Madras High Court
Tamilnadu State Primary Agrl vs The Secretary To Government on 21 December, 2022
Author: J.Nisha Banu
Bench: J.Nisha Banu
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 21.12.2022
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE Mrs. JUSTICE J.NISHA BANU
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
and
W.M.P.Nos.19984 & 19985 of 2002
Tamilnadu State Primary Agrl.
Co.op. Bank All Employees Association
rep by General Secretary V.G.Jayamani
Cuddalore ..Petitioner.
vs
1 The Secretary to Government
Co-operation Food & Consumer Protection Department,
Chennai-9.
2 The Registrar of Co-op Societies
NVN Natarajan Maaligai
Kilpauk. Chennai-10.
3 The Director, Co-op Audit
Kamarajar Salai,
Chepauk,
Chennai-5.
4 The Joint Registrar of Co-op Societies
Cuddalore Region
Ramadoss Naidu Street,
Pudupalayam, Cuddalore.
1/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
5 The Special Officer
Cuddalore District Central Co-op bank
Cuddalore
6 Deputy Registrar of Co-op Societies,
Cuddalore Circle Pudupalayam Main road,
Cuddalore.
7 Deputy Registrar of Co-op Societies
Vridhachalam Circle Main Road
Vridhachalam.
8 Assistant Director of Co-op Audit,
Sitharam Nagar,
Cuddalore.
9 The Special Officer,
Andipalayam PACB,
Ramapuram P.O
Cuddalore Taluk.
10 The Special Officer,
Naduveerapattu PACB,
Naduveerapattu P.O
C.N.Palayam (via) Cuddalore Tk.
11 The Special Officer,
Sedapalayam PACB
Sedapalayam P.O
Cuddalore Tk.
12 The Special Officer,
Thiruvanthipuram PACB,
Thiruvanthipuram P.O
Cuddalore Tk.
2/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
13 The Special Officer
Varakkalpattu PACB,
Varakkalpattu P.O
Cuddalore TK.
14 Vazhisothanaipalayam PACB
Vazhisothanaipalayam P.O
Cuddalore TK.
15 The Special Officer
Vasantharayanpalayam PACB
Vasantharayanpalayam P.O
Cuddalore Tk.
16 The Special Officer,
Vellakarai PACB
Vellakarai P.O
Cuddalore Tk.
17 The Special Officer,
Vilvarayanatham PACB
Manjakuppam P.O.
Cuddalore Tk.
18 The Special Officer
Karaimedu PACB
Boohur P.O
Cuddalore tk.
19 The Special Officer,
Keelalinjipattu PACB
Reddy Chavady P.O
Cuddalore Tk.
20 The Special Officer
3/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
P.Periyakattupalayam PACB
Mathalapattu P.O. Ariyankuppam(via) Cuddalore Tk
21 The Special Officer,
Singirikudi PACB
Singirikudi PO
Cuddalore Tk.
22 The special officer
Vadapuram Kilpathi PACB
Karrikkalampakkam P.O
Cuddalore Tk.
23 The Special Officer
Ayeekuppam PACB
Kullanchavady P.O.
Cuddalore Tk.
24 The Special Officer
Kattiyankuppam PACB
Krishnankuppam P.O
Cuddalore Tk.
25 The Special Officer
Kayalpattu PACB
Andarmullipallam P.O
Cuddalore Tk.
26 The Special Officer,
Vazhathalampattu PACB
Kullanchavady PO
Cuddalore Tk.
27 The Special Officer
T.Palayam PACB
T.Palayam P.O
4/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Cuddalore Tk.
28 The Special Officer
Aviyanur Co-op Agri Bank
Aviyanur P.O.
Panruti Tk.
29 The Special Officer
Elumedu PACB
Elumedu P.O
Panruti Tk.
30 The Special Officer
Keelkavarapattu PACB
Keelkavarapattu P.O
Panruti Tk.
31 The Special Officer
Melarungunam PACB
Manamthavazhindhaputhur P.O
Panruti Tk.
32 The Special Officer
P.Pudupettai PACB
Pudupettai P.O
Panruti Tk.
