M/S. Karle International vs The Commissioner Of Customs on 17 March, 2009

[Cites 0, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

M/S. Karle International vs The Commissioner Of Customs on 17 March, 2009

Bench: D.V.Shylendra Kumar

...".....m. !!£9Wa'dI'!@ﬂA':&_;a<'B¢3€:'%a#H\i W mauwntﬂnﬂ mm: mum cw KAMMAKA men COURT or KARNMFAKA mm cotm' 0? mmmmm éézém

H

H%"£'HE Hm: warm' aw F;é.R.F€I§TAI€A ﬁr 
mwag mis THE 132% DA'? «my EARQE 29:3'? % ;;f E  

EE§'€3'£4'.E

THE HGEBLE gaﬁaargaa n§v,;§Hy;,$;~fréR;i'gags.-aRL:_ _V " 7

Writ Fatima Rgﬂa 59:35 as   h
5  ~.   ; 'v

1.22:1! 3 Kfarkez  ;

Ha.'?3§ ﬁagmaﬁm       ' '
 i§B Wé1d..1"a.,."_1'."1.;m}a;;:a;?°--*.,2:_tm:;'i;--,,.A  ' 
Baﬁalarm        
Zfity bfifﬁ   
é3:E.-aer       %

2. ms §§%.*1**;i§«:mi}:s 5;    
iliﬁii 31.13 E§?$~33".s"E7'§§$*$i?g"'~--.. ' -
ﬁg? 1§¢£:a:m5.. Emaﬁiggw V T'   
    
' E3? éEi§;% §§§'ﬁ:?§' %"i3:1§;m::e

  

          

 *  _     

   ﬁcimaata £3? Ermm ﬁwmiahmg

  % i£j9§.I'1§i "

 V'   ﬁg {:»§$,$%ﬁm§
 _ '  Quawrzﬁ Raaég

   

1: = -wi

Vat

% % k:%.»?:*1~;g Jami    

errmﬁ 9% Efléiﬁg



Wm uvamairﬁlﬂnﬂ HEW?! £..'Ui.ﬁRT 0!' KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARMATAKA HIGH COQJRT Q? KA

RNATAKA HIGH

Ni

 a£'Fiz:am§

2%. N, HUDQQ

Vtahala Eu.§ld:§m§

E  ﬁ Em §'%:arj..

B1*:i@_§i ﬁﬁm V3969  ,

 

aw Eealhé-= 13:3 5.23%  .;%,%.AReap% % 

Thma ﬁyrﬁ gyagitéﬂxw ma    

and ?2'? 9%' ﬁx iiscmafaituéémn' r:sf"*iz1e§ia  €ﬁ.._€i.E:$§Eire
that tlm apgiicaﬁxzzn far Ra?!'s§=a'ie§n ﬁiczﬁ  [izzjgr zhvs 131"
rmwndeni ggga szgmamgﬁaj ﬁf,..§&*;._§;§::,mmH5%£i*»»ﬂG..?L; mag
ag&%mt Kw ﬁrﬁsar §::s'_";*S%;g3@fé§&lV_$v§$§,1FS3;'7.}2{3i}4~ Sm ﬁt.
23e.§§2$€}4  13:: q'az.a:a1<z- t..?*_1ef':= e::'*m§.$_ E3.-an'-€~32;G3 ﬁn
§:r:Ia.3%;32;E%SH;:%~§€A ":21: V%3,;i2.--*2@wi'j%and in yams;

gush ﬁikar   ' 

 

Tﬁzasw j:;'sat;*§,£~z};ii:.:*.s';V--_;:?::ia€;,i§;¥i§;._:,;r:i §*;Tr:%:"   - --
tw dﬁfjfs E113 §;§m'_;:;.§';§. ma?ai£':_t%2L}t.:: f%3i3Q"W§Jfgf

 

¥§':r*:i.t:" §:¥&§;ti.¢rzw*£aV   ﬁn. number. The ﬁrasa:

ye%3?ii§;.fw3:' ,c:§a.:"1:§1%  'a& &  gar mint Expsﬁ. Qriantad

 yﬁtéﬁazm a §Qmeab?$ Tmﬁ" 44% {Fnit

   withﬁawal sf Sui? Bmwhack ﬁasm

 the gxééé  agﬁ Lev}: afgemity an bath afﬁssem as
  ﬁﬁjudimaéiaﬁ srdar gamed $33. 3¢3§é.2ﬁ!Z}€£3 and
 '.'_5§ma§i.tg£"¥3n €%.§?'.§$® by ﬂag Aﬁﬁiﬁanzml Gamma" séssnar

