Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Vijay Nhanu Warang vs M/O Law And Justice And Company Affairs on 18 March, 2020
a OAN tony CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBAI, GA No. 473 /2017 .
isien ' Date of dec 18.03.2020.
R. Vijaykumar, Member {A}.
Ravinder Kaur, Caram:
Member (J).
fy ae bret bg Cant.
Appli .
Versus ie vt ... Respondents.
"op FATS -
s RR Shatty).
x S 6S | iM x Ts tH A Lt &} EG 4s @ a . ed 0 ae o a5 pe At tS Ola eg * q cy ~~ 42.06.2019. LE.023;2020.
Reserved on * "
a YTOoMOUNCed on P ard oS fe ay Se O i "* = orf ad a » ms me wv SP B® gs . .
"yf ¢ - my « eo é 4 + "3 C Q P a3 irs a » @ ane ts " Bg BR CO "4 YP om ¢ ; - { * bed ms 3 Bo 3 ie ey on fe a 43 bs 42 ay a) iD Ee io vt {hf Bo SG iS a cand 4 G ay hd AG ~ fr 43 is 4 3 fe 7 fia "1 a y 2 as CG os id 2 a cs a " 5 ' ie oA Aa ony x da ti us i 2 it 43 ky Q 4 A i i Ad Pn 3 Cy set ope 2 " ve 3 4 a tS ': ow ne J 8 6 Hoo ew Bos , yy bs By ey oa «s "A :
gi 3 i 0 ° a j 54 ed : oO gt ee z y o wt Ry " g 5 / a oe i # 6D Al ty Z "3 bn O 4 a oo n oy y oeet Ss . . 3 6s g & aa i AL ne Pen £2, % Z " 5 of 8 2 § Bo
a) a3 ' fy bd Z Be. oe & 4 5 a g ee, £3 Ct ee Cg bate y C S a ea Z : 4s % 54 o : he y i a ra os 3 i YZ e3 Low an feet oy + seed B as 52 of 3 at ved gy ay nef z aa 0} y a Se 4 2 'tt gy " as 5 : YZ a » a oe 7 as ne i ah Bs i : % 4 . ty ge we 5 my ry y ye s © 45 A a y $ %S ty ? gy Ld "4 od MG L co if} , s Pa _ ny 3 5 -
-
- yy ae:
YL ty go cs a + ' ao nS es } . int Bd » oO CG wn +54 @ ' peg ew & OM Bm oe eo 6 8 i & o co Bm rd Go oO eo 8 $3 ce e i. ' me on 4 oo @ o g 4 oa = ty ie : " :
cs «5 "C3 : Cy a 0 a3 RY C3 oa hs i$ i ; « ie or 4 mw 4 G3 ket 4 . " eh 4A hs ae M4 be ih
a) see © ¢ t ee wh Ea g m bf be ig : sy oo eo Bo la i ' ; Ly m: A iy a or ren si beg 'ht rag" "3 shed vf hs i - . C oO Pas Ka . . - co "et ey fy -, % 4; th Oh whee Be om " ad re 63 Sa nm A ut " rd a ws ie * "ed a "ed we £ rs by ie @ as aos ne 4 e '3 . Wo oO ¢ @ * us "ng O po ved ~ on 43 ted O 3 Q ip * thd ery ry ie) gi ced . , 4 > 6 w@ wy G * . (th ne by ww 1 es "4 Ey Mt ie a * a oy ¢ de $4 $9 a iB a Gh ' a es ba ti 45 wy co ia ie " Q - ky G ct ° " ~t Bagg O te A " oy on, a owe £3 * 4 et tS oe ec) * fo oe i * i bea aie
- © ao 4 o @ < so , ond et, 2 33 Ca 4.
