Ultrafilter Gmbh vs Ultrafilter (India) Private Limited on 26 August, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 3]

Karnataka High Court

Ultrafilter Gmbh vs Ultrafilter (India) Private Limited on 26 August, 2011

Bench: V.G.Sabhahit, Ravi Malimath

.x,v.wm»wk«wmmmwm\m NéTHE%ﬁG%€CGUR?@§FKARNA?AKA;NF5£%§ﬁLQéE aa?Em3wag€wE:&§"9A¥<M?Au@u§?2§;é H §RE$EN? % uV V1% Taggxﬁyaswaixﬁ1c§§k;sgé5Aﬁﬁ§ f AND. , _ ..» V .i ?ﬁ§%&wwau§MR,3uS%ﬁ§§§av§MA;§ﬁ§%%:k"S BETWEEN:

£.E£t:"af§Ef:e.:'.Gr:rj*r;5:";'-251;, é _ 'V Vj A CQmpa:é'y §§*::i§.:r*g2;c"ra%e§ unafar §;§':;é'"' Lawg £33? €féé_mi'a"2'r'%'3g §:ar=g*i..:f;§gi-- i_:$. rs-gésiemﬁ Gfﬁce a'g.B'Ls.;€::§§ng$tra5é;%= «E 'B«»<i%_2?8i_§, Haa':é';'T'§;e§'fmar§:§: "re§--:;e'S€-:n§'éd""$1y its CQ3§"£$E"§ tz_:téa*§v.g!«X.£:;{{;*;4rn&3{ - _ - ' =. ' ' '.*4*».>u' ",ﬁ@§&ﬁ&n£ {ﬁg 2'32%,;faiag~;-3;ég~:,:2€§;.-' Seniar iadvecate, far :'§P§*%;f:E;_'a$E--§E':@'E§§j'(V&VSV'§é£'f-a5'?/'E3'; Ramdag S; .5J'§§%'"%{§, Aﬁézeaaias} :;u Vci§irafE:érf{£ﬁé§a} §?§Ja€e iﬁYﬁi§é; ;ﬁ: <C$§2*::g%%g;_§':%;* §§"2CQE'§C§%"§§§§ zméer the "Q_?§%£§S'§:,'AE":§ as? me £§:'::par%:§§5 A23, 295%,, %%:.¢:;:E"§:.g £22 %""é§§§€<'3r"é§ Sfféce a': Pig': £\§<>ﬁ?§, ' AA Tﬁgwzméaganéra Enéasgiréai ﬁfﬁag E§--.a'§%"i§5§§§"€ £62 3%, ,, " --..;?e3§:'e§en%:e§ §°'%f.C'E"€§;%'"E by iig §%'§a:";a§§n§ Qifﬁifm' §E'"E.§<E'§§§'%?'EE§E"%Ja§E{§§ King' w_._»m;,.,.~u-M,...;4;ﬂ.k_.._w,..,=4.r=,,. .. '§;3§'a§§a:_§':i{ Nénfaymasf the camgéany ihai 5% manufacturing ﬁiterg in {he name am gtyia éf '£§§t:"afE§'{e:*'.

"ﬁe use 95 féiterg dgvaiczged mtg {ﬁg rmuirameni: ané use 3? fiitgrg 3Ea:"%§ with the éryergg Henge Em §a{::'§.;:: }a'n.y gtaréteﬁ manufacturing its awn 'deggicant' awe '@f':~*:;E';*';§::::_sj' be gaéﬁ aéong wéth the fﬁters mama:-"acture§ by the anther tyga viz, 'fsidge dryers' azﬁé z:;:§ :éT:¢:?'n;e:s','z§§é--sa}%%éé :' were bgéng Emparteﬁ am sofé;a_i¢:'2g 'wii_ﬁ£*;- {§'?€f"'§"§'ff€.§f S.: comgany ccgzsasited the a g§;:3Ee"Ai'2;a:f:%: @925 the reaemmendaiéan 9? the aV§}pef'5$'§;§t'§ ?'T.§fv":".if*.T '{T;Q§'¥'?§aI;I *;r' starteé émgariéng "F;j§s;':'§§=;2;':.:%_'7;:§v-:%§ge':':;.:_V€_:fé§':i§V '§":ai'§%,k fey §:*s€§rsr; gaié aiiong width the_.f§E--§e;"é'~V%%:§éi'§ég3..Vn"2&.rf:a,s.€3{it:;;~;*&€,%v"h*;,: the wmaany. At we 3§mé»,_9§--ih%; ve§'2':§%%a*:.ef; --aR::v:;;%*%:§:§e§t§':é2.£e ﬁryes, manufaaiureé by '§a§:"@é"';»._'.éA;as ._b4é«i.;§Igv.: ..'mar§~:ete§ by mm §vE,!5.9a<:e '.$q::éQr2<§5e:fsiL',* %m%éba=;s,_ _____ __!.-»§$;r':£&, {hays wag a Qamgetétéan ":%;>e%:§;-fg»*@g:": ..ji:_f';A::§'«;r:§sw*;_:§ar2;r marketing §'{$ fiéterg with 'Fﬁéuéaérf d:9§,re?§--..%ar§.§' '.?f;a§§§"E§;;%pmeni marketing f§§ier§ aiéng with ,5;a§:*'<§é ' ::,?:*"gag%§:. $3; a Ee":%:&§* éaieﬁ 2&9" {}z:%:c2%%2§§* 39%, the "?§£§2§"%é€aE

--.,*:i:f3A;§A§':3b4:éA§"§€i:§@;*'§ ﬁsgﬁeeséeenét' mg: sssmé is: gr: am? an 36"' xé"

w»w.'/-1/«.w.<wv-«q~..-uwmnu/-a-g3--¢»,:.»~.\»~:»-»,=».»»»wH=» »=,.,=. .. .. . . . . . Ef?

./».-.-<.--w.V.-«..-,_.-u.».~.w-.~,,..,,W 4". ,..,. . . .. .. §F"E§"§€.'§§i€S <3? partnerghégg are agpééaabée fa {ha 133 raggiendant Camgarrya Tha fmﬁémg 0? the {SL8 ES e:*r§.";g*2§::>e_4E;é:~:.._vv Yhgi: the ménaégieg sf §a:*%trse*e>r5§*;§Q are mast &§3§E§§:T--;'i§v.y§..§'é'''ﬁ§i :§C--3%t§-..T . case an ham. Hence, the CLE C§sfr§m'E_it€d_--éﬁ"e.é:é';f*:>'§"=%:j",$<}- heming. "mat there is me §*r:a%:e:'Ea§ p»£5€E§dT é'§3ef«:»sf e"%:§é'f€: :ii:E§;§..«ii:';f;,;:%T_:

egiiabiish a cage cf {}§§f3E"&i-3S§G§": 85§'7'§_:§ rr1ésm'a;Wageé§ﬁé%z3t..VVfﬁéwai amy beaause the campany wa$_ 1as§<e.df ta 3eE_%_a ﬁiéfferent predasct; the same wzméd.::'1Qtl_an;:§o;:_:é*:'f.:'jté'%<f;pgr*e§3%Qna we further contenég that %;he "::i;%:{fa9«:1t%--'3. s:_:5 5¢§'§:v,vi?§e apgeiiarzfg ghareg :0 '{§"';é"iS "%égE';s;§§Eyi' Ejféjiiﬁi $526 §'%EEE'§£'%§':

En%er§ezre;':<:~e._§:§~;.é§a.§'E1;a:€»_fgzﬁi-._Hé"-§h.e:"éfm"e piaads that the aggeaﬁﬁ be a-EE'{:wé'0?§s-~::,4é =§Iv§;'V§'V%?,.'_§VV"§'§"":$LJ§gf"':'E_3§ awe: aagseﬁ by rm (11% be g@f:u';.»:.s;§d9;n E.§:V:f.;_s§3~g:;_%:;'rt §f E53 saw; he reéées an {he f9§¥3w%5--:f§§ §a:aig:fr§éé"s'*§£;;V_ _____

3. ..V_V".Sf.::~:é;§é§ ﬁrasaé 3%'? vs, Kaéinga ?":;§2es* gm i""'_:,@1;;V:é;;Vv:=éa' fr: 535% :5 9&5? 3:5: g5;:§:::.~ ~:'%=§_s%.:~a5éjfe fﬁéﬂﬁffféﬁ fﬂééa i;im§é"e§ 322:2' 0§§'§€if"'S ax, gvseﬁfg Irmzggiréag :1/awgy (fnﬁia) éiaidizzgg £.;':'z;;'§@d arza' {2:"f?er§ regmrésgg :5: ﬁiﬁ :98: S€"

.:2§8 "n"'n:'-a-?A'5)1-t««)«\¢'I.\»»V~:I->I.v.\---"-4.\~¢v-»~4r-- <.w~»r~».,..,:.». . . ..._é?§%:aTf*2§%§%2 we faiéeié :"§§5E§{Z:*§""§§§'"2§§f§ §}€§E3f¢§8?% 3% §'::§s'i§§§ aa %?:f§§%

3. Hangman Prasaa' Saga' var. Basgress Cerggb §>1§..i"{3',,. ragsrfedin AER 23$: SC' 3426.

S' Qr: téze Qther hand §rLPem:aiah,. we §€§!£i:":¥4'i"'¥r€-§i'Zif Cezmseé agpearirsg fgr the §'8S§:}{}€"1d€ﬂ§S émgagned éréer. He cszetezéés that téjgre E3 an facm gr in Saw wmmétteé by th;% Cg-r:"ﬁ¥;f'ai;§--~;z' {hat caiis Ear any émerfereniteﬁ-4__. "§"hé§V.'e\ze;*°eT.€Ee:,§;E:§§f; :T§%:€ resganderti: is a majgrity $ha;'é?:»:;§;§'{§e3V{, é"-;3a1é}f:%{§§onVfgumder Sectém 39? ané 398 §::':_4_."mai:-%ﬁa§§Vr":é'r::s§.g'.»_ TE71aE there i$ mo ;§f'§§°E§b%f§@§§ a§%ééej§"V_§é£}Ei$:f°é'5f}3§7;**3.§*3151%? a majority ghare hoider tQ" S§c'57:e'E<A..%j§%2§v§&§7;;'§'V;r$»§'r.,:€he prasvéséong as? Eaw. He £ant§::@§;/,e:§§'ia«é VSe§;i§{%_§f:._ ;$%9ff-3'»».:§wavEdes the rigéét ﬁe awiy Lmégr V*:3;gc'i:£§s?é'~v35'§?V ars§{:'v. of Eha Csmgaméeg Ac: ané 'V'E,>?:":_t§t%é:.§":'t§"?;$ r:;:=:g;§§}:2§é§:"E;"ﬁ@ maintam a gﬁeiiiiﬁﬁ, %~ie.r:€&, 81$ VEc:r:;'r:i$Tf'"s":§§'::};*:v4_§f. ii§§" a§@eé§ant Em: 5 majsriiy' S§'§&§"8 mider ::'as:*:.§3'<::_ffVf§EeV_ 3"§:§.§§§i§a:': maﬁa: Eegiézisié 3%?/3% af égiha ﬁg: £3 §FT§f£:'%F'%@§ii'$ ":.3:**:§ safzmi Em $:,sS:§%ne§§ "Fhai *x;'as"§£:=;s$ ﬁ::§s'::m{§':2§£a%:é§ng have men géamé 9;": I'"€€GE"§'§ if': arég? ii} 2:"

.z..z..........-.5-~,:">x\./»"/ra¢:?r.3«,-=>«2< _.,j__1,..

3.. i/,Ssé<'r!5fmgr? aim' mfvers V, West Pbri" Higﬁtesh Hagpsfai mparzed in (2338) E42 Camg C3§€$ 235 {SC};

MSQC Qacfiva Qsmanar": 2,»: '[:'»rT4'g§2;'I}' Chamdragévekbar R333 !"€,£}G:""i'€Q' fr: ,éfg?;"'3--£?:§§i'__j':iﬁ:.,;_ L738;

3. ﬁdeeﬁie Xrrcfasirias §;3a';'3 ..éi:2v3:ea' 'a_.:{zg'z ék jy. . Needfe mdustries !&!é;:{e;xg;fi'::¢?,?a*g}'A. V'ffc:i:{mg§;::VT_A Limffed arm' Gfhesfs _{'e,{3cvf:i*53d§r? ,4z;é;Pt .: 98,: 'st LE8. A "

6. %iea.:°aj"'s:Qf_'z;ngé_.is _:as'..€.ﬁ e><é':ﬁ_'§-:f:e__é_;VVVT§he reccrésg 232(3) aha? the reggmrideni ﬁsiéing ':s~Et:_:é':=--é_s éiamat maé§'2%aén a getétiam under Se§"::<:L%é B???-3V9*g'§;3.f':%'?:LV:é' Camﬁanées 5125:. He {Z$%'"§5C€§"'§§$ that %%i"g§pgE§cai'té..Q:€'seéking a reéieif am Q§§3E"8SSE%ﬁ ané gar: (mg: be fééaé ﬁx; 3 mérmaréty §?EﬁE"€f §'é':c«§;::;.%'::é_;_' AC§%%'2;:;V_§aé%:;%:':"§ agaérsgi aha mafaréiy gharg haééerg _a§aér'*:':::t g.;;{'§2.4a§;m:§r&§sém am mésmaréagemmi. Sigma 328 H"---§:%*:aj<;:E%y"i:§ntr§E$ the managémeszé 9'? the écrgégsany, rm " my wggeggéan am mégmgmagemgmi gage: Seﬁéém "?;»i'%--?,f'3§8 i:{}%_£§{;§ :§2e:'§%c:s*@ ha griﬁémiaérgeé 3.3? 5 majeriﬁg gﬁara §%% r»w>;.::z;-w~.w-Wang»-N...>..,v..A4v.;,,:«,....-'...,ﬂ..~«w .n ..., .. <°3§;§r$'3:_$§<*:Vs'*:" .z::§%éd {:9 heiéer. Refiarzce £3 §E§€€d an the afaresaid judgements im supgart of £33 gage.