 

 



W... ,_.,..,M,. W nnmvumu-mum wmm: mumtr cw mmmmm mm»: mum' or mmarmm amm mum W mgwmam 

GH

nun wsvuy-u un

  AA ' §$s;3H't1'13 fﬁﬁawirg afsrﬁm:

ta)

mpy af Whieh EM hem gmczuma as. zanmura-2"g.;£;§':t;:}2_§

writ yaﬁﬁnﬁﬁ which sﬁmwh ms bean set  
ciammmmr 9: ﬁuatszma {Ap@f§l;bs} a;_a per j = 
§3.m;..2m# in gym; aa.w;2w§ {'"*"§'3' 

Mmmnirwa §.$ this p@%§;tim1§,    

 

 ma  the

 

--  iessgw af   arazim dab;-.c1

asaxmam  M  gr mrassim

,§uras§ictm. ::..2§:§:":  mmmm ﬁm.

{mspy  {kink yaﬁianﬁﬁ the

pzwarizt  ;§.s-e$:Z§t:;1v'"=::«§:%:  advmae araiw,

 V.     garymﬁeé E}; a shmw muse

  ~--.a;%$§€ mum zfwatim ma cam ta bus

 

     by the  a.12.t'imaz'it_v,=':

a  in vim sf my gmrgaigg ﬁnaiz-3% I

 

{§ E ﬁg': 'Kim ﬁuty Drawéack af
R3. 3'LQ§%~§34$;" s céaiﬂmd and

 



ATRKA HJGH

ggcﬁﬁérg sazarztien, in tarm sf
Eaﬁﬁaaéimﬁ Ra.£'3'?!9S ﬂtza,PI.T.

dated 1-'§----93§muad mag: rule 3 %f    
xmé with Rule 4 af gsuamm gm: ,  A .
Cent::=a§ Exaisﬁ Butises,      

Ekzlm 19%.

gag; : awﬁﬁrm    mi  %m>:y* 

Etzawbaqgk   i22:?s,56;?54*;-
grantamgdg-¢:smjw;§% m*§cx§wcus1y.
  'Em
 %?m(2%: am Caawma
   Ruiz 15 Q?

 ''''    {§enm°'&§ Exams

%  Ram 1995
 .  @: 24% ﬁum 12~--~3-
  iipiié the ﬁaté ﬁf psaymmrt.

 {:s¥% E  a many at'

,  .§$§1'§,{3§,ﬁG@!- ggupm Fem-mu

  my; m Mia L.T,KarIe

X U1'ii'3.ZI§ amass awéiarx 114; {iii} af
tkﬁmgms £5': 19522

{ivj X impame a pamhy cf

" A'?f?"".'j"'*" 'W "H"-*VH9ﬁﬁ»M Hihiﬁ SOUR? OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT 0? KARN.ATA§(A H163'! (SOUR? OF "RN

Ral-%,@§ﬁﬁ%j~ {Rama Fmgrtamn
%kh4a cniyj an ﬁuijs L.T.Kar§&§





.. -nuuw-m u

3M"fu|N¢l i,...,,5g..¢..... W mmmnm mm WW: or mxmmm Haw mum cw mimmmm mm mm: W mmm/Am 3-my

1QQ% Em; zzzzdﬁr mama 111

{iii} 6f' the Ctzsta-rm Bat $62:   

mam Twmxy   %

aniy} an 323?: 

   Cérggiggti '  'V

$$ *%  ~ E.1f§{;.;:}

$f:m'£Ti_#§.}'§§z§@3iﬁs g%é%t~.1'Q,% 52 F
3:    matter 3.11
apyaal tr:  . Thu; ispwlﬁate

 ﬁrdar dataﬁ 28.ﬁ1.,2%4

{L :=.=.n.. -"I-II?-I 

 

allcww  "    thc snﬁm' in ariwxai

 

_   ﬂttua ;;*§&$§ﬁ§;ra:m gm? ER-$'§".2%7§';,    

 

Smﬁitriah mm £33' in Pnpﬁi

   ;r§¢.c.$":,*%::}§<;y: fmsg zmgm and Ciﬁtf 2mg 32 am,

  £6

 

£53333" $1' iiugtzssmsg   

 

n  '    '?.t:I:§:z'1 sx:.msieﬁta §&rz..me ﬂibﬁ agyeiﬁtﬁ mﬁw wﬁ af the

'*2:;'.i§*



NAYAKA HIGH

~ wgqwf'wn9 war nmmwmznna Mm:-: 4E;;?QUEW L}? KARNAVAKA Hiﬂéﬁ CQURT GP %€ARNﬁh'§'AE{A Hﬁﬁﬁ COURT ¢F KAR

View mat the apgezﬁate érﬁar was mt mrrwt 1101" .aggb§ié:;§

the aarract Emmi yrirmipiwg ﬁirmtad the  .

pursuad  .   