a O i Be St vied + ry aed a igs i = : £4 CS wa * im 1k .- co at Cty ; 6 Sr Q a 4 4 G BS 2 tt a Y a Cs % i} cr 2 a Ct eet as a . 3 ty ody KE © ip Ae 43 pd 4 4.3 Th 3 Ls 6 a a 2 3 uD ee Cy £6 8 "y Fray ~ wt 3 a3 et 0 tend - ery feed i cas! or ayy * npg Ls M5 @ vad ya : '1 : ih g bet op ¢ ' ga « is) ved a a . , 5 ad ; 2 Ye wt pa EE ED v t ; fd a oft 3 4.3 iw O . ' 34 ay AG es i 3 oot Oh 4 "7 #9 Ss wn tH Q at % 3 7 en > e be -
Wy x i) no B € 1 a a 3 wha 44 hgay Ly vgs Li 3 cc = a 04 et nt O id " } 4 4 8 ¥ = es g 4A hs bt 4 ae : 6 @ Ao 3 @ seed wy % 3 ee a) FE e red ae a god baal of * O a ran £3 on n "ed by oS oe oy 8 ub ca £4, '3 23 6G Ci Q3 ci ' 4 tha weeds 4, ta 4 oa i. a 3 * 4 Cy ns OG nach nen, ee i tn G ws A - Gg 2 Le ed * ae ret ky CD oy ond 1S ed ae MS " te) * 35 ht . fs n - veep py ca a 3) , wo a nt & 's 4 {ed .
J es i W :
J re Ss ef im a 4 Yo AS Cp «6 AE Oo a4 i fet tt. a C Oo thd ie ha C3 .
4 w © 3 $53 ES: gS "ed m g + { Mg ay < a 3 (8) Ss be 4 ct hy rot ee ad * VY oo a aS Ls i ee B62 od uf Bg ri Le hs oa; te Co es ita $3 te * bt eS a 4 ae 6 G 13 £ 4A LD rts C3 i ~ a a o ' i 'i i '8 ea - q lps ae ae Q in od 2 tit mt on 2 i e £2, i ped ryt oes : 4 4
- ta fe iy QO «6 a . ia RY 1.2 " .
° st si 3 C3 a7 ah age eee S if} ad oy $e "a ; rel ' Be QD dM es og ee ne ~ 8 ® s fn Aa i io) wh a O rs cd vf bed vod Be 40 £2, z ro § a O tf 3 Gj CG wo wy a beg a a Net wa o 43 ei y +8 4 D Ry a} a z td ° i 3 'et he me 4 ved ra Ad . Cs O : 4 Ch re 4 ae a "4 ic mo en m aD hed as Ra L4 > a4 Sef % Sg 4 Se ts} ¢ Cs 4 om Q DR ow i iG o * £3 on a x cn re Cs 4 5 fy te ad st " ° at is 6 t C2 re ie » © w a Le ss 3 O $2 o ® 13 i et 4 43 64 0 ? 6 o eo % e
3) + re Ys 3 at wh i © xa i ta be aq 8 "5 . e ". whe, . a : de rf on i i i a hes us as cod r io i 2 4s 4 tes we © a oped : « . s a 3 fe ' ng . a 4 4:3 $3 au 3 ° a O eh gu eis or 43 nd es ' . Ks a * he oy '4 aed Be eyed oye : oe, pee " { ; oO / Ale Es 4 i al 5 ea : i ha . he ue syd s "ed io - a a nD) wed ert t ip res wen a5 " cag sy hei ; " 4 a uty ved Fr] " 3 wh 3 i we : fg ee ce "yey - CoS i Ad . a ey ms ri t oO R . "
o cs; : a s q a te uy O
- [a bee wep oo = , : oy + rie aw C3 4 a f vA ° Th $4 ey a SS a bed " Gg co a) tit %, at i tet "4 ® ed, C 4 oe S . . > re) re io "4 Son #4 hat 3 - . ei wy ;
i ted in or Bb ha on ma "es i ., bes 43 ¢ eS A ca) af? red a Qed id a my Me ; : ap ip se " Lo cl 4 it st a 4 % fed he a m3 bt a 5 pone od ra we vee i . oped ieee om n at 5 ce reed $33 " es os : fe % o ia ¢ ao wed o> Fy seed ¢ wh {3 ; abet kes. 5 ey 'si ht % ? Ce be : b, % . ( "S Oo ord 3 a Oh, et es a Ma o rs i} ced 'bed ae bg C 3 ca 4 a 14 3 Oo 0 6, ' @ 3 S 4 i, 2 © ra ime hy ottty 1h oF a o> re > re er axe ee wo O a e "4 in 3 o ' QO cod a Foc re sed vged & wo ' Ee a) 6 "