{b} Sn the aiher £7393, she res'g9r':ée;°2t's a:_*€;:uir_""'.-s;é*f._ CQi'ItE!"E§$ that there 2g :13 grehébéétéan 1:nderﬁaw.:}"a:.%*"=3 "': ' majoréiy ghareﬁeider is maimtaén a.;;:';Aa%;.%5{f0:'e."unﬁéﬁi,f%é%;€.§_C:m". 3§?';"3§8, That acts sf apgresgéan hé«ve1'f§7@"é§"; the €¥3%!'"3€}E'§{';,i, :5: as much ';:S.""-the é*2i;jm'i§'§?»-._E'é'a§g.,,..5;e:en iienferrad with 3 ve{@ p_;0we§: AV.§Er1ﬂ'?::§3_ei"-»g;'L:és€§At;-f,_ti";§?:'§pawér cgnfmed Cm a;§peis;a'nt :_4h..:§$""E§sd*s;§Ege§ in mg 3? wgregsion, ﬁhisié §7aé'é:da§'é:'%g3:§§.%'iafféaiéé the ragpméentsi {<:}. _?"éAEA§va:£ﬁ;e:a:__:é:'$%Q§'a,§é§__ iégsihe respsgmﬁeni an Neeﬁie .Z:m';:sz"r£€.§"§:: g'i3 Jafiyers 2/2.. Needié fréﬁusirfes ﬁewéygj {§;:;iji3)?£:§.§§§'E;?§§ Vfmfmiféﬁ aim? Gfféesiat rﬁgsrééa' in ﬁu:"§'€ ,:§§;{,'=1'f_._t{:== aaraéené {hat in the saéé saga gym":

§§':-!:us;;'2;_§*: é§*:.é"--«§és<§f§g::.,;*§:":'y peziétém wag féigé $2": the ground G? gmasridg a:«¢e:'e mwe {mi fog' '4"-..§Vé'*%':i;«r:rfera;r§':?;E , eves imugh zéze gatéiégn wag regaatedg reiief _?g";§¢3§'§i51z"§i;§"%§§€C§, ?§"'E€?§€'E§E"ﬁ iééa r§§m:"2ée§2%:"g aazsnsgi $><ies':ﬁ$

5.

'-';;':a:HM,;';*""v his wntazzizégn by Qorstendéng :9 me extrema, that ever: if the comgangz peitiizém wgra ta be regecteﬁg aﬁeguam rage? can Stiff be grarziad by Em Caurt.

{Q} In U29 case 0? Neeﬁie EE'1diESt£'§€S finémg recerdeé by the Su;3;*en*1e_,Qas.;;§t t:Eié€ 4"a%'.'jV§:ié€;é%_E_;:gn'-. unéer gamma 3%? maid orziy ge fares;ma~migigsrj:'+:;% a:§'é7%";m§;%i by a majaréty share haider. §'é"ié*~:'fTgr:t 6&3: z§7:j@:Q eA%§i:;i{;-r*a..:;a,%as uitimaieiy é%s:*':'2és§§§ an m.e%'§_ts Esi;:r:':é4:ieVé'i~;%'VE*--;"$é:':£e what is Q? reievance é$?__EE'2a}ift»V':'he.'g3et'f5:i"én f;:%.:a§"%i's:"'%ﬁ§sm§s$eé an the §¥'Q§3¥"'i@ that i1ih;V;€37§}'é'§§tEd'?%'§%_§§ xi3ééf'?i'5EiVédV }§3f the miréeréty, '£3: V&E"§@i3§ ﬁ§{'§S§Q€"sS reiéeci HQQFE, m2§§%:VVV's*§Vga.r5V;V' .'t_.%rAA'._§;E91e2:'l%::.'--~~'%'S£o§e $5 S€£'C§O§"i 3§?',f'3§8, E:

---.z;§;cs::§§§'-:.e§éj__feV'r§VVfe iV.§:'§~t:.t_;if1;§r»e $5 3:0 §§"QE":§§§%éO?'% far 3 magsyéiy A"'.g§';;§Vs*£:?3ei.€§.§A:'~§§ %%*;aé§:'ca£€: such a geiétéan, ﬁmy mamber at' a a§rs§+?¢;;n;:%:a1'ss*j§+:§§:%m:: Q?' agagresgém 33$ if §:?:& Cguri were ' ':0 mam Eg an ggmegséan Ea any member;

Em wénéégzg mg ihe ::a:*:%;§as*sg,, agzséé paw ;;:;£%*:

- .é:s;r§?;3:*3 53 ii §;h§n§<g fit: am aaagﬁderg jag: 52$ £§:_§é§§§§§* Herwce; we hoéd {fiat ever; thaugh the ra3§z::r's§ent. %'$_a ménéréty, tmy are antitiaé {Q maénitaérs a ;Q8Z"§E'£3_Q§'f§;" Sectéan 3§'?;'3§8§ ijnéer mega ciriaimstanceg, Qgiévéééén by the regprmdeni §§ maintainamé.

81(3) It was further c:3€:':Ve:*;.ﬁ é's;*i£» by Vii:-9.Vﬁap:T@:2§ié1fi'{;VVVtE1at me :18 mmmétfced an esfgor %§2V"ap§§=;§§i'g_.'ihe g'5r':'s"1:':'EVp§e$ cf parinershég is the <::as@ é!f_i' igfze CLB was misguided by E?3;%<2.:i;5c:*n;en:;Eé1§§§'rf§§ ::;.§ ?t-E?$§ie:~-_d;<3s7<:":Vj;ry'V1e§*:t tétéeé as 3 'S%:a,re%2§§§e:*s- Gméy baggage ifhe partnerghéa--Vag§§é%:€éi:§f;*:.hzézég'§,>ée:i"ea-féreﬁ érztz}, it Carma? ba izeéﬁ "'C?"§8f 'é".?'§!E';*3 fg:>:*;':*:¥c§;,%::f:g;»..g e:;.§ §~a%9'i:§_'§%5§zép are apgiésabfe Q the case an E"'san§;«--,_ V Q\ ham, 3% §°é§§@m§er:t'°§ {.'fQ§§§"Z$€§ e:':'§GL-§::*.§ 5.=&:f?2'§;§V:s: 4 %:$;": ::h& vﬁrgx rgataxe 5;? ma é$c:.ss";rsef:ia":§m: beéwéaiﬁ %:§j§e"g§}%;V:":tV%€$ am the maarser in whéah {E38 bugénegs " -Ti," ~é$"E*:$ing §é:§.s.;§:Tﬁa;£'%:e§3. Eéasrisg %:::: {¥%"?§';:' gaze ihai E E'<'"a7E'3'§"';f'é&--.§S A"§{}§§%"é§ aarzéasaieﬁg 92:': E923 ;':::"§n§%§E&§ :3? garimrghég} "--"{%"3 a;§j5E§*2$m* iﬁéﬁﬁ g zﬁarag aieéz" a;r':ﬁ&*:".3%;a;r';é"ér:g bgiwean méh 5;? *'*3«--"'-ff;g"rM% ' M16".

them; that tfw apgzeéfamc actg in the :2a%ur*e af tﬁa gagﬁsger mi giving mg te<::h:zé§a§ mew fwsw :9 me wmQ'agj},{'.:V ""E;§?'2;éV{~~,V téze materiai ms recsré ciearigz egtabiéghag {he fag: M grénaipies Q? partaerghw we a9pf--if::'laT'§§e. f::: haaé, {<3 The CL8 hem that t§°;2Lé~«.:-,:::::%'frf}par:24g* 'réetfiféng bait a gieréfieéé ;)artner*s?*:§p'A-§§,--St2v&%Vén5»':'%:"e__éé3iiT¥&%Ean§ and the reﬁﬁanﬁent, & t:e;:h:2é<:a;.t\/..%::3EV§a'hQ:§at§6n é.g§eemerzt wag erztereé Esta é_pé§a§§:_és*:_'E"'é?i:f""'the cemgany gm :'}"*" Februar';'_VV.:€%_a;81E}i$3?" x«,I.%1i %}'L; ..f<cE:'1?e'a§§:§éE§a:'2t hag is mcvéée t@:E"':r*siCa:{ §%f%é'%;#:' §s';§;:*\;VV.;§e;§é E the asmparzy fag" fzhe man;:f3C§EQ«r§'*3§ "Fherefare the teihnicaé z:"a:'§%§aE*;:£::?a'::j§.";ar2Lﬁé§.%V§5;:é"e5€- the firgi: agreemwi §§'E'x«'e§8i€§"E % 'me §a:9%::§ag; é ' sagas-5 G? §;:r2:,"?2rQ;"; ?v?3C§:;'rse 'faaig ﬁréaxgis i§§§"?f§"é;:53?§:!5*.§?:_'f§Aé:*;;§ 252:, €.§,;"vf.§::r§§f; Q33 zaaaréea' 3;"? 5": §§%,? 'E5? C"§z%:;:2 §:13§é§ 859, §"i*%€ §{§;;%;"'€f?"?€ Cami Ezaéé ag feééaszzvg: ,5} E egg éwu §77/-'¢'¢'.'N'~7.\7:~'~'4\'~Y»7:5»\'>Z\'~7r"/>7}'«1rw\\uu»:I//r~>¢¢4\~4\~-:ut»€".«/4r~z?::«/M , ,, .,.,,,= =. Qfz' 'vi company, fzczwever gmaiﬁ, /"?GW§%x'&f "-., ztiomegfslzi, is 53 mmpgny rim' a pa:/i:'2ers;'":;",§ evez: 5 qaag;-,9ar§nersh;'g2 and 3:" £5 §hr@ugi?;'_'ii%?..'_' just arm' eguzzabfa Cfaazse that o§!_igg'§;':;ns5r;_T."~ L. % gamma? :9 parznerghzp relatigéné', ';:r2a§x" CGmé'§.?:»*, V XXXX XXXX In the 53:52,. 0f1v*V' 5cé';L2ﬁ¥:g_s:;i'E::?._ 9;" fé'm'£iy' mmﬁarzées, rim ézigirig'L._,%2¢j~§ve ~ :1a,r§§,'iga' the ﬁissafufian =:>f ;:>.;=;'s*z';:e%F;:z';?;i,::z_"»L._;3;*sfzc{éia:$ wfzere J i §!?a:eha£cL{§;%Q::;i§~3rs. §:Yj29}°"§3" er and {here 21$ o:;5s€§%'r4%:gT0 }-2.s';:/ 'f$';=r_:9z7'*;2f2;§;r§é§e;é?en€ bass" frsm ﬁes:-3-;%".ﬁ§:V';:g;%.'s;f.ia§:re=i?z;%f:féVf§: 'Titre vsfegrnm' zramgany ;'a:;é:{_§e__m3s gmabie 11:2 fwia' iﬁaf Ef2€"';€;g;:£%3ér§a*§"_;'}L§%'--E;Vé"---._§3!?'i=:"" aamgany ftsad gang; éfafweéfaq, 'ér2.Vi:";'-?eAA'~.3§;:ési, it was reverses' am? _~%$-a;§s*;g??%:2g»:;g53 ""--::;;§$__'.:3ra's;"@ai fhe msézas" was f@5"€i_f:@ Sa:g3,r&;"2*;§ Caasrék ﬁfier refer:':'r::g fa '}EVZ:s§ §25?'§:é:;§f;;?".V:'{;g§s€ 529%; 2 $5; ER £92; (3923; ';15§C afaa %'es'?;::fje ?"e§§::"53 £3, £§a','5 {ﬁxgéiéﬁ E {SE2 »~/S35 {ziﬁ} 555$' sihar £53532, .. ,L_.éf?a%'V-'éugremg Cagiré fseici as' feffavvg {'55 g§ge 3 = 9;' £5 CC?f??'§ €53}:

}=fX§{'§2" ; , ~\\wI\"¢«}«}vv4\V:hNWK}-hfVn5Nn.&V/v-ysvwlwhmw-4V¢»v:'nmn4 W" .. .» » ,.,.,.,.,. . ., x,a<x,x;, In 5 given €aS€ mg ,Qfif?C§p'§E$" af a7:§sGf:.1fi§z: 0f,9§:"fr:e:"sf2;'y may aﬁgtziy sqamreiy if 3&9 agparent §i"£'U'CE'i.£f€ 9;' the grampany 53 £7579 reg? 3z:n:z.:':*u:*s 3:73' 0:7 Qiercfng éha :xe§§__g':"':';éj'_~ faund gm: 5:; ;"€2§£i€:3.r if 55 3 §3ré;f:@;'3;'3:';:3. 'M Xxxx, " ~ {6} in we Eight §f §he3' a'§::.g:*esa:i$ 'ju§gsT:ééré\;t .,aVnV§finA {he facts 9? this Cage: it £35': t%f;_{*~.='Fef0:¢;_ tifiiat: the §rEriec§§£es sf p&,§:E:;":ef§§%3%2i;3:=__staéﬁ :E§'3~§:£¥' 3.V€;'E§'?jC1tf,VVr§:{3 the case an harm, Thaw: s%:%'f§{;'E'e>;%V%'§éeat:é~:%§j;;%,E' 'it-3.5% 5e.fe';'2'g§ac:eﬁ ta estabﬁsh ma same;

if) ;;f§%_$ . %§e%_3Vi§:;h:".%:§p between the gariéas

--.;c:::2r;2e5'::Cé§" yvéééz ii';-2e.,._7"7§f;€~C%"::"i:*¢a§ Caéiabsraiéan Agregménis' "ﬂy f;%§»:f?:k:;e::a_v agreemené a Rama: mw faa 23$ 9% 2,f§;€E£3:i";,s' ? Vgéaéﬁ ﬁg {ha agggéﬁant ﬁr: yeium fa" tecﬁmécai :3;Sg§5ta§*;sr;$}'%i&€lE3r§%::?a1§ ésﬁermaiéan far {ﬁg f"§"%&f'§:if§£?CLEE'°S Q?