5. A mazsm patitiaﬁ  :5  
Cent-at Gawrwami VA  the
Aﬁllam Gammissaiaféf it     gﬁmdsiena of
Saatimn EEQZEEE:    $5 the: atria'

yaawﬁ E3? _€3é3-3£s;z§l  '13:: exmciaa of its
rmrﬁicsrwaf.'  ué}; m*eb§?"'€t§"§«'s'  ﬁsantraé ﬁa m
hag aﬂaﬁrad   ma 3%': asida Eh: afdm"

pvasaaai  §3ﬁL:n1%E$37s1wer mié zmmmﬁ the

   i§:e'"a*§§u§%:ai§ng auﬁmﬁty 51$ éuae ts
V£:§_;:;*if:;T_ iém gzmmt Wfii. gggtitiwﬁ jaigzﬁv by
  rim'  Exwrﬂt ﬁﬁmwé 535: and im simm-

 &2VgA:9$c:*&.ti2*1g as 3 Ssmaaatﬁ Yariﬁ ﬁgma ifziit -- QM



- M-rw v we unwrap":

  &y me appezme €39 

' 'A':-+..'-'ﬁr-\~ ur nnnnunumnn l'Iﬂ.73'I MUUKI OF KARNATAKR ﬁlﬁﬁ CQURT OF KARNATAKA HEGH CQUR? Q? KARNAYAKA HIGH *

333

the Qemral Excsiaaa Act am Rubs Wﬁﬂ diﬂhrcni. _

slid mt ixmlmde a gag; warlmr atac.

Q. :2 i3 alas mmm  

ruling zzf em ﬁuﬁmma cam Iéa'iP'gct_%;i§:1s§.£':~.i§f1B"j$ab
warimr wiw acmﬁég  .'  
max1ufa£%"tLu"Em .aa:::€ﬁt§.§; ié   aasmﬁ mat the
£'$lJ.3f:Z:mﬂ' Whiz:  E%$ gncﬁa
  Ewlda the:
ﬁeid En,    Suprams Czzmrt:

    2-emsa   auﬁmzéty Em interﬁexw wnth"

 £9361.' am

 

   gm haé imam declarw  tim ﬁumma

. _  twhmz ham Elm ﬁalﬁ at. 'am rgiawé pair}: Gf

"1;§ar}_'§* ﬁm But? ﬁraawhaak arﬁaiwd by the Rﬁé

 

--

f '§§§§7§:;Ci§f%§f izieing ézaf @£':%:3§ ékﬁééxf E§% $3 ﬁmzssmbar {gr 5 n'-fIJI\I \lI !\l'|I'lI'l'IIl'II\l'| III'-'I'll tn!-JIaI\u l\r\l\I'ﬂ"'\l.r°\l\r\ r'||\Jrg \_\_(|_;g\|E gr |\_p\n;V}-\}!-\I\t-Q "'IHJI'I \a\J'\-FRI V)!' NRKIVHIRKA Til'?-I1 ,z2«»4;'99 and 224/99 dc"/::"é'.r._:Z.V__ '.E:'7§*'.;?_1?-§:'?

