Karnataka State Road Transport ... vs Smt.Sreedevi G.S. W/O Ananda ... on 4 October, 2010

[Cites 0, Cited by 2]

Karnataka High Court

Karnataka State Road Transport ... vs Smt.Sreedevi G.S. W/O Ananda ... on 4 October, 2010

Bench: N.Kumar, Subhash B Adi

 .1 £j}E§Sfg3,Ezf; ;;*:3§§:§&.?}:§s::I12z:;a§§ 5-; E?sj%i};%,WA§j§A{}§ W ;%EL}"t-U

IN THE HIC3-H COURT' OF' Kz'--\R'NéX"E.'AE{ﬁ.
{E§R€3?_ﬁ'T BEZNCH M.' {EU LE3é1R{.§-A

I:>m'r:{; THIS THE 04%: zgma GE' <><:'1'::»i+3i<:I&:<':§<'.>.::;ﬁL '"   T»  M

PRESENT _M_% % », _,
'i"'H'E H{}§'\F'BLE: FviR.JUS'I'1€_3E- :$:":i;z:§a;;:x;;%'~;  "  
Mr)   '   » _ .,  
"ma HOE'~§"BL,E :vI§m:3s"§iT<:2é?:{ s1;313&;A.sVH 3-';3 £1:}Z§}E.  
xivxiw APPEAL NG. :01':;g4;i"'s:>§«* 23 :r+::s (539%) 

BE'FWEE}E'«J:

E, KARNA"FAKii'x.VS7E':%f{'E .I7{€3:Ai'} mANs;P<>;2;'if
CGRPC>I4%Z§'E*E£}:7§, s;mrG';§:"3A;3AN"
SH4%§§y£'i¥N;%$;%R;V~}{, % %
BANGA:..;oRE.' % %  ,   

BY mg zxagvqasgwa  Ef}E§"§?,E7C'_E'0R.

:2. _ ':'§~«1§«;§;:é~3;:£«:1r: pg;-zs®NA,a:, :v2AM_:;E';§ez
 " «m1~«:':.\€A':;#Am S'I'AT'E:"'E{{}.A§} 'f'RANS¥*€'}R'§_'
 c@.;:pG§'<Aj :*§:;xx2 CENTRAL €}Ff<"§<;'E§
 ;3;4;+:;:<s*§':1;x§a:;{:.;'A§:§'_; K, EMERGAEE9
E;A.E'J--€§z%E}{}3%1%:§_3--';ET;%i¥G82'7Q

_ D' A.§3PE;L§[.£aN'i'S



7 _"'*~v€?:*::{§<;?§é:,¢<§mi'? ,~ :»:_:fé§$:3é>X':.2:'<% "iii §:;;&::.:caE ':::_§;' é:'_E1s: <i:m=§:30:"2:2.i:i:::s:': a.-m{:E

?-.2

AN' {,5

$M';'.sR'E:2:I>1s:v: <33.
W/O A.NANIi3A E3A_N§>_g:x_§2KA14:
AGE: ABOUT 3:; YEZARS   
OCC: ASSIS'E'AN"1' I
ACCC)E§N"E"'S {}FF£("fE';,Z€% N§§,}%{_R'_E"€j?
€E:'E\F'£'RAL OF'F'Z'C§f:.
K.i3HC}8PI'E'AL,
CiULE3AR£}A.  é  

. -:?>:.§:s;;><1"xHj) E?£\E"§'
Tmss WR3.'_F APPEMJ' "  " .Ef:':,.~£'::i_>f  w;:~;, 4, 0%?' '_;{'1~«i§;.
KAR.NA'E'AK.A HEGH V <:O:_J.Ié~?.f:,'__' Ax:*isf:  §?'£'€;{&Ef"§».1$§--{;é 'E'E§A""1"' TE-{IS
Hammé: CO{;'R'1'VI%?iA'%'_  £%£;E;m3;£a::>--,._':'<':>-;':« i~3EI3'E' Asnim: 'm£~:
03913:}: DATE',-1'3 <;s_«:f.<>:;:::T;L2§1_¥_::f;-- Pj'§SSE4§'§A._E3"{""F"»'§'E: S§NC}E.,E J:j:><:E«:
EN WP NO. ESE}84f2«QG£i«i;;3K};. .,,.,    