33 The special Officer
Vadakailasam PACB
Vadakailasam P.O
Panruti Tk.
34 The Special Officer
Chithirai Chavadi PACB
L.N.Puram P.O
5/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Panruti T.K.
35 The Special Officer
Kadampuliyur PACB Kadampuliyur P.O.
Panruti Tk.
36 The special officer
Kandarakottai PACB
Kandarakottai P.O.
Panruti Tk.
37 The Special Officer
Maligaimedu PACB
Maligaimedu P.O.
Panruti Tk.
38 The Special Officer
Periyakattupalayam PACB
Keeliruppu P.O
Panruti Tk.
39 The Special Officer,
Melkumaramangalam PACB
Melkumaramangalam P.O
Panruti Tk.
40 The Special Officer
Poongunam PACB
L.N.Puram P.O
Panruti Tk.
41 The Special Officer
Anguchettipalayam PACB
Anguchettipalayam P.O
6/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Panruti Tk.
42 The special officer
Marungur PACB
Marungur P.O, Panruti tk.
43 The special officer
Muthandikuppam PACB
Perperiyankuppam P.O.
Panruti Tk.
44 The Special Officer
Nadukuppam PACB
Panruti Tk.
45 The special Officer
Thiruvamoor PACB
Panruti Tk.
46 The Special Officer,
V.P.Nallur
V.P.Nallur P.O
Panruti Tk.
47 The Special Officer
Keelarungunam PACB,
Keelarungunam P.O
P.O.Panruti tk.
48 The Special Officer
Melplattampakkam PACB
Meelpattampakkam P.O
Panruti Tk.
49 The Special Officer
Nellikuppam PACB
7/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Nellikuppam P.O.
Panruti Tk.
50 The Special Officer
Pacharapalayam PACB
Kezhur P.O , Panruti Tk.
51.The Special Officer,
Silambinathanpettai PACB,
Pathirikottai P.O., Panruti Tk.
52.The Special Officer,
Thirukandeswaram PACB,
Thirukandeswaram P.O, Panruti Tk.
53. The Special Officer,
Vegakollai PACB,
Vegakollai P.O., Panruti Tk.
54.The Special Officer,
Sakkankudi PACB,
Sakkankudi P.O., Chidambaram Tk.
55.The Special Officer,
Vilagam PACB, Vilagam P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk.
56.The Special Officer,
Vakkur PACB, Vakkur P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk.
57.The Special Officer,
Panapattu PACB, Panapattu P.O..
Chidambaram Tk.
58.The Special Officer,
C. Orathur PACB, C. Orathur PO.
8/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Chidambaram Tk.
59.The Special Officer,
Koolapadi PACB,
Vazhakollai PO., Chidambaram Tk
60.The Special Officer,
C. Muthur PACB, C Mutlur P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk
61.The Special Officer,
Thillaividangan PACB,
Thillaividangan P.O., Chidambaram Tk.
62.The Special Officer,
Killai PACB, Killai P.O., Chidambarak Tk.
63.The Special Officer,
Pichavaram PACB, Pichavaram P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk.
64.The Special Officer,
Sivapuri PACB, Sivapuri P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk.
65.The Special Officer,
Sivayam PACB, Nanjanallur P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk.
66.The Special Officer,
Nandhimangalam PACB,
Poolamedu P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk.
67.The Special Officer,
9/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Keerapalayam PACB, Keerapalayam P.O.,
Chidambarak Tk.
68.The Special Officer,
Puduchatram PACB, Puduchatram P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk.
69.The Special Officer,
Poovalai PACB, Poovalai P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk.
70.The Special Officer,
Keelamangudi PACB, Kuriyamangalam P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk.
71.The Special Officer,
Parangipettai PACH, Paranpipettai PO,
Chidambaram Tk.
72. The Special Officer,
Erumbur PACB,
Erumbur PO Chidambaram Tk
73.The Special Officer,
Valayamadevi PACB,
Valayamadevi PO Chidambaram Tk
74.The Special Officer,
B. Udaiyur PACB, Thalaikulam PO..
Chidambaram Tk.
