Delhi District Court
Sumedha Rani vs . Brij Mohan Pathak Cc No. 793/05 on 25 August, 2009
IN THE COURT OF SH. VIVEK KUMAR GULIA,
METROPOLITAN MAGISTRATE - 1 [ East],
KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI.
!#"%$ "!& '
(*),+
-/. ' 0/132!#"!&546"#78#"!9
: + : + ; 2 +=< >!?A@CBED
4F2HGI'KJL M N7 "#7O'K2!&QP 4 . #7 ( 'R#" .
JUDGMENT
S + T # ) . 'K"HGL& Q VU# . 2#W 7O# VJL" ) P B X S ? YQ<=X B BED X!+ T # V "#7 V2#W!JL2! VZ G["H'\& 7 P X!D + B#]6+^X B BED ? + ; "! _2 W 78# VJL2! VZ GK"H'\&#"!& 7 P ` a7 + b Q 3 !#"%$ "!& ' c de@ 2 + + 'R . "!& c .\@ 2 +gfNh S S D c 4 . #7 ( '\#" . c i HG\ ' h S S BVB > X!+ ]6+ T # j&#"! Ec Z#" . !& 7 " k -/. ' 0/132!#"!&546"#78#"!9lc "!&# . ) '[ !&#J V2#W!" JLJ# ) P )m@ 2 + n "#7 M ` + +Qop+ 46"#78#"!9lc . @ 2 +,qrhs?#B c 13"HG\9t" k "u0vc i HG\ ' h S S BVB BH<Q+ D +,w WxW !&#JL VJL2! VZ GK"H'\&# V2#W P y @s),+ S ? Yj;z+ {x+ | J}7 + ~ + 4pGK "V2#W 78# V" JLJ, ) P 4pGK " j#7!kH 'RG 7 + <Q+Q '\&#"HG w. . P :*2!& 'KJ}7 + Sumedha Rani vs. Brij Mohan Pathak CC No. 793/05 !Q H\#HtEH ! N# ! Q jQ !x !H! ! ,6 !^ E E # V# l ¡ ! ! !¢ !^ E BRIEF STATEMENT OF THE REASONS FOR THE FINDING :
£# #¥ ¡ ¡# §¦aQ©¨ L ª8#«OO[H¬Q®Ql ¨ Q ! ¡ !V¨ KH\ ¤ RK ¯ # !F°/ ¡}OK!£,± ¯#H8#³² #OK!´ Kµ =A8 ! ·¶¸¡tC¹ £ N£»ºO\5l#Ex ¼ 8#5¶¸¡t ½O¾¿ #5 ¡t »#EO ©¡LQ ¹ER% L ,#HR ¹ ! ¯8#Q E ©¡L!V¨ [H\#! ¤ ¤ # !#¡ ³ÀK !j Á8#e ¡L¡# e!³ IV ! !#À!#ª\%HI ¡ #! e#¸ I [ ! RK!´ IR ÂQ¹, ¡L¡, ILL %¡ # ÃH e´# ! \#e#EH± ,Á#C6£A6 !^ E¢ EzÄ#pÅQ¢ ¹ CÆÇ!,¦3ª!¥Èp mÉ8!´«ÊË° R#ÍÌ6! Îl¹6Ï#,¦Ð!#! ²` !8¹Ñ`H\ ¹ #¦Ð!QM¨#Ex`¨## ! Ñ#pO ÀK !Á! H `´ LÑ!e¨ Q E K!j8#À ! ¦ÐQ©#O O# Ò´ ©8#Ò´#! Ît!¸#*¡L!V¨ KH\#! /¦Ó Oe8#Ô! !OÎ ¼ È6# ! Õ !¨ ¨# Í´ ³8#§!,¦a!½¿ #! # !C¹pK HÖ##O[¡L× # × E !± ^ E¢©¦ÐQ ¤ ! # Ø!Ù ¡L¡# Ú!#Ë#Û !L¯!¨ ÂÜ#CÓ£ ! !± ^ E¢Ù¦r 8#HL» !Î \# ¨## 3E 8 #! #EE¹*O Ü ¡L¡# E¹ÐQÙ#Ý HR[ ÜÞ !Îtß8#˨## ! ¤ ¦r 8 \ÚAOR¨ [# à¨#E [ ¹ #QÙ¡L!V_ á!â# E#¡ ਠQ ã,#!´ Ká ! ¡tOK!á£,± Ë#38#ⶸ¡tC äÒ 8â# !Q H[â ¡t ,¹r¡L!V¨ KH\#! %¨ #Â Ý ! ¨ Q ¡#L K! !#j¨ ã, ! !#! ¡L¡# ¯\ ¡L¡L! !#¡L3¦r 8_K,¦ ! °b ´=A !#¡LÙ#Ð ¡ ¡# #OK!Í\å8#® !O #æ¦3 !ç##OK¡LÝ}sª!¢!£ æ \_\#H¬È/ ¡L H × ¹b£ !Å ±ªº Ç8 ÈÑèÇ ¾`¦aQe ¥# !`!#¥#é ¨ [H\# ¥ ¡L¡# §!¥HÅQ 6£#^ êE¹N ©¦Ó K¡ ×#Ò¨ [ Í## H R «!