Karnataka High Court
Dr M Savitha Pande vs The Registrar (General) University Of ... on 14 March, 2011
Author: Anand Byrareddy
Bench: Anand Byrareddy
.- '.
"EN THE; iifiGH COCK? Of? K.ARN5%TAKA AT
B,»:'iaNGALGR'E.-
DATED THIS THE %14'"" 13m' 0:: MAR{T?fH' 23:3: :__
BEEFGRE
THE H(j}N'.B.I;E MR, JUSTICE ANAND B'y'z<;;aRM;$§%i)*;V'%' %%
WRIT PE'I'2_"l"I()N N0. «$g?5"1?3i.*«{)l'§";';?'.%}(}:i{V:V3v'1_ xi BETWEEN: A j 4% Dr. M. Saxvfitha Panda Aged abaut 44$} yazzra _ Wfe Sri. M.,B. Padmashékhar I?' 11:16; _ Res;_i_<ii.ng at $50,205, ' 'a_ Z CPTRI La:-giant; Bagzidi H St21¢§:§.'V_V 1 Myscyre-«~570()(}é'. _ "; ,.PET'ITI'ONER {By Siiri. Shri. R. Ei€e1'aiz:.L Adv<3cate fer La}. ;'3&SS{'){3Vi£§:1_i€ S} A ii. ff-?i€.VRQ;§§Si'3Ta§ {Ger:ez'2:E) Ui}E'¥;f§f;T$:'§¥Zf;s: 53f Iv§:gs;<:2'a-3, C'i*:m?f'€:r<i B§'1a'a-='z:r:.§ *~ F¥'I§:S{J:'€ --~ 5'??? 005.
The Searazzizy 522:}: C=:::rre:~;§{m<ien£ A 85%. K§:s;g§§zs::§_& §V£a_h3§;ams:h3§a Ka':§ai<.;z Q'£2§'E.1pfi£?§§§§;Ts, Qaéisgs :3?' Eézgcaiiimi £5 ;§{i§a:.hu11c¥1;ma.g§.:.'_i Rind, .Kuss€:113punz1;g22r, §VE:,z:s;{>ra +~ fi?{} 823. .,.R£iSPGNDEN'TS (B3; Shri, "RP, Ra_§en:;ira Eiium-23:" Sunfgajg, f3L{§§z{}{,€%if_Lj'?, '._Vf.{3f Responéeni Nay}, Shriw H'K_az:t11z:1-zgju, Aé?~5"E'§{:a:'ieL:"wT. fag' R<:spG.:1ds:ntN<3'2) 1 " ¥' ' 'i'Ez.i:~; Wm Paiitéon {fled umer A-r§.icE:;a:f2.T25'» on: th:.$ C<msI:i_tuti<:>n ef i.n.&i2: p:'a§;-'mg ii) zictzik-1:'€':1$ ._§i.i."b§tiI"i:1F:;;'_.Vé:fid,vViW?:jg3'{? the Gfdfli' Vidf: ;i'xnn&:xL1re--D am} et<:.{"'- A' T A' ' This Wziit Petition is {3{)vI'}'3§I%'1'j.;j.,V'{)¥i f£§rVH.::;3.,§%i2g the"
cctmrt mafia thrgz f(>IEOwi::g:
V ..._.'?/"#' 'K ~--.. j » ' "
,-w.m-u.
w re.sp<3r1}:§er;:s;
S _ _ Zfhe &c:un::«;Ve7§? fi>'i;* {fizz {i_:js:t__' .r.%:s§:':£::::d€nt i'_ii1.s='.:<i 2.1 ::s;$.:n<> 5'2.
°*s:$é§:;'izigE7§;iié:1<:§ss:a_l 8f the 'as-':'E.{ petition as; hafing E)t1£I{}II}€ A ir:§':fL1=:;i§£§§1;'~;,'V ~.