q 2 } * 4 : , + oo $5 w ha ce) Bd 'CG 4 a Le et c ) © G Saag ed uy a ret @ 4 D as 3 $3 Ld t a 3 ie ay . oO ¢ aA ty 3 3 cs e gt , be py gh: iy * ve g} s §& %" & ce Eg bea te q ' im ha e oO . " ne ye * t ote i a sm ") ed uy vi a a 4 43 o 4 @ de Mo 4s 3 ( = ey a} fo i ¢ $3 a a hoe i ba $34 a Gj mn a sd a4 © a os rn " w :
: bf a3 Aad La x 7 wes LS She . . Py) +f, ttt x C3 : "ed 4 ea sed iB gee a tp . + oh iH ws oe G go fy ae vy ee B "eS as B rr: ia oe
5 43 B 'a , 4 ape ~ : g uy ra he it it be " re ne cS veo red ha im £ $ ered Cy v3 ag es ' m4 "4 4 i ™ oe bd op bg a) 2 ed o oy ory . Se ty if ipa itt a on in ° ° 4.3 or ie e a rd i i oo iG ie ch es « . a 6B "
yo Gow ' . eo iM " ef cg oA ct Ct 1h evs 3 bs Ga 3 i f Ky cs o oy ; bo of. we tk oa bos . a oe G wy an rt a oO Ae e - Me vo e ? Pa aS ~ x3 & . a ; 4 at , A G2 oy w AG of a -- i ¢ e ty Se ae G w a 1 ved © os os bd vet Gp ¢ Me 4 é ee a 3 hed "a vA 1} 2 Sei fi as ; oe cha er be ie} a) we u % a q yy, wo ot in hes es ha 4 co i or ~ tis jek , oS " wo o - 3 me wD 3 hey ; ah 4a AG tf uy. a te r 4a S et oe i © Ht hed Ww ot us vied ae wm spd cpd we te 4) 4 } te 4 nye ue oe ae - : ti ae ' Coo Oo ¢ g «4 2 ® C5 is $4 a 7 1 re en A A . 8 iy dh on 3 @ an a hy rhe . im Ls ot it sf ra gi rt 4 coe * * ES:
ee we ee, a a in e ay et wo 7 4 8 i 43 tget nD Bo Yt oy @ a i ah OSS $2 o mo i Oo 4 O G6 wh fh « 0 a 4) * . 0 x (kD AS 4 the St 3 * Mn Bt ~~ = as & bs rag 3
a) 4 5) on fo end c hod "4 bed " z cs ao as x o bd ip AG Phy , a G . 4 4 oe oa @ ' co 13 a: f cf net ae mM @ a3 co GC I che 5 % red OO . bo3 AS g ny 3 wm 4A Pe co a 2 i oe 43 rs He 4 be ' . ab w ceed te ; xd - 3 ih aka sf " ae "ES i Bh ; 3 " CG a3 . wn mp : ce bd a ¢ : 2s 4 "
ap ord oy a 7 "4 : teed ae) a5 if 4 O ot raed fit ~ ig bo $ 4 sed o 4 kA 0 ot " g 3 : ' ved hy crt os LE. 4 Son oe i a "4 h4 a mt as eo cy . Pe "
2 a a 4 of a ", £3 m oA @ a Sef ap a hd ; 0 ee ' os 3 om i 3 i it wid a a i a oO ved "oO : mG . ; on bs ved - :
5 aj in iG e a ct @D if) 3 bet rat r 4s eee . i At 3 eh a _ bef Le beg uy ogee " . epee , vd ' oa WF ard ta red C5 of} a Gy At sd me a ee eS ' a3 dee 33 * it} wD? ety uy bef Bel OS art ah te, Ja iw p pe oi 2 we on ra good 3 we 6 #3 5 Hes ot sg ore % th, " ey 2 2 o 8 a a of ws O oA $3 in 4 €t e » oe . 4d 4 O a . ted Ma £3 a '2 44 a3 ved oS i 44 Q (83 tS gt 6G ta i Ei Th uy ted "¢ + ' at 'e.
