State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Regional Provident Fund Commissioner ( ... vs Shri Shivprasad Rajendrasingh on 16 June, 2009
'x V"
'V-*'
was mam. ¥3='i.c#.i»'2.Qt a{?m~s.., a3;;=x2.z.<t mm, axuaxqza
:t:i1..<:.;..:*«.'...v'=-I g ,
; w
\._,./"I
wifsba : :'l~*z*'i%E1~t<:¢1&<iiavs:: 5%: .ss£'='w.~u
:?1w;e?:t1'i::: Iiiciisva {$32 =:?L:7mu§3:&.m
m€€1u4£?tfi (air-cs, §--sm2=.ea. :x§ea Iu=:'t,
ML-21*; vim, 2»:v.:v.ms.
Efigw
mniiveea : ail zilcmem. a;-¢?:»§:c+iE:>x
3u_a,R1:aw~L.:; zfiuxqzi,
c1§:«.im uséi, zimez, mozzzcua.
law 2' 3%! =e=B...=?a,.a»m5;m, fietrséfiébt. ='w>s.2
2&7. wf¥..2?4.1wi1*<1Z';V, Qua.
L'+9w=v§{L=a%*.: =31i'z€z~»:-:. @3332 ==?t.sv&§.:a 2 ail '~>3..?»i:'-Qt.'-**.§_.'
f°i3:\£i*$*?. aaié umm
ggn. (sit fi.'+9La>zLgm, Eitammax iimz Htzsa }
1.'<»w§1a,+u «*~:'+;s=i1s.1v1 «m.g'f« WE V-za1sx=:':$a ta: *<>Lt€ir:.»; Mavaai gructeii =u'é =::§.Q.*'q; selzru w-'s, uaxawft-1': Ec'vin"=.s:i1 aw; smélet Mt'°i>.1§*i(€éP3fi HQ éiqmi ma a. mu $216413 »i.2<'.:~:«t»;r:e gar: fix. vmaxqza $124.». was dam fiaqiela am ru..'«1_g'$_.~'c:»s.\ru 2152: ~+§i,=3; '+}__'x<-L ggvz ma. fir.
"$fl*<tL§1v{1 »:=2"N.t:+. fig: $3.-W13 =>uE'< ®.
::m=.z<s.u=1u?; ::%'hm3.»': 33% g=..1,L::a,<»;~2ro;'--3; =w.:.~«z-«.1 wig
-<?;€aiT&"s'r=2z~i gm am am: cmv-£1 =?.< 2331 sue: £2. aiuiiea :;s:x:.ram1 mfassssi as amt magma-1: 9.2. 2u{l:1V§:T,z:c:?£Aaa«.Lu§s..
=:u-"-ucutsu :w."me'i.~"1 <:flq1z.~uuf_i€:E8~a 23 'git!-'--~t §.;u.ee::e;'--vii 'ms; =9ufi.<--; amen": Stain raiua mi ggéilvu ufaczxi 1-:2 astvu c=aa='2"r 3323. max.
§-€F.iwef12?s. <%: 1'i~--2.t«€L mzwi gm 1&3: £s3.'itus~."t.~7t ?C~'C33'ii 14.: fi'*'i~{1 fin; ems. Eizfl Q:i.=»:.tq,1u1: am': vlvmvil. '3: =~'=.'~:m:3. mil siizg a9zv;'mE-*Il 23% mt mi am stm'<£M1£'ct..:v~i 'ace mru. orwzvxz am .,:m 35% ~13: «§;5.*'-£3. '£--*zaN1.et 2-u iH1;v;»i'z mi 332:1 =>w'5L..
=21». sihua 24%. 3>=L-R mi 312 zuvuqwu as*€L>4.x.sfH g:.ma::>_s'~ 3.33251 341253., Mi «$321-=34 mum 69%. mzmi :«1.qm?=.