#§¡#KH\ OO[H Sumedha Rani vs. Brij Mohan Pathak CC No. 793/05 ë ì í î ï#ðQñAòåñLó ôVô ð!î õ\î#ö ÷#ø õ[ù ÷Eî#ú ÷Eû%úLð!ôVï ü[ýHõ\î#ý!î òåñAò÷Eï ï#÷ ù õRî ò ðàòOþ ÷ ÿ õ ò8î#÷QñLñ #ð §ýQñ Áý!î#ù ÷Hõ ò ÷ ý ò÷ ùÀò8þ#÷ ý útò ñÀô ÷!î òOõ[ð!î#÷ ùÔõ\îeò8þ#÷Òï ÷Qñ ÷!î ò ú ð!ôVï üKýHõ\î òCì Hó xò8þ#÷ Cû ñ,þ#÷ßï ð#ø#÷ ùÒú þ#÷ Hó ÷Ùõ\î Hó=÷QñÕòOõKð!î Qì Çû`ú þ#÷ Hó ÷ ÷#òOó !" # Oî õ\î#öeô ÷!ô ð $ % &$ (')$ $+* Qì ì ûEüK÷ ö ýHü î#ð#òOõ[úL÷©ù#òCì Eì !ë ì Qì , - . /0! 21 3 /ûæï#ðQñAò ýHü ÷ úL÷Hõ\ï ò ì ì »ûzý ú Lî#ð ÿ üK÷ ù ö!ô ÷!î òÓúLý ù , 4! 5 Qì 6 7 87 :9 ÷!ï ü ð Óý úLú#ó ñ ÷ ù ì zì `÷ Óú ðQñ ñ O÷ ý!ô_õ\î#ý#òOõKð!î ÿ ýQñ ;
ò ÷ ý#ò ÷ ù <')= &$ = (')$ $ >
î õRüÇø õKù ÷ ð ? ù ÷ @ :9 ù#òCì Eì Eì ñlõ\î#ú ÷ ý úLú#ó ñ ÷ ù ýHõRü[÷ ùáò ð ú ðQñLñ
÷ A
#ýEô»õ\î#÷©ù ÷Hñlï õ ò ÷«î ó ô CB #÷ Öð Nð!ï ï#ð xòOó î õ ò õK÷Qñ»ö ý!îLò÷ ù ì ð%ð#ò8þ#÷ ÿ õ ò8î#÷QñLñ ÿ ýQñ
ï DE5
ð ùHó úL÷ ù ú ð!ôVï üKýHõ\î#ý!î òCì
F ì
¸úLú#ó ñ ÷ ù ÿ ýQñG Hó=÷QñÕòOõKð!î#÷ ùÀö ÷!î#÷ 5
ýHüRü Áý H
#ðHóLòpò8þ#÷³úLýQñ
÷§ï óLò ð ÿ ý ù
E5 Ðò8þ#÷VúLð!ôVï üKýHõRî ý!î ò ý ö ýHõ\î=ñAò¬þ õ\ôØý!î#ùjþ õIñ3ñAò ý#ò ÷!ô ÷!î ò I KJC + ÿ ýQñ ÷ ú ð ù ÷ ù sñ#ì ë ,ë L NM O 8ì Ñì ìxû ÿ þ#÷ ÷Hõ\îçþ#÷Ùý ù!ô_õ ò ò÷ ùÒòOþ ÷ÙõIñLñló ý!î#úL÷ P ð Ðú þ#÷ Hó ÷Ýõ\î Hó ÷QñAòOõKð!î õ\î ý ø#ðHó jð jú ð!ôVï üKýHõ\î#ý!î òÁý!î ùÛò8þ#÷ Q 5 ý útòMò8þ#ý#òþ#÷àñAò ð!ï ï#÷ ùËòOþ ÷àï#ý ô3÷Eî òeõ\î ÷Qñ,ï#÷ útò ð ¬ò8þ õIñ3ú þ#÷ Hó ÷Eì íKòÑõIñ»ñLó ô»õ ò ò ÷ ù5ò8þ#ý#ò/þ#÷ R ÷!ï#ýHõKù5ò8þ#÷%ú#þ#÷ Hó ÷©ý!ô ðHó î ò òðúLð!ôVï ü[ýHõ\î#ý!î òÑõ\î S ÷ öHó üKý õRî=ñAò ýHüRü\ô ÷!î ò ñ¯õ\îÁú ýQñ,þ T ólò`î#ð ÷ úL÷HõRï ò ÿ ýQñjõãñLñló ÷ ù E5 + Ùþ#÷ aý!î#ùÙò8þ#÷ ÷ ð ÷ßþ#÷Ûþ#ýQñ U #÷ ÷!îçú þ#÷ ý#ò ÷ ùEì V Hó xò8þ#÷ 3þ#÷ÙúLð!î#úL÷ ù ÷ ùßòOþ ÷ ÷ úL÷HõRï ò!ð ¬üK÷ ö ýHülî#ð#òOõKú ÷Eì * ì ¸úLú#ó ñ ÷ ùÔð!ï ò ÷ ùÍò ðçüK÷ ý ùçù ÷ ÷!î#úL÷ ÷#ø õKù ÷!î#úL÷ ólò ýHõRü[÷ ù¥ò ðÒý ù ùHó ú ÷ ÷#ø õKù ÷!î#úL÷%õ\î_ý!î E5W ð 8ôØý!î#ù%ó ü òOõRô ý ò÷Hü Vù ÷ 5 ÷!î#úL÷M÷#ø õ[ù ÷Eî#ú ÷ ÿ ýQñað ù ÷ ÷ ù»ò ð X #÷ ú,üKðQñ ÷ ù ø õKù ÷Vð 'Y &$ F (')$ $ % ù ÷ #ì ì Eì = Eì í/þ#ý#ø ÷ þ#÷ ý ùªòOþ ÷ÔúLð!î ò ÷!î òOõ[ð!î ñ©ð Z #ð#ò8þeò8þ#÷ ï#ý xòOõK÷Qñ³ý!