a go » fos ce O @ et t) Bay oe :. ! y whet ce apes o Ch 4 a Be te 5 Be « 4 Oy aw veh '5 a ee Oe és ea ah 4 fe on i Ad wet vi rs iG : hip 4) i a 3 an 5 ie] Bs 4 5 4 Be get 3 oe : ete, ry Ge i tt g af 4 es ry KS oA Oh 5 43 oa 2 Le . Pes seat re4 ry 7 oN, wp Meow. I, _ + yet * o CS oo ' tg td 6 £ © a4 Le ity 4d 6 ed og 43 O Cy end q 42 Ct i " ar » 9 ts 1% 5 ai cy f 6 ify be ' i . ae ff 0 Ad ct it he se . a Ch, wd c . "oy ah we fa e i 3 05 Aa q} ved tg] i uf Ae wv ae te i pe) "3 "D> ay 2 DB we ee a @ '4 tA 3 wy bt , . . oS i ip $y 4 a ey a 3 if a tf 5 a Pi a | . a ia a ce - a * 4 fs " > ad » "3 e i uM " 4 ot i we co Meet 4 we Aye. Me a' Povk tf hg sb ref B ng " iby a Q G ing 4 Sy LH gt tb ud $d ' 3 oO ho A Sea t a G ; ihe iD seed o re 9] cS 42 4 pe th "ed & ; a ® ed i fy end a 4 ee wb 3 a i be a 3 4 @ u ow tS Da ; ct 2 vy on b4 eh; ed a @ OY ky z 5 ee Ch ~ c bet i eR > oe : te a "4 3 G3 bo ' . . Ch ' wd i a iy te $4 oO 0 c 3 bs oO O ey $2, © fs &% "4 a ° © ie 4 5 rl # ot ks ; D re Ae ns Sid a ap @ oy ad
- 0 © " G Ch, be Db thy en ai 4 wi a ; ae 4 4 A on i 7 ney @ ey i) gs ed a £s i 3 i D Cs 43 a a) 4 ss wn ca 8 a 65 6 eg He og wy " 3 wn a o 6 ob G os om , ns 43 a nt Pe buf 4 Log 7, oO ot 6 ¥ veep qh cl ct "rd 0 co wed £3 i? ey ob need iG ht ' cm oy gb oi in "48 ay BE od G oh "a i) G A i} 6 tS OQ m3 ed f se" oe a ° C67 poe 3 8 ' vr 1 S ; cy 43 bt Bo 6 Oy a Bt 124 3 a cA ted bed uy ra "¢3 : «4 "i He e bo oo U te ae vy iA ey a a ip cy wn 2 i OM Syed (ig $3 5 E: Mey f AO ie noi fps ; i es tea i Chg 4 ts w@ ri £3, " sed v4 ' ve 3 jf 45 cS is £3 KO G oe . ; «3 on vet " te t L reg it oy 134 an: 5 ts 0 ea > a sn % x, 43 iv i> fa ma Oy & eed ; O. 3B os er 4 i a5 5 OS Bs i a a a w re iS s ;
i ord $y eee Q} Q as mie a Ae i s de a St a 3 ~ tS ms a 4 Roe es oS Card 4 & oe <3 & Dp a4 te we fs be 4 "
e aoe Td ~ bd act ' aa) * : s ky :
14 -< o ® nn a cho a 2 2 "4 " a 6 ot 43 a bes : * ' Pe ie 3 'a yas " a o aq Lf one { 0 wo uy se t