75.The Special Officer,
Manjakollai PACB,
Chidambaram Tk.
76. The Special Officer,
10/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Adhivaraganatham PACB,
Bhuvanagiri P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk.
77.The Special Officer,
C. Sathapadi PACB,
C. Sathapadi PO.,
Chidambaram Tk.
78.The Special Officer,
Krishnapuram PACB,
Krishnapuram P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk.
79.The Special Officer,
Keel Bhuvanagiri PACB,
Keel Bhuvanagiri P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk.
80.The Special Officer,
Sethiyathopu PACB,
Sethiyathopu P.O., Tk.
81.The Special Officer,
Gnanavinayagarsamy PACB,
Gnanavinayagarsamy P.O.,
Kattumannarkoil Tk.
82.The Special Officer,
Kuppankuzhi PACB,
Kuppankuzhi PO. Kattumannarkoil Tk.
83.The Special Officer,
Chettithangal PACB,
Chettithangal PO, Kattumannarkoil Tk
11/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
84.The Special Officer,
Reddiyur PACB, Reddiyur PO.
Kattumannarkoil Tk
85.The Special Officer,
Eyyalur PACB,
Eyyalur PO.
Kattumannarkoil Tk
86.The Special Officer,
Nattarmangalam PACB
Nattarmangalam PO.
Kattumannarkoil Tk
87.The Special Officer,
Veeranathapuram PACB,
Veeranathapuram PO, Kattumannarkoil Tk
88.The Special Officer,
Rayanallur PACB, M.Adoor PO.,
Kattumannarkoil Tk
89.The Special Officer,
Kumaratchi PACB, Kumaratchi P.O..
Kattumannarkoil Tk.
90.The Special Officer,
Ilangambur PACB,
Vennaiyur P.O.. Kattumannarkoil Tk
91.The Special Officer,
Suravilandur PACB,
Suravilandur P.O.,
Kattumannarkoil Tk.
92.The Special Officer,
12/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Melaparuthikudi PACB,
Melaparuthikudi P.O.,
Kattumannarkoil Tk.
93.The Special Officer,
Pillaiyarthangal PACB Edaiyur P.O.,
KattumannarkoilTk
94.The Special Officer,
Meyyathur PACB,
Themmur PO.,
Kattumannarkoil Tk
95.The Special Officer,
Kooduvel PACT
Koodivel PO,Kattumannarkoil Tk
96.The Special Officer,
Melavaniyur PACB,
Melavanniyur PO
Kattumannarkoil Tk
97.The Special Officer,
Athupathi PACB, Athupathi PO,
Kattumannarkoil Tk
98.The Special Officer,
Mudikandanallur PACB, Mudikandanallur PO,
Kattumannarkoil Tk.
99.The Special Officer,
Perur PACB, Perur P.O.,
Kattumannarkoil Tk.
100.The Special Officer,
Srimushnam PACB,
13/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Srimushnam P.O.,
Kattumannarkoil Tk.
101.The Special Officer,
Palayankottai PACB,
Palayankottai P.O., Kattumannarkoil Tk.
102.The Special Officer,
Nantheeswaramangalam PACB,
Vattathur P.O., Kattumannarkoil Tk.
103 The Special Officer,
Kattumannarkoil Rural Co-op Bank, Kattumannarkoil P.O..
Kattumannarkoil Tk.
104.The Special Officer,
Lalpettai PACB, Lalpettai P.O..
Kattumannarkoil Tk
105.The Special Officer,
MaligaikottamPACB, Chinnakosapallam PO..
Thittagudi Tk
106.The Special Officer,
Kilimangalam PACB,
Kilimangalam P.O. Thittagudi Tk.
107.The Special Officer,
Eraiyur PACB, Pennadam R.S. Post,
Thittagudi Taluk
108.The Special Officer,
Vakarumbur PACD,
Mungankudi PO. Thittagudi Tk
109.The Special Officer,
14/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Vadakarai PACB Konur PO.
Thittagudi Tk.
110.The Special Officer,
Pilandarai PACB, Pilandurai PO.