î#ùÒï#÷ ó ñ ÷ ù òOþ ÷ D ÷ úLð ùEì Sumedha Rani vs. Brij Mohan Pathak CC No. 793/05 []\ C^ _ _ `)acb deacb4f ag_ih j;k@l jWjmk _n_ o@_ p qrj;ags bts uvp@k _ w q@_eacbtw qx_]yzj;ags bn{E| l pEp q)y:_ }~ayb s jC} _ b)ag_ }+)l b } yacb pr_~a jHayAb s jacb.} ayi`)qrj_Ajmk l j+jmk _Kp@k _ w q@_Ah8l]y } a yik s b s q]_ } { _ prl q)y:_Us u` l | _ bEjWyzjs ` ` _ } {E|l prp q)y:_ }+ prs A`)gl acb l bEjWay _ bEj;a j;g_ }.jsSl b }T} ag}Sacb.ul pj _ |Tq ` s bGjmk _jmk _ _R` _]yrq]`rjags bxyDab~_]yi` _ pjs u k _ Hprl]y:_+b l+_ |]q#y E i@Rl b }ti s uHj;k@_Spj l b }b sih0a j-{ _ prs _]y ab p q A{ _ bEjCq ` s bWjmk _Al prp q)y:_ }jsD_ {)qrj jmk _]y:_jsGyik sihk)ayVacb b s pr_ b pr_+\ \ k _l pEp q)y:_ }ul ag_ }<jsT` s } q@pr_D_ f@_ bl bXags jlGs u_ f ag} _ b pr_.js _ {)qrj j;k@_ prs A`)gl acb l bEj y prl]y:_ s acb k)ay } _ u_ b pr_+\6¡¢s]yry¤£m_ o l acb l j;ags b s u pEs A`)gl acb l bEj ¥;¡ ¦ :§ h8l]ySb s j pEs b@} q@pj_ }ShIk)agp@k _ l bxyKl jmk _l g_ d l j;ags bxy s u pEs A`)gl acbEj_ l abq b _ {)qrj¨j_ }+\]©s _ s f@_ m]b sXl j_ agl k l]yv{ _ _ b{ s q@d kEj s bt_ prs }t} q acb dt} _ u_ b pr_t_ f)ag} _ b pr_+\ k s q@d k4a jay yq { a j¨j_ } {E|ªh8l |Us u yzjl j_ _ bEjL_ prs } _ }Pq#y \ +i ¡L2\¬« \ ¡¢\jmk l jjmk _Pp k _ w q@_ l s q bEj h8l]y` l ag} { l p@®jsXjmk _prs A`)¯l acb l bEjOacbRacbxy°jl c_ bEjyT{)qrjOacb~l {xy:_ b pr_Rs u l br|~_ f ag} _ b pr_ js0yq {xy°jl bEj;a¯l j_±jmk)ay²`)¯_ lprs A`)gl acb l bEj yprl]y:_0pEl b b s j{ _0} ayi{ _ a¯_ f@_ }+\ k)q)y ³} sDb s j u;acb }Al bE|Aa yryq@_jsD{ _A} _ p ag} _ }abWjmk)ayZprl]y¤_+\ +\ ´ s )jmk _D_ l]y¤s+bxyv_ prs } _ }Al { s f@_+rjmk _Al prp q)y:_ }GayVprs bEf agpj_ }As u]jmk _ s u¨u_+b pE_q#y \ i@s u jmk _pj2\ Announced in the open (Vivek Kumar Gulia) court on 25.08.2009 Metropolitan Magistrate-I(E) (total 4 pages) Karkardooma Courts, Delhi.
Sumedha Rani vs. Brij Mohan Pathak CC No. 793/05 IN THE COURT OF SH. VIVEK KUMAR GULIA, METROPOLITAN MAGISTRATE - 1 [ East], KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI.
In the matter of:
Sumedha Rani Vs. Brij Mohan Pathak C.C. No. 793/05 Police Station: Preet Vihar Order on sentence 26.08.2009 Present :- Complainant in person with counsel.
Convict on bail with counsel.