4 Oo sy 2 HG OG | Aa re e 2 he 42 1) i £3 + rhnet 4. hs J 2 .
© Me wi Pe C3 t) wha " o cs ne) Be G fh » ts rh £3 pa 7 49) a 5 reed rea) ' ea ce: ey ce hed "% LL . ce BD t i} 2 ist ty : 4.3 I Ci °% 4 i ha oO as ont " ro 6 be vs " G ey 2 re Fie! ca 4S ® ; Pos gt " BS) et 3 SG i in S in 43 B "e ; ore ;
hy ww ha a 4 weed ' ot ws whee At o td et i te ne Oy eee} an Oo G3 ;
4. 3 om " oa a) m3 4 os O eG :
e et set ) he me a SE wh 4 hi = e 13 a cs is pa 3 4 ify £5 geod "eg . x5 . by . ne o ae a wed 44 O ci a ' " ae Lo $ ua W ree o 4 fre NY ° a te ' os a o - % a $3 aS wp tei mt es : C $3 cs '4 me ) 5 4} if ' & vend aoe ss #4 ie ° + B 3 od ae " eo os ft be 43 , 44 re LO 13 be 6 % up ard ae my sa im eA rh iy "4% oe y i 3 Oy Ae oi oi oF @ . 3 0 if ha oF a "4 "O ' eC ia D a"
3 % "ae yy wet 4D ae is 4 a a ibg " ae ws a 3 seed 4 St G ' ~ WR.
Retna ie BNA A H oN oe NOP meee ah 'L $, ot a 5 , Sek a, x Le y Nat ys ak A PNcemeN = t a + "3
ee we q ,
1. :
$ 4 %, a y YS 4 a we BAY + ae fo eens Me ms.
os od be 4 aver we a } On ¥ we aS Vey LS wo SES ES f ?
ot on weal "Hy 4 UV} reg Pefod i "¢5 o UB oN Sat Ne cs at At raed GE rea 3 4 gy bs seg tH iy in nN meat SND ee ake Ne & are! ae tat = zg Nye enon OY rearad & S4 cd {Xa Lo ooh yey ct S34 wy * af Mes ate AE bt PETALS Nata bind eH vt San ¥ Cancs ee Ne ht Act & f Y 4s e sae re as ci i hoe ee yy Nat ¥.
vhs ¢ 4 4 5 4 ym o NS be rm ¥.
Me RAN = a bee aS aay Ue a, ina Ne Sa ¥y y % ren Me AR edee @) "4 ts ghee
i) NR x g Loe bd bey w © 4.3 OO ff a " ~ @ © on ed ved C a (3 ca o aa! 6) Yay hs ei * wy 4 aa 3 "
i th oy i ved an " es . et th ot oo i} a
- ro oH rhea es hod ~ bs e ns $3 3 " is ey ren o / @ cned C3 baa ib be Pe] "6 ee i Ae Q a © 4 £3 * a % sted : . ie a ip = ce Aa aoe} ri So By i AG © et Sy of w g3 vat ee : KE eS "y ras fo 2) ° € seed 6. fo ct pee, res "9 n . * 4 "et "
as o ay cl 23 rhe f y os : ; ¥ Cs] ud oy a3 ey ed 4 & a ke i a ws ' ft ve ikt oy ad 2 Bo 3 2 3 7 4.4 Jb B 3 deed es .
os iy sed ' $4 02, £ {> me , w mn cot oo fey 1681 , be "
ae B $2 int 2 oA BANS 43 ret Bea seed e 2 ' ww ¢ Nae, ach oe 4 R wh ae A = re + 5 a oi = at ae } he int Oy rey "5 ¢ ct é oo phe , ES 2 oA wm fe 7 Xe dk ' Me Qe SA we Ne ' + ie rey Sid eg ed & $
a) ee 5 oe whew, yoen$ ~ he :
ae 3 g £ % a VA Ae 25 e € A or Nat ne £ x 3 aA we, mS A tat ta?
aa of XN ¢ oa Ty ft x ae at Sy EN Ke 44 a3 i bd TS ce 7 .