?
xaufaan gmii «.m&~a ea? $$.*4L'-,~€x--'ll 336: m*-u<u<:u.2?t ».aa<:1»{1 mu zsuaa. ama
613) 53:»
3. =3'v1em=. »'§??:N{E'--".£_ "git: emmzrm. aim 9&3: 14:9": m=~u<w:u. swiérs MR wi!.a-1.1 mm.-4..rsu $::':u.:_2.~u gut $€'v'»ti?:i éim S3-a.4§ $.25; ua§1.<:1'£q:.éi,:z€2Es =-.i 'maxi Mb=1<:i.
E7. ivvileazauez-«C: "$21 2315?: :3 Es, $:;"m.2'E==?a, saw': aiaaaz :z€'z?s '1*=W3.t1 "int afiailészzi ru..=1_.=':z_:-M til cu.x5':,:'<;<as ggcii +b.:s:.:'1 mien ans mi :§it'1[za'i';~:4. A-£41 =3'tv~c~?u§'m 1£v~i1:.v2; :3: gm ~;::u,2, tit 3-3+."=t'.§?i'§:3'4 infzeil Mm. 'M31, .3: 3331 am =~3t=u::£\sS:s Mm; alrzrru '?.<i:<-N --zi'L3z 'iifii vi.%'i.'?.'2f\E1's"v3§7»:O*ti, Wax again eiéia:
Qéa Sues: fisifiva ~i..*:%i.'§s.x«33*<:,*&-szaa, {clam filvafl A-=..~'i zzaanjanxufi «mid fiat «:~i'm13:mi ara: oi-xaéxreaz. m.°e.;'::;7®'~; fl c:u.<;::;r:~a~ giiil &=i1zus,'1*e¥L §ui~'ua ww Q5 qm u£l.23{§=.-'1': WI: :euv.:<n.t<s11:?z wia \>u,suN.i am .m<'aat-1 €31. ¢€iau~ei1 {@513 fwsfmi saw, mu, em £1 awe} «.:,a;2;'<::>¢'~u mail éilzusilvu iii -ma 'M53 =u:<:a,.*':mu 2:15.. «{.a;'2?: 51: ~i.<::'1.=3.r.'gmrc';'%.>a~3 vu m*ws.:.tsu wit asg 5-2":
&%"v--tLzsIi-1?z =*R;.r:1~"a~e ~i*>.:.w°u~.: !zu,3=1i ggwm am: azanmtvxxawk wtfia E188. $;:"awa~u 332.$a=f3ra ;:;«««=.t<:=. mfitaz. <='=€i=u»=.'i«'1 2a.m.m<ms?t '-E2it':3.i9. ékazfiva eefm.
<.v2'1ut;fi-2?; Q3; siafi. a.L.'a:_a%;_s'\2e«.: flax »::z'ieua'3;-R -izssmidi toga swam: :»u.£i:*a;~.
Aeél s:€%au<:~.'::~»': timma '<?m<a««;: »i..nr1eu_s':m%zmi mu. 3.5». Emscu $01 vi...~..-r; cm I3'-.-raizi 'I~I.J;§ $3 3:; civxsvaz 9a3t.*a':.~{1 aavéiiui "aséi 5?": e£§s§t '£5.23 azluqxtm 112,54. $2 -'=u.€za. aim {Tr}?-i¢Zi'¥i£ €i~{'=. Ftslfl i*I.l*£t€{l¥it!;3'3i. slit '-:<'xs§é»'a., Qml {3t.:«.zr=t zfizt ftaetwti 3:;-zmi. %>u<3:*.a «ii. <*lLR'=it'zi zzumczwuzlz t'l!.Rx'3'§?§,i'0'K*1;t ilfii' g:.¢:,:;a,,ra*o;'--« ?<.