Arguments heard on the point of sentence. Complainant contended that since convict issued the cheque in discharge of the liability and his guilt has been established beyond any doubt, he be punished with maximum sentence provided.
On the other hand, convict submits that as he is first offender and is 64 years of age suffering from various ailments. Therefore, it is prayed that a lenient view view may be taken.
Keeping in view the submissions made on behalf of convict and considering that offence u/s. 138 NI Act has been introduced to encourage greater vigilance to prevent usual callous attitude of drawer of cheque and to lend greater credibility to the greater transactions and lastly that the cases of dishonour of cheques are on the high rise in the society, convict is sentenced to Sumedha Rani vs. Brij Mohan Pathak CC No. 793/05 fine of Rs. 1,30,000/- as per section 143(1) (proviso) N.I. Act r/w section 357(1)(b) of Cr.P.C. Out of this amount, Rs. 1,25,000/- (cheque amount being Rs. 75,000/-) shall be payable to complainant as compensation and Rs. 5000/- to State within a month from today. In default of payment of fine (or compensation), convict shall under go simple imprisonment for six months.
At this stage, an application u/s. 389(3) Cr.P.C. for suspension of sentence and grant of bail is moved by convict Brij Mohan Pathak. Heard. Since the convict intends to present an appeal, he is hereby admitted to bail on furnishing personal bond in the sum of Rs.10,000/- with one surety in the like amount. Bail bond furnished and accepted till 25.09.2009.
Announced in the open ( Vivek Kumar Gulia ) court on 26.08.2009 MM-I(East)/KKD/Delhi Sumedha Rani vs. Brij Mohan Pathak CC No. 793/05 Sumedha Rani Vs. Brij Mohan Pathak C.C. No. 793/05 Police Station: Preet Vihar 26.08.2009 Present:- Parties with their counsel.
Separate order on sentence passed today. Accused has been bailed out u/s. 389(3) Cr.P.C.
In case no order from the appellate court is received by ahlmad till 25.09.2009, case file be put up before me for further proceedings.
File be consigned to Record Room.
(Vivek Kumar Gulia) MM-I (East) KKD Courts Delhi.
Sumedha Rani vs. Brij Mohan Pathak CC No. 793/05