=..V'E"§'f:L::%:§:gir.é_;a§ fiiiargffiuéé §m::e§g§r2g 92:. ":'"'here3€ie5 thasgs '--é:r;t%:;§;*'§@E §§"%§Z® a '$%*2§:=E%29E§::?§:*$ ?§§"i§E€%"'S?'s§§ §%.§£"€iE'?E"s§:§":§Z§ by % migm whim the apgeiiant was is ﬁazbscrébe ta} a 2&9/9 $.:h_:;;re haléémg. it é§ thsrefore mgarenit mat a reEa{égr."'1§%:?Vi";:.;*e: 'L:'€»;§é, gartnergi wag ham firgig it {hereafter "

Sharehaiéerg rigﬁt by a aaisargté' *4';'".he understanding; object am we ;:9'<3§'a§.§'QhVsh'é3Q?* _, 'f§.«:;:§;:';f EEE€€D'{§QE"': csnwafdsf wag thaé>:s:f:"'~a» pa1.:*1:V:.3;_e:r;~:;ii°:V£ 1g:»1:,A"':.. '§'u'r'tE:zer more; the sharehoidem ...Qart§}&*rgﬁL_§;2 ';§:_§re.z'%fx'1iev:*2.'€ ..£*r*:te:'&d mm heiwem themev%de§é{:'é_$'t'he,§§'»r§:é§%i§%>Vr%V:.sfV:he gariéeg ts Carry Gﬁ the §u§i':fzte';:-.5 vé ri 'Same manna &$ izhai Q? 5 agreemenig aége aﬁég r§ée';a--§:-E:f:§ '£:;r:§.'t§€£:;;_ﬁa:'*%T_fi:é_§f;$%iE g":--«;fte.¥:{%%®£*:§§":i 53. E 5 {g} gar: be heéﬁ is be in .._';_?';e '$5 3 §%§-'--'\SL::E:'V}Qﬁ£V§'ﬁ$%'§}'§:§3t Eﬁféﬁ ihgaigh it ég 3 Camgamg in _ gar':§:es*2hEpg '"':""§3€ reaé Sirustare gf the £§m:§5.s1a,%V"§§:%';;§3'%;é ":9 be 'that as' & §ar:r:e:g'?;§g "Wag finding Q? 351% ;';§ :%20§{jis":§ éiézai ﬁha ssmmny ﬁg naihégzg bu? a g:%§:§';'§':"'L§e.;é Vvgisarinsrgféég ﬁetzsvean ma gartéég, ﬁg jug: arsé

-.f&'§;%§§a%3:{ §*°§§?"§£S,; {ma ;";:*%;":§:§§%es £2? éiggaiuiéas: Q? ;§a?§§'sas'$§'§E§ ::';«ri;:«;'1M'_""' '*/'«*'4\'*'¢7}~)"z75>(."4Vr"'5'«~f'"\\'!'>*7)"fMV4\~)«4\~.".*"Vv~¢\.,xwp-»:4.,.A»:A»n;r.». ..m2{:}.._..

ag apgafied by gm ELB, £3 §L§$t aria ;'ea§G:":abEe' aféé we fémi rm greand ta Egzierfere '«£x='Et?§ the aame. §.(aj: It wag ccmitanded by me aapeiiani, {baa rm materigé :3 ahcrw that them E3 either mégmanagemerst, It ég father <:en_i:en::i_eAﬁ hcpiders agmenzeni having come to $':n mt wand by the same arid er::'At':'-*:%ie_:§. aA rivaé §E.£§§F"':€S$, REE§a;"::°;j-tie" :33! . §'~:'3€§:§,'2_'2?;;_ént 9? Sham"? ﬁrggaa' Jam axg, ;':{e;32v..}4e;a:;r:e.a;?'sz: Azg 2955 55 3535"

wizeyeiﬂ »§;..E"":€"gt:§?V§';%&"'E%$.,A:{;s;£3E%§V'§'iZA':%iQfﬁ.53? Qaras :8, 1% and 26 as unéex A V . "';'8,' f;*:./.{5T5§rs??@r'?:; 533$, £958w3 A55 ER' V' p§ 5§,, ﬁgs ﬁaié éhaé "ff38 W§:"i'f Egﬁpregggaze' .;f';*75é:¢*:.»%':§§,'-A.§£;s.?::%f?5ama, fwrség aaﬁ v:»2r§r:gf:;i"", If wag .' a i'.§ z3 i'2:ég%':V':.%*'i__:?-2"§a§:" "éhe s*er::':}3:*: (mag 2235" §3€.ff"§?Q:"'§ EQ V a§ﬁg:'r§;2' .'§é' @wr;r 55939 in arafziztffs #25 faaég waasid .. g':,_ssé§2"}~' ﬁifhe mékzag :3? 5 :r;:s'z2ai:':g 31$ wafer mder 'jajgé aim" €<:§zi.f£'f5b§é3 52:56, 555 {mfg fa éfwsg «:::§§§s;' $5 éfzﬁgé" :t§3§:"§{;'§§z" :,sy"§':;;:";i*: f?§'v"éE':' 5;? :*%2ai3::rv {he §:;'W' vi'/1«vV§r)v(\'VVV1n"t"1;'t\§v)'vvv'}vl1vvv>>pIvnvn1v'V1 ,. M n ,»....,...., W21"

ragzzgissfe eiemerrt cf o;;*;3ress:'m"'. If was afse ﬁéfa' #23:" "me raga}? G2' 3,o§:'icar£'i0;?3 UI?{.3"§f 3.2361? 3}'? ﬁfffﬁféﬂf 5,3395 magi cfepena' am the ﬁartisuiar faczfs af Séff? case, the cirsgsmszaaceg 1'3'? ;zzrf2;'C;{x _:"-.._ ~. Ggpregsian may arise being go inﬁniéeiy' :za;fi;:;;::;ssé. ._'__L' 55:53" it 33 émgmggibie is dafiae €f'?:§f?'? Qrecisim The Cirgumstarmeg magi' ;§e.'_4';%§é;.f}7' --Q'a::

is warranz {he §f'If€f"@f?CE that ;*§f?e:=j'€..§:ra::z',bé<ék;,'° '* at 3533:, an unfair muss: _af p ::->ay1?§--rs 3{3:}f3}:: fmpairment of wr:f:*a'm€e ";<§{"~-the ' wﬁigh She compgnyﬁ affai;$V.52%éf2é:ig'g ce!é:§::£te~:§' as 0'i5§ingi:;fsf:;;§Qf_' -fm:-ix ;:z?é~§*e"«r:¢¥'si'§é;--?.:"fr2;é¥r:§ an we ﬁgs': of .52§_ -§;é;i:§'--"_::i:;:v;3:"e3§' an wme 533213 ____ _v;VOf"~ €J:Jfl<?f§&$é"§;' ' fha garage "a,§;:%_}*es1sS_i,?€¥!.',_:Q_ 'V'sQrs--'.2§"~«.§§:fi_' sf me mem:2e:§"

§;;g§é~;.<~;€S.§h5§: ::¢7nzj{:a$..;:a:??pfaia§Q' :3?" ".;<;f7{)§,:id 35 z;'§'2$ }'€2«.%.r§é:%§ §r3v0f_§?§eg §:'}' azigfbfe a'§par€:;;re fram ;'s::;"a::"ia'§ré':=: fag} éasigng, and as :z':'9§a*§s'o;: 0;'

- {:';:§;m'EZ'5r;:;r';5 sfvéﬁik giay 3;? Eﬁffféiff? mrergr gfzamw 'V =?:£?%:{f§:iC?g§§7.,E€§'§.fT§"{j$§S ms manay is 3 mmgagsvy £5 . "éf?§:?iLféC5' _:é'f$ 1';*';€§}'.,,§z',.i§, agara' fmm 35253;. 5% q:é:;;':-e5£":*fT£3%*";'v§'%' §§S€!?C€ 0:' maiagaf c::m2'}'::z'§;?::@ gar $8 A §ez*v}.:?,<a9?: ggrésergf gr $55":-*'v'«*3E§'§ {aw 3355 Q? s;:§<:§re- .,??§;%2%:§§rs_,. ﬁazvevgsy refezsagsf 50 3 szw';?a';°r§g :33 §éé=}7';=§ 35:3» 533% :35; Q'}'é'"€C§" {E563/§f§§rf §§ éfés *r2:,+:rz:£2§;¢ §:'§:2€*£§ 5;: $5236, E5 :3 {?;:?,§§'"ES$§e:'}§'? 9:"

91% W32...

same part 9:' the mare-«f:=afd@r$ by Sim masmar in wfzicf? me az'fe2;':"5 02' the mmgasy are being aosmzxczeﬁ ifiarz magi {ya averres' énﬁ gmveci'. fvfem I533 52' Cenfiafence gr pare aegdfaik ::f0§;::.. "~ mi came within 3223. If :5 ma:

£@r:2'3'a'@;?£e beéween s.%3are~ha!::;f€«:*§; gar' se'*« z§_§:'2a2:'ff~ brfngg 5.22:1? !;';£"9 way; beg: i§:":s%A»~ springing fram opgsressfm of :54 ,r33£r:§§riéf";<._.'b.}?"3" '"

majarity En £255 i'?"?3f?é,'¥g€f2"V¥:t'£'ff:'4€ afcQr:':gfa:%r2:§,..{'s:

affairs, arm' oggregsfon £'i?'i{{;i5?i5é'Of 32*-..§'€a~:;s§:': 52.5? H afemené 92' iagk sf graéééy :.,f3§}".dé'l§:=1{;";'é'g is a member i:2;a"??'ré:v V;?:"2§€T:.'ff;E.=:"g<:;f'}"2§§ igﬂ-9$§';2*:f5$:}:9ar;,r rfgfzfs as 5 g§23%Tré';%§'é?!;£§r-;:"/.__ " -j .... }}--'«5~3:$e ﬁ§5§z'?af!ﬁﬁ$§ frmn éfée fgur 5336?: rQfé}i?é.%';:;§' a;:?5g2;';x 55 :3, 39? 355:} wfzicféfsg as/m<;~3§";,}f}'~ff§e._:§a:':ée wara:.>';§ as 5, 22$ 92' 5&6 E:?g!}'§f??-':'::f§,' ;§;*?A{g'5_§';'*:g<;°*'»L'ga;é5*sz?i::;%:2 in each 533$ is a»%f57?§;$i;:'Eié?.¥" §"i?eV.'5::%r::"€§5$_§:5 G2' zzfm §ffa£r§ of 5 csmgaamr §f§§§:2§$j§:*§éy gf'2aref?$;'a's3r$ wa§ aggressive in '¥ff2é -- '§%:§;f¥<3§;§;zV j..s';"23re%3a!Q*'e:'§ gnﬁ fhgi ﬁegeﬂdg ";;g::A:? §}£§%::f§ j_f35iT§§ ;ﬁf"G%:'€§ 5:? 5 53;'/:::T<:°a.;f§:" gage, éﬁ ﬁgég a;'%je§3"g:}§r meg"; ;':*2d§:::"§ié3::', 5:" is mi eﬁaagf? {*3 .A$§?0;~v"£'?§§:" ifsére Es: géjgi' mg §§:;zi§§§i§ Cﬁéiféé' iii}:

v.2r:$'§.9§::3'f:?§ 53$ 55:35 :*Q;??;§a:;;r, égéoaggfg ;::~:§:~ mag: Em §§';m*m $3 grafiméaary :23 5&8 §;:z§§§afa§£a:; G'? g, WW N23,.

39?, it magi faszffaer be shown that {the aaaducf :12!' She majerfiy gfzarehafderg W355 0;3pre§s:':./9 mg m;'n0:*ify as' members and éfzaég re:;r:2:re3__:_?éa7'§.V'_~ evenés have m be corygietfared mg' 5?'? §s§ia;*;f§§?:._V};f3:;§{*_T."~ as 3 gar: sf 3 censecuiive $§Qr3¢;"'?'%2ere cmténuaus £555 an we grzsrflos' §%;5§j'§;9:i:'3? Sharehaiaierg, a:'$i?fir';:,:§;";g.* .;._zpm .€"g'2'é3 daze? geéftiaﬁ, sfzswing that the 3i'f§§s*$ of £"f?:2.¥c'{:z?:?pa §';;x were being canaiuciargf in 3 ma§%'g:ef'«;pprsés§v;z€{:5 SO{?'?€'3 garz" cf the ???:?f;'1be':f$. {_?f*2é'-.V{;'+:2A}'%':"f;;cf magi" be bz;.:rdensQrsfiz_e, ?}3ff:?.5?.' .;3W?Q"V._W,%${?§f{§?":V~--.3ﬂ'5 mere iack <33' {:0:I«§.('§;;?enc:£ m&ja:';'£y §;'.z§ra9§?:;a:fa,f€§:§.__V .' '-.s%3f§:;*éQ'§?;_"§;ziV_ ' sﬁaréhgféarg :zvs:;3Q'%___rz:;:;' '*:ii'$i§__ " the fack 9? ;:ar;;fEa'3n§§é 2'3'"§?'??.vv_<i3j;?;5*g"€SS§C>f? 9!' a minarifgz by §é_ ,.~m&r;&geme,r;Z" sf the 5om,@§é§';<_'§ :..%2'"2:'V:a;fi:$j,;_ szzzrrfz 9p§r@gs;'osf: magi is: sgxﬁélfvé @§ @3359 3:22 €§f€f?'§$§"§€' G?" fgak sf grabééy 0:" A fag} sifeéaffag éa §W}2"%e;'::ber in size zrsgéfar 02' ms; ' §:*e::;.7';2?¢%:::3?';;:<_'ﬁggtzhég 35' & gﬁarehaidgro 35° :3 in the ' r A}';;'g,f§fi€v'€}EC1'--§s%2§}§a§:£5V'§£'§f?Ci§§€§ ibai' we imze $9 i:a;:g:'a'er 533.5 fagéig. :1? Ems $335? :s2s;'§§'; refaararzgg ff} 3, 3§?1 ' _3XXxXxXX xxgxxxz .3€XKS{XX}€ aw' ' 2 's 3*"-'*-»-=«=~-;.