'3'?-§1S:"*$>'E€.§'i7 ;:_*:ﬁ'§?:::g¢;§:.» {:':a?:;_?a::::~;€:~ <3»: §'<}:a; {}§<';.{"}Ef~;'3§3f:§ Wis;

E_)A'3'} N K'LI"i\?E}§R  :;)%_£<:::T;';4i;£;:+;_€225;E: F()LE,i)W§N{}:

= VV  E}j_,}I3~€}};'v"{EZ}'§5E'
 V'  .,"f'§_":'-3%. {'f<i;.rp{}zf2g§.i{)§'} i*:I;:'S p2°s::§'<~:s':':<=,{.§ E__hi.s-2; awii. ;;:p§3<::e:2§ {f§'}éi.i§{EE1§_g;é?

é;.E2<?.'<i:_:'€§;j:?:_:"u §2i§}::':*$i;.§?;¥:*:'eZ.¥  ~%:3;jg?_j.. €315: £e;m':::':::% $§::;;>;§:=? £':.:{:i:>;<% £:§z.:.z2as%;§';;?':'1§_,g i,;:::»

E



 »,__:'::>'€; gé':$:§§':;§ i..E"::%i E}a::5§efi?2, {sf a:<}§'2i.§m:i%j_; :3? :s;<:'rvi:_~;:::: €;:'::sm 3; 3,23 {E

5.4J

{§ire?<7i.i1'2;g *::%1et--:':": tr; g-:"mI':: {.f{}'I'1'{'iI'}LiiE.};' 0? i"_k1«;=:% ss;£:z*vi<';:£.= E(> %'§<1€E~.fé.i'§fi%.
;.>€iéiii€3r2§?§",

2. Thrg-2 C<:ur';)<):'2-H.i<7m has-3 1-s;<§:;1'<;:ci 1;":.c3::iﬁii:-21'£"i.<.::2.X ("$.21

"£5,664 EQQQ {E1}? ':'<:c1's_4:iE.;m:=m:' z7;«:f e:.:EE".i<t::=:7ri«'; Li-2'3. x:21:€s:>:.:s;..  {3'§'_

{T}£},E§$~§E g1':».1:i£:. ﬁfhe W:"i€: ;:«ei:1t.i<3:1<2z*'vagjpfireci tbrf  TE ;:i?<3si, and V

wok «:&::>mm0:': 21pi.imde: '{..€;':1S€-§'i':..V_ E§3:i:<3%"'\>;;:zI:§_'.s},¥ é;':=:.%_e{:i;c><i":3s""Assi5at:.2::1€;
;E'si:21%;is;'i'i<t211 €3ffiCe:r ems': 213 E§L4£(7-$71' i}*i:'::2"g§;);ii§§i:'?i.::':11€_im: tsrcierr £i2;1%:=ec§;
3.1.2300

w2';1::~; s:L _'-- Eiima; a<£é§3t:.1'if:%{i- .. i_,_<_}_f' e:'EL2i,y' 21%: .E{SRT{Z §}):;1v211'121.g<-3r<:% EI)i<i?£si{;4%'::. . Ef,'§':€:§} §§§§§;£:':'{'r3::i<>z1 .}.i:e;t., 'z',h<:;*.:*:3 warm a;%a'm§ii{E.e1:.€::s.Kg::':_g:;E;i;;% 'Lé?'2a,§ --Wi'3.<'-#1': {Em nzrzzai qu:;t':a 'WQEEB {§§..E.E?zSI'E€:?{i irx}--* "-31:3? VA§;:s::§:' '~%j'z":e mu1:<:'ss~,; of 's;:h€: ca:'1«:iidaE:s:%s-1; s:se§<;%:_t*;.L:;t(i' :.:_::da:>:'r :j"z:.:':1§. V§.g'V:_.: 'as;-gm 3':-'::':":«:T><;:'=:{E {ram Eizzs 5~;«s:::Ee:E:%€.i<:>:':

§:_::;.t;,ﬁ C<§§=;é;:r<;§:s:?:s:i:§y.? "t':h:::__$5;;fi£;. §3e:;ii1'<i::':e:*':_e ':_":;;m":€: in the swig-;2<:§:§{3r1 £3 §T%:;f'~._"}JiE°f'E,.2{3 0%" Ehzzt s5;2,::i3':£;E., 5é:--s.E.':é-3: we-::~.~: 2:1;3§;<3§:'1i;e{.i 2:155; ;1::ss+;i$E:;;:.::';~'E §::':{?<v}§}'E§I"-{:§~ﬁE{?'€i%§? {.331 3 E. .Ci?.2;{}{}:'3, E'§::}§a.~'c1?§>:" S§'1€', $3225; _;'1.::i;;7n1e1'1i; "hm; m1.r:1§: W213 z'<=::m>v::r<:£ €}:<_S::;1.7i_E17t2 eai:',¥_£Vé:?,;;;:>$f;' ~ '--=as:.é;%§1i, a41;3;.__42;1;"2:,'iv.$323: '$922.3 g;;%:r<~:%:': ?;E':€: gxasst; of ﬁ.:~:;sisa;.'iT;zm§'. A:::{":z:>Lz;':é:s:

up '{1} 3 §..€}'}7.2{}{}3. SE20 mziicié? 21 i'E'.'_p.I.'ES%§€EI':'iI%?ifI§{§I'E. Er: r_ €':a Ei'§ij:.e s:~:2%.i<,i E"€','}}}'{',"§~':§€E7l'€.éﬁIi{}§'1. Eﬁhﬁ? maiseivqz-éci am €21{i<;}:*'s;s:%1?gi{:'_n:E.. a::§ V' 22:me:smr<=: 'E? p:_)i:'1%:i_:'1;g amt: I 112131. §3ET{72.E<if1'S{?-{.35 ~'_{£Z}1€i fi'§CXx {?j::::.1§*i¢, xmw aha has; i:)€<:',:1 app:::=im?.e3<:i ta 21..,.J;€'i"i~f1'é:'<3£ié;v..p:3&srAi';' '"'£<}.4é:?";94'*,e.>';V1"=vi<:e:1. V' rezizqieéraéci by her Elilﬁifif me, .&.2;.riie;i.*;}<,ssi§'~<:ré§r':;':e:>"E, %3€'a.::iw<;i<::c.i is) éhe _pr<::3s<3nt p=::»si; in i.h€-:$e {:.iE'(';'i11?}-SE2-}IE'(1i£?é§:_&S§fi}:?. '%=,g1s 22.p_p:":>;?1:}1{:€i 'i'E'z§s Czmri'. <:E':21.iI<3~nggi22§g

3.

;;>é:i:i§:i<>:1<z:' ;_,__»;c::.'mre;;§ s:'*:¢3_'i.egg;e:T>r§; :;u'1:§ :<5;fii1e 3%-"E18 Bf}? [email protected]:4:«f e{§ :2:1:3§1f§°':ip:*::§: 'i§:_:a%i}t'21, 112%; wi'::s9ws;%{i t.ha€; 2.s;h<'3:'1 ilhfi mraé <Cgi,41.{Tii5",.';::§ ?'2';:'.r g;._:22;s:.§:€s§'1,V 'i:h<§ q:,:;i'::=5t,i{im <3? :**:%:m>\:i:";.g izihsz'-_% §);.E:§§.i§§{}:'2€§'1"}'.%'1eE§1%§5:€;¥V"§.E"'{}ﬁi'""i::?%.§:..S£%i{§ p<::s;=;i: 'iJ$'{)1,£§{§ EH}? EEFESQ-;e€i?. $i§:1<:e iih:-':

53;;-§:£S§§$§.?:£§%.§"?E.,E'¥..e'}sffj;'i::T2jE§;Ef';%{ﬁ{i€i?'§' pas:-asi, is aiga g:"2;:{§:: El p<3$:":§ §'£{'?.E" rzazrm 2v_E':i_e::E1jeé;>~:':é§. §im°:*::;_§ iw§f;'v%;I"1s:? §}:;.}§IFii.£'}:}1 of €319 <%z.::*i_i_a?.:' E=I%§€:?§i'T-€i?;.iii>§E Hﬁi Ema i§;~2_,,»/"' {J5 <>ffi.<.:»:'r.r .:;2a.:'1d '£§'1c2:":;?i7<;;~{€=: Shé? 1'12-1%; bursa": w<'>:*}§i':'1_§; in '§ih{f?.:45i€«if1:.§"§.';'%;3', :*:a:§r<:*: §:"<3:°;": 3. E.¢2G{}{}. -sahéir €?§'1E',i{".hE?{"i {:3 I.h}<::'::::{i%' {Ef-'§}€}3"1§§Ij§1§.éi§'}? V' $e;*v.i€:e 21nd am':::;t:>q'1.z<%:;2i:é222.E b<%r":e{it'.:5 1:? s;;s;?:W--_i§'_jt:t=. fi_f{i}§'§j'; §"z:.é; <iV2z§:»ﬁ£--;7i'ia:? j<f2§:1e;{§ in ézhce: {t<f;:*p<m:z1i.i<.::'"; zmd *é:§2e1'e:£§;7:ré'--.the .16:-i:'3'1s':Tf{.3. J:..1{Eg;j€: Sfiii 21s5:ic1:;? iiiléz A1':r1ex'12§1fé--E~'1 2.1£.3.Ei'~ ..;,;ra1':_iiT.:%::'i 'I;.Ef;¢:'*;*E%I'ic€f" ;§{}:.:;g;}'1'£' V fax' by h:=2:: A;__:_;g:'i€Vea<i E:>y*i h:% ss;&21:':?§.~:% . 'f.'.hv€;'.'r..§1§3pé¥1}€ii'1%" ;i:?S §:,:€:.i'<3re Etéziss Cm;:"i:_, 4' '}_"i";e: £.c:%2;>a:":j:.§2{.Ev..::aL:_:1s5:%.E'§f§}£'.f::§'1.%::'--;;.ppeEE:1zi:€:. 21$s21.i§ing ii§}€;'. %::€:§1e';%fii: sf si§i<::_n.='1%«_:1:<% :{:s .§1§='1<;';%'~;}e:}&;§ 't;--:} 'w%3..i::%%1 5-e:E'2e=? was 22:pp:>§:'1i.e{.€ is; A$s;i5£t;é1?:§1 A<:::<>%;:zm"s:; <>i°i'i;T:£:r 1%;'.é;_;?_;-V mew p~:>si; 312%? E§}Z'?({': §'12'-iii zr:_pp'E_§{;:»ci £':<:§_.i':§'m :";a:-12%-j §3§}':?Si. zmazi "'7::*«;;§r2': mg': day :':'-SEEQ'-"t 2':-1pp<}§I:*;:s;,=.{i iii; ﬁx': sezziii ;>e"}'si;2§., }si§'2:: 3153 '«.:%:r3v§{i'i:._§::<i E9 1122:? 5;-;a*::m-*§<=,€T;? '§>c:':<%E_EE:$. 'I'E':e s;:;1i<:£ SE.i§}E2'E§b:?»siE,EfE 5}?' 'é§_ :--:;:'. '§=E§a2.:"m;%»:§ z::'>:,:2'1s's{i%§ is; <%<>mi..:"2:z1*y {:5} {ha E'§'1.£}§,{:E§'.§2':'£..§ " ,_:'§n j :."<;%<*{:>_:"i:1.z ?*~;f{f; §,we_> :1:<>"£:i£E{':22i:§¢_3:"2:<§ 'i.-'»:'€'fE'¢Z:?? éassaziiégi, arm ?;.w<> c §'f:'f:€:£:;2E.s; am-1% fa': :.:::;;2.(;§{%& €02' éihc? g.3:>s'ai: {sf ;'§.&%f3§$'§Ie,i§1£' §§2:E'E1§f:'§'§i.§C.?E3;§ ; Es " " --«§3i:%e:'ii*i:; in i?':Ir1i.s:::-;:;.§z;}t:z2§. K-':g3§3é32;:§ :35; :i§5m§:;.s;;€%:i, (3 €}:ff'31r::£<:* gm-zi .?x.s:.as;i5;f2;H'1£; A<':<%m.2:'1i::~:~: €j}ffi<:<::%:1 B(}f§"3 éE"1.£;~? gra{.§e:%---ii p<>s:';i'=;=5. 'E"li::;ié pé+*£:ii.i:')r::':*:§" wzzss §3;§)§}(}iI'T:.EZ§;'%{i§ 53.53 ;~é':;a:'§:. V' Si.ai?:§$€:§s:.:a§ {)'fﬁ('.i€-if em 3, "E .2{)§_€). Gfii. 'E:1r1§-:5 '€fiay. 5h--%;~ in igéler s3»~2z.Ie3<é'::i{}_:'1 £232.. her :'1a:":'1€: wzine; Ln Ehsié.-._bc)::i:<>7£11., '~W£'::%;;§'~::%ie::._ rural qu<>i.a was'; q:;a:5s.h::?{i, §'1<3r ':f1é:i:3:<2 w'c:V:_*zE:' --1::;3\:\ £E":.<>s_-:;<';:=f <:i:':71.:::1&§tz1_:':c?:ess§ she wane; g:n:=s::.;.': .,{ig<7<;:<;rii:':'Ea;*;$;s$is::21_:'1§, Offiizezx W11.i.::3'1 is 210% 2:1 .m'3I:: 2'-1, ;'1e.w p{}E5E". €037' W§1i.::h s;h§: wzxs ci€r:_i{;3£i §..}'§€?

<:<>:1"€.§:'1:.,:ii%:y Sf %:%:.a'i'. sshe-1': \ms 2: mgrzai :::21:1di<Fia'é:e: Zvéiiiii :7j§f;¥i::1*T:"»r§§j:%1:'1i<}§;VW:3;%3;3{;:'i.z1*:.:f:2er:1: hassze b£:e§i1_ azemzcéeiied a :x1~:.€ zsrghézé - 2_1p;3<i>i;1'{.e€2 for 'mac? ;3<3:+;*i" of Asssissiizmi, A,%1;§:<::;>z,§4:§::"i.«g:Vf;)w§7iTi.;::€ﬁ*;. ""§;%§1s.-3 gaid 21%;}:-5€}:'1iz'1g £55 <:%{:=1zi:::"ary E10 _:::s::':. ..&&E"é2;';si?v=:{'§§':(§'.""Aif Es; in éiimssssé aftizrrzg:":2s%:?z:2m<%é;:5s, E':.§:.é:

E@2:z::'5._:3E:.«Si::;{.§é;i.._;}'a.é{ig;;%:i..i:5 r1;g§":i:: in :i~;;e.-éﬂiin £'i_S-3'§eL£EZ' %i,§'1€>; Ei§'.':§}€;X_E.i§'{T'. $§~~E".3 ,,./QV§"§i{?§': {21::E:::::gé§4f§;,? §:1_::_:<:;:":"s3<::*;.. '§"'E*:s::r€:f<33fi':, *§.'as-1:: dz'; 353% f%%{i':€;E ;;:_:'"s}f in Ei'1::% iigghig. (Ef €:Ei:.:=': a'3..§3e:;w¢? i'2;§<_:i.s;-s i.E':2'::£' xx;'h::3:'1 aw: '*:"-ijfm 2:;31.:w3.aai §E'ss;§;?Ef zm E"£TE.€iT£T'i'C§~§. 't.%':<:';? z:;.p§>Ei<:2s..'z'§<:;»z'§ far a%<>:1%'{;Ea>:':;;:'zéiim ' deigazy 2é;E:;<;> -5.-:i'2.1':':c'§s €ZiiE5I"i'3i$5?;€;%d. ._ 5.3%}

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

Karnataka State Road Transport ... vs Smt.Sreedevi G.S. W/O Ananda ... on 4 October, 2010

Bench: N.Kumar, Subhash B Adi