4' "J; '_'..x) 'S.' J£_L-'1".=V ?'8.f:}"p€fZ'E'iL'€§f} izczrze 52:i.§c;» s':-ears, .?fe€ie'»:':Z smzed that it was me {:§rcu1Zg::f°';.d§:§iéé;2' :2---'F-.§+_§8___T j did not gpecgfy the same d%<G.i1t}3Jc::2:i:--§x:v 3333* sz's,¢?:._. ancports 19% EJar:re5iT';9rospé9_$i:2§?Zy c;':£;gfrom 35- V ?Z---99 Eﬁlnd €.3'zz:z€ €§v£é?i.f}3QE§.g}:i £523 "<::i79€:;,iE&r dz' E4-«Q-98 did not speczjfagiiigg m,e}2€iQ§i'eiig£§3iZity Q5' C§?'C§Ei)3;7C£C?§::" ,2} di<§§'"'?'£Gf :f:}'§5'eC&?{3ﬁCC1§§§~H"iE5'?li'i0??; ffzczt cirazvbtztfé zzgiasg V r;;£§z3;i:é:i::z"bZ5. On r'evi€zzJiz2.g the .<;*i:fi.i:"2,f£r;%'1;'r}2g!LT'-rjirciglar dated 55» I 3-99 zz:5»:.s issuedV.3p.ec.ifi£:ézEZy"'--:r'§£:2'z;@i7';g shat <:Em:z_2.§:>r:s.;;§s_;:. was v.92z<:%::""* '_r::g3:%1i;~'-:=;$ibZe, The a7?'C1,?.i:;'biiZ.f£:i3'£i a.&rné$si?3iE:€§;g ' f-iii?' {he relevant ez?f;::»z27_::';€s 3:é'--3§e'éxﬁ§21i;:1esi' zezéth refers:-zzse to Agsze-».;%:o:g§§ca:%¢:=:_"5;?,z_%9s my cit' 2-9-gs ziétz-ié,%L§?_1L*?i§£:?: _ii"»:z}3as rjéiimed. ,-'§S diamassed 8.1253VC?;r:%2a:*Z:,i¢:§e£E__:7:£3o'12e the drawback c£z:z.im<s:z:€ 3&9 N03' ~::.:§fi:éii:3. S'iE::Z?£:»».;i:=: ztemtg of fizis f\?'QtI_I}"z'ca:fien. 'izefzﬁfefa $53.6 "pig: ihat the cirawbszck ciaizzzezf £55 u?";r'?V_V<Zi"i"_'3s'i";i3.?°£".3§"'<72?Et"',':?é* wzfzit E326 Brgezzrd a:f,1"2'r{:1a:E::r '~me7':.z':"¥:3":w:,ed V afmtisze E1-zziicfs :19 water 1,,':.$'i§'€2.ﬁ(:a:ifEg;j; §r;>::z.rd"s <i'§z'rczz§(;:§'s N0 3.?,:'2'ﬁ§<1i 'g:7Z§'«._ "2Q-¢§~;?0§Q 13311652 fmm ﬁfe F No '»--..%'a_§2;«+:V;.%;'250& 53%: has further ciargﬁed fhafi experfs wiii be emfiiieci 01233; to Bmzwi v_v'f€\r.;z.2§i;? 0;' duty drawback, CH . ":"';'25%§'E~§'1§»€, §.}é'fffIi :33: faitis i7:m::<'§ iffi.,?:i'i'""{::.€_'E. :».in<:E a.§2"'_'E£'i;.*;:-'-:<'i M 'i"E";:<i _:*::_%:;§:~;E:,;a;aE :»a:,:.EE1{.:»1°§.%;.:2E' E1': i'€"E§;"'E",iiS 01"" §'E"1<«:# <mEs--:2" {'ié%1?.ifi{E 5~§§f~ £f]}:"38 §§::.'=a:;_;;«' aé §'i.iEEi€lfX'E,.§§'€'f~?C in §'E"1<;:= m"i':' §3<;:§.§i.%<.}§.3§5 mi-hi}-:~é '.5 iiazaz H---2§§2a1;:<éz-?: §.;~.§a<:<_::__i mi. iiiffﬁ €.§;€t't€'7§S§,£§£"'E 03" 23 E}i2Iis;i<.>:: ET§<é1;;<,*E1

2. <3? éiszrt ':'7*«2§2,§e:'i:'*aS §*§§gf§': {Tm.:2'&_ 'Q3 %.§.zse: §<ia.1.'1;_<*:c.'i atszjiymgs-;<":'E {by fijé-t Q}.

.2"s*;:i:~.;§<3'1:a1.i érZ§_iii'1i.§.1'E€fi". 'F}1c1'éii.'::>1.'<:t, i";{.:.::.:s<3 :a':'i:*"§;*=:i>i§i'§.gi3r3§2;;'aim:

it gﬁi {Hi 9mg,' W #3 _z3\u.J 59.! 51.17.; nn\J_ -53>) n.-MI.-.. on-.r=unnf.-.Pnanf--.= n\I -5,,' lit-film IlIItI.|h.t.I|lI.li.lrIIt sir -n...r.l.|._LIr -avian. r_¥..r.....»ur.r.s....r. .5: .r.!....r!. _.

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court