W34"

%% 26k ff 5:; fcrué fhaé by the b@gz'n:'::'n§ Sf T 2958 §'f?8F'€ were differencag bezweeg? if*2~[e'*- "- "

appeiianf arm' ffire Patnaik and £.3gars§€%f% a7'k?'»w»'_' groups arse' zﬁera was /ass cf «:a;':i??',$q?§r.:V;:':~.éA.T.::' .4 beéween them' Bug' mere io:s.§"'$c>;'.:j5{.:%1'?;§\é}}7Cé_ Qéeéwees? izivase gmzjps <3?" gharié s'§:%f§fc;fer;§T'~.m_,f{2:.}.{:f¢ V naé game w;'z*f:r:'r? 3,39? a;nT!e*s.§ iiée'Sh§s4»';7f 'i€f:a.f_"

zhis Iacé: sf ccnfiderzm S;3ré:;§*frem é:~.§és;?e 5:2pprés$ {Em nvinorizfy .53 :°f2g:":';:;=;§s'.3;§§;:r._2?@;3:'"é é'f'€°?:%é Camganyﬁ aﬁairs giéiz' ::$f?3i'-- .:>v$';*3: s;. 5535:" an eﬁezneni sf fg;:;'< sf p'm.§:}':;< g5*§3;:{ ;'55?;*.. is 3 meméar Kr; §iVi7'&>j.,gf§;*a§i"L%r .:;f--vf~§i3";:f;:2;§§:iat¢é%y righf a§ 1 i 3 §£::ar§~f:éz':ﬁ'£?§ ' %xxxxxxzi% §;e§§ian:e as pV:a:¥'mfa;a.;§f~:::e;sai:e fnQ'»:.;$Er:'§$ ffrzafsaj mm:

vs: igieegiie 5%;-rigsgirsées A"E\.?éi;éé*}';z" {frzdiag Maiaiﬁg £53', arm' '{':;.t§?@r;%L_j}:e§_'Q:r§§g' 32? %§§""§'§8§ .S'€ E298; wéxereén ii: wag §'";§§§ V33: §'{:%A%T§mz$':"'« '.4 ﬂ __ v_ réngfand affer ms ﬂacsgim <3? 52$ V Hgzggzée, as" iarﬁg 5:? f'v':'§;¢er {'i§5§} 2% Cam; {Z33 ' . ,2; {Hi} 3 r&§gfr:':"§@§' éniérgreiazisrr ﬁgs éearz "..§§é;?§;7 {G .<::2z§* 53;' 5% £3432": 5:?" zfaggggi :12"? }as":?';;:*;? :"§{:e*"&$;;' ?°:;s"k:;*§f': 335% 5155?, 315: 5'3 {E §ﬁé"°WH w.25__ 3 ,4}? ER 284': 42 C{'}f?"3;E? C55 9%? whim 573$ ﬁessn adyergeiy criticised by wz"'z'z"sr'5 an mmgany iaw {sea Pafmerﬁ C§mpan;z Law, 22"' _ __ Eaam, :1 5:3, paras, 5;*~»0e, 5?-422?, GQre ».. _ -._ ~.

Srawne gr; Cgmpamfes, 43'? Ec::'r3., para .22}. in fncifa, mfg :24:-5€rf.:"€s've G'é>ve!!a,9man'$:_:§?x§$*TV.:"

90 mace, far, in Sham; P;"a.§a{.>'~J§.§;?' mbes gm (2 Q65) 2 SCR 22:25 75231:, T;%:=,2"',z.§'5§"""~ 56 wag; 35; Camp fI?:3.s 3.525%V.:;55, %'35;?."

Wgnghaa J. acsegmd €??:?_: §?§"C}§C}!. gm.

irzferpwéatiesfs §:'ve;f:;._ ;:0a}fii%":Vg;}§<3'§>aer3 in "~%ﬁ.5:§%_?i;%{;5s5 gi rsferrﬁa' Ea ceréaéfgﬁ ﬁeﬁisizjggg %_;f3':r{é k cf the Engiigﬁ C€71.%??;3§§'§§EAf;i%,_..,»'3§,*E:VA:'.§%"I::§§§f{?§é{?;{}_ :°%i?e}«*ez' arm? 9bs@rve@' <'w55,>%: % kk j T % u"";?.';'§i:3~,=.~::@ §:;§;é(§f2»?,;'<§_':?Ea:? fram 55$ few" C€3S€$ ";.;£35f79:<{§5;? i"§;._3E:sV0v'e: §;:F,Q?}r' :0 geszfigrr .Z:'§? gigﬁ AV §f§..';3:'!f?'?0§:§: ;':;;'?: mg $§me 2/ararﬁg 33 geaéf-::2rs 'V = {L3-.§s': E:f§§'-.§n§!;'$fz Agi, gzzd 357:3 Qf.f€Si'fGf? in " '- :'=:$::E§ '§f§3géA';§%» avﬁeéher {he cmazscf sf 557$ gffaérg 5:5" é.::%§?§as*;:;x' by itiée m$j:3r§i:.; gfmrefyaiéers w§3::.V__A%3,§;;?re§.§§zx§ is 5525 minosﬁgr s°i7§:"ef2a£::fer5 A §'a'r;3§ 5%: dagezéﬁg as;§§;'z {E253 fggag ;§§'QEe":":'§ in 5 ',;:?;"§:"§:é;:s;f§:' £5:-::e, Ag £355 ggiregég ﬁg-2&5"; Eﬁﬁﬁcgésafj 2: £5 r2§£" ezsgsggf? is §§2s:ar' 375:5: §?'.f?£:'E°§"§ is gazgé gym' if"

....2g....

eggsifabfe causé far wskidfrzg up We Cemgjany, éﬁaugh aha: magi be Shawn 59 ;3ra.»".?ms"n§:"y 59 the apgsfécatsan 3? secfém 39?'. I5 mas: fgsrzher be shown fhaé' the Candzmf :32" the :'?'}8jOf{'£"_}v'» _:

gharefioidérs wag aggressive is the min6ri§;§""asé..' members am? 55223 reguiresg £1555" émenfs z'2a7:£:c:% be c:oz:sid&red as}: in fSO:'§f'iOf? {mi as a atonserrursve stew, ?"h€re mist ¢5c:>i"&2'f»€;92c.r'c§':;;':%"' "

actg an the par: @f 33376 ;?:af_jor;'€ly'.§fz3reh{:!:;:*':;§}'§, 1 Canifzming :23 is 321$ date"--v(§V}"",f3et!i9}"o:<?,_V::f2ﬁ;eiz}E:é'" ' ffmi" {he aﬁgirs ofAVV_£Vf:§§;V..Vc§i_§n,§3;'%y'ékaéévré being {iOf?Q'£;{;?€8&f.v n§%§ng?é%': {;;§}§:9&%3.sf z_/£5?' 69 game ﬁﬁff :35. '£;"%':3..__-V.._:*"}':;v=; 5%:j:3::§_:1:':;<:f mag: 5% b:;rG*ens:,3;fr%:e,1".;_:§2a}.s§_g'?= tizfwi' :'_§}§kr9f3g!fz;i arm' mere facéé T<V;>é"" = §:;3::f};§§.§Ee1r:::;e"~. _ §;r:~?:"wéér? 5&8 majmiéy S??§ §"€f§ ::>;_!c!€réV " ;*:r2s';:orr'§y sﬁarehefﬁerg w@:;ia7"L.{':€.§5j Vibe ;:.mi€s$ #29 555k 9%"

a}:3is'::':i;a'e:?§°a~s-» AAV}5},'s'§";r2g§':5 siren": spgregsian 9?' 3 "vL;?§'§z?.;:::*§z*;/Ab}! § s'%*:'§9jw!::.x érz {$26 managemarré sf ' . §3?fzTe''v.,4§§;?:g°3:&:ﬁ_y'§ affair; and 3523?'; ogsgregséen H ~. -;i;i:'a:;=51'z' '§;%:s%s,x<;s;5é2é ea? faagé' an éfémenz? Q2' fack Q?"

";':s"aé:_'§§':§:'-,«§::::' faér ﬁaaféng is g megméez" Em 552$ szwééér 9? 52,53 pmgrfefary ;":"gf7:"s* 35 as sf;3:"e?:§!s'e;: 2'5' 5% 33:2 5573 Eigféé" 3%' §"z"2§s@ g§*3§':':";*::"§§f§§? 55:35" 5-,r's;'§ Emzzs is 5335539? SEE E5555 ...... 35¢ :ﬁ;§§"f§ :"'8f§§'"@?'.%{,Z'€ 5:5: gaséiar? 3§7. m.2*;»_ Xxxxxxx"

R@%i'az":<:9 E5 Q§'aC€d Qﬁ Hamzman ﬁrasaaf' 3a;'§;é}':? ';r:g;';'~».4 Bagresg iieraazb P,L:"Q"., reparied in Affis 20$---j .E'C "

Wi?€*§"'€!?? if hag bees? 329% a5 Lszmfws "Se«:2;";'m 3§§?(2) 9f the ,.%5':'r:§ 1,§é_%°&i§Tsx;'é'é':"~i é'§%:«gt_ [A an arder wufa' be :?':c3*':%2'»:*¢"-~._;or: an ag,ai5{;.a%v;':%;',;r:e,, maﬁa ﬁnder gab secfian fLi";}_ %;f" gﬁe "cz:a:,_}}*£*':;'5 me Qginian (1; :~z:3:r._:,hs;':~é;:r,;:§gm;2A<s;A affaffs' are bemg condgzcfeaf 557:.=.€?2V$Vr2§;e;"""'g.%féj:;«§i£iai is gubiis s'r2afez*.?::»..§{tf~or::_;f:2 ﬁgiﬁregséve cf £5}! §?"§;£*§*?"§§;i7§§:..v-.f3§f {2} fﬁgé ma f52'£'i_'$m%»2f£§~§,f.3§ C21' a winding :19 arzﬁer :_:o[r;5§ :?'f3_§ :"_f23€W if was? just arm eq§J..€éa:£2fe :"f'§3§}:'V':f}:'[email protected]:c--;3§,;:5ny gimzgid $8 Wounﬁ asp, 35f;«::z*"(.§) f§?$'§._vvznﬁmg E.:',§ ::"3i"Q:E'i' waufd ¢§r3'f¢3§r§yV §;*ejz,:é'icé' tbs appiiwnég, fxfa Case v...g:a;#.'5%:3;**;<:..A Ea f:é:}?7@?V 23%;} mgﬁé {mi 522$: 552$ ' - ::"§s*';=<1i§;a:%%:*z";*.:%agffgésg arg ﬁemg €Qf?CfU{'féﬂ§ in 5 '--.s:=":§ %:;?::'e:*:**§<. ;f2;}éja;a'i<:i3f is ,9:2b{§:? irsiaregi $5" is? 5 "'--f?'3§.{"'§§'§€'f':"' §§§:"e§$:'::§ {if any me:':3b§r <3:

;??':e:s;%%§',r@r§. "E"f?eref::::"§,. arm 535% 5:3 Iggy 955;"

A ";::.:'sfer:€";§:? 3953:" 5a ifzsé gages?' {£235 £535 windérzg sf $.35' camggany mmga smfaérfy §r5j:;;::>'§§$ 553$ :?'2€;'?:f::2e:"§ $5 535 ::$f'3'}'§§2"?f;f' Wm .5?§%K€ siﬁa ~ .j'j -'«4_§:{.;».ééi%:ef':::;?§:eS3£§n €11!" mészrsanagemani) ._.'28....

grievance 35:52' am the apglzcarzis irefarg Em ctazgrz" and E735 affzerwise five fl3::TfS wogxia' ju$ésf;»"~._:

the makfrzg at' a winding up arder an_';"f?z$ '_~ graazﬁd that it was jzsgt" am?' egzsiéabia '% €C>f?'?,{}§f$'}»' shozgia' bg wouisi u;:;§,: "";';:.,ara9fér*}§'<.:':

§g,:C::es$faz! an éfns jgrsamzf, :hé*»..pe;':'z":<:>}?é%;<;y ég make 9:33 3 case fQr_4_w;'né*i:fz_§'* up ;*;:?'~ zrampany an jug: and equ£i"a§}'-E grGV§az;s<:;§$;~».T if facts fag'? gfmrz" of zf_!":f& Ca$e-----:§é'i*«_e3'a;:zf fa? ﬂwi:2;ff;';f?§ ug an jag: and eq'u:'{"é*b{fe'A._gr:;g::g%}:':;€:§» gfefief can ﬁe granted 30 zff?e z3§:€";'éi5;'§?.¢é{;~:f, ether hang' §f:e,;:3§j3if§«= régigééégé :'i§é""-§3ix£:2'¢{:%é§g up can <:f$ma;?;:§;§:2§?":f..,V aée' ;?§3£:§§es" jzjsé' sfsar aquiijgﬁlié,§'r;>?é_:§fi§!s' and gr; arder fag; W!n§}f:_§_..;g§;;°?3w.::$ggg--;%f§';€f ::_;,'r?}':;5E" and unfﬁslr iv ffseéém : . Sn ﬁne §§ViSf0§? Bench a,a<3mi'}*;:3;d' éhé: s3f3é€f$é;'" 5€fc>r$ ii, Vx;;xfX.x<xx"' ._ §eé'§'1y%V§f:§V.T':;'::sI:*é Ehese ﬁacégéaerza 5: ES ceniendéé ﬁg Etéée 3mé§E';:%§':%,.'_'%;%§*se"%€§""f:?z§ a€:%§ sf ihe a§g§§§a:"2%, %;xs'$:.s§§ mt amezm: iwmw m.2§m (3% {En tése éthay ham Sriﬁajjari ?cevaiah{.----.:he K ieameé Cazmgai aggearégég fer {ha reagsnéerﬁzg re! the jagdgment £5": *z;',S,;<r§shn§n arm' azhers V"---.4':§i?Ja:$§V " Hfghfesh Hgspiiaf reparfed is'? $2808;"§5ng,2'(:j£%;'7?;$v"':c:%§fi3.'L3;:; V {SC}, wiwareér": the Hen'bfe3 ﬁuﬁrame .{?7.:e:é':f_f "§éVeE&'£%_S' E¢,vEi::;z2%ﬁs}":.,:TAVi:VT'i "In 3 zwsrzber sfV}':§§:?ggne{§§s,.__ r;*z.;{g.5 V-.;:é'a%ft" csnséﬁezed in exﬁensg £"!?_c$?:V"':€§:3;3;€ <3?' ;éé§:§a;§s 39? and 398, ?"h:§f"f9iio_é£%i;3§§zL'j;g;;§j::.eer3ts §fb;}f@f be assefuffy réferred"f%G.;T" " V __ _.