._s- ' " ft. £3 ghe Sheri C2136 af the E:€Sp{§I"£.€3€i'E{ ma: the)-ugh g.,tE'":<':p§*::i{.i_':m was; fiéad aéaaiiazzging i.h_e raje<:§.i(3:":. mi? appr<}:-22$ 9:"
E33; ag3'§{:%§':2E"§2*::e;m: gf $23 p-aiézégmar 3:: tag ;::£3%~;E; ssf ?:f:i_;:<:.i.§:d ii': {he s4<:c:0nd z'csp<w:1cie:1t -- i1'1s{i.['L1:i(3:L {I13 ;:n::1i:i.(.)z1.c1" ms $L1§}.~;:':qL1c::1i1y' 1:-311:;ict'<:.ci :'esig'1'1;-:i'ic>:'1 [0 am: post of PrEm:%p;'a1 mi" 111:: s'::<:om§ rr::.~;p<m«;i'c1'1t --~ é:*:s%iu1{i('>n emd 'L"hii"- .<:.;1m:;2. basis i:~::c":1':s zicca-zpleici-~-E::}:*' the '( C:en<:raI C(j)LII3L'§L 'TE'§"1c2 COL§I1.SL'3i for Ihéj 'fi::<;1 i":;ffSp€.)f}C'i£i3."'].1["'§',§j!CI'§;§.3:hi':*?4 wcmicé submit. tlmi the p€3['i[i(')I] 1133; btii'-E}. m1'3<}c:1*<::;-<,_iV §z"T:f;".'.I'.L'I'_1(7.'}'LE.,'S 7 and all {he 1"cli:3£'$ S(">Ligi":{ by 111:; p{:.tEii<.,m'e_1' -12.1;-e__Vtxcg-«.,V_l'"'igg:;i'i:' 1*eI:':v:1r1t, =21. .I~iI'<>wcx-wzz'. tin: }~<;;21I'IT:&'3€;f. <;."a'.:a,a.1i_;«;s.=-*,}'"fax ihszz. 4fi5'cV':'¥.'i'{'}"£")V11("3I' weuki S€Ck {O c:0:_2te:':d'f:.}1:-it the veg fz='a::if' a'%¢l1;:{i*z:?}f»~.tidc_ app1'(_waI of the e1;>p<>i17'tri1E:"1'ij.<1§:i?fl1'%2c"§>é:titimf§i2.:' could have-3 been <;i:3nic':cI iiscrif :1 di$§}£ii'€du q_uestin;i.fA:$i11'::e._ %%:.r3" 1"<:}'c:cii<')r1 oi' the z1pp:'cw21§ of ;=:_;_:»_p<_>_?:3.I'm<::11%flf£'f'1:;v';3<:ii-£i<>i3<::" is on im: grm.:.:'1r,i £1322: iiitkéfi; °*t;:;.é.' jg<;:;zi"$} "e>{§;::;."ic11cc $2": icz1c2:2i.n§.;_. On t.h<: <>i1'1<:r i2:1n<;§_, 33:: Iezxmcad *;<.:i;I_n;~;k3:Ev-Via=.g:L'ti§..{§'~p1ac.:<: r<-;=.1iaz3c.c: on gm-'c3:';1E d::c%:~;_i<3t1:% 0% thzzz Sa:gi1*-r..'~:::"n:: {,f'<_.?{::fé Le: £.,'{}I}§CI'1£;'§ th;-ti, ii is; me £3X§.7€I'§€E'§i,'£;3 w¥":%c_:h ix; :'::%.c:»§'2:11:.":-1:1:i not the m;:t.I':te;.1'":;1i%<;;1I <::,=':Ic;z¥_211'i_o1: 0f't1'1:: pt'3i"§<)d uf éé'3;pe :'i<::é¢:: amci $2': i.E1::t. ar§:.:*'v¢' 0?' §'EE€3 Eliaiiiez", an '§':::::s.:, the pc£i.téo1'1::;' I:1c..E<;i:'1§g (_>ra::% §;<;:::1' (me rmmL'I"1, tine I232-imcrd c,:>:'>L:;";;_sel mwsver'. wcazlhi :'§t,§bmit' i;"E.':21I: the p<":.tiii:>r1::1' 17'1;-i$\:€.:«; up f.":.;;'Vt.1_1é[.I;1ck <:&f't<:z=:cl1i1"1'g/3} ::.><;p:~::"i:;::'":<;:::, if zmy, by 'v'§l'[l.lt;3 0'1' i1;':z11e:::§~§{9é:<:%<§3c--1"i£:%..;g;%§ _ in 1'<:;x't'-:;:1°<.:§1 and iI':u*;'cI":>1"c:. it w<":2.11<;i bf; in Iémi' "ve"i'i'--§1:;'_é?1é'-}av; 1;:.jd" "
down by {he ;1;_?:e>; c0m"£' than aha: p€:'€;j§.§'.i0':':T:-:.1""'s; E:.rs;p'e1fi<:ni:c%'""§1f1V{A1&1} ficlcis: be ta§<:-':11 into ::cc(.}Lé:1_t""-.3v§3§]c,"' céthei'V-V21;3;f;'t*:'::'v»i1'1'g £3?"
