p??w!??? ?vD ??? ? _h??8?}V ??,2C? ?oy ? ? ?????h????%M?IB 0??"?F?a?M???5?? 4 ??jK %ZE?M? MF~vWjB?? /4W?T?O^?s?_?X1?.?b??j??n?)e/ s?~ ? :?L?hz???D2?? ??i???>< ??1/????Ce ??TQ? ???V?? 5,?"??? F ????-f C? Z?%?? ?+??d ? ?@36 @Q F{5d??M????4???vK+M ?9 N???OG:G? 1?1|?? ?4 ?8??{?????!? M1??? ?? ,PW?????C %j ?? ? ? ?c 9?Xt?0L ???A?8????> J!?'eO?^????F&?O??Wk n?? &&:~J?{?f ??P????j? ? 8?? ?s?? ???-?????m????a?g?S? ?????{?? e??{??=? n{?=vln? (?Dj + ?O?)'??Z ??>Z???V? ??? ???LT??????a?>?? 4??? ?? ????C,c 3??{AZ R- bG? w?.?K?v(??8 ?=? ??Z ?? ?en&~PU?bb}S#??Q????voYOt( ??b?.yC? W?m ??N?3v?X\|? A?6???3? *? 3??? V3???jsakT0??O?CvJS ?-???( ?m???\EX? ?f?6?,=?a?t?KM ???w ??\nQ[?6 ?? ? ? ? gB??
ci C_??? Xv?y?? }L???Rh?T?$IE z ?Q?vfJ? ? (hM e?7?l?,?m ?9???v?b?Q?N?0 B?S??|?s?XT? a??U??L?Q??|???N??8? 7?M??f ???"???Jh ?? &??$)? ?)?x9C??) ?/? ?b??r? M??Q?K%??X????dn????#L??? ???G? J@ ?/? ?S ???? ? ? $ ?yQ??a?T;m?+??@?*:V?i? ?^?9m?= ?�s7??Z? _)?g?�I ? g) _???md?? ???\??TO?? ]??x ?!??s? ??? ?eY?)?k?( ??b!Bz???V ?^ ?bb????Be.^??@rcF ??8???Pz??e???w???B??RH?m???@9???g n??2jI????3[?? ??:?W??P- ~???3?3?Q??b????C]???t??^?d?y?? r?g????( na?r?/?5�C59 ????Hi??? ??? ?? ???? |????} x??HWH~ ?PK ?? ?(��?*��PK � � �?a?<������������ ���settings.xml?Y]s?: }????wJ?7???@?????�???7? -cel??_9 L ?K ~j!?%K?H?????E?= l???|? 1= ?v W???&??? ?"?????i9?0??"???Z9?!?L ~??O?? Lq???
ZS&&??6 !r`?ih??~{ ? ?G ` ?q?3|%bq% ?!??Uq???Pz??n ? ???? v &?O??m?w?%P?$K}t/??p??J???6 < ?oS???E)?&j?Q??k??^7? 1 ?z?MQ ???h?? e1l?? ?^ ???!hK?b??.??}zn{?g|? R???(?H?I~"L^ ?dCFq0??o???\?#??}0? ? ? Y~??&?p}?v???? ?D#?? Sb? ?*?q?t ?/ ??G?^? Z ?? ??d ?S? }/l?? XR?la KP??:8/?? ? ~?h??J???x[ ?A s??R??X ??3�????!,??O9?; Q??Uj??XKQ??v=??(??? ?0 g?P0?p?; 9eA ?? ?F????J0?% ? ? ?-$ Cn?; ?0?x? ??5*O M?+"? ?k1?'? �l?5?? ?z. @?jKT??`EDv 2?0??^?h????`??x?b? 1S?-K ;???%? [`?n?r ?%??HP? s?2?`s???*&?d??Db"? ? ???T9?l?N KM??j?J 9m ?A"5Q?8?Ng?M_C??~ n? PK ?|??? ��K ��PK � � �?a?<������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml???k?0 ??? ]??S??X ??A ? ?k H??\??? ?? ?~]K??? ??&?ZF;?Nh??~?c ?L?B?)? ? 6 ??????m??j?D???m ?6??Y?b??A?, ?a?m 0_???\? ?,b?$?? ? ?R??? t??? ?z}h (:I?? ?"?u???15 S??"? ???? ?U B?w+ -;]*????T? \?qY?iU????l7�G???r?
_H??D??F ojT?#???n9??;?Ik? .j^????? ?i??O_? Iv ? ? ? ???r??? g ��meta.xmlPK � � � �?a?Top