(3; 4_;3k"e'3,€(;;'fe:'"}'%':'a$}§f;ffa;§.._V§'ﬁ??ds:;§§" gm. VA Needfe _§V£"§:Q'§aeV,§ }?§:9!a*§z?g 5331 (298.2): 3r;§:e§3§:e; Z' Z """ 75 1%.: _ jz'»<?$:'fh;:::s0é:Q:*fé3?§en V. Keraia Kavamuas v@,":5§;r;,, g"2§5%s$} 54:55 2&4 'A ={:.%f}» '5*;¥¢i!é'5§r;}§"--{;;é;;r§r2g:'9{2 frzvzi Rafa, an R ;9r5§ui'.23_;:2'3r: g'2é:"2§} 2 gm 2: 2.

{ff} A§§:;-g-ramsinh P,$§@!<z»zs§a' 22:

' = .. §§;:;%A;':§f,3§€;e1':>*£__;5,Ga8i<w5@' 529%; 2 3 555 3,24. VT"-§'<'as?2§i Kama: ﬁijfiﬁ 2»: §:;;;§;x ' ._f,%'e*i3€r$§£1f*?é$§;E"&i 5:51,. {;2§§é} 2 gm 533, L 'Fra;'2': :'f?& &§9:r§ i'§€€f§S§G§?, £5 5% 55%;' §:f"z§i" V' V. _ §;'J}ﬁa'"§§.§"§{}:'? a-ﬁzazzfa' 5% mgée 92%;' :»g/*«f~r~%A* A. ..3{}..., {3} where five sawdust is harsﬁ, égxrdengome aﬁd Wang {b} where 537% zjczrzdzjéé" is maia fide and :'5 far g mfiateraf purpsge where aftfiaugh z:7'7;e:~~."' zgiffmaie aﬁjectivé may be in the interest c>_f;'i%'f;n.=:..' mmpangx, éﬁe immadiaze pazrgese waufd s*é35':,;:?;i'f~. L" in an gdvantaga far SSITFE sf?a.;a*"f?:3§:fs{*;<; §»if;éT~'.§;-- V' V ' W5 the aa'i3e=z:§., {5} The 3:21.905? £53' gggaiéétv";:r"a.f2i;'i;.«"'v'M';3;*"f§. gem' Cmdzscf, V' __ {d} The §2;3;'3resgi1{€'--~-§.:_'£< €:::::sfr3,ai3§k?e0' .53? may be :'j's~;15;';r:: '§s--@rn:;_;"s§;§b-Qé fa bm? may ye? be sff%§;€§f:§;$,_ me $655 a5 fa whe_§f;§r"'~3§§' é§j::fi;9;? _§3v::b§s;::§§;§f§ii'e 05' rzzsf is rm: bazﬁed #2?"Tvjiz;ié?_gi'§?:Ver--,§f'~« Iegaffy germ:'s's:}§fe or rmfvx'-352258' permfssibfe, if zfiize §C{"f'Qi'?V «-:':SF v.a:9f:.erée*.fé;é::3._'.~"'againsé praﬁity, gaoa' ';c.§;35:?:g:fa;z:€ 0;*"g'5.._§5r§§}?s@me, ?§§i'§f'§ or wrang car is" f§§.d7:? [email protected] ?"oV}m;é& <:'s§fa:'@ras' gsjrgaése, 5: waufa' V 3;';?i?§§V:i€:f§E¢*.T§'£;..44Vi'"ai"If:viI§§3;§i'€§TSfQf'? unﬁer segfiﬁns 3??' gang' .' igfgg: ' . _ "gag" gage Csgxrgézjcé gs fezmaf iv 38 Ta§tp:fs~::§s*;§§:z§ maﬁa? ,§@<;"€:@:':;s: 3?? 3:25' 398, ifze ﬁiggrsiéamarfg ,§;:2z»»x:@;* gsvan is She C0:"2'2-*;:?3§?3w' :31:-2»? £at:5&.:::§ ;.;sm:'ar 3"§;:i"§Qf;§ 4&2 59 3&3 !'§§.;'f'?§} :'az;2€§':;x £3?' 3:25' 3;": and $5 £5,555? »?;*:?;§§"8§$§§{? :5; axes? wéﬁa. "Z"

__3j__,...

ff) As {Q what are facfs Wfiiﬁffi wczajfd give rise 59 gr 50533335939 {'3p;:}r€S$:'O{'? is ba?Sf€a!fy _ 3 r;;z..1esi;"9n 3?" fair: and, tfierefore, whether 3;: ' 35:' is O;:?ﬁf8SSiV€ 9;" mt f:;r20'amen§§ifyifba3i£5ff;x a €?££@S{":'Qf? :33' f3c::'l _ ' . V' X;<,><XX"' ._ Reiiamce Es Qiaced an MSBC R$:zji2:;é_'_'}¥§mé;r2g?:2 ;'. ':§§;<;g§'??.i.

C?za:?air3§f28£:'ha.r' iifgja :§i;:*z3rfef;:*Ni_?é «I',§;,éF'-.M2§58 ";5§':* 2:233, wheyeén the Herfbie Saspremeé:{j%,é':2'::t'VE":&~£ﬁ":%.§..§¢_5\§@ws:

"3e;~A::;¢;:s:;; 398 {as gm' x1'r;f;.>:?_?i:3 vsﬁés fer ﬁffng :22' 3;? '3;:'é,.:f:_;€i§:-'5;€*$i;::%§-:_V:'?rg}"'~._;;°§§;'%e§&;5:12 saga; af mis:3_§n&~g¢é:7A?é§if2§, ;§ﬂ%'.'é'.5{:"g_--«';{V::3£;}i':V:.'"féi§'§f.:;%.;'E"»Vtgﬁgfitjﬁ/}fDi'f:f;@$ far ifze pm/azarg 9;' 25926 {C2:>:f_é'2;:1;."e;';7;;--' '§::V;={w an an a;9§5.:'::"§Z";'m mas': u'§%::f'é§":'37ec£;i:3z:..' 3%?' as' 398 0?" ziﬂe A6:

£;:;"§;za?§é§"----§"f?1é ﬁawer fa §a$s any arder A"*;;:;*;;«a,{§:3"i;:%'g}é"fig; zhg purcfvase 9? ma sfmres §:"

vA§ijf';"7"'::3;2;r memﬁer 3% £258 sampgrzgx by A -.;@I}i":'2as"~§§?'§%.--:%éber {$3 fﬁgféﬁf 9;' by :58 a:@m§§n;x, __ '§rQ':':"'z§(r§fy, fﬁerefare, 35:: gr ssgse w??ere 5 '~ ,_;;:;'=$§ 9%" {3;§§i'€§S°§€}§? ?2§:; §.§@;§ mag? & gmgzrsﬁ fgr §"??ff;? ;3:,;:*g::<:;z§& {E5 :'::2:{'§£<;';:gs 552$ j:;?§:'~.:ﬁ§€§z"$;? $3" 5&3 My /3 /$1 3 ,,d9<\"*-"""' MW _€i;'7§"':«g€V"2?7IHjA:%"E_ﬁE§$ acig af {ﬁe a§§e%§an*: waaéié §@m§m§?:s*a%:a $15 ..,_32.,.

803m' in terms sf seérfions 3%? and EQ8 as' me Acz; 3 %}'ng2f;%?§ of fad" 5:: {hat effearé waulcf be neireggary is 53 arrivaaf 0:15, Barf, jurisdfcéign as' {he C§mpa;2;/ gaw Beam' :0i.-- g:é3s § ' 3rzy sther as" furthér arder Is? £f:r:;+;*=H;.$'2{"ere.*5't':3:*%::;?:é"'V: ' zigmgany, 2;' if {S as' {ﬁe Ggvinsﬁféi weuid wares? {he z'nZ"'ere.§i" of '::':;."2f{é:"€:;;{.:3{?"?{f;};:§.?';f;"};'A,'. -s"z_*. "

weaxid not be §ow&ries§. _j:;ri$§::5i:§ti«<>_{:T :::}'; Campany Law 893m' in ti%§3>*«:,::_re;g;arQ'.'ztniéxéé be firefd is be ex£si§§é§r._ fné:/i{_%g' :.;V'@§a:d zfe 'A555 afareméntiegfsaa' pre:ai;§§'{;;33; ._V ' Tfsé-.§.fe§§::§L*'!g:ci~%':_;rf;1r§gg;:;::§j:'f:§ ;€V;:'§éVV€:an§':,:£f£" $2' me bu$'£;j2€é3_§;»'A_ af i*E::--:._::f%:f;r;gﬁ1%';3*'r-2'y' 3:35 been rzﬁzficeﬁ !3;{'VEf?é "€,"T§9j2;?31;:>;3§%f:% Soéfﬁfég aiso me ﬁﬁgfz C@§;s;€." "f<a3é:g3';'§?§§L.:£;:. fﬁsé faci' {ﬁat Ezfmre are @;;§y':1%4ga+%$i?§%ré?:.§é:'§;¥é;ﬁ:;4'$%né 32.2% a':"re::f€:r5 arse' §:5§f§r:§e§sV.. A?ra§ki;?§" éfrggai" 5;? ébeir gersazmi VI':/.%:':€:%fg'::'§£'ifg;3¥;9:f;;DE&( tE;'5:"'V§3r??€, is'; Gigs' :::§f;?z'@sf:,,. waif €?a2s§'§":1fE?:§=ﬁe;*t smgacé 3;? me maiiar as' sgndaaf Sf {ﬁe iramgany,

-~xgz:xx"

T {$j:':'E*s is furihsr carzignﬁeé by im f"£*S$3(:%.%'§§@§'§§ ma? deaé Eeak m the company. The iaweiiaret hag faiied {Ci perférm hi3 iliéjtiﬁﬁ T.Z§W&¥'d§ the campiany. Ther@fGre{ §t '§.g_ ism majaréty hergén Em? ha$ becsme the <';§§res_sjé7§f"§%g;%V«-ii:i'j§'§:::_. _ _ ménérétgz.

Cd} Ta sazgspori hig aase, thé=.;j*e§{_3~a§if:d$m.:.':ié§'ie$'*;'§:p.§§':;; _ variaus mmmunécatieng in cfder '{z:1!V.:E"'i:3 s§:{3x;!~a,-i_va;_;ts_'§ef ogpressiea am mi3managemen't;"'~A._*£'§*':e :"e§;;':};a*§:iI@n£g wmie the feEE3wéng ¥&tt:e:'f v§§€ )53gfj{}ﬁé':~i§,£E.é_V ., "R5F.I:;zpz;;t25;?§gg>5*;2 §;f_7"

% % _% _ __ _Z'-3'51 _F§5Ré}ﬁ§?, :99?

;%;~,§;'_;§z< 'T Uffra fiimait V:§m£¥f?"' ' §e':jma§.*:r;¢"--" ' *££!i;<'«3f§f§"£%r"".Z;:*.Q'§&3?.i'§ image 522 {$3633 ﬁgs iaizar; "5:€;'":}3:;s._ éfeafslrrg with ::.:§a'raz'i;':'er"§ ;§:fc';L.:§$iz'iarré" 3:" 'S"a;bm@ whs fave 3 CGf§§§O§'3§!£%f} ..':Ha,%;<ii*z?;.,%;3,;:*:3 EQ'é;i;:~,<::¢*:?5 in fréﬁia. iff£";"3f"}"fi°«:E*r fndsé ' 52$" f§23C::.._ are mmgetmg dafigsx §§§;'rsSf @5355:

.. "5'€ji*3'<:%::'%,,"'q,«'é;: aaﬁxigsd by wag, we fzazsg 3 *i'_;%'§5?':*;!<'a§f§;';§::T"'ﬁfe 5;; WW: Friasfaér am! we have A E3599 §;L%}%§:'§r§g in graige 0?" Friggfair pf°ﬁ§i§€E°S ﬁufy "=E3s'gf:'i;g§j2§:§:'2g 2&3}; merség Q36?' .§§5:"$§ givers, ;!'xe13:2¥A«._i2§v§r}g aramg is ;'<r:§w $235 ;5§a?uéraa"= jg _ T éﬁéiﬁfff 55¢ iifiraﬁféer, ﬁacg ms: gasﬁsé an Uﬁﬁef ';5'-z._3:?a', fr; 552$ gamgg f'"§€$?€7§{?§€§Gf?§f§ yiagv, {ﬁe "-..%:;;:>a§f éazgsiryeggesz: 5:": Zrzaiia fag? g ;'?i'€3.r' 52:? :53 greﬁgiarg, 5% is Ssmméﬁg g:a:é:e;::*se§j;: €§s'ff§2:;;i.f £52 51% ::¢":§::s%e'§ ;}z'§:::@ is €353 Eféé caggésmers, Er? %§§%* ....,3é_m 5::7'a'z'z'ioz7; Friuiair is asfsa asking us what" mi! f'?ap;3E3!? new. Zffzey want fmmadéate arzgwer fram as and aim 31;' our Ci;}SZ"8:"77€f"S and I dos?» " _ biame fhém. Thig is :39? gang; impeding" A image and c:'§a:7':'bi;'z'ty bat also mgr ba1$;Tg';«iss5,A Zrhat ﬁg why I had {*9 5&5 the §'eaa'£/':38: _.%'?e5@_ a!s£3.1"* 4 have {ha pressure ﬂies: ready _a:r2.d__5he _'f7S£,§'$§;'.?§.§ _ V maﬁa fgr exgaré, Eariiarr 35;? :fh£_s 5:: 'Lr_e;$'50:'a,.::ezj,.__ 58558;" far 313' {sf us, i ~' L ir':s';'€f? regardg, Yazgrs sinzteréfgzg, KRES é<Zf\f_§"

{3} By a Ee:i:je"r,__éat§%iQ7 5'r"'E af:§"Z§'.§x 1V§§f§ v§de Amsexure $.33, the a@;Ese:§§E;:%figVw%§i'e_§'~':E'[€t:%érV'tcfgtfié regpanderzi, which in par': Es; ext:é:ii:«3.d_aaV£:.V§@§.E§v:$; _ . ._ " 2?"? Mgrcfz 2%?

E333; ;'%é?;".i<fr3f' * "

' X}?a';xf><X "~,¥z§..XX'3<_ ' V _ ' "«V.¢§<}x';'<;§:g_..~ 'fvff?r=€reby 5-'eg:,;€.§:" 3&3: ﬁfzraﬁiter fm'§§ ans? §*£*:;=»:,¥';*&. aafieawéde ggfeg 352$ service séaff ﬁe A ;'s'2§iz?si:}£§?@cf {:3 sasggorz" me effcéri Q? Pars raéfzer A '*~:'f§?§;? éfiiﬁf' Enéa c§m§8:"i§g'cm= $5'; frfﬁgg ﬁryergy }{X,3{X'X, «x<§.

1: .

...,35m f<f!}"?€E' gerganai regards Uffraﬁiéer gmﬁf:

Dirk Qgéfrangbgéri Gwen»? Chairman "'

(f) Ey a éétéer éateﬁ 2{§5m.E§ar5ﬁh :§%§?; 'y§§e= Annexure A513»; the aﬁﬁetéarst wrstie :;?:«ie:%f!§eA§'TV:w%§'§::_%'€ extracteﬁ a3 fcrééawg:

Dearﬁ@iK&ﬁ§g7V.7A€_" , 'W x}:_;<:x--,$< ' $237::1:';g;z:;g'a,}ﬁem.-.§:'a<.:;;,':xi;§t{:?a refafiaz? E5 Qniy SE23': 9? a mi::@§r':y 5:;fj;;::;;_;je':'":*<_>fﬁ@r, /vafhirzcz efﬁe ?2?z4e9::2fa%z%, if :'za.._".3greemen§ is f'€*§C??€C5 far ";;§fraﬁiée¥:'._»;r:2?;%f?" {"9 Enareage 555* ghara aagéégi .33 _§"E%, z2§é4;~§3§;f§::?;??e;2é"s* {F3855 be msjaaged - 'zf!.§:%a2::.§é~;'=:3f -« ggram' ﬁﬂﬁ ségrzeczi 'V V 1 _ ».,%é;s;..;:<f"

.;a:é:*,j%1s.,.:>eé'}<' " . 7;£<{z":"2:2' ;;3arsm§f reggzﬁs"

ifE§';'£2%'z'@;" gf"2'§§f*?'?

giiikét €11 é<:'a:?S§2€::i:

/<0' "'M'"'"'*-wmw.

N5 ...,36__ Swap Chas':~m§n "

{gj By a fetter daieé gm aprés :%g7, 's;'s'é. @ ;5\§"°'i§"¥€XiJ§"'€":"3a*15, 3&8 aapeﬁiant cnce again v€fQ§;é"'§:'é;}.. _§?é:5«":§__u fegganéaniz whiah in part is extracteci 33 f5i§c3w::.:V _:"~~.Vv V Sear Mr,§<:'§:';;' xxxxx V X}{'}€'.3$.'X E3-;%;é§{f1~~..V~>-3:' ~__¢2'i._i_'_3C'§;-"*'_8%'." 'e:;=_'r M :fG§€:"§€":':? £5253 §efz3vi::;grii_,a5»:»?_d :'?'?z,:{s;f'~V§rr$ks2:*V' mat yaw write is z}nf5:2z'm:{ "'?3Of}*}i;§?F;€5SC:i§ &r;z;?...i;r;" genera! E3 the market ﬁe'-:s;e_és%ia€;'::g~.cie§:*fy that She mmpgny ﬁaiiie 7': Vfffyvéi:-§.V:--Ve<--_.';£'}J£f.i"V'V"'$;/"'fE'i.'T',"§' exafasﬁive importéng dgstriigaséar 25:3; 'ﬁévbrcg '::*'r3;«*es*s aria' neg" uE:raf;i!:"€r £;'zQ'ia,J*._ I AV E'-"g,:s"a":"2£;=:<s";>f;V_9z"e;,.. E insigé ézfmé yea: Sim; . "~--::*'0:"2%f§;:>ie§";3::§= agas':*?§{° F553 wiff; fridge ﬁryars as 51:? _€r;.<3: c;:3.s3»é":::f' Qsjaraz Gfass, in 533$ respeaa. 2' a%§:::§"».;f§f'é;=T._i*g2 my ,§f"€S/EQUS fgééers: gen? €55 was . '-W55': :*g:2;t§§é.~",§3":"@ as'! mam' f?'3€:"?',3§€f'S arm' gar Sega' A ...4<:as3s;;:§i§-sgf.

" _ _ 3 XXXXX Ygaxrg girsaerefy, lMl|k3--?naa uffraﬁfter gmzbf?

Eiiréz S. Kransbeiﬂ, Swag} Chairman "' {E1} E3: 5 Eetter éatectf Zﬂfb' '"€}'<,:1::3h£2§° Vﬁsiﬁg A;"sr°:e><ure~;&,.1?E, {Em ap§3eEEa;z: wr@.§%ie '--- a§ iafttv-é '%'~..i:c ressenéeaé, wfzich in par: Es ext?-za; C'é3é as: f»::55c-x:::Tsf;: V' 'iﬁctsbéf 'z9§;>7 Sear Mr. Ki???

X;*{XXX« H V _ ._ ><{¥%'*x?,s<':«:.,V ' " '

---- ﬁr: _ s;»*:"$w"' érgf? . me 8f§;"f€'SE§§;f§ ierminaficn Wé re(;_:;@sz?_ ;;k:;'=':; _;'0V.&3§péi:{g'_§fw_ 5 ﬂew iﬁenééiy aim' sazrfzpangx xr;3.&:réa V.é;*:_Vé'§e:.r" pf ":;;'traf§fiar (zrscféaj ﬁrivaztss i,€mE€:~3Q""?.;3-r _fE*:.é:'ai%ée3é' 5y :5' §6C8f'?'?b§f, § §9§8. V. - 1 V ' sexxxx U L ' .¥}<C{,¥X ' v..V"'«§~;!§3v§;:*gv~* f'?€i"€§»w}£"s'? S§i:"€£"§iI§ mgr éﬁfife ?§VaLigin?e::';é;--- géﬁa' cafiaéaraiém reiatéagig we :»=.s£§i 'ﬁ_€iI'$;"f'57?§:?E§S maéntais? aw ghare in 532$ . $a§:?g;.3;;y 51%;? aféer 5:' maggg :23 §§ cgifed AA ;:;!§"§2§;=.f}?€§:' {fs"m?i&} ?;';"v§i"§ ismfiéai ,£§ § 3??2§refm££§r' $3' iiﬁgé" :°$:?":;::§:?y we as??? :i"£?z'§i"§§'?§;,i€* fa $X€f'f§§€ mg? {IG:'?i'§'r:)5 am §"'f§??€S §S 535$ ﬁmwz ifza §€'"§,'§£§€§ sf §5§a§;°§é§a;'.s 5:33' §~w"

-33."

V % gaff:/efgx pariicigafe 5;? the ﬁirecforg' 803:3' Mﬁatirrg.

xxxxx Yaazrs siﬁaerefyf uférsfffier gmbi:

§ir§< G,f<m:1sbai;'3, GFQUQ zjhairmarz "' (9 By tag :emg: §aa§§i:§" :&gg~3§98, wde Arznexure §ag22{, '5'Z§i§':_€.5.?:. §E;3:}§.3--'-:€§§€4$F"}V;§;:Z §4s3rﬁj£t§é"'i--:>..~f§;¥"2€ resgonésntg which in par? is éktraa:E:"?d._é§]' f:;{§'n"m%:$

- V ":9"? May, 29% " Vv§E?§f'2*'f{'Q§{§:?§ "><§::~§¥:

A ﬁayiffzg ;§';§E§ :'f?;'$, was (:53? be? Siifé? 55755 5 _;gw'ifV :ee;<;::&s§:_£s'sh we w'::ra2";'Sz"er grgsarzatg is'? znasa 83-35 ;;?a%:;.., I??? whatever eﬁari ﬁnd mg: 35 A =s%::'?§;r';':§z:?:§<é;T;; ififg mi! egfarisfigir 3 Simng :;§:":"af?£§@r »._;'z'3§a§i:% §'§§'..-Germgaywposgééam E5': Eridss, " 3 ':"::sz,:rs sfréssrefgz éiféargfﬁfégr gmﬁg":

535515;: R Krgagﬁgén W39."

Qfﬁiiﬁ Cha;'rm&n. "

if} Thé r&$§@nder2t wrste a ieétter as 2§.§9.l%"9§, wide A:"znexe;:*e»R3, which in part is; €}€§§'&C'{8§ &$ f0 £E.«:;'€1'>»}é;-- i'- 2.


"Z6" Sej&tembe;5}'__f998V.:  H
ﬁear i*«?r,,f<'rar?53ei:?;  ._ "    4'

XXXXX

"?"f;er8§§x we _s§res?g!_y__ f'r.<3,_e:'..£ff?a:" mag' haw ferfeéted $58 rig???" e;~.r.;f".*<;fe::" the érgféemanav "bétf: in terms 39:1? Spiriffw'cz;>f;_ifin%.;g::? a"sLja$f:zareh$ider of the Ccmﬁany yea: -l.»"z;a-.:f)z'1"z:e g::gizi<:':f3 5:32' either being 5 c:c>:¢7;::2eti£;"r.."52*"«;'3s%" a*.s'f2aréhQ;§dré3r, Yaw Chaose §a:;"~bé« a=:_sfz_aira:%fm!dfe:§"-..;3fr2§f merﬁfore £fSi'§f§'¥!'S€3:if».;":*:"§f__2ffQ*5€"E§ 5?' ::c2;_:=2r:,;j:»€€:'£is;%;' ﬂaw was be we €.if«2£<e.ré' we ' §'7f}.£}§t'3:"(}f '£?:s3£:':g-,3 Vmmpeiiéar gm? a"ffza_:"¢Vf:::*z::tV hafasfg {?O__f"§§}'_f?'{" ie:::>___;:38 gfwarefmider, Es'? éziffs §§i:;§€:£0m,'i"f w9_ 'agié £ef:'":%éz't!? {:9 aiterrsativa $53: €@':23!!'E;;a_Q';: gaff the mares 59 us, wf3;i--:::f"; we 35?' é;vfi!:;¢zgT"-:9,--g:,:rc:f§a5e at 3 vaiuwa is be {f€£€@rm;'i'2eQ*::r:éf9r ;5§f"i"§C;'€ 20(9) $2' me {3sf_'i'5C§8$"' 97:' . gfi5sc'»:i5Tf,E'm, Immediafeiy mam __§_f%@a»:.<§:?g }%:::m yaw, W3 3.523;? EECELIEES ear ,%%as,;:-'*'f§<T;rg, !¥?j§';2m"arna§f2 Kamafh am? Cazzzgmrsy , 5:'; :§$::;e}r'.r2i2s':2e we face zxaiaze av' {he ghgrés 59 ':~%:_av:¢:;:¢=' .feé:f%?3iié§@s gar; be mmﬁséeaﬂ . . -- ' 'éggilrg :§§3"?€€f@§}»' ':""'a{ i_,f§€r§fi§i"er {fﬁdféf} gﬁvé, ifai, ;<.§<'.£<;'m", éffzzaérmgr: & fvfamgsmg Sireaiarﬁ "

<fi fé:"""~ ".43,"

{R} "Wag apgeiiam: En repiy ti.) the resgaanderzt wmte a fetter ciaiaé §9.§§.::§§8 zzéée sfmnemre R4, which 23 extracted as: faﬁimarg:

"gm Qcffjaéer .Z.§,3~9;é§' L- "

gear ;vm<':n; " " ' "We have received '§e*«::g:V:;r;% Zeiéef ,_da§é$:f ' Segiember ma' v-maid !i_§§__e"-.53-..;;::air:§ ~»:3;zz' rim falfawing e5sen££as"';:p_§nts'.* ' ' 1, Lfftraﬁfter grmfzrfé f'2as' '-- 5:05" *__s:a:'d 0;"

asgignéd any sf3ai..r*ev.c:>f~ mfffﬁﬁfiéf "§'*3fr':ia'!a,1 gvf Kid, {ﬁim {:':;:'i.g'?'?S&n§y) frgzzfarsy"~:i;>r;*2§é:z:'i£*sr G2' the {Z'Gf'?'?§3??.%'°§., . ' 2?". :7'7;*'£..?e;*<.<* '=s'S"5s<:€3 rﬁﬁtriirzfon Est: gm' sC5{1%C9£!??:'€:{fV§i" Q: §r:Q=re7e-meni' fé;«3':rEcti;?§ the right 5?' g:;§2:'ra.f;?'f@s*'§mb?;,ie";4.,{.'§;;'y.a;? £55? réarmai business ;:3cE";?;:a'i;:gF :~_'s§3£§=;§. :'>f_%;€"3 "g3am's $0 C£,!SfGi":"?€f'S in fr2Q"ia:._ . "

43 . 3, ._{Lf§i"r5ﬁffe;* gmiﬁﬁ 523$ nai gnfereﬁ '?§mf'a, any r§a.m._s{::;vmg>ei@ agreemeni with $359 _ =r:C»%r$g?3;:;;' arm' ES Eeggfiy erééféfea' {fa cramgeie " -..v¢;'%f;'~%E;«e "<;?:3;z'3p3:'2:¢., A' ghgrafiafﬁar ms: Eawfzzﬁx .. sfe%;a2'*:%;:§;e*£"§f'?~.::;4.%§%: {"1'?tEE' bassgnws 9:' {£26 {1°§}:".?"E;'3*§f?§z' :32' "Vms?§§:*;'?--"Ljf_2§'TI=i3 3 gﬁgrsﬁgiﬁsr i£f?§€S:~$ 529 ha argréeﬁ 529;? 5:? éfa ga.

x T .. :3, ?'"i7e :?"2§:'§< "Uif?R,é%§"fi?"ER" Es éﬁe"

«,§a§§ aad excfassfzxa §f§;3€£"€}f 53%" éﬁiérgzﬁimr gmﬁfm _§7§%@ féaanse graraieﬁ ta fiifﬁ Cﬂmﬁﬁﬂy E9 ass iisé :"z'§§§sm§.r§: "i?i?f1iéF§i?E§" $325 $323 z§*?§::i< "£f:.§?"§;;*%F'§L?§§" gg ﬁr: 52%" ms §:'9s?.?g§:?y"§ 2, g 33:

mgid c@r;::'3.ra2fe name 53$ been iawfufiy fermiaafeﬁ and $u«::f; Eerzyvinaizbr: wiif haiva effect an Qecembsr E 998, E. éfitraffiier gmbh ﬁgs rim" £'@mn"z'f;§f€,;3*'T:VV: "

33:32' breach 3;' the bgsia §:"aifa§§:::fa}:j§£J;?*'~..V4 agreemenzx 4%, ijffraﬁffer gmbh 553$ §§é2;<;f::3e?f:v«.

auty 59 me campany .3m,«::7' fygsf :x;':;*!_ai<9d ::n:;s"*s;;:%i;'f:. a'£..:€;/..