oe 3 ont ip : 3 2 tc 4
4) ws ha ved on am a 5 i wt :
mB x ao ®t a 6 BR a ' @ 9) oh, 4 i RO OS "t he a Me ahs Q it a Ee wd "4 os te ol mn ba oO ay oO sf mB 43 a 3 es a "is " ie ba
- MS & os fo sed ay bs red wy £4 g $4 18 ec ce 6 @ & " G 43 3 - ot aS cet 4 . « C3 is ry 4.3 bed ss 103 so 5 f ? E- 5 oo ea acs i C3 . cha bad ig.g £4 . me . a aS % "3 wo va x , of 4 oy eo i fu mG SA 4 "e ry :
43 " z 3 nm C3 "od is Z a LE j La os yt g mo 3 we % oo oe g ua : my SY Z ; GD gt . aA g "erg vee ated 5 tf g ' rhe @ 43 . of on y i Ss ' j "7 ie; y 4 hd ° . te, Ef uy gy 3 & qed & 3 gy oo £ ; ef y . 2 3 i _ « Y ed "ey tf a wey g 3 n us rs y
i) . it oo A y +5 Te, ft on ory a as eed y oO i "ag a3 i oy y 4 43 oe Gg & Ke L Oh, 5 ° 3 he y as ce: y ' & w o ay as 4 5 4 : / : we ns rat Oo is w : "yy ht ed 'yn wed tee at t os y yy " de! 4.3 chee Oy 4a iv} A? oe % ood -
oy " ~ -
i yy " Ul Sot Be MA es RS Ne Rd:
Poo a ow 3 Ax we S34 ey 2 wT Me af x wat.
A te Uy pend Ne "Ne nee is xt <.
aR mA ANS f 4 .
rye ae Bis ss uw RS Ye nae net BE .7
OREN a NR Nee:
eran = Na Se wa ns ot y NN cae 4 2 t i 3 0 %, o-
whos * 5 a "a @ 4 ce e, w wD aes (> 4 .) he S vD a " fy 4 ed,
8 ' Foe dee ty) ed i. oe hee whee cred ite in £3 44 44 ut fe} bob x nod it j3 Saat hut Le £3 lena wy At tS fo ss bt SE of, Qo o c m Ne 2 O oh. " tay 3 , o , = © iB +
- ot , 4.
a ee 4 o k oS , be us as Ss , 4 ved aa C i C $k vs fo b> ws fee 2 4 QB » tn ' ns mr bef whey i. me rss - 3 2 5 o fer p 4! a p 43 43 © ved io {3 " cs " uy w} "pe 4) ba i ti ") 2 4 wv O @ of ha € cy ny ". Cs os cB io be "fi 5 os 5 B ae ng ao) Lf iu ord ef 2 t ry bd 4 Cy oe o ke i gh es BS bed B® Go $5 Ww a ~ mn 6 A 3 Ct the Gy * aka vf $y '4 fqedt:
o us i 4 QO of es * a3 {3 G fs ft 63 f y : oe ha wy 6 1G a O 4 °. - HS 7 G3 © cB ped reid pe ' Be f : O i tof } "8 va $4 bo Sted in aA Ma fuk o @ go a Le be Q) % a re) 4 at - oy ved et ie ra : a i $4 os os MG 4 $i : ; j +) bed hd " iF) ve Lf rs 3 i "
2 4 ' ct it ua cd "C3 Sa é " a
- ke ed hed ped x t 7 He eg 3 a "a8 : v orf a ' te ' o es ba wo ed os ; is 3 "4 ne et A : 13 + 5 a} cs o om " + iD 9 ip " ® "ef c ep B mo 8 a bi t od tt es aa mp : ~~ ry e "¢ wD
- 9 " : Oy PP " 7 t tee ' > . "ed rd ib £3 é 4 aE 5 $ bal ra th 4&3 nD oO 1s he 0 fa 4 th Me e "ns 3 ze 24 cued . m " "gs - as cd fs fe i. a ws a a o3 p U2 st 6 + "¢4 vS cork as C3 tP $7) x ad Os if ved O £9 ete Mt < tt +4 if eo seek the vee tt oe peg 0 3 4 4 ee ted i ba Cy wy vhs a TE ° a yeed ved : 3 ra " pe fe 4 as Gi 4 nM a a £2, Tp SS nt a by " " es a é et 4 en vet <4 on i £4 iB rm 43 F c "ed he Cy tng a . > es 3 ; i 4 ity my ved @ . 9 ny ved i ec 4 "4 £3 "eg 4 @ Ld oe a 5 ad Qn bh ne B 4 C . "4 3 G3 . a D QO ond . A a ed Ae ie th | me a mg a oe "4 oh ' cont sed sf Lg ron ies ned whoa dt
4 % we cy, Or, inf ia v3 tt i " ort wn w aH At oe
- oh < ct ey oa ra HN be . ke "3 + 4 t 3 é yu po dat 9 od oy it 4 ie ths tom i ood co i ved go g et LA wt on wt 3 "4 % ¢ Ms ° gs C3 as Q An O ' Ss c M? & Fs) vse Sh, Ley "et My aan . Lay 43 we lle.