>L~u ma "&1.dL**.3; ~2ii'it<=Ll"lP~:£ him-(1 '-mfitez 95 1-aim >w1<:,LwL 23:1 gm waft MM we. era, Es ::a.'*s4u.~:I1=s"-a % {clam Etkwaiivix sm aia %§:*i =r-m, métset Refs. am amtézai aeia <1 min. ¢u::~r,:a vii 'w:{<3~*3. wt um -"$3; av€m~i{-->:. <?t§:-2«t, ~13»? Va?.2--w.va-it wit, s~':.\o£'Lo1 ~Si%.«em'i vzm 'wt: zusa. gzsnmvil f~_;1.'i-c§&'}N;'- :s,~'«. w;L"Lw.'i 3;a..<w>sm»;,e'-{t en': Si fan: cu.<1;'z*;<:3~:z '~%-Ma 12 am am: ga.2ws_.«'» wk =~ué{§.a-:1 owsvii 3.3% 13.2 'i'i@;'7~ ihfzmx .¥sL'£%.i§'.*£'1 wt. §5L.'3.'<:\%=E3._s'- 4&3; u:c«:1.s«:1 wt. g,a<:er2x.r'~ :u.<a.;'2:;'<:3-u 231%' M 24,2? seuzme. 2: mélé wu ma aswni. <1~1fie' f31'Reu.:§ €134 E":-'-z.i<Vs. weal 9:, <1;-.{t iggittéqg s*€tu.:~a'1=21: :.~1m;=wJu5'<. <;.m=:<u2 °$2ii:i.<'1 M3": aéiazéiafi -=:u=uq:uw'x 211.2; m":.r»c:-2st": s.-u.::;1r;;'=._r:.>oxz ew+..zt1z.e.=u mi; '4.9t<>*L€ta&.l?i mar: €128. $=iit:.=.s:1=»'¢ 1£?n.<.:H'1 $2'li(La=1i"s$w'13.-& Sim em Sigma: étwil iuzlsra 53$ mzvfl m.=a?H't '{t7i.t*=£?. mia aim {am ?<ri.3i'. 51¢. 221 és~fl.=+ um: Since: ::?.».v'i?-zs.e'.1«:z.&a:(2revu 31¢ «ion 41% smx: we data 25% gaqnz ékwar w.;-Mia zmw 3;1.u.<>,<><>s:~;'~« 2:23. "vfiivu g1..~2.::«,r::»<:>c'>,*'-~«t'l Hiangii szzii ¢2't<+.:a §i4.zs{1..
1:. azasqirazalt uT:.c:,m.1°s=u:»m.t'sé1ec:§1--~u=c?«Vz«z§na: #13: 311.3% Si '<3ts1~f3v.a zs.Lzws.~.tru mi; Q3; 2461 «am am «ii. wuxwzruzz-'t zimavat asaw-»m'L fig vssazzfica ii: 3:, :tt.Z§2f§2001f'ii vim szinzai <m»=u:il s§v5.-&<: '»£i.=?i§. fstuscu nzfxa 24$": ;'w{£ 25»; gm,'»:2.<*-_»2:o_.s'-- $E3.*iL€1;{ '~'EL3:€'.i¥F€i am Sm -a2 miru méz aim <:zu°s={a; um M1512: sun, $3» am: wo3:»<>x-{L min eatla we. §;L.'1.<::~,es&.r"--~:"i aim amaém 225$ ma 1% Eta?! m={a<u<m mék szziqzaieil 279$ am mil <=fi.ss<m{\. ewii.
'I-
5. salzafiziél '~§'&::lt*il i.'1,'~;s'u5vs?:%ti =99: mtcla 2% E, msx,-'z,,='=svw1'1 am-ami. mfzm wit:-1 A43; €m~'1 am mi": <u.'x53,-'@2261 a:-um. nvvit '=§:§=?a. SQ uraé.
