Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs M/S Himatsingka Seide Limited on 2 November, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
" .§'>*§7:?A;f.s';:%;f:§"~..f8{,?§~"§%*f£L 5539 fixgfirf ggrafiz gig 59 759 :12?' 55$ :;.erm?@z":"§;i<:";2g?? E:«@;? 5:': {E23 aravstg sf .,,, 3 ,,.., Qiifier Cfirsnecéed §'"?'?@§§§f'.§, a':'s§::>s@d 32'? an 3§,:i"?5.201: S3! haéémg $3 :;:*;ée:*:» "F395;? éffae gfaregaia' g'z;;af§m§r;§'§, gmazgeg 23:; iiéai; iiiére gfwwig' Se aisfxifarsrjékéf";/§:§ ifie ingredients Q2' fimfh me ,r:;,;;33$;'3i"G:.;T"'a':;=--;<§ éenamingtgr Q?" the fgrmuia,}§ér2;¢':;.:"?és,r':¥§;§é"i£'v._ X woagigf gzradmce &:'3om§fie.§ sf'.__a}:,-figrd }§§§:2'i,f:e.'~, VV §€€T£"fG§? 20% £3 3 bei;'§-1:»;f:VEi::?§§ 3:é::§s}3;3,_ snfenfiefi in ggmziafs §n:;§2?,§§a:'§5 id «.§:§€ama§€@ exfiarés. The ;;;;ie»{;m:; :3' éxamgi §é§r§?,ii"s refaiaéfie is e><;39r::$9; . §"r% -{"£§'e" €..3§f駧mb§n&d bazginegg _af:'f__ £33" exgeré b;;$ir;e$..<:_:§r§:;:¥ :§*:?::~%;=;iii{;:" §2;;$¥n e$;:5; "5319 iegisia Ezsrg ;:';i°e.=;'::}'§c,;¥ .: ;fa;'_%.. .};':"é'%,r'§1.'3:/fif§é'{'fE;§.i,§z'é*.§ fay ascerwfn 5&6 §;<;;:i'g'?:':i 3i§s3¢€;%é3-%€'~-.§:§ss;*::3:::§ $3; aggariianfng E??? §:3£a'r§VV;5;n:f"{§§sL% §a§"v§;<%?£'..£ééfS§f?@S§ 3:? éfse figsés 0:' §:§,;s*r;zg:?eA;i:~=:; -'_»£é;I;§?é:::é;§*§t3.§§'§::'é::: Sf maffég as 5529 Véagis: Léf : é;s":i2;::-.vé;<_ a«é:2::"sf gcsepéga? ag g meéfmg' {sf *~ig;f;j}'%,».%;?g 391% .5;_><§a<:ré" gmfffsx, 3;': 5539 55% $2' ff:'s:i%m E535 mfg? §};i§f;'s@§§ ;}r2::am§ 9? 52% ' §$gej$$;<:::*;é %z§'f?£r£§§ 3:: fieafim 18%;, 5&5 §x;par§ ';:;:*€::§?§'§§ 59 S38 §er:ér€cf she €955; §'3;:s.§§r2§$5 . 5z§a,;5§:3§§§ :2? 3:; a;zm§ei'駧«:;';3g, if m§§; ;';:s<:ti:,s§'& %;
éé, experf bazginegs and abmeséfs basginegg, in 9:".%":@;* a/%':';Q§'"fi<§j' axparé iwnfivar am' §<3ma§§f§ ._ T._ €:;r;2::w§;: "E325 exgarz ifg;';":20axe;* wsuifi V mmgsazsani {gr gaff" gr" 5 sfenamsfiafigr, €!*§:€ §éé'fi§:>=? "
aamgzanersi b*€s'r§g the §$m&Sf;5fi_4fé§f??.%f§é»*é§;....':v».§;§' 53329;" :rmm'.;<;, Ea 51% exégnf Q; /}E:_§r{:?é:'V£"i:{»£»%'1€':%:j'Er/Sf:}VV "."' .' ihere s,-«:a3:;f§ 5g 3 {:9mr:f2an<3§;'f}-"'--£;2e§w§é.;'2Zhé f'§U§'?"7€é"§Z"'Gf' and me '-:3?§'n,Q;:>?:$%:a'€{2s---VV 5:f Es'?