Thittagudi Tk
111.The Special Officer,
Tittagudi PACB, Titagudi PO. Tittagudi Tk
112.The Special Officer,
E. Keeranur PACB,
Severi P.O.
Tittagudi Tk
113.The Special Officer,
Sirumalai PACB, Sirumulai PO.,
Tittagudi Tk
114.The Special Officer,
Edacheruvai PACB, Akkanur PO.,
Tittagudi Tk.
115. The Special Officer,
Thollar PACB, Thollar PO.,
Tittagudi Tk.
116.The Special Officer,
V. Gudalore PACB,
V. Gudalore PO., TittagudiTk
117.The Special Officer,
Tholudur PACB, Tholudur PO.,
Tittagudi Tk
118.The Special Officer,
15/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Keelkalpoondi PACB,
Keelkapoondi PO, Tittagudi Tk
119.The Special Officer ,
Mangalore PACB,
Mangalore PO Tittagudi Tk
120.The Special Officer,
Lukkur PACB, Lukkur PO
TittagudiTk
121. The Special Officer,
Kaludur PACB,
Kaludur PO, TittagudiTk
122.The Special Officer,
Sirupakkam PACB,
Sirupakkam PO Tittagudi Tk
123. The Special Officer,
Vadapathi PACB,
S. Naraiyur P.O.. Tittagudi Tk.
124.The Special Officer,
Adarikalathur PACB,
Adarikalathur P.O., Tittagudi Tk.
125. The Special Officer,
Ma. Podaiyur PACB, Ma Podaiyur P.O.,
Tittagudi Tk.
126. The Special Officer,
Alichikudi PACB,
Sathukual P.O., Vridhachalam Tk.
127.The Special Officer,
16/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Sathiavadi PACB,
Karuveppalankurichi P.O., Vridhachalam Tk.
128.The Special Officer,
Karmangudi PACB,
Karuveppalankurichi PO., Vridhachalam Tk.
129.The Special Officer,
Mudhanai PACB, Mudhanai P.O.,
Vridhachalam Tk.
130.The Special Officer,
Kavanur PACBKavanur PO..
Vridhachalam Tk.
131.The Special Officer ,
V Sathapadi PACH,V
Sathapadi PO Vridhachalam Tk
132.The Special Officer,
V Sathamangalam PACB,
V Sathamangalam PO. Vridhachalam Tk
133.The Special Officer,
Uyyakondaravi PACB,
Seppalanatham PO.. Vridhachalam Tk
134.The Special Officer,
Thottikuppam PACB,
Thottikuppam PO. Vridhachalam Tk.
135.The Special Officer,
Paravalur PACB. Paravalur P.O..
Vridhachalam Tk.
136.The Special Officer,
17/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Veppur PACB, Veppur P.O..
Vridhachalam Tk
137.The Special Officer,
Seppakkam PACB,
Seppakkam P.O., Vridhachalam Tk.
138.The Special Officer,
Maligaimedu PACB,
Maligaimedu P.O., Vridhachalam Tk.
139 The Special Officer,
Mangalampettai PACB,
Mangalampettai P.O, Vridhachalam Tk.
140.The Special Officer,
Edachithur PACB,
Edachithur P.O., Vridhachalam Tk.
141.The Special Officer,
Mugasaparur PACB,
Mugasaparur PO., Vridhachalam Tk.
142.The Special Officer,
Mathur PACB, Mathur P.O.,
Vridhachalam Tk.
143.The Special Officesr,
Aladi PACB, Aladi PO Vridhachalam Tk
144.The Special Officer,
Palakollai PACH Palakollai PO
Vridhachalam Tk
145.The Special Officer,
M.Agaram PACH, Mangalam PO
18/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Vridhachalam Tk
146.The Special Officer,
Nallathur PACB, Nallathur PO,
Cuddalore Tk
147. The Special Officer,
Serakuppam PACB,
Vadalur PO Cuddalore TK
.
148.The Special Officer,
Karunkuzhi PACB,
Karunkuzhi P.O. Cuddalore TK.
149. The Special Officer,
Parvathipuram PACB,Vadalur P.O.Cuddalore TK.