di:;a:;313x"<>v'%.:.':g her ;,:ppr,_.>i I] we :11 gt-513----;% }':ii h€.i_p:1i. The §_::.:1med c<>L1;é§e_I" '.»'€r:iR§11ii _1'::1:r%E';»;%._§_9" -s;u%:>r':'1it that the z"esi_gI'1zaEi<'>n t<:_Ij1<E«;3;fc3'c§. 23;»; Eh?» .;I'.>:63ti*.tVi'<'>'*15:'.<f:'~:ru$$2;£;§ on :;n.:::c)u11t of aha:
CE113LII'1ft'Sf€§'§;iC{3f$TE3€y('5§E1Ci !~;<;;-;«:_;,~:<:>r1m:>_E"':;?:':; she was 'fz1c:ec:i V»-*i't.h hcalzh :~;m.d othez" d«c'}:m:*:_<;if; :_'tj:r1";')'I"§--?:;:%"1'2_:~'e: ="ar1::§. ii is; not on accoum of any a:e:adr:--:72i»c (list;11;z}ifi:i;1tii"s11 {ha-it gm: }1.2;}d E.::1'1.e:i«::'c:t(;i hes' :*é:.ség:é;1ié.0za.. peéi'tfi.:_>fic~:i_ Vv'{.)¥.E}{f soon seek' 1:0 pursue: her c:2u'eer and if the L"'g.}1.d';:1* A 1'é;'«§'i(§'i,fVbE.§ii§j ~:i§3p.z'LW21¥ mi' app<:irm'11e::t of tin: peiiti0r1s::::f is; ;,:II.e:'%'*»~x-J:-:-:Liv-.."fi:;}'v"%;t:m&¥ She wa':L1E_d be fltzczzai wit}; 2.1 §>e1':11;mc':17: .-/ r:Ii:;a.1p§_1it'§? <31" Em' tam:-:-::"it:*31:;cz w'it.l"1 t'h<:= 54a-3<.:0I}d z"t::§p<_)§.3c;i£:::1{ «~« i_'_;;s£§m:§<;>:f:.. 2&0: as? 21%} be-:m;;_ {;i§.<{i3§1 Em: a;:'::1s4§:'§e.1':::r;§_<:«n zmzé ii is; £22 ('ff-wt ;§ ., '.3\,%' «. ' 6 2li:£2<'3--p%'f;'-d zmd c<>m:%a§c:1'cc.i in an app:"<>p2'iate p::i'i_ti<'>n. izas<>f'z'1;*a:; the p.:'es<::z:{ peziricm is co1'1<:em:3e§, the f»'€i11'E.{;3- is 1':3miat1'<;:*ci iI"1]FI'iiCi'{§()%.2S; sizicc the §f!<i3%§Ii<)I1<;'31' 1'1;-"rs; 1':-3:;i;;:m:~ci f1'<':m 33:3 E'.B-I."v'iLit'3-S of fine: xecenxmai z':.:.~;p<":mf.::1'1t. H::z3_<:::g x:«~:iIhouI p:'c:j_12.c:i_i1:s'i: ':5;{£23 1n<:1'iL<: of the claim of ah:-2. ;_3::i§ti<'3m:1f i11:;<'>f'2:;" :3; iizef £2-$§'p:3;'§c§i{;'<:_AV ' being: takm imo 2;iCCOL1§7§[ fog' azajg fu_{"u'1':;: .'-3I}'i;}1(.}yi1}.§:-13$; ..I.;I1s;7' pr3:it%()ré sizxnds: ciispasazci of.