3?', ;'v?::Kr0nsbef{; f2§35:.:":2r;5z véafgieﬁ azéjg ffﬂbaiiary ﬁafy' tfmz: i?e.~':'r;.»'3f_;.r- J'?§ v'e 52:1:-A ffze ::9r2':28ar2:«'~ X 5 .. V.

3. 5,/Ezra 2"i{t"e:f_ _grz'2zZ3£7 .§'2a;%3?'= ,r§«:f;i*i_~.Tf*o1;*:'@§feo' any rigffgé" fa: Car:t!:ir'L:e $033 "aL":~;j7a'ra:f?aider and §"§£?€§'€'3c"Qf€'5_;5'?§f:{~--ff.G Qéfigatian ':i'::;_ §e%'i§---§.f5 gfmrag £0 f»f:.§{s:3g:5:' §;:f;@;;:;:§.';'-§%# .$f§;.é;-%:~:%§"3g:é'f§%:3%:*: H »;f%rt§z:fe iﬁfg} fvag no: apgiigafiéﬁ ,E":3A. 'Z*f?1_e"'vf";i":?Ci;':5 cf 537$ greseni C358,... .. --» V #39; . '5;5§i'¥fa52'?.Z£"§é*a7_Q;":?'?ﬁ:'7 fave every right to age me'-irade ';?3f;<%?§--~._'f£}»£.?RAF{LTER" 3:? any' sari"

$3' a":'2é"y¥:;r§a"'i;3c§:;:ié;§§; Ermiia. "fhe Ckgmpam/'s fémiéeé §e;';;r;'is.<;§':2:'; {U we the fﬂafk ,"§%_{,!:jf"§,£FI£f;*:ER" as gas: of £59 cargarsée :"'?§§'E'E@ . "._,§V£iz5§'--g§'~.§ €raG'é§r?'§ar ﬁgs $593 §€:"m:":25§"§::f grzd Sé;{:§?v..i'§§'i??i'§?§€f{§i? wéii fmare effgcz' as G?' 'E V _ §}::1;f%:§:?:%s':_:'§%§8;.

. i<;;f§g:»§é§ng fmwarzj' iv ;"'}'?€8E7 mag and gig' SE33 ':?%em§&r;<.; an 385* siéaffafﬁer 98, 3&3? $5:

uiimzﬁféer {f;'za';'3} 9:25: 5:3'.

Séf,/' Sirk SE §<r::-;:r§;g_i%5:':

M£642é& Gmup Chairman" "' {i} A reading cf the abmze cz3mmu:2icat&'@:'25f%;2».;€§£;:.E§'. ziiearﬁg disdase Em manna? in whim ihe §artieS ﬁfe V' with me am anatﬁer, ﬂy virtue sf:t?2*s=_§e?;£1ér$:'WE§i:.fté¥':.'_'{%y the E'€$§}%§"1ﬁ£=3E'Et, it emergas as faliemfxﬁé: ' } a': "mat the ap§e§Ean':._{ﬁa..s: béceygie é -V;:i::sif%':'g:»':;§i::*ier and ihere€0Ee*'*--i;§7&s:A :*§z:.; §%":a:'e§2o§6er; 5} "Phat 'then aQ.;:"e2"% E.:a§j'2:2"V'»*»{%S_'ﬁre S855 their

3.§E'1;.a§g--.-Zgg isjf;it',i:' ' 2 """ .-';CH'_'%_3*V¥":":'§"sgéiét§0E1 with 93:3 .§;?qAe¥g§'L§i2=':»af:§:%_Ei§*t :»§"'2%%_':':r:?s;2{>'ndant is unabée Ea arsgwer cugmmerss anﬁ herzm, {$29 ' ' Ci3f"§"EVf}¢73;.2§i§:%§»*%'§?E» Eiagérsg §£:$ €§"e<i§bE%éi*=;;.

« E-*:'%:e "E5-::E€:e:*§ :%;é%§*t:er: by 'aha gpggﬁéami, $23 $2}??? azzé 95:;§:sg:§h;:ié'»-:}f"§?m3_§§m& wmsiﬁ ée as f£:§§GW$:

.~ tiéa yesgaszﬁent ghauéd gugmri {ha " ﬁggémgg Q? Pam §§U§§§'§E§f"§i §"§i§'§€§" Sham %?"%E€E"

é{s§:<:; § :é&?::§e3~€;é£:E:;;': wéih 2:; /5 ~*§% é} 8} ?} ,...§3M, That an agreement mg is: be yeacﬁeé.-.___tQ érzcrease the a§9@!§ar:€:'5 ghare capiitai 1:0 "Wat the mmgany ﬁace Equipmant.-'$57 and excézssive i§'rzp:3:'§Eng.:<::'*ési:r§§u.ft@r %*c::*I,'Sé'3.2:Eg5.e dryars and rm: the :espo:':2c£é».€§€"t<3:*§"§*;':§'r':3}f; _ 'Thai the re$mndVé.{f:Qi"~V..$E"zQs.§§"aj__Q;Q§~V_Cii_§é*%';;':£;>L'§ng against i3'ace,_ mat the mggén¢m%:%é~¢::n§'a:§;<%:sm.;:d estabéish a nev§; §CE.§3_EEti'§'§?; V "Ej.E'z';=3s'¥;f'..,e*§¥°€é:s=,*--*:1--_V éE*;@}_a§_§7%=z._%;"¢E*:'é5§;j3z§g_%:*ae§3 wéaiéeréghig ES :§e§;:>e"3%§5;::;:_.VEhe:~"§.' '--._a'pi§&-E--!.an:5 weuid C{}E"3'E§ﬁLE€ is ei><&rc'é?s?éé%'-»..L4§%t;é "':i§_§"%*:é:§' in the éfirecterg bwré 'V%'::%.éFa'£f§:":g; ' V 'ﬁhaiﬂ%§E'2V+.=3,Va_Q;3a5§a:"si: wéﬁ magtabéésh 329 u§:;*af%%:er' >r§*§a__nC& in Enéia a? what aims' effsrt ané 585: taka am 'ma: they wéié egtabﬁsh 5:

éiégyzg uéirafééte-r {ééﬁﬁé in Germany-wp$$ét§@r: in Emééag ._._g;g;..,_ hf; That there are ac} resﬁrictéens in any ﬂ{}CE.é{Y7i--E¥'%{ 3:" agmement regtraisziag thg yighéz agpeiiani :0 carry an Etg nermaifr'b:.sSV§::*:;:§§:::..V_"'_'T V' in-aéudmg saieg cs? E23 gas-3&$'-tn' it}; c::2S:f:<:§.:i:*2éé*§5é.»r1 Enééag :} mat the a$De!isf;:--f:'~i$ §Aé9t'3§EV--._ §:;:€:é-%§§é'd"Vite co;**{:;3et@m«:é:h--.§§1&r:§n1%§§:ny'j'~-»__ .' 3?) That the a;;§a§;':e _§.¥a§':i_V.i:'~§;j:a%: é§j:g;";: :."fiéuc:a:'y duty {QW;;§$.gh@ {my} ,,,, it séearéy emerges 1:13? ihéifé "LS "the agpeiéant to acquérﬁ majerésy shV§:f§s.,aré'd_ "E{'%_ "au{:%'x:e at a CGﬂi§"'$E§E§'§§ §GSEE§QF§ in

--.€;he Q§'E'a.,':_?f:§,r@f;;§a§ by $18 regggrzéeni, ihe '._;a;:2§1e--EE_V;f:rn:_E*z3§.,_%§*;;f_eEa*l:&n@é m ma:*%<@€: €:%";@§:°' mm §:'eéL2::i:$ in Em}-EAa:"s2i: "Ea§33.;§'--§'€Vf'%;?;23f effarf $35 {$35 3:" 5273;; €5§<":3"1 T"E"2a% {ha js"§s_Qs§:%%,:%.;@%":.e':; $955 $6 ray an am aggréaiiaﬁt fa? the S?LE£€;§SS 9? ::;~;?;3é 't::€;§';":§%ni;. 52;': {Em ether Eéanéf the mgeﬁéant having

-.T.az:.*{;;:z;§:*éé ggéme ﬁfﬁ insiuigéng §§§*;:§§i:§tEar: wéiéz me »<M.,..

mmgarng. Emh pastieg have maﬁa aiiegatiasrzs agaéngi: each ather that {hey are manufacturing féiterg in cemgetétéen wétéz fang camgamz, {:2} The ameééaat having: acquired $§§.€§:;'8 are Enduigmg £21 camgetmg busé;:e$S~»»w_ét?2 :%'§é 'C';:%'jrn§'2:;ri_y, The mmgany ﬁg thereferé fa<:e'§ ":;2,V}'Vi:*;:%':. a V\:é't'§f&i?:V:;CV§s*";"*s;jigetEtiQs*: with Pace Equégﬁmerstf §hf:a:"2 the cempany having Seen ta§§;e*;V{§'_ax:<;é§§VA»§y "*::'§<:VVi5e"»éi;';-§;%"e§£a:':t, It $3 {wt just 3 the §%E'"f3Q&_f"§'§,='.

What is ex? §% eaEt§":y mmgetitésa, but 3 §{.":'%::}V§':';5¥"'%E:)a§.3S)"J; whéch $5 fuéiy 3::p§ar':edvv ':§y:' ';:?§e The ameiiani being a sézareheégiez' @?"i.§f§§'~<:vérﬁ';aa:5éy cams? Eézerefsre inéziége én Edeéébe:2§%€?--."L;%£E:;& cs? £%E'%é'§7s$é@n GE" Carnméggéen against me :i':;r.:f:é§'§;_a§*:':z agmeféarst tharefera has §3§§%i'i'd in §'tS d:.s§§é§..4_i§%g=:;;«:a:*§§E'..--{ﬁe wmgagzy, ""§"%2&:'e £233 beer: an aeciéazef

-e._ 35e:3.,E%be:5%'s'::, ;A«=§3:*:é zéagéégéni: am by the agpeéézarzé tswxasﬁs the '-.:3<§%f;§~;:_§'§§4;'%;. Tém %§':§$%'§§§ (2% éihé wgeiiané S§'§€3é§§é be gnéy h"--.}§:é2za.:w:»%§;'ﬁ§ 32$ asmﬁaség am §'%QE"":§ gigs; $3: §'}@§E"§§ e %§g;J.m..,.%..A .X' ~,:_%:e ;§<:§--._§@1{%'Q§ .;a;_§_g€:-ééafif: E3 harsh ané bazgdéngame. "'.§""§~*';e:::'*'z--~:'*€Q:"«:?%V,_§'ai:$'é*§ve;':a gresgure was bang §><&ri&ﬁ by the éféan .4 ic*§ "'§;:gr§:é£%: the %§2:§§*&5'{s G? ihﬁ <:§m§a§":'y', Yhg 'é'.«§s"é§'%a:Eee7%" Sfﬁééfﬁéifﬁ b%§§2§ maﬁa $3,! the awaéiasz Es; M46."

$harehe!éer :3? the cemgamy, the apgeiiaat canr2et ~'-agct agaéngt its interest. .' {9} "'§'he cemmunicatmns also ma/ea: .ltéiai:=_'j':._hjef--.____"'_ ameiiarst wag §§'"€S§EJE'éziE'Eg the reggkétagdent E-he '4 effsiri af the aampetétere, wéwiah camﬁxietétlari:'2«;éas f$aE<€3%é"

by the aggeéiant, It £3 thereferegvédéfrgic'ééﬁai =;5%f;F?eeA.:j:v.f:v§}§$;u_:§hV% ihe apgeiiani wag a shasééé' 'E;r_;*>'%§5'£:%;f.i:'éVsf; géﬁit-ggaay, Er: View at" the fact ihaé %:a;'§:éfj éaterest were amy tawarﬁg Eeimg §§§§ by I ﬁace Eqazé-;*;:<:"=;as-:'éféA'it:;V'.' é*M.;%.sA..3gp;3eE%a:zt $5; $0 ensure its awn __'E§u§§ment ratéiar {ham Em?