13. ee whee @ OG i
- ved tf £ ert we red 4 G cs "
Be & x a hog bet aS L Be sary Wek ee Nan 8 "~, w of xO syd 45 itd So ¢ we gest a wN cee Nat ake x aS we Se tae he.
nde 4 "ef x wakes Lae dh 3 La .
Ary sb Bed 4 mes Seale :
Re NT bat he = x aS 43 re = x a i "3 wy i om rg 5 ue ne ay 1 5 orf ry oe nt ag a Sa (2 @ oD ie as i 4.3 $4 rong a ; * ' cok "4 ~ : » 5 Ad te CG 3 3 3 ey red 4 we 3 bo B " cs ® BM re 4) vd ey ay i vy 3 na C : ig $3 e i Af ee ced a iB hg t os * Ad A oe e if} we £ ae.
a"
Sha be ¥ r Pe oh = ned 3 a as « e " ra td a a Ch, : in} ret gi 4.4 itn) an 3 a gt hee tt 4.3 £2 iM a fa bes 4 ce) veel ny w 4 fs : a wag v- "
OU 3 o ie o Ra 3 - 1 ts kt ii 'ie: mn 43 o nS he 4d iD dt & uy < 44 o> wt A ce a rt ny uy ee Be Ag Me 5 aed ad a ES res rl 4 ed Oy > 2 fs 3 ae a 63, ky ay oO QO $3 4 es G a ved F " a4 et Ed ie 'fy oy i wD 4 Vy ES od ci} JB SS oy 4 ag is tt n 4 rat iS Oh, 5 fs 5) CS "3 * 3 ie ph :
ay ip 8 "¢3 i 8 if 4 woes > oe oo ae a .
ed cs w r te ; Aad : orf a 2 QO my a Ow Gs "a 5 mh Bg M4 nou ° Ly 2 df fi Co eh "
Lhd Le C3 Ch, 3 o Leg Ch , cod be a fy, Moe Lt th, i & . M4 by yf rm A % % pt 4 "2 5 vet te a 3 63 2 2 Be "2 4 @ a aS ae geo a Y reek m4 9} ber QO BG S4 a
3 o ( ot i. + vn 1 ve <4 4 "s tig th 4 Mo Sa A & oo % mw we oe in * hes eS c « és ty im PS $i GM iu tS 4 4-5 hs wt ms : a co eed rt cs } ng Sd co! cs is Me M4 a a ee a we "4 pb Oo @ 2 ts te hel on oS 2, ist 6 Q a 4 hs ne wy ved . :
. ord - te "4 Me oy ved ty a :
w wy os cs O "rd ag OS red e 8 iB 4.3 . ' 7 a Gj sy om geod & ee, se . SS cf trek 4 f+ Ld eh . 's : are} at v? eres a rt ox w "s % tp "S % Fh, Le re y : ve 3 oa 5 has vied % $5 * red a + Acs cc nt ka 4 GS io eR we uO rr "
™ fh) " a es) 45 ro) on "
LD es : +e Le A tht "4 ma ht i Re bd aed < + wd a vs ae bs a bef ad 43 8 my) 4) aed as : 6 e 1B we a a9 S et _ aS o ! +e £23 $4 at ae $ ve : - e§ Mg MgB é ; oO § 5 2 We wy ur Oo "4 : Ci 4A ' vo Og BoA e a "1 ad ; hes so C "cd a ~ ad hh gs it a a Ct ped 2 vs hes he 8 ts sy ti iF 2 am KG "3 a on i t e uw 44 @ " es oF