stm;'ug'a3sa'1 eum mummi ¥>ii5{f:t 21 a3J¥ms.'L~u aim §°a'bs; asmiz; am [-mil auxcu uzésm aim -M91 atxxqxcxzg aazlg it<:n:u1ur;§ é§. films":-an rrtmmi av~:azz«u:'sw1L«{i wa 3.';.::x--3=w;'-«« sszii =+;:r.+,ZLw. 5-z<»u-[{§. we. gx.waLee:M_:"~-- §',i'=i'i§rQ azqxai c»:a.»31e£1 it =*.<:<:=2 ail '£0093; 3>ii1l*i1°i <?:s3.=<u £9 Em :smuazwua?1 <*.4*2z2}5.e: $9, Rig mt %§*-{ aecszrgexmi géviiaa exii. EH1 Ems. <3+:.°s mat amm {am-1'! %,§fi-3. ';§l.{'3:£Q£:€3_i'-~ suit mils é.<wuvr'.1 Eéfil g:.ac<x:<:w_.«"~» ¥u:c:e~:.or.x:2;'--gt z-efmafiax <?:<3:-a um. M9; .s.«<«$L°zs'1ax v?':£%.->9: amen was-u gmmsE%.r'--- exit mails $L*»%1-Li g;.x:.ee»1,='~» §:L3I3R-LE'*.§. em a3:,2;c§. is sikuzll-xx aim gm»: %iP£l<¥.li*1!.'33§ @122 $8. M:«<:~%o<>o%tz. 'ezu =:s><. gu1eszx;,-*--- ave»? .w~u;.;2 swuwl 2»,-E gm-eLr.'»<:«5--- wiisazl 2512; §.1£ nail gwaa«1\g:"~ aee{:--2oomzi 1'§i'£*{}.G3l,{7i<31Qi*{i a=+.w.<'a..c~L 945% :g1.2x3ee;'-: man, 22111 gzszravez-e,='~ Htvilsvta §N§.$§ sia; 2'9. $€i.?{l§fi~'tt yam gm etL21.a.2'1 azzczxzai $3I's*u.a 2:919: =<»u mu; 3,,w.:.ec:a».~'v;§~ iwxqmm ma: 2% am: :w.'1tu:-.'l~u ssart gm '1<cLc3'-<:"q%ti. §s7»:Itua'i«u =§t»i:t{§.+E:*{L :Asu'3-"2 vi.3:3'°L~:":"-L§"~i"~i'2f '<ri3l >3+.sz=Z2:-«a vi.%*:'1:2.v3',-wswai §:.u*3§»s:..-"-- §:i'*~l?~.R anti'; Lmfi. Staai %§'¥{ =ue:'i:s-:1 g;.2z»3e\s;'-V gmtesq. ma an ma mrse-«2r;r;c»:.i as-35; aia aw sziqzalwa sad '%§°5*«~{ §amm<m..=a?; Emu}, <?x..-:.mi§, qiafia. was 13 5% 1853. wék ztrauil ca:-mas. aefiza visit. $'e:1aufl=.?1 :,'is§'u3«--s2»L1 qgui *2-"'§'t.!si@. £9 's %1Q£cl"<~.8i{9;{ <t£.'i$-ci;'?.t:)€3\1,*Lt {me =zsi£'s'w,=_g Maw wail 'aoc.w;'¢~0<m-«u zimles. aoozj mt ' ms 5:, -m.§s'3_ & eazzasqzaxuix QM-'1 33% «M1. 823.': a==€1wLs.=1i mzau E§"a'°i*{E. *2.Le '-xulawuat 9;.
6. i?L\1cv-mt~'«z§§i<1 sii a$Tm..V211.tzz§ ma auaimmt m.% :33}. vi iaimmmi mafia 1%.