:3?' the can'2§VffaL:§§é,., %é1}e:;jée:_,"e::§'..'L't%:e faaé 0? it, it is evédeszi thai:

a§;;e§§--;%1:'§=a;i"_f§r;g';%a§§:{& the azccesg af EES. asmpgéééar raihér ya M43...

iherafcre hard and buréeﬁsame, §-ientef the amen sf tiws aggeitani ég a dear Qasa Q? gpgsregsémn, {gs} NE ﬁnesse facts and cirmmstances Eeaé. i:3 "t.§'é'evV cewaéugéésrz {hat aii is :29: Wei! with the cemganygraé ~ share heidars. In xzéew of Eh?.§i"€'$€§'§?: éi'€{}'é.ﬁ§.d'?;'f' §§"§en. V asmwsséy Canngi bg run effectivéiy.1__ *"{héi~_ :2 _ '€.1a 5s§g=..,,,<§f'1f.: oppregsign Exes; been ﬁéa. de 9;}: :«'~;Vfr:é_:'*--:". es',p0:':'§é1eVAs*§t. The aggeééant ever: i§'f':,§}L!g§'3 bVe;_§ﬁ_g_ §'; rr§»&n»i:;*.;i:§z'p~:'._'§E€~3re heiderg is £QE"§%C&¥"§"E§ w%t§"2i a Ezéfg. :;:;@z%':«fe*%' éri' .;_a§§'§--V"iE"-Ea: mam meetéagg. i2é:';i:._ 'iézés ;c'j%;:.:s:"h:'":"é";Ve%'§ce§ mraé cammtéiim Mmitteééy {$153 ';.'--"2 §';*;»'r,f';':e1 §u$%:2e<3;§ §_ér_é5Ci5E'%g.--: §'¥%i:§'iEf%€€T§§\;' égaéngt, we atismgaray by manu?aCt3;.af§%§g; --j.:*f§2a:_é4'$»<4é?z'§«:'t"g me very gams pmdazeisg "'£"%*':e ;j:§>g:e;§§aa'1:%: ms' "1e§;é=r2E:} tixreatenad that E2'; 2;-mgsié start é*:":.a'::"s":;::fa§?%ifz;2/"éV%s:3_ " 'éjiirafifmr madé 5:: Ggrmany' pméucés 5:: Erpiiar ;3Ts':»~.:;%*§x;'2;Végi"<=§é.»*,£:%;* e,2'f&;'€ gag' 50st 5:" may éake", "§"hEr§ ﬁg as §as$«i.b§§%%;~=§' :*.§§~V":he mmgamg ééeing mrz nmmaiéyy effectéveiy '"-. €3;'"Tp:'$'§€--ic'a§E2g iﬁfiﬁéf' Eééé given girmzmgiagzaeg. '§"%"z:§ . 'sfeargjaéééent aiiegeé ma? ihg ameziaﬁt ES :a:*:*g:%:"2§ GE? 5 ma? m.:u:§§%:':e$$ an fag ﬁx?-5?': aséé ma ezxm aggééeé fag' iﬁééﬁﬁfﬁ Qéﬁmw 233% _..,43....

where 'Km Canmany has aim agpiieai far me game, Tm: apgeiiarii aﬁméts m such 3 aourga GE' aatém and em§3has%ze§ that were is: as bar ta dc 35:55': a bus§:":e$s:;"'ETn the icétamiy 0? the circa;m$tanc:e§ of the cage, a maﬁa out far winding asg $2' the companyHgfis-..:}u§:V.é:€d' aqagitabée §§"OL§§""§§S. Hawever, '£58 wir:e_:i§ag-::2--§"s:)f._f§"::'e Campany weuéé be prejudicéai. and E'1é€=:--;e it :§:«:>_§L:s't neceasary m the given c% §'c'u;.m-s:':,*.a§i§:as':c?§_éciﬁe gage ta éérect 'she mingrity S§"33E'T:£=§: i"iv€',i_§é€:§_'"AVV';£i§SéE§ {SE18 majaréty. {Q} ?%'é§sV.--a§ready énétéamé OS S4X:@9§"5éf:.:«:té:ii:héu:€;;§t:i :;T.i}§;-E? }a§é_"Eg"§;'V48angaE@re with regarﬁ :9 the uéé Q3'? theVfzéégéévsi§ﬁ'a§§é'...a§a§n§i {ha mggenaent and tha mi: és"3tEE'§ g'es:"25§-¥_ng~;"»LVfherafemg 3Cms*§§§":g is the «3_§§€:"¥i.E:7'«3~n%:;A,iiéyg rea§'::i§*-::--;*;:;,:E& éa wiih regaré is {he 33% 9% {he 'é"s'i%3;*.E§"§§§§§ﬁ3f5§Ee§*' $3; {he ?$S§Q¥"?;€§@i':E, J .__§e"": ,.§_"5§*;--e?re ﬁg an aﬁggéuéa ﬁégtmsgé: batwegn tha

-'~___g:2.as*'":§e§;' ,__'A'%"i*h§ aggeéfarzi Ea érzﬁuéging ﬁg': aiéraci CG§"f'E;§§€"§1§'?§i3é'§ VA tﬁe Csmgarzgx, Tifﬁ aggaééarzi Ewaggr :h§e§%§:":e§ ,3 g_%:,»~»*~M--<»-A...

._.,4§..,..

wéthdrawaig am canceiiatimg 0? the agreﬁments' "-'libs agpeéiant is manufacturing ané setting we gama {hat are bang manufactured am mid by "

which is therefgre am/erge 1:3 V:*:-ézé"-ini:€_4re§§?$ l€;§fVV'Eﬁe zespanﬁezstﬂ Admittaaééy {here alfeg §§:%iTy [T"%:véA;§'<;-..,V sharehaiciers and bath iwave };o5é>:*::t::L:'L:'s'z*.2__ ar'2a §e:f:fae':r';fﬁ:'%_:§§:é%rr'e's"j0f the articles. Even 'a§*2Ga;g;,.?§zi:he gt-,*s--§;*V35%é,='§Ea'r's*tL'.%'so§:dTg"Q;-Esﬁzéaﬁef the ghares, E": has been C0r1ff4'7<£:-r::f.<;'3'c:E"' psweg" in the baaré meetérgggi p§{}..<,eto maan, that urztéé am VV§§"V§e§é§éa:n aauiﬁ bé taken by,t--§'*;--e he §§ a magforéty, "Pisa aQp€3iian:€'v--.§13§ '3ié'ée mam meeting feaabimg it :3 :3s:z.§'€:§é"t&::.é .;:r5a'::_a:VE;;'E;e"s;. f2'Lf 'izhﬁ raggsnéent. The maieréai .v..;§iaCe;dﬂ.v;G'§;E§ $?é<;}:,~.:._f§Eff:M3;i {hem are a seréag sf Eﬁﬁiﬂﬁﬂiﬁ AW§%:{"§*j§b:;ia¥i§_i§:.:;;a:i %§':e a§§e§§§::t., "Effie actg cgmgéaineﬁ as' are nsiAégaégayéa'i'é'ﬂr:"T:§'ut {";{}ﬁ§i§§"E'i.,§§i_§§ am are Einkea? EC: me am 'Vanaihiéri "' 7§?':'*<.=:-' é§g3e§Ea§2§ gmgsgm is gain agsaéuze cagztvsi };2:zé§'"i:%f;e ﬁﬁéézgazégr by §§§'ﬂ$E":§§§"°%§ aﬁﬁiiéasai 3?%3%'"§;'i~$. Gs": the ,.AjA'r"*§§f';;é§'é ié $3352: €%*":§m; the :*é.33§§€%:§§rF¥; has. wag:

llIIlWll5G'h-u ihrﬁateneé, The tweet is "at whatevér effarf aria' asst ii"

;233}«»* fak€"Z Qampetitive Zbugénegseg have mgr': eméarkéd upon? by the a§p@£Eas':1: which is adverge $0 the §{:t&res;;%'a§f we aampasy. The appeifant has iii advised the re$s«;":-3'r:V:<§.§:i'% arzﬁ mg ever: threateneé, 8:: 'these materéai §9:.£§4T§*:..:Eié_;:5 5:: heﬁﬁf that the intention 9? we a;§Jpe%E_$nt:; E3 pecuniary advantaga tovtzhe deétz-'%rws.:és;:t '*s:§.the«"s*e§;:»£:sV:éé&r2t, far a wrangféﬁ aggurgryatém éf §:'F;é'a:§'t§»':0;f§t;;}:%ré"€.*. an éntesztien :3 ever threw Em :°asg0rI:d?t:*1':t;:"A E~£<,>§i»<::e ii E.s5 zé féi case that €$i§ﬁE§S§"'iES éV§¢:_éE.§_é's*:%*;'*--~*'Such aiiéﬁﬁﬁ $3' the agpeiéanfcis Q-f;:*g:}§9é1$'$§s.ié"'%;'j;3,5¥' E--Sa «czsnténazing 0§p'res$£@:":e ""§'"§2e €§nd£L;~<:%:-V:"3§'*Vé:§%e"'iz;;:2gs:§§a--:1: §s"**vb~m*éen§Gme, hargéz am wmrzgfué, .;"ef£ea:*.:§V%':§.:hé%§§C:<_:G:'?.ccxééfédanse beiweer: tha 'awe sééayehsésiezigf * "E"%*:e._ 'ig3..?;3;:ef§'E4"a;__:*':'*:. by aémiiiaééy engaging §'2§:'*::s&Ef_w_it%@ a4":;:égfhg*&*§'~EtEéé'a Véémsany hag aated in 'graach C35 :_' g§z;e::3§ ?a.§:§h:,_A*-gm:_'a"':;$t= "%*é'éV wag exmcteé :3 ac: <;s;n;%y in the §ﬁ€§?E§i'«:°§§'..4;;§i;gA4Vé:§VFé§.§aﬁ'g and me: against ii; "me aggaéiam: aﬁm';¥:.s"' $r2v§f-- §;gé:.'f;%Vf'éeg his aatims E32' aiaiéng am: the :;:2§:*:§§%§2:Ev%;:% b?:..%S§n&$$&§ $25: $2'; $133 anéﬁriﬁkam, $2: mi 2% zgrww "":*:'"°"'"

._§1....

gmhébéted by fay»; since the agreements betvaam them have mes": tarmiaaieé. Thus 'me appeEla:':é: seekg is justéfy mg mmpaiétﬁze §u$§ne's$@s' we 353$ mt deny it L;iéj1§':-gr these cér€um§tar:ce$ &!"ld in View m' the mataréaé §;»'n'--s"*.;'e.§V'.;'.:;r.:";;_%'ré,_.__"

we have rm hesitation ta hoié that sufficéeat.._g_E<3.a;héS arzé made Gigi by the resparzéerztf fcéf v§:é r%:."§é%*\ mmsany an 3225?: and egazétaﬁié gr@uh':§§;'V-- C<c;:2§:é--r:§1';Ifea*'ré'%:Egs';: sa- és rsecessary that the a§pa§§'«:%;":"1§V:V: "é';eir:§ ~a""::€§z2§:;éty $9 ééfacteé E9 geii ﬁgs.:f3%:.,3res_ €§ %:'h}é §;$Sff:}¢§f;§§ér'::€¢VV'V {5} :<i2{'>%".§:§S:§:f7;'?V'é§."§;f.f:€V':"}?Va§%§ the maieriai pfaaeﬁ bafare if2n:E9é£'§e*v §;g$§»§:® .€:Eh'e'_'vém§:%§ hed Qfdﬁf, Gm facig it heéé %:ha't t§sg f'EG?§'f§§'E§§ but 3 giwéfieé gartnegghép b éi:as§,%ei€:9:" the éﬁiiiiﬁﬂﬁf §%"'%§ the %*@§§§§'"%5%E%'§i:. "°§'"%3a€:"';*~§'éV§e 3-:s;m§'é3§§a:r:§ ?€é%;?'§§r:g veta gsvgerg 22:': magcsr ﬁ€{"..§S§G§'E.;'S 5:25 Egg €§§'"f¥§€t& wéﬁz the bagsénesg a? the ::«:>m§;;»s;:_§*:3;.,~ Ehﬁfﬁ we aéiegatérszgég ﬁg: ﬁésiﬁ the §ar%:ée§

-'«4___§§a§ms%. 5'ea__é':*r; Qther. ii wmséé mean 'ma: mm 9? them have A bf*:'ga:_§*2_%:é me d§{%'I?E§"E€ :3? a;:rn§§%: gage' faéim iaaazayés aaiﬁ iézzgg, m; z:%:§§ €%*:§ ssaa-er&$':: 9? tféa §::*a3m§a::%g in "*2 E W52- jeepardy. Hence, it ﬁg a ::a$e where the majaréiy aEEVe:-u;;;_es sppresgéon by the minority and 'EHES minoyity hag g£.f<;é'*;v"V{.*~:*3r:;ﬁ'4%Lj*».*.<;é-.. gravésmng Sr: {ﬁe Artécfes. That tm re§a:ém$hs'{§_ 'b:.=;'c.$'e"én M ihe Ewe: parties hag become SS somj-t?é'a'i'«%:he'§,{ c_ér§ééé.t ﬁarfty an {$29 business 9:' Em comﬁany iéjgfﬁé-:_é5'§ a:'él<:§.. Ef~.sa5 iisevf weaséd be a very valid gVr::';aa_%:%'~.:i§> f@%"vur._i§::§--%..;é;g'_: {he camparsy $3 just and e<:'*;----=\;uEV;'c:a§>E;e::V"*g':;;5_L;--rf§:§-;_ Ar.§';::;és'<:éA::":g'§E:..=', the QLS under mega cir¢ums:t a§;_g:e§ ﬁgsmndeni ta purchage the $E'"t;Vaz5£e;s~;:.VV'§.:''>r's & fair mime ii; ée ;§V%_'}_§§-«..J$i'ef§§§§.?§:§FfT*;' Waaééiarg sf %:%'2€ €smpa:§yV.------'§*hé 'EV§"h§:1§:;g$ ':*é>c::"§Vs?dé'§€§*'v~§:i%;'}§he €L8 asé baseé 0::

mat&r%aE 8_nd ﬁr: fjééﬁ 368 any ﬁervafséty in i:§"z€ fés'2éé;'z§$ %§'c§:"ded ' »-GB ma: aaiig far any %;':t§:'fe§'s--n§§, %'":!*§$"<;:a4';r:af'E-:js.i.'a:*:§ arréwé at $3,! {ha Cw erg ' '§-via? :;A*e;a§a;":abE"é"a':"§§V are éagaci in"; "She matevéaé giacéd 7g:~:V. §*a$$r-$_,"~%:%=£.é"n:;e;, §«'¥§€ firm reg Effﬁﬁ that acaifg far any §r{:»:% Efafeéé -- _ " ' ' 3 5 ".§;g W Unées" these C¥£'C:U.¥TE5'€3{'sCES, the grater pagseé by the Cismgarzgr Law Eovaré is gust and wage? and d§e3;V.Vé:».r:%%[.§aEE far any inmrferarzae. :for the afaresaié :*éa$an_:=g;;";"2--§e'_*ag§3;;::~3a"%« _ being éewéd of merétg £5 céigmésseﬁw §§aaa %%AIi§§§g§ PrS* 9.6:'. '£3

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

Ultrafilter Gmbh vs Ultrafilter (India) Private Limited on 26 August, 2011

Bench: V.G.Sabhahit, Ravi Malimath