we mgméraier: ;§ is {be _ 3_}*fr'£a,<§.§é§./. 3.5 afief exciufimg formagia. Er: V5535? sf §§?_«:5':'»v.c:::r;j;;??s;éia%§£€ ;/_g gznabrgiawfling §;?4.;§;~*fa 7_3fsv3,L".i:e_'».V:;%;5s_ gamex Sifter w§;"d<3! 3:' 33°29 _€,'€7§$;9;'f £5':
iieffgm "*ex;i%i:&?_::%.$a::%;_' __§3*2.§ $a:%§:;:.é $§4:E.$;;§a' gfsa fie gxcfgéafgfii.{:Q}%%;;g§f§§é_géf¥§ eéjfiééré fgsrzwver 33 § {:5o ;9%9°%;§:t=A::z.}:,é{?£" K :31 ":3? ' ~ . feéaé ' "'i§§;msver gr? Em §3z;{2sf?;i;é;<§t;i%'§;..L A?f§§.TA_:"'§*@a§$r; mérgg 33% iamf §"{g'.£"§"?'f§>42%'!:'Ef" "'--.¥;':£5Zia§§ 9s---- 4' émaré éursmver, "E"!?@ ;'a:';"§'}i?'3g3€§!'§%i'?:?f,'SQ?' {firs §;<§::0nf" :":;;";'2s;;::e:* 552$ s:»_;;;r3:£v:s*§:"sr' §-s:*--~«" {Eye a'&:"s@r?2£;':§€:::;' garnszraé" be z:;i{%";'@;2:%;éEt,.__ ?f?sref§ra irfmaggfg ffiéfé :'§ {KL} « ;??eé'f§;*s§:f:'§:%;*s"'§af 5% éerm 'swig; ézgmsvgs' 5:3 §"@::€;'§;3 Ev_€Z--:€%,;f.~'z*f?as"@ gig f§G§??_5f?§? £52 3357:: saga? ;'§€2:::':s'§::% is ~~::*s:~:.r2§§ie 557$: wfieé 5:; axaffiésfi frssm £'Zf?§ AA :;:;m5;"§§{:>z {mi 555 sxgwé iaraevsr Z»''€$§,§§§ : s2:3:xe3r§"%2e§§§s fgzws gsai" sf {€28 fiafissazgzgisr, 2 ':E '-
~../ / Tfzagsgh W599 a flfifiiféfiféi" Wars' 33 :30: fiefined 5:; mg §sgisi3i2;:r:*-=3 £523' 52': Q:'Q*i;i;§;"y me§:*:s';:g ES :'& $9 §ézfr:';§§;2';'e{§ 5:: $53 §am§,. $2929 5333' 5rzj;';":§:;a megmnrg {a be aférébmféd 5:9 S5;z'C§'? ware' 55 :0 --§?e:'-» 31:? aaafarmiiy aezziié: {he Csniaxf in wfiigh. -5 ' é}S8§: Wf2$r? 3529 séafagiw ,§:'"f3Sei""i'i'§€S a.,_f§§%;:am'§§¢§~ gag? in {he safe' fafimufag 'af;$<fi?Q':£'"«:'L2:fr?:;jaré;**"._§S' A ciefimed; ancif when 5% "fefa!3fa:r;%§:3¥:a='ier';;f2:f;'5;§:"z'e&é exgsrf tarswver, {fie :za%%y..__;§§mé.{3%2'&E:§ni:::§"§;:§zz§;? :9 we axyari éurnmxer ;'ég§55§a5t':e;::+»:¥;> ifim be §a'@§z'i@a' wfiifg ..;;rr::F'e;.:"«<§i'g3%§7;:z:5i§%:ig;:._ we A' Em'-am'}2g cf 51% mm; éurnéz/é':,.. a%¢;%:e.