an at. %{l*i'a<il{!1!:';t $'v:'iw:,1€1a?s. Mia s~§"t*i«»»ci-rzvii °i£c<i,*L'?13%?.§:E§, «£2135 ay gala »t.==>.'1.. amt<1t£&.t$~;. sad: zéafira {'<':... =:.='aw am: 23;; aim. a't1'} gm': Q3: sia' «.231 3:191 '_§?.'L¥i1 Eva 1*); am. mi}. 8; «tie: %§,Hl€i.i<='t'~. xuil .95.? =;£simz::.a« 13»sz:iza3:~:s{t._M w,=m.zuu "$3: a«€§rs.: aka: 3;, afl:2+1sil+1 ~§§.33"s. as». atsanéi §<=e;s<»i1 l*£tQC{I?iE inucii $3» 62:. E1 <»mx<mz 'viii?-l aautfiwil :43; waméig =t'=-'itmfiné aizzitvs; ézzsa %m~%1. §i{3(iqEQf££i' :>.{§ sag; véufifiz 2:4 zezaus-xi esmlez, «vii. mxtqtuzzii isfizu:-2'.1vu £16 R-aw} °'«5cuM Maui': e§1'q 5. we: lg aaquai 2»u<?;ea emit. e§mz ram: vg .:«:~,<uui zqfia éaiive-ti % tam 'i<:(-.*2f~L*'-ML wt =mwcuri3. esfi 3. m:::<-.~-2.::;<:>o»zi ma:
=>ma<:.mi =»u<'z=2: azasqztrzawz sew': ~f3u.:?u=¢ %C2a9:-asii. emim nag rwii Swft »:x2'm;s1§'i \'ii:*{i§5r<%. item. muqzui awafia {.6 $1 ts=i1»zu.é1:§t 181?: 23 fix $£e<t.£3£°§i gacm sun fiiiw-119i };.$,ge.'i 23%: gaqqzwi '1 ma aft sziqza sma $24: uiég azzaaz «"u<:; aé s§. -:£l...?»'.g'%';'¥O0"a'v'it =;":=x sfliaxilait :a.x=ucuuuvE $91 L-'ism:
«:21 2»zx;'J;aV, i»'(a~:3; E: a.z.[2,\='*~s,,-='2c:<>z' gwilui iiaaét 3: wfia {7e;a.'»a'+aiV $Q"i°~'%'.i€.13t 233 igzecii Hamil *:;'1&fi¥n§. M31 '>{l%t {%a.::m?L it agsqqxni ?<r§.l5i£~1 *i'<'=fi Egg. =2.~s~m§ M151 Pmr iéfirzitfias u'l..>.?:£-a. $541 scam-<<~'ie{t}{L~¢'1} M3: °:e{--1}{ét} °a\a.L $l1:?"lEl €133 szctaxi zruri. E: \{§a:-.«=.+tL1is§1-it @113; cents 1&1 "$5 5%. .s.a§.2u.2'i ivstq-:2: $533131 sue-t £9 Sui': i:i.l*€.i¢l3,<'='tiR§. gwik 2.3 '1. semi, =.~t?i :;;'1tu.2I12?1 £15: zueia $3 2 g:.a,22,ex<:>,%-- z;2'iu;;e.'t4's. aerfi am 2} 9&1 {:2'ietz:».'1?: ufl.:>3:.§.~i'£ 25». fq<-wit gscwpti Mafia 2311'4.<.4p~a-ii 23:: mm {$2 % %<:.<:u~eeni rcsami silqiéi --»:.<{£«tz1 Ra :1"£.={{§,sH,i «€232? a:~..~ «§.rt=. neat} 82:3 23:14 i{'.'E,.,?ft:','es"i.?$',:""**- r'~li. vm eacflé $1 mtfi ;?_t*\'.i:fir2 szszmi znxcia QM 'on an 1::<ac:--amweigg-2.~:e3a ssiex r§3.¢{1g.=2'*§l£*«& $$_'lI4:.s:':--'t vaflza. E-uni :?L>»i~«1aw& was': mm gscuu an M': :m:«uqwv.~4h Era «.23. chi: {aufian %fi£'"+£ »g.é1.sm1 wlat >V:.mzq:<:u:r{t21cz1-{ihmii gzcuq suit £24 [61, :2"-.2'$;
313%'.-~:1i.2%l {ma a»ma2.><.i M' «gas, ssiaw. 493.3, wig gz...<z,22,<:1¢<::;~ iefiiiaa zoozrefi uféwi as: am: am' er. zwiiu 3»*13.'J;€t.b-it ggami 93:1 wazuu £2}, swa E». c«.a.:s*;¢_:'~z\s»~u 231% >sa'12zL€i.«€i r:?m'l git mfza ME <tz.¢.»a~;'1r;'t:é:r>~u £295 £13 $?J~'-t1»=§i~i axmcusti w~=':.<».z 23* em': &:€i.ea:2'.1 $91 -2.ae mu? iaséivtz Q5 =:.éi»-uvil
-:~:z2;"md1 'Le. .::.e=. cum atusgs' ga.a,.:: :.».,r:3»:z,=-'- {M iluiqvu, sé.&E£'~': em :3.
;--'m: *3-,;,.2:e:_,2:'u:;~«-«£1 wt *1.*s'f:"~£~~f.<%'v1.it~§,E.s§-3: 'ie£~:»':~%*3t:s»::s=~s,i gzvasra Ls['3;e<.
--é.'z2£ .s's33uts."1 am: a.:::ceu.~~r:e'a{l =L<:c;<:--~ma::> §;y{1~;; ow; {ma as: €233: 'iwzrzcu ééé-IE é§ Stsii {BL ¥§1%'*i*tl §a=~:.1ii gm-.132:-2z§_.='-~r{1T MN, 2:4}: as ra24,1°z< gggqqmg §,a1m.E '£531 éazsa smeil V32 mzzsu £s€1t;1§;"i.£s, fiwsm 445: ate. '-t':'»1Lei; vtefl fiat? {Ml ms. gsnni €>i£'«;r-1.1-{i'2{?r_;«'-*_ wait. Ftafl «wfla erismr R1352 am 'itii, sit? -{iii gig-H swmi Mar} 23:
$33 <1. mile: -"cr§.2i.<'i= 45.332 sacmi 3-'€15:
E1. :s'm.~x;:. gs-«mi ~«:E§¢. Emu 3:-Ami mi: £3}.
(gs aiw1sts1:,:&. silitzéifi as «L-:»:2<; éwi Mira: so féqee. wsétwft m'lw.2ii
-"gi.."'._,'~i"+'._,*(:?-."O_."'"--+3. §:§2"rt {Ewe r&t3§3i.r.< 'N; am. cam: 3:93 gm,u.,<:1ra_:-e§.z=qrz':ai Qr{i3=.>:-ti :1 ttR"i'~*£ c-m°2N=.'"t w»; *3§sR*<ii."":¥. gm zmuzti, M51 ii: wig. <1 rr<:.t=z:<{£ zsxzvii avsmnél 2.21 "-'EQEL zzma. wfé ¥__§',¥:~"-.cia.>ti 2»=::%1»:~a <'3ttLf"§""l'3. em «aura. 3'»=.ca:~«i'a ?§§E. <«u$i-i1 am am ':1 am 62% '?_;_V1.*e.,2;2,:;»,2roV.«"~ gmqmi '»»_::.?m 3': ruiit-:vfl --t<_g;.».~=.<,:'s€". am ~:1«1i§.§'3, 4.0 am am? =;u§t it $.91. s'fi'11zra'i.~'% ggsattzrtl .&2qw,i M31 2}.
3:tt*£E.<wJlt'<;t :w'e;'i.aa:L.v.iIé1 ae<:'»:---rse 941 av} 'i<-:é:¢':~'<€3GG gal g:.2rmm:,-Fmrii we. Gm 2:3: aqmii 31:31:12? 9% <1 zmrzrril. aw.
$::."z«-aL2iHi <i?.3fl§i'~'¥i Mtuqtui maria *J.-s:.-z. 24$:-£1 gs»-t =49; t'a-smvii 3v§m2'i£ :28: E': 2:i,3z.vii :§,'€k«1:%§;+EE. am {M as gas: -cm 2»e.zv~a<u-z\ {EL e%.2.='e. gm a3;<se. 3v 9:
22. ..s.:<emi =«»ué1 *s§, zazaazqzaztaia ailazsliiz et='m Hznaia -2:12: aver"; :.v»:'1z:.:eV I-viva gwozeoi-~{m'."§ gum: 0': =9:-m gm} =3s<-xcn~iz gm §:'9:<11*1i>.vu3ts3:.
-'aw.'1i=:-avu H3; 3:13": £553 gm 3=.:tu=*Li avuctsit vzaii.
'wi':°a* M L _\-"O<:*i.t :;;_{a:~?1. €111 '§'§__.€<'.{l3>iE.E€r!.<1;*ti'E1v&3."-é .--\-.-9----unu-,..s.........,..----,,.~\,u ,_.,...a.. _ . a-.»...a,_,.,,__,,_,_..... _...,_.,,.,,,__,....._ L' _ _ 'K ' :§:a.2&.2>a§°m§ é («saws firilg iflaasxfiag Rune Rm? '