5 ed "5 a Le ed Be 0 ri f ts ce G ee to yD A ap i. i in bn, : 3 "i Set a " ah mY v4 . 3 3 4a o % £0 is) 2 yd - oy a é RG ed ay on 44 (> ba ved w ta oN "2 co a uy ay n, co hei nA D Neg ¥ tea bea perf ay mS Lt a rd D Q 5 aa an a vee $4 a in Sinn cD oy th od ip ¥ , uO 4 ' ue ve eo oy 4 oA ord ms a a4 "a fa? LD 1 cg * Os ek 4 wd . i at we ha i sed 4h ef os) oS ved € "3 et Th ts " ce oS O of 4 a m3 Po : ; - 3 g x "4 0 By hh fe re mG a i 2s , O Med Se " i -- e $2 ge gt "ch * wo ED Oo a wh Dk bss 03 woo © Dy ed Mo $y po tee w o> wo Os et Oo a wy ep 4A mo . a ope rm ad Af ae ha o 5 " oD £8 f PD Roo Moy th Gm , z te G 4 a oh j eget a3 regi 43 £5 a} C3 z ¢ 2 2 c : o § 9 g 8 3 3 "i ' O 3 As s a es me g wy 4 x be i Sha iz Ls Sa ~t wh & Q ake a ie 43 QO % a o i iD Z OQ," a Oo QO vet Z Md 5 of & cS oS c / 2 e y 6 Oo fF ., fa . 4 ort g a ; g 4 st ub 6 $4 ii Co 4 Z a 3 @ ne oO a Pe y ay 4 ae aa sp wo "rt Seg bf x Y ae 43 gs a @ 5 6 y 3 . in B md wa t cS hel QO a y bh 4 cy a 4} i aa Oo om gy ; bee whee 4 r A rh a ab AG fl a tt os if y . ( & he a rs 4 43 nd gy 2 ts 8 a 6 8 '3 y y tf tee ee 4. 2 i ee Q o 4) by m4 i 3 "3 y oS et fae dese ' = a he is 3 {3 Ea yf O B bd ' " oa L ae - sid a i Cy C ¢ a a t ia ; 3 oH ey tf fos " dy Ss f y
8) ae BO ogy Wo ~ "ie y ey . he ) 118 ; eh i g ss wy : yg wy @ wed do 2 syed oo , th a Md y 75 "e4 a : LO "S a s. 1 s OP LD 6 Oo 6 4 @ 8 48 O in 3 of B i 1S i i oot 6 oe a " 3 id "9 3 i © 5 4 oS oy ig * a 3 : ® oy re 5 x bes tbed i - po ; wh 43 ' 8 > sa L Ls sed e ze y aap os V4 CS gy Ae : , , "ef 3 Oe C . - a 4 y aS * 4.3 i O £3 vod aed . sa wee 7 'I} eo wt a 1 _ a 2 ws yy 4 "5 a es a yy . os hb Q ia ts ro 43 4 yy fh s a ¥ it 4 re o 3 Go @ s Sp Soo bed x Lk 1a cet wd So a itt 7 « . / BA " We 3 6 1 ay ;
C ea @ a 2 @ re 3d 43 x &4 amd so n a Pe "4 a a © A ae ip 8 a :
Cog £ © x 2 cf ; . .. 55 @ eG 3 ty 4 ' ¥ 63 " mn a ng % ;
w uf ~ co mo Ad \ a f ann AS 4 A . cs io s Boe Re 8 wo . : ¢ cc SG es Os ny my 6 a _. ey And , oar : 3 wt ori we ry ceed a ws Eo j ' un rf a am ioe a cS : . Ch 3 rn i ad i os ibd ord Me apf @ © a Soy G > = ae ee 3 thy x ved sped w TG , Y uw ' Ube ; i qi . one as ped Co bd had y us c " wo re ty "eg ard wm SS is oh ref 0 pol reed 4 : 3 ates ha o wn a4 3 7 ; GS 5 w hed ns a, wept ts 4 se, £4 & " a é ie £4 Hh u3 3 ih ag "
O hed 3 B ;
sed at red nt on, sn ip ¢ ) a be 4 a A ay a ee i Re . J SO ans ie + beet : ny re a A * (3 x hy ve : ot @ 4 TD Osx Gos a ae 2 .
: io nan oD 34 xt rv eo é "e 'ai os = -
eee a