<£§;?:. :9f§':.:§:;"%;";¢}ltg:2:f_ isjrnmser sr2€!;:Q'e$ exfséré :':;.:f:3,§f31:r;@s*;V._ ;%?%?é::».'é:; ex<::'s,iQ'§5' sir; mrz3;;§::;'zi1i.*f§g.}- éffi 3é<'§a5s.=:§s*if'«.éi:;s*§?;f:{§:59;:§§%%' £5 ff3C§€.,£§'€§' gzmsse;3;?5;a_g;}:5;~--';'--;:é §"::*V§.g§f;. ':%g:}?."a:éE fiérgsaver, when She 5;»;f§_Qr§w.__§"a:g::}:;§x5€sf"ugg' ,,»*2,*. :;9:<:%.if;;§§§@.:*§&;*:€ Q? mfg? §1.§i§f§?{?%.%':€!'";*, _..SA§,§;2"ff§ --;3: :;+. _ i;2:€:i§};@§"a:°§$n wczufd am aéézsfiéar' _ ;§€.§§"'~.,,,.v§5?%;§; "~, ;"4;f§§.E§§a?i§;f€ fféféfifé §E'?€ff §f??;§§!?{F?'§"$S§§§f§3,: ' ff' 33¢: vgerg we :',nf$:*';is'm Q? $29 ;:'§?f;'§?§S7i§§§'£f§'f§,§ V§§i?E?y. wzyazfa' 323% @.><§:esg!;x géaésgf C§::1:;: "~.?f:j' &f§5&3}7'""?§§w 3&5 £°??{}§§f? :9 émresgfy ;.}%;?--;§§ 53% icégf iagrngrsvsgr msgstég, 352%, A" $6535 :"§;;'::a:z€r éncfsgfisg gxgaré 2;*:.;z*;*::*:.:;a--j23%r,, $539 meagsmg agségnefi 5??" me ;=i3ig;§::«?§§i:,;s"§ §"§ 5&5 §X;Z}G§"{ éififfifiiiéf 55 5:3 {fie £/ and gévez? effeéé" Wmfe isfgf regfiecfefi {Q3 :s"2:"§rp:'@€'i:?g £1535 §Z;f$"£'?Q%,/85" whigrf? !.§_..._ inztfwgive es' 5&9 axgari" §"£.ifs"§§i«"8f". ffierafcrg §_{r:z¢."{ ffifffiififfi far Camgasfaéian Q? iiie a'eafzgV:.:if§:i"2z;.._'__L' mafier Seséésn 2&4; wauis' 5% £1; gage:-,="'«.__V V' -- Pmfifs :3?' She Duszéréegs Exgérz =§"U}":_"I :;i?w:°r_V "
X , ~ ~_ u §E><,£3Gft Eakazo Va.-if + damesffr t:.:%'a": "3%.='e§{s of {he amo''eri3§<;'ng ' Tjtg;.f" E 5.1:'?! (EVE: 1"
3, in v§&w 5:' the afo?r°éSa 逧.éa§aE";3§§%:§a%'%§, we fig mt gee any maréi én t§éi§_é";3_§§*:a§.;;_'fi{C*c:.aj':fi"2':"%gEy; Sm aggaaé ES siésméssaé, "Fine Agubgtavntéaghé '£g:_:1es.gi:~%.,<:>r% E35 frarrseé in Ehig apmai is angiiagesézaf _.§;:.V§'av%.:m%* Qf we uagéesgea am against the :'e1¢'$:"::se%--..
Q?
wéli 33$ FA §5£'§§«é .§'§§§%§§ £25