150. The Special Officer,
Ranganathapuram PACB,
Ranganathapuram P.O. Cuddalore TK.
151.The Special Officer,
Adoorkuppam PACB,
Adoorkuppam P.O. Cuddalore Tk.
152.The Special Officer,
Avinnankudi PACB,
Avinnankudi P.O. Thittakudi TK.
153. The Special Officer,
Pennadam PACB,
Pennadam P.O. Thittakudi TK.
154. The Special Officer,
Chinnapettai PACB,
Chinnapettai PO Panruti TK.
19/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
155.The Special Officer,
Moovur PACB,
Moovur PO Kammanarko TK
156.The Special Officer ,
Vallampadugai PACB,
Vallampadugai PO Chidambaram TK
157. The Special Officer,
B.Muttular PACB,
B Muttular PO,
Chidambaram TK
158.The Special Officer,
Narayana NainarKuppam PACB,
Narayana NainarKuppam PO., Cuddalore Tk.
159.The Special Officer,
Chinna Pandaram Kuppam PACB
Chinna Pandaram Kuppam P.O.
Vridhachalam Tk.
160. The Special Officer,
T. Neruncheri PACB
T. Neruncheri P.O.. Chidambaram Tk
161.The Special Officer,
K. Adoor PACB, K. Adoor P.O.,
Chidambaram Tk.
162.The Special Officer,
Siruvarappur PACB
Siruvarappur P.O. Vridhachalam Tk.
163.The Special Officer,
20/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Adhi Narayanapuram
PACB Adhi Narayanapuram P.O
Cuddalore Tk.
164.The Special Officer,
Theerthanagiri PACB
Theerthanagiri P.O. Cuddalore Tk.
165.The Special Officer,
Subramaniyapuram
PACB Subramaniyapuram P.O.
Cuddalore Tk.
166. The Special Officer,
Maruthadu PACB Maruthadu P.O.
Cuddalore Tk.
167.The Special Officer,
ErandayiraVilagam PACD
ErandayiraVilagam Po CuddaloreTk
168.The Special Officer,
Kurinjipadi PACH
Kurinjipadi PO. Cuddalore Tk.
169.The Special Officer,
Kundiyamallur PACB
Kundiyanallur PO. Cuddalore Tk.
170. The Special Officer,
Pinnalur PACB, Pinnalur P.O.
Chidambaram Tk.
171.The Special Officer,
Devangudi PACB,
21/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.14874 of 2002
Devangudi P.O. Virudhachalam Tk.
172. The Special Officer,
V.Kumaramangalam PACB,
V.Kumaramangalam P.O.
Virudhachalam Tk.
173. The Special Officer,
Kopavalangudi PACB,
Kopavalangudi P.O. Virudhachalam Tk.
174. The Special Officer,
Sirumangalam PACB,
Sirumangalam P.O.
Virudhachalam Tk. ..Respondents
Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the constitution of India to
issue a Writ of Certioari to call for the entire records relating to the
proceedings of the 2nd respondent in RC.No.11069/2002PACB-1 dated
28.2.2002 and quash the same.
For Petitioner : Mr.C.Prakasam
For Respondents : Mr.S.Ravichandran,
Additional Government Pleader
for R1 to R3
ORDER
Learned counsel for the petitioner would state that nothing survives for 22/25 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis W.P.No.14874 of 2002 adjudication in the present writ petition.
2. Recording the statement made by the learned counsel for the petitioner, this writ petition is dismissed as infructuous. No costs.
Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.
21.12.2022 Index:Yes/No Speaking/Non-speaking order vsi To 1 The Secretary to Government Co-operation Food & Consumer Protection Department, Chennai-9.
2 The Registrar of Co-op Societies NVN Natarajan Maaligai Kilpauk. Chennai-10.
3 The Director, Co-op Audit Kamarajar Salai, Chepauk, Chennai-5.
23/25https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis W.P.No.14874 of 2002 J.NISHA BANU,J.
vsi W.P.No.14874 of 2002 24/25 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis W.P.No.14874 of 2002 21.12.2022 25/25 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis