Karnataka High Court
Sri.Veeranna S/O Chandrashekarayya vs The State Of Karnataka on 31 May, 2012
Equivalent citations: 2013 CRI. L. J. (NOC) 335 (KAR.), 2013 (2) AKR 27
Bench: K.L.Manjunath, Ravi Malimath
IN HE HIG COURT OF ARNAI KI
CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD
D4TUDIIIS HE I DAYOF MA 202
PRESENT
rYE HOTBLE MR USII E K MANJUNAfl
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAW MALIMATH
PEnTIoNrcoM6S65flooo fl4J
BE WEEN
ri Vccraiii i<.
1
Sf Sp (ij tr at - vi
Q t
\ItaL
Lejsati e As%cmbI\,
'
ea I'Lt ri al \L S!( -4t
-4: ci
P --t n '(\f
4:
3 I P j \ It)
iND
F ' a
S I IC
- 15:1-
:3. ) (( 3
111 tF 'i I
Pa; H
--
1
3
Ii 7<1 ( 63 1.
RlNP %'t147\N
3 o a h •\ I H
ri in ii a VI a Ii
CI V 1 1 an fled an \ ielt 271 227 1
lit I ansiiiuta 'Ii 4 linilo ox ing oi all iof reeord rriatina
lHe pi urerdiflg leodaig 11) insue '7 he ruptigni ci ndri
I M -H "B M S /\tJ Dl ?
21)0 vid Ar exu F P° 0 H 'he I Jar file LoLa ak a or (1
anti ptruoi e1 1idr flu
i is i ir r. x ci
K.LMANJUNATH, J,, niade the fcIloxxm
ORDER
Th 1 ie1io r H H irfl1eTi4in tar de ci I 'V I lie ml sp ii fi St of ar Ia ci ci 7 20 f']; 1< r c;nuL,: <1(12cc Ia 'on <mci h< 0113101 \I1lith1jJL,< i k i er ci Ia 1%L i l a Ii I 1 0! 111(01 ii ci;;! ui 41 -I <1 I i i i r r i
- - a K- <7 s-a a -- 1< - In I 1! -- 7 .1
2. lb.' ki"J ii ,u!tii L' ;hi'. i'iT l'tt.iLU3fl ut' 4% it. rruridrr' a't't II• .L' V. tin Pr; flit n at 'ii ''; i lid tilt tjr%: 'ni.
ii 'gd diclilt n 11 ii clah..i Ii
Kani s r uth ol
I
Intl Ii d to c lion It P
( .)i1%tItLit ( rn .,'Y t.uc 4 11w Ia'4 di e
ii')lUIfldIiisiP-- 'isa'. $1 '3 200-i and h t' 1--It with na 3w a
'Iu' hint- in tile hit rinmiridlinri Ti 1' ai'e Iii-. •ar ilit --
I)' tilt ..V%I.%fl% "I thi Rr'ple%ent Jj('n ni l%'epW'-- Vi. 195;
Iii aa'-- ie.piii.--ii t(. t'ie ..1l"i% i)TT!1Uhi('J!
t
fl iiiCi1iiIiflL iii'.
•'" 1 I
r t% ii•' a liii - nfl' lit as
InC ci r (V
tt i ii
u-hi in tL ' ItS of
i_a' 'ti:r h€'. a: i _Vi I.' •tl: 'nti 1
., t!,!;. . ." . ( . ;•t t''--('t .
-- .'
•'.•i ,': _•, •'i..h._'• •. t %• I-- tJll j. •ItjtI:_ 'fi'i
1 Ii •
1'
IC •1 •) 'Ii 1' •t • I.
a I (
'a! T1 cr •1•1•'j4 I I, )[ i a:pflj 4
'h I •' 'I W
N
)t
•' '; j:1'[,tI '. .F • IL U' '
(j, •'p afl TI
Ti 1 [1 ) 41
I jik. Hf) S IL' F lK I UI
,ip •'. icIiai. .1 )I" ...L j'ut'ika
1 ntq --ii; r
Ia 9)1 at J Iii
101 JflflP1TI%. SIR! TI! 10) 4
o IL.)s aiT..flI IIt .TL-)ftI(tdS..k' 1
L a
.1111 aiopq pu" i 'pc) fl IItTIfl1.) •'q' iszaq l.u,1LTL xl aqi
S 1)LfI(jUfl P --fl%) If) ZU11I' )f) I UU %LUU) 'IL 1I'A
1% q i
ur 0J13U dlIf) auap lI'%I sr"ja
• T
1. llLI..)TJt'i\ ' h '':" ItI.L .II'() !.Oflc. : C Ut) I
F' \ 1
lilt 'S J
I-
•1
1 to ilit ii upi it 1 €11(I
tti' Ii•.-Iunaiiniis filed in tilt pt tilioner bt-t',re the 2nd
f
1
pia hi iiiidr' Sri ioi' 22 nI tit. i'! 1
' a eh' r i 200
0 1 1
a sets an I iiabiL ie' sub ml trcl rider & lion -- of flu
Kani
i
4tak.. 1.oisavukta &n hr thest 'no 'aur% I cmiv
egar non insu I a It ht ci 'c uot x'uri I
go h J i c ce lit
i'nd trial 'it had dktlused hk own. i"liij' .l 11w Scooter in
t5-' t!rs; %Ia
e
1 rnent '1 -t%se1% aii'I ilabliltip.- anel th--
r ii u24 H r
sitht ti-iou. y lisic on in id f_ui tci tin ion in
.wnei nip 4 i hi- Sc .u"t 1 h W ilu- '--ub'-.eqi ten ve.t, ol
iar.ui ii at hi c-i )fl3 2 3 1 Lui ii
nC 01 1' lIC Ix
'.. iii't It--'! -' .h - I'.,] ir. . e ii' I.111'i ] - inttii_Ieci I fl.c
ILL t' 1' ----. •':_, - ,I lpi- _i._').,.'.r 'I •t
'1 L '4 II
0' 'it i ) 1' ,tI I lit Ic- I
Iii flU sitl lit"i' '4'idflt
vh. ka( 1(1 that It ttnuld bi. bt'ond iiis flflfl'it' :n iciuk ITt!'
.3 1 )ii)di t ilk n i (I % it ' loui tti u
Ru'ir (11c d L i%
ol Prople i( I and iiit' a%c and 1i:ihiliiIe' (let lar& tiriclr-r
S lion .2nf" L, kauk a Act
'-f..-1n hrld lza. lit vc,,i1d not jitot 'i'o thc.
ar.adaii 'ut. I,efozr thc t tunuig OfI'cc.n In-- nint-- to liii.
i r I
hahih.ies tilt '1 lb.' ib e'u ?015 200o sum... 1t i'tu, c niitec'
1• nt.':'(ion I!mt '.c.vieI%l3il) 01 Ifle .wo wheeler beatUuQ \, NA
-- o uc t di i
i' , , c etc
• tar )i .r%Ct : thu tic..
Ii )'i I jJ Ii fl lit I.i ii 11 ri ':t. ' iL
IP.Jt cud. i;l :1 t ttii'i_• IL jIr! jn. Ij 1.1. ''.' Q'!wr_
1. i r lj r a 'I • ' 4
t,l i ' I i I I ''1 C
in r;. '_ F. uIu • •: . .;.. --. •,• •i, !'
horn ih ta,t rnflirpL ni Kurn:itals tin ptic liL c'I QitaIii%
n c F 5 C t I t
flfl J'iC'tt 'li_ti ifl jfl thinly j has a nflijn,,jnj 'i: ''fun' t
ii r t'i , IT i nt.n r uc hc
Kar'unaka L.';kJv''k'a 'V t in' I1_%%Cd an ordvr dim 'irn the
RtC'4ic r I ii Iue a uni html I tnt di p i' (tiC n'I
Mi sn 4
c i Ueatne lie e lb Is ill 1w ju tic in
fiuis Pru,hi,n.
Ii ô i t t S bj )'I
2nd n'worl.te:i' d:'nvin LiCe .aI't'.iiit'an ma' It iii tihi-- Prttiiufl
1 t 1 1 1 it j ouu 11 rq ti 'r hi
d'%Ct% icil i'at'1Iltw sL'i 'ints'l b 'hi pc itit'mr. h
PDi' C nut u.le. a oti.'net iifl ici St--c .1011 I 1' of
Pt
L!'i' "ii.'l'' ' 'i 'iiita'1 ti aS Iii 'I 'tfl' t'('isij,i'i
i A r 1 ' a
I;s •1,
nj,' j•w L''J'Ia . . i'l ri•'- i I Ld' 'r lit
I I I r •r a. : \T tii iii ,
1 •' '.1 '' a
, I I rt
S
'; Eli a I nt ir I hc in t
idking 11% inroub ib. c 'urpl;ilnt hitLe ci tv' Sn lIin'dtlwt and
L )i% Iii F i It ) I %%( ii' bc s'cl
sp..ch iii a. ni'i tb.,. 'tie .'1 ('..J;.fli(I('fl$ ha'. çftf fl --.
'incline ilk in c)u1c' not io.;k I1lo tin i1IIc1a4t flu d b t)w
titi ier (tn lit 't lit Ilk an h.. (nrc C tid
I n! ha't' d:rccie.1 the Rt-'%Ira' to lnclur I cnniplaint iin.ler
I I if a lit % 0 '(C MY lit )1
tile 1k.lItinr.tr to Inil.ate criminal jirc.eeedlntit. -uainst him
i., 1-- t I •i
a t €1
llaI)1Is11es k clarrd l.n him in, 11w yea, 2003--200b .uwi 2005
Ot 'c C S C 1 1 U
.'ent1onn•Q €4 the Cwo vI.t.-1t; bt-€."mt! \o rCA 2c.•Q!*!) "n'e
I i•c w I cc qy It h ,t
• lit t' C' a' 'dl • er ;'j' - s 2(k) 1 ._';(' cilia Ic'r Stir r.n. _
t
4 :fl
C s& • in i lu 1 lb a' t' Ot
: '.1.1 pcI ,.' : •
: "ii• c•• . r_•,1. ii'--. i -- 1'--
Vs '' e •' .cr c ri' J 1* ii
I (I (S • I ii 1 1 i H i(.(• ,.
•'•• 1.'. •--.."
H, j
1
a
I •
, ,
Ci.i'l
thu I a n t,'flI( ill i I t €iI(li cliii ,lfl(Ji%( Ic)%tK1 in' 1W
1 (tdtt%i tht iw' vIicet tat 1* 1 1 'i-cIt % I Ii I
_0). ' - H ?11' I ( t(ifli Stint I u itt 0h1 tid lilt .iail 1W'
sh'c!cr Ia' N' r ' tale. I In hnii iii (hi a(1 am'
Li ibilit C sta'enl -at wbrniltd by hin I )r 2fl 1 20(5 by
(ICI tçI. ird ii I ertert Ir n I i in b i Jiske...
in die ib' qu '1 I year of 20O 200ü and (lie owner% II) 1)1
the. Sootti is alsO LI1%ClO'*d In Liii )al liCt 1
1t" dS i.hc
(au .4 :'a rnaccaitrlei,2rdt sprd rtS hr
I 7'•' ,A IP( " V.'t "r2' U
11 s 'it i ij° cc
€ ' C ,x ' i--i hi'
ci ret c I 'l' h pctitioi Ci % cuiiilriiLi,a(E
1
h: ''I1en
-
.;i' C iii.'k 1
Sec tj ,r ' ni th.a It d'ai 1 L'Ld C COt i.i 'I ictil L Ut ILl
' c it : Ki ii iP I . - P ô i I i •, I l•
' lC 11i. • ii ('--1 ij'l,?it I 1;'ciPt i
t'id'"s i • r
t •t lic iji * bib L1 I a I e • :
,bIi
•J ,l :' 1 •''•' --
A
7 P iuslng falsc
infonnation- U hocrtt. Iw"zq :e,a'zv
1) 1, 1 lii .1 1! If) 11(1 10? ('71 cifl s ibi ci
?; cU lj j ulAic ' '"ir 1 S SU 1 j *i'Csi
'1 IT ft v?gff.IJT.rgf..hl "ii lift. i.JJ(f ii'l,&'it
ii' Lit' bI'.. uL
Icd"t. shill b pu'usnnz 'viii; cj,,,iik'
1 .ro i , ti 'hi i ci I
to sL'c iris nflii.'-. .n irish line- u'hu ii may
u.. ii ript'. w1i
'r 1 ii'' "IC) 1lt"ie' ts'IiIt' "C t%
Iepalt I'o'traci :; yin TCbpL. is his'
(Oil? Si)? 1 it (I U C s€ I 1 T
"te puip )St prerr'?lrtn:j ilic cumrr'Lcslon ol
L 7 141 ft
.1 iT' ?s!,xIe r. s4:hi •r'inncau.iCrli • I 'fti'c'r
II,! if ?r Ii, ?(
ft.. _,
t iv . r u UIL 'fur. •
•.:i ,sj
C
1 .4 %j'' .'. £ . 9( •.tI ' :! 1'
'IL I -- I -- ft. Ii, '. i1( •', I. ..ifl
• t
i $ 1:•i II •._..:.
lit. •
r-- t
'i (t I' ' bt ri' i
• III 'l..1'% 1' gft• ' I
.'I' •TiL!:!c g ' ;'L'sI
I I I
• • )a i,'ii --' Ii)'
'a( ':' m. s' .!1U '! I
'P -'•. 1% '.
'U
,r: 1 r '
••;iTi i"• •'
) a'
10 )% 4) II .1 II' ). Jo S I.
.1 itIfli q •-'tp grJ,fl aur "! •)qj :; 1
T J' 't)i %11'qa)Ji qi
1 1 i I C, -1 •L
.)44 's.uIdn% U Iifl'j .11)1 T1(S?aI JtT Sl'.U •IJ-3q1 •)sfll: L.)
I. T
, ( I
ji ).P3j I"W' Nj) S%4Jt1L11 is iii in ai ,%tIaiIi, It) UOTIIJ flu ti"
11 1W )JS 10 s )L . JO U )
p.)).jUIqti--i IIO11i?J9 '-1i t.cql!flc
e
1 JJ p31' %gsna: 91 1 --btT1 )Lt1
tic iaui j p u sti U4 W I 4% UP q
I' SnOT %) JIUfl% •I1l T{tIflOI( i ura • q i(1 Inc. !WiOr t (N'
'ifl Ilj HtJ JXW( 1W %.'JIL .11 jJ Ji'1' sI a ' ji gLO UN'
341 1 u\ 11) t ) t•ta)
o 6 ,( 9 j liii n
'lt I--"n'i' 'I' lIlt' i"i kflhi)11iI.)iI '141 '-i' gUt'NJT .1113
It I JJ ,' 10 C 311 •1 )I TO T% u1
I?
L ntis lie r1rt'UI1i&L't! n t •giei" t di r1;;eniI ç ill
lii 1 nfl! and . thc nit
'-I
lFtrt that t i' 'Phil
vou1c1 have IC) )tjiic"i(h tj)t nppropnalt auth n'1 namely
the Fit 1t(ifl C nmnns Inn --mec' ti-u %alcj nlatt'r'i 46 not rnlt
t
ithin hI% jtlri%clieLlnr. the ieaedr. of hit-- impugned i'rdet
t tha e Ot1 mid •n't ii
i it ii is ii
'flit h'nt o iforrna dii Inc
1mm at .bTi)kSlc,1' It- Ive 111101 inrfli iIn ktfl re (li%ti11t'
.txid Hf triable %epan--teI in iW 1I)
.
1 flI •tt. b.t'eO ')fl tilt
fl) lien '('fl'si(tti iJi 1'
( c'It t u' rkr" ur'e!ra tc lain ;;
i1i'
iT I lit t K.
,Litt -
-itt '. ti to iii i'c nit ulec
lfrl-. 'tl'lits'! g 1Ii' .1
ffl 1i .
ilVn" j •, i
,- ':.ti
I., i• p.. fJ
.
1 .f I .--t •1 lit. l.'-%' ' J• • .e .1. r. • •T I hi.
Li'' Z 3 -
u :1.1. t 1 ir- 1 • I r1
' ft IF
1
)tCl he i wh Ie
I'rc i'"ls is lien tht 1 e 4iec I ni 'ht J'fleI"
j t' 1)j i'j5 titI%,fll! it 'lt b' (('LI I 5'' iii1i .. itI%iitiiuI
7 1
s hout ci %( tllfl -- (ho%t tal IS%t1 )ulv a (he en nd tha
tht re 'c fnilurt to him! "'ii the • 'Wilt i hin of thu Srnoter
hotit %fd th ac'kg id tht a
irn c ca d d ii jst 10
a • omplaini svlut .teeurcit in u" the orcJ.t r vU lair' for nnn
'i'1ic'i1r.fl '
mind ' :'n 'tlencr i cn.nndilen b !l1'--
0 31 IC
In i" C .irnct 's R ' idt solu1c
'iflh)' aLIrC I d.tt"l Z 5 200'i in C IJPII'LilT1i
(c)M 10K '1,' 4 Wi ) is P lmtd
• .